The three-dimensional structure of transfer RNA

Ned Seeman and the prediction of amino acid-basepair motifs mediating protein-nucleic acid recognition

Fifty years ago, the first atomic-resolution structure of a nucleic acid double helix, the mini-duplex (ApU)2, revealed details of basepair geometry, stacking, sugar conformation, and backbone torsion angles, thereby superseding earlier models based on x-ray fiber diffraction, including the original DNA double helix proposed by Watson and Crick. Just 3 years later, in 1976, Ned Seeman, John Rosenberg, and Alex Rich leapt from their structures of mini-duplexes and H-bonding motifs between bases in small-molecule structures and transfer RNA to predicting how proteins could sequence specifically recognize double helix nucleic acids. They proposed interactions between amino acid side chains and nucleobases mediated by two hydrogen bonds in the major or minor grooves. One of these, the arginine-guanine pair, emerged as the most favored amino acid-base interaction in experimental structures of protein-nucleic acid complexes determined since 1986. In this brief review we revisit the pioneering work by Seeman et al. and discuss the importance of the arginine-guanine pairing motif.

Anticipating innovations in structural biology

In this review, we describe how the interplay among science, technology and community interests contributed to the evolution of four structural biology data resources. We present the method by which data deposited by scientists are prepared for worldwide distribution, and argue that data archiving in a trusted repository must be an integral part of any scientific investigation.

Revealing structural views of biology

The first protein structures were determined in the 1950s. In the decades that followed, development of new methods for sample preparation, crystallization, data collection, and structure analysis yielded tens of thousands of biomolecular structures. This short review highlights some of the major technical advances exemplified with selected structures.

Mg2+ binding and archaeosine modification stabilize the G15 C48 Levitt base pair in tRNAs

The G15-C48 Levitt base pair, located at a crucial position in the core of canonical tRNAs, assumes a reverse Watson-Crick (RWC) geometry. By means of bioinformatics analysis and quantum mechanics calculations we show here that such a geometry is moderately more stable than an alternative bifurcated trans geometry, involving the guanine Watson-Crick face and the cytosine keto group, which we have also found in known RNA structures. However we also demonstrate that the RWC geometry can take advantage of additional stabilizing effects such as metal binding or post-transcriptional chemical modification. One of the few strong metal binding sites characterized for cytosolic tRNAs is localized on G15, and a domain-specific complex modification known as archaeosine is widespread at position 15 in archaeal tRNAs. We have found that both the bound Mg2+ ion and the archaeosine modification induce an analogous electron density redistribution, which results in an effective stabilization of the RWC geometry. Metal binding and chemical modification thus play an interchangeable role in stabilizing the G15-C48 correct geometry. Interestingly, these different but convergent strategies are selectively adopted in the different life domains.

Accurate energies of hydrogen bonded nucleic acid base pairs and triplets in tRNA tertiary interactions

Tertiary interactions are crucial in maintaining the tRNA structure and functionality. We used a combined sequence analysis and quantum mechanics approach to calculate accurate energies of the most frequent tRNA tertiary base pairing interactions. Our analysis indicates that six out of the nine classical tertiary interactions are held in place mainly by H-bonds between the bases. In the remaining three cases other effects have to be considered. Tertiary base pairing interaction energies range from -8 to -38 kcal/mol in yeast tRNA(Phe) and are estimated to contribute roughly 25% of the overall tRNA base pairing interaction energy. Six analyzed posttranslational chemical modifications were shown to have minor effect on the geometry of the tertiary interactions. Modifications that introduce a positive charge strongly stabilize the corresponding tertiary interactions. Non-additive effects contribute to the stability of base triplets.

The minimal tRNA: unique structure of Ascaris suum mitochondrial tRNA(Ser)(UCU) having a short T arm and lacking the entire D arm

The tertiary structure of Ascaris suum mitochondrial tRNA(Ser)(UCU) was examined by nuclear magnetic resonance analysis using its transcript, since tRNA(Ser)(UCU), lacking the D arm and possessing a truncated T arm, is the shortest of all the known tRNAs. Most basepairs in the proposed secondary structure of tRNA(Ser)(UCU) were shown to exist, but the connector region comprising the truncated D loop and the extra loop was flexible. This flexibility, would enable adjustment of the mutual distance between the 3'-terminus and the anticodon consistent with that of usual tRNAs. Thus, tRNA(Ser)UCU appears to function in a similar way to that of usual tRNAs in the ribosome.

Characterization and tRNA recognition of mammalian mitochondrial seryl-tRNA synthetase

Animal mitochondrial protein synthesis systems contain two serine tRNAs (tRNAs(Ser)) corresponding to the codons AGY and UCN, each possessing an unusual secondary structure; the former lacks the entire D arm, and the latter has a slightly different cloverleaf structure. To elucidate whether these two tRNAs(Ser) can be recognized by the single animal mitochondrial seryl-tRNA synthetase (mt SerRS), we purified mt SerRS from bovine liver 2400-fold and showed that it can aminoacylate both of them. Specific interaction between mt SerRS and either of the tRNAs(Ser) was also observed in a gel retardation assay. cDNA cloning of bovine mt SerRS revealed that the deduced amino acid sequence of the enzyme contains 518 amino acid residues. The cDNAs of human and mouse mt SerRS were obtained by reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction and expressed sequence tag data base searches. Elaborate inspection of primary sequences of mammalian mt SerRSs revealed diversity in the N-terminal domain responsible for tRNA recognition, indicating that the recognition mechanism of mammalian mt SerRS differs considerably from that of its prokaryotic counterpart. In addition, the human mt SerRS gene was found to be located on chromosome 19q13.1, to which the autosomal deafness locus DFNA4 is mapped.

Transfer RNA recognition by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases

The aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are an ancient group of enzymes that catalyze the covalent attachment of an amino acid to its cognate transfer RNA. The question of specificity, that is, how each synthetase selects the correct individual or isoacceptor set of tRNAs for each amino acid, has been referred to as the second genetic code. A wealth of structural, biochemical, and genetic data on this subject has accumulated over the past 40 years. Although there are now crystal structures of sixteen of the twenty synthetases from various species, there are only a few high resolution structures of synthetases complexed with cognate tRNAs. Here we review briefly the structural information available for synthetases, and focus on the structural features of tRNA that may be used for recognition. Finally, we explore in detail the insights into specific recognition gained from classical and atomic group mutagenesis experiments performed with tRNAs, tRNA fragments, and small RNAs mimicking portions of tRNAs.

Solution structure of the tobramycin-RNA aptamer complex

We have solved the solution structure of the aminoglycoside antibiotic tobramycin complexed with a stem-loop RNA aptamer. The 14 base loop of the RNA aptamer 'zippers up' alongside the attached stem through alignment of four mismatches and one Watson-Crick pair on complex formation. The tobramycin inserts into the deep groove centered about the mismatch pairs and is partially encapsulated between its floor and a looped out guanine base that flaps over the bound antibiotic. Several potential intermolecular hydrogen bonds between the charged NH3 groups of tobramycin and acceptor atoms on base pair edges and backbone phosphates anchor the aminoglycoside antibiotic within its sequence/structure specific RNA binding pocket.

Preparation of biologically active Ascaris suum mitochondrial tRNAMet with a TV-replacement loop by ligation of chemically synthesized RNA fragments

Ascaris suum mitochondrial tRNA Met lacking the entire T stem was prepared by enzymatic ligation of two chemically synthesized RNA fragments. The synthetic tRNA could be charged with methionine by A.suum mitochondrial extract, although the charging activity was considerably low compared with that of the native tRNA, probably due to lack of modification. Enzymatic probing of the synthetic tRNA showed a very similar digestion pattern to that of the native tRNA Met, which has already been concluded to take an L-shape-like structure [Watanabe et al. (1994) J. Biol. Chem., 269, 22902-22906]. These results suggest that the synthetic tRNA possesses almost the same conformation as the native one, irrespective of the presence or absence of modified residues. The method of preparing the bizarre tRNA used here will provide a useful tool for elucidating the tertiary structure of such tRNAs, because they can be obtained without too much difficulty in the amounts necessary for physicochemical studies such as NMR spectroscopy.

Higher-order structure of bovine mitochondrial tRNA(SerUGA): chemical modification and computer modeling

On the basis of enzymatic probing and phylogenetic comparison, we have previously proposed that mammalian mitochondrial tRNA(sSer) (anticodon UGA) possess a slightly altered cloverleaf structure in which only one nucleotide exists between the acceptor stem and D stem (usually two nucleotides) and the anticodon stem consists of six base pairs (usually five base pairs) [Yokogawa et al. (1991) Nucleic Acids Res. 19, 6101-6105]. To ascertain whether such tRNA(sSer) can be folded into a normal L-shaped tertiary structure, the higher-order structure of bovine mitochondrial tRNA(SerUGA) was examined by chemical probing using dimethylsulfate and diethylpyrocarbonate, and on the basis of the results a tertiary structure model was obtained by computer modeling. It was found that a one-base-pair elongation in the anticodon stem was compensated for by multiple-base deletions in the D and extra loop regions of the tRNA(SerUGA), which resulted in preservation of an L-shaped tertiary structure similar to that of conventional tRNAs. By summarizing the findings, the general structural requirements of mitochondrial tRNAs necessary for their functioning in the mitochondrial translation system are considered.

A point mutation in Euglena gracilis chloroplast tRNA(Glu) uncouples protein and chlorophyll biosynthesis

The universal precursor of tetrapyrrole pigments (e.g., chlorophylls and hemes) is 5-aminolevulinic acid (ALA), which in Euglena gracilis chloroplasts is derived via the two-step C5 pathway from glutamate charged to tRNA(Glu). The first enzyme in this pathway, Glu-tRNA reductase (GluTR) catalyzes the reduction of glutamyl-tRNA(Glu) (Glu-tRNA) to glutamate 1-semialdehyde (GSA) with the release of the uncharged tRNA(Glu). The second enzyme, GSA-2,1-aminomutase, converts GSA to ALA. tRNA(Glu) is a specific cofactor for the NADPH-dependent reduction by GluTR, an enzyme that recognizes the tRNA in a sequence-specific manner. This RNA is the normal tRNA(Glu), a dual-function molecule participating both in protein and in ALA and, hence, chlorophyll biosynthesis. A chlorophyll-deficient mutant of E. gracilis (Y9ZNalL) does not synthesize ALA from glutamate, although it contains GluTR and GSA-2,1-aminomutase activity. The tRNA(Glu) isolated from the mutant can still be acylated with glutamate in vitro and in vivo. Furthermore, it supports chloroplast protein synthesis; however, it is a poor substrate for GluTR. Sequence analysis of the tRNA and of its gene revealed a C56-->U mutation in the resulting gene product. C56 is therefore an important identity element for GluTR. Thus, a point mutation in the T loop of tRNA uncouples protein from chlorophyll biosynthesis.

Higher-order structure of bovine mitochondrial tRNA(Phe) lacking the 'conserved' GG and T psi CG sequences as inferred by enzymatic and chemical probing

Bovine mitochondrial (mt) phenylalanine tRNA (tRNA(Phe)), which lacks the 'conserved' GG and T psi YCG sequences, was efficiently purified by the selective hybridization method using a solid phase DNA probe. The entire nucleotide sequence of the tRNA, including modified nucleotides, was determined and its higher-order structure was investigated using RNaseT2 and chemical reagents as structural probes. The D and T loop regions as well as the anticodon loop region were accessible to RNaseT2, and the N-3 positions of cytidines present in the D and T loops were easily modified under the native conditions in the presence of 10mM Mg2+. On the other hand, the nucleotides present in the extra loop were protected from the chemical modification under the native conditions. From the results of these probing analyses and a comparison of the sequences of mitochondrial tRNA(Phe) genes from various organisms, it was inferred that bovine mt tRNA(Phe) lacks the D loop/T loop tertiary interactions, but does have the canonical extra loop/D stem interactions, which seem to be the main factor for bovine mt tRNA(Phe) to preserve its L-shaped higher-order structure.

Unusual anticodon loop structure found in E.coli lysine tRNA

Although both tRNA(Lys) and tRNA(Glu) of E. coli possess similar anticodon loop sequences, with the same hypermodified nucleoside 5-methylaminomethyl-2-thiouridine (mnm5s2U) at the first position of their anticodons, the anticodon loop structures of these two tRNAs containing the modified nucleoside appear to be quite different as judged from the following observations. (1) The CD band derived from the mnm5s2U residue is negative for tRNA(Glu), but positive for tRNA(Lys). (2) The mnm5s2U monomer itself and the mnm5s2U-containing anticodon loop fragment of tRNA(Lys) show the same negative CD bands as that of tRNA(Glu). (3) The positive CD band of tRNA(Lys) changes to negative when the temperature is raised. (4) The reactivity of the mnm5s2U residue toward H2O2 is much lower for tRNA(Lys) than for tRNA(Glu). These features suggest that tRNA(Lys) has an unusual anticodon loop structure, in which the mnm5s2U residue takes a different conformation from that of tRNA(Glu); whereas the mnm5s2U base of tRNA(Glu) has no direct bonding with other bases and is accessible to a solvent, that of tRNA(Lys) exists as if in some way buried in its anticodon loop. The limited hydrolysis of both tRNAs by various RNases suggests that some differences exist in the higher order structures of tRNA(Lys) and tRNA(Glu). The influence of the unusual anticodon loop structure observed for tRNA(Lys) on its function in the translational process is also discussed.

Intron excision from tRNA precursors by plant splicing endonuclease requires unique features of the mature tRNA domain

It has been proposed that yeast and Xenopus splicing endonucleases initially recognize features in the mature tRNA domain common to all tRNA species and that the sequence and structure of the intron are only minor determinants of splice-site selection. In accordance with this postulation, we show that yeast endonuclease splices heterologous pre-tRNA(Tyr) species from vertebrates and plants which differ in their mature domains and intron secondary structures. In contrast, wheat germ splicing endonuclease displays a pronounced preference for homologous pre-tRNA species; an extensive study of heterologous substrates revealed that neither yeast pre-tRNA species specific for leucine, serine, phenylalanine and tyrosine nor human and Xenopus pre-tRNA(Tyr) species were spliced. In order to identify the elements essential for pre-tRNA splicing in plants, we constructed chimeric genes coding for tRNA precursors with a plant intron secondary structure and with mature tRNA(Tyr) domains from yeast and Xenopus, respectively. The chimeric pre-tRNA comprising the mature tRNA(Tyr) domain from Xenopus was spliced efficiently in wheat germ extract, whereas the chimeric construct containing the mature tRNA(Tyr) domain from yeast was not spliced at all. These data indicate that intron secondary structure contributes to the specificity of plant splicing endonuclease and that unique features of the mature tRNA domain play a dominant role in enzyme-substrate recognition. We further investigated the influence of specific nucleotides in the mature domain on splicing by generating a number of mutated pre-tRNA species. Our results suggest that nucleotides located in the D stem, i.e. in the center of the pre-tRNA molecule, are recognition points for plant splicing endonuclease.

Effect of the higher-order structure of tRNAs on the stability of hybrids with oligodeoxyribonucleotides: separation of tRNA by an efficient solution hybridization

In the course of developing a method to purify a single tRNA species efficiently, we have examined hybridization efficiencies between some tRNAs and short oligodeoxyribonucleotide probes both by the filter and solution hybridization methods without denaturants. The hybridization efficiencies varied considerably among probes which are complementary to different regions of the tRNAs, although there was little efficiency variation in the probes toward DNA substrates including the same nucleotide sequence. This efficiency variation was shown to be due to tRNA-specific higher-order structures as well as a hypermodified nucleotide in the anticodon loop. Characterization of the tRNA-probe hybrids by both nondenaturing gel electrophoresis and chemical modification showed the existence of two stable hybridizing states as a function of ionic strength. Our results indicate that RNA molecules with a number of intramolecular base pairings are able to form stable hybrids with complementary sequences under nondenaturing conditions. On the basis of these data, an appropriate probe was designed to successfully purify yeast tRNA(Phe) by making a tRNA(Phe)-probe hybrid, which has a longer retention time in hydroxyapatite high performance liquid chromatography than the tRNA(Phe) itself.

A novel cloverleaf structure found in mammalian mitochondrial tRNA(Ser) (UCN)

Bovine mitochondrial tRNA(Ser) (UCN) has been thought to have two U-U mismatches at the top of the acceptor stem, as inferred from its gene sequence. However, this unusual structure has not been confirmed at the RNA level. In the course of investigating the structure and function of mitochondrial tRNAs, we have isolated the bovine liver mitochondrial tRNA(Ser) (UCN) and determined its complete sequence including the modified nucleotides. Analysis of the 5'-terminal nucleotide and enzymatic determination of the whole sequence of tRNA(Ser) (UCN) revealed that the tRNA started from the third nucleotide of the putative tRNA(Ser) (UCN) gene, which had formerly been supposed. Enzymatic probing of tRNA(Ser) (UCN) suggests that the tRNA possesses an unusual cloverleaf structure with the following characteristics. (1) There exists only one nucleotide between the acceptor stem with 7 base pairs and the D stem with 4 base pairs. (2) The anticodon stem seems to consist of 6 base pairs. Since the same type of cloverleaf structure as above could be constructed only for mitochondrial tRNA(Ser) (UCN) genes of mammals such as human, rat and mouse, but not for those of non-mammals such as chicken and frog, this unusual secondary structure seems to be conserved only in mammalian mitochondria.

Biomolecular dynamics. A report from a workshop in Gysinge, Sweden, October 4-7, 1982

From the results of X-ray crystallography a wealth of information is now available concerning the detailed molecular structure of proteins, nucleic acids, and membrane components. This has made it possible to apply successfully various spectroscopie techniques for time resolved studies as well as theoretical simulations of internal molecular dynamics in the biological macromolecules and molecular aggregates. We were particularly pleased to see professor Ivar Waller among the participants of the workshop since new use of the wellknown Debye–Waller factor has greatly contributed to this development. A molecular picture is presently emerging including the dimension of time which ultimately will give us a detailed understanding of the functional interactions between biomolecules in general, and in particular enzyme catalysis, nucleic acid functions, and transport of matter and information through membranes.

Comparison of Escherichia coli tRNAPhe in the free state, in the ternary complex and in the ribosomal A and P sites by chemical probing

tRNAPheE.coli was modified at accessible guanosine, cytidine, and adenosine residues using the chemical modification method described by Peattie and Gilbert [Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 77, 4679-4689 (1980)]. Modification characteristics of the tRNA in the free state, in the ternary complex with elongation factor EF-Tu and GTP and in the ribosomal A and P sites were compared. A special procedure was devised to monitor, exclusively, tRNA molecules in the aminoacylated state. In the free tRNA, the most reactive bases are confined to the A73-C-C-A sequence of the aminoacyl stem, the anticodon loop, the D-loop and the extra loop and the results correlate well with the three-dimensional structure of tRNAPheyeast determined by X-ray studies. The pattern of reactivity was not affected either by charging the tRNA with phenylalanine or by labelling the 3' terminus with pCp. In the ternary complex, with elongation factor EF-Tu and GTP, changes in modification were observed at two sites, A73-C-C-A at the 3' terminus and C-13 and C-17 in the D-loop region, which are about 6 nm apart; no difference was observed in the anticodon loop. tRNAPhe bound at the ribosomal A or P sites exhibited similar, but not identical, modification patterns. Whereas nucleotides C-74 and C-75 were strongly protected at both sites, the adjacent A-73 showed an enhanced reactivity in the A site. The anticodon region G34-A-A-ms2.6(1)A was also strongly protected at both sites. In addition, nucleotide A-21 was protected during A-site, but not P-site, binding.

Purification and characterization of tRNA (adenine-1-)-methyltransferase from Thermus flavus strain 71

tRNA (adenine-1-)-methyltransferase was isolated from the extreme thermophile Thermus flavus, strain 71. It was purified about 2000-fold by ammonium sulfate fractionation and affinity chromatography on tRNA bound to aminohydroxybutylcellulose via its oxidized 3' end. The purified protein preparation is free of nuclease and aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase activity and contains no more than 4% of tRNA (guanine-7-)methyltransferase activity. The only activity of the enzyme is to methylate A58 in the T psi loop of tRNA. Out of the eight purified tRNAs examined, only yeast tRNATrp was not utilized as a substrate. The enzyme is highly thermostable. It is most active at 75 degrees C. tRNA (adenine-1-)-methyltransferase has a Km of 0.4-0.5 microM for tRNA2Gln from Escherichia coli and a Km of 6 microM for S-adenosyl-L-methionine.

Stabilization of the tertiary structure of yeast phenylalanine tRNA by [Co(NH3)6]3+. X-ray evidence for hydrogen bonding to pairs of guanine bases in the major groove

The sites of three [Co(NH3)6]3+ ions bound to the phenylalanine tRNA of yeast have been determined by X-ray diffraction analysis. [Co(NH3)6]3+ binds to purine-purine sequences in yeast tRNA Phe. It is different from the binding fo Co2+, which binds to the base and phosphate of residue G15. There are no direct metal-nucleotide bonds, although hydrogen bonding of the coordinated ammines to double-helical guanylguanosine sequences in the major groove and to phosphate oxygen in neighboring polynucleotide strands increases the stability of the structure. Hydrogen-bonding appears to be via cis ammine ligands to N(7) and O(6) positions of adjacent purine bases.

Chemical probing of the tRNA--ribosome complex

We probed the (Escherichia coli) tRNAPhe--ribosome interaction with the chemical reagents dimethyl sulfate and diethyl pyrocarbonate. This monitored the higher-order structure of the tRNA in this biological complex and identified critical sites in the tRNA molecule involved in binding to the ribosome. The methylation of the N-7 position of guanosine and the N-3 position of cytidine as well as diethyl pyrocarbonate attack on adenosines are sensitive to secondary and tertiary interactions. Here we identify specific bases in E. coli Phe-tRNAPhe affected by the interaction with the ribosome. The 70S ribosome protects the N-3 position of cytidine-74 and 75 in the 3'-terminal C-C-A, suggesting a strong, possibly base pairing, interaction between the ribosome and that universal sequence. The ribosome also induces strong reactivities at the N-7 positions of G-24 and G-46 in the central region of the tRNA molecule near the variable-loop domain as well as less significant reactivities at 11 other guanosines. Two of these, G-10 and G-44, are close to G-24 and G-46 in the center of the molecule; the others (guanosines 1, 5, 6, 18, 19, 63, 65, 69, and 71) are in the coaxial acceptor stem-T stem helix. All of the effects are ribosome induced and occur in the presence or absence of the messenger poly(U). Prior chemical modification of the anticodon bases as well as the two adjacent 3' purines and, less effectively, four purines in the anticodon stem prevent stable poly(U)-directed ribosome binding. Thus, we identify the 3' terminal C-C-A sequence, near the peptidyl transferase site, and the anticodon stem and loop of tRNAPhe as forming critical contacts with the ribosome. Other regions of the molecule become reactive on ribosome binding, but these do not suggest a significant conformational change being more likely due to a change of environment.