Oxygen equilibrium properties of asymmetric nickel(II)-iron(II) hybrid hemoglobin

From protein structure to function via single crystal optical spectroscopy

The more than 100,000 protein structures determined by X-ray crystallography provide a wealth of information for the characterization of biological processes at the molecular level. However, several crystallographic “artifacts,” including conformational selection, crystallization conditions and radiation damages, may affect the quality and the interpretation of the electron density maps, thus limiting the relevance of structure determinations. Moreover, for most of these structures, no functional data have been obtained in the crystalline state, thus posing serious questions on their validity in infereing protein mechanisms. In order to solve these issues, spectroscopic methods have been applied for the determination of equilibrium and kinetic properties of proteins in the crystalline state. These methods are UV-vis spectrophotometry, spectrofluorimetry, IR, EPR, Raman, and resonance Raman spectroscopy. Some of these approaches have been implemented with on-line instruments at X-ray synchrotron beamlines. Here, we provide an overview of investigations predominantly carried out in our laboratory by single crystal polarized absorption UV-vis microspectrophotometry, the most applied technique for the functional characterization of proteins in the crystalline state. Studies on hemoglobins, pyridoxal 5′-phosphate dependent enzymes and green fluorescent protein in the crystalline state have addressed key biological issues, leading to either straightforward structure-function correlations or limitations to structure-based mechanisms.

Allostery and cooperativity revisited

Although phenomenlogical models that account for cooperativity in allosteric systems date back to the early and mid-60's (e.g., the KNF and MWC models), there is resurgent interest in the topic due to the recent experimental and computational studies that attempted to reveal, at an atomistic level, how allostery actually works. In this review, using systems for which atomistic simulations have been carried out in our groups as examples, we describe the current understanding of allostery, how the mechanisms go beyond the classical MWC/Pauling-KNF descriptions, and point out that the "new view" of allostery, emphasizing "population shifts," is, in fact, an "old view." The presentation offers not only an up-to-date description of allostery from a theoretical/computational perspective, but also helps to resolve several outstanding issues concerning allostery.

Oxygen carriers: A selected review

The most common and widely transplanted tissue world wide is blood, which in 2000 resulted in the transfusion of 12.5 million units of blood in the US alone [Goodnough LT, Shander A, Brecher ME. Transfusion medicine: looking to the future. Lancet 2003;361:161-9]. The current use of donated blood products is relatively safe; however, there are inherent problems with allogeneic blood transfusions. The wide spread use of blood in procedures results in problems involving inadequate supply exacerbated in times of war and disasters and by the limited storage life of blood donations (30-42 days). Blood contamination due to patient pre-disposition, poor collection, sterilization, or storage is the second most common cause of death from transfusion in the US [Hillyer CD, Josephson CD, Blajchman MA, Vostal JG, Epstein JS, Goodman JL. Bacterial contamination of blood components: risks, strategies, and regulation: joint ASH and AABB educational session in transfusion medicine. Hematology (Am Soc Hematol Educ Program) 2003:575-89]. Blood is a complex tissue involved in a plethora of homeostatic roles, including immunity, wound healing and the transport of nourishment, electrolytes, hormones, vitamins, heat, oxygen and the removal of metabolic waste products. However, by far the principle role of blood transfusions is the replacement of red cell volume and the maintenance of oxygen levels within the circulation. Creation of investigational new drugs (INDs) which would function as oxygen carriers and prolong shelf life is now a very active arena of scientific research. Several such IND products are now in clinical trials. This article gives an easy to follow concise evaluation of major areas of focus and current testing for each type of blood substitution molecule.

Cooperativity in Scapharca dimeric hemoglobin: simulation of binding intermediates and elucidation of the role of interfacial water

Cooperative binding of ligands to proteins can serve to increase their efficiency and to regulate their activity. Thus, understanding of the mechanism of cooperativity is one of the central concerns of molecular biology. For the tetrameric human hemoglobin (HbA), the cooperative mechanism involves a reasonably well understood combination of tertiary and quaternary changes that occur during the binding process. The dimeric hemoglobin of Scapharca (HbI), which is composed of subunits with the same fold as in HbA, is also highly cooperative but the structural changes on ligand binding are small. A re-orientation of Phe97 in the binding pocket and changes in the number of interfacial water molecules have been implicated in the cooperative mechanism. To explore the role of these factors, we have investigated models of partially liganded intermediate states of HbI with molecular dynamics simulation methods. Since, unlike HbA, no structures for intermediates are available, they were constructed by combining subunits from the unliganded and liganded dimers. Two structurally distinct intermediates were examined, and it was shown that the transition between the two intermediates is directly coupled to the number of interfacial water molecules. Further, it was found that there is a well-defined water channel that connects the interface between the subunits to bulk water. The bottleneck (gate) of the channel, which can be open or closed, is made of hydrophilic residues. The implication of the present results for the cooperative mechanism of HbI is discussed.

The contribution of the asymmetric alpha 1beta 1 half-oxygenated intermediate to human hemoglobin cooperativity

Considerable controversy remains as to the functional and structural properties of the asymmetric alpha1beta1 half-oxygenated intermediate of human hemoglobin, consisting of a deoxygenated and an oxygenated dimer. A recent dimer-tetramer equilibrium study using [Zn(II)/Fe(II)-O(2)] hybrid hemoglobins, in which Zn-protoporphyrin IX mimics a deoxyheme, showed that the key intermediate, [alpha(Fe-O(2))beta(Fe-O(2))][alpha(Zn)beta(Zn)], exhibited an enhanced tetramer stability relative to the other doubly oxygenated species. This is one of the strongest findings in support of distinctly favorable intra-dimer cooperativity within the tetramer. However, we present here a different conclusion drawn from direct O(2) binding experiments for the same asymmetric hybrid, [alpha(Fe)beta(Fe)][alpha(Zn)beta(Zn)], and those for [alpha(Fe)beta(Zn)](2) and [alpha(Zn)beta(Fe)](2). In this study, the O(2) equilibrium curves for [alpha(Fe)beta(Fe)][alpha(Zn)beta(Zn)] were determined by an O(2)-jump stopped-flow technique to circumvent the problem of dimer rearrangement, and those for [alpha(Fe)beta(Zn)]( 2) and [alpha(Zn)beta(Fe)]( 2) were measured by using an Imai apparatus. It was shown that the first and second O(2) equilibrium constants for [alpha(Fe)beta(Fe)][alpha(Zn)beta(Zn)] are 0.0209 mmHg(-1) and 0.0276 mmHg(-1), respectively, that are almost identical to those for [alpha(Fe)beta(Zn)](2) or [alpha(Zn)beta(Fe)](2). Therefore, we did not observe large difference among the asymmetric and symmetric hybrids. The discrepancy between the present and previous studies is mainly due to previously observed negative cooperativity for [alpha(Fe)beta(Zn)](2) and [alpha(Zn)beta(Fe)](2), which is not the case in our direct O(2) binding study.

Confirmation of a unique intra-dimer cooperativity in the human hemoglobin alpha(1)beta(1)half-oxygenated intermediate supports the symmetry rule model of allosteric regulation

The contribution of the alpha(1)beta(1)half-oxygenated tetramer [alphabeta:alphaO(2)betaO(2)] (species 21) to human hemoglobin cooperativity was evaluated using cryogenic isoelectric focusing. The cooperative free energy of binding, reflecting O(2)-driven protein structure changes, was measured as (21)DeltaG(c) = 5.1 +/- 0. 3 kcal for the Zn/FeO(2) analog. For the Fe/FeCN analog, (21)DeltaG(c) was estimated as 4.0 kcal after correction for a CN ligand rearrangement artifact, demonstrating that ligand rearrangement does not invalidate previous conclusions regarding this species. In the context of the entire Hb cooperativity cascade, which includes eight intermediate species, the 21 tetramer is highly abundant relative to the other doubly-ligated species, providing strong support for the previously determined consensus partition function of O(2) binding and for the Symmetry Rule model of hemoglobin cooperativity (Ackers et al., Science 1992;255:54-63). Cooperativity of normal human hemoglobin is shown to depend on site-configuration, and not solely the number of O(2) bound, nor the occupancy of alpha vs. beta subunits. Verification of a unique contribution from the alpha(1)beta(1)doubly-oxygenated species to the equilibrium O(2) binding curve strongly reinforces the Symmetry Rule interpretation that the alpha(1)beta(1)dimer acts both as a structural and functional element in cooperative O(2) binding.

The stereochemical mechanism of the cooperative effects in hemoglobin revisited

In 1970, Perutz tried to put the allosteric mechanism of hemoglobin, proposed by Monod, Wyman and Changeux in 1965, on a stereochemical basis. He interpreted their two-state model in terms of an equilibrium between two alternative structures, a tense one (T) with low oxygen affinity, constrained by salt-bridges between the C-termini of the four subunits, and a relaxed one (R) lacking these bridges. The equilibrium was thought to be governed primarily by the positions of the iron atoms relative to the porphyrin: out-of-plane in five-coordinated, high-spin deoxyhemoglobin, and in-plane in six-coordinated, low-spin oxyhemoglobin. The tension exercised by the salt-bridges in the T-structure was to be transmitted to the heme-linked histidines and to restrain the movement of the iron atoms into the porphyrin plane that is necessary for oxygen binding. At the beta-hemes, the distal valine and histidine block the oxygen-combining site in the T-structure; its tension was thought to strengthen that blockage. Finally, Perutz attributed the linearity of proton release with early oxygen uptake to the sequential rupture of salt-bridges in the T-structure and to the accompanying drop in pKa of the weak bases that form part of them. Almost every feature of this mechanism has been disputed, but evidence that has come to light more than 25 years later now shows it to have been substantially correct. That new evidence is reviewed below.

Oxygen equilibrium properties of chromium (III)-iron (II) hybrid hemoglobins

Cr(III)-Fe(II) hybrid hemoglobins, alpha 2(Cr) beta 2(Fe) and alpha 2(Fe) beta 2(Cr), in which hemes in either the alpha- or beta-subunits were substituted with chromium(III) protoporphyrin IX (Cr(III)(PPIX), were prepared and characterized by oxygen equilibrium measurements. Because Cr(III)PPIX binds neither oxygen molecules nor carbon monoxide, the oxygen equilibrium properties of Fe(II) subunits within these hybrids can be analyzed by a two-step oxygen equilibrium scheme. The oxygen equilibrium constants for both hybrids at the second oxygenation step agree with those for human adult hemoglobin at the last oxygenation step (at pH 6.5-8.4 with an without inositol hexaphosphate at 25 degrees C). The similarity between the effects of the Cr(III)PPIX and each subunits' oxygeme on the oxygen equilibrium properties of the counterpart Fe(II) subunits within hemoglobin indicate the utility of Cr(III)PPIX as a model for a permanently oxygenated heme within the hemoglobin molecule. We found that Cr(III)-Fe(II) hybrid hemoglobins have several advantages over cyanomet valency hybrid hemoglobins, which have been frequently used as a model system for partially oxygenated hemoglobins. In contrast to cyanomet heme, Cr(III)PPIX within hemoglobin is not subject to reduction with dithionite or enzymatic reduction systems. Therefore, we could obtain more accurate and reasonable oxygen equilibrium curves of Cr(III)-Fe(II) hybrids in the presence of an enzymatic reduction system, and we could obtain single crystals of deoxy-alpha 2(Cr) beta 2(Fe) when grown in low salt solution in the presence of polyethylene glycol 1000 and 50 mM dithionite.

Heterometallic hybrids of homometallic human hemoglobins

Hybridization experiments between normal Hb tetramers (Fe2+ Hb) and those with four metal-substituted hemes (i.e., replacement of Fe2+ by Co2+, Mg2+, Mn2+, Mn3+, Ni2+, or Zn2+) have revealed unexpected behavior. These homometallic Hbs have previously served as models that mimic the deoxy or oxy properties of normal Fe2+ Hb. In this study, hybrids were composed of one alpha 1 beta 1 dimer that is metal-substituted at both hemes, in association with a second dimer alpha 2 beta 2 that has normal Fe2+ hemes. Both metal-substituted subunits are unligated, whereas the two Fe2+ subunits either are both unligated or both ligated with O2, CO, or CN. It was found that four of the metal-substituted Hbs (Mg2+ Hb, Mn2+ Hb, Ni2+ Hb, and Zn2+ Hb) did not form detectable amounts of heterometallic hybrids with normal Fe2+ Hb even though (i) their homometallic parents formed tight tetrameric complexes with stabilities similar to that of Fe2+ Hb and (ii) hybrids with metal substitution at both alpha sites or both beta sites are known to form readily. This striking positional effect was independent of whether the normal Fe2+ hemes were ligated and of which ligand was used. These findings indicate that surprisingly large changes in tetramer behavior can arise from small and subtle perturbations at the heme sites. Possible origins of these effects are considered.

Loss of allosteric behaviour in recombinant hemoglobin alpha 2 beta 2(92)(F8) His-->Ala: restoration upon addition of strong effectors

In the stereochemical model proposed by Perutz [1], the Fe-His(F8) bond plays a significant role in the allosteric transition in hemoglobin and the resulting cooperativity in ligand binding. When this bond is ruptured, there is a loss in the transmission of the information concerning ligand binding; examples are Hb(NO)4 in the presence of inositol hexakisphosphate (IHP), or nickel substituted Hb hybrids which, despite being liganded, exhibit deoxy-like properties. To study the effects of the loss of the iron proximal histidine bond, we have engineered the alpha 2 beta 2(F8)H92A recombinant Hb. The replacement of the highly conserved proximal histidine F8 residue by an alanine results in a low affinity for the heme group and a loss of the allosteric properties; kinetics of CO recombination after photodissociation show only the rapid bimolecular phase, characteristic of the high affinity R-state. However, a significant amount of deoxy (T-state) kinetics are observed after addition of external effectors such as IHP. The iron-histidine bond is apparently crucial for the heme-heme interaction, but the allosteric equilibrium may still be influenced by external constraints.

Isolation and stability of partially oxidized intermediates of carp hemoglobin: kinetics of CO binding to the mono- and triferric species

The monoliganded and triliganded forms of the asymmetric valency hybrids of carp hemoglobin were isolated using high-performance liquid chromatography. These partially oxidized hybrids were shown to be sufficiently stable to permit the measurement of the kinetics of CO binding. The effects of protons and inositol hexaphosphate on the rates of these reactions were examined. The kinetics of CO recombination with these partially oxidized derivatives were compared to the kinetics of CO binding to the fully ferrous molecule. To a first approximation, the kinetic behavior of the monoferric derivative was consistent with a small shift in the T<==>R equilibrium in favor of the R state. The presence of three ferric ligands resulted in a still greater shift in the conformational equilibrium in favor of the R state. The kinetic behavior of the triferric molecule was similar, but not identical, to that of a fully ferrous molecule which is triliganded with CO. The properties of both asymmetric valency hybrids were responsive to the nature of the ligand; i.e., the rate of CO binding was increased more by the presence of cyanide on the ferric hemes than by water. Not all of the data could be accommodated within the two-state model. For example, there was evidence of an altered T state in the case of the tricyanomet derivative at low pH in the presence of inositol hexaphosphate.