Peroxocobalt(iii) species activates nitriles via a superoxocobalt(ii) diradical state

DFT mechanistic insights into the formation of the metal-dioxygen complex [Co(12-TMC)O2]+ using H2O2 as an [O2] unit source

The reaction of [M(L)]n with H2O2 as an [O2] unit source and NEt3 as a base is a widely used biomimetic transition metal-peroxo and -superoxo complex [M(L)O2]n-1 synthesis method, but the mechanism and accurate stoichiometry of the synthesis remain elusive. In this study, we performed DFT calculations to deeply understand the mechanism, using the synthesis of the cobalt-peroxo complex [CoIII(12-TMC)O2]+ (12-TMC = (1,4,7,10-tetramethyl-1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane)) from the reaction of [CoII(12-TMC)]2+ and H2O2 in the presence of NEt3 as an example. The study found that cobalt-peroxo complex formation proceeds via three stages: (Stage I) the conversion of [CoII(12-TMC)]2+ and H2O2 to [CoIII(12-TMC)OH]2+ and OOH˙ radical, (Stage II) the coordination of OOH˙ to [CoII(12-TMC)]2+ to give [CoIII(12-TMC)OOH]2+, followed by deprotonation with NEt3, affording [CoIII(12-TMC)O2]+, and (Stage III) the transformation of [CoIII(12-TMC)OH]2+ which is generated in Stage I to [CoIII(12-TMC)O2]+. The overall stoichiometry of the synthesis is 2*[Co(12-TMC)]2+ + 3*H2O2 + 2*NEt3 → 2*[Co(12-TMC)O2]+ + 2*HNEt3+ + 2*H2O. In addition, compared to its analog [CoIII(TBDAP)O2]+ (TBDAP = N,N-di-tert-butyl-2,11-diaza[3.3](2,6)-pyridinophane) which is synthesized by the same method and has the same Co(III) oxidation state exhibits dioxygenase-like reactivity to nitriles, [CoIII(12-TMC)O2]+ could be inactive towards acetonitrile because the reaction severely deteriorates the coordination of the 12-TMC ligand to the Co center, which results in high reaction barriers.

Controlling Reactivity through Spin Manipulation: Steric Bulkiness of Peroxocobalt(III) Complexes

The intrinsic relationship between spin states and reactivity in peroxocobalt(III) complexes was investigated, specifically focusing on the influence of steric modulation on supporting ligands. Together with the previously reported [CoIII(TBDAP)(O2)]+ (2Tb), which exhibits spin crossover characteristics, two peroxocobalt(III) complexes, [CoIII(MDAP)(O2)]+ (2Me) and [CoIII(ADDAP)(O2)]+ (2Ad), bearing pyridinophane ligands with distinct N-substituents such as methyl and adamantyl groups, were synthesized and characterized. By manipulating the steric bulkiness of the N-substituents, control of spin states in peroxocobalt(III) complexes was demonstrated through various physicochemical analyses. Notably, 2Ad oxidized the nitriles to generate hydroximatocobalt(III) complexes, while 2Me displayed an inability for such oxidation reactions. Furthermore, both 2Ad and 2Tb exhibited similarities in spectroscopic and geometric features, demonstrating spin crossover behavior between S = 0 and S = 1. The steric bulkiness of the adamantyl and tert-butyl group on the axial amines was attributed to inducing a weak ligand field on the cobalt(III) center. Thus, 2Ad and 2Tb are an S = 1 state under the reaction conditions. In contrast, the less bulky methyl group on the amines of 2Me resulted in an S = 0 state. The redox potential of the peroxocobalt(III) complexes was also influenced by the ligand field arising from the steric bulkiness of the N-substituents in the order of 2Me (-0.01 V) < 2Tb (0.29 V) = 2Ad (0.29 V). Theoretical calculations using DFT supported the experimental observations, providing insights into the electronic structure and emphasizing the importance of the spin state of peroxocobalt(III) complexes in nitrile activation.

Mechanistic Insights into Oxidation of Benzaldehyde by Co-Peroxo Complexes

Transition metal-peroxide complexes play a crucial role as intermediates in oxidation reactions. To unravel the mechanism of benzaldehyde oxidation by the Co-peroxo complex, we conducted density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The identified competing mechanisms include nucleophilic attack and hydrogen atom transfer (HAT). The nucleophilic attack pathway involves Co-O cleavage and nucleophilic attack, leading to the formation of the benzoate product. And the HAT pathway comprises O-O cleavage and HAT, ultimately resulting in the benzoate product. DFT calculations revealed that the formation of the end-on Co-superoxo complex 2 through Co-O cleavage, starting from the side-on Co-peroxo complex 1, is much more favorable than the formation of the two-terminal oxyl-radical intermediate 3 through O-O cleavage. Compared with the nucleophilic attack of benzaldehyde by 2, the abstraction of a hydrogen atom from benzaldehyde by 3 requires higher energy. The nature of the nucleophilicity of 2 and 3 accounts for the reactivity of the reaction.

Synthetic Advances for Mechanistic Insights: Metal-Oxygen Intermediates with a Macrocyclic Pyridinophane System

ConspectusMetalloenzymes, which are proteins containing earth-abundant transition-metal ions as cofactors in the active site, generate various metal-oxygen intermediates via activating a dioxygen molecule (O2) to mediate vital metabolic functions, such as the oxidative metabolism of xenobiotics and the biotransformation of naturally occurring molecules. By replicating the active sites of metalloenzymes, many bioinorganic chemists have studied the geometric and electronic properties and reactivities of model complexes to understand the nature of enzymatic intermediates and develop bioinspired metal catalysts. Among the reported model complexes, nonporphyrinic macrocyclic ligands are the predominant coordination system widely used in stabilizing and isolating diverse metal-oxygen intermediates, which allows us to extensively investigate the physicochemical characteristics of the analogs of reactive intermediates of metalloenzymes. In particular, it has been reported that the ring size of the macrocyclic ligands, defined by the number of atoms in the macrocyclic ring, drastically affects the identity of the metal-oxygen intermediate. Thus, systematic modification of the macrocyclic ligands has been a great subject being examined in various inorganic fields.In this Account, we describe synthetic advances of a macrocyclic ligand system by introducing pyridine donors into a 12-membered tetraazamacrocyclic ligand (12-TMC) that initially has 4 amine donors. Interestingly, the backbone of the pyridinophane ligand with 2 pyridine and 2 amine donors in a 12-membered ring is shown to be much more folded than in other macrocyclic ligands, thereby allowing the axial and equatorial donors to separately control the electronic structure of metal complexes. Then, we looked over independent electronic and steric effects on metal-oxygen species with thorough physicochemical analysis. The NiIII-peroxo complexes exhibit nucleophilic reactivity dependent on the steric hindrance of the second coordination sphere. Furthermore, the C-H bond strength of the second coordination sphere has also been an important factor in determining the stability of MnIV-bis(hydroxo) intermediates. Electronic tuning on CoIII-hydroperoxo intermediates results in a trend between the electron-donating abilities of para-substituents on pyridine in the pyridinophane ligand and electrophilic reactivities, from which mechanistic insights into the metal-hydroperoxo species have been gained. Importantly, the metal-oxygen intermediates supported by the pyridinophane ligand system have revealed quite challenging chemical reactions, including dioxygenase-like nitrile activation by CoIII-peroxo intermediates and the oxidation of aldehyde and aromatic compounds by manganese-oxygen intermediates. Based on the fine substitution of donors, we have addressed that those novel reactions originated from the unique framework of the pyridinophane system incorporating spin-crossover behavior and high redox potentials of the metal-oxygen intermediates. These results will be valuable for the structure-activity relationship of metal-oxygen intermediates, giving a better understanding on the enzymatic coordination system where amino acid ligands vary for specific chemical reactions.

Mechanistic Insights into Nitrile Activation by Cobalt(III)-Hydroperoxo Intermediates: The Influence of Ligand Basicity

The versatile applications of nitrile have led to the widespread use of nitrile activation in the synthesis of pharmacologically and industrially valuable compounds. We reported the activation of nitriles using mononuclear cobalt(III)-hydroperoxo complexes, [CoIII(Me3-TPADP)(O2H)(RCN)]2+ [R = Me (2) and Ph (2Ph)], to form cobalt(III)-peroxyimidato complexes, [CoIII(Me3-TPADP)(R-C(=NH)O2)]2+ [R = Me (3) and Ph (3Ph)]. The independence of the rate on the nitrile concentration and the positive Hammett value of 3.2(2) indicated that the reactions occur via an intramolecular nucleophilic attack of the hydroperoxide ligand to the coordinated nitrile carbon atom. In contrast, the previously reported cobalt(III)-hydroperoxo complex, [CoIII(TBDAP)(O2H)(CH3CN)]2+ (2TBDAP), exhibited the deficiency of reactivity toward nitrile. The comparison of pKa values and redox potentials of 2 and 2TBDAP showed that Me3-TPADP had a stronger ligand field strength than that of TBDAP. The density functional theory calculations for 2 and 2TBDAP support that the strengthened ligand field in 2 is mainly due to the replacement of two tert-butyl amine donors in TBDAP with methyl groups in Me3-TPADP, resulting in the compression of the Co-Nax bond lengths. These results provide mechanistic evidence of nitrile activation by the cobalt(III)-hydroperoxo complex and indicate that the basicity dependent on the ligand framework contributes to the ability of nitrile activation.

Systematic Electronic Tuning on the Property and Reactivity of Cobalt-(Hydro)peroxo Intermediates

A series of cobalt(III)-peroxo complexes, [Co^III(R₂-TBDAP)(O₂)]⁺ (1^R2; R₂ = Cl, H, and OMe), and cobalt(III)-hydroperoxo complexes, [Co^III(R₂-TBDAP)(O₂H)(CH₃CN)]²⁺ (2^R2), bearing electronically tuned tetraazamacrocyclic ligands (R₂-TBDAP = N,N'-di-tert-butyl-2,11-diaza[3.3](2,6)-p-R₂-pyridinophane) were prepared from their cobalt(II) precursors and characterized by various physicochemical methods. The X-ray diffraction and spectroscopic analyses unambiguously showed that all 1^R2 compounds have similar octahedral geometry with a side-on peroxocobalt(III) moiety, but the O-O bond lengths of 1^Cl [1.398(3) Å] and 1^OMe [1.401(4) Å] were shorter than that of 1^H [1.456(3) Å] due to the different spin states. For 2^R2, the O-O bond vibration energies of 2^Cl and 2^OMe were identical at 853 cm^-1 (856 cm^-1 for 2^H), but their Co-O bond vibration frequencies were observed at 572 cm^-1 for 2^Cl and 550 cm^-1 for 2^OMe, respectively, by resonance Raman spectroscopy (560 cm^-1 for 2^H). Interestingly, the redox potentials (E_1/2) of 2^R2 increased in the order of 2^OMe (0.19 V) < 2^H (0.24 V) < 2^Cl (0.34 V) according to the electron richness of the R₂-TBDAP ligands, but the oxygen-atom-transfer reactivities of 2^R2 showed a reverse trend (k₂: 2^Cl < 2^H < 2^OMe) with a 13-fold rate enhancement at 2^OMe over 2^Cl in a sulfoxidation reaction with thioanisole. Although the reactivity trend contradicts the general consideration that electron-rich metal-oxygen species with low E_1/2 values have sluggish electrophilic reactivity, this could be explained by a weak Co-O bond vibration of 2^OMe in the unusual reaction pathway. These results provide considerable insight into the electronic nature-reactivity relationship of metal-oxygen species.

DFT Mechanistic Insights into Aldehyde Deformylations with Biomimetic Metal-Dioxygen Complexes: Distinct Mechanisms and Reaction Rules

Aldehyde deformylations occurring in organisms are catalyzed by metalloenzymes through metal-dioxygen active cores, attracting great interest to study small-molecule metal-dioxygen complexes for understanding relevant biological processes and developing biomimetic catalysts for aerobic transformations. As the known deformylation mechanisms, including nucleophilic attack, aldehyde α-H-atom abstraction, and aldehyde hydrogen atom abstraction, undergo outer-sphere pathways, we herein report a distinct inner-sphere mechanism based on density functional theory (DFT) mechanistic studies of aldehyde deformylations with a copper (II)-superoxo complex. The inner-sphere mechanism proceeds via a sequence mainly including aldehyde end-on coordination, homolytic aldehyde C-C bond cleavage, and dioxygen O-O bond cleavage, among which the C-C bond cleavage is the rate-determining step with a barrier substantially lower than those of outer-sphere pathways. The aldehyde C-C bond cleavage, enabled through the activation of the dioxygen ligand radical in a second-order nucleophilic substitution (S_N2)-like fashion, leads to an alkyl radical and facilitates the subsequent dioxygen O-O bond cleavage. Furthermore, we deduced the rules for the reactions of metal-dioxygen complexes with aldehydes and nitriles via the inner-sphere mechanism. Expectedly, our proposed inner-sphere mechanisms and the reaction rules offer another perspective to understand relevant biological processes involving metal-dioxygen cores and to discover metal-dioxygen catalysts for aerobic transformations.

Controlled Regulation of the Nitrile Activation of a Peroxocobalt(III) Complex with Redox-Inactive Lewis Acidic Metals

Redox-inactive metal ions play vital roles in biological O₂ activation and oxidation reactions of various substrates. Recently, we showed a distinct reactivity of a peroxocobalt(III) complex bearing a tetradentate macrocyclic ligand, [Co^III(TBDAP)(O₂)]⁺ (1) (TBDAP = N,N'-di-tert-butyl-2,11-diaza[3.3](2,6)pyridinophane), toward nitriles that afforded a series of hydroximatocobalt(III) complexes, [Co^III(TBDAP)(R-C(═NO)O)]⁺ (R = Me (3), Et, and Ph). In this study, we report the effects of redox-inactive metal ions on nitrile activation of 1. In the presence of redox-inactive metal ions such as Zn²⁺, La³⁺, Lu³⁺, and Y³⁺, the reaction does not form the hydroximatocobalt(III) complex but instead gives peroxyimidatocobalt(III) complexes, [Co^III(TBDAP)(R-C(═NH)O₂)]²⁺ (R = Me (2) and Ph (2^Ph)). These new intermediates were characterized by various physicochemical methods including X-ray diffraction analysis. The rates of the formation of 2 are found to correlate with the Lewis acidity of the additive metal ions. Moreover, complex 2 was readily converted to 3 by the addition of a base. In the presence of Al³⁺, Sc³⁺, or H⁺, 1 is converted to [Co^III(TBDAP)(O₂H)(MeCN)]²⁺ (4), and further reaction with nitriles did not occur. These results reveal that the reactivity of the peroxocobalt(III) complex 1 in nitrile activation can be regulated by the redox-inactive metal ions and their Lewis acidity. DFT calculations show that the redox-inactive metal ions stabilize the peroxo character of end-on Co-η¹-O₂ intermediate through the charge reorganization from a Co^II-superoxo to a Co^III-peroxo intermediate. A complete mechanistic model explaining the role of the Lewis acid is presented.