Critical Appraisal of Indices for the Assessment of Baroreflex Sensitivity

Central sleep apnea is associated with blunted baroreflex sensitivity in patients with myocardial infarction

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to investigate the association of central sleep apnea (CSA) and baroreflex sensitivity (BRS) after acute myocardial infarction.

BACKGROUND

Both, CSA and blunted BRS have been shown to be independent predictors for cardiovascular mortality in patients with heart failure. But in contrast to BRS, which has been extensively studied in the setting of AMI, the incidence of CSA in patients recovering from AMI is thus far unknown. As previous reports suggested a potential role of sleep apnoea in augmenting reflex autonomic modulation, we hypothesized that there is a strong interrelation between CSA and BRS.

METHODS

Seventeen male patients in the subacute phase of a first uncomplicated ST-segment elevation AMI and eight healthy male controls without evidence of coronary artery disease underwent polysomnography with simultaneous beat-to-beat ECG- and blood-pressure recordings. Sleep stage specific spontaneous BRS was calculated from blood pressure and RR-interval fluctuations by using the time domain sequential technique.

RESULTS

AMI patients revealed to have a higher incidence and longer duration of central apnoeas in all sleep stages, light sleep, deep sleep and dream sleep. There were no significant sleep stage specific differences regarding BRS between groups, however, AMI patients with central sleep apnea exhibited blunted BRS which was inversely correlated to incidences of central apnea in all sleep stages.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings suggest a direct relationship between impaired BRS and repetitive occurrence of CSA by inverse correlation in all sleep stages in the subacute phase of AMI. Thus, reflex cardiac autonomic nervous control, being represented by the BRS, may be the link between CSA and prognosis.

Probing the arterial baroreflex: is there a ‘spontaneous’ baroreflex?

The arterial baroreflex is important for beat-to-beat arterial pressure control and its sensitivity has predictive value for clinical outcomes in a myriad of cardiovascular conditions. Given this, researchers have sought approaches for baroreflex assessment that are not invasive and easily obtained. These techniques have exploited the beat-by-beat parallel changes in arterial pressure and heart period to produce estimates that have been termed 'spontaneous' baroreflex indices. The two most commonly used analyses--frequency domain or spectral analyses and sequence analysis have been evaluated in both animals and humans. The animal data suggests an important baroreflex role in linking spontaneous heart period and pressure variabilities, but do not resolve the extent to which these fluctuations reflect baroreflex gain. The human data suggest a high correlation between spontaneous indices and pharmacologically derived baroreflex gain, but also indicate a poor correspondence between them. This may be due to the fact that short-term fluctuations in RR interval are not intimately and always linked to those in pressure via the baroreflex and thus simple observation of arterial pressure and heart period alone may not reveal the extent of arterial baroreflex involvement. If baroreflex function is to be assessed with the fewest and safest assumptions, the input to the system should be driven externally to create large and apparent responses. Nonetheless, spontaneous baroreflex indices may have predictive power; although it remains unknown whether spontaneous indices provide predictive power beyond that provided by heart rate variability indices alone.

Baroreflex sensitivity assessment and heart rate variability: relation to maneuver and technique

In the present study, we examined two baroreflex sensitivity (BRS) issues that remain uncertain: the differences among diverse BRS assessment techniques and the association between BRS and vagal outflow. Accordingly, the electrocardiogram and non-invasive arterial pressure were recorded in 27 healthy subjects, during supine with and without controlled breathing, standing, exercise, and recovery conditions. Vagal outflow was estimated by heart rate variability indexes, whereas BRS was computed by alpha-coefficient, transfer function, complex demodulation in low- and high-frequency bands, and by sequence technique. Our results indicated that only supine maneuvers showed significantly greater BRS values over the high frequency than in the low-frequency band. For maneuvers at the same frequency region, supine conditions presented a larger number of significant differences among techniques. The plots between BRS and vagal measures depicted a funnel-shaped relationship with significant log-log correlations (r=0.880-0.958). Very short latencies between systolic pressure and RR interval series in high-frequency band and strong log-log correlations between frequency bands were found. Higher variability among different baroreflex measurements was associated with higher level of vagal outflow. Methodological assumptions for each technique seem affected by non-baroreflex variation sources, and a modified responsiveness of vagal motoneurons due to distinct stimulation levels for each maneuver was suggested. Thus, highest vagal outflows corresponded to greatest BRS values, with maximum respiratory effect for the high-frequency band values. In conclusion, BRS values and differences across the tested techniques were strongly related to the vagal outflow induced by the maneuvers.

Autonomic nervous system activity in normotensive subjects with a family history of hypertension

This study was designed to address alterations in autonomic nervous system activity in normotensive subjects with a family history of hypertension. We compared the autonomic nervous system activity in 59 normotensives with a family history of hypertension and 46 normotensives with no family history of hypertension. Skin blood flow was measured using laser-Doppler method on the nailfold skin in the resting condition, during systemic cooling and during upright tilting. Finger blood pressure, pulse and ECG were monitored by a finapres device. Heart rate, systolic pressure and microvascular flow power spectral analyses were performed using fast Fourier transformation. Baroreflex sensitivity was estimated with the sequence method. Compared to the control group, normotensives with a family history of hypertension showed significantly higher systolic pressure, decreased proportion and area of the high-frequency band of the heart rate variability power spectrum and reduced baroreflex sensitivity in the resting condition as well as a decreased proportion and area of the high-frequency band of the heart rate variability power spectrum during systemic cooling. We also proved a different time course of baroreflex sensitivity during upright tilting in the two groups. In contrast, we did not find any significant differences in the parameters of systolic pressure and microvascular variability power spectra between the two groups. Our results indicate that even normotensives with a family history of hypertension exhibit an increased ratio of sympathetic to parasympathetic activity at the cardiac level; however, they do not show any alteration of the vascular sympathetic reactivity.

Human autonomic responses to blood donation

In order to characterize autonomic responses to acute volume loss, supine ECG, blood pressure (BP) and uncalibrated breathing signal (UBS) recordings were taken before and after blood donation in 48 healthy volunteers. Time and frequency domain parameters of RR interval (RRI), BP and UBS variability were determined. Baroreflex gain was calculated by the technique of the spontaneous sequences and cross-spectral analysis. The systolic (SAP), diastolic (DAP) and mean BP (MAP) increased after the blood withdrawal. The central frequency of breathing and mean heart rate did not change. RRI variability increased in low frequency band (LF), tended to decrease in high frequency band (HF). Systolic BP variability increased in both frequency bands, but was statistically significant only in the high frequency band. Diastolic BP power increased in both frequencies. From the different baroreflex gain estimates, up sequence BRS and HF alpha index decreased significantly. The phase angle between RRI and systolic blood pressure powers in LF band did not change (-58 +/- 24 degrees and -54 +/- 26 degrees ). In the high frequency range, the phase became more negative (-1 +/- 29 degrees and -17 +/- 32 degrees, p = 0.001). The withdrawal of 350-400 ml blood in 5 min resulted in sympathetic activation, which was reflected in increased systolic, diastolic and mean BP. The increased BP oscillation was a sensitive marker of the minor volume depletion. This was coupled by increased RRI oscillation via baroreflex mechanisms in the LF band. Changes in the RRI and BP oscillations in the HF band showed no similar coupling. That points to the fact that RRI oscillations in this band should not be explained entirely by baroreflex mechanisms. Vagal withdrawal was reflected in decreased root mean square of successive differences (RMSSD), decreased HF RRI power and decreased up sequence BRS.

Spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity in children and young adults calculated in the time and frequency domain

Spontaneous baroreflex receptor sensitivity (BRS) was calculated in 22 healthy normotensive children and young adults (age 14 +/- 5 years) using the sequence technique (time domain) and the alpha-coefficient or the gain of the transfer function between coherent oscillations (frequency domain). BRS estimated by the sequence technique (median: 16.7 ms/mm Hg) was significantly higher than BRS calculated from the gain of the transfer function using all frequencies (median: 13.0 ms/mm Hg; p = 0.009). However, there was a high correlation between these methods (r = 0.92). The reproducibility coefficient (RC) was high for all methods, but the coefficient of variability (VC) was best for the sequence technique and the gain of the transfer function, but significantly worse for the estimates of the alpha-coefficient in the low or high frequency band. The differentiation between increasing or decreasing blood pressure (BP) ramps did not give further information showing the same BRS values. The best BRS estimates will be achieved by using three consecutive beats without lag by the sequence technique and by using only frequencies with a proven correlation of BP and pulse interval (PI) and then calculating the gain of the transfer function using coherent oscillations.

A model for the genesis of arterial pressure Mayer waves from heart rate and sympathetic activity

Both theoretic models and cross-spectral analyses suggest that an oscillating sympathetic nervous outflow generates the low-frequency arterial pressure fluctuations termed Mayer waves. Fluctuations in heart rate also have been suggested to relate closely to Mayer waves, but empiric models have not assessed the joint causative influences of heart rate and sympathetic activity. Therefore, we constructed a model based simply upon the hemodynamic equation derived from Ohm's Law. With this model, we determined time relations and relative contributions of heart rate and sympathetic activity to the genesis of arterial pressure Mayer waves. We assessed data from eight healthy young volunteers in the basal state and in a high sympathetic state known to produce concurrent increases in sympathetic nervous outflow and Mayer wave amplitude. We fit the Mayer waves (0.05-0.20 Hz) in mean arterial pressure by the weighted sum of leading oscillations in heart rate and sympathetic nerve activity. This model of our data showed heart rate oscillations leading by 2-3.75 s were responsible for almost half of the variance in arterial pressure (basal R2 = 0.435 +/- 0.140, high sympathetic R2= 0.438 +/- 0.180). Surprisingly, sympathetic activity (lead 0-5 s) contributed only modestly to the explained variance in Mayer waves during either sympathetic state (basal: delta R2 = 0.046 +/- 0.026; heightened: delta R2 = 0.085 +/- 0.036). Thus, it appears that heart rate oscillations contribute to Mayer waves in a simple linear fashion, whereas sympathetic fluctuations contribute little to Mayer waves in this way. Although these results do not exclude an important vascular sympathetic role, they do suggest that additional factors, such as sympathetic transduction into vascular resistance, modulate its influence.

Dynamic modulation of baroreflex sensitivity in health and disease

Assessment of arterial baroreflex function in humans through laboratory tests has provided a great deal of information of pathophysiological and clinical relevance. Indeed, the sensitivity of the baroreceptor-heart rate reflex quantified through these laboratory methods was shown to predict the risk of cardiovascular events and death from myocardial infarction, heart failure, and in diabetic patients. This traditional approach, however, does not provide information on daily life baroreflex cardiovascular control. Modern techniques, based on computer analysis of spontaneous blood pressure and heart rate fluctuations, are now available and allow baroreflex sensitivity to be assessed under real-life conditions with no need for external stimulation. In particular, these methods offer the possibility of investigating the dynamic modulation of baroreflex sensitivity occurring either on a minute-to-minute basis or over 24 hours.

Physiological basis for human autonomic rhythms

Oscillations of arterial pressures, heart periods, and muscle sympathetic nerve activity have been studied intensively in recent years to explore otherwise obscure human neurophysiological mechanisms. The best-studied rhythms are those occurring at breathing frequencies. Published evidence indicates that respiratory fluctuations of muscle sympathetic nerve activity and electrocardiographic R-R intervals result primarily from the action of a central 'gate' that opens during expiration and closes during inspiration. Parallel respiratory fluctuations of arterial pressures and R-R intervals are thought to be secondary to arterial baroreflex physiology: changes in systolic pressure provoke changes in the R-R interval. However, growing evidence suggests that these parallel oscillations result from the influence of respiration on sympathetic and vagal-cardiac motoneurones rather than from baroreflex physiology. There is a rapidly growing literature on the use of mathematical models of low- and high-frequency (respiratory) R-R interval fluctuations in characterizing instantaneous 'sympathovagal balance'. The case for this approach is based primarily on measurements made with patients in upright tilt. However, the strong linear relation between such measures as the ratio of low- to high-frequency R-R interval oscillations and the angle of the tilt reflects exclusively the reductions of the vagal (high-frequency) component. As the sympathetic component does not change in tilt, the low- to high-frequency R-R interval ratio provides no proof that sympathetic activity increases. Moreover, the validity of extrapolating from measurements performed during upright tilt to measurements during supine rest has not been established. Nonetheless, it is clear that measures of heart rate variability provide important prognostic information in patients with cardiovascular diseases. It is not known whether reduced heart rate variability is merely a marker for the severity of disease or a measurement that identifies functional reflex abnormalities contributing to terminal dysrhythmias.