[Color vision in relation to age: a study of normal values]

Evaluation of colour vision impairment during acute hypobaric hypoxia in aviation medicine: a randomized controlled trial

The digitization of aircraft cockpits places high demands on the colour vision of pilots. The present study investigates colour vision changes upon acute exposure to hypobaric hypoxia. The digital Waggoner Computerized Color Vision Test and the Waggoner D-15 were performed by 54 healthy volunteers in a decompression chamber. Respective altitude levels were sea level, 10,000 or 15,000 ft for exposure periods of 15 and 60 min, respectively. As for 60 min of exposure a significant decrease in colour perception was found between subjects at 15,000 ft as compared to the control group as well as between subjects at 15,000 ft as compared to subjects at 10,000 ft. No significant difference was found in the comparison within the 15,000 ft groups across time points pre-, peri-, and post-exposure. Thus, pilots appear to experience only minor colour vision impairment up to an exposure altitude of 15,000 ft over 60 min of exposure.

Evaluation of visual evoked potentials in dysthyroid optic neuropathy

PURPOSE

To evaluate the findings of visual evoked potentials (VEP) in patients with dysthyroid optic neuropathy (DON).

METHODS

In this observational, cross-sectional study 40 eyes (22 patients) with a diagnosis of DON were included.

RESULTS

We discovered that in 16 out of 37 eyes with pattern-VEP (p-VEP), the latency of P100 wave was normal in spite of having a diagnosis of DON. The same pattern was also observed in the measurement of the amplitude of P100 wave: in 28 out of 37 eyes with p-VEP the amplitudes were observed as normal. In 3 eyes of 3 patients p-VEP showed no response, therefore a flash-VEP (f-VEP) was performed. Flash-VEPs of those patients indicated a prolonged P100 latency with a reduced amplitude. The sensitivity of abnormal P100 latency was 56.8% (95%CI 39.5-72.9%); and that of reduced P100 amplitude was 24.3% (95%CI 11.8-41.2%). Also, in 40 eyes color vision test by Arden was performed. In 36 eyes (20 patients) the tritan value was pathological (based on a threshold of ≥8%).

CONCLUSION

According our data, VEP seems to have a limited potential especially in patients with a good best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA ≤0.2 LogMAR) for identifying the optic nerve involvement. The fact that P100 latency and amplitude were normal even in cases with an optic nerve swelling makes us question the usefulness of the VEP for diagnosing cases of DON in daily clinical life.

A pathological indicator for dysthyroid optic neuropathy: tritan color vision deficiency

Purpose

To investigate the sensitivity of the color vision test by Arden in patients with dysthyroid optic neuropathy (DON) to improve diagnosis.

Methods

In this observational, retrospective study, we included the medical records of 92 eyes (48 patients) with diagnosis of DON between 2008 and 2019 in order to evaluate the full spectrum of findings from the color vision test by Arden, and to determine potential importance of this test. Thirty-five patients were female, and 13 patients were male. The mean age was 58.0 years (range: 34–79) at the time of the DON diagnosis.

Results

Forty-one eyes displayed relatively good BCVA with ≤ 0.2 LogMAR. We found a protan value exceeding the threshold of ≥ 8% in 57 eyes (30 patients) at the time of the diagnosis. The sensitivity of protan was 61.9% (95% CI 51.2–71.8%), while that of tritan was a striking 98.9% (95% CI 94.1–99.9%).

We discovered one pathological sign, tritan deficiency (based on a threshold of ≥ 8%) consistently in all eyes but one at the time of the diagnosis, regardless of the visual field defects or any changes in best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA).

Conclusion

We found blue-yellow (tritan) deficiency, to be a sensitive and reliable indicator of dysthyroid optic neuropathy. We conclude that, in cases with suspected DON, a color vision test that can detect tritan deficiency is an essential tool for the adequate assessment, diagnosis, and treatment of DON.

Functional retinal outcomes in patients with prediabetes and type 2 diabetes

PURPOSE

Type 2 diabetes (T2DM) is a leading cause of visual impairment. Its precursor, prediabetes (preDM), is growing in numbers every year. While it is well known that T2DM causes changes in retinal function early in the disease process, it is likely that some of these changes emerge during the preDM stage. This study evaluates retinal function measures in patients with preDM to determine if there are differences in colour vision, contrast sensitivity (CS), and multifocal electroretinogram (mfERG) measures present before T2DM is diagnosed.

METHODS

The L'Anthony desaturated D-15 test, Mars Chart CS test, and mfERG were administered on the right eye of 43 participants; 15 controls (HbA1c ≤ 5.6%), 17 with preDM (HbA1c 5.7%-6.4%), and 11 with T2DM (either physician diagnosed or with untreated HbA1c ≥ 6.5%). HbA1c values were measured at the time of the other tests. Colour vision confusion scores (CVCS) were calculated from the D-15 using the method developed by Torok. Multivariate regression (which controlled for age differences) was used to evaluate the relationship of HbA1c and functional measures. Kruskal-Wallis tests were also used to evaluate differences between groups with post-hoc analysis.

RESULTS

CVCSs were significantly different between the three groups (p = 0.009). There was an association between higher CVCS and higher HbA1c values across all groups as well as specifically within the preDM group when controlling for age (R²  = 0.29, p = 0.01 and R²  = 0.39, p = 0.02 respectively). Multivariate regression of all of the functional tests together and HbA1c found only colour vision remained significant, indicating that the functional examination metrics may provide redundant data, with similar changes in prediabetes where colour vision may be the strongest indicator early in the process.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with prediabetes have functional changes that can be measured in the retina before the diagnosis of diabetes, with the L'Anthony D-15 colour vision test providing the strongest association with glucose dysregulation in this population. This has important implications for follow up and screening for diabetes within optometric practices. Further studies are needed to follow these patients over time to see how and when these metrics change.

Subclinical dysthyroid optic neuropathy: tritan deficiency as an early sign of dysthyroid optic neuropathy

PURPOSE

The aim of this research was to investigate the subclinical findings of dysthyroid optic neuropathy (DON) and to look for early indicators for optic nerve compression in patients with Graves' orbitopathy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In this observational, retrospective study, the medical charts of 24 patients (32 eyes) with a diagnosis of DON between 2008 and 2019 were included. Our goal was to identify potential pathological signs in patients with DON prior to the definitive diagnosis of DON.

RESULTS

We discovered that the earliest pathological sign in the subclinical cases was tritan deficiency obtained with a standardised colour vision test by Arden. In all cases but one, regardless of the visual field (VF) defects, the tritan values were pathological (based on a threshold of ≥8%) in the subclinical phase. The mean tritan value was 19.12% (range 6.9-80.8%) at the time of the subclinical phase and 32.16% (range 6.3-100.0%) at the time of the diagnosis of DON. The sensitivity of the colour vision test was 20% for protan and 96.67% for tritan in the subclinical phase. At the time of the definitive diagnosis of DON, the sensitivity of protan was 48.15% compared to 96.30% for tritan.

CONCLUSION

We found that changes in vision affecting the blue-yellow (tritan) colours resulting from the compression of optic nerve, even in affected patients with normal VF tests, are a reliable early sign of DON.

Evaluation of medical and surgical decompression in patients with dysthyroid optic neuropathy

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effectiveness of steroid-pulse therapy and three-wall orbital decompression in patients with dysthyroid optic neuropathy (DON).

METHODS

Twenty-five patients (46 eyes) with a diagnosis of DON between 2008 and 2015 were included in the study. The first group (7 patients, 16 eyes) consisted of patients with a steroid-pulse treatment only and the second group (18 patients, 30 eyes) included patients with medical and surgical decompression.

RESULTS

Twenty patients were female; five patients were male. After the diagnosis of DON, all patients were treated with steroid-pulse treatment (intravenous 500 mg prednisolon twice/week for 4 weeks, 250 mg twice/week for 2 weeks) as a first-line treatment (medical decompression). In 30 eyes (18 patients) out of 46 eyes, (25 patients) an orbital decompression was needed to preserve the optic nerve function. In those therapy-resistant cases (surgical decompression group), the orbital decompression led to statistically significant improvements in best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), protan and tritan value of the color vision (p = 0.007, p < 0.0001, p = 0.019, respectively, comparison of first visit to last visit).

CONCLUSION

According to our data, the mild cases of DON with better initial visual acuity (in our case series mean: 0.3 logMAR) seem to respond well to steroid treatment. However, therapy-resistant cases with an impaired initial BCVA (in our case series, mean: 0.6 logMAR) seem to need the surgery to preserve the optic nerve function. In conclusion, this retrospective study confirms the effectiveness of surgical decompression in therapy-resistant cases of DON.

Development of color vision discrimination during childhood: differences between Blue-Yellow, Red-Green, and achromatic thresholds

Nonvisual demands of tests affect vision test results in children. 150 children (79 females and 71 males, 5.3-12.7 years of age) were examined. Isoluminant Blue, Yellow, Red, Green, and Black and White thresholds were established with a four-alternative forced-choice and pseudo-10-bit system with adaptive staircase and gaming elements. Where Threshold=b₀+b₁*age^-1, b₁ for RG=6.26±1.90 (95% confidence limits), Achr=3.96±1.07 and BY=12.48±2.76 were significantly different. The noncolor demands of the test are the same for RG, BY, and Achr, so the later development of BY discrimination is not an artifact of the test.

Electrophysiology and colour: a comparison of methods to evaluate inner retinal function

PURPOSE

Several methods are routinely used in the clinic to diagnose and monitor diseases of inner retinal function. In this study, we compare four such methods in patients with diabetes and glaucoma, to determine correlations between their results and to determine which method is most sensitive for detecting disease.

METHODS

Twenty control subjects, 12 patients with early glaucoma and eight patients with diabetes mellitus, were enrolled in the study. All underwent four examinations: transient pattern electroretinogram (PERG), multifocal pattern electroretinogram (mfPERG), chromatic contrast threshold measurements (protan and tritan), and blue-on-yellow short-wavelength automated perimetry (SWAP).

RESULTS

For the total cohort of 40 subjects, the results show a significant correlation between the amplitudes of the PERG and those of the mfPERG, as well as between the tritan contrast thresholds and the SWAP MD. Furthermore, ROC analyses reveal that colour contrast thresholds could significantly distinguish between the patient and the control group. Glaucoma patients alone could also be distinguished.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that the methods compared in this study show correlations between their results if they are testing same pathway or underling cells, and that the colour contrast threshold is the most sensitive method to detect early functional deficits in diabetic and glaucoma patients.

Color vision and neuroretinal function in diabetes

PURPOSE

We investigate how type 2 diabetes (T2DM) and diabetic retinopathy (DR) affect color vision (CV) and mfERG implicit time (IT), whether CV and IT are correlated, and whether CV and IT abnormality classifications agree.

METHODS

Adams desaturated D-15 color test, mfERG, and fundus photographs were examined in 37 controls, 22 T2DM patients without DR (NoRet group), and 25 T2DM patients with DR (Ret group). Color confusion score (CCS) was calculated. ITs were averaged within the central 7 hexagons (central IT; ≤4.5°) and outside this area (peripheral IT; ≥4.5°). DR was within (DRIN) or outside (DROUT) of the central 7 hexagons. Group differences, percentages of abnormalities, correlations, and agreement were determined.

RESULTS

CCS was greater in the NoRet (P = 0.002) and Ret (P < 0.0001) groups than in control group. CCS was abnormal in 3, 41, and 48 % of eyes in the control, NoRet, and Ret groups, respectively. Ret group CV abnormalities were more frequent in DRIN than in DROUT subgroups (71 vs. 18 %, respectively; P < 0.0001). CCS and IT were correlated only in the Ret group, in both retinal zones (P ≤ 0.028). Only in the Ret group did CCS and peripheral IT abnormality classifications agree (72 %; P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

CV is affected in patients with T2DM, even without DR. Central DR increases the likelihood of a CV deficit compared with non-central DR. mfERG IT averaged across central or peripheral retinal locations is less frequently abnormal than CV in the absence of DR, and these two measures are correlated only when DR is present.

Detecting chloroquine retinopathy: electro-oculogram versus colour vision

AIM

To investigate the relative sensitivity and specificity of two tests of retinal function (the electro-oculogram (EOG) and a computerised colour vision test) in screening for ocular toxicity caused by chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine.

METHODS

93 patients with rheumatic diseases receiving long term chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine therapy were followed for an average of 2.6 years. Clinical examination, an EOG, and a quantitative test of colour vision were carried out every 6 months.

RESULTS

Mild fundus changes were observed in 38 patients. Four patients developed typical bull's eye maculopathy, three of whom had received 250, 365, and 550 g total dose of chloroquine, and one 1500 g of hydroxychloroquine. Statistical analysis of all patients showed that for those with no fundus changes or stippled pigmentation a number showed elevation of tritan threshold, so that if macular stippling is a sign of mild retinopathy the test on tritan changes has a 64% sensitivity and 63% specificity for an upper threshold value of 7%. All four patients with bull's eye lesions showed a marked disturbance of tritan colour vision, with a threshold of 14.8%, a sensitivity of 75%, and a specificity of 94%. For protan colour vision a threshold of 10% gives 75% sensitivity and 91% specificity. By contrast, neither an absolute nor a relative EOG reduction was a valid criterion for early or late chloroquine retinopathy. In advanced retinopathy an Arden coefficient (AQ) <180% yields 50% sensitivity and 54% specificity. When AQ <160% is the threshold, sensitivity does not increase but specificity rises to 82%. Occurrence of marked corneal deposits on clinical examination yields 50% sensitivity and 90% specificity in this situation.

CONCLUSION

Screening for chloroquine retinopathy can be improved by using a sensitive colour test. Disturbance of the tritan axis appears to occur first. A normal test result on computerised colour testing virtually excludes any retinopathy by antimalarials. The EOG is of little diagnostic value.

Colour contrast sensitivity in ocular hypertension. A five-year prospective study

PURPOSE

To evaluate a peripheral colour contrast sensitivity test as a tool for early diagnosis of glaucoma in a five-year prospective study.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Peripheral colour contrast sensitivity was measured with a computer graphics system developed by Arden et al. The test colours were varied along the protan, deutan and tritan colour confusion axes on a scale from 0 to 100 percentage units. Fifty-five ocular hypertensive (OH) patients examined with the colour contrast test, stereoscopic photography of the optic discs, and measurements of visual fields (Humphrey 24-2 glaucoma hemifield test (GHT)) in 1994, were re-examined after five years.

RESULTS

Ten patients were 'outside normal limits' in the GHT at follow-up. This group of 10 patients did not differ in colour contrast thresholds at the test in 1994 from the 45 who were still 'normal' (or 'borderline') at follow-up. Neither were there proportionally more patients with GHT 'outside normal values' for the patients with high colour contrast thresholds (> 30% units) in 1994 regarding any of the three colour axes. As judged from patient files, 27 patients had developed glaucoma during follow-up. Although there were differences between these 27 glaucoma patients and the remaining OH group at the colour contrast test in 1994, these differences did not reach statistical significance for any of the colour axes (largest difference in the tritan axis: 6.2% units, P = 0.0745). At follow-up, however, there was a significant difference in colour contrast for the protan axis between the clinical glaucoma group and the OH group (6.7% units, P = 0.0105).

CONCLUSION

The method used for colour contrast measurement did not reveal glaucomatous changes before conventional perimetry (Humphrey 24-2, GHT). Neither did it predict the patients who, in our clinic, subsequently developed glaucoma during a five-year period. A change over time in colour contrast in the protan axis for an OH patient may, however, indicate glaucoma development.