Lewis Acidic Support Boosts C-C Coupling in the Pulsed Electrochemical CO2 Reaction

Interfacial Metal Oxides Stabilize Cu Oxidation States for Electrocatalytical CO2 Reduction

Modulating the oxidation state of copper (Cu) is crucial for enhancing the electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR), particularly for facilitating deep reductions to produce methane (CH4) or multi-carbon (C2+) products. However, Cuδ+ sites are thermodynamically unstable, fluctuating their oxidation states under reaction conditions, which complicates their functionality. Incorporating interfacial metal oxides has emerged as an effective strategy for stabilizing these oxidation states. This review provides an in-depth examination of the reaction mechanisms occurring at oxide-modified Cuδ+ sites, offering a comprehensive understanding of their behavior. We explore how Cu/metal oxide interfaces stabilize Cu oxidation states, showing that oxides-modified Cu catalysts often enhance selectivity for C2+ or CH4 products by stabilizing Cu+ or Cu2+ sites. In addition, we discuss innovative strategies for the rational design of efficient Cu catalytic sites tailored for specific deep CO2RR products. The review concludes with an outlook on current challenges and future directions, offering new insights into the rational design of selective and efficient CO2RR catalysts.

Resolving Dynamic Behavior of Electrocatalysts via Advances of Operando X-Ray Absorption Spectroscopies: Potential Artifacts and Practical Guidelines

Although numerous techniques are developed to enable real-time understanding of dynamic interactions at the solid-liquid interface during electrochemical reactions, further progress in the development of these methods over the last several decades has faced challenges. With the rapid development of high-brilliance synchrotron sources, operando X-ray spectroscopies have become increasingly popular for revealing interfacial features and catalytic mechanisms in electrocatalysis. Nevertheless, the resulting spectra are highly sensitive to factors such as X-ray radiation, reaction environment, and acquisition procedures, all of which may potentially introduce artifacts that are often overlooked, leading to misinterpretations of electrocatalytic behaviors. In this perspective, several emerging hard X-ray spectroscopies used in electrocatalysis research are reviewed, highlighting their electronic transition processes, detection modes, and functional complementarity. Significantly, based on a case study of operando X-ray absorption spectroscopy at various beamlines, potential artifacts generated by X-ray irradiation are systematically investigated through photon-flux density-, dose-, and time-dependent studies of typical copper electrocatalysts. Accordingly, a practical protocol for conducting reliable X-ray spectroscopic measurements in operando electrocatalytic studies to minimize potential artifacts that can affect the resulting X-ray spectra, thereby ensuring accurate interpretation and a deeper understanding of interfacial interactions and electrocatalytic mechanisms, is established.

Adapting Atomic Configuration Steers Dynamic Half-Occupied State for Efficient CO2 Electroreduction to CO

Electronic structures stand at the center to essentially understand the catalytic performance and reaction mechanism of atomically dispersed transition-metal-nitrogen-carbon catalysts (ADTCs). However, under realistic electrocatalytic conditions, the dynamic electronic disturbance at metal centers originating from complicated interactions with microenvironments is commonly neglected, which makes a true structure-property correlation highly ambiguous. Here, we employ operando time-resolved X-ray absorption spectroscopy to delve deeply into dynamic electronic behaviors of a family of transition-metal centers that are observed to adaptively vary in the metal-ligand configuration during the CO2 electroreduction reaction. We identify dynamic electronic/geometric configuration and d-orbital occupation under working conditions, demonstrating an unprecedentedly precise activity descriptor, i.e., dynamic axial dz2 electron, for the CO2-to-CO conversion. Direct results validate that the half-occupied state suggests the optimum binding behaviors with intermediates, significantly promoting CO production, which has been demonstrated by a significant kinetics enhancement of 1 to 2 orders of magnitude as compared with fully occupied and unoccupied states. This work presents the first empirical demonstration for a real correlation between the dynamic electronic/geometric configuration and catalytic kinetics in ADTCs, paving a new way for modulating catalysts and designing highly efficient reaction pathways.

Defect Engineering of Metal-Based Atomically Thin Materials for Catalyzing Small-Molecule Conversion Reactions

Recently, metal-based atomically thin materials (M-ATMs) have experienced rapid development due to their large specific surface areas, abundant electrochemically accessible sites, attractive surface chemistry, and strong in-plane chemical bonds. These characteristics make them highly desirable for energy-related conversion reactions. However, the insufficient active sites and slow reaction kinetics leading to unsatisfactory electrocatalytic performance limited their commercial application. To address these issues, defect engineering of M-ATMs has emerged to increase the active sites, modify the electronic structure, and enhance the catalytic reactivity and stability. This review provides a comprehensive summary of defect engineering strategies for M-ATM nanostructures, including vacancy creation, heteroatom doping, amorphous phase/grain boundary generation, and heterointerface construction. Introducing recent advancements in the application of M-ATMs in electrochemical small molecule conversion reactions (e.g., hydrogen, oxygen, carbon dioxide, nitrogen, and sulfur), which can contribute to a circular economy by recycling molecules like H2, O2, CO2, N2, and S. Furthermore, a crucial link between the reconstruction of atomic-level structure and catalytic activity via analyzing the dynamic evolution of M-ATMs during the reaction process is established. The review also outlines the challenges and prospects associated with M-ATM-based catalysts to inspire further research efforts in developing high-performance M-ATMs.

Construction of stable Cu+/Cu0 sites at the fullerene/Cu(OH)F interface to boost the electroreduction of CO2 to C2+ products

Herein, the reduction of the Cu oxidation state during the CO2 electro-reduction reaction (CO2RR) is effectively inhibited by depositing C60 supramolecular clusters onto the Cu(OH)F surface. By utilizing the unique electronic buffering capacity of C60, a significant number of Cu0/Cu+ sites are created, leading to a remarkable faradaic efficiency of C2+ products up to 76.9% and exceptional stability.

Photocatalytic asymmetric C-C coupling for CO2 reduction on dynamically reconstructed Ruδ+-O/Ru0-O sites

Solar-driven CO2 reduction to value-added C2 chemicals is thermodynamically challenging due to multiple complicated steps. The design of active sites and structures for photocatalysts is necessary to improve solar energy efficiency. In this work, atomically dispersed Ru-O sites in RuxIn2-xO3 are constructed by interior lattice anchoring of Ru. This results in the dynamic reconstruction of Ruδ+-O/Ru0-O sites upon photoexcitation, which facilitates the CO2 activation, *CO intermediates adsorption, and C-C coupling as demonstrated by varied in situ techniques. A SiO2 core in RuxIn2-xO3/SiO2 construction further enhances the solar energy utilization and individual RuxIn2-xO3 nanocrystals dispersion for photocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction. It results in the maximum ethanol production rate up to 31.6 μmol/g/h with over 90% selectivity. DFT simulation reveals that the C2 dimer formation primarily underwent an asymmetric *CO-*CHO coupling route via a low-energy precedence ladder of *CHO. This work provides an insightful understanding of active sites with dynamic reconstruction towards asymmetric C-C coupling for CO2RR at the atomic scale.

Molecular level insights on the pulsed electrochemical CO2 reduction

Electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) occurring at the electrode/electrolyte interface is sensitive to both the potential and concentration polarization. Compared to static electrolysis at a fixed potential, pulsed electrolysis with alternating anodic and cathodic potentials is an intriguing approach that not only reconstructs the surface structure, but also regulates the local pH and mass transport from the electrolyte side in the immediate vicinity of the cathode. Herein, via a combined online mass spectrometry investigation with sub-second temporal resolution and 1-dimensional diffusion profile simulations, we reveal that heightened surface CO2 concentration promotes CO2RR over H2 evolution for both polycrystalline Ag and Cu electrodes after anodic pulses. Moreover, mild oxidative pulses generate a roughened surface topology with under-coordinated Ag or Cu sites, delivering the best CO2-to-CO and CO2-to-C2+ performance, respectively. Surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy elucidates the potential dependence of *CO and *OCHO species on Ag as well as the gradually improved *CO consumption rate over under-coordinated Cu after oxidative pulses, directly correlating apparent CO2RR selectivity with dynamic interfacial chemistry at the molecular level.

Mg-Doped Cu Catalyst for Electroreduction of CO2 to Multicarbon Products: Lewis Acid Sites Simultaneously Promote *CO Adsorption and Water Dissociation

The electroreduction of CO2 to valuable fuels or high-value chemicals by using sustainable electric energy provides a promising strategy for solving environmental problems dominated by the greenhouse effect. Copper-based materials are the only catalysts that can convert CO2 into multicarbon products, but they are plagued by high potential, low selectivity, and poor stability. The key factors to optimize the conversion of CO2 into multicarbon products are to improve the adsorption capacity of intermediates on the catalyst surface, accelerate the hydrogenation step, and improve the C-C coupling efficiency. Herein, we successfully doped Lewis acid Mg into Cu-based materials using a simple liquid-phase chemical method. In situ Raman and FT-IR tracking show that the Mg site enhances the surface coverage of the *CO intermediate, simultaneously promoting water dissociation. Under an industrial current density of 0.7 A cm-2, the FEC2+ reaches 73.9 ± 3.48% with remarkable stability. Density functional theory studies show that doping the Lewis acid Mg site increases the coverage of *CO and accelerates the splitting of water, thus promoting the C-C coupling efficiency, reducing the reaction energy barrier, and greatly improving the selectivity of C2+ products.

Dynamic Cation Enrichment during Pulsed CO2 Electrolysis and the Cation-Promoted Multicarbon Formation

Recently, pulsed electrolysis has been demonstrated as an emerging electrochemical technique that significantly promotes the performance of various electrocatalysis applications. The ionic nature of aqueous electrolytes implies a likely change in ionic distribution under these alternating potential conditions. However, despite the well-known importance of cations, the impact of pulsed electrolysis on the cation distribution remains unexplored as well as its influences on the performance. Herein, we explore the cation effects on the pulsed electrochemical CO2 reduction (p-CO2RR) using the most widely utilized alkali metal cations, including Li+, Na+, K+, and Cs+. It is discovered that the nature of cations can significantly influence the product ratio of C2+ over C1 (mostly CH4) during p-CO2RR in an order of Li+< Na+< K+< Cs+, much more profoundly than those of static cases. We report direct experimental evidence for the cation enrichment caused by pulsed electrolysis, depending on the radius of the hydrated ions. With further quasi-in situ analysis of the catalyst surface, the cation-promoted Cu dissolution-and-redeposition process was identified; this is found to alter the surface CuxO/Cu ratio during the pulsed process. We demonstrate that both the cation enrichment and the cation-adjusted surface CuxO/Cu composition impact the C2+/C1 ratio through the control of the surface-adsorbed CO population. These results reveal the presence of pulse-induced cation redistribution in emerging pulsed electrolysis techniques and provide a comprehensive understanding of alkali metal cation effects for improving the selectivity of p-CO2RR.

Advances in the Stability of Catalysts for Electroreduction of CO2 to Formic Acid

The electroreduction of CO2 to high-value products is a promising approach for achieving carbon neutrality. Among these products, formic acid stands out as having the most potential for industrialization due to its optimal economic value in terms of consumption and output. In recent years, the Faraday efficiency of formic acid from CO2 electroreduction has reached 90~100 %. However, this high selectivity cannot be maintained for extended periods under high currents to meet industrial requirements. This paper reviews excellent work from the perspective of catalyst stability, summarizing and discussing the performance of typical catalysts. Strategies for preparing stable and highly active catalysts are also briefly described. This review may offer a useful data reference and valuable guidance for the future design of long-stability catalysts.

In situ/Operando Synchrotron Radiation Analytical Techniques for CO2/CO Reduction Reaction: From Atomic Scales to Mesoscales

Electrocatalytic carbon dioxide/carbon monoxide reduction reaction (CO(2)RR) has emerged as a prospective and appealing strategy to realize carbon neutrality for manufacturing sustainable chemical products. Developing highly active electrocatalysts and stable devices has been demonstrated as effective approach to enhance the conversion efficiency of CO(2)RR. In order to rationally design electrocatalysts and devices, a comprehensive understanding of the intrinsic structure evolution within catalysts and micro-environment change around electrode interface, particularly under operation conditions, is indispensable. Synchrotron radiation has been recognized as a versatile characterization platform, garnering widespread attention owing to its high brightness, elevated flux, excellent directivity, strong polarization and exceptional stability. This review systematically introduces the applications of synchrotron radiation technologies classified by radiation sources with varying wavelengths in CO(2)RR. By virtue of in situ/operando synchrotron radiationanalytical techniques, we also summarize relevant dynamic evolution processes from electronic structure, atomic configuration, molecular adsorption, crystal lattice and devices, spanning scales from the angstrom to the micrometer. The merits and limitations of diverse synchrotron characterization techniques are summarized, and their applicable scenarios in CO(2)RR are further presented. On the basis of the state-of-the-art fourth-generation synchrotron facilities, a perspective for further deeper understanding of the CO(2)RR process using synchrotron radiation analytical techniques is proposed.

Stabilizing the oxidation state of catalysts for effective electrochemical carbon dioxide conversion

In the electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR), metal catalysts with an oxidation state generally demonstrate more favorable catalytic activity and selectivity than their corresponding metallic counterparts. However, the persistence of oxidative metal sites under reductive potentials is challenging since the transition to metallic states inevitably leads to catalytic degradation. Herein, a thorough review of research on oxidation-state stabilization in the CO2RR is presented, starting from fundamental concepts and highlighting the importance of oxidation state stabilization while revealing the relevance of dynamic oxidation states in product distribution. Subsequently, the functional mechanisms of various oxidation-state protection strategies are explained in detail, and in situ detection techniques are discussed. Finally, the prevailing and prospective challenges associated with oxidation-state protection research are discussed, identifying innovative opportunities for mechanistic insights, technology upgrades, and industrial platforms to enable the commercialization of the CO2RR.

Dynamic (Sub)surface-Oxygen Enables Highly Efficient Carbonyl-Coupling for Electrochemical Carbon Dioxide Reduction

Nowadays, high-valent Cu species (i.e., Cuδ +) are clarified to enhance multi-carbon production in electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR). Nonetheless, the inconsistent average Cu valence states are reported to significantly govern the product profile of CO2RR, which may lead to misunderstanding of the enhanced mechanism for multi-carbon production and results in ambiguous roles of high-valent Cu species. Dynamic Cuδ + during CO2RR leads to erratic valence states and challenges of high-valent species determination. Herein, an alternative descriptor of (sub)surface oxygen, the (sub)surface-oxygenated degree (κ), is proposed to quantify the active high-valent Cu species on the (sub)surface, which regulates the multi-carbon production of CO2RR. The κ validates a strong correlation to the carbonyl (*CO) coupling efficiency and is the critical factor for the multi-carbon enhancement, in which an optimized Cu2O@Pd2.31 achieves the multi-carbon partial current density of ≈330 mA cm-2 with a faradaic efficiency of 83.5%. This work shows a promising way to unveil the role of high-valent species and further achieve carbon neutralization.

Customizing catalyst surface/interface structures for electrochemical CO2 reduction

Electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) provides a promising route to converting CO2 into value-added chemicals and to neutralizing the greenhouse gas emission. For the industrial application of CO2RR, high-performance electrocatalysts featuring high activities and selectivities are essential. It has been demonstrated that customizing the catalyst surface/interface structures allows for high-precision control over the microenvironment for catalysis as well as the adsorption/desorption behaviors of key reaction intermediates in CO2RR, thereby elevating the activity, selectivity and stability of the electrocatalysts. In this paper, we review the progress in customizing the surface/interface structures for CO2RR electrocatalysts (including atomic-site catalysts, metal catalysts, and metal/oxide catalysts). From the perspectives of coordination engineering, atomic interface design, surface modification, and hetero-interface construction, we delineate the resulting specific alterations in surface/interface structures, and their effect on the CO2RR process. At the end of this review, we present a brief discussion and outlook on the current challenges and future directions for achieving high-efficiency CO2RR via surface/interface engineering.

Surface engineering for stable electrocatalysis

In recent decades, significant progress has been achieved in rational developments of electrocatalysts through constructing novel atomistic structures and modulating catalytic surface topography, realizing substantial enhancement in electrocatalytic activities. Numerous advanced catalysts were developed for electrochemical energy conversion, exhibiting low overpotential, high intrinsic activity, and selectivity. Yet, maintaining the high catalytic performance under working conditions with high polarization and vigorous microkinetics that induce intensive degradation of surface nanostructures presents a significant challenge for commercial applications. Recently, advanced operando and computational techniques have provided comprehensive mechanistic insights into the degradation of surficial functional structures. Additionally, various innovative strategies have been devised and proven effective in sustaining electrocatalytic activity under harsh operating conditions. This review aims to discuss the most recent understanding of the degradation microkinetics of catalysts across an entire range of anodic to cathodic polarizations, encompassing processes such as oxygen evolution and reduction, hydrogen reduction, and carbon dioxide reduction. Subsequently, innovative strategies adopted to stabilize the materials' structure and activity are highlighted with an in-depth discussion of the underlying rationale. Finally, we present conclusions and perspectives regarding future research and development. By identifying the research gaps, this review aims to inspire further exploration of surface degradation mechanisms and rational design of durable electrocatalysts, ultimately contributing to the large-scale utilization of electroconversion technologies.

Post transition metal substituted Keggin-type POMs as thin film chemiresistive sensors for H2O and CO2 detection

Chemiresitive sensing allows the affordable and facile detection of small molecules such as H2O and CO2. Herein, we report a novel class of Earth-abundant post transition metal substituted Keggin polyoxometalates (POMs) for chemiresistive sensing applications, with conductivities up to 0.01 S cm-1 under 100% CO2 and 65% Relative Humidity (RH).

Hollow carbon-based materials for electrocatalytic and thermocatalytic CO2 conversion

Electrocatalytic and thermocatalytic CO2 conversions provide promising routes to realize global carbon neutrality, and the development of corresponding advanced catalysts is important but challenging. Hollow-structured carbon (HSC) materials with striking features, including unique cavity structure, good permeability, large surface area, and readily functionalizable surface, are flexible platforms for designing high-performance catalysts. In this review, the topics range from the accurate design of HSC materials to specific electrocatalytic and thermocatalytic CO2 conversion applications, aiming to address the drawbacks of conventional catalysts, such as sluggish reaction kinetics, inadequate selectivity, and poor stability. Firstly, the synthetic methods of HSC, including the hard template route, soft template approach, and self-template strategy are summarized, with an evaluation of their characteristics and applicability. Subsequently, the functionalization strategies (nonmetal doping, metal single-atom anchoring, and metal nanoparticle modification) for HSC are comprehensively discussed. Lastly, the recent achievements of intriguing HSC-based materials in electrocatalytic and thermocatalytic CO2 conversion applications are presented, with a particular focus on revealing the relationship between catalyst structure and activity. We anticipate that the review can provide some ideas for designing highly active and durable catalytic systems for CO2 valorization and beyond.

Sub-1 nm Cu2O Nanosheets for the Electrochemical CO2 Reduction and Valence State-Activity Relationship

The copper-based (Cu-based) electrocatalytic materials effectively carry out the electrocatalytic carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO2RR) toward C2+ products, yet the superiority and stability of the oxidation state of Cu are still worth studying. Herein, we designed and prepared three Cu-based electrocatalysts with different oxidation states to study the valence state-activity relationship. Among these Cu-based electrocatalysts, the Cu2O nanosheets with thickness of only 0.9 nm show an extremely high C2+ Faraday efficiency (FEC2+) of ∼81%, and the FEC2+ has an increase of 37% compared with the traditional CuOx phase. The ultrathin two-dimensional (2D) nanosheet structure with abundant oxygen vacancies can stabilize the oxidation state of Cu to improve the selectivity for C2+ products in CO2RR. In situ Raman spectroscopy and density functional theory calculations demonstrate that the rich Cu+ in the ultrathin 2D Cu2O nanosheets is the most suitable oxidation state for *CO adsorption and coverage on the catalyst surface, which promotes the C-C coupling reaction in CO2RR. This work provides an excellent catalyst for CO2RR toward C2+ products.

Reversibly Adapting Configuration in Atomic Catalysts Enables Efficient Oxygen Electroreduction

Single-atom catalysts (SACs) featuring M-N-C moieties have garnered significant attention as efficient electrocatalysts for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR). However, the role of the dynamic M-N configuration of SACs induced by the derived frameworks under applied ORR potentials remains poorly understood. Herein, we conduct a comprehensive investigation using multiple operando techniques to assess the dynamic configurations of Cu SACs under various microstructural interface (MSI) regulations by anchoring atomic Cu on g-C3N4 and zeolitic imidazolate framework (ZIF) substrates. Cu SACs supported on g-C3N4 exhibit symmetric Cu-N configurations characterized by a reversibly adaptive nature under operational conditions, which leads to their excellent ORR catalytic activity. In contrast, the Cu-N configuration in ZIF-derived Cu SACs undergoes irreversible structural changes during the ORR process, in which the elongated Cu-N pair is unstable and breaks during the ORR, acting as a competing reaction against the ORR and resulting in high overpotential requirements. Crucially, operando time-resolved X-ray absorption spectroscopy (TR-XAS) and Raman results unequivocally reveal the reversibly adapting properties of the local Cu-N configuration in atomic Cu-anchored g-C3N4, which have been overlooked in numerous literatures. All findings provide valuable insights into the potential-driven characteristics of atomic electrocatalysts during target reactions and offer a systematic approach to study atomic electrocatalysts and their corresponding catalytic behaviors.

Interfacial Water Tuning by Intermolecular Spacing for Stable CO2 Electroreduction to C2+ Products

Electroreduction of CO2 to multi-carbon (C2+ ) products is a promising approach for utilization of renewable energy, in which the interfacial water quantity is critical for both the C2+ product selectivity and the stability of Cu-based electrocatalytic sites. Functionalization of long-chain alkyl molecules on a catalyst surface can help to increase its stability, while it also tends to block the transport of water, thus inhibiting the C2+ product formation. Herein, we demonstrate the fine tuning of interfacial water by surface assembly of toluene on Cu nanosheets, allowing for sustained and enriched CO2 supply but retarded water transfer to catalytic surface. Compared to bare Cu with fast cathodic corrosion and long-chain alkyl-modified Cu with main CO product, the toluene assembly on Cu nanosheet surface enabled a high Faradaic efficiency of 78 % for C2+ and a partial current density of 1.81 A cm-2 . The toluene-modified Cu catalyst further exhibited highly stable CO2 -to-C2 H4 conversion of 400 h in a membrane-electrode-assembly electrolyzer, suggesting the attractive feature for both efficient C2+ selectivity and excellent stability.

Zn-induced electron-rich Sn catalysts enable highly efficient CO2 electroreduction to formate

Renewable-energy-driven CO2 electroreduction provides a promising way to address the growing greenhouse effect issue and produce value-added chemicals. As one of the bulk chemicals, formic acid/formate has the highest revenue per mole of electrons among various products. However, the scaling up of CO2-to-formate for practical applications with high faradaic efficiency (FE) and current density is constrained by the difficulty of precisely reconciling the competing intermediates (*COOH and HCOO*). Herein, a Zn-induced electron-rich Sn electrocatalyst was reported for CO2-to-formate with high efficiency. The faradaic efficiency of formate (FEformate) could reach 96.6%, and FEformate > 90% was maintained at formate partial current density up to 625.4 mA cm-1. Detailed study indicated that catalyst reconstruction occurred during electrolysis. With appropriate electron accumulation, the electron-rich Sn catalyst could facilitate the adsorption and activation of CO2 molecules to form a intermediate and then promoted the carbon protonation of to yield a HCOO* intermediate. Afterwards, the HCOO* → HCOOH* proceeded via another proton-coupled electron transfer process, leading to high activity and selectivity for formate production.