Genetic evidence of separate repressor and activator activities of the XylR regulator of the TOL plasmid, pWW0, of Pseudomonas putida

A dual-parameter identification approach for data-based predictive modeling of hybrid gene regulatory network-growth kinetics in Pseudomonas putida mt-2

Data integration to model-based description of biological systems incorporating gene dynamics improves the performance of microbial systems. Bioprocess performance, typically predicted using empirical Monod-type models, is essential for a sustainable bioeconomy. To replace empirical models, we updated a hybrid gene regulatory network-growth kinetic model, predicting aromatic pollutants degradation and biomass growth in Pseudomonas putida mt-2. We modeled a complex biological system including extensive information to understand the role of the regulatory elements in toluene biodegradation and biomass growth. The updated model exhibited extra complications such as the existence of oscillations and discontinuities. As parameter estimation of complex biological models remains a key challenge, we used the updated model to present a dual-parameter identification approach (the 'dual approach') combining two independent methodologies. Approach I handled the complexity by incorporation of demonstrated biological knowledge in the model-development process and combination of global sensitivity analysis and optimisation. Approach II complemented Approach I handling multimodality, ill-conditioning and overfitting through regularisation estimation, global optimisation, and identifiability analysis. To systematically quantify the biological system, we used a vast amount of high-quality time-course data. The dual approach resulted in an accurately calibrated kinetic model (NRMSE: 0.17055) efficiently handling the additional model complexity. We tested model validation using three independent experimental data sets, achieving greater predictive power (NRMSE: 0.18776) than the individual approaches (NRMSE I: 0.25322, II: 0.25227) and increasing model robustness. These results demonstrated data-driven predictive modeling potentially leading to bioprocess' model-based control and optimisation.

Widening functional boundaries of the σ(54) promoter Pu of Pseudomonas putida by defeating extant physiological constraints

The extant layout of the σ(54) promoter Pu, harboured by the catabolic TOL plasmid, pWW0, of Pseudomonas putida is one of the most complex instances of endogenous and exogenous signal integration known in the prokaryotic domain. In this regulatory system, all signal inputs are eventually translated into occupation of the promoter sequence by either of two necessary components: the m-xylene responsive transcriptional factor XylR and the σ(54) containing form of RNA polymerase. Modelling of these components indicated that the Pu promoter could be upgraded to respond with much greater capacity to aromatic inducers by artificially increasing the endogenous levels of both XylR and the σ(54) sigma factor, either separately or together. To explore these scenarios, expression of rpoN, the gene encoding σ(54), was placed under the control of an orthogonal regulatory system that was inducible by salicylic acid. We generated a knock-in P. putida strain containing this construct alongside the xylR/Pu regulatory module in its native configuration, and furthermore, a second strain where xylR expression was under the control of an engineered positive-feedback loop. These interventions allowed us to dramatically increase the transcriptional capacity (i.e. absolute promoter output) of Pu far beyond its natural scope. In addition, they resulted in a new regulatory device displaying more sensitive and ultra-fast responses to m-xylene. To our knowledge, this is the first time that the working regime of a promoter has been rationally modified by releasing the constraints imposed by its innate constituents.

Increasing signal specificity of the TOL network of Pseudomonas putida mt-2 by rewiring the connectivity of the master regulator XylR

Prokaryotic transcription factors (TFs) that bind small xenobiotic molecules (e.g., TFs that drive genes that respond to environmental pollutants) often display a promiscuous effector profile for analogs of the bona fide chemical signals. XylR, the master TF for expression of the m-xylene biodegradation operons encoded in the TOL plasmid pWW0 of Pseudomonas putida, responds not only to the aromatic compound but also, albeit to a lesser extent, to many other aromatic compounds, such as 3-methylbenzylalcohol (3MBA). We have examined whether such a relaxed regulatory scenario can be reshaped into a high-capacity/high-specificity regime by changing the connectivity of this effector-sensing TF within the rest of the circuit rather than modifying XylR structure itself. To this end, the natural negative feedback loop that operates on xylR transcription was modified with a translational attenuator that brings down the response to 3MBA while maintaining the transcriptional output induced by m-xylene (as measured with a luxCDABE reporter system). XylR expression was then subject to a positive feedback loop in which the TF was transcribed from its own target promoters, each known to hold different input/output transfer functions. In the first case (xylR under the strong promoter of the upper TOL operon, Pu), the reporter system displayed an increased transcriptional capacity in the resulting network for both the optimal and the suboptimal XylR effectors. In contrast, when xylR was expressed under the weaker Ps promoter, the resulting circuit unmistakably discriminated m-xylene from 3MBA. The non-natural connectivity engineered in the network resulted both in a higher promoter activity and also in a much-increased signal-to-background ratio. These results indicate that the working regimes of given genetic circuits can be dramatically altered through simple changes in the way upstream transcription factors are self-regulated by positive or negative feedback loops.

It is generally taken for granted that promoters regulated by transcriptional factors (TFs) that respond to small molecules control their specificity to given effectors by tightening or relaxing the intrinsic dual interaction between the TF and the particular inducer. One such promoter is Pu, which drives expression of an operon for the biodegradation of m-xylene by the soil bacterium P. putida mt-2. While XylR, the chief TF of this system, binds this substrate and activates Pu, the same regulator responds, to a lesser extent, to 3-methylbenzylalcohol and thus also activates the promoter. This work provides evidence that such natural effector promiscuity of the system can be altogether suppressed by replacing the naturally occurring negative autoregulation loop that governs XylR expression with an equivalent positive feedback loop. Based on this result, we argue that signal specificity of a given regulatory device depends not only on the TF involved but also on TF connectivity to upstream signals and downstream targets.

A composite feed-forward loop I4-FFL involving IHF and Crc stabilizes expression of the XylR regulator of Pseudomonas putida mt-2 from growth phase perturbations

Genetic networks are typically composed of a series of connected motifs that confer specific logic and dynamic properties to the resulting circuits. While some feed forward loop (FFL) variants abound in such networks, others (e.g. the type-4 incoherent FFL or I4-FFL) are virtually absent from the known regulatory devices. We report here that the key node that rules the expression of the m-xylene biodegradation pathway of the soil bacterium Pseudomonas putida mt-2 merges opposite physiological effects of the growth phase by means of a regulatory device based on the rarely found I4-FFL motif. Specifically, the FFL includes the integration host factor (IHF), which both co-activates the master P(u) promoter and represses transcription of its cognate regulatory gene xylR at the onset of the stationary phase. On the other hand, the catabolite repression control (Crc) protein inhibits translation of XylR during exponential growth. By computing these two conflicting regulatory actions within a composite I4-FFL gate, cells shield the expression of XylR from perturbations caused by the growth phase, thereby ensuring a steady supply of the regulator regardless of physiological conditions. This device thus endows xylR expression with a degree of robustness in respect to the growth phase that could hardly be achieved with e.g. a simple constitutive promoter.

The logicome of environmental bacteria: merging catabolic and regulatory events with Boolean formalisms

The regulatory and metabolic networks that rule biodegradation of pollutants by environmental bacteria are wired to the rest of the cellular physiology through both transcriptional factors and intermediary signal molecules. In this review, we examine some formalisms for describing catalytic/regulatory circuits of this sort and advocate the adoption of Boolean logic for combining transcriptional and enzymatic occurrences in the same biological system. As an example, we show how known regulatory and metabolic actions that bring about biodegradation of m-xylene by Pseudomonas putida mt-2 can be represented as clusters of binary operations and then reconstructed as a digital network. Despite the many simplifications, Boolean tools still capture the gross behaviour of the system even in the absence of kinetic constants determined experimentally. On this basis, we argue that still with a limited volume of data binary formalisms allow us to penetrate the raison d'être of extant regulatory and metabolic architectures.

Mining logic gates in prokaryotic transcriptional regulation networks

Prokaryotic transcriptional networks possess a large number of regulatory modules that formally implement many of the logic gates that are typical of digital, Boolean circuits. Yet, natural regulatory elements appear most often compressed and exaggeratedly context-dependent for any reliable circuit engineering barely comparable to electronic counterparts. To overcome this impasse, we argue that designing new functions with biological parts requires (i) the recognition of logic gates not yet assigned but surely present in the meta-genome, (ii) the orthogonalization and disambiguation of natural regulatory modules and (iii) the development of ways to tackle the connectivity and the definition of boundaries between minimal biological components.

The NorR protein of Escherichia coli activates expression of the flavorubredoxin gene norV in response to reactive nitrogen species

The Escherichia coli norVW genes encode a flavorubredoxin and NADH:(flavo)rubredoxin reductase, respectively, which are involved in nitric oxide detoxification under anaerobic growth conditions. Here it is shown that the norVW genes also have a role in protection against reactive nitrogen intermediates generated from nitroprusside. Transcription from the norV promoter is activated by the presence of nitroprusside in the growth medium; activation requires the product of a divergently transcribed regulatory gene, norR.

Monitoring intracellular levels of XylR in Pseudomonas putida with a single-chain antibody specific for aromatic-responsive enhancer-binding proteins

We have isolated a recombinant phage antibody (Phab) that binds a distinct epitope of the subclass of the sigma(54)-dependent prokaryotic enhancer-binding proteins that respond directly to aromatic effectors, e.g., those that activate biodegradative operons of Pseudomonas spp. The DNA segments encoding the variable (V) domains of the immunoglobulins expressed by mice immunized with the C-terminal half of TouR (TouRDeltaA) of Pseudomonas stutzeri OX1 were amplified and rearranged in vitro as single-chain Fv (scFv) genes. An scFv library was thereby constructed, expressed in an M13 display system, and subjected to a panning procedure with TouR. One clone (named B7) was selected with high affinity for TouR and XylR (the regulator of the upper TOL operon of the pWW0 plasmid). The epitope recognized by this Phab was mapped to the peptide TPRAQATLLRVL, which seems to be characteristic of the group of enhancer-binding proteins to which TouR and XylR belong and which is located adjacent to the Walker B motif of the proteins. The Phab B7 was instrumental in measuring directly the intracellular levels of XylR expressed from its natural promoter in monocopy gene dosage in Pseudomonas putida under various conditions. Growth stage, the physical form of the protein produced (XylR or XylRDeltaA), and the presence or absence of aromatic inducers in the medium influenced the intracellular pool of these molecules. XylR oscillated from a minimum of approximately 30 molecules (monomers) per cell during exponential phase to approximately140 molecules per cell at stationary phase. Activation of XylR by aromatic inducers decreased the intracellular concentration of the regulator. The levels of the constitutively active variant of XylR named XylRDeltaA were higher, fluctuating between approximately 90 and approximately 570 molecules per cell, depending on the growth stage. These results are compatible with the present model of transcriptional autoregulation of XylR and suggest the existence of mechanisms controlling the stability of XylR protein in vivo.

A la carte transcriptional regulators: unlocking responses of the prokaryotic enhancer-binding protein XylR to non-natural effectors

To investigate the activation mechanism of the enhancer-binding protein XylR encoded by the TOL plasmid of Pseudomonas putida mt-2, a combinatorial library was generated composed of shuffled N-terminal A domains of the homologous regulators DmpR, XylR and TbuT, reassembled within the XylR structure. When the library was screened in vivo for responsiveness to non-effectors bulkier than one aromatic ring (such as biphenyl) or bearing an entirely different distribution of electronegative groups (e.g. nitrotoluenes), protein variants were found that displayed an expanded inducer range including the new effectors. Although the phenotypes endowed with the corresponding changes were largely similar, the modifications involved different sites within the A domain. The positions of the mutations within a structural model of the A domain suggest that expansion of the inducer profile can be brought about not only by changes in the effector pocket of the protein but also by unlocking steps of the signal transmission mechanism that follows effector binding. These results provide a rationale for evolving in vitro regulators à la carte that are responsive to predetermined, natural or xenobiotic chemical species.

Unusual location of two nearby pairs of upstream activating sequences for HbpR, the main regulatory protein for the 2-hydroxybiphenyl degradation pathway of "Pseudomonas azelaica" HBP1

"Pseudomonas azelaica" HBP1 degrades 2-hydroxybiphenyl (2-HBP) and 2,2'-diHBP by employing a meta-cleavage pathway encoded by the hbpCAD genes. The regulatory gene hbpR, located directly upstream of the hbpCAD genes and oriented in the opposite direction, encodes a transcription activator protein belonging to the so-called XylR/DmpR subclass within the NtrC family. HbpR activates transcription from two separate sigma(54)-dependent promoters upstream of the hbpC and the hbpD genes, in the presence of the pathway substrates 2-HBP and 2,2'-diHBP. The DNA region upstream of the hbpC gene displays an unusual organization, containing two adjacent 0.3 kb regions that share 71% sequence identity. The DNA region most proximal to the hbpC promoter harbours one pair of putative upstream activating sequences (UASs C-1/C-2) and a small cryptic ORF that shows homology to hbpR itself. The second, more distal, region contains a second pair of putative UASs (UASs C-3/4) and the 5'-part of the hbpR gene. Transcriptional fusions in Escherichia coli between different deletions of the hbpR-hbpC intergenic region and the genes for bacterial luciferase revealed that most if not all of the transcriptional output from the hbpC promoter is mediated from the proximal UASs C-1/C-2. However, when the UASs C-1/C-2 were deleted and UASs C-3/C-4 were placed in an appropriate position with respect to the promoter region, the hbpC promoter was still inducible with 2-HBP, albeit at a lower level. Transcription studies in E. coli and "P. azelaica" revealed that the divergently oriented hbpR gene is expressed constitutively from a sigma(70)-dependent promoter situated within the cryptic ORF. The presence of UAS pair C-3/C-4 mediated a slightly higher promoter activity for transcription of hbpR.

Compilation and analysis of sigma(54)-dependent promoter sequences

Promoters recognized by the RNA-polymerase with the alternative sigma factor sigma(54) (Esigma54) are unique in having conserved positions around -24 and -12 nucleotides upstream from the transcriptional start site, instead of the typical -35 and -10 boxes. Here we compile 186 -24/-12 promoter sequences reported in the literature and generate an updated and extended consensus sequence. The use of the extended consensus increases the probability of identifying genuine -24/-12 promoters. The effect of several reported mutations at the -24/-12 elements on RNA-polymerase binding and promoter strength is discussed in the light of the updated consensus.

Involvement of the FtsH (HflB) protease in the activity of sigma 54 promoters

The effect of FtsH, an essential inner membrane-bound protease, in the regulation of the sigma 54-dependent Pu promoter has been examined in vivo. Escherichia coli cells lacking FtsH failed to activate a Pu-lacZ fusion in response to the cognate enhancer-binding protein XylR. However, the intracellular concentrations of XylR and sigma 54, as well as their apparent physical integrity were the same regardless of the presence or absence of the protease. The loss of Pu activity in FtsH-minus cells was not due to the imbalance between sigma factors caused by the lack of the protease. ftsH mutants could not grow in media with glutamine as the only nitrogen source and failed also to induce the sigma 54 promoters PnifH by NifA and PpspA by PspF. These lesions were fully complemented by a ftsH+ plasmid. Therefore, part of the pleiotropic phenotype of FtsH-less cells corresponded to the lack of sigma 54 activity. Overproduction of sigma 54, however, restored both transcriptional activity of Pu and growth in glutamine of a ftsH strain. These observations suggested that the activity of sigma 54 is checked in vivo by an interplay of factors that ultimately determine the performance of cognate promoters under given physiological conditions.

Regulation of the carnitine pathway in Escherichia coli: investigation of the cai-fix divergent promoter region

The divergent structural operons caiTABCDE and fixABCX of Escherichia coli are required for anaerobic carnitine metabolism. Transcriptional monocopy lacZ fusion studies showed that both operons are coexpressed during anaerobic growth in the presence of carnitine, respond to common environmental stimuli (like glucose and nitrate), and are modulated positively by the same general regulators, CRP and FNR, and negatively by H-NS. Overproduction of the CaiF specific regulatory protein mediating the carnitine signal restored induction in an fnr mutant, corresponding to its role as the primary target for anaerobiosis. Transcript analysis identified two divergent transcription start points initiating 289 bp apart. DNase I footprinting revealed three sites with various affinities for the binding of the cAMP-CRP complex inside this regulatory region. Site-directed mutagenesis experiments indicated that previously reported perfect CRP motif 1, centered at -41.5 of the cai transcriptional start site, plays a direct role in the sole cai activation. In contrast, mutation in CRP site 2, positioned at -69.5 of the fix promoter, caused only a threefold reduction in fix expression. Thus, the role of the third CRP site, located at -126.5 of fix, might be to reinforce the action of site 2. A critical 50-bp cis-acting sequence overlapping the fix mRNA start site was found, by deletion analysis, to be necessary for cai transcription. This region is thought to be involved in transduction of the signal mediated by the CaiF regulator.

Activation of the toluene-responsive regulator XylR causes a transcriptional switch between sigma54 and sigma70 promoters at the divergent Pr/Ps region of the TOL plasmid

The mechanism by which XylR, the toluene-responsive activator of the sigma54-dependent Pu and Ps promoters of the Pseudomonas TOL plasmid pWW0, downregulates its own sigma70 promoter Prhas been examined. An in vitro transcription system was developed in order to reproduce the repression of Probserved in cells of P. putida (pWW0) both in the presence and in the absence of the XylR inducer, benzyl alcohol. DNA templates bearing the two sigma70-RNA polymerase (RNAP) binding sites of Pr, which overlap the upstream activating sequences (UAS) for XylR in the divergent sigma54 promoter Ps, were transcribed in the presence of a constitutively active XylR variant deleted of its N-terminal domain (XylRdeltaA). The addition of ATP, known to trigger multimerization of the regulator at the UAS, enhanced the repression of Pr by XylR. Furthermore, we observed activation of the divergent sigma54 promoter Ps during Pr downregulation by XylRdeltaA. These results support the notion that activation of XylR by aromatic inducers in vivo triggers a transcriptional switch between Pr and Ps. Such a switch is apparently caused by the ATP-dependent multimerization and strong DNA binding of the protein required for activation of the sigma54 promoter. This device could reset the level of XylR expression during activation of the sigma54 Pu and Ps promoters of the TOL plasmid.