Carrier detection and prenatal diagnosis in haemophilia in India: realities and challenges

Gender equity in hemophilia: need for healthcare, familial, and societal advocacy

Hemophilia is a rare bleeding disorder caused by a genetic defect on chromosome X. It is inherited as an X-linked trait, and hence, it is more frequently diagnosed in males, whereas women have been traditionally considered only as carriers of the disease. However, the role of women in families of patients with hemophilia is pivotal. As mothers, sisters, daughters, and female partners of patients with hemophilia, they play a central role in the management of the patient, considering healthcare, social, and familial aspects, but they might be affected by the disease as well, particularly in regions where consanguinity is frequent. This paper aims to explore the involvement of women in hemophilia, including their carrier status, bleeding symptoms, treatment challenges, and psychosocial impact not only related to male patients, but also as patients affected with hemophilia themselves. We advocate health equity, equal access to healthcare for men and women with hemophilia and dedicated resources to improve the unique needs of the women dealing with hemophilia, ultimately leading to improved care and quality of life.

Association of Genetic Variant FVIII Gene and Factor VIII: A Pilot Study Among Hemophilia A Female Relatives in Saudi Arabia

Hemophilia A (HA) is an X-linked recessive disorder that results from mutations in the factor VIII gene (FVIII). Most affected patients are males due to the inheritance of mutations in the FVIII gene from their mothers. Females are mostly found to be carriers unless they inherited the mutation from both parents. Obligate carriers of HA are mothers whose sons are affected with HA, or daughters who inherit the mutation from their affected fathers. A possible carrier of HA could be any female who has one or more affected relatives with HA in her family. Hemophilia A carriers (HACs) could present with similar symptoms to affected patients, including low factor VIII level, and risk of bleeding especially after surgical procedures or postpartum hemorrhage.

OBJECTIVES

 Assessing the phenotype of possible HAC and its association with genetic variants in the FVIII gene for better screening methods for HAC.

METHODS

From the period between 25 June and 25 October 2021, the study was conducted at King Abdulaziz University Hospital in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. We recruited seven mothers whose sons were affected with HA, and 18 possible HAC who are relatives to sever affected patients with HA. All 25 candidates were assessed for the FVIII level, activated partial thromboplastin time (APTT), and bleeding risk and sequenced a part of Exon14 in their FVIII gene.

RESULTS

Twenty-five percent of the participants show a low level of FVIII, however, none of them have prolonged bleeding nor suffer from bleeding tendency. We also identified two missense variants in six of the candidates, but the clinical significance of these variants has not been determined previously.

CONCLUSION

This pilot study is the first to explore the phenotype of several HAC in Saudi Arabia. A larger scale study with more HA patients and their female relatives is needed to understand the correlation between phenotype and genotype for better screening for HAC.

Preventing lives affected by hemophilia: A mixed methods study of the views of adults with hemophilia and their families toward genetic screening

Background

Genomic sequencing technologies have made the possibility of population screening for whole panels of genetic disorders more feasible than ever before. As one of the most common single gene disorders affecting the UK population, hemophilia is an attractive candidate to include on such screening panels. However, very little is known about views toward genetic screening amongst people with hemophilia or their family members, despite the potential for a wide range of impacts on them.

Methods

Twenty‐two in‐depth qualitative interviews were undertaken to explore the views of adults with hemophilia and their family members, recruited through the Haemophilia Society UK. These interviews were used to develop a survey, the Haemophilia Screening Survey (UK), which was distributed in paper and online format through the support group, receiving 327 returns between January and June 2018.

Results

Fifty‐seven per cent of the sample supported preconception carrier screening of the population for hemophilia, and 59% supported prenatal carrier screening. Key reasons for support included a desire to reduce pregnancy terminations and increase awareness of hemophilia. Despite support for screening however, 90% of the sample disagreed with pregnancy terminations for hemophilia.

Conclusions

Families and adults living with hemophilia are more supportive of screening for information and preparation purposes than to prevent boys with hemophilia from being born. A distinction was made between preventing the disease and preventing the lives of people with it, with support shown for the use of screening to achieve the former, but not at the expense of the latter.

Hemophilia carrier's awareness, diagnosis, and management in emerging countries: a cross-sectional study in Côte d'Ivoire (Ivory Coast)

BACKGROUND

Little data is available on awareness of hemophilia carrier condition or associated bleeding risk and management in Sub-Saharan African countries. This study sought to identify hemophilia carriers in Côte d'Ivoire in order to collect data on demographics, bleeding phenotype, and laboratory results. Another purpose was to provide Ivorian hemophilia carriers with counseling on their risk of bleeding and of having children with hemophilia. A 12-month prospective study was conducted involving Ivorian hemophilia carriers recruited trough pedigree analysis pertaining to 81 hemophilia patients followed-up at the Yopougon Hemophilia Treatment Center in Abidjan. They were assessed using in-depth interviews, pedigree analysis, and laboratory testing.

RESULTS

Sixty-one subjects comprising 27 obligate and 34 possible carriers were recruited. None had previously been assessed, with 64% unaware of their carrier status despite a familial history of hemophilia in 69%. The most frequently reported bleeding symptom was menorrhagia (31%). Prolonged bleeding was reported after vaginal delivery in 19.6%, post-surgery in 4.9%, and post-dental extraction in 4.9%. Only one carrier was treated with tranexamic acid, with no other hemostatic therapy recorded. The median (range) clotting FVIII was 0.85 IU/mL (0.24-1.90 IU/mL) and FIX 0.60 IU/mL (0.42-1.76 IU/mL) in hemophilia A and B carriers, respectively. HA carriers had a FVIII < 0.5 IU/mL in 12.5%.

CONCLUSIONS

This study highlights the need of implementing care for hemophilia carriers in developing countries, and the high value of pedigree analysis for carrier identification, along with the relevance of diagnosis, treatment, and education of carriers, families, and caregivers.

Ethical, social, and cultural issues related to clinical genetic testing and counseling in low- and middle-income countries: a systematic review

PURPOSE

We performed a systematic review of the ethical, social, and cultural issues associated with delivery of genetic services in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs).

METHODS

We searched 11 databases for studies addressing ethical, social, and/or cultural issues associated with clinical genetic testing and/or counselling performed in LMICs. Narrative synthesis was employed to analyze findings, and resultant themes were mapped onto the social ecological model (PROSPERO #CRD42016042894).

RESULTS

After reviewing 13,308 articles, 192 met inclusion criteria. Nine themes emerged: (1) genetic counseling has a tendency of being directive, (2) genetic services have psychosocial consequences that require improved support, (3) medical genetics training is inadequate, (4) genetic services are difficult to access, (5) social determinants affect uptake and understanding of genetic services, (6) social stigma is often associated with genetic disease, (7) family values are at risk of disruption by genetic services, (8) religious principles pose barriers to acceptability and utilization of genetic services, and (9) cultural beliefs and practices influence uptake of information and understanding of genetic disease.

CONCLUSION

We identified a number of complex and interrelated ethical, cultural, and social issues with implications implications for further development of genetic services in LMICs.

Ethical, social, and cultural issues related to clinical genetic testing and counseling in low- and middle-income countries: protocol for a systematic review

BACKGROUND

There has been little focus in the literature on how to build genetic testing and counseling services in low- and middle-income countries in a responsible, ethical, and culturally appropriate manner. It is unclear to what extent this area is being explored and what form further research should take. The proposed knowledge synthesis aims to fill this gap in knowledge and mine the existing data to determine the breadth of work in this area and identify ethical, social, and cultural issues that have emerged.

METHODS/DESIGN

An integrated knowledge translation approach will be undertaken by engaging knowledge users throughout the review to ensure relevance to their practice. Electronic databases encompassing various disciplines, such as healthcare, social sciences, and public health, will be searched. Studies that address clinical genetic testing and/or counseling and ethical, social, and/or cultural issues of these genetic services, and are performed in low- and middle-income countries as defined by World Bank will be considered for inclusion. Two independent reviewers will be involved in a two-stage literature screening process, data extraction, and quality appraisal. Studies included in the review will be analyzed by thematic analysis. A narrative synthesis guided by the social ecological model will be used to summarize findings.

DISCUSSION

This systematic review will provide a foundation of evidence regarding ethical, social, and cultural issues related to clinical genetic testing and counseling in low- and middle-income countries. Using the social ecological model as a conceptual framework will facilitate the understanding of broader influences of the sociocultural context on an individual's experience with clinical genetic testing and counseling, thereby informing interdisciplinary sectors in future recommendations for practice and policy.

SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION

PROSPERO CRD42016042894.

Uptake of Genetic Counseling, Knowledge of Bleeding risks and Psychosocial Impact in a South African Cohort of Female Relatives of People with Hemophilia

In excess of 200 people with hemophilia (PWH) and their families have received genetic counseling (GC) at the Hemophilia Comprehensive Care Centre at Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital. However, very few of their at-risk female relatives have attended GC to discuss their reproductive risks and options, or their potential bleeding risks. Limited research has been conducted internationally on factors influencing uptake of GC and testing amongst female relatives of PWH. This prospective study aimed to explore the factors that influence the uptake of GC and testing by female relatives of PWH. An open-ended semi-structured interview schedule was developed. Participants included female relatives of PWH who at least had a family member who had received GC. Seventeen participants were interviewed; 7 who had GC previously and 10 who had not. All participants who had previously received GC found the service helpful and were mothers referred because their sons had hemophilia. Of those who had not had GC, possible deterrents included: being unaware of GC service, focus in clinic on PWH and not potential carriers, misunderstood risks related to hemophilia and carrier status, fear of finding out carrier status, and non-disclosure in families. Most participants were unaware of potential bleeding risks for carriers. The information will be used to provide a better service to female relatives of PWH with a goal being to set up a dedicated hemophilia carrier clinic.

Molecular pathology of haemophilia A in Indian patients: identification of 11 novel mutations

BACKGROUND

The identification of pathogenic mutations in haemophilia A (HA) patients is important as a basis for genetic diagnosis and also for the assessment of clinical manifestations.

METHOD

We analyzed 36 inversion negative congenital HA cases (28 unrelated and 8 familial) by multiplex PCR and the conformation sensitive gel electrophoresis (CSGE) technique, followed by DNA sequencing. The pathogenicity of each of these mutations was assessed using various prediction software.

RESULTS

We found 17 missense, 5 deletions, 3 insertions, and 2 nonsense mutations, out of which 16 were recurrent and 11 novel. All novel substitution mutations were found to be deleterious using the prediction softwares. We also encountered a double mutation (1 novel and 1 hot-spot mutation) in a family with a strong family history. A missense mutation in heterozygous state was also detected in a female bleeder with very low factor VIII levels, probably due to extreme lyonization.

CONCLUSION

High heterogeneity in mutational profile has been observed in the present study. The outcome of this study would enable us to give an accurate diagnosis in all affected families by direct mutation analysis.

Carrier testing in haemophilia A and B: adult carriers' and their partners' experiences and their views on the testing of young females

This is a descriptive study, which aims to report adult carriers' and their husbands/partners' experiences of carrier diagnosis and their views as to how these issues should be handled for the next generation. Following an initial pilot, 105 carriers and husbands/partners responded to a postal questionnaire. Most of the adult carriers had been tested because either they or their parents wanted to know their carrier status or they had a son diagnosed with haemophilia. The respondents agreed that the main reasons for testing young potential carriers should be either a family history of severe haemophilia or that the young person or her parents wanted to know her status. Forty per cent (35/87) believed the earliest age for carrier testing should be 0-9 years, 44% (38/87) 10-15 years and 16% (14/87) > or =16 years. Respondents aged 18-39 years were more likely to be in favour of testing <2 years. If parents and teenagers disagreed, the majority of parents thought that a test should not be forced, consent refused or results withheld. Genetic counselling provides an important opportunity for parents, who want a very early genetic test, to explore their motivations and balance their desire to prepare and protect their daughter with her right to decide as a teenager.

'Rakter dosh'--corrupting blood: The challenges of preventing thalassemia in Bengal, India

Thalassemia is an inherited blood disorder that has been receiving increasing attention in India. However, prevention of thalassemia in India continues to be difficult despite efforts of public health professionals and the government. Using West Bengal as a case study, this paper attempts to unravel some of the barriers to the prevention campaign and the consequent under utilization of the program. Lack of access, low awareness, low-risk perception and poverty are all important proximate constraints; however, one of the greatest barriers to the program is rooted in cultural notions of blood, marriage, identity, personhood and kinship in Bengali society. Blood is so deeply valued in the Bengali kinship system that this genetic mutation is perceived to be corrupting the blood (rakter dosh). Being a thalassemia carrier (i.e., having thalassemia minor) renders an individual unfit as a suitable marriage partner because of beliefs related to purity of blood, its association with the continuity of the lineage, and subsequent transmission of desirable traits to future generations. The risk of non-marriage affects women disproportionately, and parents are not inclined to test their daughters because of the possibility of not being able to marry them off to eligible suitors. The stigma associated with having thalassemia minor (TMI) is a deterrent to the disclosure of thalassemia status as well as to testing. Using anthropological theories and ethnographic methods, this paper focuses on the gendered process by which the diagnosis of a thalassemia carrier 'spoils' identities, thereby creating a disjuncture between the goals of the prevention program and people's need for social conformity, and ultimately between medical desirability and social desirability. The paper also suggests policies for enhancing the utilization of the program. Finally the conclusions from this study have potential applications for public health prevention programs that confront problems of stigma in program acceptability.

Mutation Analysis in F9 Gene of 17 Families with Haemophilia B from Iran

The most common type of surgical procedure in patients with haemophilia is orthopaedic surgery on the lower limb. These procedures are of great importance for the improvement of the function and quality of life of patients with haemophilia, but in many countries resources are lacking to provide the factor concentrates needed for these operations. We have attempted to reduce the level of replacement during and after total hip or total knee replacement without jeopardizing the outcome of the procedures. The results from 30 operations in 27 patients are presented. Steady-state levels down to 0.5 IU mL(-1) did not appear to increase the amount of blood loss or cause an increased incidence of complications, compared with higher levels. In addition, we review the possibilities to reduce the amount of factor concentrate by performing a combination of orthopaedic procedures and using local haemostatic agents or antifibrinolytic agents.

Informativeness of linkage analysis for genetic diagnosis of haemophilia A in India

The objective of this study was to assess the frequency of factor VIII (FVIII) gene intron 1 and intron 22 inversions and the informativeness of polymorphic markers for the genetic diagnosis of patients with haemophilia A (HA). Fifty unrelated patients with HA were first assessed for the intron 1 and intron 22 inversion mutations. Inversion-negative families were then screened for the bi-allelic intragenic markers--intron 7 G-->A polymorphism, HindIII site in intron 19 and XbaI site in intron 22 and the multiallelic dinucleotide CA repeat alleles in introns 13 and 22. The extragenic, multiallelic VNTR DXS52 (st14) was also analysed. Intron 22 inversion mutation was found in 38% (n = 19) of all patients and 46% of those with severe HA. Intron 1 inversion was found in one (2%) patient. Of the 30 inversion-negative families, XbaI site polymorphism was the single most informative marker (70%, n = 21/30) followed by HindIII (60%, n = 18/30), intron 13 CA repeats (56.66%, n = 17/30), intron 22 CA repeats (50%, n = 15/30), DXS52 VNTR (23.33%, n = 7/30) and intron 7 G-->A polymorphism (6.66%, n = 2/30). The combined use of these markers was informative in 92% (n = 46/50) of HA families. Based on the informativeness of these markers a comprehensive algorithm has been proposed for genetic diagnosis of HA in India.

Management of haemophilia and its complications in developing countries

Eighty per cent of people with haemophilia live in developing countries, where technical expertise and health care facilities may be less than optimal. Haemophilia is a relatively rare disease and high-cost, technology-intensive therapy is not a high priority for the governments of developing countries. The rapid spread of transfusion-related viral infections in many developing countries presents further problems for haemophiliacs. However, it is possible to manage haemophiliacs patients with limited resources. Strategies for conserving factor concentrates, include education of doctors and patients, prenatal diagnosis, increasing the use of anti-fibrinolytic agents, physiotherapy, the use of fibrin glue, and simple orthotics and prosthetic measures. These approaches are helpful in the majority of these patients. Meanwhile, with the help of the World Federation of Haemophilia (WFH), all developing countries are gradually improving management skills for this relatively rare but disabling disease. The present review broadly describes the management of various aspects of severe haemophilia in developing countries.