Quantitative standardization of resident mouse behavior for studies of aggression and social defeat

Review: Suicide and its relationship to aggression and impulsivity

Aggression and impulsivity are key risk factors for suicide, which remains a public health concern. The heterogeneity of suicidal behaviors, combined with the complexities of aggression and impulsivity, complicates the investigation of their relationship with suicide risk. This review sought to provide a comprehensive overview of the literature examining the relationship between aggression, impulsivity, and suicide. Broadly, individuals with higher levels of aggression and impulsivity were found to be more vulnerable to suicidal behaviors. Stress, the immune system, and neurotransmitters also appeared to affect the relationship between aggression, impulsivity, and suicide. The reactive aggression and proactive aggression subtypes were each found to uniquely contribute to suicide risk. Furthermore, although different facets of impulsivity have varied relationships with suicide risk, self-reported impulsivity did not consistently align with task-driven impulsivity, and distinct facets of task-driven impulsivity demonstrated unique associations with suicide risk. Task-driven impulsivity and reward-based learning, as estimated by reinforcement learning hyperparameters, may provide valuable insights into the potential utility of tasks that assess risk factors in suicide research and their relationship with sensory and emotion regulation in the brain. In addition, neuroimaging studies indicated that decreased cognitive capability and control may be involved in the link between impulsivity and suicide. Collectively, the evidence presented herein highlights the complex interplay between aggression, impulsivity, and suicide. Understanding the underlying genetic, epigenetic, stress, neural, and neurotransmitter factors involved is crucial for developing effective prevention and intervention strategies for individuals at risk of suicide.

Activation of somatostatin neurons in the medial amygdala reverses long-term aggression and social deficits associated to early-life stress in male mice

Early postnatal development is a critical period for the configuration of neural networks that support social and affective-like behaviors. In this sense, children raised in stressful environments are at high risk to develop maladaptive behaviors immediately or later in life, including anti-social and aggressive behaviors. However, the neurobiological bases of such phenomena remain poorly understood. Here we showed that, at long-term, maternal separation with early weaning (MSEW) decreased the density of somatostatin-expressing (SST+) neurons in the basolateral amygdala (BLA) of females and males, while their activity was only reduced in the medial amygdala (MeA) of males. Interestingly, only MSEW males exhibited long-term behavioral effects, including reduced sociability and social novelty preference in the 3-chamber test (3CH), decreased social interest in the resident-intruder test (RI), and increased aggressivity in both the RI and the tube dominance test (TT). To test whether the manipulation of MeASST+ neurons was sufficient to reverse these negative behavioral outcomes, we expressed the chemogenetic excitatory receptor hM3Dq in MSEW adult males. We found that the activation of MeASST+ neurons ameliorated social interest in the RI test and reduced aggression traits in the TT and RI assays. Altogether, our results highlight a role for MeASST+ neurons in the regulation of aggressivity and social interest and point to the loss of activity of these neurons as a plausible etiological mechanism linking early life stress to these maladaptive behaviors in later life.

Social experience is associated with a differential role of aromatase neurons in sexual behavior and territorial aggression in male mice

Aromatase (Aro+) neurons located in the Bed Nucleus of the Stria Terminalis (BNST) are crucial for the display of both sexual behavior and territorial aggression in naive male mice. The postero-dorsal part of the Medial Amygdala (MeApd) also contains Aro + neurons that are required for territorial aggression, but these neurons seem dispensable for the display of sexual behavior in naive animals. However, little is known about how Aro + neuron circuitry is influenced by social experience. Using a combination of chemogenetics, activity mapping and retrograde viral tracing, we show that social experience modulates Aro + neurons during sexual behavior and territorial aggression. Chemogenetic inhibition of BNST Aro + neurons in socially experienced male mice revealed that these neurons are required for territorial aggression, but not for sexual behavior. Behavior testing in experienced animals showed a specific increase in activation in the vomeronasal organ (VNO) and the Medial Amygdala (MeA) after sexual behavior but not territorial aggression, assessed by Egr1 expression. We also observed an increase of Egr1 cells in the medial Preoptic Area (mPOA), a brain region implicated in the display of sexual behavior. Combined retrograde viral tracing and Egr1 immunodetection showed that a subset of the activated cells in the MeA are Aro + neurons projecting to the mPOA. These results highlight that social experience induces a differential neural activity in the circuitry controlling sexual behavior and aggression, which include MeA Aro + neurons projecting to the mPOA.

Induction of territorial dominance and subordination behaviors in laboratory mice

Territorial behaviors comprise a set of coordinated actions and response patterns found across animal species that promote the exclusive access to resources. House mice are highly territorial with a subset of males consistently attacking and chasing competing males to expel them from their territories and performing urine marking behaviors to signal the extent of their territories. Natural variation in territorial behaviors within a mouse colony leads to the formation of dominance hierarchies in which subordinate males can reside within the territory of a dominant male. While the full repertoire of such territorial behaviors and hierarchies has been extensively studied in wild-derived mice in semi-natural enclosures, so far they have not been established in the smaller enclosures and with the genetically-defined laboratory strains required for the application of neural recording and manipulation methods. Here, we present a protocol to rapidly induce an extensive repertoire of territorial behaviors in pairs of laboratory mice in an enclosure compatible with tethered neurocircuit techniques, including a method for the simultaneous tracking of urine marking behavior in mouse pairs. Using this protocol we describe the emergence of robust dominant-subordinate hierarchies between pairs of CD1 outbred or CD1xB6 F1 hybrid mice, but unexpectedly not in C57BL/6 inbred animals. Our behavioral paradigm opens the door for neurocircuit studies of territorial behaviors and social hierarchy in the laboratory.

Simple Behavioral Analysis (SimBA) as a platform for explainable machine learning in behavioral neuroscience

The study of complex behaviors is often challenging when using manual annotation due to the absence of quantifiable behavioral definitions and the subjective nature of behavioral annotation. Integration of supervised machine learning approaches mitigates some of these issues through the inclusion of accessible and explainable model interpretation. To decrease barriers to access, and with an emphasis on accessible model explainability, we developed the open-source Simple Behavioral Analysis (SimBA) platform for behavioral neuroscientists. SimBA introduces several machine learning interpretability tools, including SHapley Additive exPlanation (SHAP) scores, that aid in creating explainable and transparent behavioral classifiers. Here we show how the addition of explainability metrics allows for quantifiable comparisons of aggressive social behavior across research groups and species, reconceptualizing behavior as a sharable reagent and providing an open-source framework. We provide an open-source, graphical user interface (GUI)-driven, well-documented package to facilitate the movement toward improved automation and sharing of behavioral classification tools across laboratories.

Studying dominance and aggression requires ethologically relevant paradigms

Although aggression is associated with several psychiatric disorders, there is no effective treatment nor a rigorous definition for "pathological aggression". Mice make a valuable model for studying aggression. They have a dynamic social structure that depends on the habitat and includes reciprocal interactions between the mice's aggression levels, social dominance hierarchy (SDH), and resource allocation. Nevertheless, the classical behavioral tests for territorial aggression and SDH in mice are reductive and have limited ethological and translational relevance. Recent work has explored the use of semi-natural environments to simultaneously study dominance-related behaviors, resource allocation, and aggressive behavior. Semi-natural setups allow experimental control of the environment combined with manipulations of neural activity. We argue that these setups can help bridge the translational gap in aggression research toward discovering neuronal mechanisms underlying maladaptive aggression.

Aggression in Group-Housed Male Mice: A Systematic Review

Aggression among group-housed male mice is a major animal welfare concern often observed at animal facilities. Studies designed to understand the causes of male mice aggression have used different methodological approaches and have been heterogeneous, using different strains, environmental enrichments, housing conditions, group formations and durations. By conducting a systematic literature review based on 198 observed conclusions from 90 articles, we showed that the methodological approach used to study aggression was relevant for the outcome and suggested that home cage observations were better when studying home cage aggression than tests provoking aggression outside the home cage. The study further revealed that aggression is a complex problem; one solution will not be appropriate for all animal facilities and all research projects. Recommendations were provided on promising tools to minimize aggression, based on the results, which included what type of environmental enrichments could be appropriate and which strains of male mice were less likely to be aggressive.

Excessive alcohol consumption after exposure to two types of chronic social stress: intermittent episodes vs. continuous exposure in C57BL/6J mice with a history of drinking

RATIONALE

The attraction to alcohol can be greatly increased when it is consumed in a social context. While pro-social interactions can potentiate voluntary alcohol drinking under some conditions, aversive social experience (i.e., social stress) can similarly intensify alcohol consumption.

OBJECTIVE

We sought to determine how exposure to different types of chronic social stress (i.e., intermittent episodes of social defeat or continuous social stress) influences alcohol consumption and the reinforcing effects of alcohol in mice with a history of drinking.

METHODS

Separate cohorts of male C57BL/6J mice were exposed to either 10 days of continuous or intermittent social defeat stress. In experiment 1, mice were assigned to 20% w/v alcohol consumption in a two-bottle choice protocol both prior to and after exposure to social defeat stress. In a second experiment, mice engaged in an operant response sequence to gain access to alcohol wherein completion of a fixed interval (FI; 5 min) schedule was reinforced with continuous access to alcohol (fixed ratio; FR1) for up to 1.8 g/kg. Alcohol-reinforced responding and subsequent alcohol consumption were assessed daily for 4 weeks prior to the 10-day social stress exposure and for 6-week post-stress. Machine learning was implemented to standardize the analysis of defeat behaviors exhibited by the intruder mouse during confrontation with an attacking resident.

RESULTS

In mice with a prior history of alcohol drinking, intermittent episodes of social defeat stress produced a significant increase in 20% EtOH consumption in preference over concurrently available water. This increased intake persisted for at least 6 weeks after the final social stress experience. Intermittently stressed mice also accelerated their anticipatory responding during the fixed interval component of the operant response chain that was reinforced by alcohol. Neither unstressed controls nor mice exposed to continuous social stress exhibited significant increases in alcohol consumption and alcohol reinforcement.

DISCUSSION

Episodic social defeat stress promotes the seeking and consumption of alcohol, extending earlier work to alcohol-experienced mice. We hypothesize that intermittent access to alcohol and intermittent episodes of social stress are additive and share common sensitizing neural mechanisms that engender excessive alcohol consumption.

To fight or not to fight: activation of the mPFC during decision to engage in aggressive behavior after ethanol consumption in a novel murine model

RATIONALE

Alcohol consumption is a common antecedent of aggressive behavior. The effects of alcohol on the decision to engage in aggression in preference over pro-social interaction are hypothesized to arise from augmented function within the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC).

OBJECTIVE

In a newly developed procedure, we studied social decision-making in male C57BL/6 J mice based on preferentially seeking access to either sociosexual interactions with a female partner or the opportunity to attack an intruder male. While deciding to engage in aggressive vs. sociosexual behavior, corresponding neural activation was assessed via c-Fos immunoreactivity in cortical, amygdaloid and tegmental regions of interest. A further objective was to investigate how self-administered alcohol impacted social choice.

METHODS

During repeated confrontations with an intruder male in their home cage, experimental mice engaged in species-specific sequence of pursuit, threat, and attack behavior within < 2 min. Mice were then conditioned to respond at one of two separate illuminated operanda in an experimental chamber (octagon) attached to their home cage; completion of 10 responses (fixed ratio 10; FR10) was reinforced by access to either a female or a male intruder which were presented in the resident's home cage. Brains were harvested following choice between the concurrently available aggressive and sociosexual options and processed for c-Fos immunoreactivity across 10 brain regions. In two separate groups, mice were trained to rapidly self-administer ethanol prior to a social choice trial in order to examine the effects of alcohol on social choice, sociosexual, aggressive acts and postures, and concurrent c-Fos activity in the mPFC and limbic regions.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Eight out of 65 mice consistently chose to engage in aggressive behavior in preference to sociosexual contact with a female when each outcome was concurrently available. Self-administered alcohol (experiment 1: 1.2 ± 0.02 g/kg; experiment 2: 0, 1.0, 1.5, and 1.8 g/kg) increased responding for the aggressive option in mice that previously opted predominantly for access to sociosexual interactions with the female. When choosing the aggressive, but not the sociosexual option, the prelimbic area of the mPFC revealed increased c-Fos activity, guiding future detailed inquiry into the neural mechanisms for aggressive choice.

Sex differences in appetitive and reactive aggression

Aggression is an evolutionarily conserved, adaptive component of social behavior. Studies in male mice illustrate that aggression is influenced by numerous factors including the degree to which an individual finds aggression rewarding and will work for access to attack and subordinate mice. While such studies have expanded our understanding of the molecular and circuit mechanisms of male aggression very little is known about female aggression, within these established contexts. Here we use an ethologically relevant model of male vs. female aggression by pair housing adult male and female outbred CFW mice with opposite sex cage mates. We assess reactive (defensive) aggression in the resident intruder (RI) test and appetitive (rewarding) aggression in the aggression conditioned place preference (CPP) and operant self-administration (SA) tests. Our results show dramatic sex differences in both qualitative and quantitative aspects of reactive vs. appetitive aggression. Males exhibit more wrestling and less investigative behavior during RI, find aggression rewarding, and will work for access to a subordinate to attack. Females exhibit more bites, alternate between aggressive behaviors and investigative behaviors more readily during RI, however, they do not find aggression to be rewarding or reinforcing. These results establish sex differences in aggression in mice, providing an important resource for the field to better understand the circuit and molecular mechanisms of aggression in both sexes.

Neurobiological Bases of Alcohol Consumption After Social Stress

The urge to seek and consume excessive alcohol is intensified by prior experiences with social stress, and this cascade can be modeled under systematically controlled laboratory conditions in rodents and non-human primates. Adaptive coping with intermittent episodes of social defeat stress often transitions to maladaptive responses to traumatic continuous stress, and alcohol consumption may become part of coping responses. At the circuit level, the neural pathways subserving stress coping intersect with those for alcohol consumption. Increasingly discrete regions and connections within the prefrontal cortex, the ventral and dorsal striatum, thalamic and hypothalamic nuclei, tegmental areas as well as brain stem structures begin to be identified as critical for reacting to and coping with social stress while seeking and consuming alcohol. Several candidate molecules that modulate signals within these neural connections have been targeted in order to reduce excessive drinking and relapse. In spite of some early clinical failures, neuropeptides such as CRF, opioids, or oxytocin continue to be examined for their role in attenuating stress-escalated drinking. Recent work has focused on neural sites of action for peptides and steroids, most likely in neuroinflammatory processes as a result of interactive effects of episodic social stress and excessive alcohol seeking and drinking.