Protected sulfur transfer reactions by the Escherichia coli Suf system

Development of a Spectrophotometric Assay for the Cysteine Desulfurase from Staphylococcus aureus

Background/Objectives: Antibiotic-resistant Staphylococcus aureus represents a growing threat in the modern world, and new antibiotic targets are needed for its successful treatment. One such potential target is the pyridoxal-5'-phosphate (PLP)-dependent cysteine desulfurase (SaSufS) of the SUF-like iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster biogenesis pathway upon which S. aureus relies exclusively for Fe-S synthesis. The current methods for measuring the activity of this protein have allowed for its recent characterization, but they are hampered by their use of chemical reagents which require long incubation times and may cause undesired side reactions. This problem highlights a need for the development of a rapid quantitative assay for the characterization of SaSufS in the presence of potential inhibitors. Methods: A spectrophotometric assay based on the well-documented absorbance of PLP intermediates at 340 nm was both compared to an established alanine detection assay and used to effectively measure the activity of SaSufS incubated in the absence and presence of the PLP-binding inhibitors, D-cycloserine (DCS) and L-cycloserine (LCS) as proof of concept. Methicillin-resistant S. aureus strain LAC was also grown in the presence of these inhibitors. Results: The Michaelis-Menten parameters kcat and Km of SaSufS were determined using the alanine detection assay and compared to corresponding intermediate-based values obtained spectrophotometrically in the absence and presence of the reducing agent tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine (TCEP). These data revealed the formation of both an intermediate that achieves steady-state during continued enzyme turnover and an intermediate that likely accumulates upon the stoppage of the catalytic cycle during the second turnover. The spectrophotometric method was then utilized to determine the half maximal inhibitory concentration (IC50) values for DCS and LCS binding to SaSufS, which are 2170 ± 920 and 62 ± 23 μM, respectively. Both inhibitors of SaSufS were also found to inhibit the growth of S. aureus. Conclusions: Together, this work offers a spectrophotometric method for the analysis of new inhibitors of SufS and lays the groundwork for the future development of novel antibiotics targeting cysteine desulfurases.

Two conserved arginine residues facilitate C-S bond cleavage and persulfide transfer in Suf family cysteine desulfurases

Under conditions of oxidative stress or iron starvation, iron-sulfur cluster biogenesis in E. coli is initiated by the cysteine desulfurase, SufS, via the SUF pathway. SufS is a type II cysteine desulfurase that catalyzes the PLP-dependent breakage of an L-cysteine C-S bond to generate L-alanine and a covalent active site persulfide as products. The persulfide is transferred from SufS to SufE and then to the SufBC2D complex, which utilizes it in iron-sulfur cluster biogenesis. Several lines of evidence suggest two conserved arginine residues that line the solvent side of the SufS active site could be important for function. To investigate the mechanistic roles of R56 and R359, the residues were substituted using site-directed mutagenesis to obtain R56A/K and R359A/K SufS variants. Steady state kinetics indicated R56 and R359 have moderate defects in the desulfurase half reaction but major defects in the transpersulfurase step. Fluorescence polarization binding assays showed that the loss of activity was not due to a defect in forming the SufS/SufE complex. Structural characterization of R56A SufS shows loss of electron density for the α3-α4 loop at the R56/G57 positions, consistent with a requirement of R56 for proper loop conformation. The structure of R359A SufS exhibits a conformational change in the α3-α4 loop allowing R56 to enter the active site and mimics the residue's position in the PLP-cysteine aldimine structure. Taken together, the kinetic, binding, and structural data support a mechanism where R359 plays a role in linking SufS catalysis with modulation of the α3-α4 loop to promote a close-approach interaction of SufS and SufE conducive to persulfide transfer.

Interactions with sulfur acceptors modulate the reactivity of cysteine desulfurases and define their physiological functions

Sulfur-containing biomolecules such as [FeS] clusters, thiamin, biotin, molybdenum cofactor, and sulfur-containing tRNA nucleosides are essential for various biochemical reactions. The amino acid l-cysteine serves as the major sulfur source for the biosynthetic pathways of these sulfur-containing cofactors in prokaryotic and eukaryotic systems. The first reaction in the sulfur mobilization involves a class of pyridoxal-5'-phosphate (PLP) dependent enzymes catalyzing a Cys:sulfur acceptor sulfurtransferase reaction. The first half of the catalytic reaction involves a PLP-dependent CS bond cleavage, resulting in a persulfide enzyme intermediate. The second half of the reaction involves the subsequent transfer of the thiol group to a specific acceptor molecule, which is responsible for the physiological role of the enzyme. Structural and biochemical analysis of these Cys sulfurtransferase enzymes shows that specific protein-protein interactions with sulfur acceptors modulate their catalytic reactivity and restrict their biochemical functions.

Fe-S biogenesis by SMS and SUF pathways: A focus on the assembly step

FeS clusters are prosthetic groups present in all organisms. Proteins with FeS centers are involved in most cellular processes. ISC and SUF are machineries necessary for the formation and insertion of FeS in proteins. Recently, a phylogenetic analysis on more than 10,000 genomes of prokaryotes have uncovered two new systems, MIS and SMS, which were proposed to be ancestral to ISC and SUF. SMS is composed of SmsBC, two homologs of SufBC(D), the scaffolding complex of SUF. In this review, we will specifically focus on the current knowledge of the SUF system and on the new perspectives given by the recent discovery of its ancestor, the SMS system.

CyaY and TusA regulate ISC- and SUF-mediated l-cysteine desulfurase activity

CyaY, the frataxin homolog of Escherichia coli, plays an important role in ISC iron-sulfur cluster assembly through interactions with the cysteine desulfurase IscS, which regulate the supply of sulfur. IscS is not exclusive for ISC Fe-S cluster assembly, as it functions as a hub for the supply of sulfur to a number of other sulfur-requiring pathways, such as for the biosynthesis of Moco and thiolated tRNAs. How the balance of sulfur supply to the various competing pathways is achieved is not fully understood, but a network of protein-protein interactions plays a key role. For example, IscU and TusA compete for binding to IscS and thus for sulfur supply to ISC and Moco/tRNA biosynthesis. Here, we show that TusA can displace CyaY from IscS and can form hetero-complexes involving IscS, CyaY and TusA. Displacement of CyaY from IscS raised the question of whether it can interact with the SUF pathway. The SUF cysteine desulfurase SufS functions as a complex with SufE. Native mass spectrometry studies showed that the SufS dimer can bind up to four SufE molecules, two at high affinity, and two at low affinity, sites. Titration of SufSE (or SufS alone) with CyaY demonstrated binding, probably at the lower affinity site in competition with SufE. Binding of CyaY dramatically reduced the activity of SufSE in vitro, and over-expression of CyaY also significantly affected total cellular desulfurase activity and Fe-S cluster assembly, with the greatest effect observed in mutant strains in which SufS was the principal desulfurase. These data point to a physiological role for CyaY in regulating the desulfurase activity of IscS and SufS and, hence, both the E.coli iron-sulfur assembly systems. They also demonstrate that TusA can displace the regulatory CyaY protein from IscS-CyaY complexes, facilitating sulfur delivery from IscS to other essential cellular processes, and increasing the likelihood of SufSE-CyaY interactions.

The structure of the SufS-SufE complex reveals interactions driving protected persulfide transfer in iron-sulfur cluster biogenesis

Fe-S clusters are critical cofactors for redox chemistry in all organisms. The cysteine desulfurase, SufS, provides sulfur in the SUF Fe-S cluster bioassembly pathway. SufS is a dimeric, pyridoxal 5'-phosphate-dependent enzyme that uses cysteine as a substrate to generate alanine and a covalent persulfide on an active site cysteine residue. SufS enzymes are activated by an accessory transpersulfurase protein, either SufE or SufU depending on the organism, which accepts the persulfide product and delivers it to downstream partners for Fe-S assembly. Here, using Escherichia coli proteins, we present the first X-ray crystal structure of a SufS/SufE complex. There is a 1:1 stoichiometry with each monomeric unit of the EcSufS dimer bound to one EcSufE subunit, though one EcSufE is rotated ∼7° closer to the EcSufS active site. EcSufE makes clear interactions with the α16 helix of EcSufS and site-directed mutants of several α16 residues were deficient in EcSufE binding. Analysis of the EcSufE structure showed a loss of electron density at the EcSufS/EcSufE interface for a flexible loop containing the highly conserved residue R119. An R119A EcSufE variant binds EcSufS but is not active in cysteine desulfurase assays and fails to support Fe-S cluster bioassembly in vivo. 35S-transfer assays suggest that R119A EcSufE can receive a persulfide, suggesting the residue may function in a release mechanism. The structure of the EcSufS/EcSufE complex allows for comparison with other cysteine desulfurases to understand mechanisms of protected persulfide transfer across protein interfaces.

Persulfide Transfer to SufE Activates the Half-Sites Reactivity of the E. coli Cysteine Desulfurase SufS

The Escherichia coli cysteine desulfurase SufS (EcSufS) is a dimeric, PLP-dependent enzyme responsible for sulfur mobilization in the SUF Fe-S cluster bioassembly pathway. The enzyme uses cysteine as a sulfur source and generates alanine and a covalent persulfide located on an active site of cysteine. Optimal in vitro activity of EcSufS requires the presence of the transpersulfurase protein, EcSufE, and a strong reductant. Here, presteady-state and single-turnover kinetics are used to investigate the mechanism of EcSufS activation by EcSufE. In the absence of EcSufE, EcSufS exhibits a presteady-state burst of product production with an amplitude of ∼0.4 active site equivalents, consistent with a half-sites reactivity. KinTek Explorer was used to isolate the first turnover of alanine formation and fit the data with a simplified kinetic mechanism with steps for alanine formation (k3) and a net rate constant for the downstream steps (k5). Using this treatment, microscopic rate constants of 2.3 ± 0.5 s-1 and 0.10 ± 0.01 s-1 were determined for k3 and k5, respectively. The inclusion of EcSufE in the reaction results in a similar rate constant for k3 but induces a 10-fold enhancement of k5 to 1.1 ± 0.2 s-1, such that both steps are partially rate-determining. The most likely downstream step where EcSufE could exert influence on EcSufS activity is the removal of the persulfide intermediate. Importantly, this step appears to serve as a limiting feature in the half-sites activity such that activating persulfide transfer allows for rapid shifting between active sites. Single-turnover assays show that the presence of EcSufE slightly slowed the rates of alanine-forming steps, suggesting it does not activate steps in the desulfurase half reaction.

The structure of the SufS-SufE complex reveals interactions driving protected persulfide transfer in iron-sulfur cluster biogenesis

Fe-S clusters are critical cofactors for redox chemistry in all organisms. The cysteine desulfurase, SufS, provides sulfur in the SUF Fe-S cluster bioassembly pathway. SufS is a dimeric, PLP-dependent enzyme that uses cysteine as a substrate to generate alanine and a covalent persulfide on an active site cysteine residue. SufS enzymes are activated by an accessory transpersulfurase protein, either SufE or SufU depending on the organism, which accepts the persulfide product and delivers it to downstream partners for Fe-S assembly. Here, using E. coli proteins, we present the first X-ray crystal structure of a SufS/SufE complex. There is a 1:1 stoichiometry with each monomeric unit of the EcSufS dimer bound to one EcSufE subunit, though one EcSufE is rotated ~7° closer to the EcSufS active site. EcSufE makes clear interactions with the α16 helix of EcSufS and site-directed mutants of several α16 residues were deficient in EcSufE binding. Analysis of the EcSufE structure showed a loss of electron density at the EcSufS/EcSufE interface for a flexible loop containing the highly conserved residue R119. An R119A EcSufE variant binds EcSufS but is not active in cysteine desulfurase assays and fails to support Fe-S cluster bioassembly in vivo. 35S-transfer assays suggest that R119A EcSufE can receive a persulfide, suggesting the residue may function in a release mechanism. The structure of the EcSufS/EcSufE complex allows for comparison with other cysteine desulfurases to understand mechanisms of protected persulfide transfer across protein interfaces.

Structural and Biochemical Characterization of Mycobacterium tuberculosis Zinc SufU-SufS Complex

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are inorganic prosthetic groups in proteins composed exclusively of iron and inorganic sulfide. These cofactors are required in a wide range of critical cellular pathways. Iron-sulfur clusters do not form spontaneously in vivo; several proteins are required to mobilize sulfur and iron, assemble and traffic-nascent clusters. Bacteria have developed several Fe-S assembly systems, such as the ISC, NIF, and SUF systems. Interestingly, in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), the causative agent of tuberculosis (TB), the SUF machinery is the primary Fe-S biogenesis system. This operon is essential for the viability of Mtb under normal growth conditions, and the genes it contains are known to be vulnerable, revealing the Mtb SUF system as an interesting target in the fight against tuberculosis. In the present study, two proteins of the Mtb SUF system were characterized for the first time: Rv1464(sufS) and Rv1465(sufU). The results presented reveal how these two proteins work together and thus provide insights into Fe-S biogenesis/metabolism by this pathogen. Combining biochemistry and structural approaches, we showed that Rv1464 is a type II cysteine-desulfurase enzyme and that Rv1465 is a zinc-dependent protein interacting with Rv1464. Endowed with a sulfurtransferase activity, Rv1465 significantly enhances the cysteine-desulfurase activity of Rv1464 by transferring the sulfur atom from persulfide on Rv1464 to its conserved Cys40 residue. The zinc ion is important for the sulfur transfer reaction between SufS and SufU, and His354 in SufS plays an essential role in this reaction. Finally, we showed that Mtb SufS-SufU is more resistant to oxidative stress than E. coli SufS-SufE and that the presence of zinc in SufU is likely responsible for this improved resistance. This study on Rv1464 and Rv1465 will help guide the design of future anti-tuberculosis agents.

The β-latch structural element of the SufS cysteine desulfurase mediates active site accessibility and SufE transpersulfurase positioning

Under oxidative stress and iron starvation conditions, Escherichia coli uses the Suf pathway to assemble iron-sulfur clusters. The Suf pathway mobilizes sulfur via SufS, a type II cysteine desulfurase. SufS is a pyridoxal-5'-phosphate-dependent enzyme that uses cysteine to generate alanine and an active-site persulfide (C₃₆₄-S-S^-). The SufS persulfide is protected from external oxidants/reductants and requires the transpersulfurase, SufE, to accept the persulfide to complete the SufS catalytic cycle. Recent reports on SufS identified a conserved "β-latch" structural element that includes the α₆ helix, a glycine-rich loop, a β-hairpin, and a cis-proline residue. To identify a functional role for the β-latch, we used site-directed mutagenesis to obtain the N99D and N99A SufS variants. N99 is a conserved residue that connects the α₆ helix to the backbone of the glycine-rich loop via hydrogen bonds. Our x-ray crystal structures for N99A and N99D SufS show a distorted beta-hairpin and glycine-rich loop, respectively, along with changes in the dimer geometry. The structural disruption of the N99 variants allowed the external reductant TCEP to react with the active-site C364-persulfide intermediate to complete the SufS catalytic cycle in the absence of SufE. The substitutions also appear to disrupt formation of a high-affinity, close approach SufS-SufE complex as measured with fluorescence polarization. Collectively, these findings demonstrate that the β-latch does not affect the chemistry of persulfide formation but does protect it from undesired reductants. The data also indicate the β-latch plays an unexpected role in forming a close approach SufS-SufE complex to promote persulfide transfer.

Structural and Biochemical Characterization of Staphylococcus aureus Cysteine Desulfurase Complex SufSU

In this work, we provide the first in vitro characterization of two essential proteins from Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) involved in iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster biogenesis: the cysteine desulfurase SufS and the sulfurtransferase SufU. Together, these proteins form the transient SufSU complex and execute the first stage of Fe-S cluster biogenesis in the SUF-like pathway in Gram-positive bacteria. The proteins involved in the SUF-like pathway, such as SufS and SufU, are essential in Gram-positive bacteria since these bacteria tend to lack redundant Fe-S cluster biogenesis pathways. Most previous work characterizing the SUF-like pathway has focused on Bacillus subtilis (B. subtilis). We focus on the SUF-like pathway in S. aureus because of its potential to serve as a therapeutic target to treat S. aureus infections. Herein, we characterize S. aureus SufS (SaSufS) by X-ray crystallography and UV-vis spectroscopy, and we characterize S. aureus SufU (SaSufU) by a zinc binding fluorescence assay and small-angle X-ray scattering. We show that SaSufS is a type II cysteine desulfurase and that SaSufU is a Zn2+-containing sulfurtransferase. Additionally, we evaluated the cysteine desulfurase activity of the SaSufSU complex and compared its activity to that of B. subtilis SufSU. Subsequent cross-species activity analysis reveals a surprising result: SaSufS is significantly less stimulated by SufU than BsSufS. Our results set a basis for further characterization of SaSufSU as well as the development of new therapeutic strategies for treating infections caused by S. aureus by inhibiting the SUF-like pathway.

Towards a metabolomic approach to investigate iron-sulfur cluster biogenesis

Iron–sulfur clusters are prosthetic groups that are assembled on their acceptor proteins through a complex machine centered on a desulfurase enzyme and a transient scaffold protein. Studies to establish the mechanism of cluster formation have so far used either in vitro or in vivo methods, which have often resulted in contrasting or non‐comparable results. We suggest, here, an alternative approach to study the enzymatic reaction, that is based on the combination of genetically engineered bacterial strains depleted of specific components, and the detection of the enzymatic kinetics in cellular extracts through metabolomics. Our data prove that this ex vivo approach closely reproduces the in vitro results while retaining the full complexity of the system. We demonstrate that co‐presence of bacterial frataxin and iron is necessary to observe an inhibitory effect of the enzymatic activity of bacterial frataxin. Our approach provides a new powerful tool for the study of iron–sulfur cluster biogenesis.

Synthetic biology for improved hydrogen production in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Hydrogen is a clean alternative to fossil fuels. It has applications for electricity generation and transportation and is used for the manufacturing of ammonia and steel. However, today, H₂ is almost exclusively produced from coal and natural gas. As such, methods to produce H₂ that do not use fossil fuels need to be developed and adopted. The biological manufacturing of H₂ may be one promising solution as this process is clean and renewable. Hydrogen is produced biologically via enzymes called hydrogenases. There are three classes of hydrogenases namely [FeFe], [NiFe] and [Fe] hydrogenases. The [FeFe] hydrogenase HydA1 from the model unicellular algae Chlamydomonas reinhardtii has been studied extensively and belongs to the A1 subclass of [FeFe] hydrogenases that have the highest turnover frequencies amongst hydrogenases (21,000 ± 12,000 H₂ s⁻¹ for CaHydA from Clostridium acetobutyliticum). Yet to date, limitations in C. reinhardtii H₂ production pathways have hampered commercial scale implementation, in part due to O₂ sensitivity of hydrogenases and competing metabolic pathways, resulting in low H₂ production efficiency. Here, we describe key processes in the biogenesis of HydA1 and H₂ production pathways in C. reinhardtii. We also summarize recent advancements of algal H₂ production using synthetic biology and describe valuable tools such as high‐throughput screening (HTS) assays to accelerate the process of engineering algae for commercial biological H₂ production.

Structural diversity of cysteine desulfurases involved in iron-sulfur cluster biosynthesis

Cysteine desulfurases are pyridoxal-5'-phosphate (PLP)-dependent enzymes that mobilize sulfur derived from the l-cysteine substrate to the partner sulfur acceptor proteins. Three cysteine desulfurases, IscS, NifS, and SufS, have been identified in ISC, NIF, and SUF/SUF-like systems for iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster biosynthesis, respectively. These cysteine desulfurases have been investigated over decades, providing insights into shared/distinct catalytic processes based on two types of enzymes (type I: IscS and NifS, type II: SufS). This review summarizes the insights into the structural/functional varieties of bacterial and eukaryotic cysteine desulfurases involved in Fe-S cluster biosynthetic systems. In addition, an inactive cysteine desulfurase IscS paralog, which contains pyridoxamine-5'-phosphate (PMP), instead of PLP, is also described to account for its hypothetical function in Fe-S cluster biosynthesis involving this paralog. The structural basis for cysteine desulfurase functions will be a stepping stone towards understanding the diversity and evolution of Fe-S cluster biosynthesis.

Bacterial Approaches for Assembling Iron-Sulfur Proteins

Building iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters and assembling Fe-S proteins are essential actions for life on Earth. The three processes that sustain life, photosynthesis, nitrogen fixation, and respiration, require Fe-S proteins. Genes coding for Fe-S proteins can be found in nearly every sequenced genome. Fe-S proteins have a wide variety of functions, and therefore, defective assembly of Fe-S proteins results in cell death or global metabolic defects. Compared to alternative essential cellular processes, there is less known about Fe-S cluster synthesis and Fe-S protein maturation. Moreover, new factors involved in Fe-S protein assembly continue to be discovered. These facts highlight the growing need to develop a deeper biological understanding of Fe-S cluster synthesis, holo-protein maturation, and Fe-S cluster repair. Here, we outline bacterial strategies used to assemble Fe-S proteins and the genetic regulation of these processes. We focus on recent and relevant findings and discuss future directions, including the proposal of using Fe-S protein assembly as an antipathogen target.

Methods to Investigate the Kinetic Profile of Cysteine Desulfurases

Biological iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are essential protein prosthetic groups that promote a range of biochemical reactions. In vivo, these clusters are synthesized by specialized protein machineries involved in sulfur mobilization, cluster assembly, and cluster transfer to their target proteins. Cysteine desulfurases initiate the first step of sulfur activation and mobilization in cluster biosynthetic pathways. The reaction catalyzed by these enzymes involves the abstraction of sulfur from the amino acid L-cysteine, with concomitant formation of alanine. The presence and availability of a sulfur acceptor modulate the sulfurtransferase activity of this class of enzymes by altering their reaction profile and catalytic turnover rate. Herein, we describe two methods used to probe the reaction profile of cysteine desulfurases through quantification of alanine and sulfide production in these reactions.

The Multifaceted Bacterial Cysteine Desulfurases: From Metabolism to Pathogenesis

Living cells have developed a relay system to efficiently transfer sulfur (S) from cysteine to various thio-cofactors (iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters, thiamine, molybdopterin, lipoic acid, and biotin) and thiolated tRNA. The presence of such a transit route involves multiple protein components that allow the flux of S to be precisely regulated as a function of environmental cues to avoid the unnecessary accumulation of toxic concentrations of soluble sulfide (S2-). The first enzyme in this relay system is cysteine desulfurase (CSD). CSD catalyzes the release of sulfane S from L-cysteine by converting it to L-alanine by forming an enzyme-linked persulfide intermediate on its conserved cysteine residue. The persulfide S is then transferred to diverse acceptor proteins for its incorporation into the thio-cofactors. The thio-cofactor binding-proteins participate in essential and diverse cellular processes, including DNA repair, respiration, intermediary metabolism, gene regulation, and redox sensing. Additionally, CSD modulates pathogenesis, antibiotic susceptibility, metabolism, and survival of several pathogenic microbes within their hosts. In this review, we aim to comprehensively illustrate the impact of CSD on bacterial core metabolic processes and its requirement to combat redox stresses and antibiotics. Targeting CSD in human pathogens can be a potential therapy for better treatment outcomes.

The sulfur formation system mediating extracellular cysteine-cystine recycling in Fervidobacterium islandicum AW-1 is associated with keratin degradation

Most extremophilic anaerobes possess a sulfur formation (Suf) system for Fe-S cluster biogenesis. In addition to its essential role in redox chemistry and stress responses of Fe-S cluster proteins, the Suf system may play an important role in keratin degradation by Fervidobacterium islandicum AW-1. Comparative genomics of the order Thermotogales revealed that the feather-degrading F. islandicum AW-1 has a complete Suf-like machinery (SufCBDSU) that is highly expressed in cells grown on native feathers in the absence of elemental sulfur (S0 ). On the other hand, F. islandicum AW-1 exhibited a significant retardation in the Suf system-mediated keratin degradation in the presence of S0 . Detailed differential expression analysis of sulfur assimilation machineries unveiled the mechanism by which an efficient sulfur delivery from persulfurated SufS to SufU is achieved during keratinolysis under sulfur starvation. Indeed, addition of SufS-SufU to cell extracts containing keratinolytic proteases accelerated keratin decomposition in vitro under reducing conditions. Remarkably, mass spectrometric analysis of extracellular and intracellular levels of amino acids suggested that redox homeostasis within cells coupled to extracellular cysteine and cystine recycling might be a prerequisite for keratinolysis. Taken together, these results suggest that the Suf-like machinery including the SufS-SufU complex may contribute to sulfur availability for an extracellular reducing environment as well as intracellular redox homeostasis through cysteine released from keratin hydrolysate under starvation conditions.

Enzymatic and Chemical In Vitro Reconstitution of Iron-Sulfur Cluster Proteins

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are key cofactors for proteins involved in essential cellular processes such as DNA replication and repair, ribosome biogenesis, tRNA thio-modification, and co-enzyme synthesis. Fe-S clusters can assemble spontaneously from inorganic compounds, but their biogenesis requires dedicated machineries to circumvent the toxic nature of iron and sulfur. To address how these machines work, different laboratories have applied various biochemical and biophysical approaches, both in vivo and in vitro. Fe-S cluster enzymatic and chemical formation in vitro is the most efficient way to follow Fe-S cluster biogenesis in a controlled environment and investigate each component of the machinery at the molecular level. In this review, we detail and discuss an efficient protocol for an in vitro Fe-S cluster enzymatic and chemical formation, which we successfully developed to study Fe-S cluster formation. We underline the applications of this approach to the study of an essential biological system.

Mechanism of Iron–Sulfur Cluster Assembly: In the Intimacy of Iron and Sulfur Encounter

Iron–sulfur (Fe–S) clusters are protein cofactors of a multitude of enzymes performing essential biological functions. Specialized multi-protein machineries present in all types of organisms support their biosynthesis. These machineries encompass a scaffold protein on which Fe–S clusters are assembled and a cysteine desulfurase that provides sulfur in the form of a persulfide. The sulfide ions are produced by reductive cleavage of the persulfide, which involves specific reductase systems. Several other components are required for Fe–S biosynthesis, including frataxin, a key protein of controversial function and accessory components for insertion of Fe–S clusters in client proteins. Fe–S cluster biosynthesis is thought to rely on concerted and carefully orchestrated processes. However, the elucidation of the mechanisms of their assembly has remained a challenging task due to the biochemical versatility of iron and sulfur and the relative instability of Fe–S clusters. Nonetheless, significant progresses have been achieved in the past years, using biochemical, spectroscopic and structural approaches with reconstituted system in vitro. In this paper, we review the most recent advances on the mechanism of assembly for the founding member of the Fe–S cluster family, the [2Fe2S] cluster that is the building block of all other Fe–S clusters. The aim is to provide a survey of the mechanisms of iron and sulfur insertion in the scaffold proteins by examining how these processes are coordinated, how sulfide is produced and how the dinuclear [2Fe2S] cluster is formed, keeping in mind the question of the physiological relevance of the reconstituted systems. We also cover the latest outcomes on the functional role of the controversial frataxin protein in Fe–S cluster biosynthesis.

Fe-S cluster biogenesis by the bacterial Suf pathway

Biogenesis of iron-sulfur (FeS) clusters in an essential process in living organisms due to the critical role of FeS cluster proteins in myriad cell functions. During biogenesis of FeS clusters, multi-protein complexes are used to drive the mobilization and protection of reactive sulfur and iron intermediates, regulate assembly of various FeS clusters on an ATPase-dependent, multi-protein scaffold, and target nascent clusters to their downstream protein targets. The evolutionarily ancient sulfur formation (Suf) pathway for FeS cluster assembly is found in bacteria and archaea. In Escherichia coli, the Suf pathway functions as an emergency pathway under conditions of iron limitation or oxidative stress. In other pathogenic bacteria, such as Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Enterococcus faecalis, the Suf pathway is the sole source for FeS clusters and therefore is a potential target for the development of novel antibacterial compounds. Here we summarize the considerable progress that has been made in characterizing the first step of mobilization and protection of reactive sulfur carried out by the SufS-SufE or SufS-SufU complex, FeS cluster assembly on SufBC₂D scaffold complexes, and the downstream trafficking of nascent FeS clusters to A-type carrier (ATC) proteins. Cell Biology of Metals III edited by Roland Lill and Mick Petris.

The Requirement of Inorganic Fe-S Clusters for the Biosynthesis of the Organometallic Molybdenum Cofactor

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are essential protein cofactors. In enzymes, they are present either in the rhombic [2Fe-2S] or the cubic [4Fe-4S] form, where they are involved in catalysis and electron transfer and in the biosynthesis of metal-containing prosthetic groups like the molybdenum cofactor (Moco). Here, we give an overview of the assembly of Fe-S clusters in bacteria and humans and present their connection to the Moco biosynthesis pathway. In all organisms, Fe-S cluster assembly starts with the abstraction of sulfur from l-cysteine and its transfer to a scaffold protein. After formation, Fe-S clusters are transferred to carrier proteins that insert them into recipient apo-proteins. In eukaryotes like humans and plants, Fe-S cluster assembly takes place both in mitochondria and in the cytosol. Both Moco biosynthesis and Fe-S cluster assembly are highly conserved among all kingdoms of life. Moco is a tricyclic pterin compound with molybdenum coordinated through its unique dithiolene group. Moco biosynthesis begins in the mitochondria in a Fe-S cluster dependent step involving radical/S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) chemistry. An intermediate is transferred to the cytosol where the dithiolene group is formed, to which molybdenum is finally added. Further connections between Fe-S cluster assembly and Moco biosynthesis are discussed in detail.

Direct observation of intermediates in the SufS cysteine desulfurase reaction reveals functional roles of conserved active-site residues

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are necessary for the proper functioning of numerous metalloproteins. Fe-S cluster (Isc) and sulfur utilization factor (Suf) pathways are the key biosynthetic routes responsible for generating these Fe-S cluster prosthetic groups in Escherichia coli Although Isc dominates under normal conditions, Suf takes over during periods of iron depletion and oxidative stress. Sulfur acquisition via these systems relies on the ability to remove sulfur from free cysteine using a cysteine desulfurase mechanism. In the Suf pathway, the dimeric SufS protein uses the cofactor pyridoxal 5'-phosphate (PLP) to abstract sulfur from free cysteine, resulting in the production of alanine and persulfide. Despite much progress, the stepwise mechanism by which this PLP-dependent enzyme operates remains unclear. Here, using rapid-mixing kinetics in conjunction with X-ray crystallography, we analyzed the pre-steady-state kinetics of this process while assigning early intermediates of the mechanism. We employed H123A and C364A SufS variants to trap Cys-aldimine and Cys-ketimine intermediates of the cysteine desulfurase reaction, enabling direct observations of these intermediates and associated conformational changes of the SufS active site. Of note, we propose that Cys-364 is essential for positioning the Cys-aldimine for Cα deprotonation, His-123 acts to protonate the Ala-enamine intermediate, and Arg-56 facilitates catalysis by hydrogen bonding with the sulfhydryl of Cys-aldimine. Our results, along with previous SufS structural findings, suggest a detailed model of the SufS-catalyzed reaction from Cys binding to C-S bond cleavage and indicate that Arg-56, His-123, and Cys-364 are critical SufS residues in this C-S bond cleavage pathway.

The Thioredoxin System Reduces Protein Persulfide Intermediates Formed during the Synthesis of Thio-Cofactors in Bacillus subtilis

The biosynthesis of Fe-S clusters and other thio-cofactors requires the participation of redox agents. A shared feature in these pathways is the formation of transient protein persulfides, which are susceptible to reduction by artificial reducing agents commonly used in reactions in vitro. These agents modulate the reactivity and catalytic efficiency of biosynthetic reactions and, in some cases, skew the enzymes' kinetic behavior, bypassing sulfur acceptors known to be critical for the functionality of these pathways in vivo. Here, we provide kinetic evidence for the selective reactivity of the Bacillus subtilis Trx (thioredoxin) system toward protein-bound persulfide intermediates. Our results demonstrate that the redox flux of the Trx system modulates the rate of sulfide production in cysteine desulfurase assays. Likewise, the activity of the Trx system is dependent on the rate of persulfide formation, suggesting the occurrence of coupled reaction schemes between both enzymatic systems in vitro. Inactivation of TrxA (thioredoxin) or TrxR (thioredoxin reductase) impairs the activity of Fe-S enzymes in B. subtilis, indicating the involvement of the Trx system in Fe-S cluster metabolism. Surprisingly, biochemical characterization of TrxA reveals that this enzyme is able to coordinate Fe-S species, resulting in the loss of its reductase activity. The inactivation of TrxA through the coordination of a labile cluster, combined with its proposed role as a physiological reducing agent in sulfur transfer pathways, suggests a model for redox regulation. These findings provide a potential link between redox regulation and Fe-S metabolism.

Structural Evidence for Dimer-Interface-Driven Regulation of the Type II Cysteine Desulfurase, SufS

SufS is a type II cysteine desulfurase and acts as the initial step in the Suf Fe-S cluster assembly pathway. In Escherichia coli, this pathway is utilized under conditions of oxidative stress and is resistant to reactive oxygen species. Mechanistically, this means SufS must shift between protecting a covalent persulfide intermediate and making it available for transfer to the next protein partner in the pathway, SufE. Here, we report five X-ray crystal structures of SufS including a new structure of SufS containing an inward-facing persulfide intermediate on C364. Additional structures of SufS variants with substitutions at the dimer interface show changes in dimer geometry and suggest a conserved β-hairpin structure plays a role in mediating interactions with SufE. These new structures, along with previous HDX-MS and biochemical data, identify an interaction network capable of communication between active-sites of the SufS dimer coordinating the shift between desulfurase and transpersulfurase activities.

B. subtilis as a Model for Studying the Assembly of Fe-S Clusters in Gram-Positive Bacteria

Complexes of iron and sulfur (Fe-S clusters) are widely distributed in nature and participate in essential biochemical reactions. The biological formation of Fe-S clusters involves dedicated pathways responsible for the mobilization of sulfur, the assembly of Fe-S clusters, and the transfer of these clusters to target proteins. Genomic analysis of Bacillus subtilis and other Gram-positive bacteria indicated the presence of only one Fe-S cluster biosynthesis pathway, which is distinct in number of components and organization from previously studied systems. B. subtilis has been used as a model system for the characterization of cysteine desulfurases responsible for sulfur mobilization reactions in the biogenesis of Fe-S clusters and other sulfur-containing cofactors. Cysteine desulfurases catalyze the cleavage of the C-S bond from the amino acid cysteine and subsequent transfer of sulfur to acceptor molecules. These reactions can be monitored by the rate of alanine formation, the first product in the reaction, and sulfide formation, a byproduct of reactions performed under reducing conditions. The assembly of Fe-S clusters on protein scaffolds and the transfer of these clusters to target acceptors are determined through a combination of spectroscopic methods probing the rate of cluster assembly and transfer. This chapter provides a description of reactions promoting the assembly of Fe-S clusters in bacteria as well as methods used to study functions of each biosynthetic component and identify mechanistic differences employed by these enzymes across different pathways.

Changes in Protein Dynamics in Escherichia coli SufS Reveal a Possible Conserved Regulatory Mechanism in Type II Cysteine Desulfurase Systems

In the Suf Fe-S cluster assembly pathway, the activity of the cysteine desulfurase, SufS, is regulated by interactions with the accessory sulfotransferase protein, SufE. SufE has been shown to stimulate SufS activity, likely by inducing conformational changes in the SufS active site that promote the desulfurase step and by acting as an efficient persulfide acceptor in the transpersulfuration step. Previous results point toward an additional level of regulation through a "half-sites" mechanism that affects the stoichiometry and affinity for SufE as the dimeric SufS shifts between desulfurase and transpersulfuration activities. Investigation of the covalent persulfide intermediate of SufS by backbone amide hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry identified two active site peptides (residues 225-236 and 356-366) and two peptides at the dimer interface of SufS (residues 88-100 and 243-255) that exhibit changes in deuterium uptake upon formation of the intermediate. Residues in these peptides are organized to form a conduit between the two active sites upon persulfide formation and include key cross-monomer interactions, suggesting they may play a role in the half-sites regulation. Three evolutionarily conserved residues at the dimer interface (R92, E96, and E250) were investigated by alanine scanning mutagenesis. Two of the substituted enzymes (E96A and E250A SufS) resulted in 6-fold increases in the value of K_SufE, confirming a functional role. Re-examination of the dimer interface in reported crystal structures of SufS and the SufS homologue CsdA identified previously unnoticed residue mobility at the dimer interface. The identification of conformational changes at the dimer interface by hydrogen-deuterium exchange confirmed by mutagenesis and structural reports provides a physical mechanism for active site communication in the half-sites regulation of SufS activity. Given the conservation of the interface interactions, this mechanism may be broadly applicable to type II cysteine desulfurase systems.

Iron-sulfur clusters biogenesis by the SUF machinery: close to the molecular mechanism understanding

Iron–sulfur clusters (Fe–S) are amongst the most ancient and versatile inorganic cofactors in nature which are used by proteins for fundamental biological processes. Multiprotein machineries (NIF, ISC, SUF) exist for Fe–S cluster biogenesis which are mainly conserved from bacteria to human. SUF system (sufABCDSE operon) plays a general role in many bacteria under conditions of iron limitation or oxidative stress. In this mini-review, we will summarize the current understanding of the molecular mechanism of Fe–S biogenesis by SUF. The advances in our understanding of the molecular aspects of SUF originate from biochemical, biophysical and recent structural studies. Combined with recent in vivo experiments, the understanding of the Fe–S biogenesis mechanism considerably moved forward.

Biogenesis and functions of mammalian iron-sulfur proteins in the regulation of iron homeostasis and pivotal metabolic pathways

Fe-S cofactors are composed of iron and inorganic sulfur in various stoichiometries. A complex assembly pathway conducts their initial synthesis and subsequent binding to recipient proteins. In this minireview, we discuss how discovery of the role of the mammalian cytosolic aconitase, known as iron regulatory protein 1 (IRP1), led to the characterization of the function of its Fe-S cluster in sensing and regulating cellular iron homeostasis. Moreover, we present an overview of recent studies that have provided insights into the mechanism of Fe-S cluster transfer to recipient Fe-S proteins.

Uncovering Large-Scale Conformational Change in Molecular Dynamics without Prior Knowledge

As the length of molecular dynamics (MD) trajectories grows with increasing computational power, so does the importance of clustering methods for partitioning trajectories into conformational bins. Of the methods available, the vast majority require users to either have some a priori knowledge about the system to be clustered or to tune clustering parameters through trial and error. Here we present non-parametric uses of two modern clustering techniques suitable for first-pass investigation of an MD trajectory. Being non-parametric, these methods require neither prior knowledge nor parameter tuning. The first method, HDBSCAN, is fast-relative to other popular clustering methods-and is able to group unstructured or intrinsically disordered systems (such as intrinsically disordered proteins, or IDPs) into bins that represent global conformational shifts. HDBSCAN is also useful for determining the overall stability of a system-as it tends to group stable systems into one or two bins-and identifying transition events between metastable states. The second method, iMWK-Means, with explicit rescaling followed by K-Means, while slower than HDBSCAN, performs well with stable, structured systems such as folded proteins and is able to identify higher resolution details such as changes in relative position of secondary structural elements. Used in conjunction, these clustering methods allow a user to discern quickly and without prior knowledge the stability of a simulated system and identify both local and global conformational changes.

Visualizing ensembles in structural biology

Displaying a single representative conformation of a biopolymer rather than an ensemble of states mistakenly conveys a static nature rather than the actual dynamic personality of biopolymers. However, there are few apparent options due to the fixed nature of print media. Here we suggest a standardized methodology for visually indicating the distribution width, standard deviation and uncertainty of ensembles of states with little loss of the visual simplicity of displaying a single representative conformation. Of particular note is that the visualization method employed clearly distinguishes between isotropic and anisotropic motion of polymer subunits. We also apply this method to ligand binding, suggesting a way to indicate the expected error in many high throughput docking programs when visualizing the structural spread of the output. We provide several examples in the context of nucleic acids and proteins with particular insights gained via this method. Such examples include investigating a therapeutic polymer of FdUMP (5-fluoro-2-deoxyuridine-5-O-monophosphate) - a topoisomerase-1 (Top1), apoptosis-inducing poison - and nucleotide-binding proteins responsible for ATP hydrolysis from Bacillus subtilis. We also discuss how these methods can be extended to any macromolecular data set with an underlying distribution, including experimental data such as NMR structures.

SufE D74R Substitution Alters Active Site Loop Dynamics To Further Enhance SufE Interaction with the SufS Cysteine Desulfurase

Many essential metalloproteins require iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster cofactors for their function. In vivo persulfide formation from l-cysteine is a key step in the biogenesis of Fe-S clusters in most organisms. In Escherichia coli, the SufS cysteine desulfurase mobilizes persulfide from l-cysteine via a PLP-dependent ping-pong reaction. SufS requires the SufE partner protein to transfer the persulfide to the SufB Fe-S cluster scaffold. Without SufE, the SufS enzyme fails to efficiently turn over and remains locked in the persulfide-bound state. Coordinated protein-protein interactions mediate sulfur transfer from SufS to SufE. Multiple studies have suggested that SufE must undergo a conformational change to extend its active site Cys loop during sulfur transfer from SufS. To test this putative model, we mutated SufE Asp74 to Arg (D74R) to increase the dynamics of the SufE Cys51 loop. Amide hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) analysis of SufE D74R revealed an increase in solvent accessibility and dynamics in the loop containing the active site Cys51 used to accept persulfide from SufS. Our results indicate that the mutant protein has a stronger binding affinity for SufS than that of wild-type SufE. In addition, SufE D74R can still enhance SufS desulfurase activity and did not show saturation at higher SufE D74R concentrations, unlike wild-type SufE. These results show that dynamic changes may shift SufE to a sulfur-acceptor state that interacts more strongly with SufS.

Abbreviated Pathway for Biosynthesis of 2-Thiouridine in Bacillus subtilis

The 2-thiouridine (s(2)U) modification of the wobble position in glutamate, glutamine, and lysine tRNA molecules serves to stabilize the anticodon structure, improving ribosomal binding and overall efficiency of the translational process. Biosynthesis of s(2)U in Escherichia coli requires a cysteine desulfurase (IscS), a thiouridylase (MnmA), and five intermediate sulfur-relay enzymes (TusABCDE). The E. coli MnmA adenylates and subsequently thiolates tRNA to form the s(2)U modification. Bacillus subtilis lacks IscS and the intermediate sulfur relay proteins, yet its genome contains a cysteine desulfurase gene, yrvO, directly adjacent to mnmA. The genomic synteny of yrvO and mnmA combined with the absence of the Tus proteins indicated a potential functionality of these proteins in s(2)U formation. Here, we provide evidence that the B. subtilis YrvO and MnmA are sufficient for s(2)U biosynthesis. A conditional B. subtilis knockout strain showed that s(2)U abundance correlates with MnmA expression, and in vivo complementation studies in E. coli IscS- or MnmA-deficient strains revealed the competency of these proteins in s(2)U biosynthesis. In vitro experiments demonstrated s(2)U formation by YrvO and MnmA, and kinetic analysis established a partnership between the B. subtilis proteins that is contingent upon the presence of ATP. Furthermore, we observed that the slow-growth phenotype of E. coli ΔiscS and ΔmnmA strains associated with s(2)U depletion is recovered by B. subtilis yrvO and mnmA. These results support the proposal that the involvement of a devoted cysteine desulfurase, YrvO, in s(2)U synthesis bypasses the need for a complex biosynthetic pathway by direct sulfur transfer to MnmA.

IMPORTANCE

The 2-thiouridine (s(2)U) modification of the wobble position in glutamate, glutamine, and lysine tRNA is conserved in all three domains of life and stabilizes the anticodon structure, thus guaranteeing fidelity in translation. The biosynthesis of s(2)U in Escherichia coli requires seven proteins: the cysteine desulfurase IscS, the thiouridylase MnmA, and five intermediate sulfur-relay enzymes (TusABCDE). Bacillus subtilis and most Gram-positive bacteria lack a complete set of biosynthetic components. Interestingly, the mnmA coding sequence is located adjacent to yrvO, encoding a cysteine desulfurase. In this work, we provide evidence that the B. subtilis YrvO is able to transfer sulfur directly to MnmA. Both proteins are sufficient for s(2)U biosynthesis in a pathway independent of the one used in E. coli.

Recent advances in the Suf Fe-S cluster biogenesis pathway: Beyond the Proteobacteria

Fe-S clusters play critical roles in cellular function throughout all three kingdoms of life. Consequently, Fe-S cluster biogenesis systems are present in most organisms. The Suf (sulfur formation) system is the most ancient of the three characterized Fe-S cluster biogenesis pathways, which also include the Isc and Nif systems. Much of the first work on the Suf system took place in Gram-negative Proteobacteria used as model organisms. These early studies led to a wealth of biochemical, genetic, and physiological information on Suf function. From those studies we have learned that SufB functions as an Fe-S scaffold in conjunction with SufC (and in some cases SufD). SufS and SufE together mobilize sulfur for cluster assembly and SufA traffics the complete Fe-S cluster from SufB to target apo-proteins. However, recent progress on the Suf system in other organisms has opened up new avenues of research and new hypotheses about Suf function. This review focuses primarily on the most recent discoveries about the Suf pathway and where those new models may lead the field. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Fe/S proteins: Analysis, structure, function, biogenesis and diseases.

Shared-intermediates in the biosynthesis of thio-cofactors: Mechanism and functions of cysteine desulfurases and sulfur acceptors

Cysteine desulfurases utilize a PLP-dependent mechanism to catalyze the first step of sulfur mobilization in the biosynthesis of sulfur-containing cofactors. Sulfur activation and integration into thiocofactors involve complex mechanisms and intricate biosynthetic schemes. Cysteine desulfurases catalyze sulfur-transfer reactions from l-cysteine to sulfur acceptor molecules participating in the biosynthesis of thio-cofactors, including Fe-S clusters, thionucleosides, thiamin, biotin, and molybdenum cofactor. The proposed mechanism of cysteine desulfurases involves the PLP-dependent cleavage of the C-S bond from l-cysteine via the formation of a persulfide enzyme intermediate, which is considered the hallmark step in sulfur mobilization. The subsequent sulfur transfer reaction varies with the class of cysteine desulfurase and sulfur acceptor. IscS serves as a mecca for sulfur incorporation into a network of intertwined pathways for the biosynthesis of thio-cofactors. The involvement of a single enzyme interacting with multiple acceptors, the recruitment of shared-intermediates partaking roles in multiple pathways, and the participation of Fe-S enzymes denote the interconnectivity of pathways involving sulfur trafficking. In Bacillus subtilis, the occurrence of multiple cysteine desulfurases partnering with dedicated sulfur acceptors partially deconvolutes the routes of sulfur trafficking and assigns specific roles for these enzymes. Understanding the roles of promiscuous vs. dedicated cysteine desulfurases and their partnership with shared-intermediates in the biosynthesis of thio-cofactors will help to map sulfur transfer events across interconnected pathways and to provide insight into the hierarchy of sulfur incorporation into biomolecules. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Fe/S proteins: Analysis, structure, function, biogenesis and diseases.

Iron-sulfur cluster biogenesis in mammalian cells: New insights into the molecular mechanisms of cluster delivery

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are ancient, ubiquitous cofactors composed of iron and inorganic sulfur. The combination of the chemical reactivity of iron and sulfur, together with many variations of cluster composition, oxidation states and protein environments, enables Fe-S clusters to participate in numerous biological processes. Fe-S clusters are essential to redox catalysis in nitrogen fixation, mitochondrial respiration and photosynthesis, to regulatory sensing in key metabolic pathways (i.e. cellular iron homeostasis and oxidative stress response), and to the replication and maintenance of the nuclear genome. Fe-S cluster biogenesis is a multistep process that involves a complex sequence of catalyzed protein-protein interactions and coupled conformational changes between the components of several dedicated multimeric complexes. Intensive studies of the assembly process have clarified key points in the biogenesis of Fe-S proteins. However several critical questions still remain, such as: what is the role of frataxin? Why do some defects of Fe-S cluster biogenesis cause mitochondrial iron overload? How are specific Fe-S recipient proteins recognized in the process of Fe-S transfer? This review focuses on the basic steps of Fe-S cluster biogenesis, drawing attention to recent advances achieved on the identification of molecular features that guide selection of specific subsets of nascent Fe-S recipients by the cochaperone HSC20. Additionally, it outlines the distinctive phenotypes of human diseases due to mutations in the components of the basic pathway. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Fe/S proteins: Analysis, structure, function, biogenesis and diseases.

Interplay between oxygen and Fe-S cluster biogenesis: insights from the Suf pathway

Iron–sulfur (Fe–S) cluster metalloproteins conduct essential functions in nearly all contemporary forms of life. The nearly ubiquitous presence of Fe–S clusters and the fundamental requirement for Fe–S clusters in both aerobic and anaerobic Archaea, Bacteria, and Eukarya suggest that these clusters were likely integrated into central metabolic pathways early in the evolution of life prior to the widespread oxidation of Earth’s atmosphere. Intriguingly, Fe–S cluster-dependent metabolism is sensitive to disruption by oxygen because of the decreased bioavailability of ferric iron as well as direct oxidation of sulfur trafficking intermediates and Fe–S clusters by reactive oxygen species. This fact, coupled with the ubiquity of Fe–S clusters in aerobic organisms, suggests that organisms evolved with mechanisms that facilitate the biogenesis and use of these essential cofactors in the presence of oxygen, which gradually began to accumulate around 2.5 billion years ago as oxygenic photosynthesis proliferated and reduced minerals that buffered against oxidation were depleted. This review highlights the most ancient of the Fe–S cluster biogenesis pathways, the Suf system, which likely was present in early anaerobic forms of life. Herein, we use the evolution of the Suf pathway to assess the relationships between the biochemical functions and physiological roles of Suf proteins, with an emphasis on the selective pressure of oxygen toxicity. Our analysis suggests that diversification into oxygen-containing environments disrupted iron and sulfur metabolism and was a main driving force in the acquisition of accessory Suf proteins (such as SufD, SufE, and SufS) by the core SufB–SufC scaffold complex. This analysis provides a new framework for the study of Fe–S cluster biogenesis pathways and Fe–S cluster-containing metalloenzymes and their complicated patterns of divergence in response to oxygen.

Fe-S cluster biogenesis in Gram-positive bacteria: SufU is a zinc-dependent sulfur transfer protein

The biosynthesis of Fe-S clusters in Bacillus subtilis and other Gram-positive bacteria is catalyzed by the SufCDSUB system. The first step in this pathway involves the sulfur mobilization from the free amino acid cysteine to a sulfur acceptor protein SufU via a PLP-dependent cysteine desulfurase SufS. In this reaction scheme, the formation of an enzyme S-covalent intermediate is followed by the binding of SufU. This event leads to the second half of the reaction where a deprotonated thiol of SufU promotes the nucleophilic attack onto the persulfide intermediate of SufS. Kinetic analysis combined with spectroscopic methods identified that the presence of a zinc atom tightly bound to SufU (Ka = 10(17) M(-1)) is crucial for its structural and catalytic competency. Fe-S cluster assembly experiments showed that despite the high degree of sequence and structural similarity to the ortholog enzyme IscU, the B. subtilis SufU does not act as a standard Fe-S cluster scaffold protein. The involvement of SufU as a dedicated agent of sulfur transfer, rather than as an assembly scaffold, in the biogenesis of Fe-S clusters in Gram-positive microbes indicates distinct strategies used by bacterial systems to assemble Fe-S clusters.

Escherichia coli SufE sulfur transfer protein modulates the SufS cysteine desulfurase through allosteric conformational dynamics

Fe-S clusters are critical metallocofactors required for cell function. Fe-S cluster biogenesis is carried out by assembly machinery consisting of multiple proteins. Fe-S cluster biogenesis proteins work together to mobilize sulfide and iron, form the nascent cluster, traffic the cluster to target metalloproteins, and regulate the assembly machinery in response to cellular Fe-S cluster demand. A complex series of protein-protein interactions is required for the assembly machinery to function properly. Despite considerable progress in obtaining static three-dimensional structures of the assembly proteins, little is known about transient protein-protein interactions during cluster assembly or the role of protein dynamics in the cluster assembly process. The Escherichia coli cysteine desulfurase SufS (EC 2.8.1.7) and its accessory protein SufE work together to mobilize persulfide from L-cysteine, which is then donated to the SufB Fe-S cluster scaffold. Here we use amide hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) to characterize SufS-SufE interactions and protein dynamics in solution. HDX-MS analysis shows that SufE binds near the SufS active site to accept persulfide from Cys-364. Furthermore, SufE binding initiates allosteric changes in other parts of the SufS structure that likely affect SufS catalysis and alter SufS monomer-monomer interactions. SufE enhances the initial l-cysteine substrate binding to SufS and formation of the external aldimine with pyridoxal phosphate required for early steps in SufS catalysis. Together, these results provide a new picture of the SufS-SufE sulfur transferase pathway and suggest a more active role for SufE in promoting the SufS cysteine desulfurase reaction for Fe-S cluster assembly.