Role of aggregates and microstructure of mixed-ionic-electronic-conductors on charge transport in electrochemical transistors

Balancing performance and stability characteristics in organic electrochemical transistor

Nowadays organic electrochemical transistors (OECTs) are becoming a promising platform for bioelectronics and biosensing due to its biocompatibility, high sensitivity and selectivity, low driving voltages, high transconductance and flexibility. However, the existing problems associated with degradation processes within the OECT during long-term operation hinder their widespread implementation. Moreover, trade-offs often arise between OECT transconductance and speed, fast ion transport and electron mobility, electrochemical stability and sensitivity, cycling stability and signal amplification, and other metrics. Ensuring high performance characteristics and achieving enhanced stability in OECTs are distinct strategies that do not always align, as progress in one aspect often necessitates a trade-off with the other. This dynamic arises from the need to find a balance between reversible and irreversible processes in the behavior of OECT active layers, and providing simultaneously favorable conditions for ion and electron transport and their efficient charge coupling. This review article systematically summarizes the phenomenological and physical-chemical aspects associated with factors and mechanisms that determine both performance and long-term stability of OECT, paying special attention to the consideration of existing and promising approaches to extend the OECT lifespan, while maintaining (or even increasing) high effectiveness of its operation.

Structural Modifications for Tuning Performance and Operational Modes in n-Type Organic Electrochemical Transistors

Organic mixed ionic-electronic conductors (OMIECs) are crucial in defining the operational modes and performance of organic electrochemical transistors (OECTs). However, studies on the design and structure-performance correlations of small-molecule n-type OMIECs remain scarce. Herein, we designed and synthesized a series of naphthalene diimide (NDI)-based n-type small molecules by extending π-conjugation and increasing the number of electron-withdrawing groups, achieving performance optimization and even changes in operational modes through structural regulations. OECTs based on 4Br-NDI-3EG exhibit a low threshold voltage of -0.022 V, which is the lowest reported for n-type channel materials to date. NDI-DTYA-3EG, synthesized through π-expansion of 4Br-NDI-3EG, maintains a low threshold voltage of -0.041 V and achieves 2 orders of magnitude improvement in electron mobility (1.04 × 10-2 cm2 V-1 s-1) owing to its mixed edge-on and face-on orientation. Specifically, by further increasing the number of electron-withdrawing groups, NDI-DTYM-3EG attains a sufficiently low LUMO energy level (-4.51 eV), enabling a spontaneous reduction in 0.1 M NaCl solution without external bias, thereby achieving self-doping. Consequently, it exhibits n-depletion-mode characteristics with a transconductance value of 287 μS. Moreover, devices made with NDI-DTYM-3EG show exceptional stability, retaining 98% of the initial drain current after 150 min operation. These results provide insights into the understanding and design of n-type mixed ionic-electronic conductor materials.

The hierarchical structure of organic mixed ionic-electronic conductors and its evolution in water

Polymeric organic mixed ionic-electronic conductors underpin several technologies in which their electrochemical properties are desirable. These properties, however, depend on the microstructure that develops in their aqueous operational environment. We investigated the structure of a model organic mixed ionic-electronic conductor across multiple length scales using cryogenic four-dimensional scanning transmission electron microscopy in both its dry and hydrated states. Four-dimensional scanning transmission electron microscopy allows us to identify the prevalent defects in the polymer crystalline regions and to analyse the liquid crystalline nature of the polymer. The orientation maps of the dry and hydrated polymers show that swelling-induced disorder is mostly localized in discrete regions, thereby largely preserving the liquid crystalline order. Therefore, the liquid crystalline mesostructure makes electronic transport robust to electrolyte ingress. This study demonstrates that cryogenic four-dimensional scanning transmission electron microscopy provides multiscale structural insights into complex, hierarchical structures such as polymeric organic mixed ionic-electronic conductors, even in their hydrated operating state.

Correlation of Processing and Structure in an Ethylene-Glycol Side-Chain Modified Polythiophene via Combined X-Ray Scattering and 4D Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy

The results of a combined grazing incidence wide-angle X-ray scattering (GIWAXS) and 4D scanning transmission microscopy (4D-STEM) analysis of the effects of thermal processing on poly(3[2-(2-methoxyethoxy)ethoxy]-methylthiophene-2,5-diyl) are reported, a conjugated semiconducting polymer used as the active layer in organic electrochemical transistor devices. GIWAXS provides a measure of overall crystallinity in the film, while 4D-STEM produces real-space maps of the morphology and orientation of individual crystallites along with their spatial extent and distribution. The sensitivity of the 4D-STEM detector allows for collection of electron diffraction patterns at each position in an image scan while limiting the imparted electron dose to below the damage threshold. The effects of heat treatment on the distribution and type of crystallites present in the films is determined.

Charge Carrier Induced Structural Ordering And Disordering in Organic Mixed Ionic Electronic Conductors

Operational stability underpins the successful application of organic mixed ionic-electronic conductors (OMIECs) in a wide range of fields, including biosensing, neuromorphic computing, and wearable electronics. In this work, both the operation and stability of a p-type OMIEC material of various molecular weights are investigated. Electrochemical transistor measurements reveal that device operation is very stable for at least 300 charging/discharging cycles independent of molecular weight, provided the charge density is kept below the threshold where strong charge-charge interactions become likely. When electrochemically charged to higher charge densities, an increase in device hysteresis and a decrease in conductivity due to a drop in the hole mobility arising from long-range microstructural disruptions are observed. By employing operando X-ray scattering techniques, two regimes of polaron-induced structural changes are found: 1) polaron-induced structural ordering at low carrier densities, and 2) irreversible structural disordering that disrupts charge transport at high carrier densities, where charge-charge interactions are significant. These operando measurements also reveal that the transfer curve hysteresis at high carrier densities is accompanied by an analogous structural hysteresis, providing a microstructural basis for such instabilities. This work provides a mechanistic understanding of the structural dynamics and material instabilities of OMIEC materials during device operation.

Impact of doping on the mechanical properties of conjugated polymers

Conjugated polymers exhibit a unique portfolio of electrical and electrochemical behavior, which - paired with the mechanical properties that are typical for macromolecules - make them intriguing candidates for a wide range of application areas from wearable electronics to bioelectronics. However, the degree of oxidation or reduction of the polymer can strongly impact the mechanical response and thus must be considered when designing flexible or stretchable devices. This tutorial review first explores how the chain architecture, processing as well as the resulting nano- and microstructure impact the rheological and mechanical properties. In addition, different methods for the mechanical characterization of thin films and bulk materials such as fibers are summarized. Then, the review discusses how chemical and electrochemical doping alter the mechanical properties in terms of stiffness and ductility. Finally, the mechanical response of (doped) conjugated polymers is discussed in the context of (1) organic photovoltaics, representing thin-film devices with a relatively low charge-carrier density, (2) organic thermoelectrics, where chemical doping is used to realize thin films or bulk materials with a high doping level, and (3) organic electrochemical transistors, where electrochemical doping allows high charge-carrier densities to be reached, albeit accompanied by significant swelling. In the future, chemical and electrochemical doping may not only allow modulation and optimization of the electrical and electrochemical behavior of conjugated polymers, but also facilitate the design of materials with a tunable mechanical response.

The relationship between ionic-electronic coupling and transport in organic mixed conductors

Organic mixed ionic-electronic conductors (OMIECs) directly convert between ionic and electronic charge through electrochemical (de)doping, enabling a wide range of applications in bioelectronics, neuromorphic computing, and energy storage and conversion. While both ionic and electronic transport are individually well characterized, their combined transport has been difficult to describe self-consistently. We use in situ measurements of electrochemical (de)doping of an archetypal OMIEC to inform a quasi-field drift-diffusion model, which accurately captures experimentally measured ion transport across a range of potentials. We find that the chemical potential of holes, which is modulated by changes in doping level, represents a major driving force for mixed charge transport. Using numerical simulations at device-relevant time scales and potentials, we find that the competition between hole drift and diffusion leads to diffuse space charge regions despite high charge densities. This effect is unique to mixed conducting systems where mobile ionic charges can compensate the accumulation or depletion of electronic charge, thereby screening electrostatic driving forces.