DR2 antigens are associated with severity of disease in toxic oil syndrome (TOS)

The Use of Deceased Controls in Epidemiologic Research: A Systematic Review

Scholarly debate on the use of deceased controls in epidemiologic research continues. This systematic review examined published epidemiologic research using deceased persons as a control group. A systematic search of 5 major biomedical literature databases (MEDLINE, CINAHL, PsycINFO, Scopus, and EMBASE) was conducted, using variations of the search terms "deceased" and "controls" to identify relevant peer-reviewed journal articles. Information was sought on study design, rationale for using deceased controls, application of theoretical principles of control selection, and discussion of the use of deceased controls. The review identified 134 studies using deceased controls published in English between 1978 and 2015. Common health outcomes under investigation included cancer (n = 31; 23.1%), nervous system diseases (n = 26; 19.4%), and injury and other external causes (n = 22; 16.4%). The majority of studies used deceased controls for comparison with deceased cases (n = 95; 70.9%). Investigators rarely presented their rationale for control selection (n = 25/134; 18.7%); however, common reasons included comparability of information on exposures, lack of appropriate controls from other sources, and counteracting bias associated with living controls. Comparable accuracy was the most frequently observed principle of control selection (n = 92; 68.7%). This review highlights the breadth of research using deceased controls and indicates their appropriateness in studies using deceased cases.

Proteomics of toxic oil syndrome in humans: Phenotype distribution in a population of patients

OBJECTIVES

Toxic oil syndrome (TOS) is a disease that appeared in Spain in 1981. Epidemiological work traced the origin to the ingestion of aniline-adulterated rapeseed oil, fraudulently marketed and sold as edible oil. It affected more than 20,000 people with over 400 deaths in the first 2 years. In 2001 evidence was presented that genetic factors could play a role in the susceptibility of individuals to the disease. Thus, a prospective study on the differences in gene expression in sera between control versus TOS-affected populations, both originally exposed to the toxic oil, was undertaken in our laboratory.

METHODS

Differential protein expression was analyzed by two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE). Problems related with serum analysis by 2-DE were addressed to improve protein detection in the gel images. Three new commercial systems for albumin depletion were tested to optimize the detection of minor proteins. The use of nonionic reductants or the presence of thiourea in the gels, were also tested.

RESULTS

From the resulting optimized images, a group of 329 major gel spots was located, matched and compared with serum samples. Thirty-five of these protein spots were found to be under- or over-expressed in TOS patients (threefold increase or decrease). Proteins in these spots were identified by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight (MALDI-TOF) peptide map fingerprinting and database search. Several haptoglobin (Hp) isoforms were found to be differentially expressed, showing expression phenotypes that could be related with TOS. Resolution of the homologous α-1s and α-1f chains, with a mass difference of only 0.043Da, was obtained after guanidation of the protein with O-methylisourea. We applied this procedure to the study of the distribution of the Hp alleles HP(2), HP(1s) and HP(1f) in control versus TOS-affected populations. The MALDI-TOF proteotyping method was validated by a parallel analysis of the serum samples by 2-DE.

CONCLUSIONS

Data obtained from 54 TOS cases and 48 controls indicate significant differences in the distribution of Hp phenotypes in the two populations. Haptoglobin phenotypes have been reported to have biological and clinical consequences and have been described as risk factors for several diseases. Consequently, it was concluded that haptoglobin polymorphism could play a role in TOS.

Genetic approaches in the understanding of Toxic Oil Syndrome

The Toxic Oil Syndrome (TOS) is a multisystemic disease that occurred in Spain in 1981 due to the ingestion of rapeseed oil denatured with 2% aniline. Female prevalence and the different clinical evolution even inside the same family (similar exposition), pointed to genetic implications. Furthermore, HLA-DR2 was increased in patients dead because of TOS. Th2 activation and eosinophilia implicated immunological mechanisms. For those reasons we firstly decided, to do a genome-wide search by linkage mapping set along the chromosome 6 (where HLA loci are located), to identify loci associated to the TOS development. The design was case-control-matched (n = 328). By this procedure, microsatellite (near to HLA) was related with the patients. After fine-mapping around this marker, we defined four more closely related to TOS-, , and . Secondly, we analysed in 420 patients, the association of these four markers with 14 TOS clinical phenotypes. We demonstrated that alveolar infiltration, liver disease and scleroderma are clearly associated with . As conclusion, we have identified in chromosome 6, a region where are located some genes related with autoimmune diseases, associated with certain TOS phenotypes, pointing out the possible role of autoimmune reactions in the pathogenesis of the disease.

Toxic oil syndrome: Genetic restriction and immunomodulatory effects due to adulterated oils in a model of HLA transgenic mice

Toxic oil syndrome (TOS) was described in Spain in 1981, due to the ingestion of contaminated rapeseed oil denatured with 2% aniline. More than 20,000 persons were affected, causing over 2500 deaths. Immunological findings were: eosinophilia, mRNA for Th2 cytokines (IL-4 and IL-5) in lungs, elevated total IgE and sIL-2R and increase of DR2 HLA class II phenotypic frequency in patients died by TOS. Our objective is to test the genetic restriction found in humans using HLA transgenic mice. Results show that mice expressing human DR2 and DQ6 (both in linkage disequilibrium), had higher percentage of eosinophils (DQ6) and IgE (DR2) than other transgenic mice tested (DR3 and DR4). Also, a Th2 shift was found in DR2 transgenic mice when toxic oil was administered with OVA. This has been corroborated by the IL-5 mRNA expression in 4 out of 6 lung tissues from TOS oil treated BALB/c mice. These data indicate that an immunological response was induced as consequence of the toxic administration. These results correlate with those found in TOS patients and reinforce the implication of genetic restrictions in the acquisition of toxic-mediated disease.

Revisión de los aspectos éticos en la investigación biomédica: la experiencia del Comité de Ética del Centro de Investigación sobre el Síndrome del Aceite Tóxico y Enfermedades Raras (CISATER)

This Field Note aims to make known the decisions taken by the Ethics Committee of the Instituto de Salud Carlos III for Toxic Oil Syndrome regarding the secondary use of research specimens in biological research when informed consent is lacking. This is a common concern in the field of biomedical research. After debating the ethical suitability of the secondary use of these samples, our main conclusion is that researchers conducting prospective studies should expressly solicit written informed consent from participants in the study about i) whether there will or could be any secondary use of the samples and, if so, ii) whether such secondary use would be conditional on the type of research.

Molecular analysis of HLA-DRB1 polymorphism in north-east Spain

The DRB1* polymorphism in 941 randomly selected individuals from the Umbilical Cord Blood Bank of Barcelona (92.75% of Spanish origin) was determined by sequence-based typing. The HLA profile was similar to that of other Mediterranean populations, with DRB1*0701 and *0301 being the most frequent alleles. This may be a consequence of the mixture of alleles as a result of migration from contiguous geographical areas.