Mapping the interaction between the hemophore HasA and its outer membrane receptor HasR using CRINEPT-TROSY NMR spectroscopy

2D NMR Analysis as a Sensitive Tool for Evaluating the Higher-Order Structural Integrity of Monoclonal Antibody against COVID-19

The higher-order structure (HOS) of protein therapeutics has been confirmed as a critical quality parameter. In this study, we compared 2D ¹H-¹³C ALSOFAST-HMQC NMR spectra with immunochemical ELISA-based analysis to evaluate their sensitivity in assessing the HOS of a potent human monoclonal antibody (mAb) for the treatment of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). The study confirmed that the methyl region of the 2D ¹H-¹³C NMR spectrum is sensitive to changes in the secondary and tertiary structure of the mAb, more than ELISA immunoassay. Because of its highly detailed level of characterization (i.e., many ¹H-¹³C cross-peaks are used for statistical comparability), the NMR technique also provided a more informative outcome for the product characterization of biopharmaceuticals. This NMR approach represents a powerful tool in assessing the overall higher-order structural integrity of mAb as an alternative to conventional immunoassays.

Gallium(III)-Salophen as a Dual Inhibitor of Pseudomonas aeruginosa Heme Sensing and Iron Acquisition

Pseudomonas aeruginosa is an opportunistic bacterium that causes life-threatening infections in immunocompromised patients. In infection, it uses heme as a primary iron source and senses the availability of exogenous heme through the heme assimilation system (Has), an extra cytoplasmic function σ-factor system. A secreted hemophore HasAp scavenges heme and, upon interaction with the outer-membrane receptor HasR, activates a signaling cascade, which in turn creates a positive feedback loop critical for sensing and adaptation within the host. The ability to sense and respond to heme as an iron source contributes to virulence. Consequently, the inhibition of this system will lead to a disruption in iron homeostasis, decreasing virulence. We have identified a salophen scaffold that successfully inhibits the activation of the Has signaling system while simultaneously targeting iron uptake via xenosiderophore receptors. We propose this dual mechanism wherein free Ga³⁺-salophen reduces growth through uptake and iron mimicry. A dual mechanism targeting extracellular heme signaling and uptake together with Ga³⁺-induced toxicity following active Ga³⁺salophen uptake provides a significant therapeutic advantage while reducing the propensity to develop resistance.

The molecular basis of transient heme-protein interactions: analysis, concept and implementation

Deviant levels of available heme and related molecules can result from pathological situations such as impaired heme biosynthesis or increased hemolysis as a consequence of vascular trauma or bacterial infections. Heme-related biological processes are affected by these situations, and it is essential to fully understand the underlying mechanisms. While heme has long been known as an important prosthetic group of various proteins, its function as a regulatory and signaling molecule is poorly understood. Diseases such as porphyria are caused by impaired heme metabolism, and heme itself might be used as a drug in order to downregulate its own biosynthesis. In addition, heme-driven side effects and symptoms emerging from heme-related pathological conditions are not fully comprehended and thus impede adequate medical treatment. Several heme-regulated proteins have been identified in the past decades, however, the molecular basis of transient heme-protein interactions remains to be explored. Herein, we summarize the results of an in-depth analysis of heme binding to proteins, which revealed specific binding modes and affinities depending on the amino acid sequence. Evaluating the binding behavior of a plethora of heme-peptide complexes resulted in the implementation of a prediction tool (SeqD-HBM) for heme-binding motifs, which eventually led and will perspectively lead to the identification and verification of so far unknown heme-regulated proteins. This systematic approach resulted in a broader picture of the alternative functions of heme as a regulator of proteins. However, knowledge on heme regulation of proteins is still a bottomless barrel that leaves much scope for future research and development.

About the use of 13C-13C NOESY in bioinorganic chemistry

Herein we present examples of the application of the ¹³C-¹³C Nuclear Overhauser Effect Spectroscopy (NOESY) experiment to the study of metalloproteins and we critically discuss the advantages and drawbacks of the method as a function of the molecular size of the investigated systems. The contribution is focused on a few case studies among the systems analyzed in the group of the corresponding author. The ¹³C-¹³C NOESY experiment represents the gold standard for the observation of NMR signals in the 480 kDa ferritin nanocage and for monitoring its interaction with iron. By decreasing the protein size, the experiment progressively loses its importance as a tool for the detection of the complete spin pattern of the amino acid side chains, as exemplified by nickel-dependent regulatory protein, NikR (molecular mass of the homo-tetramer ~80 kDa). In very small proteins, such as mitochondrial cytochrome c (12.3 kDa), we are only able to detect cross peaks between adjacent ¹³C nuclei; this feature turned out to be useful for the assignment of the ¹³C core resonances of the porphyrin in a uniformly enriched heme.

Extracellular Heme Uptake and the Challenge of Bacterial Cell Membranes

Iron is essential for the survival of most bacteria but presents a significant challenge given its limited bioavailability. Furthermore, the toxicity of iron combined with the need to maintain physiological iron levels within a narrow concentration range requires sophisticated systems to sense, regulate, and transport iron. Most bacteria have evolved mechanisms to chelate and transport ferric iron (Fe³⁺) via siderophore receptor systems, and pathogenic bacteria have further lowered this barrier by employing mechanisms to utilize the host's hemoproteins. Once internalized, heme is cleaved by both oxidative and nonoxidative mechanisms to release iron. Heme, itself a lipophilic and toxic molecule, presents a significant challenge for transport into the cell. As such, pathogenic bacteria have evolved sophisticated cell surface signaling and transport systems to obtain heme from the host. In this review, we summarize the structure and function of the heme-sensing and transport systems of pathogenic bacteria and the potential of these systems as antimicrobial targets.

Structural basis of the signalling through a bacterial membrane receptor HasR deciphered by an integrative approach

In bacteria, some scarce nutrients are sensed, bound and internalized by their specific transporter. In the present study, using an integrative structural approach, we study HasR, a bacterial haem transporter in both its free and its loaded forms.

Bacteria use diverse signalling pathways to adapt gene expression to external stimuli. In Gram-negative bacteria, the binding of scarce nutrients to membrane transporters triggers a signalling process that up-regulates the expression of genes of various functions, from uptake of nutrient to production of virulence factors. Although proteins involved in this process have been identified, signal transduction through this family of transporters is not well understood. In the present study, using an integrative approach (EM, SAXS, X-ray crystallography and NMR), we have studied the structure of the haem transporter HasR captured in two stages of the signalling process, i.e. before and after the arrival of signalling activators (haem and its carrier protein). We show for the first time that the HasR domain responsible for signal transfer: (i) is highly flexible in two stages of signalling; (ii) extends into the periplasm at approximately 70–90 Å (1 Å=0.1 nm) from the HasR β-barrel; and (iii) exhibits local conformational changes in response to the arrival of signalling activators. These features would favour the signal transfer from HasR to its cytoplasmic membrane partners.

Heme interacts with histidine- and tyrosine-based protein motifs and inhibits enzymatic activity of chloramphenicol acetyltransferase from Escherichia coli

BACKGROUND

The occurrence of free organismal heme can either contribute to serious diseases or beneficially regulate important physiological processes. Research on transient binding to heme-regulatory motifs (HRMs) in proteins resulted in the discovery of numerous Cys-based, especially Cys-Pro (CP)-based motifs. However, the number of His- and Tyr-based protein representatives is comparatively low so far, which is in part caused by a lack of information regarding recognition and binding requirements.

METHODS

To understand transient heme association with such motifs on the molecular level, we analyzed a set of 44 His- and Tyr-based peptides using UV-vis, resonance Raman, cw-EPR and 2D NMR spectroscopy.

RESULTS

We observed similarities with Cys-based sequences with respect to their spectral behavior and complex geometries. However, significant differences regarding heme-binding affinities and sequence requirements were also found. Compared to Cys-based peptides and proteins all sequences investigated structurally display increased flexibility already in the free-state, which is also maintained upon heme association. The acquired knowledge allowed for identification and prediction of a His-based HRM in chloramphenicol acetyltransferase from Escherichia coli as potential heme-regulated protein. The enzyme's heme-interacting capability was studied, and revealed an inhibitory effect of heme on the protein activity with an IC50 value of 57.69±4.37 μM.

CONCLUSIONS

It was found that heme inhibits a bacterial protein carrying a potential His-based HRM. This finding brings microbial proteins more into focus of regulation by free heme.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

Understanding transient binding and regulatory action of heme with bacterial proteins, being crucial for survival, might promote new strategies for the treatment of bacterial infections.

Using singular value decomposition to characterize protein-protein interactions by in-cell NMR spectroscopy

Distinct differences between how model proteins interact in-cell and in vitro suggest that the cytosol might have a profound effect in modulating protein-protein and/or protein-ligand interactions that are not observed in vitro. Analyses of in-cell NMR spectra of target proteins interacting with physiological partners are further complicated by low signal-to-noise ratios, and the long overexpression times used in protein-protein interaction studies may lead to changes in the in-cell spectra over the course of the experiment. To unambiguously resolve the principal binding mode between two interacting species against the dynamic cellular background, we analyzed in-cell spectral data of a target protein over the time course of overexpression of its interacting partner by using single-value decomposition (SVD). SVD differentiates between concentration-dependent and concentration-independent events and identifies the principal binding mode between the two species. The analysis implicates a set of amino acids involved in the specific interaction that differs from previous NMR analyses but is in good agreement with crystallographic data.

Information-driven modeling of large macromolecular assemblies using NMR data

Availability of high-resolution atomic structures is one of the prerequisites for a mechanistic understanding of biomolecular function. This atomic information can, however, be difficult to acquire for interesting systems such as high molecular weight and multi-subunit complexes. For these, low-resolution and/or sparse data from a variety of sources including NMR are often available to define the interaction between the subunits. To make best use of all the available information and shed light on these challenging systems, integrative computational tools are required that can judiciously combine and accurately translate the sparse experimental data into structural information. In this Perspective we discuss NMR techniques and data sources available for the modeling of large and multi-subunit complexes. Recent developments are illustrated by particularly challenging application examples taken from the literature. Within this context, we also position our data-driven docking approach, HADDOCK, which can integrate a variety of information sources to drive the modeling of biomolecular complexes. It is the synergy between experimentation and computational modeling that will provides us with detailed views on the machinery of life and lead to a mechanistic understanding of biomolecular function.

Solution and solid state NMR approaches to draw iron pathways in the ferritin nanocage

Ferritins are intracellular proteins that can store thousands of iron(III) ions as a solid mineral. These structures autoassemble from four-helix bundle subunits to form a hollow sphere and are a prototypical example of protein nanocages. The protein acts as a reservoir, encapsulating iron as ferric oxide in its central cavity in a nontoxic and bioavailable form. Scientists have long known the structural details of the protein shell, owing to very high resolution X-ray structures of the apoform. However, the atomic level mechanism governing the multistep biomineralization process remained largely elusive. Through analysis of the chemical behavior of ferritin mutants, chemists have found the role of some residues in key reaction steps. Using Mössbauer and XAS, they have identified some di-iron intermediates of the catalytic reaction trapped by rapid freeze quench. However, structural information about the iron interaction sites remains scarce. The entire process is governed by a number of specific, but weak, interactions between the protein shell and the iron species moving across the cage. While this situation may constitute a major problem for crystallography, NMR spectroscopy represents an optimal tool to detect and characterize transient species involving soluble proteins. Regardless, NMR analysis of the 480 kDa ferritin represents a real challenge. Our interest in ferritin chemistry inspired us to use an original combination of solution and solid state approaches. While the highly symmetric structure of the homo-24-mer frog ferritin greatly simplifies the spectra, the large protein size hinders the efficient coherence transfer in solution, thus preventing the sequence specific assignments. In contrast, extensive (13)C-spin diffusion makes the solution (13)C-(13)C NOESY experiment our gold standard to monitor protein side chains both in the apoprotein alone and in its interaction with paramagnetic iron species, inducing line broadening on the resonances of nearby residues. We could retrieve the structural information embedded in the (13)C-(13)C NOESY due to a partial sequence specific assignment of protein backbone and side chains we obtained from solid state MAS NMR of ferritin microcrystals. We used the 59 assigned amino acids (∼33% of the total) as probes to locate paramagnetic ferric species in the protein cage. Through this approach, we could identify ferric dimers at the ferroxidase site and on their pathway towards the nanocage. Comparison with existing data on bacterioferritins and bacterial ferritins, as well as with eukaryotic ferritins loaded with various nonfunctional divalent ions, allowed us to reinterpret the available information. The resulting picture of the ferroxidase site is slightly different with various ferritins but is designed to provide multiple and generally weak iron ligands. The latter assist binding of two incoming iron(II) ions in two proximal positions to facilitate coupling with oxygen. Subsequent oxidation is accompanied by a decrease in the metal-metal distance (consistent with XAS/Mössbauer) and in the number of protein residues involved in metal coordination, facilitating the release of products as di-iron clusters under the effect of new incoming iron(II) ions.

Axial ligand replacement mechanism in heme transfer from streptococcal heme-binding protein Shp to HtsA of the HtsABC transporter

The heme-binding protein Shp of Group A Streptococcus rapidly transfers its heme to HtsA, the lipoprotein component of the HtsABC transporter, in a concerted two-step process with one kinetic phase. Heme axial residue-to-alanine replacement mutant proteins of Shp and HtsA (Shp(M66A), Shp(M153A), HtsA(M79A), and HtsA(H229A)) were used to probe the axial displacement mechanism of this heme transfer reaction. Ferric Shp(M66A) at high pH and Shp(M153A) have a pentacoordinate heme iron complex with a methionine axial ligand. ApoHtsA(M79A) efficiently acquires heme from ferric Shp but alters the reaction mechanism to two kinetic phases from a single phase in the wild-type protein reactions. In contrast, apoHtsA(H229A) cannot assimilate heme from ferric Shp. The conversion of pentacoordinate holoShp(M66A) into pentacoordinate holoHtsA(H229A) involves an intermediate, whereas holoHtsA(H229A) is directly formed from pentacoordinate holoShp(M153A). Conversely, apoHtsA(M79A) reacts with holoShp(M66A) and holoShp(M153A) in mechanisms with one and two kinetic phases, respectively. These results imply that the Met79 and His229 residues of HtsA displace the Met66 and Met153 residues of Shp, respectively. Structural docking analysis supports this mechanism of the specific axial residue displacement. Furthermore, the rates of the cleavage of the axial bond in Shp in the presence of a replacing HtsA axial residue are greater than that in the absence of a replacing HtsA axial residue. These findings reveal a novel heme transfer mechanism of the specific displacement of the Shp axial residues with the HtsA axial residues and the involvement of the HtsA axial residues in the displacement.

The structure of HasB reveals a new class of TonB protein fold

TonB is a key protein in active transport of essential nutrients like vitamin B12 and metal sources through the outer membrane transporters of Gram-negative bacteria. This inner membrane protein spans the periplasm, contacts the outer membrane receptor by its periplasmic domain and transduces energy from the cytoplasmic membrane pmf to the receptor allowing nutrient internalization. Whereas generally a single TonB protein allows the acquisition of several nutrients through their cognate receptor, in some species one particular TonB is dedicated to a specific system. Despite a considerable amount of data available, the molecular mechanism of TonB-dependent active transport is still poorly understood. In this work, we present a structural study of a TonB-like protein, HasB dedicated to the HasR receptor. HasR acquires heme either free or via an extracellular heme transporter, the hemophore HasA. Heme is used as an iron source by bacteria. We have solved the structure of the HasB periplasmic domain of Serratia marcescens and describe its interaction with a critical region of HasR. Some important differences are observed between HasB and TonB structures. The HasB fold reveals a new structural class of TonB-like proteins. Furthermore, we have identified the structural features that explain the functional specificity of HasB. These results give a new insight into the molecular mechanism of nutrient active transport through the bacterial outer membrane and present the first detailed structural study of a specific TonB-like protein and its interaction with the receptor.

Heme uptake and metabolism in bacteria

All but a few bacterial species have an absolute need for heme, and most are able to synthesize it via a pathway that is highly conserved among all life domains. Because heme is a rich source for iron, many pathogenic bacteria have also evolved processes for sequestering heme from their hosts. The heme biosynthesis pathways are well understood at the genetic and structural biology levels. In comparison, much less is known about the heme acquisition, trafficking, and degradation processes in bacteria. Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria have evolved similar strategies but different tactics for importing and degrading heme, likely as a consequence of their different cellular architectures. The differences are manifested in distinct structures for molecules that perform similar functions. Consequently, the aim of this chapter is to provide an overview of the structural biology of proteins and protein-protein interactions that enable Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria to sequester heme from the extracellular milieu, import it to the cytosol, and degrade it to mine iron.

Role of the iron axial ligands of heme carrier HasA in heme uptake and release

The hemophore protein HasA from Serratia marcescens cycles between two states as follows: the heme-bound holoprotein, which functions as a carrier of the metal cofactor toward the membrane receptor HasR, and the heme-free apoprotein fishing for new porphyrin to be taken up after the heme has been delivered to HasR. Holo- and apo-forms differ for the conformation of the two loops L1 and L2, which provide the axial ligands of the iron through His(32) and Tyr(75), respectively. In the apo-form, loop L1 protrudes toward the solvent far away from loop L2; in the holoprotein, closing of the loops on the heme occurs upon establishment of the two axial coordination bonds. We have established that the two variants obtained via single point mutations of either axial ligand (namely H32A and Y75A) are both in the closed conformation. The presence of the heme and one out of two axial ligands is sufficient to establish a link between L1 and L2, thanks to the presence of coordinating solvent molecules. The latter are stabilized in the iron coordination environment by H-bond interactions with surrounding protein residues. The presence of such a water molecule in both variants is revealed here through a set of different spectroscopic techniques. Previous studies had shown that heme release and uptake processes occur via intermediate states characterized by a Tyr(75)-iron-bound form with open conformation of loop L1. Here, we demonstrate that these states do not naturally occur in the free protein but can only be driven by the interaction with the partner proteins.

Ionic strength effects on the critical micellar concentration of ionic and nonionic surfactants: the binding model

We have recently investigated the aggregation behavior of zwitterionic n-dodecyl phosphocholine in the presence of high salt. As double logarithmic Corrin-Harkins plots of the critical micellar concentration versus the salt concentration were not linear, here we re-examine those data in the context of the binding model of surfactant aggregation, as previously developed by us for ionic surfactants. We have also re-examined plenty of data available in the literature on the salt-dependent aggregation of neutral surfactants. The use of double-logarithmic plots allowed us to show that the binding model is of general applicability. Indeed, it permits unified treatment of ionic and uncharged aggregation without requiring the introduction of linear terms in the salt concentration, as needed in the empirical Corrin-Harkins treatment of nonionic surfactants. The use of this model could be of help in a broad range of surfactant-based applications in the presence of high salt.

Transient weak protein-protein complexes transfer heme across the cell wall of Staphylococcus aureus

Iron is an essential nutrient for the bacterial pathogen Staphylococcus aureus . Heme in hemoglobin (Hb) is the most abundant source of iron in the human body and during infections is captured by S. aureus using iron-regulated surface determinant (Isd) proteins. A central step in this process is the transfer of heme between the cell wall associated IsdA and IsdC hemoproteins. Biochemical evidence indicates that heme is transferred via an activated IsdA:heme:IsdC heme complex. Transfer is rapid and occurs up to 70,000 times faster than indirect mechanisms in which heme is released into the solvent. To gain insight into the mechanism of transfer, we modeled the structure of the complex using NMR paramagnetic relaxation enhancement (PRE) methods. Our results indicate that IsdA and IsdC transfer heme via an ultraweak affinity "handclasp" complex that juxtaposes their respective 3(10) helices and β7/β8 loops. Interestingly, PRE also identified a set of transient complexes that could represent high-energy pre-equilibrium encounter species that form prior to the stereospecific handclasp complex. Targeted amino acid mutagenesis and stopped-flow measurements substantiate the functional relevance of a PRE-derived model, as mutation of interfacial side chains significantly slows the rate of transfer. IsdA and IsdC bind heme using NEAr Transporter (NEAT) domains that are conserved in many species of pathogenic Gram-positive bacteria. Heme transfer in these microbes may also occur through structurally similar transient stereospecific complexes.

Recent advances in bacterial heme protein biochemistry

Recent progress in genetics, fed by the burst in genome sequence data, has led to the identification of a host of novel bacterial heme proteins that are now being characterized in structural and mechanistic terms. The following short review highlights very recent work with bacterial heme proteins involved in the uptake, biosynthesis, degradation, and use of heme in respiration and sensing.

Effective critical micellar concentration of a zwitterionic detergent: a fluorimetric study on n-dodecyl phosphocholine

We have investigated the effect of ionic strength on the aggregation behavior of n-dodecyl phosphocholine. On the basis of the classical Corrin-Harkins relation, the critical micellar concentration of this detergent decreases with a biphasic trend on lithium chloride addition. It is nearly constant below 150 mM salt, with a mean value of 0.91 mM, whereas it undergoes a dramatic 80-fold decrease in 7 M LiCl. Such a drop in the critical micellar concentration could be explained by the effect of salting out and the implication of phosphocholine head groups on the organization of surrounding water. Knowledge of the effective critical micellar concentration of n-dodecyl phosphocholine could be useful in the purification of membrane proteins in non-denaturing conditions.

The role of solution NMR in the structure determinations of VDAC-1 and other membrane proteins

The voltage-dependent anion channel (VDAC) is an essential protein in the eukaryotic outer mitochondrial membrane, providing the pore for substrate diffusion. Three high-resolution structures of the isoform 1 of VDAC in detergent micelles and bicelles have recently been published, using solution NMR and X-ray crystallography. They resolve longstanding discussions about the membrane topology of VDAC and provide the first eukaryotic beta-barrel membrane protein structure. The structure contains a surprising feature that had not been observed in an integral membrane protein before: A parallel beta-strand pairing and thus an odd number of strands. The studies also give a structural and functional basis for the voltage gating mechanism of VDAC and its modulation by NADH; however, they do not fully explain these functions yet. With the de novo structure of VDAC-1, as well as those of half a dozen other proteins, the number of integral membrane protein structures solved by solution NMR has doubled in the past two years. Numerous further structural and functional studies on many different membrane proteins show that solution NMR has become an important tool for membrane protein molecular biology.

Rubredoxin as a paramagnetic relaxation-inducing probe

The paramagnetic effect due to the presence of a metal center with unpaired electrons is no longer considered a hindrance in protein NMR spectroscopy. In the present work, the paramagnetic effect due to the presence of a metal center with unpaired electrons was used to map the interface of an electron transfer complex. Desulfovibrio gigas cytochrome c(3) was chosen as target to study the effect of the paramagnetic probe, Fe-rubredoxin, which produced specific line broadening in the heme IV methyl resonances M2(1) and M18(1). The rubredoxin binding surface in the complex with cytochrome c(3) was identified in a heteronuclear 2D NMR titration. The identified heme methyls on cytochrome c(3) are involved in the binding interface of the complex, a result that is in agreement with the predicted complexes obtained by restrained molecular docking, which shows a cluster of possible solutions near heme IV. The use of a paramagnetic probe in (1)HNMR titration and the mapping of the complex interface, in combination with a molecular simulation algorithm proved to be a valuable strategy to study electron transfer complexes involving non-heme iron proteins and cytochromes.