The case against universal WBC reduction (and for the practice of evidence-based medicine)

Role of Leukoreduction of Packed Red Blood Cell Units in Trauma Patients: A Review

Hemorrhagic shock is a leading cause of mortality within the trauma population, and blood transfusion is the standard of care. Leukoreduction filters remove donor leukocytes prior to transfusion of blood products. While the benefits of leukocyte depletion are well documented in scientific literature, these benefits do not translate directly to the clinical setting. This review summarizes current research regarding leukoreduction in the clinical arena, as well as studies performed exclusively in the trauma population.

Effect of red cell transfusions on future kidney transplantation

Red cell transfusions, erythropoiesis-stimulating agents (ESAs), and intravenous iron therapy all have a place in the treatment of anemia associated with CKD. Their relative merits and uses are subject to many clinical and nonclinical factors. New concerns associated with the use of ESA therapy make it likely that the use of blood transfusions will increase, refueling previous debates about their associated risks. Data on whether red cell transfusions increase sensitization to HLA antigens, rendering subsequent transplantation more problematic, are mainly derived from older literature. Older data suggested that women were more at risk of HLA sensitization than men, particularly those with previous multiple pregnancies, although recent U.S. Renal Data System data have challenged this. HLA sensitization prolongs the waiting time for transplantation and reduces graft survival. Leukocyte depletion of red cells does not appear to reduce the risk of HLA sensitization. This review summarizes much of the data on these issues, as well as highlighting the need for further research on the potential risks for blood transfusion in patients with CKD.

Variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease and the Canadian blood system after the tainted blood tragedy

The transfusion transmission of hepatitis C and HIV to thousands of Canadian blood recipients was one of this country's largest public health catastrophes. In response to this crisis, and in an effort to prevent such a tragedy from occurring again, the Canadian blood system has undergone substantial reform. Variant Creutzfeldt–Jakob (vCJD) disease was the first infectious threat faced by the blood system since undergoing reform. The response at the time to this risk provides insights into the Canadian blood system's new approach to infectious threats. Our analysis of the decision-making concerning vCJD identifies two dominant themes characterizing the new blood system's approach to safety:(1)

the adoption of a precautionary approach to new risks which involves taking action in advance of definitive evidence, and

(2)

risk aversion amongst policy makers, which has contributed to the adoption of safety measures with comparatively high cost-effectiveness ratios.

Overall the principles governing the new blood system have contributed to the system both providing protection against emerging infectious risks and regaining the confidence of the public and recipients. However, the current set of policy factors will likely contribute to increasingly risk-averse policy making that will contribute to continued increases in the cost of the blood system. The challenge the blood system now faces is to find the appropriate balance between maximizing safety and ensuring the system remains affordable.

Chemokine receptors expressed on T cells in packed red blood cell units change over storage time

The transfusion of blood products is associated with adverse events that are related to the leukocytes in stored units of blood. These leukocytes have been shown to promote the elaboration of inflammatory cytokines. However, the status of a set of key inflammatory mediators, chemokine receptors, expressed on T lymphocytes in stored red blood cell (RBC) units is largely unknown. We investigated the expression pattern of selected chemokine receptors on T cells from non-leukocyte-reduced RBC units over storage time. Selecting segments from stored RBC units, we evaluated the T-cell subsets for the chemokine receptors CXCR3 and CCR4 by flow cytometry. Statistical analysis was performed by regression analysis. We analysed 30 samples stored between 5 and 38 days. The CD4+ T cells expressing CXCR3 increased by 0.27% daily (P= 0.02), whereas the expression of CCR4 declined by 0.40% daily (P < 0.001). Though the expression of the chemokine receptors on CD8+ cells followed the same trend, the changes were statistically nonsignificant. This study suggests that a longer duration of storage is associated with a higher expression of chemokine receptor CXCR3 and a lower expression of CCR4 on T cells in RBC units, suggesting a pro-inflammatory Th1 bias. The clinical significance of these changes in the setting of adverse transfusion events needs further evaluation.

Strengthening the service continuum between transfusion providers and suppliers: enhancing the blood services network

As the cost of health care increases, the focus on cost containment grows. The pressure to reduce costs comes at the same time the public focus is on ensuring a zero-risk blood supply. The blood supply has never been safer or more expensive. With the relative vanquishing of transfusion-transmitted diseases, noninfectious risks now exceed infectious risks. This has resulted in a call to refocus blood safety efforts on interconnected processes that link a unit of blood from its volunteer blood donor to the patient. Additional costs in the blood supply chain will create new pressures on an already taxed system that gets little additional reimbursement with each new safety initiative. Opposing interests have created a tenuous relationship between the blood supplier and the transfusion provider. This adversarial relationship does not benefit the ultimate stakeholder, the patient. It is time to create a service partnership that is built on access, cost, and quality. Initiatives must be undertaken at a local, regional, and national level. Locally, blood suppliers and transfusion providers must reevaluate policies that are focused on individual gain and reinvent policies that will reward improvements in the overall system and expand cooperative services. Regionally, both blood suppliers and transfusion providers need to consolidate services to gain cost and quality benefits without compromising the competitive nature of the industry. Nationally, the creation of a strategic plan will help ensure that a mutually beneficial relationship focused on the patient is created between the blood supplier and transfusion provider at all levels. Development of such a plan would benefit the transfusing and supplying parties by identifying areas of common interest and how each may facilitate the achievement of shared benefits.

Prestorage leukoreduction and low-temperature filtration reduce hemolysis of stored red cell concentrates

BACKGROUND

Universal prestorage leukoreduction in Canada created the perception that stored red cells (RBCs) are more hemolyzed than their unfiltered predecessors. A pool-split design tested the effects of leukoreduction on hemolysis of stored RBCs.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Two ABO-matched units were pooled, divided, and then processed into leukoreduced (LR) and nonleukoreduced (NLR) units with the Pall LT-WB or RC-PL systems and sampled during standard processing and storage for testing of sterility, counts, hemolysis, and osmotic fragility.

RESULTS

Room temperature (RT) filtration of 10 pairs of LT-WB-LR and -NLR units showed significantly different percentage of hemolysis (0.39%) and osmotic fragility (0.643%) at 42 days. Cold-stored and -filtered units (2 days at 4 degrees C before processing) were less hemolyzed, but showed a similar proportional decrease of hemolysis in LR units (0.13% vs. 0.25% at 42 days). RBCs from RC-PL systems showed the lowest hemolysis although there was a filtration effect (0.05% vs. 0.12%, 42 days). Osmotic fragility paralleled hemolysis. Segment samples gave inaccurate results. Two-day prefiltration cold storage reduced hemolysis from 0.36 to 0.07 percent (42 days, p < 0.001). RT-LR hemolysis became significantly higher by Day 10 and 4 degrees C LR by Day 12. NLR units showed hemolysis by Day 7. LR units filtered cold were less hemolyzed (p < 0.05) than RT-LR but osmotic fragility was unchanged.

CONCLUSIONS

LR-RBCs prepared by any of three methods (LT-WB, RT or cold; RC-PL), filtered at 4 degrees C, were less hemolyzed during storage than nonfiltered concentrates: 4 degrees C leukoreduction is beneficial for RBCs and does not cause hemolysis or enhance fragility.

Universal leukoreduction decreases the incidence of febrile nonhemolytic transfusion reactions to RBCs

BACKGROUND

Febrile nonhemolytic transfusion reactions (FNHTR) is a relatively common complication associated with allogeneic transfusion. Because WBCs have been implicated in the mechanism of FNHTRs, it has been proposed that the transfusion of leukoreduced RBCs should be associated with a decreased incidence of FNHTRs. These reactions are generally not life threatening, but they are expensive in their management, evaluation, and associated blood-product wastage. Over the past several years, the proportion of leukoreduced RBCs has increased at Johns Hopkins Hospital in an effort to move toward complete leuko-reduction. A retrospective analysis is reported here of FNHTRs in RBC recipients as the inventory increased in percentage of leukoreduced RBC units.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Between July 1994 and December 2001, all transfusion reactions (TRs) associated with the transfusion of allogeneic RBCs were retrospectively analyzed. Both computerized data and individual TR reports were reviewed. Patients who had both allergic and febrile features were included as part of both categories. TRs were reported as a percentage of total units transfused. Two time periods were selected for direct comparison. July to December 1994 represents the time period before the initiation of an increase in leuko-reduction. July to December 2001 represents a time period when almost complete leukoreduction (99.5%) had been achieved. The TR data were compared between these two time periods, comparing a time before leuko-reduction to a time period after leukoreduction had been achieved. The trends in TRs over the entire 7.5-year period of July 1994 to December 2001 were also assessed.

RESULTS

In the initial period before the initiative to move toward leukoreduction, 96 percent of our RBC inventory was non-leukoreduced. In the study period after leukoreduction, 99.5 percent of our RBC inventory was leukoreduced. When comparing these two time periods, the incidence of FNHTRs decreased from 0.37 percent to 0.19 percent (p = 0.0008). The trend over the entire 7.5-year study period confirms the decrease in FNHTRs as the percentage of leukoreduced RBCs increased. The incidence of allergic TRs has remained unchanged over this time period.

CONCLUSIONS

As our institution has increased its inventory of leukoreduced RBCs to approximately 100 percent, selective leukoreduced protocols have been discontinued. The incidence of FNHTRs has decreased significantly and the rate of allergic reactions has essentially remained unchanged. Leukoreduction is effective in decreasing FNHTRs associated with the transfusion of allogeneic RBCs.

Universal prestorage leukoreduction in Canada decreases platelet alloimmunization and refractoriness

Randomized controlled trials have shown a reduction in platelet alloimmunization and refractoriness in patients with acute leukemia (AL) with the use of poststorage leukoreduction of blood products. Universal prestorage leukoreduction (ULR) of red cell and platelet products has been performed in Canada since August 1999. We conducted a retrospective analysis of 13 902 platelet transfusions in 617 patients undergoing chemotherapy (CT) for AL or stem cell transplantation (SCT) before (n = 315) and after (n = 302) the introduction of ULR. Alloimmunization was significantly reduced (19% to 7%, P <.001) in the post-ULR group. Alloimmune platelet refractoriness was similarly reduced (14% to 4%, P <.001). Fewer patients in the post-ULR group received HLA-matched platelets (14% vs 5%, P <.001). Alloimmunization and alloimmune refractoriness in the 318 patients who were previously pregnant and/or transfused were also reduced after ULR (P =.023 and P =.005, respectively). In a Cox regression model, the 3 independent factors that predicted for alloimmune refractoriness were nonleukoreduced blood products (relative risk [RR], 2.2 [95% CI, 1.2-4.3]), a history of pregnancy and/or transfusion (RR, 2.3 [95% CI, 1.3-4.2]), and receipt of 13 or more platelet transfusions (RR, 6.0 [95% CI, 2.4-15.3]). In conclusion, ULR reduces alloimmunization, refractoriness, and requirements for HLA-matched platelets when applied as routine transfusion practice to patients receiving CT or SCT.

Risks of blood transfusion

OBJECTIVE

To review the current status of risks of blood transfusion.

DATA SOURCES, EXTRACTIONS, AND SYNTHESIS

English-speaking literature, literature search using key works, human data, and follow-up with key bibliographic citations.

CONCLUSIONS

Substantial advances have been achieved in blood safety during the last 20 yrs, particularly for transfusion-transmitted viral infections. Currently, the most serious known risks from blood transfusion are administrative error (leading to ABO-incompatible blood transfusion), transfusion-related acute lung injury, and bacterial contamination in platelet products. Emerging pathogens, such as West Nile virus infection emphasize the need for implementation of proactive strategies, such as pathogen inactivation technologies, as well as reactive strategies, such as nucleic acid testing, to ensure continued advances in blood safety.

Prophylactic platelet transfusions: which dose is the best dose? A review of the literature

Routine platelet transfusions for patients with acute leukemia were introduced in the early 1960s, and since then platelet use has increased steadily. Despite widespread use, good clinical evidence supporting prophylactic platelet transfusions is limited, and there are very few studies that have examined the dose for prophylactic platelet transfusions. Review of the platelet dose used in both early studies of routine platelet transfusions and more recent clinical trials of platelet transfusions shows wide variation in dosing, which is also reflected in clinical practice. As such, only limited recommendations for platelet dose have been forthcoming from consensus conferences or guidelines. The results from 3 recent clinical trials and a mathematical model examining the dose for prophylactic platelet transfusions suggest that lower dose transfusions may decrease the total number of platelets transfused; however, no definitive conclusions about the optimal platelet dose can be reached as these trials were not designed to evaluate bleeding outcomes or total platelet utilization. Future large clinical trials of platelet dose, which examine these critical outcomes, are required. Only with these results can the optimal platelet dose be determined.

Inline-filtration

BACKGROUND

Routine leukocyte-depletion (LD) of cellular blood products, and even plasma, is currently being implemented in most European countries, as a result of the fear that the variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob-disease (vCJD) might be transmissible by transfusion. However, not only is the scientific evidence supporting such a notion scarce, but the benefits of applying this procedure to all patients also remain unfounded.

METHODS

A MEDLINE-research for studies dealing with the indications for LD was performed. In addition, the guidelines and recommendations of national and international health authorities were scrutinized.

RESULTS

To date,the only proven benefit of LD that can be applied to all patients is the reduction of non-hemolytic febrile transfusion reactions. In addition, LD reduces HLA-immunization and platelet refractoriness in multi-transfused patients. In immunocompromized patients, LD reduces transfusion-transmitted CMV-disease. Furthermore, a minority of 5-10% of transfusion-related-acute-lung-injury cases can be prevented by LD. However, the potential of reducing the immunomodulating effects of transfusion such as postoperative infection, cancer-recurrence-related or overall mortality and of reducing septicemia due to bacterial contamination is still at issue. AIDS patients do not benefit from LD, at least. The suitability of LD for preventing the transmission of vCJD is at best hypothetical. Potential risks of LD like increased leakages have not been taken into account adequately to date.

CONCLUSIONS

At present, the scientific evidence does not justify the introduction of LD as a routine measure. In times of limited health care resources, this costly procedure might limit access to medical services with proven effectiveness and efficiency. In addition, the loss of 5-10% of the red cell pool is predicted to lead to more blood supply shortages than previously seen.

Erythropoietin therapy versus red cell transfusion

Erythropoietin therapy was approved for use as a blood conservation intervention beginning in 1989 for patients with medical anemia and in 1997 for surgical patients. The adoption of this strategy has been rapid in some settings (such as renal failure patients), progressive in others ( eg, cancer patients), and slow in others (surgery patients, for instance). At the same time, the risks of blood transfusion have declined substantially whereas the costs of blood transfusion have increased significantly. The evolution of new techniques such as acute normovolemic hemodilution (ANH) and the novel erythropoiesis-stimulating protein (NESP) bring new options to allogeneic blood transfusion. Erythropoietin therapy, with or without autologous blood procurement, is undergoing new scrutiny as an alternative to blood transfusion. This is not only because of traditional concerns regarding blood risks but because of new blood inventory and cost considerations.

Blood transfusion: the silent epidemic

Blood transfusion has been widely studied and the risk/benefit ratio remains unclear. Focus historically has been upon viral transmission, particularly hepatitis and HIV. Today, with advanced screening for these viruses, the risk for such transmission has become vanishingly small. Immunosuppression, with consequent postoperative bacterial infection and ABO incompatibility are now risks that physicians should consider as associated with allogeneic blood transfusion. Other inflammatory events, such as transfusion associated acute lung injury, also occur. The benefits of transfusion have never been well studied and there is scant literature on that area. Therefore, in an evidence-based medical practice the physician should regard transfusion with a skewed risk/benefit ratio. The following article examines that risk/benefit ratio in the post-AIDS era.

Prestorage universal WBC reduction of RBC units does not affect the incidence of transfusion reactions

BACKGROUND

Febrile nonhemolytic transfusion reaction (FNHTR) has been identified as a pivotal reason for prestorage universal WBC reduction. A regional blood center implemented universal prestorage WBC reduction for RBCs on January 1, 2000. Whether prestorage universal WBC reduction of RBC units will affect FNHTR is not known.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

All reports of RBC transfusion reactions at Barnes-Jewish Hospital submitted for evaluation to the blood bank, before and after the implementation of WBC reduction of RBCs, were retrospectively evaluated.

RESULTS

For the 36,303 allogeneic RBC transfusions administered in 1999, 85 reactions (0.23%) were reported. These reactions were classified as FNHTR in 43 cases, allergic in 13, delayed hemolytic in 19, and miscellaneous in 10. For the 31,543 non-WBC-reduced RBC transfusions performed in 1999, 78 reactions (0.25%) were reported. These reactions were classified as FNHTR in 39 cases, allergic in 13, delayed hemolytic in 19, and miscellaneous in 7. In the first half of 2000, 32 reactions (0.20%) were reported for 16,093 prestorage WBC-reduced RBC transfusions (p = 0.41). There were 13 FNHTRs and 10 allergic, 7 delayed hemolytic, and 2 miscellaneous reactions. The use of prestorage WBC-reduced RBCs did not significantly affect the rate of reactions classified as allergic (0.04% in 1999; 0.06% in 2000; p = 0.43) or as FNHTR (0.12% in 1999; 0.08% in 2000; p = 0.33). For all patients, universal WBC reduction in 2000 did not reduce the rate of FNHTR from the rate seen with selective bedside WBC reduction, the practice used in 1999 (0.12% in 1999; 0.08% in 2000; p = 0.36).

CONCLUSION

No significant difference was found in the incidence of transfusion reactions in patients receiving prestorage WBC-reduced RBCs and non-WBC-reduced RBCs. In addition, no difference was found in transfusion reaction rates when periods of prestorage universal WBC reduction were compared to those of selective WBC reduction.

Transfusion medicine : support of patients undergoing cardiac surgery

There is still no alternative that is as effective or as well tolerated as blood; nevertheless, the search for ways to conserve, and even eliminate blood transfusion, continues. Based on hemoglobin levels, practice guidelines for the use of perioperative transfusion of red blood cells in patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting have been formulated by the National Institutes of Health and the American Society of Anesthesiologists. However, it has been argued that more physiologic indicators of adequacy of oxygen delivery should be used to assess the need for blood transfusion. Methods used for conserving blood during surgery include autologous blood donation, acute normovolemic hemodilution and intra- and postoperative blood recovery and reinfusion. The guidelines for the use of autologous blood transfusion are controversial and it does not appear to be cost effective compared with allogeneic blood transfusion in patients undergoing cardiac surgery. Similarly, the cost effectiveness of intra- and postoperative blood recovery and reinfusion need further evaluation. Treatment with recombinant human erythropoietin (rhEPO) remains unapproved in the US for patients undergoing cardiac or vascular surgery, but it is a valuable adjunct in Jehovah's Witness patients, for whom blood is unacceptable. The characterization of darbepoetin alfa, a novel erythropoiesis stimulating protein with a 3-fold greater plasma elimination half-life compared with rhEPO, is an important advance in this field. Darbepoetin alfa appears to be effective in treating the anemia in patients with renal failure or cancer and trials in patients with surgical anemia are planned. Desmopressin has been used to effectively reduce intraoperative blood loss. Topical agents to prevent blood loss, such as fibrin glue and fibrin gel, and agents that alter platelet function, such as aspirin (acetylsalicylic acid) or dipyridamole, need further evaluation in patients undergoing cardiac surgery. Aprotinin has been shown to preserve hemostasis and reduce allogeneic blood exposure to a greater extent than the antifibrinolytic agents tranexamic acid and aminocaproic acid. Controlled clinical trials comparing the costs of these agents with clinical outcomes, along with tolerability profiles in patients at risk for substantial perioperative bleeding are needed.