Effects of remobilization on rat femur are dose-dependent

A feasibility study for a pragmatic randomised controlled trial comparing cast immobilisation versus no immobilisation for patients following first-time patellar dislocation

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this feasibility study was to begin to determine the efficacy of cylinder cast immobilisation compared to no form of immobilisation for patients following first-time patellar dislocation (FTPD).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Participants were patients who attended a National Health Service Accident and Emergency department following a FTPD. Patients were randomised to receive immobilisation for four weeks in a cylinder cast followed by rehabilitation, versus no immobilisation and early rehabilitation. All patients were followed-up over a three month period, assessed using the Visual analogue scale for pain, Short Form-36, the Lysholm knee score and the Modified Functional Index.

RESULTS

Forty-one patients were approached to participate. Eight satisfied the pre-defined eligibility criteria and were randomised between the two groups. Whilst the results indicated a trend for superior short-term functional outcomes for those patients not immobilised compared to those immobilised following a FTPD, the small sample and baseline imbalances between the groups may have had a substantial influence on the results.

CONCLUSION

This feasibility study has indicated that the outcome measurements adopted were appropriate to answer this research question, but the assessment of return to normal activity, recurrent instability and dislocation and cost-effectiveness over a longer follow-up period is recommended. Similarly, defining a more pragmatic eligibility criteria and recruiting from multiple centres would be recommended for the definitive trial requiring a sample of 348 patients to demonstrate a statistical significant treatment effect.

The effects of loading and estrogen on rat bone growth

This study evaluated the contributions of locomotive loading and estrogen to the development of diaphysis of rat femur. A randomized 2 × 2 study design was used. Altogether, 70 female Sprague-Dawley rats were used, of which 10 were euthanized at entry. Of the remaining rats, 16 served as controls, and the rest, 44, underwent a unilateral sciatic neurectomy. The effect of estrogen was removed by ovariectomizing one-half of the neurectomized rats. After 27 wk, the animals were euthanized, and the femora were excised. Irrespective of loading or estrogen, the femur length and mineral mass increased by 142 and 687%, respectively. Axial growth was not modulated either by locomotive loading or estrogen, but the loading resulted in direction-specific changes in the cross-sectional geometry. The estrogen-related gains were evident on the endocortical surface, while the loading-related gains occurred on the periosteal surface. The loading and estrogen were significantly associated with increased bone strength (21 and 15%, respectively) in the mediolateral direction, but not in the anteroposterior direction. Axial growth and accrual of bone mineral mass of the rat femur are largely independent of locomotive loading or estrogen, whereas these factors specifically account for the femur function, as either a mechanical lever or a mineral reservoir for reproduction, respectively.

Exercise and the preservation of bone health

Exercise is generally accepted as having favorable effects on bone health and, subsequently, a reduction in fracture risk. In the absence of large randomized controlled trials of the potential benefits of exercise on fracture risk, support for this belief comes from cross-sectional studies and interventional studies using surrogate endpoints such as bone mineral density and falls. In this review, we discuss the characteristics of exercise programs that provide an osteogenic stimulus. The goals and benefits of exercise on bone across the age spectrum are discussed. Where there is a paucity of human data, animal studies examining the roles of variables such as exercise intensity, frequency, duration, and mode in shaping the response of bone to exercise are discussed. The effects of disuse and the limited response of bone to remobilization are described. The rapid and dramatic decrease in bone mineral density observed in the early period after heart or lung transplantation is discussed, as are the available data on the benefits of exercise on bone in this population. For cardiopulmonary rehabilitation programs to improve bone health, they should include not just weight-supported activities (eg, cycling) but also weight-bearing activities (eg, walking, resistance exercise). Although the optimal exercise routine for bone health is unknown, components of an osteogenic program are discussed.

A comparison of bone mineral density in adolescent female swimmers, soccer players, and weight lifters

PURPOSE

The study was designed to examine the effect of sports of varying skeletal loading on bone density in adolescent female athletes.

METHODS

Bone mineral densities of female swimmers, soccer players, and weight lifters were examined. Between-sport comparisons were made using a one-way analysis of covariance with age and body mass index as covariates and group bone mass density (BMD) was compared to the World Health Organization's (WHO) normative values for adult females.

RESULTS

BMD was significantly greater in the soccer group compared to the weight lifting (p = 0.025) and swimming groups (p = 0.001) with no difference between weight-lifting and swimming groups (p = 0.209). Compared to normative data from the WHO, soccer was the only sport whose participants' BMDs were significantly greater than adult norms (p = 0.003), while those of the swimmers were significantly less (p < 0.001) than adult females, and the weight lifters were not different (p = 0.103).

CONCLUSIONS

Participation in sports such as soccer or weight lifting with significant skeletal loading may enhance BMD in adolescent females.

Mechanical signals regulating extracellular matrix gene expression in fibroblasts

Mechanical forces are essential for connective tissue homeostasis. The extracellular matrix (ECM) plays a key role in the transmission of forces generated by the organism (e.g. muscle contraction) and externally applied (e.g. gravity). The expression of specific ECM proteins such as collagens and tenascin-C, as well as of matrix metalloproteinases, involved in their turnover, is influenced by mechanical stimuli. The precise mechanisms by which mechanical strains are translated into chemical signals and lead to differential gene expression are however not fully understood. Cell-matrix adhesion sites are good candidates for hosting a "mechanosensory switch", as they transmit forces from the ECM to the cytoskeleton and vice versa by physically linking the cytoskeleton to the ECM. Integrins, transmembrane proteins located to these adhesion sites, have been shown to trigger a set of internal signaling cascades after mechanical stimulation. We have shown that the expression level of tenascin-C directly correlates with externally applied mechanical stress, as well as with RhoA/RhoA-dependent kinase-mediated cytoskeletal tension. Presumably other genes are regulated in a similar manner. The changes in ECM composition and mechanical properties derived from mechanical stress are relevant in medical intervention after ligament and tendon injury.

Bone defect repair in immobilization-induced osteopenia: a pQCT, biomechanical, and molecular biologic study in the mouse femur

The present study was carried out to determine whether immobilization-induced (Im) osteopenic bone possesses the same reparative capacity as normal healthy bone. Furthermore, the effects of mechanical loading versus immobilization on bone defect healing were studied. Three-week cast-immobilization was used to induce local osteopenia in mice. A standardized metaphyseal bone defect of the distal femur was created unilaterally both in immobilization-induced (Im) osteopenic mice and in nonimmobilized (Mo) age-matched control animals. After creation of the bone defect, the animals in both groups were further divided into two groups: 3-week cast-immobilization (Im-Im and Mo-Im) groups, and unrestricted weight-bearing (Im-Mo and Mo-Mo) groups. The healing process was followed up to 3 weeks using RNA analysis, histomorphometry, biomechanical testing, and pQCT measurements. At 3 weeks of healing without immobilization, bone mineral density (BMD), as well as bone bending stiffness and strength were higher in normal (Mo-Mo) than in osteopenic (Im-Mo) bone. Although the levels of mRNAs characteristic to chondrocytes (Sox9 and type II collagen), hypertrophic chondrocytes (Type X collagen), osteoblasts (type I collagen and osteocalcin), and osteoclasts (cathepsin K) during the bone defect healing exhibited similarities in their expression profiles, mechanical loading conditions also caused characteristic differences. Mechanical loading during healing (Mo-Mo group) induced stronger expression of cartilage- and bone-specific genes and resulted in higher BMD than that seen in the cast-immobilized group (Mo-Im). In biomechanical analysis, increased bending stiffness and strength were also observed in animals that were allowed weight-bearing during healing. Thus, our study shows that bone healing follows the same molecular pathway both in osteopenic and normal bones and presents evidence for reduced or delayed regeneration of noncritical size defects in immobilization-induced osteopenic bone.

Femoral neck response to exercise and subsequent deconditioning in young and adult rats

Aged bones have been considered to have reduced capacity to respond to changes in incident loading. By subjecting young and adult rats to increased loading and subsequent deconditioning, we observed quantitatively similar adaptive responses of bone in these two groups, but young skeletons adapted primarily through geometric changes and adult bones through increased volumetric density. Loss of the exercise-induced bone benefits did not depend on age.

INTRODUCTION

Aging has been shown to decrease the sensitivity of the mechanosensory cells of bones to loading-induced stimuli, presumably resulting in not only reduced capacity but also different adaptive mechanism of the aged skeleton to altered loading, as well as poorer capacity to preserve exercise-induced bone benefits.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fifty young (5-week-old) and 50 adult (33-week-old) male rats were randomized into control and exercise (+deconditioning) groups. After a 14-week progressively intensified running program, one-half of the exercised rats (both young and adult) were killed, and the remaining rats underwent subsequent 14-week period of deconditioning (free cage activity). A comprehensive analysis of the femoral neck was performed using peripheral quantitative computed tomography and mechanical testing.

RESULTS

In comparison with the controls, both young and adult exercised rats had significant increases in almost all measured parameters: +25% (p < 0.001) and +10% (not significant [NS]) in the cross-sectional area; +28% (p < 0.001) and +18% (p < 0.001) in bone mineral content; +11% (p < 0.05) and +23% (p < 0.001) in bone mineral density; and +30% (p < 0.01) and +28% (p < 0.01) in the breaking load, respectively. The skeletal responses were not statistically different between the young and adult rats. After the 14-week period of deconditioning, the corresponding exercised-to-controls differences were +17% (p < 0.05) and +10% (NS), +18% (p < 0.05) and +13% (p < 0.05), +2% (NS) and +2% (NS), and +11% (NS) and +6% (NS), respectively. Again, the response differences were not significant between the age groups.

CONCLUSION

Quantitatively, the capacity of the young and adult skeleton to adapt to increased loading was similar, but the adaptive mechanisms appeared different: growing bones seemed to primarily display geometric changes (increase in bone size), whereas the adult skeleton responded mainly through an increase in density. Despite this apparent difference in the adaptive mechanism, aging did not modulate the ability of the skeleton to preserve the exercise-induced bone gain, because the bone loss was similar in the young and adult rats after cessation of training.

The bone gain induced by exercise in puberty is not preserved through a virtually life-long deconditioning: a randomized controlled experimental study in male rats

To investigate the controversial issue whether exercise-induced positive effects on bone can be maintained after cessation of exercise, 100 5-week-old male Sprague-Dawley rats were used to assess the effects of long-term exercise (EX, treadmill running) and subsequent deconditioning (DC, free cage activity) on the femoral neck and femoral midshaft. At entry, the rats were randomly assigned into eight groups: four control groups (C14, C28, C42, and C56), and four exercise groups (EX, EX + DC14, EX + DC28, and EX + DC42). Rats in the exercise groups were first subjected to a 14-week period of progressively intensifying running, after which the rats of group EX were killed and the remaining exercise groups (EX + DC14, EX + DC28, and EX + DC42) were allowed to move freely in their cages for a subsequent deconditioning period of 14, 28, or 42 weeks, whereas control rats were kept free in their cages for the entire study period (0-56 weeks) and killed with their respective exercise group. At each time point, a comprehensive analysis of the femoral neck and midshaft characteristics (peripheral quantitative computed tomography analysis and fracture load [Fmax]) was performed. In comparison with their age-matched controls, 14 weeks of treadmill training resulted in significant (p < 0.05) increases in all measured femoral neck parameters of the growing male rats (i.e., +25% in total cross-sectional area [tCSA], +28% in total bone mineral content [tBMC], +11% in total bone mineral density [tBMD], and +30% in Fmax). On the contrary, no exercise-induced positive effects were seen in femoral midshaft. The exercise-induced benefits in the femoral neck were partially maintained during the deconditioning period of 14 weeks, the tCSA being + 17%, tBMC + 18% (both p < 0.05), and the Fmax + 11% (p = 0.066) higher in the exercised group than control group. However, after 42 weeks of deconditioning, these benefits were eventually lost. In conclusion, exercise through the period of the fastest skeletal growth results in significant improvements in size, mineral mass, and strength of the femoral neck of male rats. However, these exercise-induced bone benefits are eventually lost if exercise is completely ceased, and thus, continued training is probably needed to maintain the positive effects of youth exercise into adulthood. Further studies should focus on assessing the minimal level of activity needed to maintain the exercise-induced bone gains.