Phenol kinase activity of the serine/threonine-specific cAMP-dependent protein kinase: steric and electronic effects

Biosensors of protein kinase action: from in vitro assays to living cells

Protein kinases, and the signal transduction pathways in which they participate, are now recognized to be medicinally attractive targets of opportunity. Inhibitors of the protein kinase family not only hold great promise as therapeutic agents, but are also of profound utility in the characterization of signaling pathways. The direct visualization of protein kinase activity in living cells provides a genuine assessment of the efficacy and selectivity of these inhibitors in a physiological setting. In addition, the ability to visualize the activity of a protein kinase in real time furnishes a direct measurement of the activation of specific signaling pathways in response to extracellular stimuli. We have developed two series of fluorescent substrates for protein kinase C (PKC) using a strategy that positions the reporter-group directly on the residue undergoing phosphorylation. The first series of PKC substrates is based, in part, on the Ca(+2) indicators developed by Tsien and his collaborators during the 1980s. In this case, phosphorylation of the substrate creates a divalent metal ion binding site. Upon metal ion coordination, a fluorescence change transpires via a mechanism analogous to that described for the Ca(+2) indicators. The second series of PKC sensors was identified via the preparation and subsequent screen of a library of fluorescently-labeled PKC peptide substrates. The lead derivative displays a phosphorylation-induced fluorescence change that allows the visualization of real-time PKC activity in both cell lysates and living cells. Furthermore, immunodepletion experiments demonstrate that the fluorescently-tagged peptide is selectively, if not exclusively, phosphorylated by the conventional PKCs. Both of the protein kinase biosensor strategies take advantage of the ease with which peptides can be modified to create libraries of structurally altered analogs. However, the inherent synthetic mutability of peptides is not just limited to library construction. For example, it may ultimately be possible to simultaneously monitor multiple protein kinases by affixing fluorophores with distinct photophysical properties to appropriately designed active site-directed peptides.

Real time visualization of protein kinase activity in living cells

A library of fluorescently labeled protein kinase C (PKC) peptide substrates was prepared to identify a phosphorylation-induced reporter of protein kinase activity. The lead PKC substrate displays a 2.5-fold change in fluorescence intensity upon phosphorylation. PKC activity is readily sampled in cell lysates containing the activated PKCs. Immunodepletion of conventional PKCs from the cell lysate eliminates the fluorescence response, suggesting that this peptide substrate is selectively phosphorylated by PKCalpha, beta, and gamma. Finally, living cells microinjected with the peptide substrate exhibit a 2-fold increase in fluorescence intensity upon exposure to a PKC activator. These results suggest that peptide-based protein kinase biosensors may be useful in monitoring the temporal and spatial dynamics of PKC activity in living cells.

The specificity of the protein kinase C alpha, betaII and gamma isoforms as assessed by an unnatural alcohol-appended peptide library

Previous studies using conventional peptide-based libraries have demonstrated that homologous protein-processing enzymes [e.g. the alpha, betaII and gamma isoforms of protein kinase (PKC)] typically display identical amino acid consensus sequences. These observations have hampered the acquisition of selective synthetic substrates for the individual members of these enzyme families. We describe here a parallel synthesis strategy, readily adaptable to the preparation of large libraries, that has led to the emergence of the first examples of selective substrates for the conventional PKC isoforms. In addition, we have found that a wide variety of structurally diverse N-appended alcohol-containing residues, including tyrosine, serve as substrates for the PKC alpha, betaII and gamma isoforms. This broad active-site substrate specificity with respect to both natural and unnatural residues may prove to be especially applicable to the construction of transition-state analogues and suicide substrates, species that often require the presence of structurally elaborate functionality.

Tyrosine analogues as alternative substrates for protein tyrosine kinase Csk: insights into substrate selectivity and catalytic mechanism

Protein tyrosine kinases are critical enzymes in cell signal transduction but relatively little is known about the molecular recognition of the tyrosine substrate by these enzymes. Details of tyrosine substrate specificity within the context of a short peptide were investigated for protein tyrosine kinase Csk. It was found that aryl ring functional group substitutions the size of methyl group or smaller were generally well tolerated by the protein tyrosine kinase Csk whereas larger groups caused a decline in substrate efficiency. Extension of the phenol from the peptide backbone by a single methylene was acceptable for phosphorylation whereas removal of a methylene nearly abolished reactivity. Only the L-tyrosine derivative was processed. A negative charge ortho to the phenol hydroxyl was incompatible with substrate reactivity, consistent with previous pH rate profiles which indicated the importance of the neutral phenol. Overall, these studies confirmed the interpretation of a previous linear free energy relationship analysis which suggested that the enzyme followed a dissociative transition state mechanism.

Synthesis of (2S,3R)-beta-methyltyrosine catalyzed by tyrosine phenol-lyase

A one-step enzymatic synthesis of the conformationally restrained tyrosine analog (2S,3R)-beta-methyltyrosine is reported. This synthesis extends the preparative chemistry associated with tyrosine phenol-lyase. This beta-methyltyrosine derivative was shown to be an efficient protein tyrosine kinase substrate, suggesting that conformational restraint may ultimately be used to enhance tyrosine kinase recognition of substrates.

The active site specificity of the Yersinia protein-tyrosine phosphatase

Yersinia protein-tyrosine phosphatase substrates have been synthesized employing an expedient methodology that incorporates phosphorylated non-amino acid residues into an active site-directed peptide. While the peptidic portion of these compounds serves an enzyme targeting role, the nonpeptidic component provides a critical assessment of the range of functionality that can be accommodated within the active site region. We have found that the Yersinia phosphatase hydrolyzes both L- and D-stereoisomers of phosphotyrosine in active site-directed peptides, with the former serving as a 10-fold more efficient substrate than the latter. In addition, this enzyme catalyzes the hydrolysis of a variety of aromatic and aliphatic phosphates. Indeed, a peptide bearing the achiral phosphotyrosine analog, phosphotyramine, is not only the most efficient substrate described in this study, it is also one of the most efficient substrates ever reported for the Yersinia phosphatase. Straight chain peptide-bound aliphatic phosphates of the general structure, (Glu)4-NH-(CH2)n-OPO3(2-) (n = 2-8), are also hydrolyzed, where the most efficient substrate contains seven methylene groups. Finally, a comparison of the substrate efficacy of the peptide-bound species with that of the corresponding non-peptidic analogs, reveals that the peptide component enhances kcat/Km by up to nearly 3 orders of magnitude.

Is protein kinase substrate efficacy a reliable barometer for successful inhibitor design?

We have addressed the question of whether protein kinase substrate efficacy is a reliable barometer for successful inhibitor design by assessing the dependence of kcat and kcat/Km for eight separate alcohol-bearing residues on solvent viscosity. We have found that the Km for three structurally distinct primary alcohol-containing peptides overestimates the affinity that these species exhibit for the cAMP-dependent protein kinase. In all three cases, the rate-determining step is product release, and substrate binding is best described as rapid equilibrium. In contrast, peptides containing the following phosphorylatable residues all provide Km values that are accurate assessments of substrate affinity for the protein kinase: a secondary alcohol, a simple phenol, and a primary alcohol with a relatively long side chain. In the latter three instances, the rate-determining step is phosphoryl transfer. Finally, two aromatic alcohol-containing residues that possess lipophilic side chains exhibit Michaelis constants that underestimate enzyme affinity. These results demonstrate that while it may be tempting to employ structural elements from the most efficient substrates (e.g. primary alcohols) for inhibitor design, less effective substrates may serve as a more accurate assessment of inhibitory success.

Precision substrate targeting of protein kinases. The cGMP- and cAMP-dependent protein kinases

The cAMP-dependent (PKA) and cGMP-dependent protein kinases (PKG) share a strong primary sequence homology within their respective active site regions. Not surprisingly, these enzymes also exhibit overlapping substrate specificities, a feature that often interferes with efforts to elucidate their distinct biological roles. In this report, we demonstrate that PKA and PKG exhibit dramatically different behavior with respect to the phosphorylation of alpha-substituted alcohols. Although PKA will phosphorylate only residues that contain an alpha-center configuration analogous to that found in L-serine, PKG utilizes residues that correspond to both L- and D-serine as substrates. The PKG/PKA selectivity of these substrates is the highest ever reported.

Precision substrate targeting of protein kinases v-Abl and c-Src

The active site substrate specificities of v-Abl and c-Src are compared and contrasted. Both enzymes catalyze the phosphorylation of a broad assortment of peptide-bound aliphatic and aromatic alcohols, such as achiral and simple straight chain residues. In addition, both protein kinases exhibit a "dual specificity" with respect to the ability to utilize D- and L-configurational isomers as substrates. However, c-Src and v-Abl are extremely inefficient as catalysts for certain structural arrangements, including secondary alcohols and primary alcohols containing large substituents in close proximity to the hydroxyl moiety. In addition to these similarities, these enzymes also display noteworthy differences in catalytic behavior. Whereas c-Src exhibits a modest preference for aromatic versus aliphatic alcohols, v-Abl does not. Most dramatic is the ability of c-Src to utilize short chain alcohols as substrates, an activity virtually absent from the catalytic repertoire of v-Abl. The implications of these observations are 2-fold. First, because both enzymes are able to accommodate a wide variety of structural variants within their respective active site regions, there exists a substantial degree of flexibility with respect to inhibitor design. Second, because these enzymes exhibit disparate active site specificities, it is possible that other tyrosine-specific protein kinases will display unique substrate specificities as well. Consequently, it may ultimately be possible to exploit these differences to generate inhibitors that precisely target specific protein kinases.

The role of the catalytic base in the protein tyrosine kinase Csk

A potential distinguishing feature between protein tyrosine kinases and homologous serine/threonine kinases is the function of the catalytic base in these enzymes. In this study, we show that a peptide containing the unnatural amino acid trifluorotyrosine shows remarkably similar efficiency as a substrate of the tyrosine kinase Csk (C-terminal Src kinase) compared with the corresponding tyrosine-containing peptide despite a 4-unit change in the phenolic pKa. These results argue against the importance of early tyrosine deprotonation by a catalytic base in Csk. To further explore the role of the proposed catalytic base, the Csk mutant protein D314E was produced. This mutant displayed a significant reduction in kcat (approximately 10(4)) but relatively little effect on substrate Km values compared with wild-type Csk. Examination of the thio effect (kcat-ATP/kcat-adenosine 5'-O-(thiotriphosphate)) for D314E Csk led to the suggestion that a role of aspartate 314 may be to enhance the reactivity of the gamma-phosphate of ATP toward electrophilic attack. These results may have significant impact on protein tyrosine kinase inhibitor design.

The extraordinary active site substrate specificity of pp60c-src. A multiple specificity protein kinase

We report the first active site substrate specificity analysis of a tyrosine-specific protein kinase, namely pp60c-src. Like the cAMP-dependent protein kinase and protein kinase C, pp60c-src will phosphorylate an assortment of achiral residues attached to active site-directed peptides. Furthermore, pp60c-src phosphorylates both aromatic and aliphatic alcohols. However, the substrate specificity of pp60c-src is much broader than that of the two previously examined serine/threonine-specific protein kinases. We have previously shown that both the cAMP-dependent protein kinase and protein kinase C will utilize a wide array of non-amino acid residues as substrates, as long as the distance between the hydroxyl moiety and the adjacent peptide backbone is comparable with that present in serine and threonine (Kwon, Y.-G., Mendelow, M., and Lawrence, D. S. (1994) J. Biol. Chem. 269, 4839-4844). In marked contrast, pp60c-src does not discriminate against substrates on the basis of chain length, catalyzing the phosphorylation of residues that contain anywhere from 2-12 carbons between the alcohol functional group and the adjacent peptide bond. In addition, pp60c-src phosphorylates L-serine in an active site-directed peptide. The possible structural basis for the multiple specificity of pp60c-src is discussed. Finally, the active site specificity of pp60c-src is not just limited to L-amino acid residues, but also extends into the realm of D-amino acids as well.