Photomechanical Motions in Organoboron-Based Phosphorescent Molecular Crystals Driven by a Crystal-State [2 + 2] Cycloaddition Reaction

Elusive Interplay of 3D Structural Similarity and Twinning in Mechanical Flexibility of Luminescent Organic Crystals

The properties of molecular crystalline solids are critically dependent on the spatial arrangement of molecules and underlying noncovalent interactions. Here, two new isoelectronic cocrystals of a substituted carbazole-based emitter are presented, with bipyridyl ethylene and azene molecules, namely, cocrystal 1 and cocrystal 2, respectively. Though both isoelectronic cocrystals are also three-dimensional (3D) isostructural at the supramolecular level, they show similar photoluminescence properties as anticipated, but irreconcilable macroscopic mechanical properties. Upon applying external stress on their respective major crystal faces, cocrystal 1 is elastically flexible, while the 3D isostructural cocrystal 2 exhibits brittle fracture. Remarkably, elastic flexibility in cocrystal 2 can be induced through twinning-mediated crystal face modification, without any change in crystal structure.

Head-to-Tail Packing to Facilitate [2+2] Cycloaddition for Green Synthesis of Cyclobutane Derivatives in Specific Configuration

Topological [2+2] cycloaddition is known to provide a convenient synthetic route for cyclobutane derivatives from favorably dispositioned dienes. In this study, new (2Z,4E)-2-(2,4-difluorophenyl)-5-phenylpenta-2,4-dienenitrile (HDE), (2Z,4E)-2-(2,4-difluorophenyl)-5-(p-tolyl)penta-2,4-dienenitrile (MeDE), (2Z,4E)-5-(4-chlorophenyl)-2-(2,4-difluorophenyl)penta-2,4-dienenitrile (ClDE), (2Z,4E)-5-(4-bromophenyl)-2-(2,4-difluorophenyl)penta-2,4-dienenitrile (BrDE), (2Z,4E)-2-(2,4-difluorophenyl)-5-(4-methoxyphenyl) penta-2,4-dienenitrile (MeODE), and (2Z,4E)-2-(2,4-difluorophenyl)-5-(4-(dimethylamino)phenyl)penta-2,4-dienenitrile (MeNDE) were synthesized, and their reactivity and selectivity were investigated in relation to their molecular packing in the respective crystals. HDE and MeDE, with head-to-tail (HT) arrangement, yielded only one type of photodimer. On the contrary, ClDE and BrDE, with head-to-head (HH) packing, and where the "olefin pairsα,β-α,β" and "olefin pairsγ,δ-γ,δ" satisfy Schimdt's criteria, reacted to a mixture of photoproducts. Kinetics analysis suggests that the reaction rates of HDE and MeDE are higher than those of ClDE and BrDE. This observation may be due to the strong non-covalent interactions between the potentially reactive olefin pairs as suggested by energy decomposition analysis. Furthermore, the reaction activation energies for photodimerization of the HT-packed olefin pairs are indeed lower than those of the HH-arranged ones. The HT packing of the diphenyldienes not only enhances the reactivity in the topological [2+2] cycloaddition but also contributes chemospecificity, regiospecifity, and stereospecificity, all of which are essential for the preparation of specific cyclobutanes derivatives based on photodimerization.

Broadband-Light-Induced [2+2] Cycloaddition and Thermoinduced Cycloreversion-Powered Dynamic Molecular Crystals

Photomechanically responsive dynamic molecular crystals are central to developing efficient, rapid, and robust materials capable of conversion of light energy to mechanical work. However, unlike some other, mainly photochromic molecular solar thermal energy storage (MOST) systems, solids that undergo photoinduced [2+2] cycloaddition have not been thoroughly explored for powering reversible actuation, despite that this reaction system carries potential in the heavily strained bonds of the cyclobutane ring. In this study, we propose that broadband-light-induced [2+2] cycloaddition can be used to store energy and actuate dynamic organic crystals by irradiation with visible light. The prototypical material, pyrenylvinylpyrylium tetrafluoroborate (1-PVPyL), undergoes a topochemical [2+2] cycloaddition induced not only by ultraviolet radiation (365 nm) but also by monochromatic green light (532 nm), red light (620 nm) and broadband visible light in a single-crystal-to-single-crystal (SCSC) manner, causing its crystals to bend. The crystals effectively act as energy depots, where the reverse deformation can be initiated by heating and the stored energy is released via thermal cycloreversion reaction. Given the ubiquity of the [2+2] cycloaddition in the solid state, the current study invites the development of new dimeric MOST architectures that utilize sunlight for energy storage and thermal triggers for energy release. Within a broader scope, this approach provides a platform for fabrication of visible-light-driven crystal actuators capable of harnessing sunlight.

Manipulating Dynamic Light-Driven Solid-Liquid Transition and Static Reversible Photochromism by an Organic Cocrystal Strategy

Developing of molecular crystalline materials with light-induced multiple dynamic deformation in space dimension and photochromism on time scales has attracted much attention for its potential applications in actuators, sensoring and information storage. Nevertheless, organic crystals capable of both photoinduced dynamic effects and static color change are rare, particularly for multi-component cocrystal system. In this study, we first report the construction of charge transfer cocrystal allows their light-induced solid-to-liquid transition and photochromic behaviors to be controlled by trans-stilbene (TSB) as an electron donor and 3,4,5,6-tetrafluorophthalonitrile (TFP) as an electron acceptor. In this case, the dynamic photo-responsive solid-to-liquid phase transition is due to the photoisomerization of TSB under UV light irradiation, while the accumulation of melted droplets during solid-state photochemical process causes mechanical deformation of TSB-TFP cocrystals. The subsequent reversible photochromic behavior is attributed to the emergence of free radicals through a photo-induced electron transfer. Moreover, TSB-TFP microcrystals present typical excitation wavelength dependent emission (EWDE) fluorescence by surfactant-mediated method. This work realizes the dynamic-static photochemical cascade processes in response to UV light irradiation in an organic cocrystal system, providing the effective method for a new type of smart photo-responsive materials.

Light-Driven Adaptive Molecular Crystals Activated by [2+2] and [4+4] Cycloadditions

Photomechanical crystals act as light-driven material-machines that can convert the energy carried by photons into kinetic energy via shape deformation or displacement, and this capability holds a paramount significance for the development of photoactuated devices. This transformation is usually attributed to anisotropic expansion or contraction of the unit cell engendered by light-induced structural modifications that lead to accumulation and release of stress that generates a momentum, resulting in readily observable mechanical effects. Among the available photochemical processes, the photoinduced [2+2] and [4+4] reactions are known for their robustness, predictability, amenability to control with molecular and supramolecular engineering approaches, and efficiency that has already been elevated to a proof-of-concept smart devices based on organic crystals. This review article presents a summary of the recent research progress on photomechanical properties of organic and metal-organic crystals where the mechanical effects are based on [2+2] and [4+4] cycloaddition reactions. It consolidates the current understating of the chemical strategies and structure-property correlations, and highlights the advantages and drawbacks of this class of adaptive crystals within the broader field of crystal adaptronics.

Cu(I)-Induced 'Click Reaction' Involving Coordination and Covalent Assembly of Hybrid Borates for the Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction

The design and synthesis of hybrid borates by the organic ligand modification method are urgent and undeveloped areas of research. It is difficult to directly integrate organoboronic acids within inorganic borate chemistry by adopting the traditional preparation approaches. This work reports a facile synthetic method to synthesize a large family of pyrazole molecule-protected borates in a rapid and precise manner under mild conditions. A unique cyclic eight-membered B4O4-ring has been identified as the cluster core for all these hybrid borates with two different conformations (boat and crown). This strategy can be applied to a system of pyrazolyl molecules to generate such hybrid borates in two independent routes from organoboronic or inorganic boric acids. Furtherly, the mechanism of 'click reaction' between boric acid and pyrazole induced by copper ions has been proposed based on the synthetic conditions and the structure of intermediate. Due to the bimetallic Cu sites and the functional surfaces, these materials can be used as electrocatalysts for CO2 reduction reaction and efficiently enhance the selectivity of HCOOH and C2H4. Our strategy can be regarded as a typical template technique for organic molecule-protected borates.

Visible Light-Responsive Crystalline B←N Host Adducts with Solvent-Induced Allosteric Effect for Guest Release

Photo-responsive organic crystals, capable of converting light energy into chemical energy to initiate conformational transitions, present an emerging strategy for developing lightweight and versatile smart materials. However, visible light-triggered tailored guests capture and release behaviors in all-organic solids are rarely reported. Here, we introduce a photoreactive crystalline boron-nitrogen (B←N) host adduct with the ability to undergo [2+2] photocycloaddition upon 447 nm light exposure. This process facilitates single-crystal-to-single-crystal (SCSC) photodimerization in the mother liquor, maintaining the original B←N host structure. Weakened intermolecular interactions within the photodimer host contribute to fast guest release in air under irradiation. Furthermore, the dynamic B←N bonds enable reversible transformations between organic host adducts and adduct cocrystals under the solvent-induced allosteric effect. As a result, four B←N host adduct crystals containing individual alkane guest are easily obtained and exhibited the ability of photo-controlled alkane release. Therefore, the integration of photo reactivity and structural transformation within B←N host adduct enables customized capture and release of guest molecules.

The Use of Photocycloaddition Reactions to Drive Mechanical Motions Resembling Humanoid Movements

With the aim of producing a photomechanical material for incorporation in soft microrobots, a one-dimensional diene coordination polymer (CP) [Cd(F-bpeb)(3-CBA)2]n (CP1, F-bpeb=4,4'-((1E,1'E)-(2,5-difluoro-1,4-phenylene)bis(ethene-2,1-diyl))dipyridine, 3-HCBA=3-chlorobenzoic acid) was synthesized and characterized. Irradiation of CP1 with ultraviolet (UV) or visible light causes [2+2] photocycloaddition reactions resulting in the introduction of crystal strain which triggers various types of crystal movements. Composite films of CP1-PVA (SC) fabricated by dispersing CP1 crystals into polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) solution allow amplification of the crystal movement so that the film strips exhibit fast and flexible curling upon photoirradiation. The composite films may be cut into long rectangular strips and folded to simulate soft microrobots which exhibit a variety of fast, flexible and continuous photomechanical movements resembling a human performing various gymnastic exercises.

Photodimerization-Triggered Photopolymerization of Triene Coordination Polymers Enables Macroscopic Photomechanical Movements

Controlling the packing of olefinic molecules in crystals is essential for triggering solid-state [2 + 2] photocycloaddition reactions and the synthesis of photocontrolled smart materials. Herein, we report the stepwise photodimerization-triggered photopolymerization of two triene coordination polymers (CPs), {[Zn(2-BBA)2(tpeb)]·0.5CH3CN}n (1, 2-HBBA = 2-bromobenzoic acid, tpeb = 1,3,5-tri-4-pyridyl-1,2-ethenylbenzene) and {[Zn(3-BBA)2(tpeb)]·CH3CN)}n (2, 3-HBBA = 3-bromobenzoic acid). Upon irradiation with 420 nm light, each pair of closely packed and parallel olefinic bonds in 1 undergoes a [2 + 2] cycloaddition reaction, which connects two adjacent Z-shaped chains into a ladder-like coordination chain [Zn(2-BBA)2(bpbdpvpcb)0.5]n (1a, bpbdpvpcb = 1,3-bis(4-pyridyl)-2,4-bis(3,5-di(2-(4-pyridyl)vinyl)phenyl]cyclobutene) through single-crystal to single-crystal (SCSC) transformation. After photodimerization from 1 to 1a has occurred, the olefinic bonds that were initially distant are brought in close enough proximity to meet the requirements for a subsequent [2 + 2] cycloaddition reaction. Upon further light irradiation, the neighboring bpbdpvpcb ligands in 1a experience a SCSC photopolymerization based on [2 + 2] photocycloaddition and transform into poly-3b,4,5,5a,8b,9,10a-octahydro-4,5,9,10-tetrapyridyl-2,7-di(2-(4-pyridyl)vinyl)dicyclobuta[e,l]-pyren (poly-otpdpvdcbp). 2 showed similar structural changes under UV light illumination. Under light exposure, single crystals of 1 and 2 with different morphologies exhibit bending, cracking, and jumping photomechanical motions. The composite film (1-PVA) engineered by dispersing crystalline particles of 1 in poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) displays interesting light-wavelength-dependent photomechanical motions and can perform photodriven swimming on a liquid surface. This work provides a useful and promising approach to enable photodimerization of those photoinactive olefin pairs embedded in CPs and opens a new route to synthesize organic polymers by using olefinic CP platforms.

Trimodal operation of a robust smart organic crystal

We describe a dynamic crystalline material that integrates mechanical, thermal, and light modes of operation, with unusual robustness and resilience and a variety of both slow and fast kinematic effects that occur on very different time scales. In the mechanical mode of operation, crystals of this material are amenable to elastic deformation, and they can be reversibly morphed and even closed into a loop, sustaining strains of up to about 2.6%. Upon release of the external force, the crystals resume their original shape without any sign of damage, demonstrating outstanding elasticity. Application of torque results in plastic twisting for several rotations without damage, and the twisted crystal can still be bent elastically. The thermal mode of operation relies on switching the lattice at least several dozen times. The migration of the phase boundaries depends on the crystal habit. It can be precisely controlled by temperature, and it is accompanied by both slow and fast motions, including shear deformation and leaping. Parallel boundaries result in a thermomechanical effect, while non-parallel boundaries result in a thermosalient effect. Finally, the photochemical mode of operation is driven by isomerization and can be thermally reverted. The structure of the crystal can also be switched photochemically, and the generation of a bilayer induces rapid bending upon exposure to ultraviolet light, an effect that further diversifies the mechanical response of the material. The small structural changes, low-energy and weak intramolecular hydrogen bonds, and shear deformation, which could dissipate part of the elastic energy, are considered to be the decisive factors for the conservation of the long-range order and the extraordinary diversity in the response of this, and potentially many other dynamic crystalline materials.

Bending, Twisting, and Propulsion of Photoreactive Crystals by Controlled Gas Release

The rapid release of gas by a chemical reaction to generate momentum is one of the most fundamental ways to elicit motion that could be used to sustain and control the motility of objects. We report that hollow crystals of a three-dimensional supramolecular metal complex that releases gas by photolysis can propel themselves or other objects and advance in space when suspended in mother solution. In needle-like regular crystals, the reaction occurs mainly on the surface and results in the formation of cracks that evolve due to internal pressure; the expansion on the cracked surface of the crystal results in bending, twisting, or coiling of the crystal. In hollow crystals, gas accumulates inside their cavities and emanates preferentially from the recess at the crystal terminus, propelling the crystals to undergo directional photomechanical motion through the mother solution. The motility of the object which can be controlled externally to perform work delineates the concept of "crystal microbots", realized by photoreactive organic crystals capable of prolonged directional motion for actuation or delivery. Within the prospects, we envisage the development of a plethora of light-weight, efficient, autonomously operating robots based on organic crystals with high work capacity where motion over large distances can be attained due to the large volume of latent gas generated from a small volume of the crystalline solid.

Single-Crystal-to-Single-Crystal Photosynthesis of Supramolecular Organoboron Polymers with Dynamic Effects

The solid-state synthesis of single-crystalline organic polymers, having functional properties, remains an attractive and developing research area in polymer chemistry and materials science. However, light-triggered topochemical synthesis of crystalline polymers comprising an organoboron backbone has not yet been reported. Here, we describe an intriguing example of single-crystal-to-single-crystal (SCSC) rapid photosynthesis (occurs on a seconds-scale) of two structurally different linear organoboron polymers, driven by environmentally sustainable visible/sun light, obtained from the same monomer molecule. A newly designed Lewis acid-base type molecular B ← N organoboron adduct (consisting of an organoboron core and naphthylvinylpyridine ligands) crystallizes in two solid-state forms featuring the same chemical structure but different 3D structural topologies, namely, monomers 1 and 2. The solvate molecule-free crystals of 1 undergo topochemical photopolymerization via an unusual olefin-naphthyl ring [2 + 2] cyclization to yield the single crystalline [3]-ladderane polymer 1P growing along the B ← N linkages, accompanied by instantaneous and violent macroscopic mechanical motions or photosalient effects (such as bending-reshaping and jumping motions). In contrast, visible light-harvesting single crystals of 2 quantitatively polymerize to a B ← N bond-stabilized polymer 2P in a SCSC fashion owing to the rapid [2 + 2] cycloaddition reaction among olefin double bonds. Such olefin bonds in the crystals of 2 are suitably preorganized for photoreaction due to the presence of solvate molecules in the crystal packing. Single crystals of 2 also show photodynamic jumping motions - in response to visible light but in a relatively slower fashion than the crystals of 1. In addition to SCSC topochemical polymerization and dynamic motions, both monomer crystals and their single-crystalline polymers feature green emissive and short-lived room-temperature phosphorescence properties upon excitation with visible-light wavelength.

Massive Molecular Motion in Crystal Leads to an Unexpected Helical Covalent Polymer in a Solid-state Polymerization

We designed a proline-derived monomer with azide and alkene functional groups to enable topochemical ene-azide cycloaddition (TEAC) polymerization. In its crystal, the monomer forms supramolecular helices along the 'a' axis through various non-covalent interactions. Along the 'c' axis, the molecules arrange themselves head-to-tail in a wave-like pattern, positioning the azide and alkene groups of adjacent molecules in close proximity and anti-parallel orientation, complying with Schmidt's criteria for topochemical reaction. This prearranged configuration was expected to facilitate smooth topochemical polymerization, resulting in a 1,4-triazoline-linked polymer. Upon heating, the monomer underwent TEAC polymerization in a remarkable single-crystal-to-single-crystal fashion, but, to our surprise, it yielded an unexpected covalent helical polymer linked by 1,5-disubstituted triazoline units. Remarkably, the crystal avoids the ready-to-react arrangement for polymerization, but connects monomer molecules within the supramolecular helix through the cycloaddition of azide and alkene groups, even though they are not in close proximity nor in the expected orientation. This unexpected path, involving a substantial 134° rotation of the alkene group, yields hitherto unknown 1,5-disubstituted triazoline product regiospecifically. This study serves as a cautionary reminder that relying solely on topochemical postulates for predicting reactivity can sometimes be misleading.

Boron-Nitrogen Lewis Pairs in the Assembly of Supramolecular Macrocycles, Molecular Cages, Polymers, and 3D Materials

Covering an exceptionally wide range of bond strengths, the dynamic nature and facile tunability of dative B-N bonds is highly attractive when it comes to the assembly of supramolecular polymers and materials. This Minireview offers an overview of advances in the development of functional materials where Lewis pairs (LPs) play a key role in their assembly and critically influence their properties. Specifically, we describe the reversible assembly of linear polymers with interesting optical, electronic and catalytic properties, discrete macrocycles and molecular cages that take up diverse guest molecules and undergo structural changes triggered by external stimuli, covalent organic frameworks (COFs) with intriguing interlocked structures that can embed and separate gases such as CO2 and acetylene, and soft polymer networks that serve as recyclable, self-healing, and responsive thermosets, gels and elastomeric materials.