Bioinspired crowding directs supramolecular polymerisation

Elucidating the Boundary of Intercalation vs Sequestration in Supramolecular Polymers by Retrosynthetic Design Toward the Construction of Complex Supramolecular Systems

Controlled social self-sorting by intercalation can offer distinct properties at the supramolecular level that go beyond the sum of its parts. Likewise, controlling narcissistic self-sorting by sequestration can induce unique system properties. In contrast, the interface between the two cases has hitherto remained underexplored, and clear design rules remain elusive. Herein it is demonstrated that by fine-tuning the molecular similarity of supramolecular synthons, intricate control over concerted supramolecular equilibria can be achieved. By reducing the molecular similarity, a former intercalator can be tuned to become a strong or weak sequestrator. Understanding these roles in binary mixtures allows to rationalize more complex tertiary systems. Consequently, the influence of an uncommon dual sequestration mechanism is revealed. Further, an unprecedented hybrid mechanism between supramolecular intercalation and sequestration can be demonstrated. We are hopeful that the results presented herein will contribute to the development and understanding of concerted processes in complex supramolecular systems.

Secondary nucleation as a strategy towards hierarchically organized mesoscale topologies in supramolecular polymerization

Developing new generic methodologies for organizing molecules into nano- to mesoscale structures of precise shapes and sizes is a research topic at the forefront of modern chemistry. Creating hierarchical molecular assembly, especially at the mesoscale, is important to realize functions reminiscent of those manifested by biomolecular assemblies in the mesoscopic regime. However, this is challenging due to the difficulty in maintaining stringent controllability over the organization of molecules at higher hierarchical levels, wherein weak non-directional intermolecular interactions rather than strong directional interactions typically play a predominant role. Recent studies have revealed that secondary nucleation, often experienced by one-dimensional assemblies such as supramolecular polymers that grow with spontaneous nucleation, is effective in the hierarchical construction of higher-order structures. Here we illustrate how secondary nucleation can be combined with the well-established precision synthesis of supramolecular polymers to realize precise control over hierarchical structures in the mesoscopic regime. We present a roadmap for creating hierarchical supramolecular polymers by exploiting secondary nucleation-elongation processes and discuss future prospects for the field.

Interfacing Flexible Design and Social Self-Sorting Enables Comprehensive Control over Photophysical and Self-Assembly Properties of Supramolecular Polymers

Supramolecular self-assembly offers an intriguing approach to construct microarchitectures, which combine properties of their molecular constituents with dynamic supramolecular features. Control over intermolecular interactions and their resulting properties can sometimes be achieved by targeted design. However, it is often unfeasible to transfer the insights gained from a specific supramolecular synthon to another chromophore without tedious synthetic work guided by trial and error. Herein we demonstrate how a flexible molecular design approach enables access to a diverse library of photophysical properties, which can be further diversified by social self-sorting strategies using a second supramolecular building block as a modulator. By intercalation into the supramolecular polymer the modulator can disrupt interchromophore interactions and modulate the ensembles emissive properties across the visible color space by simply adjusting the ratio between the two building blocks. Furthermore, by combining a chromophore appended synthon with a different morphology than the modulator the mesoscopic size distribution of the coassemblies can be modified to resemble either of its constituents. Crucially, this moldability is not only achievable for systems under thermodynamic control, but can be also employed to tune photophysical properties and thermal stability profiles of kinetically controlled states. Finally, the thermodynamic stability of the modulated polymers can be adjusted by varying the amount of solubilizing alkyl chains in the ensemble. This peripheral stabilization approach does not affect the engineered photophysical or supramolecular properties. Our results demonstrate how flexible molecular design enriched by a supramolecular modulator can offer access to a wide variety of photophysical properties and enable unique fine-tuning of various supramolecular properties.

Coaxial Helices in Chiral Supramolecular Aggregates from Highly Hindered Chiral Allenes

Chiral allenes self-assembly following a cooperative mechanism into a supramolecular chiral aggregate consisting of two coaxial helices: the internal helix described by the allene stack and the external helix which consist in a 4-helix described by the four allene substituents. More precisely, this supramolecular aggregate possesses six axially chiral elements within its structure-the allene, the allene stack (internal helix) and the stacks of the four allene substituents (external 4-helix)-. Interestingly, slight variations in the magnitude of the tilting degree while keeping its P- or M- orientation (internal helix) can vary the orientation of the 4-axial motifs at the external helix. Thus, while (P)-1 produces a supramolecular helix with a Θ ca. 15° (Pint) and a M1/P2/M1'/P2' orientation of the four axial motifs at the periphery, (P)-2 produces a supramolecular helix with a Θ ca. 23° (Pint) and a P1/P2/P1'/P2' orientation of the four axial motifs at the external helix. As a result, the ECD spectra and the AFM images of the (P)-1 and (P)-2 supramolecular aggregates dominated by the 1 and 1' substituents of the chiral allene indicate opposite handedness although the chirality of the building block and the orientation of the allene stack are the same.

Tetrahedral DNA framework-directed hybridization chain reaction controlled self-assembly

Nonenzymatic isothermal nucleic acid self-assembly techniques (e.g., the hybridization chain reaction, HCR) hold potential in building materials and biological sensing. However, a traditional HCR is triggered by the random diffusion and disordered conformations of ssDNA initiators, resulting in asynchronous initiation and inherently highly heterogeneous products that do not meet the standards of well-defined nanomaterials. Herein, we developed a nanomechanical restricted strategy directed by tetrahedral DNA frameworks (TDFs) to control HCR self-assembly. We found that the restricted initiator at TDF vertices could induce DNA hairpin assembly to form homogeneous products in solution. Mechanistically, we found that TDFs accelerated the strand displacement rate of the starting H1 and synchronized the assembly process of the HCR. Furthermore, the TDF exhibited strict vertex specificity for HCR controllable assembly, and side extension of the initiator could not result in homogeneous products. This work presents a straightforward and efficient approach for controlling the living self-assembly of macromolecular DNA, thus providing a novel tool for HCR-based nanomanufacturing and quantitative sensing applications.

Excited-State Carrier Dynamics in Semiconducting Heterostructures from Self-Sorted NIR Active Dyes

Heterostructures comprise two or more different semiconducting materials stacked either as co-assemblies or self-sorted based on their dynamics of aggregates. However, self-sorting in heterostructures is rather significant in improving the short exciton diffusion length and charge separation. Despite small organic molecules being known for their self-sorting nature, macrocyclic are hitherto unknown owing to unrestrained assemblies from extended π-conjugated systems. Herein, two near infrared region (NIR) active molecules comprised of porphyrin appended D-π-D (1) and A-π-A (2) have been reported to show the self-assembled 0D and 2D nanostructures via J-aggregates. Interestingly, the mixture of 1 and 2 reveals self-sorting at the molecular level promoting nanosphere and sheet structures which further rolled over to spheres through π-π stacking leading to core-shell type heterostructure. Consequently, electrical conductivity is 10 times higher than the individual assemblies due to excited state electron transfer from 1 to 2 in a mixture, confirmed by femto second-transient absorption spectroscopy and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. These results suggest that controlling the self-sorted heterostructures fosters refining the electronic properties which pave the way for designing novel NIR-absorbed molecules for organic solar cells (OSCs).

Kinetic Control over Social and Narcissistic Self-Sorting from Multicomponent Mixtures in Seed-Initiated Supramolecular Polymerization by Fine-Tuning of Steric Effects

Supramolecular polymers offer an intriguing possibility to transfer molecular properties from the nano- to the mesoscale. Towards this achievement, seed-initiated supramolecular polymerization has emerged as a powerful tool, as it prevents unlimited growth and enables size control of the assembly outcome. However, the potential application of the seeding method in the context of complex supramolecular systems is hitherto unclear. Herein we demonstrate that minute differences in molecular design in direct proximity to intermolecular recognition sites govern the molecular packing and in turn dictate the efficacy of seeded polymerization processes. We introduce a stepwise increase in steric demand in the central amino acid residue of a diamide system, which gradually increases the rotational displacement within the aggregated state. This fine-tuning of the molecular packing directly affects the propensity of the different aggregates to act as seeds for the other supramolecular synthons. In turn this allows us to selectively target specific trapped monomer states in binary mixtures for social or narcissistic seeded polymerization.

Two-Dimensional Supramolecular Polymorphism in Cyanine H- and J-Aggregates

We designed a new cyanine dye 1, with two pedant rod-like groups, capable of forming two distinct two-dimensional (2D) supramolecular polymorphs in methylcyclohexane; an H-type aggregate (Agg-H2) and a J-type aggregate (Agg-J). Importantly, these two polymorphs were not accessed through polymerization events, and instead through the thermal transformation of a third particle-like polymorph (Agg-H1) formed by the anti-cooperative assembly of 1. While Agg-H2 is generated upon cooling the solution of Agg-H1 by a thermoreversible polymorph transition, the Agg-J was obtained through a hidden pathway by combining sonication and cooling to the Agg-H1 solution. This is the first report on the obtention of H- and J-type cyanine polymorphs that in turn could be isolated in solid-state to render two new 2D photoactive materials. This paper unveils new strategies for designing 2D supramolecular polymers using calamitic residues, but also undercovers relevant aspects of pathway complexity and polymorph transitions that might be crucial for developing novel photonic systems.

Smart Crowding on pH-Induced Elasticity of Weakly Anionic poly(N-Isopropylacrylamide)-Based Semi-Interpenetrating Polymer Networks via Integration of Methacrylic Acid and Linear Polyacrylamide Chains

Weakly anionic semi-interpenetrating polymer networks (semi-IPNs), comprised of copolymer poly(N-isopropylacrylamide-co-methacrylic acid) P(NIPA-MA) and linear poly(acrylamide) (LPA) chains as macromolecular crowding agent, are designed to evaluate pH-induced swelling and elasticity. Uniaxial compression testing after swelling in various pH-conditions is used to analyze the compressive elasticity as a function of swelling pH and LPA-content. The swelling of P(NIPA-MA)/LPA semi-IPNs is strongly pH-dependent due to MA units incorporated into the copolymer network which already exhibits temperature-sensitivity by presence of PNIPA counterpart. Since the behavior of semi-IPNs is a combination of PMA, LPA, and PNIPA moieties, the sensitivity of swelling to external pH can be modified with increasing swelling temperature. At high pH conditions, LPA-doped semi-IPNs show elasticity representing soft and loosely cross-linked structure. Elastic modulus is higher in acidic pH condition due to the less swelling tendency, while in basic pH, the modulus decreases significantly in coordination with swelling. Oscillatory swelling reveals how fast semi-IPNs can respond to environmental pH change (2.1-10.7). By describing adsorption potential of semi-IPNs for cationic methylene blue uptake by pseudo-first-order and Freundlich model, the designed poly(NIPA-MA)/LPA semi-IPNs emerge as promising smart materials in applications requiring rapid response to changes in temperature and pH via diffusional properties.

Modulating self-assembly and polymorph transitions in bisdendronized squaramides

Supramolecular self-assembly is an advanced approach for constructing ordered nanoscale architectures with broad applications. While the principles of supramolecular polymerization have been thoroughly explored in artificial small molecules, polymer transformations remain barely explored, likely due to the lack of suitable reference models presenting well-defined and reversible transitions between aggregates. In this study, we introduce a series of bisdendronized squaramides (SQs) 1-3, showcasing complex self-assembly behaviours involving four distinct aggregates, three different interaction patterns, and various thermodynamically controlled polymorph transformations. Notably, SQ 3, with ethyl spacers between the SQ cores and the dendrons, exhibits a concentration and temperature-dependent equilibrium among three polymorphs: the particle-like Agg-A and fibrillar Agg-C, formed by slipped hydrogen bonds, and the fibrillar Agg-B, formed by head-to-tail hydrogen bonds. Additional solid-state experiments revealed that these SQs also form columnar liquid crystals, assembled by π-π interactions in SQ 1 and hydrogen bonding in SQ 2 and SQ 3. This work positions SQ units as valuable models for understanding polymorph equilibrium in solution and solid-state, which is crucial for developing stimuli-responsive supramolecular polymers.

Wide-range tunable circularly polarized luminescence in triphenylamine supramolecular polymers via charge-transfer complexation

Circularly polarized luminescence materials with broad color tunability are highly valuable for applications in 3D display and photonic technologies. Here we show that incorporating intermolecular charge-transfer complexation into chiral supramolecular polymers is an efficient strategy to achieve this objective. Adjusting the charge-transfer strength between triphenylamine donors and naphthalenemonoimide acceptors enables tunable circularly polarized luminescence signals across the visible light spectrum. This includes blue-colored emission for the supramolecular donor polymers, as well as green, yellow, orange and red-colored emission for supramolecular donor-acceptor polymers. The donor-acceptor packing modes are further influenced by the presence or absence of acetylene linkages on the triphenylamine donors, resulting in ground- or excited-state charge transfer with varying luminescent lifetimes. Additionally, white-light circularly polarized luminescence is achieved by encapsulating blue- and orange-emitting species into surfactant-based micelles in a compartmentalized manner. Overall, manipulating charge-transfer complexation in supramolecular polymers provides an effective approach to wide-range tunable circularly polarized luminescence materials.

Pathway-dependent supramolecular polymerization by planarity breaking

In controlled supramolecular polymerization, planar π-conjugated scaffolds are commonly used to predictably regulate stacking interactions, with various assembly pathways arising from competing interactions involving side groups. However, the extent to which the nature of the chromophore itself (planar vs. non-planar) affects pathway complexity requires clarification. To address this question, we herein designed a new BOPHY dye 2, where two oppositely oriented BF2 groups induce a disruption of planarity, and compared its supramolecular polymerization in non-polar media with that of a previously reported planar BODIPY 1 bearing identical substituents. The slightly non-planar structure of the BOPHY dye 2, as evident in previously reported X-ray structures, together with the additional out-of-plane BF2 group, allow for more diverse stacking possibilities leading to two fiber-like assemblies (kinetic 2A and thermodynamic 2B), in contrast to the single assembly previously observed for BODIPY 1. The impact of the less rigid, preorganized BOPHY core compared to the planar BODIPY counterpart is also reflected in the stronger tendency of the former to form anisotropic assemblies as a result of more favorable hydrogen bonding arrays. The structural versatility of the BOPHY core ultimately enables two stable packing arrangements: a kinetically controlled antiparallel face-to-face stacking (2A), and a thermodynamically controlled parallel slipped packing (2B) stabilized by (BF2) F⋯H (meso) interactions. Our findings underscore the significance of planarity breaking and out-of-plane substituents on chromophores as design elements in controlled supramolecular polymerization.

Achieving Circularly Polarized Phosphorescence through Noncovalent Clipping of Metallotweezers

Circularly polarized phosphorescent materials, based on host-guest complexation, have received significant attention due to their outstanding emission performance in solutions. Recent studies have primarily focused on macrocyclic host-guest complexes. To broaden the scope of this research, there is a keen pursuit of developing novel chiral phosphorescent host-guest systems. Metallotweezers with square-planar d8 transition metal complexes emerge as promising candidates for achieving this objective. Specifically, metallotweezers, comprising platinum(II) terpyridine and gold(III) diphenylpyridine pincers on a diphenylpyridine scaffold, have been designed and synthesized. Due to the preorganization effect rendered by the diphenylpyridine scaffold, the resulting metallotweezers are capable of complexing with each other and forming quadruple stacking structures. The phosphorescent emission is enhanced owing to the synergistic rigidifying and shielding effects. Meanwhile, the steric effect of chiral (1R) pinene units on the platinum(II) terpyridine pincers results in a stereospecific twist for the quadruple stacking structures. Thus, the chirality transfers from the molecular to the supramolecular level. By a combination of phosphorescent enhancement and supramolecular chirality for the clipping complex, circularly polarized phosphorescent emission is achieved. Overall, noncovalent clipping of metallotweezers exemplified in the current study presents a novel and effective approach toward solution-processable circularly polarized phosphorescent materials.

Increasing Dimensionality in Self-Assembly: Toward Two-Dimensional Supramolecular Polymers

Different approaches to achieve 2D supramolecular polymers, as an alternative to the covalent bottom-up approaches reported for the preparation of 2D materials, are reviewed. The significance of the operation of weak non-covalent forces to induce a lateral growth of a number of self-assembling units is collected. The examples of both thermodynamically and kinetically controlled formation of 2D supramolecular polymers showed in this review demonstrate the utility of this strategy to achieve new 2D materials with biased morphologies (nanosheets, scrolls, porous surfaces) and showing elegant applications like chiral recognition, enantioselective uptake or asymmetric organic transformations. Furthermore, elaborated techniques like seeded or living supramolecular polymerizations have been demonstrated to give rise to complex 2D nanostructures.

Controlled Supramolecular Polymerization via Bioinspired, Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation of Monomers

Dynamic supramolecular assemblies, driven by noncovalent interactions, pervade the biological realm. In the synthetic domain, their counterparts, supramolecular polymers, endowed with remarkable self-repair and adaptive traits, are often realized through bioinspired designs. Recently, controlled supramolecular polymerization strategies have emerged, drawing inspiration from protein self-assembly. A burgeoning area of research involves mimicking the liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) observed in proteins to create coacervate droplets and recognizing their significance in cellular organization and diverse functions. Herein, we introduce a novel perspective on synthetic coacervates, extending beyond their established role in synthetic biology as dynamic, membraneless phases to enable structural control in synthetic supramolecular polymers. Drawing parallels with the cooperative growth of amyloid fibrils through LLPS, we present metastable coacervate droplets as dormant monomer phases for controlled supramolecular polymerization. This is achieved via a π-conjugated monomer design that combines structural characteristics for both coacervation through its terminal ionic groups and one-dimensional growth via a π-conjugated core. This design leads to a unique temporal LLPS, resulting in a metastable coacervate phase, which subsequently undergoes one-dimensional growth via nucleation within the droplets. In-depth spectroscopic and microscopic characterization provides insights into the temporal evolution of disordered and ordered phases. Furthermore, to modulate the kinetics of liquid-to-solid transformation and to achieve precise control over the structural characteristics of the resulting supramolecular polymers, we invoke seeding in the droplets, showcasing living growth characteristics. Our work thus opens up new avenues in the exciting field of supramolecular polymerization, offering general design principles and controlled synthesis of precision self-assembled structures in confined environments.

Supramolecular polymers form tactoids through liquid-liquid phase separation

Liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) of biopolymers has recently been shown to play a central role in the formation of membraneless organelles with a multitude of biological functions1-3. The interplay between LLPS and macromolecular condensation is part of continuing studies4,5. Synthetic supramolecular polymers are the non-covalent equivalent of macromolecules but they are not reported to undergo LLPS yet. Here we show that continuously growing fibrils, obtained from supramolecular polymerizations of synthetic components, are responsible for phase separation into highly anisotropic aqueous liquid droplets (tactoids) by means of an entropy-driven pathway. The crowding environment, regulated by dextran concentration, affects not only the kinetics of supramolecular polymerizations but also the properties of LLPS, including phase-separation kinetics, morphology, internal order, fluidity and mechanical properties of the final tactoids. In addition, substrate-liquid and liquid-liquid interfaces proved capable of accelerating LLPS of supramolecular polymers, allowing the generation of a myriad of three-dimensional-ordered structures, including highly ordered arrays of micrometre-long tactoids at surfaces. The generality and many possibilities of supramolecular polymerizations to control emerging morphologies are demonstrated with several supramolecular polymers, opening up a new field of matter ranging from highly structured aqueous solutions by means of stabilized LLPS to nanoscopic soft matter.

Two-Dimensional Supramolecular Polymerization of a Bis-Urea Macrocycle into a Brick-Like Hydrogen-Bonded Network

We report on a dendronized bis-urea macrocycle 1 self-assembling via a cooperative mechanism into two-dimensional (2D) nanosheets formed solely by alternated urea-urea hydrogen bonding interactions. The pure macrocycle self-assembles in bulk into one-dimensional liquid-crystalline columnar phases. In contrast, its self-assembly mode drastically changes in CHCl3 or tetrachloroethane, leading to 2D hydrogen-bonded networks. Theoretical calculations, complemented by previously reported crystalline structures, indicate that the 2D assembly is formed by a brick-like hydrogen bonding pattern between bis-urea macrocycles. This assembly is promoted by the swelling of the trisdodecyloxyphenyl groups upon solvation, which frustrates, due to steric effects, the formation of the thermodynamically more stable columnar macrocycle stacks. This work proposes a new design strategy to access 2D supramolecular polymers by means of a single non-covalent interaction motif, which is of great interest for materials development.

Controlled Noncovalent Synthesis of Secondary Supramolecular Polymers

Dynamic supramolecular polymers, with their functional similarities to classical covalent polymers and their adaptive and self-repairing nature reminiscent of biological assemblies, have emerged as highly promising systems for the design of smart soft materials. Recent advancements in mechanistic investigations and novel synthetic strategies, such as living supramolecular polymerization, have significantly enhanced our ability to control the primary structure of these supramolecular polymers. However, realizing their full functional potential requires expanding their topological diversity in a manner akin to classical polymers as well as achieving precise molecular organization at higher hierarchical levels of self-assembly. In this paper, we present a remarkable advancement in this field, introducing an unprecedented and controlled synthesis of secondary supramolecular polymers. Our innovative strategy combines chirality-controlled surface-catalyzed secondary nucleation and a bioinspired peptide design, effectively stabilizing higher-order assembly. Furthermore, by harnessing this stereoselective nucleation process, we demonstrate the successful synthesis of racemic supramolecular polymers featuring parallelly stacked conglomerate microstructures─a previously unreported topology in synthetic self-assembled systems. Additionally, we elucidate that the extent of secondary supramolecular polymers can be regulated by modulating the enantiomeric excess of the chiral monomers. Consequently, our study unveils new topologies that exhibit enhanced higher-order structural complexity in the realm of supramolecular polymers.