Orientation Resolving Dipolar High-Field EPR Spectroscopy on Disordered Solids: II. Structure of Spin-Correlated Radical Pairs in Photosystem I

Determining and controlling conformational information from orientationally selective light-induced triplet-triplet electron resonance spectroscopy for a set of bis-porphyrin rulers

We recently reported a new technique, light-induced triplet-triplet electron resonance (LITTER) spectroscopy, which allows quantification of the dipolar interaction between the photogenerated triplet states of two chromophores. Here we carry out a systematic LITTER study, considering orientation selection by the detection pulses, of a series of bis-porphyrin model peptides with different porphyrin-porphyrin distances and relative orientations. Orientation-dependent analysis of the dipolar datasets yields conformational information of the molecules in frozen solution which is in good agreement with density functional theory predictions. Additionally, a fast partial orientational-averaging treatment produces distance distributions with minimized orientational artefacts. Finally, by direct comparison of LITTER data to double electron-electron resonance (DEER) measured on a system with Cu(II) coordinated into the porphyrins, we demonstrate the advantages of the LITTER technique over the standard DEER methodology. This is due to the remarkable spectroscopic properties of the photogenerated porphyrin triplet state. This work sets the basis for the use of LITTER in structural investigations of unmodified complex biological macromolecules, which could be combined with Förster resonance energy transfer and microscopy inside cells.

Coherences of Photoinduced Electron Spin Qubit Pair States in Photosystem I

This publication presents the first comprehensive experimental study of electron spin coherences in photosynthetic reaction center proteins, specifically focusing on photosystem I (PSI). The ultrafast electron transfer in PSI generates spin-correlated radical pairs (SCRPs), which are entangled spin pairs formed in well-defined spin states (Bell states). Since their discovery in our group in the 1980s, SCRPs have been extensively used to enhance our understanding of structure-function relationships in photosynthetic proteins. More recently, SCRPs have been utilized as tools for quantum sensing. Electron spin decoherence poses a significant challenge in realizing practical applications of electron spin qubits, particularly the creation of quantum entanglement between multiple electron spins. This work is focused on the systematic characterization of decoherence in SCRPs of PSI. These decoherence times were measured as electron spin echo decay times, termed phase memory times (TM), at various temperatures. Decoherence was recorded on both transient SCRP states P700+A1- and thermalized states. Our study reveals that TM exhibits minimal dependence on the biological species, biochemical treatment, and paramagnetic species. The analysis indicates that nuclear spin diffusion and instantaneous diffusion mechanisms alone cannot explain the observed decoherence. As a plausible explanation we discuss the assumption that the low-temperature dynamics of methyl groups in the protein surrounding the unpaired electron spin centers is the main factor governing the loss of the spin coherence in PSI.

Conditions for EPR detection of chirality-induced spin selectivity in spin-polarized radical pairs in isotropic solution

Chiral molecules can act as spin filters, preferentially transmitting electrons with spins polarized along their direction of travel, an effect known as chirality-induced spin selectivity (CISS). In a typical experiment, injected electrons tunnel coherently through a layer of chiral material and emerge spin-polarized. It is also possible that spin polarization arises in radical pairs formed photochemically when electrons hop incoherently between donor and acceptor sites. Here we aim to identify the magnetic properties that would optimise the visibility of CISS polarization in time-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra of transient radical pairs without the need to orient or align their precursors. By simulating spectra of actual and model systems, we find that CISS contributions to the polarization should be most obvious when at least one of the radicals has small g-anisotropy and an inhomogeneous linewidth larger than the dipolar coupling of the two radicals. Under these conditions there is extensive cancellation of absorptive and emissive enhancements making the spectrum sensitive to small changes in the individual EPR line intensities. Although these cancellation effects are more pronounced at lower spectrometer frequencies, the spectral changes are easier to appreciate with the enhanced resolution afforded by high-frequency EPR. Consideration of published spectra of light-induced radical pairs in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centres reveals no significant CISS component in the polarization generated by the conventional spin-correlated radical pair mechanism.

OOP-ESEEM Spectroscopy: Accuracies of Distances of Spin-Correlated Radical Pairs in Biomolecules

In addition to the commonly used electron–electron double resonance (ELDOR) technique, there are several other electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) methods by which structure information can be obtained by exploiting the dipolar coupling between two radicals based on its characteristic r⁻³ dependence. In this contribution, we explore the potential of out-of-phase-electron-spin echo envelope modulation (OOP-ESEEM) spectroscopy to collect accurate distance information in photo-sensitive (bio) molecules. Although the method has already been applied to spin-correlated radical pairs in several classes of light-active proteins, the accuracy of the information obtained has not yet been extensively evaluated. To do this in a system-independent fashion, OOP-ESEEM time traces simulated with different values of the dipolar and exchange couplings were generated and analyzed in a best-possible way. Excellent agreement between calculated and numerically fitted values over a wide range of distances (between 15 and 45 Å) was obtained. Furthermore, the limitations of the method and the dependence on various experimental parameters could be evaluated.

Cryo-EM photosystem I structure reveals adaptation mechanisms to extreme high light in Chlorella ohadii

Photosynthesis in deserts is challenging since it requires fast adaptation to rapid night-to-day changes, that is, from dawn's low light (LL) to extreme high light (HL) intensities during the daytime. To understand these adaptation mechanisms, we purified photosystem I (PSI) from Chlorella ohadii, a green alga that was isolated from a desert soil crust, and identified the essential functional and structural changes that enable the photosystem to perform photosynthesis under extreme high light conditions. The cryo-electron microscopy structures of PSI from cells grown under low light (PSI_LL) and high light (PSI_HL), obtained at 2.70 and 2.71 Å, respectively, show that part of light-harvesting antenna complex I (LHCI) and the core complex subunit (PsaO) are eliminated from PSI_HL to minimize the photodamage. An additional change is in the pigment composition and their number in LHCI_HL; about 50% of chlorophyll b is replaced by chlorophyll a. This leads to higher electron transfer rates in PSI_HL and might enable C. ohadii PSI to act as a natural photosynthesiser in photobiocatalytic systems. PSI_HL or PSI_LL were attached to an electrode and their induced photocurrent was determined. To obtain photocurrents comparable with PSI_HL, 25 times the amount of PSI_LL was required, demonstrating the high efficiency of PSI_HL. Hence, we suggest that C. ohadii PSI_HL is an ideal candidate for the design of desert artificial photobiocatalytic systems.

Quantum Sensing of Electron Transfer Pathways in Natural Photosynthesis Using Time-Resolved High-Field Electron Paramagnetic Resonance/Electron-Nuclear Double Resonance Spectroscopy

Photosynthetic integral membrane reaction center (RC) proteins capture and convert sunlight into chemical energy via efficient charge separation achieved through a series of rapid, photoinitiated electron transfer steps. These fast electron transfers create an entangled spin qubit (radical) pair that contains detailed information about the weak magnetic interactions, structure, and dynamics of localized protein environments involved in charge separation events. Herein, we investigate how these entangled electron spin qubits interact with nuclear spins of the protein environment using the high spectral resolution of 130 GHz electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and electron-nuclear double resonance (ENDOR). Spectroscopic interrogation enabled the observation and probing of protons located in the electron transfer pathway between the membrane-spanning electron pair P⁺Q_A^- (where P⁺ is the primary donor, a special pair of bacteriochlorophylls, and Q_A is the primary quinone acceptor) in the bacterial RC. Spectroscopic analysis reveals hydrogen-bonding interactions involved in regulating the route that light-induced electrons travel through the RC protein during charge separation.

Generation of ion-radical chlorophyll states in the light-harvesting antenna and the reaction center of cyanobacterial photosystem I

The energy and charge-transfer processes in photosystem I (PS I) complexes isolated from cyanobacteria Thermosynechococcus elongatus and Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 were investigated by pump-to-probe femtosecond spectroscopy. The formation of charge-transfer (CT) states in excitonically coupled chlorophyll a complexes (exciplexes) was monitored by measuring the electrochromic shift of β-carotene in the spectral range 500-510 nm. The excitation of high-energy chlorophyll in light-harvesting antenna of both species was not accompanied by immediate appearance of an electrochromic shift. In PS I from T. elongatus, the excitation of long-wavelength chlorophyll (LWC) caused a pronounced electrochromic effect at 502 nm assigned to the appearance of CT states of chlorophyll exciplexes. The formation of ion-radical pair P₇₀₀⁺A₁^- at 40 ps was limited by energy transfer from LWC to the primary donor P₇₀₀ and accompanied by carotenoid bleach at 498 nm. In PS I from Synechocystis 6803, the excitation at 720 nm produced an immediate bidentate bleach at 690/704 nm and synchronous carotenoid response at 508 nm. The bidentate bleach was assigned to the formation of primary ion-radical state P_B⁺Chl_2B^-, where negative charge is localized predominantly at the accessory chlorophyll molecule in the branch B, Chl_2B. The following decrease of carotenoid signal at ~ 5 ps was ascribed to electron transfer to the more distant molecule Chl_3B. The reduction of phylloquinone in the sites A_1A and A_1B was accompanied by a synchronous blue-shift of the carotenoid response to 498 nm, pointing to fast redistribution of unpaired electron between two branches in favor of the state P_B⁺A_1A^-.

EPR characterization of Mn(ii) complexes for distance determination with pulsed dipolar spectroscopy

EPR properties of four Mn(ii) complexes and Tikhonov regularization-based analysis of RIDME data containing dipolar overtones are presented.

RIDME Spectroscopy with Gd(III) Centers

The relaxation induced dipolar modulation enhancement (RIDME) technique is applied at W-band microwave frequencies around 94 GHz to a pair of Gd(III) complexes that are connected by a rodlike spacer, and the extraction of the interspin distance distribution is discussed. A dipolar pattern derived from RIDME experimental data is a superposition of Pake-like dipolar patterns corresponding to the fundamental dipolar interaction and higher harmonics thereof. Intriguingly, the relative weights of the stretched patterns do not depend significantly on mixing time. As much larger modulation depths can be achieved than in double electron-electron resonance distance measurements at the same frequency, Gd(III)-Gd(III) RIDME may become attractive for structural characterization of biomacromolecules and biomolecular complexes.

High-field EPR on membrane proteins - crossing the gap to NMR

In this review on advanced EPR spectroscopy, which addresses both the EPR and NMR communities, considerable emphasis is put on delineating the complementarity of NMR and EPR concerning the measurement of molecular interactions in large biomolecules. From these interactions, detailed information can be revealed on structure and dynamics of macromolecules embedded in solution- or solid-state environments. New developments in pulsed microwave and sweepable cryomagnet technology as well as ultrafast electronics for signal data handling and processing have pushed to new horizons the limits of EPR spectroscopy and its multifrequency extensions concerning the sensitivity of detection, the selectivity with respect to interactions, and the resolution in frequency and time domains. One of the most important advances has been the extension of EPR to high magnetic fields and microwave frequencies, very much in analogy to what happens in NMR. This is exemplified by referring to ongoing efforts for signal enhancement in both NMR and EPR double-resonance techniques by exploiting dynamic nuclear or electron spin polarization via unpaired electron spins and their electron-nuclear or electron-electron interactions. Signal and resolution enhancements are particularly spectacular for double-resonance techniques such as ENDOR and PELDOR at high magnetic fields. They provide greatly improved orientational selection for disordered samples that approaches single-crystal resolution at canonical g-tensor orientations - even for molecules with small g-anisotropies. Exchange of experience between the EPR and NMR communities allows for handling polarization and resolution improvement strategies in an optimal manner. Consequently, a dramatic improvement of EPR detection sensitivity could be achieved, even for short-lived paramagnetic reaction intermediates. Unique structural and dynamic information is thus revealed that can hardly be obtained by any other analytical techniques. Micromolar quantities of sample molecules have become sufficient to characterize stable and transient reaction intermediates of complex molecular systems - offering highly interesting applications for chemists, biochemists and molecular biologists. In three case studies, representative examples of advanced EPR spectroscopy are reviewed: (I) High-field PELDOR and ENDOR structure determination of cation-anion radical pairs in reaction centers from photosynthetic purple bacteria and cyanobacteria (Photosystem I); (II) High-field ENDOR and ELDOR-detected NMR spectroscopy on the oxygen-evolving complex of Photosystem II; and (III) High-field electron dipolar spectroscopy on nitroxide spin-labelled bacteriorhodopsin for structure-function studies. An extended conclusion with an outlook to further developments and applications is also presented.

Crystal structures of virus-like photosystem I complexes from the mesophilic cyanobacterium Synechocystis PCC 6803

Oxygenic photosynthesis supports virtually all life forms on earth. Light energy is converted by two photosystems—photosystem I (PSI) and photosystem II (PSII). Globally, nearly 50% of photosynthesis takes place in the Ocean, where single cell cyanobacteria and algae reside together with their viruses. An operon encoding PSI was identified in cyanobacterial marine viruses. We generated a PSI that mimics the salient features of the viral complex, named PSI^PsaJF. PSI^PsaJF is promiscuous for its electron donors and can accept electrons from respiratory cytochromes. We solved the structure of PSI^PsaJF and a monomeric PSI, with subunit composition similar to the viral PSI, providing for the first time a detailed description of the reaction center and antenna system from mesophilic cyanobacteria, including red chlorophylls and cofactors of the electron transport chain. Our finding extends the understanding of PSI structure, function and evolution and suggests a unique function for the viral PSI.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.01496.001

Photosynthesis—the process by which plants and other organisms harness the energy in sunlight—is the source of almost all oxygen, food and fuel on earth. Oxygenic photosynthesis in living cells involves a series of reactions catalyzed by large protein complexes, various other soluble chemicals, and the transfer of electrons from so-called donors to acceptors. The energy in the sunlight is captured by two membrane-embedded protein complexes—photosystem I, which is the most powerful electron donor in nature, and photosystem II—and converted into chemical energy.

Almost half of the world’s photosynthesis occurs in the oceans, and is performed by single-celled cyanobacteria and algae. Interestingly, some of the genes that encode photosynthetic enzymes in cyanobacteria are also found in the genomes of viruses that infect these bacteria. It is thought that these viruses can alter photosynthetic pathways in their hosts, but the interactions between these viruses and their hosts are not fully understood.

Now, Mazor et al. have created a photosystem I complex that mimics the viral version of this complex, and have gone on to solve its three-dimensional structure. This mimetic virus-encoded complex was shown to be a ‘promiscuous’ electron acceptor: this means that, unlike most electron acceptors, it can accept electrons from more than one electron donor.

Further, Mazor et al. solved the structure of photosystem I from Synechocystis, a cyanobacterium that lives in fresh water; and found some surprising differences between it and the only other published structure for photosystem I from a cyanobacterium (which was from a species that lives in hot water springs). These included differences in components involved in the electron transfer chain—a series of chemical reactions in which electrons are passed from donor to acceptor molecules—that were thought to be highly conserved. Other differences in the structures allowed Mazor et al. to identify the location of a unique chlorophyll pigment group in the Synechocystis photosystem I.

Since Synechocystis is commonly used as a model to study photosynthesis, an improved understanding of its photosystem I should lead to further improvements in our knowledge of photosynthesis.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.01496.002