Tetranuclear [MnIIIMn3IVO4] Complexes as Spectroscopic Models of the S2 State of the Oxygen Evolving Complex in Photosystem II

Fresh Impetus in the Chemistry of Calcium Peroxides

Redox-inactive metal ions are essential in modulating the reactivity of various oxygen-containing metal complexes and metalloenzymes, including photosystem II (PSII). The heart of this unique membrane-protein complex comprises the Mn4CaO5 cluster, in which the Ca2+ ion acts as a critical cofactor in the splitting of water in PSII. However, there is still a lack of studies involving Ca-based reactive oxygen species (ROS) systems, and the exact nature of the interaction between the Ca2+ center and ROS in PSII still generates intense debate. Here, harnessing a novel Ca-TEMPO complex supported by the β-diketiminate ligand to control the activation of O2, we report the isolation and structural characterization of hitherto elusive Ca peroxides, a homometallic Ca hydroperoxide and a heterometallic Ca/K peroxide. Our studies indicate that the presence of K+ cations is a key factor controlling the outcome of the oxygenation reaction of the model Ca-TEMPO complex. Combining experimental observations with computational investigations, we also propose a mechanistic rationalization for the reaction outcomes. The designed approach demonstrates metal-TEMPO complexes as a versatile platform for O2 activation and advances the understanding of Ca/ROS systems.

Coordination Number in High-Spin-Low-Spin Equilibrium in Cluster Models of the S2 State of the Oxygen Evolving Complex

The S2 state of the Oxygen Evolving Complex (OEC) of Photosystem II (PSII) shows high-spin (HS) and low-spin (LS) EPR signals attributed to distinct structures based on computation. Five-coordinate MnIII centers are proposed in these species but are absent in available spectroscopic model complexes. Herein, we report the synthesis, crystal structure, electrochemistry, SQUID magnetometry, and EPR spectroscopy of a MnIIIMnIV3O4 cuboidal complex featuring five-coordinate MnIII. This cluster displays a spin ground state of S = 5/2, while conversion to a six-coordinate Mn upon treatment with water results in a spin state change to S = 1/2. These results demonstrate that coordination number, without dramatic changes within the Mn4O4 core, has a substantial effect on spectroscopy.

MnIV4O4 Model of the S3 Intermediate of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex: Effect of the Dianionic Disiloxide Ligand

Synthetic complexes provide useful models to study the interplay between the structure and spectroscopy of the different Sn-state intermediates of the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) of photosystem II (PSII). Complexes containing the MnIV4 core corresponding to the S3 state, the last observable intermediate prior to dioxygen formation, remain very rare. Toward the development of synthetic strategies to stabilize highly oxidized tetranuclear complexes, ligands with increased anion charge were pursued. Herein, we report the synthesis, electrochemistry, SQUID magnetometry, and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy of a stable MnIV4O4 cuboidal complex supported by a disiloxide ligand. The substitution of an anionic acetate or amidate ligand with a dianionic disiloxide ligand shifts the reduction potential of the MnIIIMnIV3/MnIV4 redox couple by up to ∼760 mV, improving stability. The S = 3 spin ground state of the siloxide-ligated MnIV4O4 complex matches the acetate and amidate variants, in corroboration with the MnIV4 assignment of the S3 state of the OEC.

Jahn-Teller Effects in a Vanadate-Stabilized Manganese-Oxo Cubane Water Oxidation Catalyst

Heuristic rules that allow identifying the preferred mixed-valence isomers and Jahn-Teller axis arrangements in the water oxidation catalyst [(Mn4 O4 )(V4 O13 )(OAc)3 ]n- and its activated form [(Mn4 O4 )(V4 O13 )(OAc)2 (H2 O)(OH)]n- are derived. These rules are based on computing all combinatorially possible mixed-valence isomers and Jahn-Teller axis arrangements of the MnIII atoms, and associate energetic costs with some structural features, like crossings of multiple Jahn-Teller axes, the location of these axes, or the involved ligands. It is found that the different oxidation states localize on different Mn centers, giving rise to clear Jahn-Teller distortions, unlike in previous crystallographic findings where an apparent valence delocalization was found. The low barriers that connect different Jahn-Teller axis arrangements suggest that the system quickly interconverts between them, leading to the observation of averaged bond lengths in the crystal structure. We conclude that the combination of cubane-vanadate bonds that are chemically inert, cubane-acetate/water bonds that can be activated through a Jahn-Teller axis, and low activation barriers for intramolecular rearrangement of the Jahn-Teller axes plays an essential role in the reactivity of this and probably related compounds.

Electrochemical Properties and Reactivity Study of [MnV(O)(μ-OR-Lewis Acid)] Cores

A mononuclear manganese(V) oxo complex of a bis(amidate)bis(alkoxide) ligand, (NMe₄)[Mn^V(HMPAB)(O)] [2; H₄HMPAB = 1,2-bis(2-hydroxy-2-methylpropanamido)benzene], was synthesized and structurally characterized. A Mn-O_term distance of 1.566(4) Å was observed in the solid-state structure of 2, consistent with the Mn≡O formulation. The reaction of redox-inactive metal ions (Mⁿ⁺ = Li⁺, Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺, Y³⁺, and Sc³⁺) with 2 resulted in the formation of 2-Mⁿ⁺ species, which were characterized by UV-vis, ¹H NMR, cyclic voltammetry, and in situ IR spectroscopy. Theoretical calculations suggested that the alkoxide oxygen atoms of the ligand scaffold are energetically most favorable for coordinating the Mⁿ⁺ ions in 2. Complex 2 revealed one-electron-reduction potential at -0.01 V versus ferrocenium/ferrocene, which shifted anodically upon coordination of Mⁿ⁺ ions to 2, and such a shift became more prominent with stronger Lewis acids. The oxygen-atom transfer (OAT) reactivities of 2 and 2-Mⁿ⁺ species with triphenylphosphine were compared, which exhibited a systematic increase of the reaction rate with increasing Lewis acidity of Mⁿ⁺ ions, and a plot of log k₂ versus Lewis acidity of Mⁿ⁺ ions (ΔE) followed a linear relationship. It was observed that 2-Sc³⁺ was ca. 3200 times more reactive toward the OAT reaction compared to 2. Hammett analysis of 2 exhibited a V-shaped plot, indicating a change of the reaction mechanism upon going from electron-rich to electron-deficient Ar₃P substrates. In contrast, 2-Ca²⁺ and 2-Sc³⁺ showed an electrophilic nature toward the OAT reaction, thus demonstrating the role of the Lewis acid in controlling the OAT mechanism. The hydrogen-atom abstraction reaction of 2 and 2-Mⁿ⁺ adducts with 1-benzyl-1,4-dihydronicotinamide was investigated, and it was observed that the rate of reaction did not vary considerably with the Lewis acidity of Mⁿ⁺ ions. On the basis of Eyring analysis of 2 and 2-Mⁿ⁺ adducts, we hypothesized an entropy-controlled hydrogen-atom-transfer reaction for 2-Sc³⁺, which is different from the reaction mechanism of 2 and 2-Ca²⁺.

Spectral Signatures of Oxidation States in a Manganese-Oxo Cubane Water Oxidation Catalyst

We report IR and UV/Vis spectroscopic signatures that allow discriminating between the oxidation states of the manganese-based water oxidation catalyst [(Mn4 O4 )(V4 O13 )(OAc)3 ]3- . Simulated IR spectra show that V=O stretching vibrations in the 900-1000 cm-1 region shift consistently by about 20 cm-1 per oxidation equivalent. Multiple bands in the 1450-1550 cm-1 region also change systematically upon oxidation/reduction. The computed UV/Vis spectra predict that the spectral range above 350 nm is characteristic of the managanese-oxo cubane oxidation state, whereas transitions at higher energy are due to the vanadate ligand. The presence of absorption signals above 680 nm is indicative of the presence of MnIII atoms. Spectroelectrochemical measurements of the oxidation from [Mn2 III Mn2 IV ] to [Mn4 IV ] showed that the change in oxidation state can indeed be tracked by both IR and UV/Vis spectroscopy.

Activation by oxidation and ligand exchange in a molecular manganese vanadium oxide water oxidation catalyst

Despite their technological importance for water splitting, the reaction mechanisms of most water oxidation catalysts (WOCs) are poorly understood. This paper combines theoretical and experimental methods to reveal mechanistic insights into the reactivity of the highly active molecular manganese vanadium oxide WOC [Mn4V4O17(OAc)3]3- in aqueous acetonitrile solutions. Using density functional theory together with electrochemistry and IR-spectroscopy, we propose a sequential three-step activation mechanism including a one-electron oxidation of the catalyst from [Mn2 3+Mn2 4+] to [Mn3+Mn3 4+], acetate-to-water ligand exchange, and a second one-electron oxidation from [Mn3+Mn3 4+] to [Mn4 4+]. Analysis of several plausible ligand exchange pathways shows that nucleophilic attack of water molecules along the Jahn-Teller axis of the Mn3+ centers leads to significantly lower activation barriers compared with attack at Mn4+ centers. Deprotonation of one water ligand by the leaving acetate group leads to the formation of the activated species [Mn4V4O17(OAc)2(H2O)(OH)]- featuring one H2O and one OH ligand. Redox potentials based on the computed intermediates are in excellent agreement with electrochemical measurements at various solvent compositions. This intricate interplay between redox chemistry and ligand exchange controls the formation of the catalytically active species. These results provide key reactivity information essential to further study bio-inspired molecular WOCs and solid-state manganese oxide catalysts.

Biohybrid Systems for Improved Bioinspired, Energy-Relevant Catalysis

Biomimetic catalysts, ranging from small-molecule metal complexes to supramolecular assembles, possess many exciting properties that could address salient challenges in industrial-scale manufacturing. Inspired by natural enzymes, these biohybrid catalytic systems demonstrate superior characteristics, including high activity, enantioselectivity, and enhanced aqueous solubility, over their fully synthetic counterparts. However, instability and limitations in the prediction of structure-function relationships are major drawbacks that often prevent the application of biomimetic catalysts outside of the laboratory. Despite these obstacles, recent advances in synthetic enzyme models have improved our understanding of complicated biological enzymatic processes and enabled the production of catalysts with increased efficiency. This review outlines important developments and future prospects for the design and application of bioinspired and biohybrid systems at multiple length scales for important, biologically relevant, clean energy transformations.

CaMn3 IV O4 Cubane Models of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex: Spin Ground States S<9/2 and the Effect of Oxo Protonation

We report the single crystal XRD and MicroED structure, magnetic susceptibility, and EPR data of a series of CaMn₃ ^IV O₄ and YMn₃ ^IV O₄ complexes as structural and spectroscopic models of the cuboidal subunit of the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC). The effect of changes in heterometal identity, cluster geometry, and bridging oxo protonation on the spin-state structure was investigated. In contrast to previous computational models, we show that the spin ground state of CaMn₃ ^IV O₄ complexes and variants with protonated oxo moieties need not be S=9/2. Desymmetrization of the pseudo-C₃ -symmetric Ca(Y)Mn₃ ^IV O₄ core leads to a lower S=5/2 spin ground state. The magnitude of the magnetic exchange coupling is attenuated upon oxo protonation, and an S=3/2 spin ground state is observed in CaMn₃ ^IV O₃ (OH). Our studies complement the observation that the interconversion between the low-spin and high-spin forms of the S₂ state is pH-dependent, suggesting that the (de)protonation of bridging or terminal oxygen atoms in the OEC may be connected to spin-state changes.

Successes, challenges, and opportunities for quantum chemistry in understanding metalloenzymes for solar fuels research

Overview of the rich and diverse contributions of quantum chemistry to understanding the structure and function of the biological archetypes for solar fuel research, photosystem II and hydrogenases.

Ligand architecture for triangular metal complexes: a high oxidation state Ni3 cluster with proximal metal arrangement

A new multidentate tetraanionic ligand platform for supporting trinuclear transition metal clusters has been developed. Two trisphenoxide phosphinimide ligands bind three Ni centers in a triangular arrangement. The phosphinimide donors bridge in μ3 fashion and the phenoxides complete a pseudo-square planar coordination sphere around each metal center. Electrochemical studies reveal two pseudo-reversible oxidation events at notably low potentials (-0.80 V and +0.05 V). The one electron oxidized species was characterized structurally, and it is assigned as a NiIII-containing cluster.

Probing the Structure and Binding Mode of EDTA on the Surface of Mn3O4 Nanoparticles for Water Oxidation by Advanced Electron Paramagnetic Resonance Spectroscopy

Identification of the surface structure of nanoparticles is important for understanding the catalytic mechanism and improving the properties of the particles. Here, we provide a detailed description of the coordination modes of ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA) on Mn₃O₄ nanoparticles at the atomic level, as obtained by advanced electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. Binding of EDTA to Mn₃O₄ leads to dramatic changes in the EPR spectrum, with a 5-fold increase in the axial zero-field splitting parameter of Mn(II). This indicates significant changes in the coordination environment of the Mn(II) site; hence, the binding of EDTA causes a profound change in the electronic structure of the manganese site. Furthermore, the electron spin echo envelope modulation results reveal that two ¹⁴N atoms of EDTA are directly coordinated to the Mn site and a water molecule is coordinated to the surface of the nanoparticles. An Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy study shows that the Ca(II) ion is coordinated to the carboxylic ligands via the pseudobridging mode. The EPR spectroscopic results provide an atomic picture of surface-modified Mn₃O₄ nanoparticles for the first time. These results can enhance our understanding of the rational design of catalysts, for example, for the water oxidation reaction.

Molecular Identification of a High-Spin Deprotonated Intermediate during the S2 to S3 Transition of Nature's Water-Oxidizing Complex

The identity of a key intermediate in the S₂ to S₃ transition of nature's water-oxidizing complex (WOC) in Photosystem 2 is presented. Broken-symmetry density functional theory (BS-DFT) calculations and Heisenberg-Dirac-van Vleck (HDvV) spin ladder calculations show that an S₂ state open cubane model of the WOC containing a μ-hydroxo O4 changes from an S = ⁵/₂ form to an S = ⁷/₂, form upon deprotonation of W1. Combined with X-band electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectral analysis, this indicates that the g = 4.1 EPR signal corresponds to an S = ⁵/₂ form of the WOC with W1 present as a water ligand to Mn₄, while the g = 4.8/4.9 form observed at high pH values corresponds to an S = ⁷/₂ form, with W1 as a hydroxo ligand. The latter is also likely to represent the form needed to progress to S₃ in the functioning enzyme.

S = 3 Ground State for a Tetranuclear MnIV4O4 Complex Mimicking the S3 State of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex

The S₃ state is currently the last observable intermediate prior to O-O bond formation at the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) of Photosystem II, and its electronic structure has been assigned to a homovalent Mn^IV₄ core with an S = 3 ground state. While structural interpretations based on the EPR spectroscopic features of the S₃ state provide valuable mechanistic insight, corresponding synthetic and spectroscopic studies on tetranuclear complexes mirroring the Mn oxidation states of the S₃ state remain rare. Herein, we report the synthesis and characterization by XAS and multifrequency EPR spectroscopy of a Mn^IV₄O₄ cuboidal complex as a spectroscopic model of the S₃ state. Results show that this Mn^IV₄O₄ complex has an S = 3 ground state with isotropic ⁵⁵Mn hyperfine coupling constants of -75, -88, -91, and 66 MHz. These parameters are consistent with an αααβ spin topology approaching the trimer-monomer magnetic coupling model of pseudo-octahedral Mn^IV centers. Importantly, the spin ground state changes from S = 1/2 to S = 3 as the OEC is oxidized from the S₂ state to the S₃ state. This same spin state change is observed following oxidation of the previously reported Mn^IIIMn^IV₃O₄ cuboidal complex to the Mn^IV₄O₄ complex described here. This sets a synthetic precedent for the observed low-spin to high-spin conversion in the OEC.

Remote Ligand Modifications Tune Electronic Distribution and Reactivity in Site-Differentiated, High-Spin Iron Clusters: Flipping Scaling Relationships

We report the synthesis, characterization, and reactivity of [LFe₃O(^RArIm)₃Fe][OTf]₂, the first Hammett series of a site-differentiated cluster. The cluster reduction potentials and CO stretching frequencies shift as expected on the basis of the electronic properties of the ligand: electron-donating substituents result in more reducing clusters and weaker C-O bonds. However, unusual trends in the energetics of their two sequential CO binding events with the substituent σ_p parameters are observed. Specifically, introduction of electron-donating substituents suppresses the first CO binding event (ΔΔH by as much as 7.9 kcal mol^-1) but enhances the second (ΔΔH by as much as 1.9 kcal mol^-1). X-ray crystallography, including multiple-wavelength anomalous diffraction, Mössbauer spectroscopy, and SQUID magnetometry, reveal that these substituent effects result from changes in the energetic penalty associated with electronic redistribution within the cluster, which occurs during the CO binding event.

Molecular Vibrations of an Oxygen-Evolving Complex and Its Synthetic Mimic

Bio-inspired catalysis for artificial photosynthesis has been widely studied for decades, in particular, with the purpose of using bio-disposable and non-toxic metals as building blocks. The characterisation of such catalysts has been achieved by using different kinds of spectroscopic methods, from X-ray crystallography to NMR spectroscopy. An artificial Mn₄ CaO₄ cubane cluster with dangling Mn₄ was synthesised in 2015 [Zhang et al. Science 2015, 348, 690-693]; this cluster showed many structural similarities to that of the natural oxygen-evolving complex. An accurate structural and spectroscopic comparison between the natural and artificial systems is highly relevant to understand the catalytic mechanism. Among data from different techniques, the differential FTIR spectra (S_n+1 -S_n ) of photosystem II are still lacking a complete interpretation. The availability of IR data of the artificial cluster offers a unique opportunity to assign absolute absorption spectra on a well-defined and easier to interpret analogous moiety. The present work aims to investigate the novel inorganic compound as a model system for an oxygen-evolving complex through measurement of its spectroscopic properties. The experimental results are compared with calculations by using a variety of theoretical methods (normal mode analysis, effective normal mode analysis) in the S₁ state. We underline the similarities and the differences in the computational spectra based on atomistic models of Mn₄ CaO₅ and Mn₄ CaO₄ complexes.

Redox Tuning via Ligand-Induced Geometric Distortions at a YMn3O4 Cubane Model of the Biological Oxygen Evolving Complex

The function of proteins involved in electron transfer is dependent on cofactors attaining the necessary reduction potentials. We establish a mode of cluster redox tuning through steric pressure on a synthetic model related to Photosystem II. Resembling the cuboidal [CaMn₃O₄] subsite of the biological oxygen evolving complex (OEC), [Mn₄O₄] and [YMn₃O₄] complexes featuring ligands of different basicity and chelating properties were characterized by cyclic voltammetry. In the absence of ligand-induced distortions, increasing the basicity of the ligands results in a decrease of cluster reduction potential. Contraction of Y-oxo/Y–Mn distances by 0.1/0.15 Å enforced by a chelating ligand results in an increase of cluster reduction potential even in the presence of strongly basic donors. Related protein-induced changes in Ca-oxo/Ca–Mn distances may have similar effects in tuning the redox potential of the OEC through entatic states and may explain the cation size dependence on the progression of the S-state cycle.

The redox properties of [YMn₃O₄] and [Mn₄O₄] complexes featuring bridging ligands of different basicity and chelating properties are reported. In the absence of ligand-induced geometric distortions, increasing the basicity of the ligands results in a decrease of cluster reduction potential. A chelating ligand results in contractions of Y-oxo distances by ∼0.1 Å, which correlates with an increase of cluster reduction potential even in the presence of strongly basic donors.

Artificial Mn4 Ca Clusters with Exchangeable Solvent Molecules Mimicking the Oxygen-Evolving Center in Photosynthesis

The natural Mn₄ Ca cluster in photosystem II serves as a blueprint to develop artificial water-splitting catalysts for the generation of solar fuel in artificial photosynthesis. Although significant advances have recently been achieved, it remains a great challenge to prepare robust artificial Mn₄ Ca clusters that precisely mimic the structure and function of the biological catalyst. Herein, we report the isolation and structural characterization of two Mn₄ CaO₄ complexes with polar solvent molecules, acetonitrile or N,N-dimethylformamide, which closely mimics the two water molecules on the calcium ion, as well as the oxidation states of the four manganese ions and the main geometric structure of the natural Mn₄ Ca cluster. These new artificial Mn₄ Ca complexes provide important chemical clues to understand the structure and mechanism of the biological system.

The effect of the orientation of the Jahn–Teller distortion on the magnetic interactions of trinuclear mixed-valence Mn(ii)/Mn(iii) complexes

The effect of the orientation of the Jahn–Teller distortion on the magnetic interactions in two new mixed-valence trinuclear Mn(iii)–Mn(ii)–Mn(iii) complexes has been investigated.

Oxo-bridged trinuclear and tetranuclear manganese complexes supported with nitrogen donor ligands: syntheses, structures and properties

This work illustrates syntheses, structures, redox and magnetic properties as well as catalase activities of rare μ₃-oxo bridged mixed-valent trinuclear Mn^IIMn^III complexes (1 and 2) and a μ₄-oxo bridged tetranuclear MnII4 complex (3) supported with nitrogen donor ligands.