An artificial beta-sheet that dimerizes through parallel beta-sheet interactions

Reduced IgG1 Antibody Left-Twisted Antiparallel β-Sheet Structure Stability Occurs under Metal-Catalyzed Oxidation Conditions in the Presence of Polysorbates

Polysorbates are common surfactants in monoclonal antibody (mAb) drug products. While polysorbates assist in stabilizing and refolding proteins, oxidative stress conditions can reduce protein stability wherein polysorbate binds to the oxidized and unfolded protein. We investigated the effects of polysorbates on the higher-order structural stability of mAbs under oxidative conditions that may occur during manufacturing, storage, and use. Secondary and tertiary structures of trastuzumab and rituximab products were investigated under two oxidative conditions: metal-catalyzed oxidation (MCO; CuSO4 and ascorbic acid) and 2,2'-azobis (2-aminidinopropane) dihydrochloride (AAPH) using either polysorbate-containing formulations or after polysorbate depletion. Higher-order structures were predicted from the collected circular dichroism spectra with an algorithm optimized for β-sheet structural predictions. Secondary structure analyses using circular dichroism at increasing temperatures demonstrated that MCO and AAPH triggered differing β-sheet structure degradation patterns. Rituximab products were more sensitive to MCO compared with trastuzumab products as shown by left-twisted antiparallel β-sheet structure loss and increase in unstructured elements at lower temperatures. AAPH-exposed drugs tended to have distinct unfolding states compared with the MCO-treated drugs as shown by the increase in parallel β-sheet structures for AAPH and decreased parallel β-sheet structures with MCO. Polysorbate depletion transiently improved the stability of MCO-treated material as shown by delayed circular dichroism (CD) signal degradation at 202 nm and improved peak area of the antibody monomer by nonreducing capillary electrophoresis sodium dodecyl sulfate (nrCE-SDS) and peak intensity of intact antibody in matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight (MALDI-TOF) analysis. The improved stability of detergent-depleted material is traced to improved stability in the predicted left-twisted β-sheet structural elements. Our data further highlights the need for formulation studies that consider the impact of polysorbate binding and/or degradation for specific drug products under stress conditions such as metal-catalyzed oxidation.

Somatostatin binds to the human amyloid β peptide and favors the formation of distinct oligomers

The amyloid β peptide (Aβ) is a key player in the etiology of Alzheimer disease (AD), yet a systematic investigation of its molecular interactions has not been reported. Here we identified by quantitative mass spectrometry proteins in human brain extract that bind to oligomeric Aβ1-42 (oAβ1-42) and/or monomeric Aβ1-42 (mAβ1-42) baits. Remarkably, the cyclic neuroendocrine peptide somatostatin-14 (SST14) was observed to be the most selectively enriched oAβ1-42 binder. The binding interface comprises a central tryptophan within SST14 and the N-terminus of Aβ1-42. The presence of SST14 inhibited Aβ aggregation and masked the ability of several antibodies to detect Aβ. Notably, Aβ1-42, but not Aβ1-40, formed in the presence of SST14 oligomeric assemblies of 50 to 60 kDa that were visualized by gel electrophoresis, nanoparticle tracking analysis and electron microscopy. These findings may be relevant for Aβ-directed diagnostics and may signify a role of SST14 in the etiology of AD.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.28401.001

Treating Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias is one of the major challenges currently facing healthcare providers worldwide. A hallmark of the disease is the formation of large deposits of a specific molecule, known as amyloid beta (Aβ), in the brain. However, more and more research suggests that smaller and particularly toxic amyloid beta clumps – often referred to as oligomeric Aβ – appear as an early sign of Alzheimer’s disease.

To understand how the formation of these smaller amyloid beta clumps triggers other aspects of the disease, it is important to identify molecules in the human brain that oligomeric Aβ binds to. To this end, Wang et al. attached amyloid beta or oligomeric Aβ molecules to microscopically small beads. The beads were then exposed to human brain extracts in a test tube, which allowed molecules in the extracts to bind to the amyloid beta or oligomeric Aβ. The samples were then spun at high speed, meaning that the beads and any other molecules bound to them sunk and formed pellets at the bottom of the tubes. Each pellet was then analyzed to see which molecules it contained.

The experiments identified more than a hundred human brain proteins that can bind to amyloid beta. One of them, known as somatostatin, selectively binds to oligomeric Aβ. Wang et al. were able to determine the structural features of somatostatin that control this binding.

Finally, in further experiments performed in test tubes, Wang et al. noticed that smaller oligomeric Aβ clumps were more likely to form than larger amyloid beta deposits when somatostatin was present. This could signify a previously unrecognized role of somatostatin in the development of Alzheimer’s disease.

Further studies are now needed to confirm whether the presence of somatostatin in the brain favors the formation of smaller, toxic oligomeric Aβ clumps over large innocuous amyloid beta deposits. If so, new treatments could be developed that aim to reduce oligomeric Aβ levels in the brain by preventing somatostatin from interacting with amyloid beta molecules. Wang et al. also suggest that somatostatin could be used in diagnostic tests to detect abnormal levels of oligomeric Aβ in the brain or body fluids of people who have Alzheimer’s disease.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.28401.002

The supramolecular chemistry of β-sheets

Interactions among β-sheets occur widely in protein quaternary structure, protein-protein interaction, and protein aggregation and are central in Alzheimer's and other amyloid-related diseases. This Perspective looks at the structural biology of these important yet under-appreciated interactions from a supramolecular chemist's point of view. Common themes in the supramolecular interactions of β-sheets are identified and richly illustrated though examples from proteins, amyloids, and chemical model systems. β-Sheets interact through edge-to-edge hydrogen bonding to form extended layers and through face-to-face hydrophobic or van der Waals interactions to form layered sandwich-like structures. Side chains from adjacent layers can fit together through simple hydrophobic contacts or can participate in complementary interdigitation or knob-hole interactions. The layers can be aligned, offset, or rotated. The right-handed twist of β-sheets provides additional opportunities for stabilization of edge-to-edge contacts and rotated layered structures.

Molecular duplexes with encoded sequences and stabilities

Through specific molecular shapes and repeating polymeric sequences, biomacromolecules encode information about both structure and function. Inspired by DNA molecules, we have conceived a strategy to encode linear molecular strands with sequences that specify intermolecular association, and we and our collaborators have supported this idea through our experimental work. This Account summarizes the design and development of a class of molecular duplexes with programmable hydrogen-bonding sequences and adjustable stabilities. The specific system involves oligoamide strands synthesized from readily available monomeric modules based on standard amide (peptide) chemistry. By covalently linking three types of basic building blocks in different orders, we create oligoamide strands with various arrangements of amide O and H atoms that provide arrays of hydrogen bonding sequences. Because one of the two edges of these molecules presents the sequences of hydrogen-bond donors and acceptors, these oligoamide strands associate via their hydrogen-bonding edges into double-stranded pairs or duplexes. Systematic studies have demonstrated the strict sequence specificity and tunable stability of this system. These structurally simple duplexes exhibit many features associated with DNA sequences such as programmable sequence specificity, shape and hydrogen-bonding complementarity, and cooperativity of multipoint interactions. Capable of specifying intermolecular associations, these duplexes have formed supramolecular structures such as β-sheets and non-covalent block copolymers and have templated chemical reactions. The incorporation of dynamic covalent interactions into these H-bonded duplexes has created association units that undergo sequence-specific association and covalent ligation in both nonpolar solvents and polar media including water. These new association units may facilitate the development of new dynamic covalent structures, and new properties are emerging from these structures. For example, we discovered hydrogen-bonded duplexes that could gelate different organic solvents, and we could tune the gelatinization by adjusting the multiple side chains attached to the duplexes. In addition, we have recently designed duplexes whose formation and dissociation are controlled by changes in external stimuli such as acidity. With their programmable specificity and tunable stability, these molecular duplexes have provided a systematic approach for the association of different structural units. Further development of this system could facilitate the creation of many supramolecular and dynamic covalent structures. Because these duplexes are easily modifiable and information is easily encoded and retrieved, this system may address some of the remaining challenges facing information-storing molecules including self-replication.

Characteristics of amyloid-related oligomers revealed by crystal structures of macrocyclic β-sheet mimics

Protein amyloid oligomers have been strongly linked to amyloid diseases and can be intermediates to amyloid fibers. β-Sheets have been identified in amyloid oligomers. However, because of their transient and highly polymorphic properties, the details of their self-association remain elusive. Here we explore oligomer structure using a model system: macrocyclic peptides. Key amyloidogenic sequences from Aβ and tau were incorporated into macrocycles, thereby restraining them to β-strands, but limiting the growth of the oligomers so they may crystallize and cannot fibrillate. We determined the atomic structures for four such oligomers, and all four reveal tetrameric interfaces in which β-sheet dimers pair together by highly complementary, dry interfaces, analogous to steric zippers found in fibers, suggesting a common structure for amyloid oligomers and fibers. In amyloid fibers, the axes of the paired sheets are either parallel or antiparallel, whereas the oligomeric interfaces display a variety of sheet-to-sheet pairing angles, offering a structural explanation for the heterogeneity of amyloid oligomers.

Synthesis and conformational analysis of bicyclic extended dipeptide surrogates

Regio- and diastereoselective reactions of a homoproline enolate enable the synthesis of novel extended dipeptide surrogates. Bicyclic carbamate 9 and fused beta-lactam scaffold 11 were prepared from L-pyroglutamic acid via substrate-controlled electrophilic azidation. Synthesis of orthogonally protected hexahydropyrrolizine, hexahydropyrrolizinone, and hexahydropyrroloazepinone dipeptide surrogates relied on allylation of proline derivative 5, followed by Curtius rearrangement to introduce the N-terminal carbamate group. A total of six azabicycloalkane derivatives were evaluated for conformational mimicry of extended dipeptides by a combination of X-ray diffraction and molecular modeling. Analysis of putative backbone dihedral angles and N- to C-terminal dipeptide distances indicate that compounds (alpha'S)-14b and 21 approximate the conformation of dipeptides found in beta-sheets, while tripeptide mimic 28 is also highly extended in the solid state. Structural data suggest that ring size and relative stereochemistry have a profound effect on the ability of these scaffolds to act as beta-strand mimetics and should inform the design of related conformational probes.

Investigation on the individual contributions of N-H...O=C and C-H...O=C interactions to the binding energies of beta-sheet models

In this article, the binding energies of 16 antiparallel and parallel beta-sheet models are estimated using the analytic potential energy function we proposed recently and the results are compared with those obtained from MP2, AMBER99, OPLSAA/L, and CHARMM27 calculations. The comparisons indicate that the analytic potential energy function can produce reasonable binding energies for beta-sheet models. Further comparisons suggest that the binding energy of the beta-sheet models might come mainly from dipole-dipole attractive and repulsive interactions and VDW interactions between the two strands. The dipole-dipole attractive and repulsive interactions are further obtained in this article. The total of N-H...H-N and C=O...O=C dipole-dipole repulsive interaction (the secondary electrostatic repulsive interaction) in the small ring of the antiparallel beta-sheet models is estimated to be about 6.0 kcal/mol. The individual N-H...O=C dipole-dipole attractive interaction is predicted to be -6.2 +/- 0.2 kcal/mol in the antiparallel beta-sheet models and -5.2 +/- 0.6 kcal/mol in the parallel beta-sheet models. The individual C(alpha)-H...O=C attractive interaction is -1.2 +/- 0.2 kcal/mol in the antiparallel beta-sheet models and -1.5 +/- 0.2 kcal/mol in the parallel beta-sheet models. These values are important in understanding the interactions at protein-protein interfaces and developing a more accurate force field for peptides and proteins.

Synthesis and binding studies of two new macrocyclic receptors for the stereoselective recognition of dipeptides

We present here the design, synthesis, and analysis of a series of receptors for peptide ligands inspired by the hydrogen-bonding pattern of protein β-sheets. The receptors themselves can be regarded as strands 1 and 3 of a three-stranded β-sheet, with cross-linking between the chains through the 4-position of adjacent phenylalanine residues. We also report on the conformational equilibria of these receptors in solution as well as on their tendency to dimerize. ¹H NMR titration experiments are used to quantify the dimerization constants, as well as the association constant values of the 1:1 complexes formed between the receptors and a series of diamides and dipeptides. The receptors show moderate levels of selectivity in the molecular recognition of the hydrogen-bonding pattern present in the diamide series, selecting the α-amino acid-related hydrogen-bonding functionality. Only one of the two cyclic receptors shows modest signs of enantioselectivity and moderate diastereoselectivity in the recognition of the enantiomers and diastereoisomers of the Ala-Ala dipeptide (ΔΔG⁰₁ (DD-DL) = −1.08 kcal/mol and ΔΔG⁰₁ (DD-LD) = −0.89 kcal/mol). Surprisingly, the linear synthetic precursors show higher levels of stereoselectivity than their cyclic counterparts.

An analytic potential energy function for the amide-amide and amide-water intermolecular hydrogen bonds in peptides

An analytic potential energy function is proposed and applied to evaluate the amide-amide and amide-water hydrogen-bonding interaction energies in peptides. The parameters in the analytic function are derived from fitting to the potential energy curves of 10 hydrogen-bonded training dimers. The analytic potential energy function is then employed to calculate the N-H...O=C, C-H...O=C, N-H...OH2, and C=O...HOH hydrogen-bonding interaction energies in amide-amide and amide-water dimers containing N-methylacetamide, acetamide, glycine dipeptide, alanine dipeptide, N-methylformamide, N-methylpropanamide, N-ethylacetamide and/or water molecules. The potential energy curves of these systems are therefore obtained, including the equilibrium hydrogen bond distances R(O...H) and the hydrogen-bonding energies. The function is also applied to calculate the binding energies in models of beta-sheets. The calculation results show that the potential energy curves obtained from the analytic function are in good agreement with those obtained from MP2/6-31+G** calculations by including the BSSE correction, which demonstrate that the analytic function proposed in this work can be used to predict the hydrogen-bonding interaction energies in peptides quickly and accurately.

Binding mechanisms in supramolecular complexes

Supramolecular chemistry has expanded dramatically in recent years both in terms of potential applications and in its relevance to analogous biological systems. The formation and function of supramolecular complexes occur through a multiplicity of often difficult to differentiate noncovalent forces. The aim of this Review is to describe the crucial interaction mechanisms in context, and thus classify the entire subject. In most cases, organic host-guest complexes have been selected as examples, but biologically relevant problems are also considered. An understanding and quantification of intermolecular interactions is of importance both for the rational planning of new supramolecular systems, including intelligent materials, as well as for developing new biologically active agents.

Macrocyclic design strategies for small, stable parallel beta-sheet scaffolds

Pairs of short peptide strands can be induced to adopt an antiparallel beta-sheet secondary structure in aqueous solution via a macrocyclic constraint, as illustrated by many natural and designed peptides. We show that an analogous strategy is successful for creation of small units of parallel beta-sheet secondary structure in aqueous solution. Cyclization in this case requires nonpeptide segments for N-to-N and C-to-C interstrand linkage. Surprisingly, we find that only one of these segments needs to be preorganized.

A new artificial beta-sheet that dimerizes through parallel beta-sheet interactions

This paper introduces a chemical model of a beta-sheet that dimerizes through parallel beta-sheet interactions in CDCl(3) solution. The model consists of two C-terminally linked dipeptides connected to a molecular template. (1)H NMR studies establish the beta-sheet folding and dimerization of the model system. This system corroborates that linking two peptide strands and blocking one edge of the assembly creates soluble, easy-to-study systems that participate in the types of interactions that occur widely in peptide and protein aggregates.

Artificial beta-sheets: chemical models of beta-sheets

Chemical models provide tools with which to simplify and study complicated biological systems. Forces and chemical processes that govern the structure, function, and interactions of a biomacromolecule can be explored with a simple, easy-to-study synthetic molecule. Chemical models of beta-sheet structures have helped to elucidate the factors influencing protein structures and functions. Chemical models that mimic beta-sheet quaternary structure and interactions are emerging as valuable tools with which to better understand and control protein recognition and protein aggregation.

Exploring beta-sheet structure and interactions with chemical model systems

Beta-sheets consist of extended polypeptide strands (beta-strands) connected by a network of hydrogen bonds and occur widely in proteins. Although the importance of beta-sheets in the folded structures of proteins has long been recognized, there is a growing recognition of the importance of intermolecular interactions among beta-sheets. Intermolecular interactions between the hydrogen-bonding edges of beta-sheets constitute a fundamental form of biomolecular recognition (like DNA base pairing) and are involved protein quaternary structure, protein-protein interactions, and peptide and protein aggregation. The importance of beta-sheet interactions in biological processes makes them potential targets for intervention in diseases such as AIDS, cancer, and Alzheimer's disease. This Account describes my research group's use of chemical model systems to study the structure and interactions of beta-sheets. Chemical model systems provide an excellent vehicle with which to explore beta-sheets, because they are smaller, simpler, and easier to manipulate than proteins. Synthetic chemical models also provide the opportunity to control or modulate natural systems or to develop other useful applications and may eventually lead to new drugs with which to treat diseases. In our "artificial beta-sheets", molecular template and turn units are combined with peptides to mimic the structures of parallel and antiparallel beta-sheets. The templates and turn units form folded, hydrogen-bonded structures with the peptide groups and help prevent the formation of complex, ill-defined aggregates. Templates that duplicate the hydrogen-bonding pattern of one edge of a peptide beta-strand while blocking the other edge have proven particularly valuable in preventing aggregate formation and in promoting the formation of simple monomeric and dimeric structures. Artificial beta-sheets that present exposed hydrogen-bonding edges can form well-defined hydrogen-bonded dimers. Dimerization occurs readily in chloroform solutions but requires additional hydrophobic interactions to occur in aqueous solution. Interactions among the side chains, as well as hydrogen bonding among the main chains, are important in dimer formation. NMR studies of artificial beta-sheets have elucidated the importance of hydrogen-bonding complementarity, size complementarity, and chiral complementarity in these interactions. These pairing preferences demonstrate sequence selectivity in the molecular recognition between beta-sheets. These studies help illustrate the importance of intermolecular edge-to-edge interactions between beta-sheets in peptides and proteins. Ultimately, these model systems may lead to new ways of controlling beta-sheet interactions and treating diseases in which they are involved.

Diacid linkers that promote parallel beta-sheet secondary structure in water

We report the development of diacid units that promote formation of a two-stranded parallel beta-sheet secondary structure between peptide segments attached via their N-termini. These linker units are formed by attaching glycine to one carboxyl group of cis-1,2-cyclohexanedicarboxylic acid (CHDA). Parallel sheet formation in water is observed when l-residue strands are attached to the CHDA-Gly unit with either of the two absolute configurations.