Evolutionary significance of autogenous regulation

In praise of erroneous hypotheses

In the sixties Cove and Pateman discovered that mutants of Aspergillus nidulans lacking nitrate reductase activity were constitutive for the expression of genes induced by nitrate and dependent on the transcription factor NirA. They proposed that the nitrate protein acted as a repressor, preventing the transcription factor activity of NirA. Nitrate-mediated regulation behaved similarly in other organisms. This "autogenous regulation hypothesis" has recently shown to be erroneous, in the very organism for which it was first proposed. Nevertheless this erroneous hypothesis have led to a thorough dissection of the process of regulation of nitrate assimilation and more importantly to a hypothesis bearing on the origin of metabolite-responsive transcription factors. In this article I discuss the heuristic value and evolutionary importance of autogenous regulation.

Sequence and structural differences between enzyme and nonenzyme homologs

To improve our understanding of the evolution of novel functions, we performed a sequence, structural, and functional analysis of homologous enzymes and nonenzymes of known three-dimensional structure. In most examples identified, the nonenzyme is derived from an ancestral catalytic precursor (as opposed to the reverse evolutionary scenario, nonenzyme to enzyme), and the active site pocket has been disrupted in some way, owing to the substitution of critical catalytic residues and/or steric interactions that impede substrate binding and catalysis. Pairwise sequence identity is typically insignificant, and almost one-half of the enzyme and nonenzyme pairs do not share any similarity in function. Heterooligomeric enzymes comprising homologous subunits in which one chain is catalytically inactive and enzyme polypeptides that contain internal catalytic and noncatalytic duplications of an ancient enzyme domain are also discussed.

The molecular biology of multidomain proteins. Selected examples

The aim of this review is to give an overview of the contribution molecular biology can make to an understanding of the functions and interactions within multidomain proteins. The contemporary advantages ascribed to multidomain proteins include (a) the potential for metabolite channelling and the protection of unstable intermediates; (b) the potential for interactions between domains catalysing sequential steps in a metabolic pathway, thereby giving the potential for allosteric interactions; and (c) the facility to produce enzymic activities in a fixed stoichiometric ratio. The alleged advantages in (a) and (b) however apply equally well to multi-enzyme complexes; therefore, specific examples of these phenomena are examined in multidomain proteins to determine whether the proposed advantages are apparent. Some transcription-regulating proteins active in the control of metabolic pathways are composed of multiple domains and their control is exerted and modulated at the molecular level by protein-DNA, protein-protein and protein-metabolite interactions. These complex recognition events place strong constraints upon the proteins involved, requiring the recognition of and interaction with different classes of cellular metabolites and macromolecules. Specific examples of transcription-regulating proteins are examined to probe how their multidomain nature facilitates a general solution to the problem of multiple recognition events. A general unifying theme that emerges from these case studies is that a basic unitary design of modules provided by enzymes is exploited to produce multidomain proteins by a complex series of gene duplication and fusion events. Successful modules provided by enzymes are co-opted to new function by selection apparently acting upon duplicated copies of the genes encoding the enzymes. In multidomain transcription-regulating proteins, former enzyme modules can be recruited as molecular sensors that facilitate presumed allosteric interactions necessary for the molecular control of transcription.

On the early emergence of reverse transcription: theoretical basis and experimental evidence

Reverse transcriptase (RT) was first discovered as an essential catalyst in the biological cycle of retroviruses. However, in the past years evidence has accumulated showing that RTs are involved in a surprisingly large number of RNA-mediated transpositional events that include both viral and nonviral genetic entities. Although it is probable that some RT-bearing genetic elements like the different types of AIDS viruses and the mammalian LINE family have arisen in recent geological times, the possibility that reverse transcription first took place in the early Archean is supported by (1) the hypothesis that RNA preceded DNA as cellular genetic material; (2) the existence of homologous regions of the subunit tau of the E. coli DNA polymerase III with the simian immunodeficiency virus RT, the hepatitis B virus RT, and the beta' subunit of the E. coli RNA polymerase (McHenry et al. 1988); (3) the presence of several conserved motifs, including a 14-amino-acid segment that consists of an Asp-Asp pair flanked by hydrophobic amino acids, which are found in all RTs and in most cellular and viral RNA polymerases. However, whether extant RTs descend from the primitive polymerase involved in the RNA-to-DNA transition remains unproven. Substrate specificity of the AMV and HIV-1 RTs can be modified in the presence of Mn2+, a cation which allows them to add ribonucleotides to an oligo (dG) primer in a template-dependent reaction. This change in specificity is comparable to that observed under similar conditions in other nucleic acid polymerases. This experimentally induced change in RT substrate specificity may explain previous observations on the misincorporation of ribonucleotides by the Maloney murine sarcoma virus RT in the minus and plus DNA of this retrovirus (Chen and Temin 1980). Our results also suggest that HIV-infected macrophages and T-cell cells may contain mixed polynucleotides containing both ribo- and deoxyribonucleotides. The evolutionary significance of these changes in substrate specificities of nucleic acid polymerases is also discussed.

Phosphoribosylpyrophosphate synthetase is elevated in fibroblasts from patients with the Lesch-Nyhan syndrome

In subconfluent cultures of fibroblasts from patients with complete or partial deficiencies of hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase, phosphoribosylpyrophosphate synthetase activity is elevated. The abnormally high catalytic activity of the synthetase appears to account for the overproduction of purines by the cultured mutant cells and presumably for that by the patients.

Pyrimidine biosynthesis in Aspergillus nidulans: isolation and preliminary characterisation of auxotrophic mutants

113 pyrimidine auxotrophs, unable to synthesise UMP have been selected in Aspergillus nidulans. These mutants can be classified by complementation into eight groups, and genetic analysis has shown that five loci are involved. One complex locus consists of the mutually complementing pyrA, pyrB and pyrC groups, as well as the cis-dominant pyrN group, members of which do not complement with members of the A, B or C groups. pyrA mutants have been shown to lack CPSase-ur, pyrB and pyrC mutants have been shown to lack ACTase, and pyrN to lack both these enzymes. This locus appears to code for products which form an enzyme aggregate. The four simple loci, as well as the complex loci have been located genetically, and distinguished from one another on the basis of accumulation of pyrimidine precursors in vivo. The synthesis of ACTase has been shown to subject to end-product repression.