Spatial control of avidity regulates initiation and progression of selective autophagy

The emerging significance of Vac8, a multi-purpose armadillo-repeat protein in yeast

Vac8 is the sole armadillo-repeat (ARM) protein in yeast. The function of Vac8 in the cytoplasm-to-vacuole targeting pathway has been known for a long time but its role in the phagophore assembly site localization and recruitment of autophagy-related protein complexes is slowly coming to light. Because Vac8 is also involved in formation of the nuclear-vacuole junction and vacuole inheritance, the protein needs to be a competent and wide-ranging mediator of cellular processes. In this article, we discuss two recent studies reporting on Vac8 and its binding partners. We describe Vac8 in the context of crystallized protein complexes as well as predicted models to reveal the versatility of Vac8 and its potential to become a subject of future autophagy research.Abbreviation: ARM, armadillo repeat; Cvt, cytoplasm-to-vacuole targeting; IDPR, intrinsically disordered protein region NVJ, nucleus-vacuole junction; SEC, size-exclusion chromatography.

Temporal dissection of the roles of Atg4 and ESCRT in autophagosome formation in yeast

Autophagosomes are formed by the enlargement and sealing of phagophores. This is accompanied by the recruitment and release of autophagy-related (Atg) proteins that function therein. Presently, the relationship among factors that act after the initial emergence of the phagophore is unclear. The endosomal sorting complexes required for transport (ESCRT) machinery and Atg4 are known to function in phagophore sealing and Atg8 release, respectively. Here we show that biochemically, both Atg4 and ESCRT promoted phagophore sealing. Intriguingly, Atg4-mediated release of Atg8 from the phagophore promoted phagophore sealing even in the absence of ESCRT. This sealing activity could be reconstituted in vitro using cell lysate and purified Atg4. To elucidate the temporal relationship between Atg4 and ESCRT, we charted a timeline of the autophagosome formation cycle based on the trafficking of Atg proteins and mapped the actions of Atg4 and ESCRT to specific stages. The temporal impact of Atg4-mediated release of Atg8 from phagophore was mapped to the stage after the assembly of phagophore assembly site (PAS) scaffold and phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase (PtdIns-3-K) complex; its retardation only extended the duration of Atg8 release stage, leading to delayed phagophore sealing and accumulation of multiple phagophores. The impacts of ESCRT were mapped to two stages. In addition to promoting phagophore sealing, it also dictates whether PtdIns-3-K recruitment can occur by controlling Atg9 trafficking, thereby determining the incidence of autophagosome formation. Accordingly, ESCRT deficiency led to a combination of reduced autophagosome frequency and extended autophagosome formation duration, manifesting as reduced autophagic flux but normal apparent Atg8 puncta number. Our study thus identifies Atg4-mediated Atg8 shedding as a novel membrane scission mechanism and reveals a new early-stage role for ESCRT in autophagy.

Recruitment of Atg1 to the phagophore by Atg8 orchestrates autophagy machineries

Autophagy-related (Atg) proteins catalyze autophagosome formation at the phagophore assembly site (PAS). The assembly of Atg proteins at the PAS follows a semihierarchical order, in which Atg8 is thought to be quite downstream but still able to control the size of autophagosomes. Yet, how Atg8 coordinates multiple branches of autophagy machinery to regulate autophagosomal size is not clear. Here, we show that, in yeast, Atg8 positively regulates the autophagy-specific phosphatidylinositol 3-OH kinase complex and the retrograde trafficking of Atg9 vesicles through interaction with Atg1. Mechanistically, Atg8 does not enhance the kinase activity of Atg1; instead, it recruits Atg1 to the surface of the phagophore likely to orient Atg1's activity toward select substrates, leading to efficient phagophore expansion. Artificial tethering of Atg1 kinase domains to Atg8s enhanced autophagy in yeast, human and plant cells and improved muscle performance in worms. We propose that Atg8-mediated relocation of Atg1 from the PAS scaffold to the phagophore is a critical step in positive autophagy regulation.

The Role of WIPI2, ATG16L1 and ATG12-ATG5 in Selective and Nonselective Autophagy

Autophagy is a conserved cellular recycling pathway that delivers damaged or superfluous cytoplasmic material to lysosomes for degradation. In response to cytotoxic stress or starvation, autophagy can also sequester bulk cytoplasm and deliver it to lysosomes to regenerate building blocks. In macroautophagy, a membrane cisterna termed phagophore that encloses autophagic cargo is generated. The formation of the phagophore depends on a conserved machinery of autophagy related proteins. The phosphatidylinositol(3)-phosphate binding protein WIPI2 facilitates the transition from phagophore initiation to phagophore expansion by recruiting the ATG12-ATG5-ATG16L1 complex to phagophores. This complex functions as an E3-ligase to conjugate ubiquitin-like ATG8 proteins to phagophore membranes, which promotes tethering of cargo to phagophore membranes, phagophore expansion, maturation and the fusion of autophagosomes with lysosomes. ATG16L1 also has important functions independently of ATG12-ATG5 in autophagy and beyond. In this review, we will summarize the functions of WIPI2 and ATG16L1 in selective and nonselective autophagy.

Phase separation of initiation hubs on cargo is a trigger switch for selective autophagy

Autophagy is a key cellular quality control mechanism. Nutrient stress triggers bulk autophagy, which nonselectively degrades cytoplasmic material upon formation and liquid-liquid phase separation of the autophagy-related gene 1 (Atg1) complex. In contrast, selective autophagy eliminates protein aggregates, damaged organelles and other cargoes that are targeted by an autophagy receptor. Phase separation of cargo has been observed, but its regulation and impact on selective autophagy are poorly understood. Here, we find that key autophagy biogenesis factors phase separate into initiation hubs at cargo surfaces in yeast, subsequently maturing into sites that drive phagophore nucleation. This phase separation is dependent on multivalent, low-affinity interactions between autophagy receptors and cargo, creating a dynamic cargo surface. Notably, high-affinity interactions between autophagy receptors and cargo complexes block initiation hub formation and autophagy progression. Using these principles, we converted the mammalian reovirus nonstructural protein µNS, which accumulates as particles in the yeast cytoplasm that are not degraded, into a neo-cargo that is degraded by selective autophagy. We show that initiation hubs also form on the surface of different cargoes in human cells and are key to establish the connection to the endoplasmic reticulum, where the phagophore assembly site is formed to initiate phagophore biogenesis. Overall, our findings suggest that regulated phase separation underscores the initiation of both bulk and selective autophagy in evolutionarily diverse organisms.

Quiescent cells maintain active degradation-mediated protein quality control requiring proteasome, autophagy, and nucleus-vacuole junctions

Many cells spend a major part of their life in quiescence, a reversible state characterized by a distinct cellular organization and metabolism. In glucose-depleted quiescent yeast cells, there is a metabolic shift from glycolysis to mitochondrial respiration, and a large fraction of proteasomes are reorganized into cytoplasmic granules containing disassembled particles. Given these changes, the operation of protein quality control (PQC) in quiescent cells, in particular the reliance on degradation-mediated PQC and the specific pathways involved, remains unclear. By examining model misfolded proteins expressed in glucose-depleted quiescent yeast cells, we found that misfolded proteins are targeted for selective degradation requiring functional 26S proteasomes. This indicates that a significant pool of proteasomes remains active in degrading quality control substrates. Misfolded proteins were degraded in a manner dependent on the E3 ubiquitin ligases Ubr1 and San1, with Ubr1 playing a dominant role. In contrast to exponentially growing cells, the efficient clearance of certain misfolded proteins additionally required intact nucleus-vacuole junctions (NVJ) and Cue5-independent selective autophagy. Our findings suggest that proteasome activity, autophagy, and NVJ-dependent degradation operate in parallel. Together, the data demonstrate that quiescent cells maintain active PQC that relies primarily on selective protein degradation. The necessity of multiple degradation pathways for the removal of misfolded proteins during quiescence underscores the importance of misfolded protein clearance in this cellular state.

A quantitative ultrastructural timeline of nuclear autophagy reveals a role for dynamin-like protein 1 at the nuclear envelope

Autophagic mechanisms that maintain nuclear envelope homeostasis are bulwarks to aging and disease. By leveraging 4D lattice light sheet microscopy and correlative light and electron tomography, we define a quantitative and ultrastructural timeline of nuclear macroautophagy (nucleophagy) in yeast. Nucleophagy begins with a rapid accumulation of the selective autophagy receptor Atg39 at the nuclear envelope and finishes in ~300 seconds with Atg39-cargo delivery to the vacuole. Although there are several routes to the vacuole, at least one pathway incorporates two consecutive membrane fission steps: inner nuclear membrane (INM) fission to generate an INM-derived vesicle in the perinuclear space and outer nuclear membrane (ONM) fission to liberate a double membraned vesicle to the cytosol. ONM fission occurs independently of phagophore engagement and instead relies surprisingly on dynamin like 1 (Dnm1), which is recruited to sites of Atg39 accumulation by Atg11. Loss of Dnm1 compromises nucleophagic flux by stalling nucleophagy after INM fission. Our findings reveal how nuclear and INM cargo are removed from an intact nucleus without compromising its integrity, achieved in part by a non-canonical role for Dnm1 in nuclear envelope remodeling.

Biogenesis of omegasomes and autophagosomes in mammalian autophagy

Autophagy is a highly conserved catabolic pathway that maintains cellular homeostasis by promoting the degradation of damaged or superfluous cytoplasmic material. A hallmark of autophagy is the generation of membrane cisternae that sequester autophagic cargo. Expansion of these structures allows cargo to be engulfed in a highly selective and exclusive manner. Cytotoxic stress or starvation induces the formation of autophagosomes that sequester bulk cytoplasm instead of selected cargo. This rather nonselective pathway is essential for maintaining vital cellular functions during adverse conditions and is thus a major stress response pathway. Both selective and nonselective autophagy rely on the same molecular machinery. However, due to the different nature of cargo to be sequestered, the involved molecular mechanisms are fundamentally different. Although intense research over the past decades has advanced our understanding of autophagy, fundamental questions remain to be addressed. This review will focus on molecular principles and open questions regarding the formation of omegasomes and phagophores in nonselective mammalian autophagy.

FIP200 Phosphorylation Regulates Late Steps in Mitophagy

Mitophagy is a specific type of autophagy responsible for the selective elimination of dysfunctional or superfluous mitochondria, ensuring the maintenance of mitochondrial quality control. The initiation of mitophagy is coordinated by the ULK1 kinase complex, which engages mitophagy receptors via its FIP200 subunit. Whether FIP200 performs additional functions in the subsequent later phases of mitophagy beyond this initial step and how its regulation occurs, remains unclear. Our findings reveal that multiple phosphorylation events on FIP200 differentially control the early and late stages of mitophagy. Furthermore, these phosphorylation events influence FIP200's interaction with ATG16L1. In summary, our results highlight the necessity for precise and dynamic regulation of FIP200, underscoring its importance in the progression of mitophagy.

LDO proteins and Vac8 form a vacuole-lipid droplet contact site to enable starvation-induced lipophagy in yeast

Lipid droplets (LDs) are fat storage organelles critical for energy and lipid metabolism. Upon nutrient exhaustion, cells consume LDs via gradual lipolysis or via lipophagy, the en bloc uptake of LDs into the vacuole. Here, we show that LDs dock to the vacuolar membrane via a contact site that is required for lipophagy in yeast. The LD-localized LDO proteins carry an intrinsically disordered region that directly binds vacuolar Vac8 to form vCLIP, the vacuolar-LD contact site. Nutrient limitation drives vCLIP formation, and its inactivation blocks lipophagy, resulting in impaired caloric restriction-induced longevity. We establish a functional link between lipophagy and microautophagy of the nucleus, both requiring Vac8 to form respective contact sites upon metabolic stress. In sum, we identify the tethering machinery of vCLIP and find that Vac8 provides a platform for multiple and competing contact sites associated with autophagy.

Molecular Mechanism of Autophagy, Cytoplasmic Zoning by Lipid Membranes

Autophagy is a highly conserved intracellular degradation mechanism. The most distinctive feature of autophagy is the formation of double-membrane structures called autophagosomes, which compartmentalize portions of the cytoplasm. The outer membrane of the autophagosome fuses with the vacuolar/lysosomal membrane, leading to the degradation of the contents of the autophagosome. Approximately 30 years have passed since the identification of autophagy-related (ATG) genes and Atg proteins essential for autophagosome formation, and the primary functions of these Atg proteins have been elucidated. These achievements have significantly advanced our understanding of the mechanism of autophagosome formation. This article summarizes our current knowledge on how the autophagosome precursor is generated, and how the membrane expands and seals to complete the autophagosome.

Phagophore closure, autophagosome maturation and autophagosome fusion during macroautophagy in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Macroautophagy, hereafter referred to as autophagy, is a complex process in which multiple membrane-remodeling events lead to the formation of a cisterna known as the phagophore, which then expands and closes into a double-membrane vesicle termed the autophagosome. During the past decade, enormous progress has been made in understanding the molecular function of the autophagy-related proteins and their role in generating these phagophores. In this Review, we discuss the current understanding of three membrane remodeling steps in autophagy that remain to be largely characterized; namely, the closure of phagophores, the maturation of the resulting autophagosomes into fusion-competent vesicles, and their fusion with vacuoles/lysosomes. Our review will mainly focus on the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, which has been the leading model system for the study of molecular events in autophagy and has led to the discovery of the major mechanistic concepts, which have been found to be mostly conserved in higher eukaryotes.

Autophagy as a caretaker of nuclear integrity

Due to their essential functions, dysregulation of nuclear pore complexes (NPCs) is strongly associated with numerous human diseases, including neurodegeneration and cancer. On a cellular level, longevity of scaffold nucleoporins in postmitotic cells of both C. elegans and mammals renders them vulnerable to age-related damage, which is associated with an increase in pore leakiness and accumulation of intranuclear aggregates in rat brain cells. Thus, understanding the mechanisms which underpin the homeostasis of this complex, as well as other nuclear proteins, is essential. In this review, autophagy-mediated degradation pathways governing nuclear components in yeast will be discussed, with a particular focus on NPCs. Furthermore, the various nuclear degradation mechanisms identified thus far in diverse eukaryotes will also be highlighted.

The Atg1 complex, Atg9, and Vac8 recruit PI3K complex I to the pre-autophagosomal structure

In macroautophagy, cellular components are sequestered within autophagosomes and transported to lysosomes/vacuoles for degradation. Although phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase complex I (PI3KCI) plays a pivotal role in the regulation of autophagosome biogenesis, little is known about how this complex localizes to the pre-autophagosomal structure (PAS). In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, PI3KCI is composed of PI3K Vps34 and conserved subunits Vps15, Vps30, Atg14, and Atg38. In this study, we discover that PI3KCI interacts with the vacuolar membrane anchor Vac8, the PAS scaffold Atg1 complex, and the pre-autophagosomal vesicle component Atg9 via the Atg14 C-terminal region, the Atg38 C-terminal region, and the Vps30 BARA domain, respectively. While the Atg14-Vac8 interaction is constitutive, the Atg38-Atg1 complex interaction and the Vps30-Atg9 interaction are enhanced upon macroautophagy induction depending on Atg1 kinase activity. These interactions cooperate to target PI3KCI to the PAS. These findings provide a molecular basis for PAS targeting of PI3KCI during autophagosome biogenesis.

Autophagic and non-autophagic functions of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae PROPPINs Atg18, Atg21 and Hsv2

Atg18, Atg21 and Hsv2 are homologous β-propeller proteins binding to PI3P and PI(3,5)P2. Atg18 is thought to organize lipid transferring protein complexes at contact sites of the growing autophagosome (phagophore) with both the ER and the vacuole. Atg21 is restricted to the vacuole phagophore contact, where it organizes part of the Atg8-lipidation machinery. The role of Hsv2 is less understood, it partly affects micronucleophagy. Atg18 is further involved in regulation of PI(3,5)P2 synthesis. Recently, a novel Atg18-retromer complex and its role in vacuole homeostasis and membrane fission was uncovered.

How Membrane Contact Sites Shape the Phagophore

During macroautophagy, phagophores establish multiple membrane contact sites (MCSs) with other organelles that are pivotal for proper phagophore assembly and growth. In S. cerevisiae, phagophore contacts have been observed with the vacuole, the ER, and lipid droplets. In situ imaging studies have greatly advanced our understanding of the structure and function of these sites. Here, we discuss how in situ structural methods like cryo-CLEM can give unprecedented insights into MCSs, and how they help to elucidate the structural arrangements of MCSs within cells. We further summarize the current knowledge of the contact sites in autophagy, focusing on autophagosome biogenesis in the model organism S. cerevisiae.

Membrane Contact Sites in Autophagy

Eukaryotes utilize different communication strategies to coordinate processes between different cellular compartments either indirectly, through vesicular transport, or directly, via membrane contact sites (MCSs). MCSs have been implicated in lipid metabolism, calcium signaling and the regulation of organelle biogenesis in various cell types. Several studies have shown that MCSs play a crucial role in the regulation of macroautophagy, an intracellular catabolic transport route that is characterized by the delivery of cargoes (proteins, protein complexes or aggregates, organelles and pathogens) to yeast and plant vacuoles or mammalian lysosomes, for their degradation and recycling into basic metabolites. Macroautophagy is characterized by the de novo formation of double-membrane vesicles called autophagosomes, and their biogenesis requires an enormous amount of lipids. MCSs appear to have a central role in this supply, as well as in the organization of the autophagy-related (ATG) machinery. In this review, we will summarize the evidence for the participation of specific MCSs in autophagosome formation, with a focus on the budding yeast and mammalian systems.

In situ structural analysis reveals membrane shape transitions during autophagosome formation

Autophagosomes are unique organelles that form de novo as double-membrane vesicles engulfing cytosolic material for destruction. Their biogenesis involves membrane transformations of distinctly shaped intermediates whose ultrastructure is poorly understood. Here, we combine cell biology, correlative cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET), and extensive data analysis to reveal the step-by-step structural progression of autophagosome biogenesis at high resolution directly within yeast cells. The analysis uncovers an unexpectedly thin intermembrane distance that is dilated at the phagophore rim. Mapping of individual autophagic structures onto a timeline based on geometric features reveals a dynamical change of membrane shape and curvature in growing phagophores. Moreover, our tomograms show the organelle interactome of growing autophagosomes, highlighting a polar organization of contact sites between the phagophore and organelles, such as the vacuole and the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). Collectively, these findings have important implications for the contribution of different membrane sources during autophagy and for the forces shaping and driving phagophores toward closure without a templating cargo.

Characterization of Protein-Membrane Interactions in Yeast Autophagy

Cells rely on autophagy to degrade cytosolic material and maintain homeostasis. During autophagy, content to be degraded is encapsulated in double membrane vesicles, termed autophagosomes, which fuse with the yeast vacuole for degradation. This conserved cellular process requires the dynamic rearrangement of membranes. As such, the process of autophagy requires many soluble proteins that bind to membranes to restructure, tether, or facilitate lipid transfer between membranes. Here, we review the methods that have been used to investigate membrane binding by the core autophagy machinery and additional accessory proteins involved in autophagy in yeast. We also review the key experiments demonstrating how each autophagy protein was shown to interact with membranes.