Multiscale Investigation of the Mechanism and Selectivity of CO2 Hydrogenation over Rh(111)

CO2 hydrogenation over Rh catalysts comprises multiple reaction pathways, presenting a wide range of possible intermediates and end products, with selectivity toward either CO or methane being of particular interest. We investigate in detail the reaction mechanism of CO2 hydrogenation to the single-carbon (C1) products on the Rh(111) facet by performing periodic density functional theory (DFT) calculations and kinetic Monte Carlo (kMC) simulations, which account for the adsorbate interactions through a cluster expansion approach. We observe that Rh readily facilitates the dissociation of hydrogen, thus contributing to the subsequent hydrogenation processes. The reverse water-gas shift (RWGS) reaction occurs via three different reaction pathways, with CO hydrogenation to the COH intermediate being a key step for CO2 methanation. The effects of temperature, pressure, and the composition ratio of the gas reactant feed are considered. Temperature plays a pivotal role in determining the surface coverage and adsorbate composition, with competitive adsorption between CO and H species influencing the product distribution. The observed adlayer configurations indicate that the adsorbed CO species are separated by adsorbed H atoms, with a high ratio of H to CO coverage on the Rh(111) surface being essential to promote CO2 methanation.

Carbon dioxide hydrogenation over the carbon-terminated niobium carbide (111) surface: a density functional theory study

Carbon dioxide (CO₂) hydrogenation is an energetic process which could be made more efficient through the use of effective catalysts, for example transition metal carbides. Here, we have employed calculations based on the density functional theory (DFT) to evaluate the reaction processes of CO₂ hydrogenation to methane (CH₄), carbon monoxide (CO), methanol (CH₃OH), formaldehyde (CH₂O), and formic acid (HCOOH) over the carbon-terminated niobium carbide (111) surface. First, we have studied the adsorption geometries and energies of 25 different surface-adsorbed species, followed by calculations of all of the elementary steps in the CO₂ hydrogenation process. The theoretical findings indicate that the NbC (111) surface has higher catalytic activity towards CO₂ methanation, releasing 4.902 eV in energy. CO represents the second-most preferred product, followed by CH₃OH, CH₂O, and HCOOH, all of which have exothermic reaction energies of 4.107, 2.435, 1.090, and 0.163 eV, respectively. Except for the mechanism that goes through HCOOH to produce CH₂O, all favourable hydrogenation reactions lead to desired compounds through the creation of the dihydroxycarbene (HOCOH) intermediate. Along these routes, CH₃* hydrogenation to CH₄* has the highest endothermic reaction energy of 3.105 eV, while CO production from HCO dehydrogenation causes the highest exothermic reaction energy of -3.049 eV. The surface-adsorbed CO₂ hydrogenation intermediates have minimal effect on the electronic structure and interact only weakly with the surface. Our results are consistent with experimental observations.

Enhanced stability of sub-nanometric iridium decorated graphitic carbon nitride for H2 production upon hydrous hydrazine decomposition

Stabilizing metal nanoparticles is vital for large scale implementations of supported metal catalysts, particularly for a sustainable transition to clean energy, e.g., H₂ production. In this work, iridium sub-nanometric particles were deposited on commercial graphite and on graphitic carbon nitride by a wet impregnation method to investigate the metal-support interaction during the hydrous hydrazine decomposition reaction. To establish a structure-activity relationship, samples were characterized by transmission electron microscopy and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. The catalytic performance of the synthesized materials was evaluated under mild reaction conditions, i.e. 323 K and ambient pressure. The results showed that graphitic carbon nitride (GCN) enhances the stability of Ir nanoparticles compared to graphite, while maintaining remarkable activity and selectivity. Simulation techniques including Genetic Algorithm geometry screening and electronic structure analyses were employed to provide a valuable atomic level understanding of the metal-support interactions. N anchoring sites of GCN were found to minimise the thermodynamic driving force of coalescence, thus improving the catalyst stability, as well as to lead charge redistributions in the cluster improving the resistance to poisoning by decomposition intermediates.

Recent Advances in Carbon Dioxide Adsorption, Activation and Hydrogenation to Methanol using Transition Metal Carbides

The inevitable emission of carbon dioxide (CO₂ ) due to the burning of a substantial amount of fossil fuels has led to serious energy and environmental challenges. Metal-based catalytic CO₂ transformations into commodity chemicals are a favorable approach in the CO₂ mitigation strategy. Among these transformations, selective hydrogenation of CO₂ to methanol is the most promising process that not only fulfils the energy demands but also re-balances the carbon cycle. The investigation of CO₂ adsorption on the surface of heterogeneous catalyst is highly important because the formation of various intermediates which determines the selectivity of product. Transition metal carbides (TMCs) have received considerable attention in recent years because of their noble metal-like reactivity, ceramic-like properties, high chemical and thermal stability. These features make them excellent catalytic materials for a variety of transformations such as CO₂ adsorption and its conversion into value-added chemicals. Herein, the catalytic properties of TMCs are summarize along with synthetic methods, CO₂ binding modes, mechanistic studies, effects of dopant on CO₂ adsorption, and carbon/metal ratio in the CO₂ hydrogenation reaction to methanol using computational as well as experimental studies. Additionally, this Review provides an outline of the challenges and opportunities for the development of potential TMCs in CO₂ hydrogenation reactions.

Catalytic formation of oxalic acid on the partially oxidised greigite Fe3S4(001) surface

Greigite (Fe₃S₄), with its ferredoxin-like 4Fe-4S redox centres, is a naturally occurring mineral capable of acting as a catalyst in the conversion of carbon dioxide (CO₂) into low molecular-weight organic acids (LMWOAs), which are of paramount significance in several soil and plant processes as well as in the chemical industry. In this paper, we report the reaction between CO₂ and water (H₂O) to form oxalic acid (H₂C₂O₄) on the partially oxidised greigite Fe₃S₄(001) surface by means of spin-polarised density functional theory calculations with on-site Coulomb corrections and long-range dispersion interactions (DFT+U-D2). We have calculated the bulk phase of Fe₃S₄ and the two reconstructed Tasker type 3 terminations of its (001) surface, whose properties are in good agreement with available experimental data. We have obtained the relevant phase diagram, showing that the Fe₃S₄(001) surface becomes 62.5% partially oxidised, by replacing S by O atoms, in the presence of water at the typical conditions of calcination [Mitchell et al. Faraday Discuss. 2021, 230, 30-51]. The adsorption and co-adsorption of the reactants on the partially oxidised Fe₃S₄(001) surface are exothermic processes. We have considered three mechanistic pathways to explain the formation of H₂C₂O₄, showing that the coupling of the C-C bond and second protonation are the elementary steps with the largest energy penalty. Our calculations suggest that the partially oxidised Fe₃S₄(001) surface is a mineral phase that can catalyse the formation of H₂C₂O₄ under favourable conditions, which has important implications for natural ecosystems and is a process that can be harnessed for the industrial manufacture of this organic acid.

Effect of nanostructuring on the interaction of CO2 with molybdenum carbide nanoparticles

Transition metal carbides are increasingly used as catalysts for the transformation of CO₂ into useful chemicals. Recently, the effect of nanostructuring of such carbides has started to gain relevance in tailoring their catalytic capabilities. Catalytic materials based on molybdenum carbide nanoparticles (MoC_y) have shown a remarkable ability to bind CO₂ at room temperature and to hydrogenate it into oxygenates or light alkanes. However, the involved chemistry is largely unknown. In the present work, a systematic computational study is presented aiming to elucidate the chemistry behind the bonding of CO₂ with a representative set of MoC_y nanoparticles of increasing size, including stoichiometric and non-stoichiometric cases. The obtained results provide clear trends to tune the catalytic activity of these systems and to move towards more efficient CO₂ transformation processes.

Catalytic Reduction of Carbon Dioxide on the (001), (011), and (111) Surfaces of TiC and ZrC: A Computational Study

We present a computational study of the activity and selectivity of early transition-metal carbides as carbon dioxide reduction catalysts. We analyze the effects of the adsorption of CO₂ and H₂ on the (001), (011), and metal-terminated (111) surfaces of TiC and ZrC, as carbon dioxide undergoes either dissociation to CO or hydrogenation to COOH or HCOO. The relative stabilities of the three reduction intermediates and the activation energies for their formation allow the identification of favored pathways on each surface, which are examined as they lead to the release of CO, HCOOH, CH₃OH, and CH₄, thereby also characterizing the activity and selectivity of the two materials. Reaction energetics implicate HCO as the key common intermediate on all surfaces studied and rule out the release of formaldehyde. Surface hydroxylation is shown to be highly selective toward methane production as the formation of methanol is hindered on all surfaces by its barrierless conversion to CO.

Selective decomposition of hydrazine over metal free carbonaceous materials

Herein we report a combined experimental and computational investigation unravelling the hydrazine hydrate decomposition reaction on metal-free catalysts. The study focuses on commercial graphite and two different carbon nanofibers, pyrolytically stripped (CNF-PS) and high heat-treated (CNF-HHT), respectively, treated at 700 and 3000 °C to increase their intrinsic defects. Raman spectroscopy demonstrated a correlation between the initial catalytic activity and the intrinsic defectiveness of carbonaceous materials. CNF-PS with higher defectivity (I_D/I_G = 1.54) was found to be the best performing metal-free catalyst, showing a hydrazine conversion of 94% after 6 hours of reaction and a selectivity to H₂ of 89%. In addition, to unveil the role of NaOH, CNF-PS was also tested in the absence of alkaline solution, showing a decrease in the reaction rate and selectivity to H₂. Density functional theory (DFT) demonstrated that the single vacancies (SV) present on the graphitic layer are the only active sites promoting hydrazine decomposition, whereas other defects such as double vacancy (DV) and Stone-Wales (SW) defects are unable to adsorb hydrazine fragments. Two symmetrical and one asymmetrical dehydrogenation pathways were found, in addition to an incomplete decomposition pathway forming N₂ and NH₃. On the most stable hydrogen production pathway, the effect of the alkaline medium was elucidated through calculations concerning the diffusion and recombination of atomic hydrogen. Indeed, the presence of NaOH helps the extraction of H species without additional energetic barriers, as opposed to the calculations performed in a polarizable continuum medium. Considering the initial hydrazine dissociative adsorption, the first step of the dehydrogenation pathway is more favourable than the scission of the N-N bond, which leads to NH₃ as the product. This first reaction step is crucial to define the reaction mechanisms and the computational results are in agreement with the experimental ones. Moreover, comparing two different hydrogen production pathways (with and without diffusion and recombination), we confirmed that the presence of sodium hydroxide in the experimental reaction environment can modify the energy gap between the two pathways, leading to an increased reaction rate and selectivity to H₂.

A first-principles study of CO2 hydrogenation on Niobium-terminated NbC (111) surface

As a promising material for the reduction of Greenhouse gas, Transition metal carbides which are highly active in the hydrogenation of CO2 are mainly considered. In this regard, the reaction mechanism of CO2 hydrogenation to useful products on the Nb-terminated NbC (111) surface is investigated by applying density functional theory calculations. The computational results display that formation of CH4 , CH3OH and CO are more favored than other compounds, where CH4 is the dominant product. In addition, the findings from reaction energies reveal that the preferred mechanism for CO2 hydrogenation is thorough HCOOH * where the largest exothermic reaction energy releases during HCOOH * dissociation reaction (2.004eV). The preferred mechanism of CO2 hydrogenation towards CH 4 production is CO2 *→ t,c-COOH *→ HCOOH *→ HCO *→ CH2O *→ CH2OH *→ CH2 *→ CH3 *→ CH4 * where CO2 * → t,c-COOH * → HCOOH * → HCO * → CH2O * → CH2OH * → CH3OH * and CO2 * → t,c-COOH * → CO * are also found as the favored mechanisms for CH3 OH and CO productions thermodynamically, respectively. During the mentioned mechanisms the hydrogenation of CH2O * to CH2OH * has the largest endothermic reaction energy of 1.344 eV. It is also found from the electronic properties calculations that Nb-terminated NbC (111) is a suitable catalyst for CO2 hydrogenation where adsorption and activation of CO2 and also desorption of final products can be easily done on the surface.

Theoretical Insights into Synergistic Effects at Cu/TiC Interfaces for Promoting CO2 Activation

The adsorption behaviors of CO2 at the Cu n /TiC(001) interfaces (n = 1-8) have been investigated using the density functional theory method. Our results reveal that the introduction of copper clusters on a TiC surface can significantly improve the thermodynamic stability of CO2 chemisorption. However, the most stable adsorption site is sensitive to the size and morphology of Cu n particles. The interfacial configuration is the most stable structure for copper clusters with small (n ≤ 2) and large (n ≥ 8) sizes, in which both Cu particles and TiC support are involved in CO2 activation. In such a case, the synergistic behavior is associated with the ligand effect introduced by directly forming adsorption bonds with CO2. For those Cu n clusters with a medium size (n = 3-7), the configuration where CO2 adsorbs solely on the exposed hollow site constructed by Cu atoms at the interface shows the best stability, and the charger transfer becomes the primary origin of the synergistic effect in promoting CO2 activation. Since the most obvious deformation of CO2 is observed for the TiC(001)-surface-supported Cu4 and Cu7 particles, copper clusters with specific sizes of n = 4 and 7 exhibit the best ability for CO2 activation. Furthermore, the kinetic barriers for CO2 dissociation on Cu4- and Cu7-supported TiC surfaces are determined. The findings obtained in this work provide useful insights into optimizing the Cu/TiC interface with high catalytic activation of CO2 by precisely controlling the size and dispersion of copper particles.

High-Throughput Screening of Atomic Defects in MXenes for CO2 Capture, Activation, and Dissociation

The capture, activation, and dissociation of carbon dioxide (CO₂) is of fundamental interest to overcome the ramifications of the greenhouse effect. In this regard, high-throughput screening of two-dimensional MXenes has been examined using well-resolved first-principles simulations through DFT-D3 dispersion correction. We systematically investigated different types of structural defects to understand their influence on the performance of M₂X-type MXenes. Defect calculations demonstrate that the formation of M₂C(V_MC) and M₂N(V_MN) vacancies require higher energy, while M₂C(V_C) and M₂N(V_N) vacancies are favorable to form during the synthesis of M₂X-type MXenes. The M₂X-type MXenes from group III to VII series show remarkable behavior for active capturing of CO₂, especially group IV (Ti₂X and Zr₂X) MXenes exhibit unprecedentedly high adsorption energies and charge transfer (>2e) from M₂X to CO₂. The potential CO₂ capture, activation, and dissociation abilities of MXenes are emanated from Dewar interactions involving hybridization between π orbitals of CO₂ and metal d-orbitals. Our high-throughput screening demonstrates chemisorption of CO₂ on pure and defective MXenes, followed by dissociation into CO and O species.

How bulk and surface properties of Ti4SiC3, V4SiC3, Nb4SiC3 and Zr4SiC3 tune reactivity: a computational study

We present several in silico insights into the MAX-phase of early transition metal silicon carbides and explore how these affect carbon dioxide hydrogenation. Periodic density functional methodology is applied to models of Ti4SiC3, V4SiC3, Nb4SiC3 and Zr4SiC3. We find that silicon and carbon terminations are unstable, with sintering occurring in vacuum and significant reconstruction taking place under an oxidising environment. In contrast, the metal terminated surfaces are highly stable and very active towards CO2 reduction. However, we predict that under reaction conditions these surfaces are likely to be oxidised. These results are compared to studies on comparable materials and we predict optimal values for hydrogen evolution and CO2 reduction.

Role of defects in carbon materials during metal-free formic acid dehydrogenation

Commercial graphite (GP), graphite oxide (GO), and two carbon nanofibers (CNF-PR24-PS and CNF-PR24-LHT) were used as catalysts for the metal-free dehydrogenation reaction of formic acid (FA) in the liquid phase. Raman and XPS spectroscopy demonstrated that the activity is directly correlated with the defectiveness of the carbon material (GO > CNF-PR24-PS > CNF-PR24-LHT > GP). Strong deactivation phenomena were observed for all the catalysts after 5 minutes of reaction. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations demonstrated that the single vacancies present on the graphitic layers are the only active sites for FA dehydrogenation, while other defects, such as double vacancies and Stone-Wales (SW) defects, rarely adsorb FA molecules. Two different reaction pathways were found, one passing through a carboxyl species and the other through a hydroxymethylene intermediate. In both mechanisms, the active sites were poisoned by an intermediate species such as CO and atomic hydrogen, explaining the catalyst deactivation observed in the experimental results.

CO2 capture, activation and dissociation on the Ti2C surface and Ti2C MXene: the role of surface structure

Barrier-less CO₂ activation on Ti₂C(100) and MXene with preferential adsorption on the (100) surface and a lower dissociation barrier on MXene.

Mechanism of CO2 conversion to methanol over Cu(110) and Cu(100) surfaces

Density functional methods are applied to explore the reaction mechanism for CO₂ hydrogenation to methanol over low-index Cu surfaces, namely Cu(110) and Cu(100).