Biophysical properties of membrane-active peptides based on micelle modeling: a case study of cell-penetrating and antimicrobial peptides

Effect of a monovalent salt on the energetics of an antimicrobial-peptide: micelle dissociation

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are promising antimicrobial and therapeutic agents. Recently, we synthesized a cationic 14 residue AMP (LL-14: LKWLKKLLKWLKKL), which showed high broad-spectrum antimicrobial activity. However, the antimicrobial activity of LL-14 was compromised in the presence of NaCl. Salt sensitivity of antimicrobial potency is one of the fundamental limitations of AMP therapeutics. Thus, understanding the thermodynamics of AMP binding to simple membrane-mimetic systems and the effect of NaCl that contributes to their stability is crucial for designing promising AMPs against microbial infection. In this work, we reported computational analysis of LL-14 binding to SDS micelles (the simplest bacterial membrane mimic) at various NaCl concentrations (0.0%, 0.5%, 1.0% w/v). The thermodynamics of LL-14 dissociation from the SDS micelles was estimated by employing steered molecular dynamics (SMD) simulation followed by umbrella sampling. The results indicated that the increase in NaCl concentration systematically disfavoured the LL-14:SDS binding, primarily by stabilizing the dissociative state (i.e., free LL-14 and free micelles in water). We proposed a kinetic scheme in which the salt-induced selective stabilization of the dissociative state increased the activation barrier for the peptide:micelle binding event resulting in reduced affinity. Center-of-mass pulling indicated that the interactions involving the N-terminal of the LL-14 (residues 1-6) and SDS micelle were crucial for the stability of the LL-14:SDS complex, and LL-14 underwent a conformational change (helix → unstructured) before dissociating from the SDS micelle. The observed structural features from the peptide:micelle dissociation pathway corroborate our previous simulations as well as circular dichroism (CD), and fluorescence experiments.

Effect of Leu/Val Mutation on the Energetics of Antimicrobial Peptide:Micelle Binding

Recently, we had reported a synthetic positively charged leucine-rich 14-residue-long antimicrobial peptide (AMP, LL-14: NH₃⁺-LKWLKKLLKWLKKL-CONH₂), which was highly active and cytotoxic relative to its valine analogue (VV-14). However, the thermodynamics underlying this differential toxicity and antimicrobial activity was unclear. Understanding the energetics of peptide binding to micelles (simplest membrane mimic, viz., SDS as a bacterial membrane and DPC as a eukaryotic membrane) and the effect of Leu → Val peptide mutations on the stability of the peptide:micelle complexes are of great academic interest and relevant for the rational design of potent and selective AMPs for therapeutic use. Here, we have reported the molecular dynamics free energy simulations that allowed us to quantitatively estimate the strength of peptide discrimination (based on single- or multiple-site Leu/Val mutations in LL-14) by membrane mimetic micelles (SDS and DPC) and decipher the energetics underlying peptide selectivity by micelles. The Leu-containing peptide (LL-14) was found to be preferred for micelle (SDS and DPC) binding relative to its Val analogues (single or multiple Val mutants). The strength of the preference depended on the position of the Leu/Val mutation in the peptide. Surprisingly, the N-terminal LL-14 single mutation (Leu → Val: L1V) was found to fine-tune the electrostatic interactions, resulting in the highest peptide selectivity (ΔΔG ∼ 8 kcal/mol for both SDS and DPC). However, the mechanism of L1V peptide selectivity was distinctly different for SDS and DPC micelles. SDS ensured high selectivity by disrupting the peptide:micelle salt bridge, whereas DPC desolvated the broken-peptide-backbone hydrogen bond in the V1 peptide:micelle complex. Mutations (Leu → Val) in the middle positions of the LL-14 (4th, 7th, 8th, and 11th) were disfavored by the micelles primarily due to the loss of peptide:micelle hydrophobic interactions. Peptides differing at the C-terminal (i.e., L14V) were recognized by SDS micelles (ΔΔG ∼ 4 kcal/mol) by altering peptide:micelle interactions. L14V mutation, on the other hand, did not play any role in the peptide:DPC binding, as no direct interactions between the C-terminal and DPC micelle were observed due to obvious electrostatic reasons. The strength of selectivity favoring LL-14 binding against VV-14 was found to be much higher for DPC micelles (ΔΔG ∼ 25 kcal/mol) relative to SDS micelles (ΔΔG ∼ 19 kcal/mol). The loss of the peptide:micelle hydrophobic contact in response to LL-14 → VV-14 mutation was found to be significantly larger for DPC relative to SDS micelles, resulting in higher discriminatory power for the former. Peptide:SDS salt bridges seemed to prevent the loss of peptide:micelle hydrophobic contact to some extent, leading to weaker selectivity for SDS micelles. High selectivity of DPC micelles provided an efficient mechanism for VV-14 dissociation from DPC micelles, whereas low-selectivity of SDS micelles ensured binding of both LL-14 and VV-14. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study in which the experimental observations (antimicrobial activity and toxicity) between leucine-rich and valine-rich peptides have been explained by establishing a direct link between the energetics and structures.

Delineating the Mechanism of Action of a Protease Resistant and Salt Tolerant Synthetic Antimicrobial Peptide against Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Rapidly growing antimicrobial resistance (AMR) against antibiotics has propelled the development of synthetic antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) as potential antimicrobial agents. An antimicrobial peptide Nle-Dab-Trp-Nle-Dab-Dab-Nle-CONH₂ (P36; Nle = norleucine, Dab = diaminobutyric acid, Trp = tryptophan) potent against Pseudomonas aeruginosa (P. aeruginosa) has been developed in the present study. Rational design strategy adopted in this study led to the improvisation of the therapeutic qualities such as activity, salt tolerance, cytotoxicity, and protease resistance of the template peptide P4, which was earlier reported from our group. P36 exhibited salt tolerant antimicrobial potency against P. aeruginosa, along with very low cytotoxicity against mammalian cell lines. P36 was found to be nonhemolytic and resistant toward protease degradation which qualified it as a potent antimicrobial agent. We have investigated the mechanism of action of this molecule in detail using several experimental techniques (spectroscopic, biophysical, and microscopic) and molecular dynamics simulations. P36 was a membrane active AMP with membrane destabilization and deformation abilities, leading to leakage of the intracellular materials and causing eventual cell death. The interaction between P36 and the microbial membrane/membrane mimics was primarily driven by electrostatics. P36 was unstructured in water and upon binding to the microbial membrane mimic SDS, suggesting no influence of secondary structure on its antimicrobial potency. Positive charge, optimum hydrophobic-hydrophilic balance, and chain length remained the most important concerns to be addressed while designing small cationic antimicrobial peptides.

Effect of monovalent salt concentration and peptide secondary structure in peptide-micelle binding

Recently, we reported a cationic 14 residue peptide LL-14 (LKWLKKLLKWLKKL) with salt-sensitive broad-spectrum antimicrobial potency. However, the mechanism of its salt (NaCl) sensitivity remained unclear. In this study, we have reported computational (∼14.2 μs of MD) and experimental (CD, fluorescence) investigations to examine the salt-sensitivity and the role of peptide secondary structure on LL-14 binding to simple membrane mimetic (SDS, DPC) systems. LL-14 was shown to adopt a random coil (P^c) conformation in water and α-helical conformation (P^h) in the peptide:SDS micelle complex, accompanied by tryptophan burial, using both simulations and experiments. Simulations successfully deconvoluted the LL-14:micelle binding event in terms of secondary structure (random coil P^cversus helix P^h) and gave atomic insight into the initial and final LL-14:SDS complexes. Electrostatics drove the N-terminus (L1 and K2) of LL-14 (P^c or P^h) to bind the SDS micellar surface, initiating complex formation. LL-14 in amphipathic P^h conformation bound faster and buried deeper into the SDS micelle relative to P^c. Increasing NaCl concentration incrementally delayed LL-14:micelle binding by shielding the overall charges of the interacting partners. LL-14 binding to the SDS micelle was significantly faster relative to that of the zwitterionic DPC micelle due to electrostatic reasons. Cationic α-helical amphipathic peptides (with positively charged N-terminus) with low salt-ion concentration seemed to be ideal for faster SDS binding.

We report computational (∼14.2 μs of MD) and experimental (CD, fluorescence) investigations to examine the salt-sensitivity and the role of the peptide secondary structure on LL-14 binding to simple membrane mimetic systems.

Membrane Active Peptides and Their Biophysical Characterization

In the last 20 years, an increasing number of studies have been reported on membrane active peptides. These peptides exert their biological activity by interacting with the cell membrane, either to disrupt it and lead to cell lysis or to translocate through it to deliver cargos into the cell and reach their target. Membrane active peptides are attractive alternatives to currently used pharmaceuticals and the number of antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) and peptides designed for drug and gene delivery in the drug pipeline is increasing. Here, we focus on two most prominent classes of membrane active peptides; AMPs and cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs). Antimicrobial peptides are a group of membrane active peptides that disrupt the membrane integrity or inhibit the cellular functions of bacteria, virus, and fungi. Cell penetrating peptides are another group of membrane active peptides that mainly function as cargo-carriers even though they may also show antimicrobial activity. Biophysical techniques shed light on peptide–membrane interactions at higher resolution due to the advances in optics, image processing, and computational resources. Structural investigation of membrane active peptides in the presence of the membrane provides important clues on the effect of the membrane environment on peptide conformations. Live imaging techniques allow examination of peptide action at a single cell or single molecule level. In addition to these experimental biophysical techniques, molecular dynamics simulations provide clues on the peptide–lipid interactions and dynamics of the cell entry process at atomic detail. In this review, we summarize the recent advances in experimental and computational investigation of membrane active peptides with particular emphasis on two amphipathic membrane active peptides, the AMP melittin and the CPP pVEC.

Membrane-active peptides from marine organisms--antimicrobials, cell-penetrating peptides and peptide toxins: applications and prospects

Marine organisms are known to be a rich and unique source of bioactive compounds as they are exposed to extreme conditions in the oceans. The present study is an attempt to briefly describe some of the important membrane-active peptides (MAPs) such as antimicrobial peptides (AMPs), cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) and peptide toxins from marine organisms. Since both AMPs and CPPs play a role in membrane perturbation and exhibit interchangeable role, they can speculatively fall under the broad umbrella of MAPs. The study focuses on the structural and functional characteristics of different classes of marine MAPs. Further, AMPs are considered as a potential remedy to antibiotic resistance acquired by several pathogens. Peptides from marine organisms show novel post-translational modifications such as cysteine knots, halogenation and histidino-alanine bridge that enable these peptides to withstand harsh marine environmental conditions. These unusual modifications of AMPs from marine organisms are expected to increase their half-life in living systems, contributing to their increased bioavailability and stability when administered as drug in in vivo systems. Apart from AMPs, marine toxins with membrane-perturbing properties could be essentially investigated for their cytotoxic effect on various pathogens and their cell-penetrating activity across various mammalian cells. The current review will help in identifying the MAPs from marine organisms with crucial post-translational modifications that can be used as template for designing novel therapeutic agents and drug-delivery vehicles for treatment of human diseases.

Evidence for a novel mechanism of antimicrobial action of a cyclic R-,W-rich hexapeptide

The development of antimicrobial peptides as new class of antibiotic agents requires structural characterisation and understanding of their diverse mechanisms of action. As the cyclic hexapeptide cWFW (cyclo(RRRWFW)) does not exert its rapid cell killing activity by membrane permeabilisation, in this study we investigated alternative mechanisms of action, such as peptide translocation into the cytoplasm and peptide interaction with components of the phospholipid matrix of the bacterial membrane. Using fluorescence microscopy and an HPLC-based strategy to analyse peptide uptake into the cells we could confirm the cytoplasmic membrane as the major peptide target. However, unexpectedly we observed accumulation of cWFW at distinct sites of the membrane. Further characterisation of peptide-membrane interaction involved live cell imaging to visualise the distribution of the lipid cardiolipin (CL) and isothermal titration calorimetry to determine the binding affinity to model membranes with different bacterial lipid compositions. Our results demonstrate a distribution of the cyclic peptide similar to that of cardiolipin within the membrane and highly preferred affinity of cWFW for CL-rich phosphatidylethanolamine (POPE) matrices. These observations point to a novel mechanism of antimicrobial killing for the cyclic hexapeptide cWFW which is neither based on membrane permeabilisation nor translocation into the cytoplasm but rather on preferred partitioning into particular lipid domains. As the phospholipids POPE/CL play a key role in the dynamic organisation of bacterial membranes we discuss the consequences of this peptide-lipid-interaction and outline the impact on antimicrobial peptide research.

Peptide-membrane interactions of arginine-tryptophan peptides probed using quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring

Membrane-active peptides include peptides that can cross cellular membranes and deliver macromolecular cargo as well as peptides that inhibit bacterial growth. Some of these peptides can act as both transporters and antibacterial agents. It is desirable to combine the knowledge from these two different fields of membrane-active peptides into design of new peptides with tailored actions, as transporters of cargo or as antibacterial substances, targeting specific membranes. We have previously shown that the position of the amino acid tryptophan in the peptide sequence of three arginine-tryptophan peptides affects their uptake and intracellular localization in live mammalian cells, as well as their ability to inhibit bacterial growth. Here, we use quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring to assess the induced changes caused by binding of the three peptides to supported model membranes composed of POPC, POPC/POPG, POPC/POPG/cholesterol or POPC/lactosyl PE. Our results indicate that the tryptophan position in the peptide sequence affects the way these peptides interact with the different model membranes and that the presence of cholesterol in particular seems to affect the membrane interaction of the peptide with an even distribution of tryptophans in the peptide sequence. These results give mechanistic insight into the function of these peptides and may aid in the design of membrane-active peptides with specified cellular targets and actions.

Designing antimicrobial peptides: form follows function

Multidrug-resistant bacteria are a severe threat to public health. Conventional antibiotics are becoming increasingly ineffective as a result of resistance, and it is imperative to find new antibacterial strategies. Natural antimicrobials, known as host defence peptides or antimicrobial peptides, defend host organisms against microbes but most have modest direct antibiotic activity. Enhanced variants have been developed using straightforward design and optimization strategies and are being tested clinically. Here, we describe advanced computer-assisted design strategies that address the difficult problem of relating primary sequence to peptide structure, and are delivering more potent, cost-effective, broad-spectrum peptides as potential next-generation antibiotics.

Nanocarrier possibilities for functional targeting of bioactive peptides and proteins: state-of-the-art

This review attempts to provide an updated compilation of studies reported in the literature pertaining to production of nanocarriers encasing peptides and/or proteins, in a way that helps the reader direct a bibliographic search and develop an integrated perspective of the subject. Highlights are given to bioactive proteins and peptides, with a special focus on those from dairy sources (including physicochemical characteristics and properties, and biopharmaceutical application possibilities of e.g. lactoferrin and glycomacropeptide), as well as to nanocarrier functional targeting. Features associated with micro- and (multiple) nanoemulsions, micellar systems, liposomes and solid lipid nanoparticles, together with biopharmaceutical considerations, are presented in the text in a systematic fashion.