Mechanistic Studies of Aziridine Formation Catalyzed by Mononuclear Non-Heme Iron Enzymes

Unusual mechanism of aziridine biosynthesis catalysed by the αKG-dependent non-heme enzyme TqaL

Aziridines are present in many synthetic pharmaceuticals. The synthesis of the aziridine ring remains challenging due to its highly strained three-membered ring structure. Recently, a non-heme αKG-dependent enzyme, TqaL, has been demonstrated to catalyze the synthesis of aziridines from L-Val. However, the detailed reaction mechanism of the enzyme remains elusive. Herein, we reported, for the first time, the mechanism of oxidative cyclisation for aziridine synthesis catalyzed by TqaL. Following the HAA step, the reaction proceeded via a unique concerted process with a single electron transfer from the isopropyl radical to the Fe(III)-OH motif, which was coupled with the electrophilic attack of the primary amine substrate on the tertiary isopropyl radical and simultaneous proton transfer from the substrate amine to the hydroxyl group of the Fe(III)-OH to give the aziridine. This research would provide a valuable structural basis for tailoring the non-heme αKG-dependent enzyme for the biosynthesis of highly active aziridine derivatives as pharmaceuticals.

Discovery of Noncanonical Iron and 2-Oxoglutarate Dependent Enzymes Involved in C-C and C-N Bond Formation in Biosynthetic Pathways

Iron and 2-oxoglutarate dependent (Fe/2OG) enzymes utilize an FeIV=O species to catalyze the functionalization of otherwise chemically inert C-H bonds. In addition to the more familiar canonical reactions of hydroxylation and chlorination, they also catalyze several other types of reactions that contribute to the diversity and complexity of natural products. In the past decade, several new Fe/2OG enzymes that catalyze C-C and C-N bond formation have been reported in the biosynthesis of structurally complex natural products. Compared with hydroxylation and chlorination, the catalytic cycles of these Fe/2OG enzymes involve distinct mechanistic features to enable noncanonical reaction outcomes. This Review summarizes recent discoveries of Fe/2OG enzymes involved in C-C and C-N bond formation with a focus on reaction mechanisms and their roles in natural product biosynthesis.

Biosynthesis of unique natural product scaffolds by Fe(II)/αKG-dependent oxygenases

Fe(II)/αKG-dependent oxygenases are multifunctional oxidases responsible for the formation of unique natural product skeletons. Studies of these enzymes are important because the knowledge of their catalytic functions, enzyme structures, and reaction mechanisms can be used to create non-natural enzymes through mutation and synthesize non-natural compounds. In this review, I will introduce the research we have conducted on two fungal Fe(II)/αKG-dependent oxygenases, TlxI-J and TqaL. TlxI-J is the first Fe(II)/αKG-dependent oxygenase type enzyme heterodimer that catalyzes consecutive oxidation reactions, hydroxylation followed by retro-aldol or ketal formation, to form the complex skeletons of meroterpenoids. TqaL is the first naturally occurring aziridine synthase, and I will discuss the mechanism of its unique C-N bond formation in nonproteinogenic amino acid biosynthesis. This review will advance research on the discovery of new enzymes and the analysis of their functions by reviewing the structures and functions of these extraordinary Fe(II)/αKG-dependent oxygenases, and promote their use in the synthesis of new natural medicines.

Ringing medicinal chemistry: The importance of 3-membered rings in drug discovery

Scaffold-based drug design has become increasingly prominent in the pharmaceutical field due to the systematic and effective approach through which it facilitates the development of novel drugs. The identification of key scaffolds provides medicinal chemists with a fundamental framework for subsequent research. With mounting evidence suggesting that increased aromaticity could impede the chances of developmental success for oral drug candidates, there is an imperative need for a more thorough exploration of alternative ring systems to mitigate attrition risks. The unique characteristics exhibited by three-membered rings have led to their application in medicinal chemistry. This review explores the use of cyclopropane-, aziridine-, thiirane-, and epoxide-containing compounds in drug discovery, focusing on their roles in approved medicines and drug candidates. Specifically, the importance of the three-membered ring systems in rending biological activity for each drug molecule was highlighted. The undeniable therapeutic value and intriguing features presented by these compounds suggest significant pharmacological potential, providing justification for their incorporation into the design of novel drug candidates.

A single diiron enzyme catalyses the oxidative rearrangement of tryptophan to indole nitrile

Nitriles are uncommon in nature and are typically constructed from oximes through the oxidative decarboxylation of amino acid substrates or from the derivatization of carboxylic acids. Here we report a third nitrile biosynthesis strategy featuring the cyanobacterial nitrile synthase AetD. During the biosynthesis of the eagle-killing neurotoxin, aetokthonotoxin, AetD transforms the 2-aminopropionate portion of 5,7-dibromo-L-tryptophan to a nitrile. Employing a combination of structural, biochemical and biophysical techniques, we characterized AetD as a non-haem diiron enzyme that belongs to the emerging haem-oxygenase-like dimetal oxidase superfamily. High-resolution crystal structures of AetD together with the identification of catalytically relevant products provide mechanistic insights into how AetD affords this unique transformation, which we propose proceeds via an aziridine intermediate. Our work presents a unique template for nitrile biogenesis and portrays a substrate binding and metallocofactor assembly mechanism that may be shared among other haem-oxygenase-like dimetal oxidase enzymes.

Optimized Substrate Positioning Enables Switches in the C-H Cleavage Site and Reaction Outcome in the Hydroxylation-Epoxidation Sequence Catalyzed by Hyoscyamine 6β-Hydroxylase

Hyoscyamine 6β-hydroxylase (H6H) is an iron(II)- and 2-oxoglutarate-dependent (Fe/2OG) oxygenase that produces the prolifically administered antinausea drug, scopolamine. After its namesake hydroxylation reaction, H6H then couples the newly installed C6 oxygen to C7 to produce the drug's epoxide functionality. Oxoiron(IV) (ferryl) intermediates initiate both reactions by cleaving C-H bonds, but it remains unclear how the enzyme switches the target site and promotes (C6)O-C7 coupling in preference to C7 hydroxylation in the second step. In one possible epoxidation mechanism, the C6 oxygen would─analogously to mechanisms proposed for the Fe/2OG halogenases and, in our more recent study, N-acetylnorloline synthase (LolO)─coordinate as alkoxide to the C7-H-cleaving ferryl intermediate to enable alkoxyl coupling to the ensuing C7 radical. Here, we provide structural and kinetic evidence that H6H does not employ substrate coordination or repositioning for the epoxidation step but instead exploits the distinct spatial dependencies of competitive C-H cleavage (C6 vs C7) and C-O-coupling (oxygen rebound vs cyclization) steps to promote the two-step sequence. Structural comparisons of ferryl-mimicking vanadyl complexes of wild-type H6H and a variant that preferentially 7-hydroxylates instead of epoxidizing 6β-hydroxyhyoscyamine suggest that a modest (∼10°) shift in the Fe-O-H(C7) approach angle is sufficient to change the outcome. The 7-hydroxylation:epoxidation partition ratios of both proteins increase more than 5-fold in 2H2O, reflecting an epoxidation-specific requirement for cleavage of the alcohol O-H bond, which, unlike in the LolO oxacyclization, is not accomplished by iron coordination in advance of C-H cleavage.

Recent Developments in the Biosynthesis of Aziridines

Only 0.016 % of all known natural products contain an aziridine ring, but this unique structural feature imparts high reactivity and cytotoxicity to the compounds in which it is found. Until 2021, no naturally occurring aziridine-forming enzymes had been identified. Since 2021, the biosynthetic enzymes for ~10 % of known aziridine containing natural products have been identified and characterized. This article describes the recent advances in our understanding of enzyme-catalyzed aziridine formation in the context of historical methods for aziridine formation through synthetic chemistry.

Cyclopropanation and aziridination catalyzed by non-heme iron and 2-oxoglutarate dependent enzymes

Cyclopropane and azacyclopropane, also known as aziridine, moieties are found in natural products. These moieties serve as pivotal components that lead to a broad spectrum of biological activities. While diverse strategies involving various classes of enzymes are utilized to catalyze formation of these strained three-membered rings, how non-heme iron and 2-oxoglutarate (Fe/2OG) dependent enzymes enable regio- and stereo-selective C-C and C-N ring closure has only been reported very recently. Herein, we present detailed experimental protocols for mechanistically studying Fe/2OG enzymes that catalyze cyclopropanation and aziridination reactions. These protocols include protein purification, in vitro assays, biophysical spectroscopies, and isotope-tracer experiments. We also report how to use in silico approaches to look for Fe/2OG aziridinases. Furthermore, our current mechanistic understanding of three-membered ring formation is discussed. These results not only shed light on the reaction mechanisms of Fe/2OG enzymes-catalyzed cyclopropanation and aziridination, but also open avenues for expanding the reaction repertoire of the Fe/2OG enzyme superfamily.

Spectroscopic and computational studies of a bifunctional iron- and 2-oxoglutarate dependent enzyme, AsqJ

Iron and 2-oxoglutarate dependent (Fe/2OG) enzymes exhibit an exceedingly broad reaction repertoire. The most prevalent reactivity is hydroxylation, but many other reactivities have also been discovered in recent years, including halogenation, desaturation, epoxidation, endoperoxidation, epimerization, and cyclization. To fully explore the reaction mechanisms that support such a diverse reactivities in Fe/2OG enzyme, it is necessary to utilize a multi-faceted research methodology, consisting of molecular probe design and synthesis, in vitro enzyme assay development, enzyme kinetics, spectroscopy, protein crystallography, and theoretical calculations. By using such a multi-faceted research approach, we have explored reaction mechanisms of desaturation and epoxidation catalyzed by a bi-functional Fe/2OG enzyme, AsqJ. Herein, we describe the experimental protocols and computational workflows used in our studies.

Controllable multi-halogenation of a non-native substrate by SyrB2 iron halogenase

Geminal, multi-halogenated functional groups are widespread in natural products and pharmaceuticals, yet no synthetic methodologies exist that enable selective multi-halogenation of unactivated C-H bonds. Biocatalysts are powerful tools for late-stage C-H functionalization, as they operate with high degrees of regio-, chemo-, and stereoselectivity. 2-oxoglutarate (2OG)-dependent non-heme iron halogenases chlorinate and brominate aliphatic C-H bonds offering a solution for achieving these challenging transformations. Here, we describe the ability of a non-heme iron halogenase, SyrB2, to controllably halogenate non-native substrate alpha-aminobutyric acid (Aba) to yield mono-chlorinated, di-chlorinated, and tri-chlorinated products. These chemoselective outcomes are achieved by controlling the loading of 2OG cofactor and SyrB2 biocatalyst. By using a ferredoxin-based biological reductant for electron transfer to the catalytic center of SyrB2, we demonstrate order-of-magnitude enhancement in the yield of tri-chlorinated product that were previously inaccessible using any single halogenase enzyme. We also apply these strategies to broaden SyrB2's reactivity scope to include multi-bromination and demonstrate chemoenzymatic conversion of the ethyl side chain in Aba to an ethylyne functional group. We show how steric hindrance induced by the successive addition of halogen atoms on Aba's C4 carbon dictates the degree of multi-halogenation by hampering C3-C4 bond rotation within SyrB2's catalytic pocket. Overall, our work showcases the synthetic potential of iron halogenases to facilitate multi-C-H functionalization chemistry.

Characterization of Aziridine-Forming α-Ketoglutarate-Dependent Oxygenase in l-Isovaline Biosynthesis

l-Isovaline biosynthesis by TqaLFM-ti from Tolypocladium inflatum was demonstrated in vitro. The biochemical analysis of the α-ketoglutarate-dependent oxygenase TqaL-ti revealed that it produces (2S,3S)-3-ethyl-3-methylaziridine-2-carboxylic acid from l-isoleucine, thus exhibiting a stereoselectivity different from those of the reported homologues. Remarkably, a single mutation on I295 in TqaL-ti completely exchanged its stereoselectivity to produce the C-3 stereoisomer. TqaFM-ti generates d-isovaline from (2S,3R)-aziridine-2-carboxylic acid, suggesting that the stereochemistry of the TqaL product defines that of isovaline.

Three-membered ring formation catalyzed by α-ketoglutarate-dependent nonheme iron enzymes

Epoxides, aziridines, and cyclopropanes are found in various medicinal natural products, including polyketides, terpenes, peptides, and alkaloids. Many classes of biosynthetic enzymes are involved in constructing these ring structures during their biosynthesis. This review summarizes our current knowledge regarding how α-ketoglutarate-dependent nonheme iron enzymes catalyze the formation of epoxides, aziridines, and cyclopropanes in nature, with a focus on enzyme mechanisms.

Algal Kainoid Synthases Exhibit Substrate-Dependent Hydroxylation and Cyclization Activities

FeII/α-ketoglutarate-dependent dioxygenases (Fe/αKG) make up a large enzyme family that functionalize C-H bonds on diverse organic substrates. Although Fe/αKG homologues catalyze an array of chemically useful reactions, hydroxylation typically predominates. Microalgal DabC uniquely forms a novel C-C bond to construct the bioactive pyrrolidine ring in domoic acid biosynthesis; however, we have identified that this kainoid synthase exclusively performs a stereospecific hydroxylation reaction on its cis substrate regioisomer. Mechanistic and kinetic analyses with native and alternative substrates identified a 20-fold rate increase in DabC radical cyclization over β-hydroxylation with no observable 1,5-hydrogen atom transfer. Moreover, this dual activity was conserved among macroalgal RadC1 and KabC homologues and provided insight into substrate recognition and reactivity trends. Investigation of this substrate-dependent chemistry improves our understanding of kainoid synthases and their biocatalytic application.

Mechanistic Analysis of Stereodivergent Nitroalkane Cyclopropanation Catalyzed by Nonheme Iron Enzymes

BelL and HrmJ are α-ketoglutarate-dependent nonheme iron enzymes that catalyze the oxidative cyclization of 6-nitronorleucine, resulting in the formation of two diastereomeric 3-(2-nitrocyclopropyl)alanine (Ncpa) products containing trans-cyclopropane rings with (1'R,2'R) and (1'S,2'S) configurations, respectively. Herein, we investigate the catalytic mechanism and stereodivergency of the cyclopropanases. The results suggest that the nitroalkane moiety of the substrate is first deprotonated to produce the nitronate form. Spectroscopic analyses and biochemical assays with substrates and analogues indicate that an iron(IV)-oxo species abstracts proS-H from C4 to initiate intramolecular C-C bond formation. A hydroxylation intermediate is unlikely to be involved in the cyclopropanation reaction. Additionally, a genome mining approach is employed to discover new homologues that perform the cyclopropanation of 6-nitronorleucine to generate cis-configured Ncpa products with (1'R,2'S) or (1'S,2'R) stereochemistries. Sequence and structure comparisons of these cyclopropanases enable us to determine the amino acid residues critical for controlling the stereoselectivity of cyclopropanation.

Oxidative rearrangement of tryptophan to indole nitrile by a single diiron enzyme

Nitriles are uncommon in nature and are typically constructed from oximes via the oxidative decarboxylation of amino acid substrates or from the derivatization of carboxylic acids. Here we report a third strategy of nitrile biosynthesis featuring the cyanobacterial nitrile synthase AetD. During the biosynthesis of the 'eagle-killing' neurotoxin, aetokthonotoxin, AetD converts the alanyl side chain of 5,7-dibromo-L-tryptophan to a nitrile. Employing a combination of structural, biochemical, and biophysical techniques, we characterized AetD as a non-heme diiron enzyme that belongs to the emerging Heme Oxygenase-like Diiron Oxidase and Oxygenase (HDO) superfamily. High-resolution crystal structures of AetD together with the identification of catalytically relevant products provide mechanistic insights into how AetD affords this unique transformation that we propose proceeds via an aziridine intermediate. Our work presents a new paradigm for nitrile biogenesis and portrays a substrate binding and metallocofactor assembly mechanism that may be shared among other HDO enzymes.