Beyond molecular recognition: using a repulsive field to tune interfacial valency and binding specificity between adhesive surfaces

Nanoscale Functionalized Particles with Rotation-Controlled Capture in Shear Flow

Important processes in nature and technology involve the adhesive capture of flowing particles or cells on the walls of a conduit. This paper introduces engineered spherical microparticles whose capture rates are limited by their near surface motions in flow. Specifically, these microparticles are sparsely functionalized with nanoscopic regions ("patches") of adhesive functionality, without which they would be nonadhesive. Not only is particle capture on the wall of a shear-chamber limited by surface chemistry as opposed to transport, but also the capture rates depend specifically on particle rotations that result from the vorticity of the shear flow field. These particle rotations continually expose new particle surface to the opposing chamber wall, sampling the particle surface for an adhesive region and controlling the capture rate. Control studies with the same patchy functionality on the chamber wall rather than the particles reveal a related signature of particle capture but substantially faster (still surface limited) particle capture rates. Thus, when the same functionality is placed on the wall rather than the particles, the capture is faster because it depends on the particle translation past a functionalized wall rather than on the particle rotations. The dependence of particle capture on functionalization of the particles versus the wall is consistent with the faster near-wall particle translation in shearing flow compared with the velocity of the rotating particle surface near the wall. These findings, in addition to providing a new class of nanoscopically patchy engineered particles, provide insight into the capture and detection of cells presenting sparse distinguishing surface features and the design of delivery packages for highly targeted pharmaceutical delivery.

Selective Adhesive Cell Capture without Molecular Specificity: New Surfaces Exploiting Nanoscopic Polycationic Features as Discrete Adhesive Units

This work explored how molecularly non-specific polycationic nanoscale features on a collecting surface control kinetic and selectivity aspects of mammalian cell capture. Key principles for selective collector design were demonstrated by comparing the capture of two closely related breast cancer cell lines: MCF-7 and TMX2-28. TMX2-28 is a tamoxifen-selected clone of MCF-7. The collector was a silica surface, negatively-charged at pH 7.4, containing isolated molecules (~ 8 nm diameter) of the cationic polymer, poly(dimethyl-aminoethylmethacrylate), pDMAEMA. Important in this work is the non-selective nature of the pDMAEMA interactions with cells: pDMAEMA generally adheres negatively charged particles and cells in solution. We show here that selectivity towards cells results from collector design: this includes competition between repulsive interactions involving the negative silica and attractions to the immobilized pDMAEMA molecules, the random pDMAEMA arrangement on the surface, and the concentration of positive charge in the vicinity of the adsorbed pDMAEMA chains. The latter act as nanoscopic cationic surface patches, each weakly attracted to negatively-charged cells. Collecting surfaces engineered with an appropriate amount pDMAEMA, exposed to mixtures of MCF-7 and TMX2-28 cells preferentially captured TMX2-28 with a selectivity of 2.5. (This means that the ratio of TMX2-28 to MCF cells on the surface was 2.5 times their compositional ratio in free solution.) The ionic strength-dependence of cell capture was shown to be similar to that of silica microparticles on the same surfaces. This suggests that the mechanism of selective cell capture involves nanoscopic differences in the contact areas of the cells with the collector, allowing discrimination of closely related cell line-based small scale features of the cell surface. This work demonstrated that even without molecular specificity, selectivity for physical cell attributes produces adhesive discrimination.

Diffusing Colloidal Probes of kT-Scale Biomaterial-Cell Interactions

In the optimization of applied biomaterials, measurements of their interactions with cell surfaces are important to understand their influence on specific and nonspecific cell surface adhesion, internalization pathways, and toxicity. In this study, a novel approach using dark field video microscopy with combined real-time particle and cell tracking allows the trajectories of biomaterial-coated colloids to be monitored in relation to their distance from cell perimeters. Dynamic and statistical mechanical analyses enable direct measurement of colloid-cell surface association lifetimes and interaction potentials mediated by biomaterials. Our analyses of colloidal transport showed polyethylene glycol (PEG) and bovine serum albumin (BSA) lead to net repulsive interactions with cell surfaces, while dextran and hyaluronic acid (HA) lead to reversible and irreversible association to the cell surface, respectively. Our results demonstrate how diffusing colloidal probes can be used for nonobtrusive, sensitive measurements of biomaterial-cell surface interactions important to therapeutics, diagnostics, and tissue engineering.

Engineering nanoscale surface features to sustain microparticle rolling in flow

Nanoscopic features of channel walls are often engineered to facilitate microfluidic transport, for instance when surface charge enables electro-osmosis or when grooves drive mixing. The dynamic or rolling adhesion of flowing microparticles on a channel wall holds potential to accomplish particle sorting or to selectively transfer reactive species or signals between the wall and flowing particles. Inspired by cell rolling under the direction of adhesion molecules called selectins, we present an engineered platform in which the rolling of flowing microparticles is sustained through the incorporation of entirely synthetic, discrete, nanoscale, attractive features into the nonadhesive (electrostatically repulsive) surface of a flow channel. Focusing on one example or type of nanoscale feature and probing the impact of broad systematic variations in surface feature loading and processing parameters, this study demonstrates how relatively flat, weakly adhesive nanoscale features, positioned with average spacings on the order of tens of nanometers, can produce sustained microparticle rolling. We further demonstrate how the rolling velocity and travel distance depend on flow and surface design. We identify classes of related surfaces that fail to support rolling and present a state space that identifies combinations of surface and processing variables corresponding to transitions between rolling, free particle motion, and arrest. Finally we identify combinations of parameters (surface length scales, particle size, flow rates) where particles can be manipulated with size-selectivity.

Surfaces for competitive selective bacterial capture from protein solutions

Active surfaces that form the basis for bacterial sensors for threat detection, food safety, or certain diagnostic applications rely on bacterial adhesion. However, bacteria capture from complex fluids on the active surfaces can be reduced by the competing adsorption of proteins and other large molecules. Such adsorption can also interfere with device performance. As a result, multiple upstream processing steps are frequently employed to separate macromolecules from any cells, which remain in the buffer. Here, we present an economical approach to capture bacteria, without competitive adsorption by proteins, on engineered surfaces that do not employ biomolecular recognition, antibodies, or other molecules with engineered sequences. The surfaces are based on polyethylene glycol (PEG) brushes that, on their own, repel both proteins and bacteria. These PEG brushes backfill the surface around sparsely adsorbed cationic polymer coils (here, poly-L-lysine (PLL)). The PLL coils are effectively embedded within the brush and produce locally cationic nanoscale regions that attract negatively charged regions of proteins or cells against the steric background repulsion from the PEG brush. By carefully designing the surfaces to include just enough PLL to capture bacteria, but not enough to capture proteins, we achieve sharp selectivity where S. aureus is captured from albumin- or fibrinogen-containing solutions, but free albumin or fibrinogen molecules are rejected from the surface. Bacterial adhesion on these surfaces is not reduced by competitive protein adsorption, in contrast to performance of more uniformly cationic surfaces. Also, protein adsorption to the bacteria does not interfere with capture, at least for the case of S. aureus, to which fibrinogen binds through a specific receptor.

Capture of soft particles on electrostatically heterogeneous collectors: brushy particles

This work investigated how particle softness can influence the initial adhesive capture of submicrometer colloidal particles from flow onto collecting surfaces. The study focused on the case dominated by potential attractions at the particle periphery (rather than, for instance, steric stabilization, requiring entropically costly deformations to access shorter-range van der Waals attractions.) The particles, "spherical polyelectrolyte brushes" with diameters in the range of 150-200 nm depending on the ionic strength, consisted of a polystyrene core and a corona of grafted poly(acrylic acid) chains, producing a relatively thick (20-40 nm) negative brushy layer. The adhesion of these particles was studied on electrostatically heterogeneous collecting surfaces: negatively charged substrates carrying flat polycationic patches made by irreversibly adsorbing the poly-l-lysine (PLL) polyelectrolyte. Variation in the amount of adsorbed PLL changed the net collector charge from completely negatively charged (repulsive) to positively charged (attractive). Adjustments in ionic strength varied the range of the electrostatic interactions. Comparing capture kinetics of soft brushy particles to those of similarly sized and similarly charged silica particles revealed nearly identical particle capture kinetics over the full range of collecting surface compositions at high ionic strengths. Even though the brushy particles contained an average of 5 vol % PAA in the brushy shell, with the rest being water under these conditions, their capture was indistinguishable from that of similarly charged rigid spheres. The brushy particles were, however, considerably less adherent at low ionic strengths where the brush was more extended, suggesting an influence of particle deformability or reduced interfacial charge. These findings, that the short time adhesion of brushy particles can resemble that of rigid particles, suggest that for bacteria and cell capture, modeling the cells as rigid particles can, in some instances, be a good approximation.

Using flow to switch the valency of bacterial capture on engineered surfaces containing immobilized nanoparticles

Toward an understanding of nanoparticle-bacterial interactions and the development of sensors and other substrates for controlled bacterial adhesion, this article describes the influence of flow on the initial stages of bacterial capture (Staphylococcus aureus) on surfaces containing cationic nanoparticles. A PEG (poly(ethylene glycol)) brush on the surface around the nanoparticles sterically repels the bacteria. Variations in ionic strength tune the Debye length from 1 to 4 nm, increasing the strength and range of the nanoparticle attractions toward the bacteria. At relatively high ionic strengths (physiological conditions), bacterial capture requires several nanoparticle-bacterial contacts, termed "multivalent capture". At low ionic strength and gentle wall shear rates (on the order of 10 s(-1)), individual bacteria can be captured and held by single surface-immobilized nanoparticles. Increasing the flow rate to 50 s(-1) causes a shift from monovalent to divalent capture. A comparison of experimental capture efficiencies with statistically determined capture probabilities reveals the initial area of bacteria-surface interaction, here about 50 nm in diameter for a Debye length κ(-1) of 4 nm. Additionally, for κ(-1) = 4 nm, the net per nanoparticle binding energies are strong but highly shear-sensitive, as is the case for biological ligand-receptor interactions. Although these results have been obtained for a specific system, they represent a regime of behavior that could be achieved with different bacteria and different materials, presenting an opportunity for further tuning of selective interactions. These finding suggest the use of surface elements to manipulate individual bacteria and nonfouling designs with precise but finite bacterial interactions.

Sensitivity of protein adsorption to architectural variations in a protein-resistant polymer brush containing engineered nanoscale adhesive sites

Patchy polymer brushes contain nanoscale (5-15 nm) adhesive elements, such as polymer coils or nanoparticles, embedded at their base at random positions on the surface. The competition between the brush's steric (protein resistant) repulsions and the attractions from the discrete adhesive elements provides a precise means to control bioadhesion. This differs from the classical approach, where functionality is placed on the brush's periphery. The current study demonstrates the impact of poly(etheylene glycol) (PEG) brush architecture and ionic strength on fibrinogen adsorption on brushes containing embedded poly-l-lysine (PLL, 20K MW) coils or "patches". The consistent appearance of a fibrinogen adsorption threshold, a minimum loading of patches on the surface, below which protein adsorption does not occur, suggests multivalent protein capture: Adsorbing proteins simultaneously engage several patches. The surface composition (patch loading) at the threshold is extremely sensitive to the brush height and ionic strength, varying up to a factor of 5 in the surface loading of the PLL patches (~50% of the range of possible surfaces). Variations in ionic strength have a similar effect, with the smallest thresholds seen for the largest Debye lengths. While trends with brush height were the clearest and most dominant, consideration of the PEG loading within the brush or its persistence length did not reveal a critical brush parameter for the onset of adsorption. The lack of straightforward correlation on brush physics was likely a result of multivalent binding, (producing an additional dependence on patch loading), and might be resolved for univalent adsorption onto more strongly binding patches. While studies with similar brushes placed uniformly on a surface revealed that the PEG loading within the brush is the best indicator of protein resistance, the current results suggest that brush height is more important for patchy brushes. Likely the interactions producing brush extension normal to the interface act similarly to drive lateral tether extension to obstruct patches.

Altered binding of a multimeric protein by changing the self-assembling properties of its substrate

Artificially controlled cell recognition has potentially far-reaching applications in both the understanding and altering of biological function. The event of recognition often involves a multimeric protein binding a cellular membrane. While such an interaction is energetically favorable, it has been surprisingly underexploited in artificial control of recognition. Herein we describe how changing properties of substrate (phosphocholine, PC) self-assembly can affect both binding behavior and substrate affinity to a pentameric recognition protein (C-reactive protein, CRP). PC was modified with a short, self-assembling DNA strand to make the substrate self-assembly sensitive and responsive to ionic environment. A significant shift in CRP binding affinity was observed when substrates were assembled in the presence of Cs(+) rather than K(+). Furthermore, alteration of the linker length tethering PC to DNA showed trends similar to other multivalent systems. In optimizing these linker lengths, positive cooperativity increased and K(d) of the substrate assembly to CRP improved roughly 1000-fold. Such experiments both inform our understanding of biological, multivalent interactions in self-assembling systems and present a potential method to exogenously control events in cell recognition.

Thermodynamics of multivalent interactions: influence of the linker

This paper describes a thermodynamic analysis of multivalent interactions, with the goal of clarifying the influence of the linker on the enhancement in avidity due to multivalency. The use of multivalency represents a promising approach to inhibit undesired biological interactions, promote desired cellular responses, and control recognition events at surfaces. Several groups have synthesized multivalent ligands that are orders of magnitude more potent than the corresponding monovalent ligands. A better understanding of the theoretical basis for the large enhancements in avidity would help guide the design of more potent synthetic multivalent ligands. In particular, there has been significant controversy regarding the extent to which the loss of conformational entropy of the linker influences the enhancement in avidity due to multivalency. To help clarify this issue, we present the thermodynamic analysis of a heterodivalent ligand-receptor interaction. Our analysis helps reconcile seemingly competing theoretical analyses of multivalent binding. Our results indicate that the dependence of the free energy of multivalent binding on linker length can be weak even if there is a significant decrease in the conformational entropy of the linker on binding. Our results are also consistent with studies demonstrating that the use of flexible linkers represents an effective strategy to design potent multivalent ligands.

Thin film assemblies of molecularly-linked metal nanoparticles and multifunctional properties

The use of metal nanoparticles as building blocks toward thin film assembly creates intriguing opportunities for exploring multifunctional properties. Such an exploration requires the ability to engineer the size, shape, composition, and especially interparticle properties in nanoparticle assemblies for harnessing the collective properties of the nanoscale building blocks. This article highlights some of the important findings of our investigations of thin film assemblies of molecularly linked nanoparticles for exploiting their multifunctional and collective properties in molecular recognition and chemical sensing. The thermally activated processing approach presents a viable pathway for nanoengineering metal, alloy, and core-shell nanoparticles as building blocks. The molecular mediator-templating approach offers an effective strategy to thin film assemblies of the nanoscale building blocks that impart multifunctional properties. In such thin film assemblies, the interparticle interactions and structures dictate the correlation between the nanostructural parameters and the optical and electrical properties. By highlighting selected examples involving ligand-framework binding of ionic species at the film/liquid interface and electrical responses to molecular sorption at the film/gas interface, the multifunctional properties of the thin film assemblies are further discussed in terms of interparticle covalent, hydrogen bonding, ionic, or van der Waals interactions in a framework-type architecture for the creation of molecular recognition and chemical sensing sites that can be tuned chemically or electrochemically. Implications of these insights to expanding the exploration of nanoparticle thin film assemblies for a wide range of technological applications are also discussed.