Investigation of Charge-State-Dependent Compaction of Protein Ions with Native Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometry and Theory

Top-down mass spectrometry of native proteoforms and their complexes: a community study

The combination of native electrospray ionization with top-down fragmentation in mass spectrometry (MS) allows simultaneous determination of the stoichiometry of noncovalent complexes and identification of their component proteoforms and cofactors. Although this approach is powerful, both native MS and top-down MS are not yet well standardized, and only a limited number of laboratories regularly carry out this type of research. To address this challenge, the Consortium for Top-Down Proteomics initiated a study to develop and test protocols for native MS combined with top-down fragmentation of proteins and protein complexes across 11 instruments in nine laboratories. Here we report the summary of the outcomes to provide robust benchmarks and a valuable entry point for the scientific community.

Perspective: The complex relationship between charge, mobility, and gas-phase protein structure

Ion mobility spectrometry coupled to mass spectrometry (IMS/MS) is a widely used tool for biomolecular separations and structural elucidation. The application of IMS/MS has resulted in exciting developments in structural proteomics and genomics. This perspective gives a brief background of the field, addresses some of the important issues in making structural measurements, and introduces complementary techniques.

Effects of charge on protein ion structure: Lessons from cation-to-anion, proton-transfer reactions

Collision cross-section values, which can be determined using ion mobility experiments, are sensitive to the structures of protein ions and useful for applications to structural biology and biophysics. Protein ions with different charge states can exhibit very different collision cross-section values, but a comprehensive understanding of this relationship remains elusive. Here, we review cation-to-anion, proton-transfer reactions (CAPTR), a method for generating a series of charge-reduced protein cations by reacting quadrupole-selected cations with even-electron monoanions. The resulting CAPTR products are analyzed using a combination of ion mobility, mass spectrometry, and collisional activation. We compare CAPTR to other charge-manipulation strategies and review the results of various CAPTR-based experiments, exploring their contribution to a deeper understanding of the relationship between protein ion structure and charge state.

Collision-Induced Unfolding Reveals Disease-Associated Stability Shifts in Mitochondrial Transfer Ribonucleic Acids

Ribonucleic acids (RNAs) remain challenging targets for structural biology, creating barriers to understanding their vast functions in cellular biology and fully realizing their applications in biotechnology. The inherent dynamism of RNAs creates numerous obstacles in capturing their biologically relevant higher-order structures (HOSs), and as a result, many RNA functions remain unknown. In this study, we describe the development of native ion mobility-mass spectrometry and collision-induced unfolding (CIU) for the structural characterization of a variety of RNAs. We evaluate the ability of these techniques to preserve native structural features in the gas phase across a wide range of functional RNAs. Finally, we apply these tools to study the elusive mitochondrial encephalopathy, lactic acidosis, and stroke-like episodes-associated A3243G mutation. Our data demonstrate that our experimentally determined conditions preserve some solution-state memory of RNAs via the correlated complexity of CIU fingerprints and RNA HOS, the observation of predicted stability shifts in the control RNA samples, and the retention of predicted magnesium binding events in gas-phase RNA ions. Significant differences in collision cross section and stability are observed as a function of the A3243G mutation across a subset of the mitochondrial tRNA maturation pathway. We conclude by discussing the potential application of CIU for the development of RNA-based biotherapeutics and, more broadly, transcriptomic characterization.

Elucidating Structures of Protein Complexes by Collision-Induced Dissociation at Elevated Gas Pressures

Ion activation methods carried out at gas pressures compatible with ion mobility separations are not yet widely established. This limits the analytical utility of emerging tandem-ion mobility spectrometers that conduct multiple ion mobility separations in series. The present work investigates the applicability of collision-induced dissociation (CID) at 1 to 3 mbar in a tandem-trapped ion mobility spectrometer (tandem-TIMS) to study the architecture of protein complexes. We show that CID of the homotetrameric protein complexes streptavidin (53 kDa), neutravidin (60 kDa), and concanavalin A (110 kDa) provides access to all subunits of the investigated protein complexes, including structurally informative dimers. We report on an "atypical" dissociation pathway, which for concanavalin A proceeds via symmetric partitioning of the precursor charges and produces dimers with the same charge states that were previously reported from surface induced dissociation. Our data suggest a correlation between the formation of subunits by CID in tandem-TIMS/MS, their binding strengths in the native tetramer structures, and the applied activation voltage. Ion mobility spectra of in situ-generated subunits reveal a marked structural heterogeneity inconsistent with annealing into their most stable gas phase structures. Structural transitions are observed for in situ-generated subunits that resemble the transitions reported from collision-induced unfolding of natively folded proteins. These observations indicate that some aspects of the native precursor structure is preserved in the subunits generated from disassembly of the precursor complex. We rationalize our observations by an approximately 100-fold shorter activation time scale in comparison to traditional CID in a collision cell. Finally, the approach discussed here to conduct CID at elevated pressures appears generally applicable also for other types of tandem-ion mobility spectrometers.

Eye lens β-crystallins are predicted by native ion mobility-mass spectrometry and computations to form compact higher-ordered heterooligomers

Eye lens α- and β-/γ-crystallin proteins are not replaced after fiber cell denucleation and maintain lens transparency and refractive properties. The exceptionally high (∼400-500 mg/mL) concentration of crystallins in mature lens tissue and multiple other factors impede precise characterization of β-crystallin interactions, oligomer composition, size, and topology. Native ion mobility-mass spectrometry is used here to probe β-crystallin association and provide insight into homo- and heterooligomerization kinetics for these proteins. These experiments include separation and characterization of higher-order β-crystallin oligomers and illustrate the unique advantages of native IM-MS. Recombinantly expressed βB1, βB2, and βA3 isoforms are found to have different homodimerization propensities, and only βA3 forms larger homooligomers. Heterodimerization of βB2 with βA3 occurs ∼3 times as fast as that of βB1 with βA3, and βB1 and βB2 heterodimerize less readily. Ion mobility experiments, molecular dynamics simulations, and PISA analysis together reveal that observed oligomers are consistent with predominantly compact, ring-like topologies.

Top-down mass spectrometry of native proteoforms and their complexes: A community study

The combination of native electrospray ionisation with top-down fragmentation in mass spectrometry allows simultaneous determination of the stoichiometry of noncovalent complexes and identification of their component proteoforms and co-factors. While this approach is powerful, both native mass spectrometry and top-down mass spectrometry are not yet well standardised, and only a limited number of laboratories regularly carry out this type of research. To address this challenge, the Consortium for Top-Down Proteomics (CTDP) initiated a study to develop and test protocols for native mass spectrometry combined with top-down fragmentation of proteins and protein complexes across eleven instruments in nine laboratories. The outcomes are summarised in this report to provide robust benchmarks and a valuable entry point for the scientific community.

The Role of Ion Rotation in Ion Mobility: Ultrahigh-Precision Prediction of Ion Mobility Dependence on Ion Mass Distribution and Translational to Rotational Energy Transfer

The role of ion rotation in determining ion mobilities is explored using the subtle gas phase ion mobility shifts based on differences in ion mass distributions between isotopomer ions that have been observed with ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) measurements. These mobility shifts become apparent for IMS resolving powers on the order of ∼1500 where relative mobilities (or alternatively momentum transfer collision cross sections; Ω) can be measured with a precision of ∼10 ppm. The isotopomer ions have identical structures and masses, differing only in their internal mass distributions, and their Ω differences cannot be predicted by widely used computational approaches, which ignore the dependence of Ω on the ion's rotational properties. Here, we investigate the rotational dependence of Ω, which includes changes to its collision frequency due to thermal rotation as well as the coupling of translational to rotational energy transfer. We show that differences in rotational energy transfer during ion-molecule collisions provide the major contribution to isotopomer ion separations, with only a minor contribution due to an increase in collision frequency due to ion rotation. Modeling including these factors allowed for differences in Ω to be calculated that precisely mirror the experimental separations. These findings also highlight the promise of pairing high-resolution IMS measurements with theory and computation for improved elucidation of subtle structural differences between ions.

Structure Relaxation Approximation (SRA) for Elucidation of Protein Structures from Ion Mobility Measurements (II). Protein Complexes

Characterizing structures of protein complexes and their disease-related aberrations is essential to understanding molecular mechanisms of many biological processes. Electrospray ionization coupled with hybrid ion mobility/mass spectrometry (ESI-IM/MS) methods offer sufficient sensitivity, sample throughput, and dynamic range to enable systematic structural characterization of proteomes. However, because ESI-IM/MS characterizes ionized protein systems in the gas phase, it generally remains unclear to what extent the protein ions characterized by IM/MS have retained their solution structures. Here, we discuss the first application of our computational structure relaxation approximation [Bleiholder, C.; et al. J. Phys. Chem. B 2019, 123 (13), 2756-2769] to assign structures of protein complexes in the range from ∼16 to ∼60 kDa from their "native" IM/MS spectra. Our analysis shows that the computed IM/MS spectra agree with the experimental spectra within the errors of the methods. The structure relaxation approximation (SRA) indicates that native backbone contacts appear largely retained in the absence of solvent for the investigated protein complexes and charge states. Native contacts between polypeptide chains of the protein complex appear to be retained to a comparable extent as contacts within a folded polypeptide chain. Our computations also indicate that the hallmark "compaction" often observed for protein systems in native IM/MS measurements appears to be a poor indicator of the extent to which native residue-residue interactions are lost in the absence of solvent. Further, the SRA indicates that structural reorganization of the protein systems in IM/MS measurements appears driven largely by remodeling of the protein surface that increases its hydrophobic content by approximately 10%. For the systems studied here, this remodeling of the protein surface appears to occur mainly by structural reorganization of surface-associated hydrophilic amino acid residues not associated with β-strand secondary structure elements. Properties related to the internal protein structure, as assessed by void volume or packing density, appear unaffected by remodeling of the surface. Taken together, the structural reorganization of the protein surface appears to be generic in nature and to sufficiently stabilize protein structures to render them metastable on the time scale of IM/MS measurements.

Using Density Functional Theory for Testing the Robustness of Mobile-Proton Molecular Dynamics Simulations on Electrosprayed Ions: Structural Implications for Gaseous Proteins

Current experiments only provide low-resolution information on gaseous protein ions generated by electrospray ionization (ESI). Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations can yield complementary insights. Unfortunately, conventional MD does not capture the mobile nature of protons in gaseous proteins. Mobile-proton MD (MPMD) overcomes this limitation. Earlier MPMD data at 300 K indicated that protein ions generated by "native" ESI retain solution-like structures with a hydrophobic core and zwitterionic exterior [Bakhtiari, M.; Konermann, L. J. Phys. Chem. B 2019, 123, 1784-1796]. MPMD redistributes protons using electrostatic and proton affinity calculations. The robustness of this approach has never been scrutinized. Here, we close this gap by benchmarking MPMD against density functional theory (DFT) at the B3LYP/6-31G* level, which is well suited for predicting proton affinities. The computational cost of DFT necessitated the use of small peptides. The MPMD energetic ranking of proton configurations was found to be consistent with DFT single-point energies, implying that MPMD can reliably identify favorable protonation sites. Peptide MPMD runs converged to DFT-optimized structures only when applying 300-500 K temperature cycling, which was necessary to prevent trapping in local minima. Temperature cycling MPMD was then applied to gaseous protein ions. Native ubiquitin converted to slightly expanded structures with a zwitterionic core and a nonpolar exterior. Our data suggest that such inside-out protein structures are intrinsically preferred in the gas phase, and that they form in ESI experiments after moderate collisional excitation. This is in contrast to native ESI (with minimal collisional excitation, simulated by MPMD at 300 K), where kinetic trapping promotes the survival of solution-like structures. In summary, this work validates the MPMD approach for simulations on gaseous peptides and proteins.

Ion mobility mass spectrometry and molecular dynamics simulations unravel the conformational stability of zinc metallothionein-2 species

Ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) unraveled different conformational stability in Zn4-7-metallothionein-2. We introduced a new molecular dynamics simulation approach that permitted the exploration of all of the conformational space confirming the experimental data, and revealed that not only the Zn-S bonds but also the α-β domain interactions modulate protein unfolding.

Diserinol Isophthalamide: A Novel Reagent for Complexation with Biomolecular Anions in Electrospray Ionization Mass Spectrometry

Transferring biomolecules from solution to vacuum facilitates a detailed analysis of molecular structure and dynamics by isolating molecules of interest from a complex environment. However, inherent in the ion desolvation process is the loss of solvent hydrogen bonding partners, which are critical for the stability of a condensed-phase structure. Thus, transfer of ions to vacuum can favor structural rearrangement, especially near solvent-accessible charge sites, which tend to adopt intramolecular hydrogen bonding motifs in the absence of solvent. Complexation of monoalkylammonium moieties (e.g., lysine side chains) with crown ethers such as 18-crown-6 can disfavor structural rearrangement of protonated sites, but no equivalent ligand has been investigated for deprotonated groups. Herein we describe diserinol isophthalamide (DIP), a novel reagent for the gas-phase complexation of anionic moieties within biomolecules. Complexation is observed to the C-terminus or side chains of the small model peptides GD, GE, GG, DF-OMe, VYV, YGGFL, and EYMPME in electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) studies. In addition, complexation is observed with the phosphate and carboxylate moieities of phosphoserine and phosphotyrosine. DIP performs favorably in comparison to an existing anion recognition reagent, 1,1'-(1,2-phenylene)bis(3-phenylurea), that exhibits moderate carboxylate binding in organic solvent. This improved performance in ESI-MS experiments is attributed to reduced steric constraints to complexation with carboxylate groups of larger molecules. Overall, diserinol isophthalamide is an effective complexation reagent that can be applied in future work to study retention of solution-phase structure, investigate intrinsic molecular properties, and examine solvation effects.

Ultraviolet Photodissociation Reveals the Molecular Mechanism of Crown Ether Microsolvation Effect on the Gas-Phase Native-like Protein Structure

Maintaining the protein high-order structures and interactions during the transition from aqueous solution to gas phase is essential to the structural analysis of native mass spectrometry (nMS). Herein, we systematically interrogate the effects of charge state and crown ether (CE) complexation on the gas-phase native-like protein structure by integrating nMS with 193 nm ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD). The alterations of photofragmentation yields of protein residues and the charge site distribution of fragment ions reveal the specific sites and sequence regions where charge and CE take effect. Our results exhibit the CE complexation on protonated residues can largely alleviate the structure disruption induced by the intramolecular solvation of charged side chains. The influences of CE complexation and positive charge on gas-phase protein structure exhibit generally opposite trends because the CE microsolvation avoids the hydrogen-bonding formation between the charged side chains with backbone carbonyls. Thus, CE complexation leads to a more stable and native-like protein structure in the gas phase.

Gas-Phase Unfolding of Protein Complexes Distinguishes Conformational Isomers

Proteins can adopt different conformational states that are important for their biological function and, in some cases, can be responsible for their dysfunction. The essential roles that proteins play in biological systems make distinguishing the structural differences between these conformational states both fundamentally and practically important. Here, we demonstrate that collision-induced unfolding (CIU), in combination with ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) measurements, distinguish subtly different conformational states for protein complexes. Using the open and closed states of the β-lactoglobulin (βLG) dimer as a model, we show that these two conformational isomers unfold during collisional activation to generate distinct states that are readily separated by IM-MS. Extensive molecular modeling of the CIU process reproduces the distinct unfolding intermediates and identifies the molecular details that explain why the two conformational states unfold in distinct ways. Strikingly, the open conformational state forms new electrostatic interactions upon collisional heating, while the closed state does not. These newly formed electrostatic interactions involve residues on the loop differentially positioned in the two βLG conformational isomers, highlighting that gas-phase unfolding pathways reflect aspects of solution structure. This combination of experiment and theory provides a path forward for distinguishing subtly different conformational isomers for protein complexes via gas-phase unfolding experiments. Our results also have implications for understanding how protein complexes dissociate in the gas phase, indicating that current models need to be refined to explain protein complex dissociation.

Stability and conformational memory of electrosprayed and rehydrated bacteriophage MS2 virus coat proteins

Proteins are innately dynamic, which is important for their functions, but which also poses significant challenges when studying their structures. Gas-phase techniques can utilise separation and a range of sample manipulations to transcend some of the limitations of conventional techniques for structural biology in crystalline or solution phase, and isolate different states for separate interrogation. However, the transfer from solution to the gas phase risks affecting the structures, and it is unclear to what extent different conformations remain distinct in the gas phase, and if resolution in silico can recover the native conformations and their differences. Here, we use extensive molecular dynamics simulations to study the two distinct conformations of dimeric capsid protein of the MS2 bacteriophage. The protein undergoes notable restructuring of its peripheral parts in the gas phase, but subsequent simulation in solvent largely recovers the native structure. Our results suggest that despite some structural loss due to the experimental conditions, gas-phase structural biology techniques provide meaningful data that inform not only about the structures but also conformational dynamics of proteins.

•

Presented extensive molecular dynamics (MD) simulation data investigating protein vacuum exposure and rehydration dynamics.

•

Demonstrated that the majority of the protein structure recovers their initial solution conformation after vacuum exposure.

•

Explored the potential gain for structural biology of using MD simulation to refine gas-phase determined protein structures.

Native mass spectrometry for the investigation of protein structural (dis)order

A central challenge in structural biology is represented by dynamic and heterogeneous systems, as typically represented by proteins in solution, with the extreme case of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) [1-3]. These proteins lack a specific three-dimensional structure and have poorly organized secondary structure. For these reasons, they escape structural characterization by conventional biophysical methods. The investigation of these systems requires description of conformational ensembles, rather than of unique, defined structures or bundles of largely superimposable structures. Mass spectrometry (MS) has become a central tool in this field, offering a variety of complementary approaches to generate structural information on either folded or disordered proteins [4-6]. Two main categories of methods can be recognized. On one side, conformation-dependent reactions (such as cross-linking, covalent labeling, H/D exchange) are exploited to label molecules in solution, followed by the characterization of the labeling products by denaturing MS [7-11]. On the other side, non-denaturing ("native") MS can be used to directly explore the different conformational components in terms of geometry and structural compactness [12-16]. All these approaches have in common the capability to conjugate protein structure investigation with the peculiar analytical power of MS measurements, offering the possibility of assessing species distributions for folding and binding equilibria and the combination of both. These methods can be combined with characterization of noncovalent complexes [17, 18] and post-translational modifications [19-23]. This review focuses on the application of native MS to protein structure and dynamics investigation, with a general methodological section, followed by examples on specific proteins from our laboratory.

Protein shape sampled by ion mobility mass spectrometry consistently improves protein structure prediction

Ion mobility (IM) mass spectrometry provides structural information about protein shape and size in the form of an orientationally-averaged collision cross-section (CCS_IM). While IM data have been used with various computational methods, they have not yet been utilized to predict monomeric protein structure from sequence. Here, we show that IM data can significantly improve protein structure determination using the modelling suite Rosetta. We develop the Rosetta Projection Approximation using Rough Circular Shapes (PARCS) algorithm that allows for fast and accurate prediction of CCS_IM from structure. Following successful testing of the PARCS algorithm, we use an integrative modelling approach to utilize IM data for protein structure prediction. Additionally, we propose a confidence metric that identifies near native models in the absence of a known structure. The results of this study demonstrate the ability of IM data to consistently improve protein structure prediction.

Collision cross sections (CCS) from ion mobility mass spectrometry provide information about protein shape and size. Here, the authors develop an algorithm to predict CCS and integrate experimental ion mobility data into Rosetta-based molecular modelling to predict protein structures from sequence.

Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometry Reveals the Structures and Stabilities of Biotherapeutic Antibody Aggregates

Stability is a key critical quality attribute monitored throughout the development of monoclonal antibody (mAb) therapeutics. Minor changes in their higher order structure (HOS) caused by stress or environment may alter mAb aggregation, immunogenicity, and efficacy. In addition, the structures of the resulting mAb aggregates are largely unknown, as are their dependencies on conditions under which they are created. In this report, we investigate the HOS of mAb monomers and dimers under a variety of forced degradation conditions with ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) and collision-induced unfolding (CIU) technologies. We evaluate two model IgG1 antibodies that differ significantly only in their complementarity-determinant regions: IgG1α and IgG1β. Our data covering both heat- and pH-based forced degradation conditions, aquired on two different IM-MS platforms, show that these mAbs undergo global HOS changes at both monomer and dimer levels upon degradation, but shifts in collision cross section (CCS) differ under pH or heat degradation conditions. In addition, the level of CCS change detected is different between IgG1α and IgG1β, suggesting that differences in the CDR drive differential responses to degradation that influence the antibody HOS. Dramatically different CIU fingerprints are obtained for IgG1α and IgG1β monomers and dimers for both degradation conditions. Finally, we constructed a series of computational models of mAb dimers for comparison with experimental CCS values and found evidence for a compact, overlapped dimer structure under native and heat degradation conditions, possibly adopting an inverted or nonoverlapped quaternary structure when produced through pH degredation. We conclude by discussing the potential impact of our findings on ongoing biotherapeutic discovery and development efforts.