Generation of novel copper sites by mutation of the axial ligand of amicyanin. Atomic resolution structures and spectroscopic properties

X-ray crystallographic evidence for the simultaneous presence of axial and rhombic sites in cupredoxins: atomic resolution X-ray crystal structure analysis of pseudoazurin and DFT modelling

The simultaneous presence of axial (blue) and rhombic (green) Cu sites in pseudoazurin is described from experiments and computational modelling.

Mechanisms for control of biological electron transfer reactions

Electron transfer (ET) through and between proteins is a fundamental biological process. The rates and mechanisms of these ET reactions are controlled by the proteins in which the redox centers that donate and accept electrons reside. The protein influences the magnitudes of the ET parameters, the electronic coupling and reorganization energy that are associated with the ET reaction. The protein can regulate the rates of the ET reaction by requiring reaction steps to optimize the system for ET, leading to kinetic mechanisms of gated or coupled ET. Amino acid residues in the segment of the protein through which long range ET occurs can also modulate the ET rate by serving as staging points for hopping mechanisms of ET. Specific examples are presented to illustrate these mechanisms by which proteins control rates of ET reactions.

Spectroscopic characterization of a green copper site in a single-domain cupredoxin

Cupredoxins are widespread copper-binding proteins, mainly involved in electron transfer pathways. They display a typical rigid greek key motif consisting of an eight stranded β-sandwich. A fascinating feature of cupredoxins is the natural diversity of their copper center geometry. These geometry variations give rise to drastic changes in their color, such as blue, green, red or purple. Based on several spectroscopic and structural analyses, a connection between the geometry of their copper-binding site and their color has been proposed. However, little is known about the relationship between such diversity of copper center geometry in cupredoxins and possible implications for function. This has been difficult to assess, as only a few naturally occurring green and red copper sites have been described so far. We report herein the spectrocopic characterization of a novel kind of single domain cupredoxin of green color, involved in a respiratory pathway of the acidophilic organism Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans. Biochemical and spectroscopic characterization coupled to bioinformatics analysis reveal the existence of some unusual features for this novel member of the green cupredoxin sub-family. This protein has the highest redox potential reported to date for a green-type cupredoxin. It has a constrained green copper site insensitive to pH or temperature variations. It is a green-type cupredoxin found for the first time in a respiratory pathway. These unique properties might be explained by a region of unknown function never found in other cupredoxins, and by an unusual length of the loop between the second and the fourth copper ligands. These discoveries will impact our knowledge on non-engineered green copper sites, whose involvement in respiratory chains seems more widespread than initially thought.

The sole tryptophan of amicyanin enhances its thermal stability but does not influence the electronic properties of the type 1 copper site

The cupredoxin amicyanin possesses a single tryptophan residue, Trp45. Its fluorescence is quenched when copper is bound even though it is separated by 10.1Å. Mutation of Trp45 to Ala, Phe, Leu and Lys resulted in undetectable protein expression. A W45Y amicyanin variant was isolated. The W45Y mutation did not alter the spectroscopic properties or intrinsic redox potential of amicyanin, but increased the pKa value for the pH-dependent redox potential by 0.5 units. This is due to a hydrogen-bond involving the His95 copper ligand which is present in reduced W45Y amicyanin but not in native amicyanin. The W45Y mutation significantly decreased the thermal stability of amicyanin, as determined by changes in the visible absorbance of oxidized amicyanin and in the circular dichroism spectra for oxidized, reduced and apo forms of amicyanin. Comparison of the crystal structures suggests that the decreased stability of W45Y amicyanin may be attributed to the loss of a strong interior hydrogen bond between Trp45 and Tyr90 in native amicyanin which links two of the β-sheets that comprise the overall structure of amicyanin. Thus, Trp45 is critical for stabilizing the structure of amicyanin but it does not influence the electronic properties of the copper which quenches its fluorescence.

Functional importance of a pair of conserved glutamic acid residues and of Ca(2+) binding in the cbb(3)-type oxygen reductases from Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Vibrio cholerae

The cbb(3)-type cytochrome c oxidases are members of the family of heme-copper proton pumping respiratory oxygen reductases. The structure of the cbb(3)-type oxidase from Pseudomonas stutzeri reveals that, in addition to the six redox-active metal centers (two b-type hemes, three c-type hemes, and Cu(B)), the enzyme also contains at least one Ca(2+). The calcium bridges two propionate carboxyls at the interface between the low-spin heme b and the active-site heme b(3) and, in addition, is ligated to a serine in subunit CcoO and by a glutamate in subunit CcoN. The glutamate that is ligated to Ca(2+) is one of a pair of glutamic acid residues that has previously been suggested to be part of a proton exit pathway for pumped protons. In this work, mutations of these glutamates are investigated in the cbb(3)-type oxidases from Vibrio cholerae and Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Metal analysis shows that each of these wild-type enzymes contains Ca(2+). Mutations of the glutamate expected to ligate the Ca(2+) in each of these enzymes (E126 in V. cholerae and E180 in R. sphaeroides) result in a loss of activity as well as a loss of Ca(2+). Mutations of the nearby glutamate (E129 in V. cholerae and E183 in R. sphaeroides) also resulted in a loss of oxidase activity and a loss of Ca(2+). It is concluded that the Ca(2+) is essential for assembly of the fully functional enzyme and that neither of the glutamates is likely to be part of a pathway for pumped protons within the cbb(3)-type oxygen reductases. A more likely role for these glutamates is the maintenance of the structural integrity of the active conformation of the enzyme.

Differential effects of glutamate-286 mutations in the aa(3)-type cytochrome c oxidase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides and the cytochrome bo(3) ubiquinol oxidase from Escherichia coli

Both the aa(3)-type cytochrome c oxidase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides (RsCcO(aa3)) and the closely related bo(3)-type ubiquinol oxidase from Escherichia coli (EcQO(bo3)) possess a proton-conducting D-channel that terminates at a glutamic acid, E286, which is critical for controlling proton transfer to the active site for oxygen chemistry and to a proton loading site for proton pumping. E286 mutations in each enzyme block proton flux and, therefore, inhibit oxidase function. In the current work, resonance Raman spectroscopy was used to show that the E286A and E286C mutations in RsCcO(aa3) result in long range conformational changes that influence the protein interactions with both heme a and heme a(3). Therefore, the severe reduction of the steady-state activity of the E286 mutants in RsCcO(aa3) to ~0.05% is not simply a result of the direct blockage of the D-channel, but it is also a consequence of the conformational changes induced by the mutations to heme a and to the heme a(3)-Cu(B) active site. In contrast, the E286C mutation of EcQO(bo3) exhibits no evidence of conformational changes at the two heme sites, indicating that its reduced activity (3%) is exclusively a result of the inhibition of proton transfer from the D-channel. We propose that in RsCcO(aa3), the E286 mutations severely perturb the active site through a close interaction with F282, which lies between E286 and the heme-copper active site. The local structure around E286 in EcQO(bo3) is different, providing a rationale for the very different effects of E286 mutations in the two enzymes. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Allosteric cooperativity in respiratory proteins.

Replacement of the axial copper ligand methionine with lysine in amicyanin converts it to a zinc-binding protein that no longer binds copper

The mutation of the axial ligand of the type I copper protein amicyanin from Met to Lys results in a protein that is spectroscopically invisible and redox inactive. M98K amicyanin acts as a competitive inhibitor in the reaction of native amicyanin with methylamine dehydrogenase indicating that the M98K mutation has not affected the affinity for its natural electron donor. The crystal structure of M98K amicyanin reveals that its overall structure is very similar to native amicyanin but that the type I binding site is occupied by zinc. Anomalous difference Fourier maps calculated using the data collected around the absorption edges of copper and zinc confirm the presence of Zn(2+) at the type I site. The Lys98 NZ donates a hydrogen bond to a well-ordered water molecule at the type I site which enhances the ability of Lys98 to provide a ligand for Zn(2+). Attempts to reconstitute M98K apoamicyanin with copper resulted in precipitation of the protein. The fact that the M98K mutation generated such a selective zinc-binding protein was surprising as ligation of zinc by Lys is rare and this ligand set is unique for zinc.

Cupredoxins--a study of how proteins may evolve to use metals for bioenergetic processes

Cupredoxins are small proteins that contain type I copper centers, which are ubiquitous in nature. They function as electron transfer shuttles between proteins. This review of the structure and properties of native cupredoxins, and those modified by site-directed mutagenesis, illustrates how these proteins may have evolved to specifically bind copper, develop recognition sites for specific redox partners, tune redox potential for a particular function, and allow for efficient electron transfer through the protein matrix. This is relevant to the general understanding of the roles of metals in energy metabolism, respiration and photosynthesis.

Communication between R481 and Cu(B) in cytochrome bo(3) ubiquinol oxidase from Escherichia coli

The R481 residue of cytochrome bo(3) ubiquinol oxidase from E. coli is highly conserved in the heme-copper oxidase superfamily. It has been postulated to serve as part of a proton loading site that regulates proton translocation across the protein matrix of the enzyme. Along these lines, proton pumping efficiency has been demonstrated to be abolished in many R481 mutants. However, R481Q in bo(3) from E. coli has been shown to be fully functional, implying that the positive charge of the arginine is not required for proton translocation [ Puustinen , A. and Wikstrom , M. ( 1999 ) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 96 , 35 - 37 ]. In an effort to delineate the structural role of R481 in the bo(3) oxidase, we used resonance Raman spectroscopy to compare the nonfunctional R481L mutant and the functional R481Q mutant, to the wild type protein. Resonance Raman data of the oxidized and reduced forms of the R481L mutant indicate that the mutation introduces changes to the heme o(3) coordination state, reflecting a change in position and/or coordination of the Cu(B) located on the distal side of heme o(3), although it is approximately 10 A away from R481. In the reduced-CO adduct of R481L, the frequencies of the Fe-CO and C-O stretching modes indicate that, unlike the wild type protein, the Cu(B) is no longer close to the heme-bound CO. In contrast, resonance Raman data obtained from the various oxidation and ligation states of the R481Q mutant are similar to those of the wild type protein, except that the mutation causes an enhancement of the relative intensity of the beta conformer of the CO-adduct, indicating a shift in the equilibrium between the alpha and beta conformers. The current findings, together with crystallographic structural data of heme-copper oxidases, indicate that R481 plays a keystone role in stabilizing the functional structure of the Cu(B) site through a hydrogen bonding network involving ordered water molecules. The implications of these data on the proton translocation mechanism are considered.

Defining the role of the axial ligand of the type 1 copper site in amicyanin by replacement of methionine with leucine

The effects of replacing the axial methionine ligand of the type 1 copper site with leucine on the structure and function of amicyanin have been characterized. The crystal structures of the oxidized and reduced forms of the protein reveal that the copper site is now tricoordinate with no axial ligand, and that the copper coordination distances for the two ligands provided by histidines are significantly increased. Despite these structural changes, the absorption and EPR spectra of M98L amicyanin are only slightly altered and still consistent with that of a typical type 1 site. The oxidation-reduction midpoint potential (E(m)) value becomes 127 mV more positive as a consequence of the M98L mutation, most likely because of the increased hydrophobicity of the copper site. The most dramatic effect of the mutation was on the electron transfer (ET) reaction from reduced M98L amicyanin to cytochrome c(551i) within the protein ET complex. The rate decreased 435-fold, which was much more than expected from the change in E(m). Examination of the temperature dependence of the ET rate (k(ET)) revealed that the mutation caused a 13.6-fold decrease in the electronic coupling (H(AB)) for the reaction. A similar decrease was predicted from a comparative analysis of the crystal structures of reduced M98L and native amicyanins. The most direct route of ET for this reaction is through the Met98 ligand. Inspection of the structures suggests that the major determinant of the large decrease in the experimentally determined values of H(AB) and k(ET) is the increased distance from the copper to the protein within the type 1 site of M98L amicyanin.

Molecular dynamics of amicyanin reveals a conserved dynamical core for blue copper proteins

Molecular dynamics simulation has been carried out for the blue copper protein amicyanin from two different sources, Paracoccus denitrificans and Paraccocus versutus, to investigate the structural and dynamical properties common to the two molecules and to identify prominent features shared with proteins of the same family, the monomeric cupredoxins. The two amicyanins have almost identical secondary and tertiary structure. In the simulation, they differ for the number of hydrogen bonds in the main chain and the conformation of some beta-strands. However, they strictly maintain the arrangement of the portions of the beta-barrel that are conserved in the folding architecture of the blue copper proteins. Paracoccus versutus amicyanin equilibrates more rapidly, shows lower atomic deviation values, and is less rigid with respect to Paracoccus denitrificans amicyanin. Principal component analysis reveals that the conformational subspaces corresponding to eigenvectors with the same index for each of the two molecules are not necessarily equivalent. Nevertheless, a core scaffold with constrained dynamics exist for both amicyanins. In addition, two fairly flexible regions that are located on the opposite side with respect to the interaction sites with the partner molecules in the redox process have been evidenced in the protein structure. This description of amicyanin, with a few mobile regions remote from the active site and a rigid scaffold including most of the protein beta-barrel, has a close similarity with that of azurin and plastocyanin, two other cupredoxins previously investigated in simulation. Furthermore, similarities in the distribution of the atomic fluctuations indicate that amicyanin, azurin, and plastocyanin possess common dynamical features, in spite of differences in their structure. On the basis of these findings, we suggest that topological constraints imposed by the folding in correspondence of protein regions that are the most conserved determine the protein dynamics of the cupredoxin family. The dynamical properties of the cupredoxins might be controlled for functional advantages that include the binding mechanism with the biological partners and the collective inner motions of the protein matrix required for the electron transfer, whereas long-range conformational changes in the redox reaction should be excluded.

Protein control of true, gated, and coupled electron transfer reactions

Electron transfer (ET) through and between proteins is a fundamental biological process. The rates of ET depend upon the thermodynamic driving force, the reorganization energy, and the degree of electronic coupling between the reactant and product states. The analysis of protein ET reactions is complicated by the fact that non-ET processes might influence the observed ET rate in kinetically complex biological systems. This Account describes studies of the methylamine dehydrogenase-amicyanin-cytochrome c-551i protein ET complex that have revealed the influence of several features of the protein structure on the magnitudes of the physical parameters for true ET reactions and how they dictate the kinetic mechanisms of non-ET processes that sometimes influence protein ET reactions. Kinetic and thermodynamic studies, coupled with structural information and biochemical data, are necessary to fully describe the ET reactions of proteins. Site-directed mutagenesis can be used to elucidate specific structure-function relationships. When mutations selectively alter the electronic coupling, reorganization energy, or driving force for the ET reaction, it becomes possible to use the parameters of the ET process to determine how specific amino acid residues and other features of the protein structure influence the ET rates. When mutations alter the kinetic mechanism for ET, one can determine the mechanisms by which non-ET processes, such as protein conformational changes or proton transfers, control the rates of ET reactions and how specific amino acid residues and certain features of the protein structure influence these non-ET reactions. A complete description of the mechanism of regulation of biological ET reactions enhances our understanding of metabolism, respiration, and photosynthesis at the molecular level. Such information has important medical relevance. Defective protein ET leads to production of the reactive oxygen species and free radicals that are associated with aging and many disease states. Defective ET within the respiratory chain also causes certain mitochondrial myopathies. An understanding of the mechanisms of regulation of protein ET is also of practical value because it provides a logical basis for the design of applications utilizing redox enzymes, such as enzyme-based electrode sensors and fuel cells.

The axial ligand and extent of protein folding determine whether Zn or Cu binds to amicyanin

M98Q amicyanin is isolated with zinc bound to its type 1 copper-binding site. The influence of the axial ligand of the type 1 copper site on metal specificity is strongest prior to the completion of protein folding and adoption of the final type 1 site geometry. The preference for zinc over copper correlated with the selectivity of apoamicyanin in vitro in the partially folded, rather than the completely folded state. These results suggest that metal incorporation in vivo occurs during protein folding in the periplasm and not to a preformed type 1 site.

Correlation of rhombic distortion of the type 1 copper site of M98Q amicyanin with increased electron transfer reorganization energy

Mutation of the axial Met ligand of the type 1 copper site of amicyanin to Ala or Gln yielded M98A amicyanin, which exhibits typical axial type 1 ligation geometry but with a water molecule providing the axial ligand, and M98Q amicyanin, which exhibits significant rhombic distortion of the type 1 site (Carrell, C. J., Ma, J. K., Antholine, W. E., Hosler, J. P., Mathews, F. S., and Davidson, V. L. (2007) Biochemistry 46, 1900-1912). Despite the change of the axial ligand, the M98Q and M98A mutations had little effect on the redox potential of copper. The true electron transfer (ET) reactions from O-quinol methylamine dehydrogenase to oxidized native and mutant amicyanins revealed that the M98A mutation had little effect on kET, but the M98Q mutation reduced kET 45-fold. Thermodynamic analysis of the latter showed that the decrease in kET was due to an increase of 0.4 eV in the reorganization energy (lambda) associated with the ET reaction to M98Q amicyanin. No change in the experimentally determined electronic coupling or ET distance was observed, confirming that the mutation had not altered the rate-determining step for ET and that this was still a true ET reaction. The basis for the increased lambda is not the nature of the atom that provides the axial ligand because each uses an oxygen from Gln in M98Q amicyanin and from water in M98A amicyanin. Comparisons of the distance of the axial copper ligand from the equatorial plane that is formed by the other three copper ligands in isomorphous crystals of native and mutant amicyanins at atomic resolution indicate an increase in distance from 0.20 A in the native to 0.42 A in M98Q amicyanin and a slight decrease in distance for M98A amicyanin. This correlates with the rhombic distortion caused by the M98Q mutation that is clearly evident in the EPR and visible absorption spectra of the protein and suggests that the extent of rhombicity of the type 1 copper site influences the magnitude of lambda.