Visualizing catalyst heterogeneity by a multifrequential oscillating reaction

Oscillating Structural Transformations in the Electrochemical Synthesis of Graphene Oxide from Graphite

Electrochemical synthesis of graphene oxide (GO) is known to occur with potential oscillations, but the structural changes underlying these oscillations have remained unclear. In situ time-resolved synchrotron radiation X-ray diffraction demonstrates that the electrochemical synthesis of GO in aqueous H2SO4 can be described as an oscillating reaction. The transformation from graphite to GO proceeds through periodic structural oscillations that correlate with potential cycles. Stage-1 graphite intercalation compound (GIC) is found only at the peak of the potential cycle, but not at the bottom of the cycle. Stage-1 GIC is formed in the first half-cycle from stage-2 GIC and then transforms into "pristine graphite oxide" (PGO) on the lower side of the potential cycle, after which the cycle restarts with the formation of a new portion of stage-1 GIC. Water-washing results in the transformation of PGO into water-swollen GO with d(001) ~11 Å. These periodic structural changes can be considered a new type of oscillating reaction. The presented results provide broad insights into the oscillating structural changes occurring during the anodic graphite oxidation in aqueous H2SO4 and allow to update of the mechanism of GO electrochemical formation.

Sensitive detection and imaging of H2O density through Rydberg resonant femtosecond laser induced photofragmentation fluorescence

A femtosecond laser induced photofragmentation fluorescence (fs-LIPF) scheme for the sensitive detection and imaging of water vapor is presented. Two photons of 244.3 nm excite water to the D̃ state and produce hydroxyl radicals in the fluorescing à state. Two more photons promote electrons from the D̃ state to a neutral Rydberg state of the (1b2)-1 ionic core through a 2 + 2 doubly resonant process. The resulting high-lying Rydberg state undergoes neutral dissociation, and the energetic hydrogen fragments are detected from their Balmer series fluorescence. These channels (in the low-pressure limit) have detection sensitivities around 1012 molecules per cubic centimeters, orders of magnitude more sensitive than laser-induced fluorescence based approaches, allowing for sensitive non-invasive detection and imaging of water density for many important processes.

Reverse water gas-shift reaction product driven dynamic activation of molybdenum nitride catalyst surface

In heterogeneous catalysis catalyst activation is often observed during the reaction process, which is mostly attributed to the induction by reactants. In this work we report that surface structure of molybdenum nitride (MoNx) catalyst exhibits a high dependency on the partial pressure or concentration of reaction products i.e., CO and H2O in reverse water gas-shift reaction (RWGS) (CO2:H2 = 1:3) but not reactants of CO2 and H2. Molybdenum oxide (MoOx) overlayers formed by oxidation with H2O are observed at reaction pressure below 10 mbar or with low partial pressure of CO/H2O products, while CO-induced surface carbonization happens at reaction pressure above 100 mbar and with high partial pressure of CO/H2O products. The reaction products induce restructuring of MoNx surface into more active molybdenum carbide (MoCx) to increase the reaction rate and make for higher partial pressure CO, which in turn promote further surface carbonization of MoNx. We refer to this as the positive feedback between catalytic activity and catalyst activation in RWGS, which should be widely present in heterogeneous catalysis.

Lanthanum modulated reaction pacemakers on a single catalytic nanoparticle

Promoters are important in catalysis, but the atomistic details of their function and particularly their role in reaction instabilities such as kinetic phase transitions and oscillations are often unknown. Employing hydrogen oxidation as probe reaction, a Rh nanotip for mimicking a single Rh nanoparticle and field electron microscopy for in situ monitoring, we demonstrate a La-mediated local catalytic effect. The oscillatory mode of the reaction provides a tool for studying the interplay between different types of reaction pacemakers, i.e., specific local surface atomic configurations that initiate kinetic transitions. The presence of La shifts the bistable reaction states, changes the oscillation pattern and deactivates one of two pacemaker types for the La-free surface. The observed effects originate from the La-enhanced oxygen activation on the catalyst. The experimental observations are corroborated by micro-kinetic model simulations comprising a system of 25 coupled oscillators.

Imaging Interface and Particle Size Effects by In Situ Correlative Microscopy of a Catalytic Reaction

The catalytic behavior of Rh particles supported by three different materials (Rh, Au, and ZrO₂) in H₂ oxidation has been studied in situ by correlative photoemission electron microscopy (PEEM) and scanning photoemission electron microscopy (SPEM). Kinetic transitions between the inactive and active steady states were monitored, and self-sustaining oscillations on supported Rh particles were observed. Catalytic performance differed depending on the support and Rh particle size. Oscillations varied from particle size-independent (Rh/Rh) via size-dependent (Rh/ZrO₂) to fully inhibited (Rh/Au). For Rh/Au, the formation of a surface alloy induced such effects, whereas for Rh/ZrO₂, the formation of substoichiometric Zr oxides on the Rh surface, enhanced oxygen bonding, Rh-oxidation, and hydrogen spillover onto the ZrO₂ support were held responsible. The experimental observations were complemented by micro-kinetic simulations, based on variations of hydrogen adsorption and oxygen binding. The results demonstrate how correlative in situ surface microscopy enables linking of the local structure, composition, and catalytic performance.

Emergence of chaos in a compartmentalized catalytic reaction nanosystem

In compartmentalized systems, chemical reactions may proceed in differing ways even in adjacent compartments. In compartmentalized nanosystems, the reaction behaviour may deviate from that observed on the macro- or mesoscale. In situ studies of processes in such nanosystems meet severe experimental challenges, often leaving the field to theoretical simulations. Here, a rhodium nanocrystal surface consisting of different nm-sized nanofacets is used as a model of a compartmentalized reaction nanosystem. Using field emission microscopy, different reaction modes are observed, including a transition to spatio-temporal chaos. The transitions between different modes are caused by variations of the hydrogen pressure modifying the strength of diffusive coupling between individual nanofacets. Microkinetic simulations, performed for a network of 52 coupled oscillators, reveal the origins of the different reaction modes. Since diffusive coupling is characteristic for many living and non-living compartmentalized systems, the current findings may be relevant for a wide class of reaction systems.

Oscillatory Reaction Activity of Single Cuprous Oxide Microparticles with NO2

Here, we report on using dark-field microscopy (DFM) as a simple and low-cost imaging platform to visually resolve the kinetics of single cuprous oxide (Cu₂O) microparticles for NO₂ removal in a real-time manner. Unexpectedly, we find that the redox reaction between Cu₂O microparticles and NO₂ is oscillating with the reaction time. Specifically, the oscillatory behavior of single Cu₂O microparticles for NO₂ reduction shows a large particle-to-particle variability, which is also dependent upon the NO₂ pressure and Cu₂O facets. A combined DFM imaging, spectroscopic, scanning electron microscopy, and density functional theory study uncovers that Cu₂O is gradually transformed to copper nitrate hydroxide [Cu₂(NO₃)(OH)₃], and this oscillatory reaction is attributed to the cyclic formation and structural collapse of Cu₂(NO₃)(OH)₃. The present findings open an alternative avenue for probing structure-performance relationships, which are anticipated to benefit the creation of functional materials for air purification.

Periodic structural changes in Pd nanoparticles during oscillatory CO oxidation reaction

Nanoparticle (NP) catalysts are ubiquitous in energy systems, chemical production, and reducing the environmental impact of many industrial processes. Under reactive environments, the availability of catalytically active sites on the NP surface is determined by its dynamic structure. However, atomic-scale insights into how a NP surface reconstructs under reaction conditions and the impact of the reconstruction on catalytic activity are still lacking. Using operando transmission electron microscopy, we show that Pd NPs exhibit periodic round-to-flat transitions altering their facets during CO oxidation reaction at atmospheric pressure and elevated temperatures. This restructuring causes spontaneous oscillations in the conversion of CO to CO₂ under constant reaction conditions. Our study reveals that the oscillatory behavior stems from the CO-adsorption-mediated periodic restructuring of the nanocatalysts between high-index-faceted round and low-index-faceted flat shapes. These atomic-scale insights into the dynamic surface properties of NPs under reactive conditions play an important role in the design of high-performance catalysts.

Reaction Modes on a Single Catalytic Particle: Nanoscale Imaging and Micro-Kinetic Modeling

The kinetic behavior of individual Rh(hkl) nanofacets coupled in a common reaction system was studied using the apex of a curved rhodium microcrystal (radius of 0.65 μm) as a model of a single catalytic particle and field electron microscopy for in situ imaging of catalytic hydrogen oxidation. Depending on the extent of interfacet coupling via hydrogen diffusion, different oscillating reaction modes were observed including highly unusual multifrequential oscillations: differently oriented nanofacets oscillated with differing frequencies despite their immediate neighborhood. The transitions between different modes were induced by variations in the particle temperature, causing local surface reconstructions, which create locally protruding atomic rows. These atomic rows modified the coupling strength between individual nanofacets and caused the transitions between different oscillating modes. Effects such as entrainment, frequency locking, and reconstruction-induced collapse of spatial coupling were observed. To reveal the origin of the different experimentally observed effects, microkinetic simulations were performed for a network of 105 coupled oscillators, modeling the individual nanofacets communicating via hydrogen surface diffusion. The calculated behavior of the oscillators, the local frequencies, and the varying degree of spatial synchronization describe the experimental observations well.

Pattern Formation in Catalytic H2 Oxidation on Rh: Zooming in by Correlative Microscopy

Spatio-temporal nonuniformities in H₂ oxidation on individual Rh(h k l) domains of a polycrystalline Rh foil were studied in the 10^–6 mbar pressure range by photoemission electron microscopy (PEEM), X-ray photoemission electron microscopy (XPEEM), and low-energy electron microscopy (LEEM). The latter two were used for in situ correlative microscopy to zoom in with significantly higher lateral resolution, allowing detection of an unusual island-mediated oxygen front propagation during kinetic transitions. The origin of the island-mediated front propagation was rationalized by model calculations based on a hybrid approach of microkinetic modeling and Monte Carlo simulations.

Dynamics of Heterogeneous Catalytic Processes at Operando Conditions

The rational design of high-performance catalysts is hindered by the lack of knowledge of the structures of active sites and the reaction pathways under reaction conditions, which can be ideally addressed by an in situ/operando characterization. Besides the experimental insights, a theoretical investigation that simulates reaction conditions-so-called operando modeling-is necessary for a plausible understanding of a working catalyst system at the atomic scale. However, there is still a huge gap between the current widely used computational model and the concept of operando modeling, which should be achieved through multiscale computational modeling. This Perspective describes various modeling approaches and machine learning techniques that step toward operando modeling, followed by selected experimental examples that present an operando understanding in the thermo- and electrocatalytic processes. At last, the remaining challenges in this area are outlined.

Coexisting multi-states in catalytic hydrogen oxidation on rhodium

Catalytic hydrogen oxidation on a polycrystalline rhodium foil used as a surface structure library is studied by scanning photoelectron microscopy (SPEM) in the 10-6 mbar pressure range, yielding spatially resolved X-ray photoemission spectroscopy (XPS) measurements. Here we report an observation of a previously unknown coexistence of four different states on adjacent differently oriented domains of the same Rh sample at the exactly same conditions. A catalytically active steady state, a catalytically inactive steady state and multifrequential oscillating states are simultaneously observed. Our results thus demonstrate the general possibility of multi-states in a catalytic reaction. This highly unusual behaviour is explained on the basis of peculiarities of the formation and depletion of subsurface oxygen on differently structured Rh surfaces. The experimental findings are supported by mean-field micro-kinetic modelling. The present observations raise the interdisciplinary question of how self-organising dynamic processes in a heterogeneous system are influenced by the permeability of the borders confining the adjacent regions.

Single-Particle Catalysis: Revealing Intraparticle Pacemakers in Catalytic H2 Oxidation on Rh

Self-sustained oscillations in H₂ oxidation on a Rh nanotip mimicking a single catalytic nanoparticle were studied by in situ field emission microscopy (FEM). The observed spatio-temporal oscillations result from the coupling of subsurface oxide formation/depletion with reaction front propagation. An original sophisticated method for tracking kinetic transition points allowed the identification of local pacemakers, initiating kinetic transitions and the nucleation of reaction fronts, with much higher temporal resolution than conventional processing of FEM video files provides. The pacemakers turned out to be specific surface atomic configurations at the border between strongly corrugated Rh{973} regions and adjacent relatively flat terraces. These structural ensembles are crucial for reactivity: while the corrugated region allows sufficient oxygen incorporation under the Rh surface, the flat terrace provides sufficient hydrogen supply required for the kinetic transition, highlighting the importance of interfacet communication. The experimental observations are complemented by mean-field microkinetic modeling. The insights into the initiation and propagation of kinetic transitions on a single catalytic nanoparticle demonstrate how in situ monitoring of an ongoing reaction on individual nanofacets can single out active configurations, especially when combined with atomically resolving the nanoparticle surface by field ion microscopy (FIM).

Emergence of Subsurface Oxygen on Rh(111)

Oxygen atoms on transition metal surfaces are highly mobile under the demanding pressures and temperatures typically employed for heterogeneously catalyzed oxidation reactions. This mobility allows for rapid surface diffusion of oxygen atoms, as well as absorption into the subsurface and reemergence to the surface, resulting in variable reactivity. Subsurface oxygen atoms play a unique role in the chemistry of oxidized metal catalysts, yet little is known about how subsurface oxygen is formed or returns to the surface. Furthermore, if oxygen diffusion between the surface and subsurface is mediated by defects, there will be localized changes in the surface chemistry due to the elevated oxygen concentration near the emergence sites. We observed that oxygen atoms emerge preferentially along the boundary between surface phases and that subsurface oxygen is depleted before the surface oxide decomposes.

Operando Surface Spectroscopy and Microscopy during Catalytic Reactions: From Clusters via Nanoparticles to Meso-Scale Aggregates

Operando characterization of working catalysts, requiring per definitionem the simultaneous measurement of catalytic performance, is crucial to identify the relevant catalyst structure, composition and adsorbed species. Frequently applied operando techniques are discussed, including X-ray absorption spectroscopy, near ambient pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and infrared spectroscopy. In contrast to these area-averaging spectroscopies, operando surface microscopy by photoemission electron microscopy delivers spatially-resolved data, directly visualizing catalyst heterogeneity. For thorough interpretation, the experimental results should be complemented by density functional theory. The operando approach enables to identify changes of cluster/nanoparticle structure and composition during ongoing catalytic reactions and reveal how molecules interact with surfaces and interfaces. The case studies cover the length-scales from clusters via nanoparticles to meso-scale aggregates, and demonstrate the benefits of specific operando methods. Restructuring, ligand/atom mobility, and surface composition alterations during the reaction may have pronounced effects on activity and selectivity. The nanoscale metal/oxide interface steers catalytic performance via a long ranging effect. Combining operando spectroscopy with switching gas feeds or concentration-modulation provides further mechanistic insights. The obtained fundamental understanding is a prerequisite for improving catalytic performance and for rational design.

Resolving multifrequential oscillations and nanoscale interfacet communication in single-particle catalysis

In heterogeneous catalysis research, the reactivity of individual nanofacets of single particles is typically not resolved. We applied in situ field electron microscopy to the apex of a curved rhodium crystal (radius of 650 nanometers), providing high spatial (~2 nanometers) and time resolution (~2 milliseconds) of oscillatory catalytic hydrogen oxidation, to image adsorbed species and reaction fronts on the individual facets. Using ionized water as the imaging species, the active sites were directly imaged with field ion microscopy. The catalytic behavior of differently structured nanofacets and the extent of coupling between them were monitored individually. We observed limited interfacet coupling, entrainment, frequency locking, and reconstruction-induced collapse of spatial coupling. The experimental results are backed up by microkinetic modeling of time-dependent oxygen species coverages and oscillation frequencies.

Bimetallic nanocatalysts supported on graphitic carbon nitride for sustainable energy development: the shape-structure-activity relation

The catalytic performance of metal nanoparticles (NPs), including activity, selectivity, and durability, depends on their shape and structure at the molecular level. Consequently, metal NPs of different size and shape, e.g., nanobelts, nanocubes, nanoflakes, and nanowires, demonstrate different reactivity and provide different reaction rates depending on the facet exposed. In this context, the present review aims to summarize the shape-structure-activity relation of metallic nanocatalysts. Moreover, keeping in mind that the application of noble metal catalysts is expensive, we would like to draw the reader's attention to bimetallic nanocatalysts supported on graphitic carbon nitride. One of the advantages of these systems is the possibility to minimize the use of noble metals by introducing another metal either to the parent NPs and/or modifying the support materials. The development and optimization of bimetallic nanocatalysts might provide the new class of materials with superior, tunable performance, thermal stability and reduced costs compared to presently available commercial catalysts. Therefore, further application of these bimetallic composites for sustainable development in energy, green chemicals/fuels and environmental protection will be discussed.

How the anisotropy of surface oxide formation influences the transient activity of a surface reaction

Scanning photoelectron microscopy (SPEM) and photoemission electron microscopy (PEEM) allow local surface analysis and visualising ongoing reactions on a µm-scale. These two spatio-temporal imaging methods are applied to polycrystalline Rh, representing a library of well-defined high-Miller-index surface structures. The combination of these techniques enables revealing the anisotropy of surface oxidation, as well as its effect on catalytic hydrogen oxidation. In the present work we observe, using locally-resolved SPEM, structure-sensitive surface oxide formation, which is summarised in an oxidation map and quantitatively explained by the novel step density (SDP) and step edge (SEP) parameters. In situ PEEM imaging of ongoing H₂ oxidation allows a direct comparison of the local reactivity of metallic and oxidised Rh surfaces for the very same different stepped surface structures, demonstrating the effect of Rh surface oxides. Employing the velocity of propagating reaction fronts as indicator of surface reactivity, we observe a high transient activity of Rh surface oxide in H₂ oxidation. The corresponding velocity map reveals the structure-dependence of such activity, representing a direct imaging of a structure-activity relation for plenty of well-defined surface structures within one sample.

Surface oxide formation under reaction conditions may change the catalytic activity of a catalyst. Here, the authors explore the effect of atomic structure of Rh surfaces on the surface oxide formation and its influence on catalytic activity in hydrogen oxidation, revealing a high transient activity.

Tunable deep ultraviolet laser based near ambient pressure photoemission electron microscope for surface imaging in the millibar regime

A newly developed instrument comprising a near ambient pressure (NAP) photoemission electron microscope (PEEM) and a tunable deep ultraviolet (DUV) laser source is described. This NAP-PEEM instrument enables dynamic imaging of solid surfaces in gases at pressures up to 1 mbar. A diode laser (976 nm) can illuminate a sample from the backside for in situ heating in gases up to 1200 K in minutes. The DUV laser with a tunable wavelength between 175 nm and 210 nm is perpendicularly incident onto the sample surface for PEEM imaging of a wide spectrum of solids with different surface work functions. Using this setup, we have first demonstrated spatiotemporal oscillation patterns of CO oxidation reaction on Pt(110) from high vacuum to NAPs and gas-induced restructuring of metal nanostructures in millibar gases. The new facility promises important applications in heterogeneous catalysis, electrochemical devices, and other surface processes under nearly working conditions.

A novel wireless sample temperature control system for field ion, field electron, and atom probe techniques

A novel sample temperature control system for field ion microscopy (FIM), field electron microscopy (FEM), and atom probe techniques based on wireless data transmission was designed, built, and applied for FIM and FEM studies of surface reactions. The system solves the longstanding problem of the temperature control of micrometer- to nanometer-sized samples during the operation in field emission based techniques. The new system can also be used for other applications requiring the specimen to be under high electric potential (tens of kilovolts or even higher). The chosen case studies of nanocatalysis demonstrate the capabilities and superior performance of the new temperature control system.

Formation and Functioning of Bimetallic Nanocatalysts: The Power of X-ray Probes

Bimetallic nanocatalysts are key enablers of current chemical technologies, including car exhaust converters and fuel cells, and play a crucial role in industry to promote a wide range of chemical reactions. However, owing to significant characterization challenges, insights in the dynamic phenomena that shape and change the working state of the catalyst await further refinement. Herein, we discuss the atomic-scale processes leading to mono- and bimetallic nanoparticle formation and highlight the dynamics and kinetics of lifetime changes in bimetallic catalysts with showcase examples for Pt-based systems. We discuss how in situ and operando X-ray spectroscopy, scattering, and diffraction can be used as a complementary toolbox to interrogate the working principles of today's and tomorrow's bimetallic nanocatalysts.

CO Oxidation on Stepped Rh Surfaces: μm-Scale Versus Nanoscale

Abstract

The catalytic CO oxidation reaction on stepped Rh surfaces in the 10−6 mbar pressure range was studied in situ on individual μm-sized high-Miller-index domains of a polycrystalline Rh foil and on nm-sized facets of a Rh tip, employing photoemission electron microscopy (PEEM) and field-ion/field-emission microscopy (FIM/FEM), respectively. Such approach permits a direct comparison of the reaction kinetics for crystallographically different regions under identical reaction conditions. The catalytic activity of the different Rh surfaces, particularly their tolerance towards poisoning by CO, was found to be strongly dependent on the density of steps and defects, as well as on the size (µm vs. nm) of the respective catalytically active surface.

Graphic Abstract

Rate and selectivity hysteresis during the carbon monoxide hydrogenation over promoted Co/MnOx catalysts

While cobalt-based catalysts have been used in industrial Fischer-Tropsch synthesis for decades, little is known about how the dynamics of the Co-Co₂C phase transformation drive their performance. Here we report on the occurrence of hysteresis effects in the Fischer-Tropsch reaction over potassium promoted Co/MnO_x catalyst. Both the reaction rate and the selectivity to chain-lengthened paraffins and terminally functionalized products (aldehydes, alcohols, olefins) show bistability when varying the hydrogen/carbon monoxide partial pressures back and forth from overall reducing to carbidizing conditions. While the carbon monoxide conversion and the selectivity to functionalized products follow clockwise hysteresis, the selectivity to paraffins shows counter-clockwise behavior. In situ X-ray diffraction demonstrates the activity/selectivity bistability to be driven by a Co-Co₂C phase transformation. The conclusions are supported by High Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy which identifies the Co-Co₂C transformation, Mn₅O₈ layered topologies at low H₂/CO partial pressure ratios, and MnO at high such ratios.

The question for the structure-reactivity relationship of cobalt-based catalysts for the carbon monoxide hydrogenation is as old as the reaction itself. Here the authors show kinetic hysteresis for a potassium-promoted cobalt-manganese oxide catalyst to be driven by the Co-Co₂C phase transition.

Surface-Structure Libraries: Multifrequential Oscillations in Catalytic Hydrogen Oxidation on Rhodium

Multifrequential oscillating spatiotemporal patterns in the catalytic hydrogen oxidation on rhodium have been observed in situ in the 10-6 mbar pressure range using photoemission electron microscopy. The effect is manifested by periodic chemical waves, which travel over the polycrystalline Rh surface and change their oscillation frequency while crossing boundaries between different Rh(hkl) domains. Each crystallographically specific μm-sized Rh(hkl) domain exhibits an individual wave pattern and oscillation frequency, despite the global diffusional coupling of the surface reaction, altogether creating a structure library. This unique reaction behavior is attributed to the ability of stepped surfaces of high-Miller-index domains to facilitate the formation of subsurface oxygen, serving as a feedback mechanism of kinetic oscillations. Formation of a network of subsurface oxygen as a result of colliding reaction fronts was observed in situ. Microkinetic model analysis was used to rationalize the observed effects and to reveal the relation between the barriers for surface oxidation and oscillation frequency. Structural limits of the oscillations, the existence range of oscillations, as well as the effect of varying hydrogen pressure are demonstrated.

Operando Insights into CO Oxidation on Cobalt Oxide Catalysts by NAP-XPS, FTIR, and XRD

Cobalt oxide Co₃O₄ has recently emerged as promising, noble metal-free catalyst for oxidation reactions but a better understanding of the active catalyst under working conditions is required for further development and potential commercialization. An operando approach has been applied, combining near ambient (atmospheric) pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (NAP-XPS), Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), or X-ray diffraction (XRD) with simultaneous catalytic tests of CO oxidation on Co₃O₄, enabling one to monitor surface and bulk states under various reaction conditions (steady-state and dynamic conditions switching between CO and O₂). On the basis of the surface-specific chemical information a complex network of different reaction pathways unfolded: Mars-van-Krevelen (MvK), CO dissociation followed by carbon oxidation, and formation of carbonates. A possible Langmuir–Hinshelwood (LH) pathway cannot be excluded because of the good activity when no oxygen vacancies were detected. The combined NAP-XPS/FTIR results are in line with a MvK mechanism above 100 °C, involving the Co³⁺/Co²⁺ redox couple and oxygen vacancy formation. Under steady state, the Co₃O₄ surface appeared oxidized and the amount of reduced Co²⁺ species at/near the surface remained low up to 200 °C. Only in pure CO, about 15% of surface reduction were detected, suggesting that the active sites are a minority species. The operando spectroscopic studies also revealed additional reaction pathways: CO dissociation followed by carbon reoxidation and carbonate formation and its decomposition. However, due to their thermal stability in various atmospheres, the carbonates are rather spectators and also CO dissociation seems a minor route. This study thus highlights the benefits of combining operando surface sensitive techniques to gain insight into catalytically active surfaces.