Stickler syndrome - lessons from a national cohort

Stickler syndrome: associated musculoskeletal manifestations and first population-based incidence

The objective of this study is to identify musculoskeletal manifestations associated with Stickler syndrome from an inclusive literature review and to perform the first population study to establish its incidence. We reviewed all for us retrievable publications linked to Stickler syndrome listed in PubMed and publications quoted within these publications going back to 1954. From our medical record data bases, we identified all patients with the diagnosis of Stickler syndrome out of a population of consecutive live births born in our maternity hospital between 2000 and 2016. We identified 504 publications of which we managed to obtain and review 487, listing 6182 patients with Stickler syndrome. Musculoskeletal manifestations were recorded in 161 publications (2157 patients: 649 children, 931 adults, unknown 577), providing information on musculoskeletal findings for 1738 patients. There were 237 lower limb-, 233 spinal- and 80 upper limb abnormalities recorded for children. Hyperlaxity was recorded for 100 and unspecified pain for 70 children and for 77 abnormalities it was not specified if upper or lower limbs were affected. Coronal and axial lower limb malalignment was documented 74 times. We identified four patients with Stickler syndrome out of 87 378 consecutive live births, giving an incidence of 1 in 21 844 live births. Patients with Stickler syndrome present with a large variety of musculoskeletal manifestations. Assessment by a paediatric orthopaedic surgeon in childhood would be beneficial to identify spinal abnormalities and alignment problems, such as coxa vara/valga, abnormal femoral version, genu valgum and distal lateral tibial dysplasia, where guided growth or osteotomies might be useful to alleviate future function and symptoms.

Hereditary Vitreoretinopathies: Molecular Diagnosis, Clinical Presentation and Management

Hereditary vitreoretinopathies (HVRs), also known as hereditary vitreoretinal degenerations comprise a heterogeneous group of inherited disorders of the retina and vitreous, collectively and variably characterised by vitreal abnormalities, such as fibrillary condensations, liquefaction or membranes, as well as peripheral retinal abnormalities, vascular changes in some, an increased risk of retinal detachment and early-onset cataract formation. The pathology often involves the vitreoretinal interface in some, while the major underlying abnormality is vascular in others. Recent advances in molecular diagnosis and identification of the responsible genes and have improved our understanding of the pathogenesis, risks and management of the HVRs. Clinically, HVRs can be classified according to the presence or absence of skeletal or other systemic abnormalities, retinal dysfunction or retinal vascular abnormalities [2]. There are some discrepancies in the literature regarding which diseases are included under the overarching term 'hereditary vitreoretinopathies'. Conditions such as Stickler syndrome, Wagner syndrome and familial exudative vitreoretinopathy are generally included, while others such as autosomal dominant neovascular inflammatory vitreoretinopathy (ADNIV) and autosomal dominant vitreoretinochoroidapathy (ADVIRC) may not. In this review, we will discuss some historical aspects, the molecular pathogenesis, clinical features and management of diseases and syndromes commonly considered as HVRs.

Retinal detachment in Type IX collagen recessive Stickler syndrome

OBJECTIVE

Stickler Syndrome (SS) is associated with eye, joint and orofacial abnormalities. Most cases are dominantly inherited through COL2A1/COL11A1 variants encoding type-II/XI collagen, with patients having up to 78% retinal detachment (RD) risk. Rarer cases of recessive SS have also been identified, associated with pathogenic variants of genes including COL9A1, COL9A2 & COL9A3 encoding type-IX collagen, but there is limited published data on patients' phenotype or RD risk. Our study aimed to investigate RD risk in type-IX recessive SS, determining whether patients would benefit from prophylactic retinopexy. A secondary objective was to explore patient phenotypes, identifying key features which clinicians should identify, leading to earlier diagnosis.

METHODS

We report 13 cases from 11 families with Type-IX recessive SS, identified from the cohort attending the NHS England Highly Specialised Stickler Syndrome Service (1/1/15-31/12/22). Patients underwent multidisciplinary assessment by ophthalmology, rheumatology and audiology.

RESULTS

6/11 families exhibited previously undescribed genetic variants, and 7 had consanguineous parents. Clinical findings included abnormal vitreous architecture and high myopia. 15.4% of patients developed RD secondary to horseshoe retinal tears, with no cases of bilateral RD or giant retinal tears (GRTs). No patients had cleft palate, and 30.8% had midfacial hypoplasia. Hearing loss was more prevalent (91.7%) than in dominant SS. Arthropathy was uncommon but variable in manifestation.

CONCLUSIONS

Ours results do not point to high RD nor GRT incidence in recessive SS, although given the rarity, our numbers are small. Prophylactic retinopexy should only be offered case-by-case for fellow eyes of patients presenting with GRT detachments in their first eye.

Peripapillary Hyperreflective Ovoid Mass-Like Structures in Stickler Syndrome

PURPOSE

To report a previously undescribed finding of peripapillary hyperreflective ovoid mass-like structures (PHOMS) in Stickler syndrome.

DESIGN

Noncomparative case series.

SUBJECTS

Twenty-two eyes with anomalous optic disc from 11 Stickler syndrome patients were identified and imaged.

METHODS

Peripapillary hyperreflective ovoid mass-like structures were graded using enhanced-depth imaging OCT (EDI-OCT) according to the consensus recommendations of the Optic Disc Drusen Studies Consortium. All EDI-OCT scans were obtained using the Heidelberg Spectralis (Heidelberg Engineering) with a dense horizontal raster (15 × 10°, 97 sections) centered on the optic nerve head and graded by 2 independent assessors. In case of disagreement, the image was graded by a third assessor. The presence of any coexisting optic disc drusen was also assessed using EDI-OCT and autofluorescence.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The presence of PHOMS, clinical characteristics and genetic mutations.

RESULTS

A pilot sample of 22 eyes with phenotypic optic disc abnormalities from 11 Stickler syndrome patients were identified and imaged. Eight patients were female and 3 were male. The mean age was 31 years (13-58 years). Peripapillary hyperreflective ovoid mass-like structures were present in 91% (n = 20) of imaged eyes. Seventy percent (n = 14) were type 1 Stickler syndrome and 30% (n = 6) were type 2 Stickler syndrome. All eyes were myopic and the degree of myopia did not seem to affect whether or not PHOMS was present in this cohort. One eye with PHOMS had retinal detachment, and 77.3% (n = 17) of eyes had undergone 360o prophylactic retinopexy. Thirty-two percent (n = 7) of eyes with PHOMS were present in patients with coexisting hearing loss and 22.7% (n = 5) had orofacial manifestation of Stickler syndrome in the form of a cleft palate. Seventy-seven percent (n = 15) of eyes with PHOMS were present in patients who reported joint laxity or symptoms of arthritis. No coexisting optic disc drusen were identified and raised intracranial pressure was also excluded after neurological investigation.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that PHOMS are a novel finding in Stickler syndrome patients and should be considered when evaluating the optic nerves of these patients.

FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S)

Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found in the Footnotes and Disclosures at the end of this article.

Outcomes of rhegmatogenous retinal detachment surgery in patients with Stickler syndrome

PURPOSE

Despite recent developments in vitrectomy technology and instrumentation, rhegmatogenous retinal detachment in Stickler syndrome (RDS) remains a challenge for surgeons. RDSs are associated with a higher rate of complications and surgical failures than those not associated with Stickler syndrome. This study is a report about anatomic and visual outcomes of RDS surgery and describes the surgical techniques associated with the treatment of this specific condition.

METHODS

This is a retrospective, interventional, consecutive case series of patients with RDS undergoing retinal reattachment surgery from 1990 to 2020 at the Institute of Ocular Microsurgery (IMO) in Barcelona, Spain.

RESULTS

Twenty-four eyes of 18 patients with genetically confirmed Stickler syndrome were included in the study. Ten eyes (41.6%) presented a giant retinal tear. Retinal reattachment was achieved in all cases after an average of 1.21 (range 1-6) surgical interventions. Nineteen eyes (79%) required only one operation to achieve complete retinal reattachment. The most common first surgical procedure was a 4-mm scleral buckle with posterior pars plana vitrectomy and silicone oil endotamponade, performed on 16 (66.6%) of the eyes. The mean follow-up period was 10.2 years. Mean preoperative visual acuity LogMar was 1.10 (Snellen equivalent 20/252), which improved to 0.50 (Snellen equivalent 20/63) at final follow-up (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

In most RDS cases, anatomic success and visual acuity improvement can be achieved with the first surgical procedure, using a combination of silicone oil tamponade and a 4-mm scleral encircling band. In some early cases of RDS, other less invasive surgical techniques can be used.

Microphthalmia and congenital cataract in two patients with Stickler syndrome type II: a case report

BACKGROUND

Stickler syndrome (STL) is a collagenopathy caused by pathogenic variants in collagen-coding genes, mainly COL2A1 or COL11A1 associated with Stickler syndrome type 1 (STL1) or type 2 (STL2), respectively. Affected individuals manifest ocular, auditory, articular, and craniofacial findings in varying degrees. Previous literature and case reports describe high variability in clinical findings for patients with STL. With this case report, we broaden the clinical spectrum of the phenotype.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Case report on two members of a family (mother and son) including clinical examination and genetic testing using targeted trio whole exome sequencing (trio-WES).

RESULTS

A boy and his mother presented with microphthalmia, congenital cataract, ptosis, and moderate-to-severe sensorineural hearing loss. Trio-WES found a novel heterozygote missense variant, c.4526A>G; p(Gln1509Arg) in COL11A1 in both affected individuals.

CONCLUSIONS

We report a previously undescribed phenotype associated with a COL11A1-variant in a mother and son, expanding the spectrum for phenotype-genotype correlation in STL2, presenting with microphthalmia, congenital cataract, and ptosis not normally associated with Stickler syndrome.

Clinician Awareness of Stickler Syndromes Among Australian Allied Health Care Professionals

Purpose

Stickler Syndromes are multisystem collagenopathies affecting 1 in 7500-9000 individuals and are associated with craniofacial, ocular, auditory, and musculoskeletal complications. Prophylactic retinopexy treatment reduces the risk of retinal detachment, emphasising the need for early detection and multidisciplinary referral. This study evaluated knowledge and awareness of Stickler Syndromes among allied health professionals and their perceived needs for targeted education to improve multidisciplinary care.

Methods

A cross-sectional survey was undertaken among audiologists, speech pathologists, optometrists, orthoptists, and physiotherapists in Australia. Survey questions included practitioner demographics, awareness and knowledge of Stickler Syndromes, confidence managing Stickler Syndromes, and perception of multidisciplinary care needs for Stickler Syndromes.

Results

Of 180 healthcare professions who participated (79% female; 78% aged between 25 and 44 years), 55% indicated that they had heard of Stickler Syndrome, and 14% had directly worked with patients known to have Stickler Syndromes. Practitioners who had were either optometrists, orthoptists, or audiologists. The most recognised clinical sign of Stickler Syndromes was retinal detachment (selected by 66% of optometrists and orthoptists and 16% of other professions), but only 41% of optometrists and orthoptists (27% all respondents) selected cryopexy as a potential management strategy. Vitreous anomaly was recognised as a clinical feature by 20% of all respondents. Overall, 69% of allied health professionals did not feel confident managing Stickler Syndromes, and a similar number of practitioners (69%) indicated that they were willing to attend professional development courses for complex conditions such as Stickler Syndromes.

Conclusion

This study provides meaningful insights on awareness and knowledge of Stickler Syndromes among allied healthcare professionals. Targeted clinician education, enhanced communication between healthcare entities, and multidisciplinary care programs can significantly improve the integrated care of Stickler Syndromes leading to better patient outcomes.

Use of vitreous phenotype as a key clinical marker to identify Ocular-only Stickler syndrome in a family with Marfan syndrome

This clinical report describes a family with both Marfan and ocular-only Stickler syndromes. We report 2 cases of ocular-only Stickler syndrome and 2 cases of Marfan syndrome concurrent with ocular-only Stickler syndrome. Type 1 Stickler syndrome and Marfan syndrome share many clinical similarities, and it can be difficult to differentiate them solely based on clinical presentation. Vitreous phenotyping allows for the identification of vitreous anomalies pathognomonic of Stickler syndrome, which can guide future gene sequencing. Having the accurate diagnosis of Marfan or type 1 Stickler syndrome is important, as patients with type 1 Stickler syndrome have higher rates of retinal detachment and will benefit from prophylaxis.

A patient with concurrent Axenfeld-Rieger and Stickler syndromes verified by molecular genetics

Purpose

To report a case of Axenfeld-Rieger and Stickler Syndrome in a pediatric patient.

Observations

A 3-month-old male was referred to the glaucoma clinic after he was noted to have elevated intraocular pressures in both eyes. His family history was notable for infantile glaucoma on his maternal side and retinal detachment on his paternal side. He was found to have anterior segment dysgenesis with iris strands, iridocorneal adhesions, and corectopia, as well as veil-like vitreous in both eyes. He required trabeculotomy, goniotomy, and multiple Baerveldt glaucoma implants in both eyes to achieve intraocular pressure control. Furthermore, the patient later developed macula-involving retinal detachments in both eyes, requiring pars plana vitrectomy with silicone oil tamponade. Genetic analysis confirmed heterozygous pathogenic variants in both the FOXC1 and COL2A1 genes, leading to the concurrent diagnoses of Axenfeld-Rieger and Stickler syndromes.

Conclusions and importance

This is a rare case of a patient with concurrent Axenfeld-Rieger and Stickler syndromes. The severity of pathology in both the anterior and posterior segments required a collaborative multidisciplinary approach. In the diagnostic evaluation of congenital eye diseases, if there is strong family history of atypical findings for a given diagnosis, concurrent syndromes should be considered and ruled out. A comprehensive eye genetics panel may be a useful tool in these cases.

Axial length shortening in myopic children with Stickler syndrome after repeated low-level red-light therapy

AIM

To report the myopia-controlling effect of repeated low-level red-light (RLRL) therapy in patients with Stickler syndrome (STL), an inherited collagenic disease typically presenting with early onset myopia.

METHODS

Three STL children, aged 3, 7, and 11y, received RLRL therapy throughout the follow-up period of 17, 3, and 6mo, respectively after exclusion of fundus anomalies. Data on best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), intraocular pressure, cycloplegic subjective refraction, ocular biometrics, scanning laser ophthalmoscope, optical coherence tomography, genetic testing, systemic disease history, and family history were recorded.

RESULTS

At the initiation of the RLRL therapy, the spherical equivalent (SE) of 6 eyes from 3 patients ranged from -3.75 to -20.38 D, axial length (AL) were from 23.88 to 30.68 mm, and BCVA were from 0.4 to 1.0 (decimal notation). Myopia progression of all six eyes slowed down after RLRL therapy. AL in five out of the six eyes shortened -0.07 to -0.63 mm. No side effects were observed.

CONCLUSION

Three cases of STL whose progression of myopic shift and AL elongation are successfully reduced and even reversed after RLRL therapy.

Case report: Autosomal recessive type 3 Stickler syndrome caused by compound heterozygous mutations in COL11A2

Background: Stickler syndrome (SS) is a group of hereditary collagenopathies caused by a variety of collagen and non-collagen genes. Affected patients have characteristic manifestations involving ophthalmic, articular, craniofacial and auditory disorders. SS is classified into several subtypes according to clinical and molecular features. Type 3 SS is an ultra-rare disease, known as non-ocular SS or otospondylomegaepiphyseal dysplasia (OSMED) with only a few pathogenic COL11A2 variants reported to date. Case presentation: A 29-year-old Chinese male was referred to our hospital for hearing loss and multiple joint pain. He presented a phenotype highly suggestive of OSMED, including progressive sensorineural deafness, spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia with large epiphyses, platyspondyly, degenerative osteoarthritis, and sunken nasal bridge. We detected compound heterozygous mutations in COL11A2, both of which were predicted to be splicing mutations. One is synonymous mutation c.3774C>T (p.Gly1258Gly) supposed to be a splice site mutation, the other is a novel intron mutation c.4750 + 5 G>A, which is a highly conservative site across several species. We also present a review of the current known pathogenic mutation spectrum of COL11A2 in patients with type 3 SS. Conclusion: Both synonymous extonic and intronic variants are easily overlooked by whole-exome sequencing. For patients with clinical manifestations suspected of SS syndrome, next-generation whole-genome sequencing is necessary for precision diagnosis and genetic counseling.

Quality of Life in Children and Adolescents with Stickler Syndrome in Spain

Objective: To describe the quality of life and daily functioning of Spanish children and adolescents living with Stickler syndrome (SS) and to estimate the prevalence of associated disease features in a representative sample. Methods: A cross-sectional study of children and adolescents with SS were recruited via telephone calls through the Spanish SS Association. All participants underwent a structured clinical interview and filled in questionnaires reporting their quality of life (EuroQol-5D, TSK-11, CHAQ and PedsQoL). The prevalence of the main features associated with the syndrome and the mean scores of the questionnaires were estimated with 95% confidence intervals (95% CI). Results: The recruited sample included 26 persons who were mainly children (mean age 10.4 ± 4.5 (SD) range: 5–14) and male (65.4%). The prevalence estimates of SS features were as follows: the presence of moderate pain (52%), hearing loss 67% (95% CI: 54.8 to 91.3) and myopia 96% (95% CI: 87.2 to 104.4). The mean scores of the QoL indices were as follows: 22.4 (95% CI: 19.2 to 25.5) (±7.5) for TSK-11; 76.2 (95% CI: 68.8 to 83.6) (±17.1) for PedsQoL, 0.8 (95% CI: 0.7 to 0.9) (±0.3) for EQ-5D and 0.61 (95% CI: 0.24 to 1.0) (±0.9) for the cHAQ functional index. Conclusions: Our results confirmed a high variability in syndrome-related manifestations, with a large prevalence of visual and hearing deficits, pain and maxillofacial alterations. These findings may facilitate the detection of the most prevalent problems in this population, which could be a target to be addressed during the treatment of children and adolescents with SS.

Dominant Stickler Syndrome

The Stickler syndromes are a group of genetic connective tissue disorders associated with an increased risk of rhegmatogenous retinal detachment, deafness, cleft palate, and premature arthritis. This review article focuses on the molecular genetics of the autosomal dominant forms of the disease. Pathogenic variants in COL2A1 causing Stickler syndrome usually result in haploinsufficiency of the protein, whereas pathogenic variants of type XI collagen more usually exert dominant negative effects. The severity of the disease phenotype is thus dependent on the location and nature of the mutation, as well as the normal developmental role of the respective protein.