Substrate-assisted catalysis as a mechanism for GTP hydrolysis of p21ras and other GTP-binding proteins

Reflections on the Origin of Coded Protein Biosynthesis

The principle of continuity posits that some central features of primordial biocatalytic mechanisms should still be present in the genetically dependent pathway of protein synthesis, a crucial step in the emergence of life. Key bimolecular reactions of this process are catalyzed by DNA-dependent RNA polymerases, aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, and ribosomes. Remarkably, none of these biocatalysts contribute chemically active groups to their respective reactions. Instead, structural and functional studies have demonstrated that nucleotidic α-phosphate and β-d-ribosyl 2' OH and 3' OH groups can help their own catalysis, a process which, consequently, has been called "substrate-assisted". Furthermore, upon binding, the substrates significantly lower the entropy of activation, exclude water from these catalysts' active sites, and are readily positioned for a reaction. This binding mode has been described as an "entropy trap". The combination of this effect with substrate-assisted catalysis results in reactions that are stereochemically and mechanistically simpler than the ones found in most modern enzymes. This observation is consistent with the way in which primordial catalysts could have operated; it may also explain why, thanks to their complementary reactivities, β-d-ribose and phosphate were naturally selected to be the central components of early coding polymers.

High Pressure Promotes Binding of the Allosteric Inhibitor Zn2+-Cyclen in Crystals of Activated H-Ras

In this work, we experimentally investigate the potency of high pressure to drive a protein toward an excited state where an inhibitor targeted for this state can bind. Ras proteins are small GTPases cycling between active GTP-bound and inactive GDP-bound states. Various states of GTP-bound Ras in active conformation coexist in solution, amongst them, state 2 which binds to effectors, and state 1, weakly populated at ambient conditions, which has a low affinity for effectors. Zn2+-cyclen is an allosteric inhibitor of Ras protein, designed to bind specifically to the state 1. In H-Ras(wt).Mg2+.GppNHp crystals soaked with Zn2+-cyclen, no binding could be observed, as expected in the state 2 conformation which is the dominant state at ambient pressure. Interestingly, Zn2+-cyclen binding is observed at 500 MPa pressure, close to the nucleotide, in Ras protein that is driven by pressure to a state 1 conformer. The unknown binding mode of Zn2+-cyclen to H-Ras can thus be fully characterized in atomic details. As a more general conjunction from our study, high pressure x-ray crystallography turns out to be a powerful method to induce transitions allowing drug binding in proteins that are in low-populated conformations at ambient conditions, enabling the design of specific inhibitors.

Crystal structure of phosphate bound Acyl phosphatase mini-enzyme from Deinococcus radiodurans at 1Å resolution

Acylphosphatase (Acp) is a hydrolase which specifically cleaves carboxyl-phosphate bond of intermediates of metabolic pathways. It is a small cytosolic enzyme found in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms. Previous crystal structures of acylphosphatase from different organisms have provided insights into the active site but the complete understanding of substrate binding and catalytic mechanisms in acylphosphatase remain elusive. Here we report the crystal structure of phosphate bound acylphosphatase from a mesothermic bacterium, Deinococcus radiodurans (drAcp) at resolution of 1.0 Å. Our structural analysis shows how the terminal phosphate group of substrates is bound to the active site, highlighting the importance of arginine in substrate recognition, role of asparagine in mode of catalysis and shedding light on the reaction mechanism. Additionally, the protein can refold after thermal melting by gradually lowering the temperature. To further explore the dynamics of drAcp, molecular dynamics simulation of drAcp and homologs from thermophilic organisms were carried out which revealed similar root mean square fluctuation profile but drAcp showed comparatively higher fluctuations.

Biochemical Characterization of a Human Septin Octamer

Septins are part of the cytoskeleton and polymerize into non-polar filaments of heteromeric hexamers or octamers. They belong to the class of P-loop GTPases but the roles of GTP binding and hydrolysis on filament formation and dynamics are not well understood. The basic human septin building block is the septin rod, a hetero-octamer composed of SEPT2, SEPT6, SEPT7, and SEPT9 with a stoichiometry of 2:2:2:2 (2-6-7-9-9-7-6-2). Septin rods polymerize by end-to-end and lateral joining into linear filaments and higher ordered structures such as rings, sheets, and gauzes. We purified a recombinant human septin octamer from E. coli for in vitro experimentation that is able to polymerize into filaments. We could show that the C-terminal region of the central SEPT9 subunit contributes to filament formation and that the human septin rod decreases the rate of in vitro actin polymerization. We provide further first kinetic data on the nucleotide uptake- and exchange properties of human hexameric and octameric septin rods. We could show that nucleotide uptake prior to hydrolysis is a dynamic process and that a bound nucleotide is exchangeable. However, the hydrolyzed γ-phosphate is not released from the native protein complex. We consequently propose that GTP hydrolysis in human septins does not follow the typical mechanism known from other small GTPases.

Elucidating microscopic events driven by GTP hydrolysis reaction in the Ras-GAP system with semi-reactive molecular dynamics simulations: the alternative role of a phosphate binding loop for mechanical energy storage

ATPase and GTPase have been widely found as chemical energy-mechanical work transducers, whereas the physicochemical mechanisms are not satisfactorily understood. We addressed the problem by examining John Ross' conjecture that repulsive Coulomb interaction between ADP/GDP and inorganic phosphate (P_i) does the mechanical work upon the system. We effectively simulated the consequence of a GTP hydrolysis reaction in a complex system of Rat sarcoma (Ras) and GTPase activation protein (GAP) in the framework of classical molecular dynamics by switching force field parameters between the reactant and product systems. We then observed a ca. 5 kcal mol^-1 increase of potential energy about the phosphate-binding loop (P-loop) in the Ras protein, indicating that the mechanical work generated via the GTP hydrolysis is converted into the local interaction energy and stored in the P-loop. Interestingly, this local energy storage in the P-loop depends on neither impulsive nor consecutive collisions of GDP and P_i with the P-loop. Instead, GTP-GDP conversion itself does work on the Ras system, elevating the potential energy. These observations encourage us to challenge a conjecture previously given by Ross. We assert that triphosphate nucleotide hydrolyses do mechanical work by producing emergent steric interaction accompanied by relaxation, namely, a shift of the biomolecular system to the non-equilibrium state on the reshaped potential energy landscape. Recalling the universality of the P-loop motif among GTPases and ATPases, the observations that we obtained through this study would progress the physicochemical understanding of the operating principles of GTP/ATP hydrolysis-driven biological nano-machines.

The CTPase activity of ParB determines the size and dynamics of prokaryotic DNA partition complexes

ParB-like CTPases mediate the segregation of bacterial chromosomes and low-copy number plasmids. They act as DNA-sliding clamps that are loaded at parS motifs in the centromere of target DNA molecules and spread laterally to form large nucleoprotein complexes serving as docking points for the DNA segregation machinery. Here, we solve crystal structures of ParB in the pre- and post-hydrolysis state and illuminate the catalytic mechanism of nucleotide hydrolysis. Moreover, we identify conformational changes that underlie the CTP- and parS-dependent closure of ParB clamps. The study of CTPase-deficient ParB variants reveals that CTP hydrolysis serves to limit the sliding time of ParB clamps and thus drives the establishment of a well-defined ParB diffusion gradient across the centromere whose dynamics are critical for DNA segregation. These findings clarify the role of the ParB CTPase cycle in partition complex assembly and function and thus advance our understanding of this prototypic CTP-dependent molecular switch.

Peculiarities in Activation of Hydrolytic Activity of Elongation Factors

Translational GTPases (trGTPases) belong to the family of G proteins and play key roles at all stages of protein biosynthesis on the ribosome. Unidirectional and cyclic functioning of G proteins is ensured by their ability to switch between the active and inactive states due to GTP hydrolysis accelerated by the auxiliary GTPase-activating proteins. Although trGTPases interact with the ribosomes in different conformational states, they bind to the same conserved region, which, unlike in classical GTPase-activating proteins, is represented by ribosomal RNA. The resulting catalytic sites have almost identical structure in all elongation factors suggesting a common mechanism of GTP hydrolysis. However, fine details of the activated state formation and significantly different rates of GTP hydrolysis indicate the existence of distinctive features upon GTP hydrolysis catalyzed by the different factors. Here, we present a contemporary view on the mechanism of GTPase activation and GTP hydrolysis by the elongation factors EF-Tu, EF-G, and SelB based on the analysis of structural, biochemical, and bioinformatics data.

Structural impact of GTP binding on downstream KRAS signaling

Oncogenic RAS proteins, involved in ∼30% of human tumors, are molecular switches of various signal transduction pathways. Here we apply a new protocol for the NMR study of KRAS in its (inactive) GDP- and (activated) GTP-bound form, allowing a comprehensive analysis of the backbone dynamics of its WT-, G12C- and G12D variants. We found that Tyr32 shows opposite mobility with respect to the backbone of its surroundings: it is more flexible in the GDP-bound form while more rigid in GTP-complexes (especially in WT- and G12D-GTP). Using the G12C/Y32F double mutant, we showed that the presence of the hydroxyl group of Tyr32 has a marked effect on the G12C-KRAS-GTP system as well. Molecular dynamics simulations indicate that Tyr32 is linked to the γ-phosphate of GTP in the activated states – an arrangement shown, using QM/MM calculations, to support catalysis. Anchoring Tyr32 to the γ-phosphate contributes to the capture of the catalytic waters participating in the intrinsic hydrolysis of GTP and supports a simultaneous triple proton transfer step (catalytic water → assisting water → Tyr32 → O1G of the γ-phosphate) leading to straightforward product formation. The coupled flip of negatively charged residues of switch I toward the inside of the effector binding pocket potentiates ligand recognition, while positioning of Thr35 to enter the coordination sphere of the Mg²⁺ widens the pocket. Position 12 mutations do not disturb the capture of Tyr32 by the γ-phosphate, but (partially) displace Gln61, which opens up the catalytic pocket and destabilizes catalytic water molecules thus impairing intrinsic hydrolysis.

Nucleotide exchange to the physiological, activated, GTP-bound form of KRAS results in the anchoring of Tyr32 within the active site.

RasGRP2 Structure, Function and Genetic Variants in Platelet Pathophysiology

RasGRP2 is calcium and diacylglycerol-regulated guanine nucleotide exchange factor I that activates Rap1, which is an essential signaling-knot in "inside-out" αIIbβ3 integrin activation in platelets. Inherited platelet function disorder caused by variants of RASGRP2 represents a new congenital bleeding disorder referred to as platelet-type bleeding disorder-18 (BDPLT18). We review here the structure of RasGRP2 and its functions in the pathophysiology of platelets and of the other cellular types that express it. We will also examine the different pathogenic variants reported so far as well as strategies for the diagnosis and management of patients with BDPLT18.

Diversity of mechanisms in Ras-GAP catalysis of guanosine triphosphate hydrolysis revealed by molecular modeling

The mechanism of the deceptively simple reaction of guanosine triphosphate (GTP) hydrolysis catalyzed by the cellular protein Ras in complex with the activating protein GAP is an important issue because of the significance of this reaction in cancer research. We show that molecular modeling of GTP hydrolysis in the Ras-GAP active site reveals a diversity of mechanisms of the intrinsic chemical reaction depending on molecular groups at position 61 in Ras occupied by glutamine in the wild-type enzyme. First, a comparison of reaction energy profiles computed at the quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) level shows that an assignment of the Gln61 side chain in the wild-type Ras either to QM or to MM parts leads to different scenarios corresponding to the glutamine-assisted or the substrate-assisted mechanisms. Second, replacement of Gln61 by the nitro-analog of glutamine (NGln) or by Glu, applied in experimental studies, results in two more scenarios featuring the so-called two-water and the concerted-type mechanisms. The glutamine-assisted mechanism in the wild-type Ras-GAP, in which the conserved Gln61 plays a decisive role, switching between the amide and imide tautomer forms, is consistent with the known experimental results of structural, kinetic and spectroscopy studies. The results emphasize the role of the Ras residue Gln61 in Ras-GAP catalysis and explain the retained catalytic activity of the Ras-GAP complex towards GTP hydrolysis in the Gln61NGln and Gln61Glu mutants of Ras.

Insight into the mechanism of allosteric activation of PI3Kα by oncoprotein K-Ras4B

Ras is a key member in the superfamily of small GTPase. Transforming between GTP-bound active state and GDP-bound inactive state in response to exogenous signals, Ras serves as a binary switch in various signaling pathways. One of its downstream effectors is phosphatidylinositol-4,5-bisphosphate 3-kinase α (PI3Kα), which phosphorylates phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate into phosphatidylinositol 3,4,5-trisphosphate in the PI3K/Akt/mTOR pathway and mediates an array of important cellular activities including cell growth, migration and survival. Hyperactivation of PI3Kα induced by the Ras isoform K-Ras4B has been unveiled as a key event during the oncogenesis of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma, but the underlying mechanism of how K-Ras4B allosterically activates PI3Kα still remains largely unsolved. Here, we employed accelerated molecular dynamic simulations and allosteric pathway analysis to explore into the activation process of PI3Kα by K-Ras4B and unraveled the underlying structural mechanisms. We found that K-Ras4B binding induced more conformational dynamics within PI3Kα and triggered its step-wise transition from a self-inhibited state towards an activated state. Moreover, K-Ras4B binding markedly disrupted the interactions along the p110/p85 interface, especially the ones between nSH2 in p85 and its nearby functional domains in p110 like C2, helical, and kinase domains. The altered inter-domain interactions exposed the kinase domain, which promoted the membrane association and substrate phosphorylation of PI3Kα, thereby facilitating its activation. In particular, the community networks and allosteric pathways analysis further revealed that in PI3Kα/K-Ras4B system, allosteric signaling regulating p110/p85 interaction was rewired from the helical domain to the kinase domain and several important residues and their related allosteric pathways mediating PI3Kα autoinhibition were bypassed. The obtained structural mechanisms provide an in-depth mechanistic insight into the allosteric activation of PI3Kα by K-Ras4B as well as shed light on its drug discovery.

GTP Hydrolysis Without an Active Site Base: A Unifying Mechanism for Ras and Related GTPases

GTP hydrolysis is a biologically crucial reaction, being involved in regulating almost all cellular processes. As a result, the enzymes that catalyze this reaction are among the most important drug targets. Despite their vital importance and decades of substantial research effort, the fundamental mechanism of enzyme-catalyzed GTP hydrolysis by GTPases remains highly controversial. Specifically, how do these regulatory proteins hydrolyze GTP without an obvious general base in the active site to activate the water molecule for nucleophilic attack? To answer this question, we perform empirical valence bond simulations of GTPase-catalyzed GTP hydrolysis, comparing solvent- and substrate-assisted pathways in three distinct GTPases, Ras, Rab, and the G_αi subunit of a heterotrimeric G-protein, both in the presence and in the absence of the corresponding GTPase activating proteins. Our results demonstrate that a general base is not needed in the active site, as the preferred mechanism for GTP hydrolysis is a conserved solvent-assisted pathway. This pathway involves the rate-limiting nucleophilic attack of a water molecule, leading to a short-lived intermediate that tautomerizes to form H₂PO₄^- and GDP as the final products. Our fundamental biochemical insight into the enzymatic regulation of GTP hydrolysis not only resolves a decades-old mechanistic controversy but also has high relevance for drug discovery efforts. That is, revisiting the role of oncogenic mutants with respect to our mechanistic findings would pave the way for a new starting point to discover drugs for (so far) "undruggable" GTPases like Ras.

Biochemical and kinetic properties of the complex Roco G-protein cycle

Roco proteins have come into focus after mutations in the gene coding for the human Roco protein Leucine-rich repeat kinase 2 (LRRK2) were discovered to be one of the most common genetic causes of late onset Parkinson's disease. Roco proteins are characterized by a Roc domain responsible for GTP binding and hydrolysis, followed by a COR dimerization device. The regulation and function of this RocCOR domain tandem is still not completely understood. To fully biochemically characterize Roco proteins, we performed a systematic survey of the kinetic properties of several Roco protein family members, including LRRK2. Together, our results show that Roco proteins have a unique G-protein cycle. Our results confirm that Roco proteins have a low nucleotide affinity in the micromolar range and thus do not strictly depend on G-nucleotide exchange factors. Measurement of multiple and single turnover reactions shows that neither Pi nor GDP release are rate-limiting, while this is the case for the GAP-mediated GTPase reaction of some small G-proteins like Ras and for most other high affinity Ras-like proteins, respectively. The KM values of the reactions are in the range of the physiological GTP concentration, suggesting that LRRK2 functioning might be regulated by the cellular GTP level.

Hybrid QM/MM vs Pure MM Molecular Dynamics for Evaluating Water Distribution within p21N-ras and the Resulting GTP Electronic Density

p21^ras protein activity, regulated by GTP hydrolysis, constitutes an active field of research for the development of cancer targeted therapies that would concern ∼30% of human tumors to which specific mutations have been associated. Indeed, the catalyzing mechanisms provided by the protein environment during GTP hydrolysis and how they are impaired by specific mutations remain to be fully elucidated. In this article, we present results from molecular mechanics (MM) molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and density functional theory (DFT) calculations carried out for wild-type p21 ^N-ras and six Gln 61 mutants. In the first part, we present the water distribution within the active site of the wild-type protein according to MM MD. Significant differences are observed when comparing the results to the previous distribution assessed through quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) MD. Such method-dependent results highlight the importance of accounting for the electrostatic coupling between the protein complex and the solvent molecules in identifying hydration sites. In the second part, we present the results from DFT calculations performed to determine the electronic distribution of the GTP ligand, considering the wild-type active site arrangement according to both classical and hybrid approaches. Only in the QM/MM-based configuration is the ligand electronic density similar to that of a GDP-like state observed experimentally. For this reason, in the last set of calculations carried out for p21 ^N-ras Gln 61 mutants, only the active site structural conformations obtained through hybrid MD are considered. Through the analysis of the GTP electronic density, we conclude that the wild-type active site arrangement according to QM/MM MD is closer to a catalytically efficient conformation of the protein than the arrangement according to MM MD. Hence, water distribution according to the hybrid approach must correspond to the optimal placement of solvent in the active site. Within all of the studied Gln 61 substituted proteins, p21^ras major catalyzing effect, which consists of stabilizing a more GDP-like state, is lost.

Roco Proteins: GTPases with a Baroque Structure and Mechanism

Mutations in leucine-rich repeat kinase 2 (LRRK2) are a common cause of genetically inherited Parkinson’s Disease (PD). LRRK2 is a large, multi-domain protein belonging to the Roco protein family, a family of GTPases characterized by a central RocCOR (Ras of complex proteins/C-terminal of Roc) domain tandem. Despite the progress in characterizing the GTPase function of Roco proteins, there is still an ongoing debate concerning the working mechanism of Roco proteins in general, and LRRK2 in particular. This review consists of two parts. First, an overview is given of the wide evolutionary range of Roco proteins, leading to a variety of physiological functions. The second part focusses on the GTPase function of the RocCOR domain tandem central to the action of all Roco proteins, and progress in the understanding of its structure and biochemistry is discussed and reviewed. Finally, based on the recent work of our and other labs, a new working hypothesis for the mechanism of Roco proteins is proposed.

Two symmetric arginine residues play distinct roles in Thermus thermophilus Argonaute DNA guide strand-mediated DNA target cleavage

Bacterium Thermus thermophilus Argonaute (Ago; TtAgo) is a prokaryotic Ago (pAgo) that acts as the host defense against the uptake and propagation of foreign DNA by catalyzing the DNA cleavage reaction. The TtAgo active site consists of a plugged-in glutamate finger with two arginine residues (R545 and R486) located symmetrically around it. An interesting challenge is to understand how they can collaboratively facilitate enzymatic catalysis. In Kluyveromyces polysporus Ago, a eukaryotic Ago, the evolutionarily symmetrical residues are arginine and histidine, both of which function to stabilize the plugged-in catalytic tetrad conformation. Surprisingly, our simulation results indicated that, in TtAgo, only R545 is involved in the cleavage reaction by serving as a critical structural anchor to stabilize the catalytic tetrad Asp-Glu-Asp-Asp that is completed by the insertion of the glutamate finger, whereas R486 is not involved in target cleavage. The TtAgo-mediated target DNA cleavage occurs in a substrate-assisted mechanism, in which the pro-Rp (Rp, a tetrahedral phosphorus center with "R-type" chirality) oxygen of scissile phosphate acts as a general base to activate the nucleophilic water. Our unexpected theoretical findings on distinct roles played by R545 and R486 in TtAgo catalysis have been validated by single-point site-mutagenesis experiments, wherein the target cleavage is abolished for all mutants of R545. In sharp contrast, the cleavage activity is maintained for all mutants of R486. Our work provides mechanistic insights on the catalytic specificity of Ago proteins and could facilitate the design of new gene-editing tools in the long term.

Quantitative Measurement of Intrinsic GTP Hydrolysis for Carcinogenic Glutamine 61 Mutants in H-Ras

Mutations of human oncoprotein p²¹H-Ras (hereafter "Ras") at glutamine 61 are known to slow the rate of guanosine triphosphate (GTP) hydrolysis and transform healthy cells into malignant cells. It has been hypothesized that this glutamine plays a role in the intrinsic mechanism of GTP hydrolysis by interacting with an active site water molecule that stabilizes the formation of the charged transition state at the γ-phosphate during hydrolysis. However, there is no comprehensive data set of the effects of mutations to Q61 on the protein's intrinsic catalytic rate, structure, or interactions with water at the active site. Here, we present the first comprehensive and quantitative set of initial rates of intrinsic hydrolysis for all stable variants of RasQ61X. We further conducted enhanced molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of each construct to determine the solvent accessible surface area (SASA) of the side chain at position 61 and compared these results to previously measured changes in electric fields caused by RasQ61X mutations. For polar and negatively charged residues, we found that the rates are normally distributed about an optimal electrostatic contribution, close to that of the native Q61 residue, and the rates are strongly correlated to the number of waters in the active site. Together, these results support a mechanism of GTP hydrolysis in which Q61 stabilizes a transient hydronium ion, which then stabilizes the transition state while the γ-phosphate is undergoing nucleophilic attack by a second, catalytically active water molecule. We discuss the implications of such a mechanism on future strategies for combating Ras-based cancers.

Amide-imide tautomerization in the glutamine side chain in enzymatic and photochemical reactions in proteins

Amide-imide tautomerization presents a pervasive class of chemical transformations in organic chemistry of natural compounds. In this Perspective, we describe two distinctively different protein systems, in which the amide-imide tautomerization in the glutamine side chain takes place in enzymatic or photochemical reactions. First, hydrolysis of guanosine triphosphate (GTP) catalyzed by the Ras-GAP protein complex suggests the occurrence of the imide tautomer of glutamine in reaction intermediates. Second, photoexcitation of flavin-binding protein domains (BLUFs) initiates a chain of reactions in the chromophore-binding pocket, including amide-imide tautomerization of glutamine. Mechanisms of these reactions at the atomic level have been revealed in quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) simulations. To reinforce conclusions on the critical role of amide-imide tautomerization of glutamine in these reactions we describe results of new quantum chemistry and QM/MM calculations for relevant molecular model systems. We reexamine results of the recent IR spectroscopy studies of BLUF domains, which provide experimental evidences of Gln tautomerization in proteins. We also propose to validate the glutamine-assisted mechanism of enzymatic GTP hydrolysis by using IR spectroscopy in a proper range of wavenumbers.

Water Distribution within Wild-Type NRas Protein and Q61 Mutants during Unrestrained QM/MM Dynamics

Point mutations in p21^ras are associated with ∼30% of human tumors by disrupting its GTP hydrolysis cycle, which is critical to its molecular switch function in cellular signaling pathways. In this work, we investigate the impact of Gln 61 substitutions in the structure of the p21^N-ras active site and particularly focus on water reorganization around GTP, which appears to be crucial to evaluate favorable and unfavorable hydration sites for hydrolysis. The NRas-GTP complex is analyzed using a hybrid quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics approach, treating for the first time to our knowledge transient water molecules at the ab initio level and leading to results that account for the electrostatic coupling between the protein complex and the solvent. We show that for the wild-type protein, water molecules are found around the GTP γ-phosphate group, forming an arch extended from residues 12 to 35. Two density peaks are observed, supporting previous results that suggest the presence of two water molecules in the active site, one in the vicinity of residue 35 and a second one stabilized by hydrogen bonds formed with nitrogen backbone atoms of residues 12 and 60. The structural changes observed in NRas Gln 61 mutants result in the drastic delocalization of water molecules that we discuss. In mutants Q61H and Q61K, for which water distribution is overlocalized next to residue 60, the second density peak supports the hypothesis of a second water molecule. We also conclude that Gly 60 indirectly participates in GTP hydrolysis by correctly positioning transient water molecules in the protein complex and that Gln 61 has an indirect steric effect in stabilizing the preorganized catalytic site.

Specific Substates of Ras To Interact with GAPs and Effectors: Revealed by Theoretical Simulations and FTIR Experiments

The oncogenic Ras protein adopts various specific conformational states to execute its function in signal transduction. The large number of Ras structures obtained from X-ray and NMR experiments illustrates the diverse conformations that Ras adopts. It is difficult, however, to connect specific structural features with Ras functions. We report the free-energy landscape of Ras·GTP based on extensive explicit solvent simulations. The free-energy map clearly shows that the functional state 2 of Ras·GTP in fact has two distinct substates, denoted here as "Tyr32_in" and "Tyr32_out". Unbiased MD simulations show that the two substrates interconvert on the submicrosecond scale in solution, pointing to a novel mechanism for Ras·GTP to selectively interact with GAPs and effectors. This proposal is further supported by time-resolved FTIR experiments, which demonstrate that Tyr32 destabilizes the Ras·GAP complex and facilitates an efficient termination of Ras signaling.

Challenges and advances in the computational modeling of biological phosphate hydrolysis

Phosphate ester hydrolysis is fundamental to many life processes, and has been the topic of substantial experimental and computational research effort. However, even the simplest of phosphate esters can be hydrolyzed through multiple possible pathways that can be difficult to distinguish between, either experimentally, or computationally. Therefore, the mechanisms of both the enzymatic and non-enzymatic reactions have been historically controversial. In the present contribution, we highlight a number of technical issues involved in reliably modeling these computationally challenging reactions, as well as proposing potential solutions. We also showcase examples of our own work in this area, discussing both the non-enzymatic reaction in aqueous solution, as well as insights obtained from the computational modeling of organophosphate hydrolysis and catalytic promiscuity amongst enzymes that catalyze phosphoryl transfer.

The protonation states of GTP and GppNHp in Ras proteins

The small GTPase Ras transmits signals in a variety of cellular signaling pathways, most prominently in cell proliferation. GTP hydrolysis in the active center of Ras acts as a prototype for many GTPases and is the key to the understanding of several diseases, including cancer. Therefore, Ras has been the focus of intense research over the last decades. A recent neutron diffraction crystal structure of Ras indicated a protonated γ-guanylyl imidodiphosphate (γ-GppNHp) group, which has put the protonation state of GTP in question. A possible protonation of GTP was not considered in previously published mechanistic studies. To determine the detailed prehydrolysis state of Ras, we calculated infrared and NMR spectra from quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) simulations and compared them with those from previous studies. Furthermore, we measured infrared spectra of GTP and several GTP analogs bound to lipidated Ras on a membrane system under near-native conditions. Our findings unify results from previous studies and indicate a structural model confirming the hypothesis that γ-GTP is fully deprotonated in the prehydrolysis state of Ras.

Computer simulations of the catalytic mechanism of wild-type and mutant β-phosphoglucomutase

β-Phosphoglucomutase (β-PGM) has served as an important model system for understanding biological phosphoryl transfer.

Phosphoryl Transfer Reaction in RNA: Is the Substrate-Assisted Catalysis a Possible Mechanism in Certain Solvents?

A proton shuttle mechanism for the phosphoryl transfer reaction in RNA, in which a proton is transferred from the nucleophile to the leaving group through a nonbridged oxygen atom of the phosphate, was explored using the MO6-2X density functional method and the solvent continuum model. This reaction is the initial step of the RNA hydrolysis. We used different solvents characterized by their dielectric constant, and, for each of them, we studied the nuclear and electronic relaxation, produced by the solvent reaction field, for the stationary points. Given that RNA has a poor leaving group, the bond breaking corresponds to the rate-determining step. If the O atom is substituted by a S atom, the leaving group is now good, and the rate-determining step is now the nucleophilic attack concerted with the proton transfer. The most relevant result we found is that none of the solvents we studied has a free energy of activation that is smaller than the one in water. This suggests that the enzyme catalysis following this mechanism must be due to the permanent electric field that is created by a preorganized charge distribution but not to the solvent reaction field.

Elucidation of Single Hydrogen Bonds in GTPases via Experimental and Theoretical Infrared Spectroscopy

Time-resolved Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy is a powerful tool to elucidate label-free the reaction mechanisms of proteins. After assignment of the absorption bands to individual groups of the protein, the order of events during the reaction mechanism can be monitored and rate constants can be obtained. Additionally, structural information is encoded into infrared spectra and can be decoded by combining the experimental data with biomolecular simulations. We have determined recently the infrared vibrations of GTP and guanosine diphosphate (GDP) bound to Gα_i1, a ubiquitous GTPase. These vibrations are highly sensitive for the environment of the phosphate groups and thereby for the binding mode the GTPase adopts to enable fast hydrolysis of GTP. In this study we calculated these infrared vibrations from biomolecular simulations to transfer the spectral information into a computational model that provides structural information far beyond crystal structure resolution. Conformational ensembles were generated using 15 snapshots of several 100 ns molecular-mechanics/molecular-dynamics (MM-MD) simulations, followed by quantum-mechanics/molecular-mechanics (QM/MM) minimization and normal mode analysis. In comparison with other approaches, no time-consuming QM/MM-MD simulation was necessary. We carefully benchmarked the simulation systems by deletion of single hydrogen bonds between the GTPase and GTP through several Gα_i1 point mutants. The missing hydrogen bonds lead to blue-shifts of the corresponding absorption bands. These band shifts for α-GTP (Gα_i1-T48A), γ-GTP (Gα_i1-R178S), and for both β-GTP/γ-GTP (Gα_i1-K46A, Gα_i1-D200E) were found in agreement in the experimental and the theoretical spectra. We applied our approach to open questions regarding Gα_i1: we show that the GDP state of Gα_i1 carries a Mg²⁺, which is not found in x-ray structures. Further, the catalytic role of K46, a central residue of the P-loop, and the protonation state of the GTP are elucidated.

The effect of magnesium ions on triphosphate hydrolysis

The role of metal ions in catalyzing phosphate ester hydrolysis has been the subject of much debate, both in terms of whether they change the transition state structure or mechanistic pathway. Understanding the impact of metal ions on these biologically critical reactions is central to improving our understanding of the role of metal ions in the numerous enzymes that facilitate them. In the present study, we have performed density functional theory studies of the mechanisms of methyl triphosphate and acetyl phosphate hydrolysis in aqueous solution to explore the competition between solvent- and substrate-assisted pathways, and examined the impact of Mg2+ on the energetics and transition state geometries. In both cases, we observe a clear preference for a more dissociative solvent-assisted transition state, which is not significantly changed by coordination of Mg2+. The effect of Mg2+ on the transition state geometries for the two pathways is minimal. While our calculations cannot rule out a substrate-assisted pathway as a possible solution for biological phosphate hydrolysis, they demonstrate that a significantly higher energy barrier needs to be overcome in the enzymatic reaction for this to be an energetically viable reaction pathway.

Review: Translational GTPases

Translational GTPases (trGTPases) play key roles in facilitating protein synthesis on the ribosome. Despite the high degree of evolutionary conservation in the sequences of their GTP-binding domains, the rates of GTP hydrolysis and nucleotide exchange vary broadly between different trGTPases. EF-Tu, one of the best-characterized model G proteins, evolved an exceptionally rapid and tightly regulated GTPase activity, which ensures rapid and accurate incorporation of amino acids into the nascent chain. Other trGTPases instead use the energy of GTP hydrolysis to promote movement or to ensure the forward commitment of translation reactions. Recent data suggest the GTPase mechanism of EF-Tu and provide an insight in the catalysis of GTP hydrolysis by its unusual activator, the ribosome. Here we summarize these advances in understanding the functional cycle and the regulation of trGTPases, stimulated by the elucidation of their structures on the ribosome and the progress in dissecting the reaction mechanism of GTPases. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 105: 463-475, 2016.

Drugging Ras GTPase: a comprehensive mechanistic and signaling structural view

Ras proteins are small GTPases, cycling between inactive GDP-bound and active GTP-bound states. Through these switches they regulate signaling that controls cell growth and proliferation. Activating Ras mutations are associated with approximately 30% of human cancers, which are frequently resistant to standard therapies. Over the past few years, structural biology and in silico drug design, coupled with improved screening technology, led to a handful of promising inhibitors, raising the possibility of drugging Ras proteins. At the same time, the invariable emergence of drug resistance argues for the critical importance of additionally honing in on signaling pathways which are likely to be involved. Here we overview current advances in Ras structural knowledge, including the conformational dynamic of full-length Ras in solution and at the membrane, therapeutic inhibition of Ras activity by targeting its active site, allosteric sites, and Ras-effector protein-protein interfaces, Ras dimers, the K-Ras4B/calmodulin/PI3Kα trimer, and targeting Ras with siRNA. To mitigate drug resistance, we propose signaling pathways that can be co-targeted along with Ras and explain why. These include pathways leading to the expression (or activation) of YAP1 and c-Myc. We postulate that these and Ras signaling pathways, MAPK/ERK and PI3K/Akt/mTOR, act independently and in corresponding ways in cell cycle control. The structural data are instrumental in the discovery and development of Ras inhibitors for treating RAS-driven cancers. Together with the signaling blueprints through which drug resistance can evolve, this review provides a comprehensive and innovative master plan for tackling mutant Ras proteins.

Theoretical vibrational spectroscopy of intermediates and the reaction mechanism of the guanosine triphosphate hydrolysis by the protein complex Ras-GAP

The structures and vibrational spectra of the reacting species upon guanosine triphosphate (GTP) hydrolysis to guanosine diphosphate and inorganic phosphate (Pi) trapped inside the protein complex Ras-GAP were analyzed following the results of QM/MM simulations. The frequencies of the phosphate vibrations referring to the reactants and to Pi were compared to those observed in the experimental FTIR studies. A good correlation between the theoretical and experimental vibrational data provides a strong support to the reaction mechanism of GTP hydrolysis by the Ras-GAP enzyme system revealed by the recent QM/MM modeling. Evolution of the vibrational bands associated with the inorganic phosphate Pi during the elementary stages of GTP hydrolysis is predicted.

Invited review: Small GTPases and their GAPs

Widespread utilization of small GTPases as major regulatory hubs in many different biological systems derives from a conserved conformational switch mechanism that facilitates cycling between GTP-bound active and GDP-bound inactive states under control of guanine nucleotide exchange factors (GEFs) and GTPase activating proteins (GAPs), which accelerate slow intrinsic rates of activation by nucleotide exchange and deactivation by GTP hydrolysis, respectively. Here we review developments leading to current understanding of intrinsic and GAP catalyzed GTP hydrolytic reactions in small GTPases from structural, molecular and chemical mechanistic perspectives. Despite the apparent simplicity of the GTPase cycle, the structural bases underlying the hallmark hydrolytic reaction and catalytic acceleration by GAPs are considerably more diverse than originally anticipated. Even the most fundamental aspects of the reaction mechanism have been challenging to decipher. Through a combination of experimental and in silico approaches, the outlines of a consensus view have begun to emerge for the best studied paradigms. Nevertheless, recent observations indicate that there is still much to be learned. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 105: 431-448, 2016.

(19)F NMR and DFT Analysis Reveal Structural and Electronic Transition State Features for RhoA-Catalyzed GTP Hydrolysis

Molecular details for RhoA/GAP catalysis of the hydrolysis of GTP to GDP are poorly understood. We use (19)F NMR chemical shifts in the MgF3(-) transition state analogue (TSA) complex as a spectroscopic reporter to indicate electron distribution for the γ-PO3(-) oxygens in the corresponding TS, implying that oxygen coordinated to Mg has the greatest electron density. This was validated by QM calculations giving a picture of the electronic properties of the transition state (TS) for nucleophilic attack of water on the γ-PO3(-) group based on the structure of a RhoA/GAP-GDP-MgF3(-) TSA complex. The TS model displays a network of 20 hydrogen bonds, including the GAP Arg85' side chain, but neither phosphate torsional strain nor general base catalysis is evident. The nucleophilic water occupies a reactive location different from that in multiple ground state complexes, arising from reorientation of the Gln-63 carboxamide by Arg85' to preclude direct hydrogen bonding from water to the target γ-PO3(-) group.

Ras Conformational Ensembles, Allostery, and Signaling

Ras proteins are classical members of small GTPases that function as molecular switches by alternating between inactive GDP-bound and active GTP-bound states. Ras activation is regulated by guanine nucleotide exchange factors that catalyze the exchange of GDP by GTP, and inactivation is terminated by GTPase-activating proteins that accelerate the intrinsic GTP hydrolysis rate by orders of magnitude. In this review, we focus on data that have accumulated over the past few years pertaining to the conformational ensembles and the allosteric regulation of Ras proteins and their interpretation from our conformational landscape standpoint. The Ras ensemble embodies all states, including the ligand-bound conformations, the activated (or inactivated) allosteric modulated states, post-translationally modified states, mutational states, transition states, and nonfunctional states serving as a reservoir for emerging functions. The ensemble is shifted by distinct mutational events, cofactors, post-translational modifications, and different membrane compositions. A better understanding of Ras biology can contribute to therapeutic strategies.

Theoretical Insights on the Mechanism of the GTP Hydrolysis Catalyzed by the Elongation Factor Tu (EF-Tu)

The purpose of this work is to have a better understanding of the mechanism of GTP hydrolysis catalyzed by the elongation factor Tu. Two main aspects are being discussed in the literature: the associative or dissociative character of the process and the nature of nucleophile activation. The calculations of the QM subsystem have been done by means of the M06-2X density functional and the split valence triple-ζ 6-311+G(d,p) basis set. The environmental effect has been introduced through the continuum SMD method. We have studied three models of increasing complexity in order to analyze the different factors that intervene in the catalytic action. The results obtained in this paper confirm that the protonated His84 plays a fundamental role in the catalytic mechanism, but we have also found that the crystallographic sodium ion has a notable effect in the catalysis. So, our work has permitted a new insight, complementary to those obtained with QM/MM calculations, into this very complex process.

Neutron Crystal Structure of RAS GTPase Puts in Question the Protonation State of the GTP γ-Phosphate

RAS GTPase is a prototype for nucleotide-binding proteins that function by cycling between GTP and GDP, with hydrogen atoms playing an important role in the GTP hydrolysis mechanism. It is one of the most well studied proteins in the superfamily of small GTPases, which has representatives in a wide range of cellular functions. These proteins share a GTP-binding pocket with highly conserved motifs that promote hydrolysis to GDP. The neutron crystal structure of RAS presented here strongly supports a protonated γ-phosphate at physiological pH. This counters the notion that the phosphate groups of GTP are fully deprotonated at the start of the hydrolysis reaction, which has colored the interpretation of experimental and computational data in studies of the hydrolysis mechanism. The neutron crystal structure presented here puts in question our understanding of the pre-catalytic state associated with the hydrolysis reaction central to the function of RAS and other GTPases.

Exceptionally large entropy contributions enable the high rates of GTP hydrolysis on the ribosome

Protein synthesis on the ribosome involves hydrolysis of GTP in several key steps of the mRNA translation cycle. These steps are catalyzed by the translational GTPases of which elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) is the fastest GTPase known. Here, we use extensive computer simulations to explore the origin of its remarkably high catalytic rate on the ribosome and show that it is made possible by a very large positive activation entropy. This entropy term (TΔS(‡)) amounts to more than 7 kcal/mol at 25 °C. It is further found to be characteristic of the reaction mechanism utilized by the translational, but not other, GTPases and it enables these enzymes to attain hydrolysis rates exceeding 500 s(-1). This entropy driven mechanism likely reflects the very high selection pressure on the speed of protein synthesis, which drives the rate of each individual GTPase towards maximal turnover rate of the whole translation cycle.

Catalytic Mechanism of Mammalian Adenylyl Cyclase: A Computational Investigation

Adenylyl cyclase (AC) catalyzes the synthesis of cyclic AMP, an important intracellular regulatory molecule, from ATP. We propose a catalytic mechanism for class III mammalian AC based on density functional theory calculations. We employ a model of the AC active site derived from a crystal structure of mammalian AC activated by Gα·GTP and forskolin at separate allosteric sites. We compared the calculated activation free energies for 13 possible reaction sequences involving proton transfer, nucleophilic attack, and elimination of pyrophosphate. The proposed most probable mechanism is initiated by deprotonation of 3'OH and water-mediated transfer of the 3'H to the γ-phosphate. Proton transfer is followed by changes in coordination of the two magnesium ion cofactors and changes in the conformation of ATP to enhance the role of 3'O as a nucleophile and to bring 3'O close to Pα. The subsequent phosphoryl transfer step is concerted and rate-limiting. Comparison of the enzyme-catalyzed and nonenzymatic reactions reveals that the active site residues lower the free energy barrier for both phosphoryl transfer and proton transfer and significantly shift the proton transfer equilibrium. Calculations for mutants K1065A and R1029A demonstrate that K1065 plays a significant role in shifting the proton transfer equilibrium, whereas R1029 is important for making the transition state of concerted phosphoryl transfer tight rather than loose.

Hydrolysis of Guanosine Triphosphate (GTP) by the Ras·GAP Protein Complex: Reaction Mechanism and Kinetic Scheme

Molecular mechanisms of the hydrolysis of guanosine triphosphate (GTP) to guanosine diphosphate (GDP) and inorganic phosphate (Pi) by the Ras·GAP protein complex are fully investigated by using modern modeling tools. The previously hypothesized stages of the cleavage of the phosphorus-oxygen bond in GTP and the formation of the imide form of catalytic Gln61 from Ras upon creation of Pi are confirmed by using the higher-level quantum-based calculations. The steps of the enzyme regeneration are modeled for the first time, providing a comprehensive description of the catalytic cycle. It is found that for the reaction Ras·GAP·GTP·H2O → Ras·GAP·GDP·Pi, the highest barriers correspond to the process of regeneration of the active site but not to the process of substrate cleavage. The specific shape of the energy profile is responsible for an interesting kinetic mechanism of the GTP hydrolysis. The analysis of the process using the first-passage approach and consideration of kinetic equations suggest that the overall reaction rate is a result of the balance between relatively fast transitions and low probability of states from which these transitions are taking place. Our theoretical predictions are in excellent agreement with available experimental observations on GTP hydrolysis rates.

Modeling the mechanisms of biological GTP hydrolysis

Enzymes that hydrolyze GTP are currently in the spotlight, due to their molecular switch mechanism that controls many cellular processes. One of the best-known classes of these enzymes are small GTPases such as members of the Ras superfamily, which catalyze the hydrolysis of the γ-phosphate bond in GTP. In addition, the availability of an increasing number of crystal structures of translational GTPases such as EF-Tu and EF-G have made it possible to probe the molecular details of GTP hydrolysis on the ribosome. However, despite a wealth of biochemical, structural and computational data, the way in which GTP hydrolysis is activated and regulated is still a controversial topic and well-designed simulations can play an important role in resolving and rationalizing the experimental data. In this review, we discuss the contributions of computational biology to our understanding of GTP hydrolysis on the ribosome and in small GTPases.

Ribosome-induced tuning of GTP hydrolysis by a translational GTPase

GTP hydrolysis by elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu), a translational GTPase that delivers aminoacyl-tRNAs to the ribosome, plays a crucial role in decoding and translational fidelity. The basic reaction mechanism and the way the ribosome contributes to catalysis are a matter of debate. Here we use mutational analysis in combination with measurements of rate/pH profiles, kinetic solvent isotope effects, and ion dependence of GTP hydrolysis by EF-Tu off and on the ribosome to dissect the reaction mechanism. Our data suggest that--contrary to current models--the reaction in free EF-Tu follows a pathway that does not involve the critical residue H84 in the switch II region. Binding to the ribosome without a cognate codon in the A site has little effect on the GTPase mechanism. In contrast, upon cognate codon recognition, the ribosome induces a rearrangement of EF-Tu that renders GTP hydrolysis sensitive to mutations of Asp21 and His84 and insensitive to K(+) ions. We suggest that Asp21 and His84 provide a network of interactions that stabilize the positions of the γ-phosphate and the nucleophilic water, respectively, and thus play an indirect catalytic role in the GTPase mechanism on the ribosome.

Common hydrogen bond interactions in diverse phosphoryl transfer active sites

Phosphoryl transfer reactions figure prominently in energy metabolism, signaling, transport and motility. Prior detailed studies of selected systems have highlighted mechanistic features that distinguish different phosphoryl transfer enzymes. Here, a top-down approach is developed for comparing statistically the active site configurations between populations of diverse structures in the Protein Data Bank, and it reveals patterns of hydrogen bonding that transcend enzyme families. Through analysis of large samples of structures, insights are drawn at a level of detail exceeding the experimental precision of an individual structure. In phosphagen kinases, for example, hydrogen bonds with the O3β of the nucleotide substrate are revealed as analogous to those in unrelated G proteins. In G proteins and other enzymes, interactions with O3β have been understood in terms of electrostatic favoring of the transition state. Ground state quantum mechanical calculations on model compounds show that the active site interactions highlighted in our database analysis can affect substrate phosphate charge and bond length, in ways that are consistent with prior experimental observations, by modulating hyperconjugative orbital interactions that weaken the scissile bond. Testing experimentally the inference about the importance of O3β interactions in phosphagen kinases, mutation of arginine kinase Arg280 decreases kcat, as predicted, with little impact upon KM.

Overview of simulation studies on the enzymatic activity and conformational dynamics of the GTPase Ras

Over the last 40 years, we have learnt a great deal about the Ras onco-proteins. These intracellular molecular switches are essential for the function of a variety of physiological processes, including signal transduction cascades responsible for cell growth and proliferation. Molecular simulations and free energy calculations have played an essential role in elucidating the conformational dynamics and energetics underlying the GTP hydrolysis reaction catalysed by Ras. Here we present an overview of the main lessons from molecular simulations on the GTPase reaction and conformational dynamics of this important anti-cancer drug target. In the first part, we summarise insights from quantum mechanical and combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical simulations as well as other free energy methods and highlight consensus viewpoints as well as remaining controversies. The second part provides a very brief overview of new insights emerging from large-scale molecular dynamics simulations. We conclude with a perspective regarding future studies of Ras where computational approaches will likely play an active role.

Quantitative exploration of the molecular origin of the activation of GTPase

GTPases play a major role in cellular processes, and gaining quantitative understanding of their activation demands reliable free energy surfaces of the relevant mechanistic paths in solution, as well as the interpolation of this information to GTPases. Recently, we generated ab initio quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical free energy surfaces for the hydrolysis of phosphate monoesters in solution, establishing quantitatively that the barrier for the reactions with a proton transfer (PT) step from a single attacking water (1 W) is higher than the one where the PT is assisted by a second water (2 W). The implication of this finding on the activation of GTPases is quantified here, by using the ab initio solution surfaces to calibrate empirical valence bond surfaces and then exploring the origin of the activation effect. It is found that, although the 2 W PT path is a new element, this step is not rate determining, and the catalytic effect is actually due to the electrostatic stabilization of the pre-PT transition state and the subsequent plateau. Thus, the electrostatic catalytic effect found in our previous studies of the Ras GTPase activating protein (RasGAP) and the elongation factor-Tu (EF-Tu) with a 1 W mechanism is still valid for the 2 W path. Furthermore, as found before, the corresponding activation appears to involve a major allosteric effect. Overall, we believe that our finding is general to both GTPases and ATPases. In addition to the biologically relevant finding, we also provide a critical discussion of the requirements from reliable surfaces for enzymatic reactions.

Energetics of activation of GTP hydrolysis on the ribosome

Several of the steps in protein synthesis on the ribosome utilize hydrolysis of guanosine triphosphate (GTP) as the driving force. This reaction is catalyzed by translation factors that become activated upon binding to the ribosome. The recently determined crystal structure of an elongation factor-Tu ternary complex bound to the ribosome allows the energetics of GTP activation to be explored by computer simulations. A central problem regards the role of the universally conserved histidine, which has been proposed to act as a general base for guanosine triphosphate hydrolysis. Here we report a detailed energetic and structural analysis of different possible protonation states that could be involved in activation of the reaction. We show that the histidine cannot act as a general base, but must be protonated and in its active conformation to promote GTP hydrolysis. We further show that the sarcin-ricin loop of the ribosome spontaneously drives the histidine into the correct conformation for GTP activation.