Advances in Electrocatalyzed Water Oxidation by Molecular Complexes of First Row Transition Metals

Energy transition toward sustainable, alternative, and affordable solutions is likely to be one of the major challenges of the anthropocene era. The oxygen evolution reaction (OER) is a pivotal electrocatalytic process essential for advancing renewable energy conversion and storage technologies, including water splitting, artificial photosynthesis, metal-air batteries, and fuel cells. Electrocatalytic pathways can significantly reduce the overall energy requirements of these devices, particularly focusing on the energy demands associated with water splitting for hydrogen production. This review, after introducing the state of the art in heterogeneous catalysis, will be devoted to the description of molecular water oxidation electrocatalysts (MWOCs), focusing on the recent advancements on catalysts composed of various metals, including Mn, Co, Cu, Ni, and Fe, in combination with a range of mono- and multidentate ligands. Critical insights are presented and discussed to provide readers with suggestions for ligand design in assisted catalysis. These observations aim to identify synergistic solutions that could enhance technological maturity by reducing energy absorption while improving stability and efficiency.

Uncovering Interfacial Oxygen-Bridged Binuclear Metal Centers of Heterogenized Molecular Catalyst for Water Electrolysis

The success of different heterogeneous strategies of organometallic catalysts has been demonstrated to achieve high selectivity and activity in photo/electrocatalysis. However, yielding their catalytic mechanisms at complex molecule-electrode and electrochemical interfaces remains a great challenge. Herein, shell-isolated nanoparticle-enhanced Raman spectroscopy is employed to elucidate the dynamic process, interfacial structure, and intermediates of copper hydroxide-2-2' bipyridine on Au electrode ((bpy)Cu(OH)2/Au) during the oxygen evolution reaction (OER). Direct Raman molecular evidences reveal that the interfacial (bpy)Cu(OH)2 oxidizes into Cu(III) and bridges to Au atoms via oxygenated species, forming (bpy)Cu(III)O2-Au with oxygen-bridged binuclear metal centers of Cu(III)-O-Au for the OER. As the potential further increases, Cu(III)-O-Au combines with surface hydroxyl groups (*OH) to form the important intermediate of Cu(III)-OOH-Au, which then turns into Cu(III)-OO-Au to release O2. Furthermore, in situ electrochemical impedance spectroscopy proves that the Cu(III)-O-Au has lower resistance and faster mass transport of hydroxy to enhance OER. Theoretical calculations reveal that the formation of Cu(III)-O-Au significantly modify the elementary reaction steps of the OER, resulting in a lower potential-determining step of ≈0.58 V than that of bare Au. This work provides new insights into the OER mechanism of immobilized-molecule catalysts for the development and application of renewable energy conversion devices.

An intramolecular cobalt-peptoid complex as an efficient electrocatalyst for water oxidation at low overpotential

Water electrolysis is the simplest way to produce hydrogen, as a clean renewable fuel. However, the high overpotential and slow kinetics hamper its applicability. Designing efficient and stable electrocatalysts for water oxidation (WO), which is the first and limiting step of the water splitting process, can overcome this limitation. However, the development of such catalysts based on non-precious metal ions is still challenging. Herein we describe a bio-inspired Co(iii)-based complex i.e., a stable and efficient molecular electrocatalyst for WO, constructed from a peptidomimetic oligomer called peptoid - N-substituted glycine oligomer - bearing two binding ligands, terpyridine and bipyridine, and one ethanolic group as a proton shuttler. Upon binding of a cobalt ion, this peptoid forms an intramolecular Co(iii) complex, that acts as an efficient electrocatalyst for homogeneous WO in aqueous phosphate buffer at pH 7 with a high faradaic efficiency of up to 92% at an overpotential of about 430 mV, which is the lowest reported for Co-based homogeneous WO electrocatalysts to date. We demonstrated the high stability of the complex during electrocatalytic WO and that the ethanolic side chain plays a key role in the stability and activity of the complex and also in facilitating water binding, thus mimicking an enzymatic second coordination sphere.

Isomerization pathway of a C-C sigma bond in a bis(octaazamacrocycle)dinickel(II) complex activated by deprotonation: a DFT study

The anti (a) to syn (s) isomerization pathway of the deprotonated form of the dimer with two nickel(II) 15-membered octaazamacrocyclic units connected via a carbon-carbon (C-C) σ bond was investigated. For the initial anti (a) structure, a deprotonation of one of the bridging (sp3 hybridized) carbon atoms is suggested to allow for an a to s geometry twist. A 360° scan around the bridging C-C dihedral angle was performed first to find an intermediate geometry. Subsequently, the isomerization pathway was explored via individual steps using a series of mode redundant geometry optimizations (internal coordinates potential energy surface scans) and geometry relaxations leading to the s structure. The prominent geometries (intermediates) of the isomerization pathway are chosen and compared to the a and s structures, and geometry relaxations of the protonated forms of selected intermediates are considered.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s00214-024-03100-5.

Electrocatalytic Water Oxidation by Mononuclear Copper Complexes of Bis-amide Ligands with N4 Donor: Experimental and Theoretical Investigation

The present work describes electrocatalytic water oxidation of three monomeric copper complexes [CuII(L1)] (1), [CuII(L2)(H2O)] (2), and [CuII(L3)] (3) with bis-amide tetradentate ligands: L1 = N,N'-(1,2-phenylene)dipicolinamide, L2 = N,N'-(4,5-dimethyl-1,2-phenylene)bis(pyrazine-2-carboxamide), L3 = N,N'-(1,2-phenylene)bis(pyrazine-2-carboxamide), for the production of molecular oxygen by the oxidation of water at pH 13.0. Ligands and all complexes have been synthesized and characterized by single crystal XRD, analytical, and spectroscopic techniques. X-ray crystallographic data show that the ligand coordinates to copper in a dianionic fashion through deprotonation of two -NH protons. Cyclic voltammetry study shows a reversible copper-centered redox couple with one ligand-based oxidation event. The electrocatalytic water oxidation occurs at an onset potential of 1.16 (overpotential, η ≈ 697 mV), 1.2 (η ≈ 737 mV), and 1.23 V (η ≈ 767 mV) for 1, 2, and 3 respectively. A systematic variation of the ligand scaffold has been found to display a profound effect on the rate of electrocatalytic oxygen evolution. The results of the theoretical (density functional theory) studies show the stepwise ligand-centered oxidation process and the formation of the O-O bond during water oxidation passes through the water nucleophilic attack for all the copper complexes. At pH = 13, the turnover frequencies have been experimentally obtained as 88, 1462, and 10 s-1 (peak current measurements) for complexes 1, 2, and 3, respectively. Production of oxygen gas during controlled potential electrolysis was detected by gas chromatography.

Electrochemical Water Oxidation and CO2 Reduction with a Nickel Molecular Catalyst

Mimicking the photosynthesis of green plants to combine water oxidation with CO2 reduction is of great significance for solving energy and environmental crises. In this context, a trinuclear nickel complex, [NiII3(paoH)6(PhPO3)2]·2ClO4 (1), with a novel structure has been constructed with PhPO32- (phenylphosphonate) and paoH (2-pyridine formaldehyde oxime) ligands and possesses a reflection symmetry with a mirror plane revealed by single-crystal X-ray diffraction. Bulk electrocatalysis demonstrates that complex 1 can homogeneously catalyze water oxidation and CO2 reduction simultaneously. It can catalyze water oxidation at a near-neutral condition of pH = 7.45 with a high TOF of 12.2 s-1, and the Faraday efficiency is as high as 95%. Meanwhile, it also exhibits high electrocatalytic activity for CO2 reduction towards CO with a TOF of 7.84 s-1 in DMF solution. The excellent electrocatalytic performance of the water oxidation and CO2 reduction of complex 1 could be attributed to the two unique µ3-PhPO32- bridges as the crucial factor for stabilizing the trinuclear molecule as well as the proton transformation during the catalytic process, while the oxime groups modulate the electronic structure of the metal centers via π back-bonding. Therefore, apart from the cooperation effect of the three Ni centers for catalysis, simultaneously, the two kinds of ligands in complex 1 can also synergistically coordinate the central metal, thereby significantly promoting its catalytic performance. Complex 1 represents the first nickel molecular electrocatalyst for both water oxidation and CO2 reduction. The findings in this work open an avenue for designing efficient molecular electrocatalysts with peculiar ligands.

Water electrolysis: from textbook knowledge to the latest scientific strategies and industrial developments

Replacing fossil fuels with energy sources and carriers that are sustainable, environmentally benign, and affordable is amongst the most pressing challenges for future socio-economic development. To that goal, hydrogen is presumed to be the most promising energy carrier. Electrocatalytic water splitting, if driven by green electricity, would provide hydrogen with minimal CO2 footprint. The viability of water electrolysis still hinges on the availability of durable earth-abundant electrocatalyst materials and the overall process efficiency. This review spans from the fundamentals of electrocatalytically initiated water splitting to the very latest scientific findings from university and institutional research, also covering specifications and special features of the current industrial processes and those processes currently being tested in large-scale applications. Recently developed strategies are described for the optimisation and discovery of active and durable materials for electrodes that ever-increasingly harness first-principles calculations and machine learning. In addition, a technoeconomic analysis of water electrolysis is included that allows an assessment of the extent to which a large-scale implementation of water splitting can help to combat climate change. This review article is intended to cross-pollinate and strengthen efforts from fundamental understanding to technical implementation and to improve the 'junctions' between the field's physical chemists, materials scientists and engineers, as well as stimulate much-needed exchange among these groups on challenges encountered in the different domains.

Homogeneous Water Oxidation Catalyzed by First-Row Transition Metal Complexes: Unveiling the Relationship between Turnover Frequency and Reaction Overpotential

The utilization of earth-abundant low-toxicity metal ions in the construction of highly active and efficient molecular catalysts promoting the water oxidation reaction is important for developing a sustainable artificial energy cycle. However, the kinetic and thermodynamic properties of the currently available molecular water oxidation catalysts (MWOCs) have not been comprehensively investigated. This Review summarizes the current status of MWOCs based on first-row transition metals in terms of their turnover frequency (TOF, a kinetic property) and overpotential (η, a thermodynamic property) and uses the relationship between log(TOF) and η to assess catalytic performance. Furthermore, the effects of the same ligand classes on these MWOCs are discussed in terms of TOF and η, and vice versa. The collective analysis of these relationships provides a metric for the direct comparison of catalyst systems and identifying factors crucial for catalyst design.

Finding the True Catalyst for Water Oxidation at Low Overpotential in the Presence of a Metal Complex

The design of molecular-based catalysts for oxygen-evolution reaction (OER) requires more investigations for the true catalyst to be found. First-row transition metal complexes are extensively investigated for OER, but the role of these metal complexes as a true catalyst is doubtful. Some doubts have been expressed about the role of first-row transition metal complexes for OER at high overpotentials (η > 450). Generally, the detection of the true catalyst has so far been focused on high overpotentials (η > 450) because at low overpotentials (η < 450), many methods are not sensitive enough to detect small amounts of heterogeneous catalysts on the electrode surface during the first seconds of the reaction. Ni(II) phthalocyanine-tetra sulfonate tetrasodium (1) is in moderate conditions (at 20-50 °C and pH 5-13) in the absence of electrochemical driving forces, which could make it noteworthy for OER. Herein, the results of OER in the presence of 1 at low overpotentials under alkaline conditions are presented. In addition, in the presence of Ni complexes, using an Fe ion is introduced as a new method for detecting Ni (hydr)oxide under OER. Our experiments indicate that in the presence of a homogeneous OER (pre)catalyst, a deep investigation is necessary to rule out the heterogeneous catalysts formed. Our approach is a roadmap in the field of catalysis to understand the OER mechanism in the presence of a molecular Ni-based catalyst design. Our results shown in this study are likely to open up new perspectives and discussion on many molecular catalysts in a considerable part of the chemistry community.

Efficient Alkaline Water Oxidation with a Regenerable Nickel Pseudo-Complex

Efficient and robust electrocatalysts are required for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER). Photosystem II-inspired synthetic transition metal complexes have shown promising OER activity in water-poor or mild conditions, yet challenges remain in the improvement of current density and performance stability for practical applications in alkaline electrolytes in contrast to solid-state oxide catalysts. Here, we report that a nickel pseudo-complex (bpy)_zNiO_xH_y (bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine) catalyst, which bridges solid oxide and molecular catalysts, exhibits the highest OER activity among nickel-based catalysts with a turnover frequency of 1.1 s^-1 at an overpotential of 0.30 volts, even outperforming iron-incorporated nickel (oxy)hydroxide under an identical nickel mass load. Benefiting from the strong coordination between bpy and nickel, this (bpy)_zNiO_xH_y catalyst exhibits long-term stability in highly alkaline media at 1.0 mA cm^-2 for over 200 h and at 20 mA cm^-2 for over 60 h. Our findings indicate that dynamically coordinating a small amount of bpy in the catalyst layer efficiently sustains highly active nickel sites for water oxidation, demonstrating a general strategy for improving the activity of transition metal sites with active ligands beyond the incorporation of metal cations to form double-layered hydroxides.

Efficient Electrochemical Water Oxidation Mediated by Pyridylpyrrole-Carboxylate Ruthenium Complexes

Spurred by the rapid growth of Ru-based complexes as molecular water oxidation catalysts (WOCs), we propose novel ruthenium(II) complexes bearing pyridylpyrrole-carboxylate (H₂ppc) ligands as members of the WOC family. The structure of these complexes has 4-picoline (pic)/dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) in [Ru(ppc)(pic)₂(dmso)] and pic/pic in [Ru(ppc)(pic)₃] as axial ligands. Another ppc^2- ligand and one pic ligand are located at the equatorial positions. [Ru(ppc)(pic)₂(dmso)] behaves as a WOC as determined by electrochemical measurement and has an ultrahigh electrocatalytic current density of 8.17 mA cm^-2 at 1.55 V (vs NHE) with a low onset potential of 0.352 V (vs NHE), a turnover number of 241, a turnover frequency of 203.39 s^-1, and k_cat of 16.34 s^-1 under neutral conditions. The H₂O/pic exchange of the complexes accompanied by oxidation of a ruthenium center is the initial step in the catalytic cycle. The cyclic voltametric measurements of [Ru(ppc)(pic)₂(dmso)] at various scan rates, Pourbaix diagrams (plots of E vs pH), and kinetic studies suggested a water nucleophilic attack mechanism. HPO₄^2- in a phosphate buffer solution is invoked in water oxidation as the proton acceptor.

Identifying Intermediates in Electrocatalytic Water Oxidation with a Manganese Corrole Complex

Water nucleophilic attack (WNA) on high-valent terminal Mn-oxo species is proposed for O-O bond formation in natural and artificial water oxidation. Herein, we report an electrocatalytic water oxidation reaction with Mn^III tris(pentafluorophenyl)corrole (1) in propylene carbonate (PC). O₂ was generated at the Mn^V/IV potential with hydroxide, but a more anodic potential was required to evolve O₂ with only water. With a synthetic Mn^V(O) complex of 1, a second-order rate constant, k₂(OH^-), of 7.4 × 10³ M^-1 s^-1 was determined in the reaction of the Mn^V(O) complex of 1 with hydroxide, whereas its reaction with water occurred much more slowly with a k₂(H₂O) value of 4.4 × 10^-3 M^-1 s^-1. This large reactivity difference of Mn^V(O) with hydroxide and water is consistent with different electrocatalytic behaviors of 1 with these two substrates. Significantly, during the electrolysis of 1 with water, a Mn^IV-peroxo species was identified with various spectroscopic methods, including UV-vis, electron paramagnetic resonance, and infrared spectroscopy. Isotope-labeling experiments confirmed that both O atoms of this peroxo species are derived from water, suggesting the involvement of the WNA mechanism in water oxidation by a Mn complex. Density functional theory calculations suggested that the nucleophilic attack of hydroxide on Mn^V(O) and also WNA to 1e^--oxidized Mn^V(O) are feasibly involved in the catalytic cycles but that direct WNA to Mn^V(O) is not likely to be the main O-O bond formation pathway in the electrocatalytic water oxidation by 1.

A Ru diphosphonato complex with a metal-metal bond for water oxidation

Unlike [Ru2(μ-O2CCH3)4], the structurally analogous water-soluble RuII,III2 diphosphonato complex K3[Ru2(hedp)2(H2O)2] (K3·1) is only involved in stoichiometric water oxidation with a maximum 67% O2 yield under CAN/HNO3 solution (pH 1.0) for 2.5 h. The water oxidation mechanism and intermediate products were ascertained by UV-vis, ESI-MS and DFT calculation.

Homogeneous Catalysts Based on First-Row Transition-Metals for Electrochemical Water Oxidation

Strategies that enable the renewable production of storable fuels (i. e. hydrogen or hydrocarbons) through electrocatalysis continue to generate interest in the scientific community. Of central importance to this pursuit is obtaining the requisite chemical (H+ ) and electronic (e- ) inputs for fuel-forming reduction reactions, which can be met sustainably by water oxidation catalysis. Further possibility exists to couple these redox transformations to renewable energy sources (i. e. solar), thus creating a carbon neutral solution for long-term energy storage. Nature uses a Mn-Ca cluster for water oxidation catalysis via multiple proton-coupled electron-transfers (PCETs) with a photogenerated bias to perform this process with TOF 100∼300 s-1 . Synthetic molecular catalysts that efficiently perform this conversion commonly utilize rare metals (e. g., Ru, Ir), whose low abundance are associated to higher costs and scalability limitations. Inspired by nature's use of 1st row transition metal (TM) complexes for water oxidation catalysts (WOCs), attempts to use these abundant metals have been intensively explored but met with limited success. The smaller atomic size of 1st row TM ions lowers its ability to accommodate the oxidative equivalents required in the 4e- /4H+ water oxidation catalysis process, unlike noble metal catalysts that perform single-site electrocatalysis at lower overpotentials (η). Overcoming the limitations of 1st row TMs requires developing molecular catalysts that exploit biomimetic phenomena - multiple-metal redox-cooperativity, PCET and second-sphere interactions - to lower the overpotential, preorganize substrates and maintain stability. Thus, the ultimate goal of developing efficient, robust and scalable WOCs remains a challenge. This Review provides a summary of previous research works highlighting 1st row TM-based homogeneous WOCs, catalytic mechanisms, followed by strategies for catalytic activity improvements, before closing with a future outlook for this field.

Metal-free graphene-based nanoelectrodes for the electrochemical determination of ascorbic acid (AA) and p-nitrophenol (p-NP): implication towards biosensing and environmental monitoring

Herein, tyramine functionalized graphene oxide electrocatalyst is used for the electrochemical determination of ascorbic acid and p-nitrophenol in 1 M phosphate buffer solution at pH-7  with long term current/potential stability and reproducibility.

Nickel is a Different Pickle: Trends in Water Oxidation Catalysis for Molecular Nickel Complexes

The development of novel water oxidation catalysts is important in the context of renewable fuels production. Ligand design is one of the key tools to improve the activity and stability of molecular catalysts. The establishment of ligand design rules can facilitate the development of improved molecular catalysts. In this paper it is shown that chemical oxidants can be used to probe oxygen evolution activity for nickel-based systems, and trends are reported that can improve future ligand design. Interestingly, different ligand effects were observed in comparison to other first-row transition metal complexes. For example, nickel complexes with secondary amine donors were more active than with tertiary amine donors, which is the opposite for iron complexes. The incorporation of imine donor groups in a cyclam ligand resulted in the fastest and most durable nickel catalyst of our series, achieving oxygen evolution turnover numbers up to 380 and turnover frequencies up to 68 min-1 in a pH 5.0 acetate buffer using Oxone as oxidant. Initial kinetic experiments with this catalyst revealed a first order in chemical oxidant and a half order in catalyst. This implies a rate-determining oxidation step from a dimeric species that needs to break up to generate the active catalyst. These findings lay the foundation for the rational design of molecular nickel catalysts for water oxidation and highlight that catalyst design rules are not generally applicable for different metals.

Potential- and Buffer-Dependent Catalyst Decomposition during Nickel-Based Water Oxidation Catalysis

The production of hydrogen by water electrolysis benefits from the development of water oxidation catalysts. This development process can be aided by the postulation of design rules for catalytic systems. The analysis of the reactivity of molecular complexes can be complicated by their decomposition under catalytic conditions into nanoparticles that may also be active. Such a misinterpretation can lead to incorrect design rules. In this study, the nickel-based water oxidation catalyst [NiII (meso-L)](ClO4 )2 , which was previously thought to operate as a molecular catalyst, is found to decompose to form a NiOx layer in a pH 7.0 phosphate buffer under prolonged catalytic conditions, as indicated by controlled potential electrolysis, electrochemical quartz crystal microbalance, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy measurements. Interestingly, the formed NiOx layer desorbs from the surface of the electrode under less anodic potentials. Therefore, no nickel species can be detected on the electrode after electrolysis. Catalyst decomposition is strongly dependent on the pH and buffer, as there is no indication of NiOx layer formation at pH 6.5 in phosphate buffer nor in a pH 7.0 acetate buffer. Under these conditions, the activity stems from a molecular species, but currents are much lower. This study demonstrates the importance of in situ characterization methods for catalyst decomposition and metal oxide layer formation, and previously proposed design elements for nickel-based catalysts need to be revised.

Molecular quaterpyridine-based metal complexes for small molecule activation: water splitting and CO2 reduction

This tutorial describes recent developments in the use of metal quaterpyridine complexes as electrocatalysts and photocatalysts for water splitting and CO₂ reduction.

Efficient visible light-driven water oxidation catalysed by an iron(iv) clathrochelate complex

A water-stable FeIV clathrochelate complex catalyses fast and homogeneous photochemical oxidation of water to dioxygen with a turnover frequency of 2.27 s-1 and a maximum turnover number of 365. An FeV intermediate generated under catalytic conditions is trapped and characterised using EPR and Mössbauer spectroscopy.

Enhanced oxygen evolution reaction on amine functionalized graphene oxide in alkaline medium

Development of highly efficient oxygen evolution reaction (OER) electrocatalysts is a critical challenge in the cost-effective generation of clean fuels. Here, a metal-free tyramine functionalized graphene oxide (T-GO) electrocatalyst is proposed to use in alkaline electrolytes for enhanced OER. Moreover, the T-GO and GO nanomaterials are well characterized by SEM, XRD, FTIR, XPS and Raman spectroscopy. T-GO exhibits an electrocatalytic OER with a current density of 2 mA cm^-2 at a low onset potential of ∼1.39 V and a small Tafel slope of about 69 mV dec^-1 and GO exhibits an onset potential of 1.51 V and Tafel slope of about 92 mV dec^-1. Additionally, the current stability and RRDE based diffusion controlled response of the T-GO electrocatalyst are outstanding compared to GO. This study establishes metal free T-GO as an efficient electrocatalyst for the OER and used for cathodic production of hydrogen as a counter reaction in the field of water splitting.

Kinetics and mechanisms of catalytic water oxidation

The kinetics and mechanisms of thermal and photochemical oxidation of water with homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysts, including conversion from homogeneous to heterogeneous catalysts in the course of water oxidation, are discussed in this review article. Molecular and homogeneous catalysts have the advantage to clarify the catalytic mechanisms by detecting active intermediates in catalytic water oxidation. On the other hand, heterogeneous nanoparticle catalysts have advantages for practical applications due to high catalytic activity, robustness and easier separation of catalysts by filtration as compared with molecular homogeneous precursors. Ligand oxidation of homogeneous catalysts sometimes results in the dissociation of ligands to form nanoparticles, which act as much more efficient catalysts for water oxidation. Since it is quite difficult to identify active intermediates on the heterogeneous catalyst surface, the mechanism of water oxidation has hardly been clarified under heterogeneous catalytic conditions. This review focuses on the kinetics and mechanisms of catalytic water oxidation with homogeneous catalysts, which may be converted to heterogeneous nanoparticle catalysts depending on various reaction conditions.

Homogenous electrochemical water oxidation by a nickel(ii) complex based on a macrocyclic N-heterocyclic carbene/pyridine hybrid ligand

Electrochemical water oxidation catalyzed by a homogeneous Ni–NHC/pyridine complex demonstrated electrolyte-dependent catalytic performances. The catalyst displayed a stable catalytic current of oxygen evolution in long-term bulk electrolysis.

Base-enhanced electrochemical water oxidation by a nickel complex in neutral aqueous solution

Electrochemical water oxidation catalyzed by a homogeneous Ni complex at low overpotential in neutral media.