Additional chromosome 1q aberrations and der(16)t(1;16), correlation to the phenotypic expression and clinical behavior of the Ewing family of tumors

Twenty Years on: What Do We Really Know about Ewing Sarcoma and What Is the Path Forward?

Ewing sarcoma (ES) is a highly aggressive bone and soft-tissue tumor with peak incidence among adolescents and young adults. Despite advances in local control and systemic chemotherapy, metastatic relapse after an initial clinical remission remains a significant clinical problem. In addition, metastasis at the time of presentation or at relapse continues to be the leading cause of death for patients diagnosed with ES. Since the discovery of the pathognomonic EWS-FLI1 fusion gene more than 20 years ago, much about the molecular and cellular biology of ES pathogenesis has been learned. In addition, more recent exploitation of advances in stem cell and developmental biology has provided key insights into the cellular origins of ES and the role of epigenetic deregulation in tumor initiation and maintenance. Nevertheless, the mechanisms that drive tumor relapse and metastasis remain largely unknown. These gaps in our knowledge continue to hamper the development of novel therapeutic strategies that may improve outcomes for patients with relapsed and metastatic disease. In this article we review the current status of ES biology research, highlighting areas of investigation that we consider to have the greatest potential to yield findings that will translate into clinically significant advances.

Complex rearrangement of chromosomes 19, 21, and 22 in Ewing sarcoma involving a novel reciprocal inversion-insertion mechanism of EWS-ERG fusion gene formation: a case analysis and literature review

EWS-ERG Ewing sarcoma (ES) gene fusions often result from complex chromosomal rearrangements. We report an unusually aggressive case of ES with an EWS-ERG fusion gene that appeared to be a result of a simple balanced and reciprocal translocation, t(19;22)(q13.2;q12.2). Subsequent molecular investigation of the primary tumor, the metastasis, and a cell line generated from this ES permitted reconstruction of each genomic step in the evolution of this complex EWS-ERG fusion. We elucidated a new mechanism of reciprocal insertion inversion between chromosome 21 and 22, involving cryptic alterations to both the ERG and EWS genes. Molecular cytogenetic investigation, using systematic analysis with locus-specific probes, identified the cognate genomic breakpoints within chromosome 21 and 22, mandatory for the excision and exchange of both 3'ERG and 3'EWS, resulting in the formation of the EWS-ERG fusion gene present on the der(22). Array comparative genomic hybridization and fluorescence in situ hybridization studies of the ES cell line derived from this tumor identified additional acquired chromosomal and genomic abnormalities, likely associated with establishment and adaptation to in vitro growth. Notably, the cell line had lost one copy of the RB1 gene within the 13q13.1 approximately q14.2 region, and also had a near-tetraploid karyotype. The significance of these findings and their relationship to other reports of variant and complex ES translocations involving the ERG gene are reviewed.

Embryonal rhabdomyosarcoma with a der(16)t(1;16) translocation

Embryonal rhabdomyosarcoma (ERMS) is the most common subtype of RMS that predominantly involves the genitourinary tract and the head and neck regions in children younger than 10 years of age. Cytogenetically, ERMS is most frequently hyperdiploid, with extra copies of chromosomes 2, 7, 8, 11, 12, 13, and 20. No consistent structural chromosomal alteration has been identified in ERMS. In contrast, a t(2;13)(q35;q14) or t(1;13)(q36;q14) corresponding to PAX3-FOXO1A (previously FKHR) and PAX7-FOXO1A gene fusions are considered tumor-specific anomalies for alveolar RMS (ARMS). Occasionally, a recurrent secondary structural rearrangement involving chromosomes 1 and 16 is seen in translocation-positive ARMS, a der(16)t(1;16) resulting in an imbalance of 1q and 16q material. Conventional cytogenetic analysis of an ERMS arising in the urinary bladder of a 22-month-old male child revealed this nonrandom secondary chromosomal aberration, der(16)(1;16)(q22;q24), in a hyperdiploid complement with extra copies of chromosomes 2, 7, 8, 10, 12, 13, 19, and 20. Subsequent analyses showed tumor cells to be negative for FOXO1A, PAX3, or PAX7 gene locus rearrangements (by fluorescence in situ hybridization) and also negative for PAX3-FOXO1A and PAX7-FOXO1A fusion transcripts (by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction). These results suggest that the unbalanced t(1;16) translocation may be seen in RMSs lacking a primary genetic rearrangement.

Cytogenetic characterization of Ewing tumors with high-ploidy

The formation of a high-ploidy is rare in Ewing tumor (ET) and is in contrast to some other childhood tumors such as neuroblastoma. In a series of 37 Ewing tumors analyzed by conventional cytogenetics, 4 of the 34 tumors with an abnormal clone (11.8%) demonstrated the presence of a high-ploidy clone, with a chromosome number that ranged from hypotriploid to pentaploid. All 4 contained a t(11;22)(q24;q12) and the karyotypes had further aberrations of the type that would be generally expected in ET. Numerical aberrations represented the majority of the karyotypic events identified and gain of chromosome 8 and loss of chromosomes 3, 10, 16, 19, and 22 occurred in at least 3 tumors. However, no single mechanism could be implicated to explain the karyotypic picture of the 4 cases. It is proposed that high-ploidy subgroups exist in ET and it would be potentially erroneous to group these and other cases together when determining their clinical implications.

High frequency of genomic instability in Ewing family of tumors

We tested Ewing sarcoma tumors for microsatellite instability (MSI) and loss of heterozygosity (LOH) to investigate the role of genomic instability (GI) in this sarcoma. We detected a high frequency of GI (57%), mostly on 1p and 11p, 35% and 30%, respectively. Patients with GI compared to those with stable genome had a median progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) of 24 months and 70 months, compared with 39 and 84 months, respectively. MSI was observed in 48% (11/23) of the tumor samples. Low-MSI (L-MSI) patients (with MSI presented at only one locus) tended to have a better prognosis, 70% PFS, compared with 25% in the high-MSI (H-MSI) group (P=0.13). LOH without MSI did not correlate with progression. H-GI (MSI and/or LOH in > or =30% of tested markers) tended to associate with an adverse prognosis (P=0.28), and correlated significantly with the pelvic site of the primary tumor (P=0.02). The instability of 1p was not associated with progression, while alterations at the 11p locus tended to correlate with a more aggressive disease (P=0.18). Our data suggest that GI may play a role in Ewing sarcoma clinical behavior and outcome.

Inconspicuous insertion 22;12 in myxoid/round cell liposarcoma accompanied by the secondary structural abnormality der(16)t(1;16)

In myxoid/round cell liposarcoma, the t(12;16)(q13;p11) and its associated fusion transcript, FUS-CHOP, characterize greater than 95% of cases. The variant translocation t(12;22)(q13;q12) and associated EWS-CHOP fusion transcript are rare. A second non-random aberration observed in roughly 20% of Ewing's sarcomas, and to a lesser extent other select sarcomas, is the unbalanced 1;16 translocation. Recognition of this secondary aberration in the absence of an obvious primary karyotypic abnormality strongly suggests that the use of other genetic approaches will be informative in uncovering a clinically suspected primary anomaly. The following case illustrates the utility of molecular cytogenetic and reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction techniques in diagnosing an ins(22;12)(q12;q13q14) and associated EWS-CHOP fusion transcript in a myxoid/round cell liposarcoma exhibiting a der(16)t(1;16)(q11;q11).

Prognostic impact of chromosomal aberrations in Ewing tumours

Although greater than 50% of Ewing tumours contain non-random cytogenetic aberrations in addition to the pathognomonic 22q12 rearrangements, little is known about their prognostic significance. To address this question, tumour samples from 134 Ewing tumour patients were analysed using a combination of classical cytogenetics, comparative genomic and fluorescence in situ hybridisation. The evaluation of the compiled data revealed that gain of chromosome 8 occurred in 52% of Ewing tumours but was not a predictive factor for outcome. Gain of 1q was associated with adverse overall survival and event-free survival in all patients, irrespective of whether the tumour was localised or disseminated (overall survival: P=0.002 and P=0.029; event-free survival: P=0.018 and P=0.010). Loss of 16q was a significant predictive factor for adverse overall survival in all patients (P=0.008) and was associated with disseminated disease at diagnosis (P=0.039). Gain of chromosome 12 was associated with adverse event-free survival (P=0.009) in patients with localised disease. These results indicate that in addition to a 22q12 rearrangement confirmation in Ewing tumours it is important to assess the copy number of 1q and 16q to identify patients with a higher probability of adverse outcome.

Acquisition of secondary structural chromosomal changes in pediatric ewing sarcoma is a probable prognostic factor for tumor response and clinical outcome

BACKGROUND

The Ewing sarcoma (ES) group of tumors commonly have the t(11;22)(q24;q12) or other rearrangements involving 22q12. In addition to these consistent aberrations, both numeric and structural aberrations have been reported: namely gains of chromosomes 8 and 12, the unbalanced translocation t(1;16), and deletions at the short arm of chromosome 1.

METHODS

To evaluate the frequency and to study the prognostic implications of some of these aberrations in children, the authors performed a pilot study of 26 ES pediatric patients by classic cytogenetics and/or interphase fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) and compared these data with clinical parameters.

RESULTS

Gains of chromosomes 8 and 12 were detected, by interphase FISH, in 48% (10 of 21) and 38% (6 of 16) of the tumors, respectively, and this was not significant with respect to treatment response. Statistical analysis revealed that the presence of additional secondary structural chromosomal aberrations was associated with an unfavorable outcome (P = 0.0034 as an independent prognostic value as an unfavorable marker). Presence of metastasis at diagnosis also was found to be associated with poor outcome (P = 0.0131). Spectral karyotyping analysis was shown to facilitate the detection of more complex structural chromosomal aberrations in a representative ES tumor.

CONCLUSIONS

It is important to determine whether additional structural chromosomal aberrations are present in ES tumors because it appears that a more complex karyotype with multiple chromosomal aberrations is associated with poor outcome in ES.

Cytogenetic characterization of Ewing tumors using fine needle aspiration samples. a 10-year experience and review of the literature

Chromosomal analysis was performed in fine needle aspiration samples of 98 primary Ewing tumors (ETs) prior to treatment. Among the 58 (59.18%) successful cultures, t(11;22)(q24;q12) was observed in 87.9% and 6.8% had abnormalities other than t(11;22), viz., del(22)(q12), der(16)t(1;16)(q12;q11), and variant t(8;22)(q24;q12). Involvement of breakpoints 1q21, 1q22, 3p14, 16q22, and 17p13 was also observed. Numerical abnormalities such as trisomies 8 and 12 were found in 29.3% and 20.6% and trisomy 18 in 17.2%. An attempt was made to evaluate the role of these additional changes in the process of tumor development, metastasis, and progression of the disease. This is the largest cytogenetic study on ET from a single center using a simple and reliable technique of fine-needle aspiration culture. The literature on cytogenetics of ET is reviewed.

Prognostic impact of deletions at 1p36 and numerical aberrations in Ewing tumors

Ewing's sarcoma, peripheral primitive neuroectodermal tumors, and Askin tumors are referred to as Ewing tumors (ETs), and are characterized by high MIC2 expression and a t(11;22)(q24;q12) or other rearrangements involving 22q12. In addition to these constant aberrations, facultative numerical and structural aberrations have been reported: gains of chromosomes 8 and 12, the unbalanced translocation t(1;16), and deletions at the short arm of chromosome 1. To evaluate the frequency and to study the biological impact of these facultative aberrations, we analyzed tumor specimens from 58 ET patients by classical cytogenetics and/or in situ hybridization techniques and compared these data with clinical parameters. Gains of chromosomes 8 and 12 were detected in 55% (32/58) and 24% (14/58) of the cases, respectively. Loss of chromosome 16 or der (16)t(1;16) chromosomes were found in 20% (10/51); deletions at 1p36 were observed in 18% (9/51) of the cases evaluated. The presence of these aberrations did not correlate with age and sex of the patients, with the location of the primary tumor or with the extent of disease at diagnosis by chi-square analysis and Fisher's exact test. Patients with tumors harboring gains of chromosome 8 showed a slightly better clinical outcome (n = 14/30, P = 0.17), whereas gains of chromosome 12 did not influence the clinical outcome (n = 7/30, P = 0.63). However, Kaplan and Meier analysis revealed that deletions at the short arm of chromosome 1 were associated with an unfavorable outcome in patients with localized disease (n = 6/22; P = 0.004).