A comparative study of human muscle and brain creatine kinases expressed in Escherichia coli

How the ankyrin and SOCS box protein, ASB9, binds to creatine kinase

The ankyrin repeat and SOCS box (ASB) family is composed of 18 proteins and belongs to the suppressor of cytokine signaling (SOCS) box protein superfamily. The ASB proteins function as the substrate-recognition subunits of ECS-type (ElonginBC-Cullin-SOCS-box) Cullin RING E3 ubiquitin ligase (CRL) complexes that specifically transfer ubiquitin to cellular proteins targeting them for degradation by the proteasome. ASB9 binds to creatine kinase (CK) and targets it for degradation; however, the way in which ASB9 interacts with CK is not yet known. We present a complete characterization of the binding of ASB9 to CK. One ASB9 molecule binds to a dimer of CK. The binding affinity of ASB9(1-252) was extremely tight, and no dissociation could be observed. Deletion of the 34 N-terminal amino acids forming ASB9(35-252) resulted in weakening of the binding, so that a binding affinity of 2.6 nM could be measured. Amide hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDXMS) experiments showed that both ASB9(1-252) and ASB9(35-252) protected the same region of CK, residues 182-203, which forms one side of the active site. The HDXMS experiments indicated that the N-terminal disordered region and first ankyrin repeat of ASB9 are protected from exchange in the complex. Molecular docking yielded a structural model consistent with all of the data that suggested the N-terminal residues of ASB9(1-252) may lie in one CK active site. This model was corroborated by enzymatic activity assays and mutational analysis.

Dissimilarity in the folding of human cytosolic creatine kinase isoenzymes

Creatine kinase (CK, EC 2.7.3.2) plays a key role in the energy homeostasis of excitable cells. The cytosolic human CK isoenzymes exist as homodimers (HMCK and HBCK) or a heterodimer (MBCK) formed by the muscle CK subunit (M) and/or brain CK subunit (B) with highly conserved three-dimensional structures composed of a small N-terminal domain (NTD) and a large C-terminal domain (CTD). The isoforms of CK provide a novel system to investigate the sequence/structural determinants of multimeric/multidomain protein folding. In this research, the role of NTD and CTD as well as the domain interactions in CK folding was investigated by comparing the equilibrium and kinetic folding parameters of HMCK, HBCK, MBCK and two domain-swapped chimeric forms (BnMc and MnBc). Spectroscopic results indicated that the five proteins had distinct structural features depending on the domain organizations. MBCK BnMc had the smallest CD signals and the lowest stability against guanidine chloride-induced denaturation. During the biphasic kinetic refolding, three proteins (HMCK, BnMc and MnBc), which contained either the NTD or CTD of the M subunit and similar microenvironments of the Trp fluorophores, refolded about 10-fold faster than HBCK for both the fast and slow phase. The fast folding of these three proteins led to an accumulation of the aggregation-prone intermediate and slowed down the reactivation rate thereby during the kinetic refolding. Our results suggested that the intra- and inter-subunit domain interactions modified the behavior of kinetic refolding. The alternation of domain interactions based on isoenzymes also provides a valuable strategy to improve the properties of multidomain enzymes in biotechnology.

Trehalose has a protective effect on human brain-type creatine kinase during thermal denaturation

We investigated the effects of trehalose on thermal inactivation and aggregation of human brain-type creatine kinase (hBBCK) in this study. In the presence of 1.0 M trehalose, the midpoint temperature of thermal inactivation (T (m)) of hBBCK increased by 4.6 °C, and the activation energy (E (a)) for thermal inactivation increased from 29.7 to 41.1 kJ mol(-1). Intrinsic fluorescence spectra also showed an increase in the apparent transition temperature (T (1/2)) of hBBCK from 43.0 °C to 46.5 °C, 47.7 °C, and 49.9 °C in 0, 0.6, 0.8, and 1.2 M trehalose, respectively. In addition, trehalose significantly blocked the aggregation of hBBCK during thermal denaturation. Our results indicate that trehalose has potential applications as a thermal stabilizer and may aid in the folding of other enzymes in addition to hBBCK.

Isoenzyme-specific thermostability of human cytosolic creatine kinase

Creatine kinase (CK) is a key enzyme involved in intracellular energy homeostasis. The distinct tissue distribution of muscle CK (MMCK) and brain CK (BBCK) implies that they function under conditions facing dissimilar environmental stresses. We found that MMCK and BBCK were significantly different in their stability and reversibility against heat stress. MMCK was more stable than BBCK, and BBCK was only marginally stable and began to inactivate at temperatures just above normal body temperature. The thermal inactivation of MMCK was fully irreversible, whereas that of BBCK was highly reversible at temperatures below 55 degrees C. These differences in stability were proposed to be closely correlated to the isoenzymes' adaptation to the distinct tissue environments.

The role of Arg-96 in Danio rerio creatine kinase in substrate recognition and active center configuration

In creatine kinases (CKs), the amino acid residue-96 is a strictly conserved arginine. This residue is not directly associated with substrate binding, but it is located close to the binding site of the substrate creatine. On the other hand, the residue-96 is known to be involved in expression in the substrate specificity of various other phosphagen (guanidino) kinases, since each enzyme has a specific residue at this position: arginine kinase (Tyr), glycocyamine kinase (Ile), taurocyamine kinase (His) and lombricine kinase (Lys). To gain a greater understanding of the role of residue-96 in CKs, we replaced this residue in zebra fish Danio rerio cytoplasmic CK with other 19 amino acids, and expressed these constructs in Escherichia coli. All the twenty recombinant enzymes, including the wild-type, were obtained as soluble form, and their activities were determined in the forward direction. Compared with the activity of wild-type, the R96K mutant showed significant activity (8.3% to the wild-type), but 10 mutants (R96Y, A, S, E, H, T, F, C, V and N) showed a weak activity (0.056-1.0%). In the remaining mutants (R96Q, G, M, P, L, W, D and I), the activity was less than 0.05%. Our mutagenesis studies indicated that Arg-96 in Danio CK can be substituted for partially by Lys, but other replacements caused remarkable loss of activity. From careful inspection of the crystal structures (transition state analog complex (TSAC) and open state) of Torpedo cytoplasmic CK, we found that the side chain of R96 forms hydrogen bonds with A339 and D340 only in the TSAC structure. Based on the assumption that CKs consist of four dynamic domains (domains 1-3, and fixed domain), the above hydrogen bonds act to link putative domains 1 and 3 in TSAC structure. We suggest that residue-96 in CK and equivalent residues in other phosphagen kinases, which are structurally similar, have dual roles: (1) one involves in distinguishing guanidino substrates, and (2) the other plays a key role in organizing the hydrogen-bond network around residue-96 which offers an appropriate active center for the high catalytic turnover. The mode of development of the network appears to be unique each phosphagen kinase, reflecting evolution of each enzyme.

Cytoplasmic and mitochondrial creatine kinases from the skeletal muscle of sperm whale (Physeter macrocephalus). Molecular cloning and enzyme characterization

We have amplified two cDNAs, coding for creatine kinases (CKs), from the skeletal muscle of sperm whale Physeter macrocephalus by PCR, and cloned these cDNAs into pMAL plasmid. These are the first CK cDNA and deduced amino acid sequences from cetaceans to be reported. One of the two amino acid sequences is a cytoplasmic, muscle-type isoform (MCK), while the other was identified as a sarcomeric, mitochondrial isoform (sMiCK) that included a mitochondrial targeting peptide. The amino acid sequences of sperm whale MCK and sMiCK showed 94-96% sequence identity with corresponding isoforms of mammalian CKs, and all of the key residues necessary for CK function were conserved. The phylogenetic analyses of vertebrate CKs with three independent methods (neighbor-joining, maximum-likelihood and Bayes) supported the clustering of sperm whale MCK with Bos and Sus MCKs, in agreement with the contemporary view that these groups are closely related. Sperm whale MCK and sMiCK were expressed in Escherichia coli as a fusion protein with maltose-binding protein, and the kinetic constants (K (m), K (d) and k (cat)) were determined for the forward reaction. Comparison of kinetic constants with those of human and mouse CKs indicated that sperm whale MCK has a comparable affinity for creatine (K (m) (Cr) = 9.38 mM) to that of human MCK, and the sMiCK has two times higher affinity for creatine than the human enzyme. Both the MCK and sMiCK of sperm whale display a synergistic substrate binding (K (d) /K (m) = 3.1-7.8) like those of other mammalian CKs.

Kinetic analysis of two purified forms of arginine kinase: absence of cooperativity in substrate binding of dimeric phosphagen kinase

Arginine kinase from sea urchin eggs and sea cucumber muscle are dimeric enzymes, unlike the more widely distributed monomeric enzyme found in other invertebrates. Both purified enzymes exhibited features characteristic of the monomeric arginine kinases including pH optima, formation of a catalytic dead-end complex (enzyme-MgADP-arginine) and stabilization of this complex by monovalent anions. A complete analysis of initial velocity data, in both directions for each substrate, indicated that substrate binding cooperativity was either minimal or non-existent. Unlike many other multi-subunit enzymes, the significance of the dimeric state of the phosphagen kinases remains unclear. These present results would suggest that (a) cooperativity, or so-called synergism in substrate binding is not a characteristic of the dimeric state of the protein and (b) the functional significance of the dimeric state is not related to the ability of some of these enzymes to undergo cooperativity in substrate binding. The significance of the dimeric state for the creatine kinases and arginine kinases remains to be established.

Exploring the role of the active site cysteine in human muscle creatine kinase

All known guanidino kinases contain a conserved cysteine residue that interacts with the non-nucleophilic eta1-nitrogen of the guanidino substrate. Site-directed mutagenesis studies have shown that this cysteine is important, but not essential for activity. In human muscle creatine kinase (HMCK) this residue, Cys283, forms part of a conserved cysteine-proline-serine (CPS) motif and has a pKa about 3 pH units below that of a regular cysteine residue. Here we employ a computational approach to predict the contribution of residues in this motif to the unusually low cysteine pKa. We calculate that hydrogen bonds to the hydroxyl and to the backbone amide of Ser285 would both contribute approximately 1 pH unit, while the presence of Pro284 in the motif lowers the pKa of Cys283 by a further 1.2 pH units. Using UV difference spectroscopy the pKa of the active site cysteine in WT HMCK and in the P284A, S285A, and C283S/S285C mutants was determined experimentally. The pKa values, although consistently about 0.5 pH unit lower, were in broad agreement with those predicted. The effect of each of these mutations on the pH-rate profile was also examined. The results show conclusively that, contrary to a previous report (Wang et al. (2001) Biochemistry 40, 11698-11705), Cys283 is not responsible for the pKa of 5.4 observed in the WT V/K(creatine) pH profile. Finally we use molecular dynamics simulations to demonstrate that, in order to maintain the linear alignment necessary for associative inline transfer of a phosphoryl group, Cys283 needs to be ionized.

Heterogeneity of Escherichia coli -expressed human muscle creatine kinase

Creatine kinase (CK) plays an important role in maintaining a constant ATP:ADP ratio during periods of high energy usage. Elevated levels of CK give an early indication of myocardial infarction. The enzyme has four major isozymes with heterogeneity being observed for each of them. In many cases the source of the heterogeneity is unclear. However, some of the isoforms are known to result from exposure to serum proteases, and analysis of the plasma isoforms provides an estimate of the time of onset of the infarction. Somewhat surprisingly, isoelectric focusing (IEF) experiments provided evidence of heterogeneity in human muscle CK (HMCK) expressed in E. coli. To investigate this further, HMCK was purified to apparent homogeneity utilizing Blue Sepharose affinity chromatography and HiPrep Q anion exchange chromatography. Additional purification on a PBE 94 chromatofocusing column resulted in four fractions, three of which, HMCK I - III, were characterized. The three isoforms are all active and have similar kinetic parameters. They exhibited identical bands on SDS PAGE but different anodal mobility on non-denaturing gels. Modification of C-terminal and/or cysteine residues has been ruled out, and deamidation of asparagine or glutamine residue(s) is proposed to be the cause of isoform formation. In addition each of these isoforms showed a similar four-band pattern on a carrier ampholytes-based IEF gel. Two-dimensional IEF analysis showed that an equilibrium was established between the four bands, suggesting that the four components were unstable and generated only when the protein was subjected to IEF.

Comparison of kinetic constants of creatine kinase isoforms

The purpose of this study was to elucidate the functional differences between the CK isoforms by cloning the cDNAs of 12 CK isoforms: the M and B cytoplasmic forms and uMiCK from mouse, the M1, M2 and B cytoplasmic forms from Danio rerio, M1 and M2 cytoplasmic forms from the lower vertebrate Lampetra japonica, a cytoplasmic CK and a MiCK from the marine worm Neanthes diversicolor, and a cytoplasmic CK and a MiCK from the soft coral Dendronephthya gigantea. These were expressed in Escherichia coli as a fusion protein with maltose-binding protein, and kinetic constants (K(m), K(d) and k(cat)) of all the recombinant enzymes, except for the unstable Dendronephthya cytoplasmic CK, were determined for the forward reaction. The kinetic constants of the M- and B-forms of the mouse and Danio cytoplasmic CKs differed significantly, with the K(m) for creatine (K(m)Cr) of M-CK being three- to nine-fold higher than that of B-CK, possibly reflecting differences in the concentration of creatine in muscle and brain cells. The mouse uMiCK had the lowest K(m)Cr value among the CK isoforms. In addition, it also exhibited a strong synergism for substrate binding (K(d)/K(m)=11.8). These results indicate that uMiCK has unique characteristics compared with other CK isoforms. Two subisoforms of M-CK were found in the lower vertebrate L. japonica, and the kinetic constants of recombinant M1- and M2-CKs differed significantly. The M1- and M2-CKs were expressed in skeletal muscle with a ratio of 7:3, while M1-CK was the predominant subisoform in the testis. The kinetic constants of cytoplasmic CK from the marine worm Neanthes were significantly different from those of Neanthes MiCK, possibly indicating that functional differences among CK isoforms occurred at least before the divergence of annelids from other protostome invertebrates.

Loop movement and catalysis in creatine kinase

Recently the crystal structure of creatine kinase from Torpedocalifornica was determined to 2.1 A. The dimeric structure revealed two different forms in the unit cell: one monomer was bound to a substrate, MgADP, and the other monomer was bound to a transition-state analogue complex composed of MgADP, nitrate and creatine. The most striking difference between the structures is the movement of two loops (comprising residues 60-70 and residues 323-333) into the active site in the transition state structure. This loop movement effectively occludes the active site from solvent, and the loops appear to be locked into place by a salt bridge formed between His66 and Asp326. His66 is of particular interest as it is located within a PGHP motif conserved in all creatine kinases but not found in other guanidino kinases. We have carried out alanine-scanning mutagenesis of each of the residues in the PGHP motif and determined that only the His66 plays a significant role in the creatine kinase reaction. Although neither residue interacts directly with the substrate, the interaction His66 and Asp326 appears to be important in providing the precise alignment of substrates necessary for phosphoryl group transfer. Finally, it is clear that neither His66 nor Asp326 are responsible for the pKs observed in the pH-rate profile for HMCK.

Relating structure to mechanism in creatine kinase

Found in all vertebrates, creatine kinase catalyzes the reversible reaction of creatine and ATP forming phosphocreatine and ADP. Phosphocreatine may be viewed as a reservoir of "high-energy phosphate" which is able to supply ATP, the primary energy source in bioenergetics, on demand. Consequently, creatine kinase plays a significant role in energy homeostasis of cells with intermittently high energy requirements. The enzyme is of clinical importance and its levels are routinely used as an indicator of myocardial and skeletal muscle disorders and for the diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction. First identified in 1928, the enzyme has undergone intensive investigation for over 75 years. There are four major isozymes, two cytosolic and two mitochondrial, which form dimers and octamers, respectively. Depending on the pH, the enzyme operates by a random or an ordered bimolecular mechanism, with the equilibrium lying towards phosphocreatine production. Evidence suggests that conversion of creatine to phosphocreatine occurs via the in-line transfer of a phosphoryl group from ATP. A recent X-ray structure of creatine kinase bound to a transition state analog complex confirmed many of the predictions based on kinetic, spectroscopic, and mutagenesis studies. This review summarizes and correlates the more significant mechanistic and structural studies on creatine kinase.

Amino acid residues 62 and 193 play the key role in regulating the synergism of substrate binding in oyster arginine kinase

The purpose of this study is to clarify the amino acid residues responsible for the synergism in substrate binding of arginine kinase (AK), a key enzyme in invertebrate energy metabolism. AKs contain a pair of highly conserved amino acids (D62 and R193) that form an ion pair, and replacement of these residues can cause a pronounced loss of activity. Interestingly, in the oyster Crassostrea AK, these residues are replaced by an N and a K, respectively. Despite this replacement, the enzyme retains high activity and moderate synergism in substrate binding (Kd/Km=2.3). We replaced the N62 by G or D and the K193 by G or R in Crassostrea AK, and also constructed the double mutants of N62G/K193G and N62D/K193R. All of the mutants retained 50-90% of the wild-type activity. In N62G and N62D mutants, the Kmarg for arginine binding was comparable to that of wild-type enzyme, but the Kdarg was increased 2-5-fold, resulting in a strong synergism (Kd/Km=4.9-11.3). On the other hand, in K193G and K193R mutants, the Kmarg was increased 4-fold, and synergism was lost almost completely (Kd/Km=1.0-1.4). The N62G/K193G double mutant showed similar characteristics to the K193G and K193R mutants. Another double mutant, N62D/K193R, similar to the amino acid pair in the wild-type enzyme, had characteristics similar to those of the wild-type enzyme. These results indicate that the amino acid residues 62 and 193 play the key role in mediating the synergism in substrate binding of oyster arginine kinase.

Expression of Torpedo californica creatine kinase in Escherichia coli and purification from inclusion bodies

The pET17 expression vector was used to express creatine kinase from the electric organ of Torpedo californica as inclusion bodies in Escherichia coli BL21(DE3) cells. The insoluble aggregate was dissolved in 8M urea and, following extraction with Triton X-100, the enzyme was refolded by dialysis against Tris buffer (pH 8.0) containing 0.2M NaCl. After two buffer changes, chromatography on Blue Sepharose was used as a final step in the purification procedure. Approximately 54mg active protein was recovered from a 1L culture and the refolded enzyme had a specific activity of 75U/mg. The molecular mass of the purified protein was consistent with that predicted from the amino acid sequence and the CD spectrum of the refolded enzyme was essentially identical to that of creatine kinase from human muscle (HMCK). The K(m) values of ATP and ADP were also similar to those of HMCK, while the K(m) values for both phosphocreatine and creatine were approximately 5-10-fold higher. The purification described here is in marked contrast with earlier attempts at purification of this isozyme where, in a process yielding less than 1mg/L culture, enzyme with a specific activity of ca. 5U/mg was obtained.