LRRning the RIte of springs

Targeted human cytolytic fusion proteins at the cutting edge: harnessing the apoptosis-inducing properties of human enzymes for the selective elimination of tumor cells

Patient-specific targeted therapy represents the holy grail of anti-cancer therapeutics, allowing potent tumor depletion without detrimental off-target toxicities. Disease-specific monoclonal antibodies have been employed to bind to oncogenic cell-surface receptors, representing the earliest form of immunotherapy. Targeted drug delivery was first achieved by means of antibody-drug conjugates, which exploit the differential expression of tumor-associated antigens as a guiding mechanism for the specific delivery of chemically-conjugated chemotherapeutic agents to diseased target cells. Biotechnological advances have expanded the repertoire of immunology-based tumor-targeting strategies, also paving the way for the next intuitive step in targeted drug delivery: the construction of recombinant protein drugs consisting of an antibody-based targeting domain genetically fused with a cytotoxic peptide, known as an immunotoxin. However, the most potent protein toxins have typically been derived from bacterial or plant virulence factors and commonly feature both off-target toxicity and immunogenicity in human patients. Further refinement of immunotoxin technology thus led to the replacement of monoclonal antibodies with humanized antibody derivatives, including the substitution of non-human toxic peptides with human cytolytic proteins. Preclinically tested human cytolytic fusion proteins (hCFPs) have proven promising as non-immunogenic combinatory anti-cancer agents, however they still require further enhancement to achieve convincing candidacy as a single-mode therapeutic. To date, a portfolio of highly potent human toxins has been established; ranging from microtubule-associated protein tau (MAP tau), RNases, granzyme B (GrB) and death-associated protein kinase (DAPk). In this review, we discuss the most recent findings on the use of these apoptosis-inducing hCFPs for the treatment of various cancers.

Molecular recognition of human eosinophil-derived neurotoxin (RNase 2) by placental ribonuclease inhibitor

Placental ribonuclease inhibitor (RI) binds diverse mammalian RNases with dissociation constants that are in the femtomolar range. Previous studies on the complexes of RI with RNase A and angiogenin revealed that RI utilises largely distinctive interactions to achieve high affinity for these two ligands. Here we report a 2.0 angstroms resolution crystal structure of RI in complex with a third ligand, eosinophil-derived neurotoxin (EDN), and a mutational analysis based on this structure. The RI-EDN interface is more extensive than those of the other two complexes and contains a considerably larger set of interactions. Few of the contacts present in the RI-angiogenin complex are replicated; the correspondence to the RI-RNase A complex is somewhat greater, but still modest. The energetic contributions of various interface regions differ strikingly from those in the earlier complexes. These findings provide insight into the structural basis for the unusual combination of high avidity and relaxed stringency that RI displays.

High-level soluble production and characterization of porcine ribonuclease inhibitor

Ribonucleases can be cytotoxic if they retain their ribonucleolytic activity in the cytosol. The cytosolic ribonucleolytic activity of ribonuclease A (RNase A) and other pancreatic-type ribonucleases is limited by the presence of excess ribonuclease inhibitor (RI). RI is a 50-kDa cytosolic scavenger of pancreatic-type ribonucleases that competitively inhibits their ribonucleolytic activity. RI had been overproduced as inclusion bodies, but its folding in vitro is inefficient. Here, porcine RI (pRI) was overproduced in Escherichia coli using the trp promoter and minimal medium. This expression system maintains pRI in the soluble fraction of the cytosol. pRI was purified by affinity chromatography using immobilized RNase A and by anion-exchange chromatography. The resulting yield of 15 mg of purified RI per liter of culture represents a 60-fold increase relative to previously reported recombinant DNA systems. Differential scanning calorimetry was used to study the thermal denaturation of pRI, RNase A, and the pRI-RNase A complex. The conformational stability of the complex is greater than that of the individual components.

The role of ecotin dimerization in protease inhibition

Ecotin is a homodimeric protein from Escherichia coli that inhibits many serine proteases of the chymotrypsin fold, often with little effect from the character or extent of enzyme substrate specificity. This pan-specificity of inhibition is believed to derive from formation of a heterotetrameric complex with target proteases involving three types of interface: the dimerization interface, a primary substrate-like interaction, and a smaller secondary interaction between the partner ecotin subunit and the protease. A monomeric ecotin variant (mEcotin) and a single-chain ecotin dimer (scEcotin) were constructed to study the effect of a network of protein interactions on binding affinity and the role of dimerization in broad inhibitor specificity. mEcotin was produced by inserting a beta-turn into the C-terminal arm, which normally exchanges with the other subunit. While the dimerization constant (K(dim)) of wild-type (WT) ecotin was found to be picomolar by subunit exchange experiments using FRET and by association kinetics, mEcotin was monomeric up to 1 mM as judged by gel filtration and analytical centrifugation. A crystal structure of uncomplexed mEcotin to 2.0 A resolution verifies the design, showing a monomeric protein in which the C-terminal arm folds back onto itself to form a beta-barrel structure nearly identical to its dimeric counterpart. The kinetic rate constants and equilibrium dissociation constants for monomeric and dimeric ecotin variants were determined with both trypsin and chymotrypsin. The effect of the secondary binding site on affinity was found to vary inversely with the strength of the interaction at the primary site. This compensatory effect yields a nonadditivity of up to 5 kcal/mol and can be explained in terms of the optimization of binding orientation. Such a mechanism of adaptability allows femtomolar affinities for two proteases with very different specificities.

Basic homopolyamino acids, histones and protamines are potent antagonists of angiogenin binding to ribonuclease inhibitor

A radio-ribonuclease inhibitor assay based on the interaction of 125I-angiogenin with ribonuclease inhibitor (RI) was used to detect pancreatic-type ribonucleases and potential modulators of their action. We show that highly basic proteins including the homopolypeptides poly-arginine, poly-lysine and poly-ornithine, core histones, spermatid-specific S1 protein and the protamines HP3 and Z3 were strong inhibitors of angiogenin binding to RI. A minimum size of poly-arginine and poly-lysine was required for efficient inhibition. The inhibition likely resulted from direct association of the basic proteins with the acidic inhibitor, as RI bound to poly-lysine and protamines while 125I-angiogenin did not. Antagonists of the angiogenin-RI interaction are potential regulators of either angiogenin-triggered angiogenesis and/or intracellular RI function, depending on their preferential target.

Molecular recognition of human angiogenin by placental ribonuclease inhibitor--an X-ray crystallographic study at 2.0 A resolution

Human placental RNase inhibitor (hRI), a leucine-rich repeat protein, binds the blood vessel-inducing protein human angiogenin (Ang) with extraordinary affinity (Ki <1 fM). Here we report a 2.0 A resolution crystal structure for the hRI-Ang complex that, together with extensive mutagenesis data from earlier studies, reveals the molecular features of this tight interaction. The hRI-Ang binding interface is large and encompasses 26 residues from hRI and 24 from Ang, recruited from multiple domains of both proteins. However, a substantial fraction of the energetically important contacts involve only a single region of each: the C-terminal segment 434-460 of hRI and the ribonucleolytic active centre of Ang, most notably the catalytic residue Lys40. Although the overall docking of Ang resembles that observed for RNase A in the crystal structure of its complex with the porcine RNase inhibitor, the vast majority of the interactions in the two complexes are distinctive, indicating that the broad specificity of the inhibitor for pancreatic RNase superfamily proteins is based largely on its capacity to recognize features unique to each of them. The implications of these findings for the development of small, hRI-based inhibitors of Ang for therapeutic use are discussed.

Site-specific mutagenesis reveals differences in the structural bases for tight binding of RNase inhibitor to angiogenin and RNase A

RNase inhibitor (RI) binds with extraordinary affinity (Ki approximately 10(-13)-10(-16) M) to diverse proteins in the pancreatic RNase superfamily. In the present study, the structural basis for the recognition of two RI ligands, human angiogenin (Ang) and bovine RNase A, has been investigated by site-specific mutagenesis of human RI and Ang. The RI residues examined were those that appear to form strong contacts with RNase A in the crystal structure of the porcine RI x RNase A complex [Kobe, B. & Deisenhofer, J. (1995) Nature (London) 374, 183-186] that would not be replicated in the Ang complex. Ala substitutions of five of these residues (Glu-287, Lys-320, Glu-401, Cys-408, and Arg-457) were found to have little or no effect on binding of RNase A. In contrast, replacements of Tyr-434, Asp-435, and Tyr-437 and deletion of the C-terminal residue Ser-460 substantially weakened affinity for RNase A: the losses of binding energy associated with the mutations were 5.9, 3.6, 2.6, and 3.5 kcal/mol, respectively. Thus these four residues, which are neighbors in the tertiary structure, appear to constitute a "hot spot" for the RNase A interaction. However, only one of them, Asp-435, was equally important for binding of Ang; the Ki increases produced by mutations of the others were 20- to 93-fold smaller for Ang than for RNase A. Consequently, Tyr-434 plays a significant but lesser role in the Ang complex, whereas Tyr-437 and Ser-460 make only minor contributions. Ala mutations of four Ang residues (His-8, Gln-12, Asn-68, and Glu-108) that correspond to RI contacts on RNase A produced no major changes in affinity for RI. These findings indicate that RI uses largely different interactions to achieve its extremely tight binding of RNase A and Ang.

Mechanism of ribonuclease inhibition by ribonuclease inhibitor protein based on the crystal structure of its complex with ribonuclease A

We describe the mechanism of ribonuclease inhibition by ribonuclease inhibitor, a protein built of leucine-rich repeats, based on the crystal structure of the complex between the inhibitor and ribonuclease A. The structure was determined by molecular replacement and refined to an Rcryst of 19.4% at 2.5 A resolution. Ribonuclease A binds to the concave region of the inhibitor protein comprising its parallel beta-sheet and loops. The inhibitor covers the ribonuclease active site and directly contacts several active-site residues. The inhibitor only partially mimics the RNase-nucleotide interaction and does not utilize the p1 phosphate-binding pocket of ribonuclease A, where a sulfate ion remains bound. The 2550 A2 of accessible surface area buried upon complex formation may be one of the major contributors to the extremely tight association (Ki = 5.9 x 10(-14) M). The interaction is predominantly electrostatic; there is a high chemical complementarity with 18 putative hydrogen bonds and salt links, but the shape complementarity is lower than in most other protein-protein complexes. Ribonuclease inhibitor changes its conformation upon complex formation; the conformational change is unusual in that it is a plastic reorganization of the entire structure without any obvious hinge and reflects the conformational flexibility of the structure of the inhibitor. There is a good agreement between the crystal structure and other biochemical studies of the interaction. The structure suggests that the conformational flexibility of RI and an unusually large contact area that compensates for a lower degree of complementarity may be the principal reasons for the ability of RI to potently inhibit diverse ribonucleases. However, the inhibition is lost with amphibian ribonucleases that have substituted most residues corresponding to inhibitor-binding residues in RNase A, and with bovine seminal ribonuclease that prevents inhibitor binding by forming a dimer.

Interaction between Yersinia pestis YopM protein and human alpha-thrombin

YopM, a 41.5 kDa virulence protein of Yersinia pestis is believed to have an anti-inflammatory role in bubonic plague. It has been shown previously that YopM binds human alpha-thrombin but not prothrombin and inhibits thrombin-induced platelet aggregation in vitro. In the present studies we carried out crosslinking reactions between purified YopM and alpha-thrombin or its blocked form FPR-alpha-thrombin in the presence of various competitors to identify where on thrombin YopM binds. We found that thrombin cleaves YopM at the C-terminus, indicating that this part of YopM must interact with thrombin's catalytic site. Hirudin, a 65 amino acid natural thrombin inhibitor, prevents both the YopM degradation and the formation of a ca. 75 kDa crosslinking complex between YopM and alpha-thrombin. A similar effect is observed when hirugen, a short peptide corresponding to hirudin's C-terminus (amino acids 58-64), is used as a synthetic thrombin inhibitor. A 15 bp long specific oligonucleotide known to block alpha-thrombin successfully competes with YopM for the thrombin-binding site, whereas a control, scrambled sequence aptamer does not. As these competitors block a fibrinogen binding site (also called anion binding exosite I), our crosslinking data indicate that YopM binds not only to the active site of alpha-thrombin but also to the abeI.