Bottom-up coarse-grained models that accurately describe the structure, pressure, and compressibility of molecular liquids

Thermodynamic Transferability in Coarse-Grained Force Fields Using Graph Neural Networks

Coarse-graining is a molecular modeling technique in which an atomistic system is represented in a simplified fashion that retains the most significant system features that contribute to a target output while removing the degrees of freedom that are less relevant. This reduction in model complexity allows coarse-grained molecular simulations to reach increased spatial and temporal scales compared with corresponding all-atom models. A core challenge in coarse-graining is to construct a force field that represents the interactions in the new representation in a way that preserves the atomistic-level properties. Many approaches to building coarse-grained force fields have limited transferability between different thermodynamic conditions as a result of averaging over internal fluctuations at a specific thermodynamic state point. Here, we use a graph-convolutional neural network architecture, the Hierarchically Interacting Particle Neural Network with Tensor Sensitivity (HIP-NN-TS), to develop a highly automated training pipeline for coarse-grained force fields, which allows for studying the transferability of coarse-grained models based on the force-matching approach. We show that this approach yields not only highly accurate force fields but also that these force fields are more transferable through a variety of thermodynamic conditions. These results illustrate the potential of machine learning techniques, such as graph neural networks, to improve the construction of transferable coarse-grained force fields.

Enhancing the Assembly Properties of Bottom-Up Coarse-Grained Phospholipids

A plethora of key biological events occur at the cellular membrane where the large spatiotemporal scales necessitate dimensionality reduction or coarse-graining approaches over conventional all-atom molecular dynamics simulation. Constructing coarse-grained descriptions of membranes systematically from statistical mechanical principles has largely remained challenging due to the necessity of capturing amphipathic self-assembling behavior in coarse-grained models. We show that bottom-up coarse-grained lipid models can possess metastable morphological behavior and that this potential metastability has ramifications for accurate development and training. We in turn develop a training algorithm which evades metastability issues by linking model training to self-assembling behavior, and demonstrate its robustness via construction of solvent-free coarse-grained models of various phospholipid membranes, including lipid species such as phosphatidylcholines, phosphatidylserines, sphingolipids, and cholesterol. The resulting coarse-grained lipid models are orders of magnitude faster than their atomistic counterparts while retaining structural fidelity and constitute a promising direction for the development of coarse-grained models of realistic cell membranes.

Rigorous Progress in Coarse-Graining

Low-resolution coarse-grained (CG) models provide remarkable computational and conceptual advantages for simulating soft materials. In principle, bottom-up CG models can reproduce all structural and thermodynamic properties of atomically detailed models that can be observed at the resolution of the CG model. This review discusses recent progress in developing theory and computational methods for achieving this promise. We first briefly review variational approaches for parameterizing interaction potentials and their relationship to machine learning methods. We then discuss recent approaches for simultaneously improving both the transferability and thermodynamic properties of bottom-up models by rigorously addressing the density and temperature dependence of these potentials. We also briefly discuss exciting progress in modeling high-resolution observables with low-resolution CG models. More generally, we highlight the essential role of the bottom-up framework not only for fundamentally understanding the limitations of prior CG models but also for developing robust computational methods that resolve these limitations in practice.

Structural Coarse-Graining via Multiobjective Optimization with Differentiable Simulation

In the realm of multiscale molecular simulations, structure-based coarse-graining is a prominent approach for creating efficient coarse-grained (CG) representations of soft matter systems, such as polymers. This involves optimizing CG interactions by matching static correlation functions of the corresponding degrees of freedom in all-atom (AA) models. Here, we present a versatile method, namely, differentiable coarse-graining (DiffCG), which combines multiobjective optimization and differentiable simulation. The DiffCG approach is capable of constructing robust CG models by iteratively optimizing the effective potentials to simultaneously match multiple target properties. We demonstrate our approach by concurrently optimizing bonded and nonbonded potentials of a CG model of polystyrene (PS) melts. The resulting CG-PS model effectively reproduces both the structural characteristics, such as the equilibrium probability distribution of microscopic degrees of freedom and the thermodynamic pressure of the AA counterpart. More importantly, leveraging the multiobjective optimization capability, we develop a precise and efficient CG model for PS melts that is transferable across a wide range of temperatures, i.e., from 400 to 600 K. It is achieved via optimizing a pairwise potential with nonlinear temperature dependence in the CG model to simultaneously match target data from AA-MD simulations at multiple thermodynamic states. The temperature transferable CG-PS model demonstrates its ability to accurately predict the radial distribution functions and density at different temperatures, including those that are not included in the target thermodynamic states. Our work opens up a promising route for developing accurate and transferable CG models of complex soft-matter systems through multiobjective optimization with differentiable simulation.

Force matching and iterative Boltzmann inversion coarse grained force fields for ZIF-8

Despite the intense activity at electronic and atomistic resolutions, coarse grained (CG) modeling of metal-organic frameworks remains largely unexplored. One of the main reasons for this is the lack of adequate CG force fields. In this work, we present iterative Boltzmann inversion and force matching (FM) force fields for modeling ZIF-8 at three different coarse grained resolutions. Their ability to reproduce structure, elastic tensor, and thermal expansion is evaluated and compared with that of MARTINI force fields considered in previous work [Alvares et al., J. Chem. Phys. 158, 194107 (2023)]. Moreover, MARTINI and FM are evaluated for their ability to depict the swing effect, a subtle phase transition ZIF-8 undergoes when loaded with guest molecules. Overall, we found that all our force fields reproduce structure reasonably well. Elastic constants and volume expansion results are analyzed, and the technical and conceptual challenges of reproducing them are explained. Force matching exhibits promising results for capturing the swing effect. This is the first time these CG methods, widely applied in polymer and biomolecule communities, are deployed to model porous solids. We highlight the challenges of fitting CG force fields for these materials.

Insight into the Density-Dependence of Pair Potentials for Predictive Coarse-Grained Models

We investigate the temperature- and density-dependence of effective pair potentials for 1-site coarse-grained (CG) models of two industrial solvents, 1,4-dioxane and tetrahydrofuran. We observe that the calculated pair potentials are much more sensitive to density than to temperature. The generalized-Yvon-Born-Green framework reveals that this striking density-dependence reflects corresponding variations in the many-body correlations that determine the environment-mediated indirect contribution to the pair mean force. Moreover, we demonstrate, perhaps surprisingly, that this density-dependence is not important for accurately modeling the intermolecular structure. Accordingly, we adopt a density-independent interaction potential and transfer the density-dependence of the calculated pair potentials into a configuration-independent volume potential. Furthermore, we develop a single global potential that accurately models the intermolecular structure and pressure-volume equation of state across a very wide range of liquid state points. Consequently, this work provides fundamental insight into the density-dependence of effective pair potentials and also provides a significant step toward developing predictive CG models for efficiently modeling industrial solvents.

Derived Coarse-Grained Potentials for Semicrystalline Polymers with a Blended Multistate Iterative Boltzmann Inversion Method

In this article, we employ the multistate iterative Boltzmann inversion (MS-IBI) method to develop coarse-grained potentials capable of representing molecular structure in both the amorphous and crystalline phases of semicrystalline polymers with improved accuracy while allowing for tunable control over the dynamics governing the α-relaxation process. A unique feature of this method is that the potentials are blended using the product of the target structural distributions, for example, the radial density function, for each phase and a weighting factor. To demonstrate this approach, a family of potentials for polyethylene is developed where the weighting factor of the crystalline phase ranges is varied from zero, incorporating information only from the amorphous phase, to unity, where the model is trained from only the crystalline phase. The most accurate representation of structural distributions was obtained when the crystalline phases is weighted at 50%. However, we show that when the crystalline phase is weighted at 90%, the model more accurately represents dynamics of the α-relaxation process, with realistic predicted values of activation energy and diffusion rates, with relatively minor impact on accuracy in structure.

Gaussian representation of coarse-grained interactions of liquids: Theory, parametrization, and transferability

Coarse-grained (CG) interactions determined via bottom-up methodologies can faithfully reproduce the structural correlations observed in fine-grained (atomistic resolution) systems, yet they can suffer from limited extensibility due to complex many-body correlations. As part of an ongoing effort to understand and improve the applicability of bottom-up CG models, we propose an alternative approach to address both accuracy and transferability. Our main idea draws from classical perturbation theory to partition the hard sphere repulsive term from effective CG interactions. We then introduce Gaussian basis functions corresponding to the system's characteristic length by linking these Gaussian sub-interactions to the local particle densities at each coordination shell. The remaining perturbative long-range interaction can be treated as a collective solvation interaction, which we show exhibits a Gaussian form derived from integral equation theories. By applying this numerical parametrization protocol to CG liquid systems, our microscopic theory elucidates the emergence of Gaussian interactions in common phenomenological CG models. To facilitate transferability for these reduced descriptions, we further infer equations of state to determine the sub-interaction parameter as a function of the system variables. The reduced models exhibit excellent transferability across the thermodynamic state points. Furthermore, we propose a new strategy to design the cross-interactions between distinct CG sites in liquid mixtures. This involves combining each Gaussian in the proper radial domain, yielding accurate CG potentials of mean force and structural correlations for multi-component systems. Overall, our findings establish a solid foundation for constructing transferable bottom-up CG models of liquids with enhanced extensibility.

Machine learning assisted coarse-grained molecular dynamics modeling of meso-scale interfacial fluids

A hallmark of meso-scale interfacial fluids is the multi-faceted, scale-dependent interfacial energy, which often manifests different characteristics across the molecular and continuum scale. The multi-scale nature imposes a challenge to construct reliable coarse-grained (CG) models, where the CG potential function needs to faithfully encode the many-body interactions arising from the unresolved atomistic interactions and account for the heterogeneous density distributions across the interface. We construct the CG models of both single- and two-component polymeric fluid systems based on the recently developed deep coarse-grained potential [Zhang et al., J. Chem. Phys. 149, 034101 (2018)] scheme, where each polymer molecule is modeled as a CG particle. By only using the training samples of the instantaneous force under the thermal equilibrium state, the constructed CG models can accurately reproduce both the probability density function of the void formation in bulk and the spectrum of the capillary wave across the fluid interface. More importantly, the CG models accurately predict the volume-to-area scaling transition for the apolar solvation energy, illustrating the effectiveness to probe the meso-scale collective behaviors encoded with molecular-level fidelity.

Enhancing pressure consistency and transferability of structure-based coarse-graining

Coarse-graining, which models molecules with coarse-grained (CG) beads, allows molecular dynamics simulations to be applied to systems with large length and time scales while preserving the essential molecular structure. However, CG models generally have insufficient representability and transferability. A commonly used method to resolve this problem is multi-state iterative Boltzmann inversion (MS-IBI) with pressure correction, which matches both the structural properties and pressures at different thermodynamic states between CG and all-atom (AA) simulations. Nevertheless, this method is usually effective only in a narrow pressure range. In this paper, we propose a modified CG scheme to overcome this limitation. We find that the fundamental reason for this limitation is that CG beads at close distances are ellipsoids rather than isotropically compressed spheres, as described in conventional CG models. Hence, we propose a method to compensate for such differences by slightly modifying the radial distribution functions (RDFs) derived from AA simulations and using the modified RDFs as references for pressure-corrected MS-IBI. We also propose a method to determine the initial non-bonded potential using both the target RDF and pressure. Using n-dodecane as a case study, we demonstrate that the CG model developed using our scheme reproduces the RDFs and pressures over a wide range of pressure states, including three reference low-pressure states and two test high-pressure states. The proposed scheme allows for accurate CG simulations of systems in which pressure or density varies with time and/or position.

Toward a Mobility-Preserving Coarse-Grained Model: A Data-Driven Approach

Coarse-grained molecular dynamics (MD) simulation is a promising alternative to all-atom MD simulation for the fast calculation of system properties, which is imperative in designing materials with a specific target property. There have been several coarse-graining strategies developed over the past few years that provide accurate structural properties of the system. However, these coarse-grained models share a major drawback in that they introduce an artificial acceleration in molecular mobility. In this paper, we report a data-driven approach to generate coarse-grained models that preserve the all-atom molecular mobility. We designed a machine learning model in the form of an artificial neural network, which directly predicts the simulation-ready mobility-preserving coarse-grained potential as an output given the all-atom force field (FF) parameters as inputs. As a proof of principle, we took 2,3,4-trimethylpentane as a model system and described the development of machine learning models in detail. We quantify the artificial acceleration in molecular mobility by defining the acceleration factor as the ratio of the coarse-grained and the all-atom diffusion coefficient. The predicted coarse-grained potential generated by the best machine learning model can bring down the acceleration factor to a value of ∼2, which could be otherwise as large as 7 for a typical value of 3 × 10^-9 m² s^-1 for the all-atom diffusion coefficient. We believe our method will be of interest in the community as a route to generating coarse-grained potentials with accurate dynamics.

Bottom-up Coarse-Graining: Principles and Perspectives

Large-scale computational molecular models provide scientists a means to investigate the effect of microscopic details on emergent mesoscopic behavior. Elucidating the relationship between variations on the molecular scale and macroscopic observable properties facilitates an understanding of the molecular interactions driving the properties of real world materials and complex systems (e.g., those found in biology, chemistry, and materials science). As a result, discovering an explicit, systematic connection between microscopic nature and emergent mesoscopic behavior is a fundamental goal for this type of investigation. The molecular forces critical to driving the behavior of complex heterogeneous systems are often unclear. More problematically, simulations of representative model systems are often prohibitively expensive from both spatial and temporal perspectives, impeding straightforward investigations over possible hypotheses characterizing molecular behavior. While the reduction in resolution of a study, such as moving from an atomistic simulation to that of the resolution of large coarse-grained (CG) groups of atoms, can partially ameliorate the cost of individual simulations, the relationship between the proposed microscopic details and this intermediate resolution is nontrivial and presents new obstacles to study. Small portions of these complex systems can be realistically simulated. Alone, these smaller simulations likely do not provide insight into collectively emergent behavior. However, by proposing that the driving forces in both smaller and larger systems (containing many related copies of the smaller system) have an explicit connection, systematic bottom-up CG techniques can be used to transfer CG hypotheses discovered using a smaller scale system to a larger system of primary interest. The proposed connection between different CG systems is prescribed by (i) the CG representation (mapping) and (ii) the functional form and parameters used to represent the CG energetics, which approximate potentials of mean force (PMFs). As a result, the design of CG methods that facilitate a variety of physically relevant representations, approximations, and force fields is critical to moving the frontier of systematic CG forward. Crucially, the proposed connection between the system used for parametrization and the system of interest is orthogonal to the optimization used to approximate the potential of mean force present in all systematic CG methods. The empirical efficacy of machine learning techniques on a variety of tasks provides strong motivation to consider these approaches for approximating the PMF and analyzing these approximations.

Consistent and Transferable Force Fields for Statistical Copolymer Systems at the Mesoscale

The statistical trajectory matching (STM) method was applied successfully to derive coarse grain (CG) models for bulk properties of homopolymers. The extension of the methodology for building CG models for statistical copolymer systems is much more challenging. We present here the strategy for developing CG models for styrene-butadiene-rubber, and we compare the quality of the resulting CG force fields on the structure and thermodynamics at different chemical compositions. The CG models are used through the use of a genuine mesoscopic method called the dissipative particle dynamics method and compared to high-resolution molecular dynamics simulations. We conclude that the STM method is able to produce coarse-grained potentials that are transferable in composition by using only a few reference systems. Additionally, this methodology can be applied on any copolymer system.

Broad chemical transferability in structure-based coarse-graining

Compared to top-down coarse-grained (CG) models, bottom-up approaches are capable of offering higher structural fidelity. This fidelity results from the tight link to a higher-resolution reference, making the CG model chemically specific. Unfortunately, chemical specificity can be at odds with compound-screening strategies, which call for transferable parametrizations. Here we present an approach to reconcile bottom-up, structure-preserving CG models with chemical transferability. We consider the bottom-up CG parametrization of 3,441 C7O2 small-molecule isomers. Our approach combines atomic representations, unsupervised learning, and a large-scale extended-ensemble force-matching parametrization. We first identify a subset of 19 representative molecules, which maximally encode the local environment of all gas-phase conformers. Reference interactions between the 19 representative molecules were obtained from both homogeneous bulk liquids and various binary mixtures. An extended-ensemble parametrization over all 703 state points leads to a CG model that is both structure-based and chemically transferable. Remarkably, the resulting force field is on average more structurally accurate than single-state-point equivalents. Averaging over the extended ensemble acts as a mean-force regularizer, smoothing out both force and structural correlations that are overly specific to a single state point. Our approach aims at transferability through a set of CG bead types that can be used to easily construct new molecules, while retaining the benefits of a structure-based parametrization.

Systematic bottom-up molecular coarse-graining via force and torque matching using anisotropic particles

We derive a systematic and general method for parametrizing coarse-grained molecular models consisting of anisotropic particles from fine-grained (e.g. all-atom) models for condensed-phase molecular dynamics simulations. The method, which we call anisotropic force-matching coarse-graining (AFM-CG), is based on rigorous statistical mechanical principles, enforcing consistency between the coarse-grained and fine-grained phase-space distributions to derive equations for the coarse-grained forces, torques, masses, and moments of inertia in terms of properties of a condensed-phase fine-grained system. We verify the accuracy and efficiency of the method by coarse-graining liquid-state systems of two different anisotropic organic molecules, benzene and perylene, and show that the parametrized coarse-grained models more accurately describe properties of these systems than previous anisotropic coarse-grained models parametrized using other methods that do not account for finite-temperature and many-body effects on the condensed-phase coarse-grained interactions. The AFM-CG method will be useful for developing accurate and efficient dynamical simulation models of condensed-phase systems of molecules consisting of large, rigid, anisotropic fragments, such as liquid crystals, organic semiconductors, and nucleic acids.

A coarse-grained model for capturing the helical behavior of isotactic polypropylene

Understanding the process-property relations of helical polymers using molecular simulations has been an attractive research field over the years. Specifically, isotactic polypropylene still remains a challenge for current computational experimentation, as it exhibits phenomena such as crystallization that emerge on large spatial and temporal scales. Coarse-graining is an efficient technique for approaching such phenomena, although previous coarse-grained models lack in preserving important atomistic and structural details. In this paper we develop a new coarse-grained model, based on the popular MARTINI force field, that is able to reproduce the helical behavior of isotactic polypropylene. To test the model, the predicted statistical and structural properties (characteristic ratio, density, entanglement molecular weight, solubility parameter in the melt) are compared with previous simulation results and available experimental data. For the development of the new coarse-grained force field, a single unperturbed chain Monte Carlo algorithm has been implemented: an efficient algorithm which samples conformations representative of a melt by simulating just a single chain.

A microcanonical approach to temperature-transferable coarse-grained models using the relative entropy

Bottom-up coarse-graining methods provide systematic tools for creating simplified models of molecular systems. However, coarse-grained (CG) models produced with such methods frequently fail to accurately reproduce all thermodynamic properties of the reference atomistic systems they seek to model and, moreover, can fail in even more significant ways when used at thermodynamic state points different from the reference conditions. These related problems of representability and transferability limit the usefulness of CG models, especially those of strongly state-dependent systems. In this work, we present a new strategy for creating temperature-transferable CG models using a single reference system and temperature. The approach is based on two complementary concepts. First, we switch to a microcanonical basis for formulating CG models, focusing on effective entropy functions rather than energy functions. This allows CG models to naturally represent information about underlying atomistic energy fluctuations, which would otherwise be lost. Such information not only reproduces energy distributions of the reference model but also successfully predicts the correct temperature dependence of the CG interactions, enabling temperature transferability. Second, we show that relative entropy minimization provides a direct and systematic approach to parameterize such classes of temperature-transferable CG models. We calibrate the approach initially using idealized model systems and then demonstrate its ability to create temperature-transferable CG models for several complex molecular liquids.

An Enhanced Scheme for Multiscale Modeling of Thermomechanical Properties of Polymer Bulks

While multiscale modeling significantly enhances the capability of molecular simulations of polymer systems, it is well realized that the systematically derived coarse-grained (CG) models generally underestimate the thermomechanical properties. In this work, a charge-based mapping scheme has been adopted to include explicit electrostatic interactions and benchmarked against two typical polymers, atactic poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) and polystyrene (PS). The CG potentials are parameterized against the oligomer bulks of nine monomers per chain to match the essential structural features and the two basic pressure-volume-temperature (PVT) properties, which are obtained from the all-atomistic (AA) molecular dynamics (MD) simulations at a single elevated temperature. The so-parameterized CG potentials are extended with the MD method to simulate the two polymer bulks of one hundred monomers per chain over a wide temperature range. Without any scaling, all the simulated results, including mass densities and bulk moduli at room temperature, thermal expansion coefficients at rubbery and glassy states, and glass transition temperatures (T_g), compare well with the corresponding experimental data. The proposed scheme not only contributes to realistically simulating various thermomechanical properties of both apolar and polar polymers but also allows for directly simulating their electrical properties.

BoltzmaNN: Predicting effective pair potentials and equations of state using neural networks

Neural networks (NNs) are employed to predict equations of state from a given isotropic pair potential using the virial expansion of the pressure. The NNs are trained with data from molecular dynamics simulations of monoatomic gases and liquids, sampled in the NVT ensemble at various densities. We find that the NNs provide much more accurate results compared to the analytic low-density limit estimate of the second virial coefficient and the Carnahan-Starling equation of state for hard sphere liquids. Furthermore, we design and train NNs for computing (effective) pair potentials from radial pair distribution functions, g(r), a task that is often performed for inverse design and coarse-graining. Providing the NNs with additional information on the forces greatly improves the accuracy of the predictions since more correlations are taken into account; the predicted potentials become smoother, are significantly closer to the target potentials, and are more transferable as a result.

Investigating the energetic and entropic components of effective potentials across a glass transition

By eliminating unnecessary details, coarse-grained (CG) models provide the necessary efficiency for simulating scales that are inaccessible to higher resolution models. However, because they average over atomic details, the effective potentials governing CG degrees of freedom necessarily incorporate significant entropic contributions, which limit their transferability and complicate the treatment of thermodynamic properties. This work employs a dual-potential approach to consider the energetic and entropic contributions to effective interaction potentials for CG models. Specifically, we consider one- and three-site CG models for ortho-terphenyl (OTP) both above and below its glass transition. We employ the multiscale coarse-graining (MS-CG) variational principle to determine interaction potentials that accurately reproduce the structural properties of an all-atom (AA) model for OTP at each state point. We employ an energy-matching variational principle to determine an energy operator that accurately reproduces the intra- and inter-molecular energy of the AA model. While the MS-CG pair potentials are almost purely repulsive, the corresponding pair energy functions feature a pronounced minima that corresponds to contacting benzene rings. These energetic functions then determine an estimate for the entropic component of the MS-CG interaction potentials. These entropic functions accurately predict the MS-CG pair potentials across a wide range of liquid state points at constant density. Moreover, the entropic functions also predict pair potentials that quite accurately model the AA pair structure below the glass transition. Thus, the dual-potential approach appears a promising approach for modeling AA energetics, as well as for predicting the temperature-dependence of CG effective potentials.

A new one-site coarse-grained model for water: Bottom-up many-body projected water (BUMPer). II. Temperature transferability and structural properties at low temperature

A number of studies have constructed coarse-grained (CG) models of water to understand its anomalous properties. Most of these properties emerge at low temperatures, and an accurate CG model needs to be applicable to these low-temperature ranges. However, direct use of CG models parameterized from other temperatures, e.g., room temperature, encounters a problem known as transferability, as the CG potential essentially follows the form of the many-body CG free energy function. Therefore, temperature-dependent changes to CG interactions must be accounted for. The collective behavior of water at low temperature is generally a many-body process, which often motivates the use of expensive many-body terms in the CG interactions. To surmount the aforementioned problems, we apply the Bottom-Up Many-Body Projected Water (BUMPer) CG model constructed from Paper I to study the low-temperature behavior of water. We report for the first time that the embedded three-body interaction enables BUMPer, despite its pairwise form, to capture the growth of ice at the ice/water interface with corroborating many-body correlations during the crystal growth. Furthermore, we propose temperature transferable BUMPer models that are indirectly constructed from the free energy decomposition scheme. Changes in CG interactions and corresponding structures are faithfully recapitulated by this framework. We further extend BUMPer to examine its ability to predict the structure, density, and diffusion anomalies by employing an alternative analysis based on structural correlations and pairwise potential forms to predict such anomalies. The presented analysis highlights the existence of these anomalies in the low-temperature regime and overcomes potential transferability problems.

Bottom-up coarse-grained models for external fields and interfaces

Bottom-up coarse-grained (CG) models accurately describe the structure of homogeneous systems but sometimes provide limited transferability and a poor description of thermodynamic properties. Consequently, inhomogeneous systems present a severe challenge for bottom-up models. In this work, we examine bottom-up CG models for interfaces and inhomogeneous systems. We first analyze the effect of external fields upon the many-body potential of mean force. We also demonstrate that the multiscale CG (MS-CG) variational principle for modeling the external field corresponds to a generalization of the first Yvon-Born-Green equation. This provides an important connection with liquid state theory, as well as physical insight into the structure of interfaces and the resulting MS-CG models. We then develop and assess MS-CG models for a film of liquid methanol that is adsorbed on an attractive wall and in coexistence with its vapor phase. While pair-additive potentials provide unsatisfactory accuracy and transferability, the inclusion of local-density (LD) potentials dramatically improves the accuracy and transferability of the MS-CG model. The MS-CG model with LD potentials quite accurately describes the wall-liquid interface, the bulk liquid density, and the liquid-vapor interface while simultaneously providing a much improved description of the vapor phase. This model also provides an excellent description of the pair structure and pressure-density equation of state for the bulk liquid. Thus, LD potentials hold considerable promise for transferable bottom-up models that accurately describe the structure and thermodynamic properties of both bulk and interfacial systems.

Backbone oriented anisotropic coarse grains for efficient simulations of polymers

Despite the fact that anisotropic particles have been introduced to describe molecular interactions for decades, they have been poorly used for polymers because of their computing time overhead and the absence of a relevant proof of their impact in this field. We first report a method using anisotropic beads for polymers, which solves the computing time issue by considering that beads keep their principal orientation alongside the mean local backbone vector of the polymer chain, avoiding the computation of torques during the dynamics. Applying this method to a polymer bulk, we study the effect of anisotropic interactions vs isotropic ones for various properties such as density, pressure, topology of the chain network, local structure, and orientational order. We show that for different classes of potentials traditionally used in molecular simulations, those backbone oriented anisotropic beads can solve numerous issues usually encountered with isotropic interactions. We conclude that the use of backbone oriented anisotropic beads is a promising approach for the development of realistic coarse-grained potentials for polymers.

Temperature and Phase Transferable Bottom-up Coarse-Grained Models

Despite the high fidelity of bottom-up coarse-grained (CG) approaches to recapitulate the structural correlations in atomistic simulations, the general use of bottom-up CG methods is limited because of the nontransferable nature of these CG models under different thermodynamic conditions. Because bottom-up CG potentials usually correspond to configuration-dependent free energies of the system, recent studies have focused on adjusting enthalpic or entropic contributions to account for issues with transferability. However, these approaches can require a manual adjustment of the CG interaction a priori and are usually limited to constant volume ensembles. To overcome these limitations, we construct temperature and phase transferable CG models under constant pressure by developing the ultra-coarse-graining (UCG) methodology in the mean-field limit. In the mean-field ansatz, an embedded semi-global order parameter recapitulates global changes to the system by automatically adjusting the effective CG interactions, thus bridging free energy decompositions with UCG theory. The method presented is designed to faithfully capture structural correlations under different thermodynamic conditions, using a single UCG model. Specifically, we test the applicability of the developed theory in three distinct cases: (1) different temperatures at constant pressure in liquids, (2) different temperatures across thermodynamic phases, and (3) liquid/vapor interfaces. We demonstrate that the systematic construction of both temperature and phase transferable bottom-up CG models is possible using this generalized UCG theory. Based on our findings, this approach significantly extends the transferability and applicability of the bottom-up CG theory and method.

Learning Coarse-Grained Potentials for Binary Fluids

For a multiple-fluid system, CG models capable of accurately predicting the interfacial properties as a function of curvature are still lacking. In this work, we propose a new probabilistic machine learning (ML) model for learning CG potentials for binary fluids. The water-hexane mixture is selected as a typical immiscible binary liquid-liquid system. We develop a new CG force field (FF) using the Shinoda-DeVane-Klein (SDK) FF framework and compute parameters in this CG FF using the proposed probabilistic ML method. It is shown that a standard response-surface approach does not provide a unique set of parameters, as it results in a loss function with multiple shallow minima. To address this challenge, we develop a probabilistic ML approach where we compute the probability density function (PDF) of parameters that minimize the loss function. The PDF has a well-defined peak corresponding to a unique set of parameters in the CG FF that reproduces the desired properties of a liquid-liquid interface. We compare the performance of the new CG FF with several existing FFs for the water-hexane mixture, including two atomistic and three CG FFs with respect to modeling the interface structure and thermodynamic properties. It is demonstrated that the new FF significantly improves the CG model prediction of both the interfacial tension and structure for the water-hexane mixture.

Coarse-graining of polyisoprene melts using inverse Monte Carlo and local density potentials

Bottom-up coarse-graining of polymers is commonly performed by matching structural order parameters such as distribution of bond lengths, bending and dihedral angles, and pair distribution functions. In this study, we introduce the distribution of nearest-neighbors as an additional order parameter in the concept of local density potentials. We describe how the inverse-Monte Carlo method provides a framework for forcefield development that is capable of overcoming challenges associated with the parameterization of interaction terms in polymer systems. The technique is applied on polyisoprene melts as a prototype system. We demonstrate that while different forcefields can be developed that perform equally in terms of matching target distributions, the inclusion of nearest-neighbors provides a straightforward route to match both thermodynamic and conformational properties. We find that several temperature state points can also be addressed, provided that the forcefield is refined accordingly. Finally, we examine both the single-particle and the collective dynamics of the coarse-grain models, demonstrating that all forcefields present a similar acceleration relative to the atomistic systems.

Direct route to reproducing pair distribution functions with coarse-grained models via transformed atomistic cross correlations

Coarse-grained (CG) models are often parameterized to reproduce one-dimensional structural correlation functions of an atomically detailed model along the degrees of freedom governing each interaction potential. While cross correlations between these degrees of freedom inform the optimal set of interaction parameters, the correlations generated from the higher-resolution simulations are often too complex to act as an accurate proxy for the CG correlations. Instead, the most popular methods determine the interaction parameters iteratively while assuming that individual interactions are uncorrelated. While these iterative methods have been validated for a wide range of systems, they also have disadvantages when parameterizing models for multicomponent systems or when refining previously established models to better reproduce particular structural features. In this work, we propose two distinct approaches for the direct (i.e., noniterative) parameterization of a CG model by adjusting the high-resolution cross correlations of an atomistic model in order to more accurately reflect correlations that will be generated by the resulting CG model. The derived models more accurately describe the low-order structural features of the underlying AA model while necessarily generating inherently distinct cross correlations compared with the atomically detailed reference model. We demonstrate the proposed methods for a one-site-per-molecule representation of liquid water, where pairwise interactions are incapable of reproducing the true tetrahedral solvation structure. We then investigate the precise role that distinct cross-correlation features play in determining the correct pair correlation functions, evaluating the importance of the placement of correlation features as well as the balance between features appearing in different solvation shells.

Evidence of information limitations in coarse-grained models

Developing accurate coarse-grained (CG) models is critical for addressing long time and length scale phenomena with molecular simulations. Here, we distinguish and quantify two sources of error that are relevant to CG models in order to guide further methods development: "representability" errors, which result from the finite basis associated with the chosen functional form of the CG model and mapping operator, and "information" errors, which result from the limited kind and quantity of data supplied to the CG parameterization algorithm. We have performed a systematic investigation of these errors by generating all possible CG models of three liquids (butane, 1-butanol, and 1,3-propanediol) that conserve a set of chemically motivated locality and topology relationships. In turn, standard algorithms (iterative Boltzmann inversion, IBI, and multiscale coarse-graining, MSCG) were used to parameterize the models and the CG predictions were compared with atomistic results. For off-target properties, we observe a strong correlation between the accuracy and the resolution of the CG model, which suggests that the approximations represented by MSCG and IBI deteriorate with decreasing resolution. Conversely, on-target properties exhibit an extremely weak resolution dependence that suggests a limited role of representability errors in model accuracy. Taken together, these results suggest that simple CG models are capable of utilizing more information than is provided by standard parameterization algorithms, and that model accuracy can be improved by algorithm development rather than resorting to more complicated CG models.

Bottom-up derived flexible water model with dipole and quadrupole moments for coarse-grained molecular simulations

A bottom-up CG water model is developed to capture the electrostatic multipoles, structural correlation and thermodynamics of water.

Analysis of local density potentials

Low resolution coarse-grained (CG) models are widely adopted for investigating phenomena that cannot be effectively simulated with all-atom (AA) models. Since the development of the many-body dissipative particle dynamics method, CG models have increasingly supplemented conventional pair potentials with one-body potentials of the local density (LD) around each site. These LD potentials appear to significantly extend the transferability of CG models, while also enabling more accurate descriptions of thermodynamic properties, interfacial phenomena, and many-body correlations. In this work, we systematically examine the properties of LD potentials. We first derive and numerically demonstrate a nontrivial transformation of pair and LD potentials that leaves the total forces and equilibrium distribution invariant. Consequently, the pair and LD potentials determined via bottom-up methods are not unique. We then investigate the sensitivity of CG models for glycerol to the weighting function employed for defining the local density. We employ the multiscale coarse-graining (MS-CG) method to simultaneously parameterize both pair and LD potentials. When employing a short-ranged Lucy function that defines the local density from the first solvation shell, the MS-CG model accurately reproduces the pair structure, pressure-density equation of state, and liquid-vapor interfacial profile of the AA model. The accuracy of the model generally decreases as the range of the Lucy function increases further. The MS-CG model provides similar accuracy when a smoothed Heaviside function is employed to define the local density from the first solvation shell. However, the model performs less well when this function acts on either longer or shorter length scales.

Dual-potential approach for coarse-grained implicit solvent models with accurate, internally consistent energetics and predictive transferability

The dual-potential approach promises coarse-grained (CG) models that accurately reproduce both structural and energetic properties, while simultaneously providing predictive estimates for the temperature-dependence of the effective CG potentials. In this work, we examine the dual-potential approach for implicit solvent CG models that reflect large entropic effects from the eliminated solvent. Specifically, we construct implicit solvent models at various resolutions, R, by retaining a fraction 0.10 ≤ R ≤ 0.95 of the molecules from a simple fluid of Lennard-Jones spheres. We consider the dual-potential approach in both the constant volume and constant pressure ensembles across a relatively wide range of temperatures. We approximate the many-body potential of mean force for the remaining solutes with pair and volume potentials, which we determine via multiscale coarse-graining and self-consistent pressure-matching, respectively. Interestingly, with increasing temperature, the pair potentials appear increasingly attractive, while the volume potentials become increasingly repulsive. The dual-potential approach not only reproduces the atomic energetics but also quite accurately predicts this temperature-dependence. We also derive an exact relationship between the thermodynamic specific heat of an atomic model and the energetic fluctuations that are observable at the CG resolution. With this generalized fluctuation relationship, the approximate CG models quite accurately reproduce the thermodynamic specific heat of the underlying atomic model.

Compatible observable decompositions for coarse-grained representations of real molecular systems

Coarse-grained (CG) observable expressions, such as pressure or potential energy, are generally different than their fine-grained (FG, e.g., atomistic) counterparts. Recently, we analyzed this so-called "representability problem" in Wagner et al. [J. Chem. Phys. 145, 044108 (2016)]. While the issue of representability was clearly and mathematically stated in that work, it was not made clear how to actually determine CG observable expressions from the underlying FG systems that can only be simulated numerically. In this work, we propose minimization targets for the CG observables of such systems. These CG observables are compatible with each other and with structural observables. Also, these CG observables are systematically improvable since they are variationally minimized. Our methods are local and data efficient because we decompose the observable contributions. Hence, our approaches are called the multiscale compatible observable decomposition (MS-CODE) and the relative entropy compatible observable decomposition (RE-CODE), which reflect two main approaches to the "bottom-up" coarse-graining of real FG systems. The parameterization of these CG observable expressions requires the introduction of new, symmetric basis sets and one-body terms. We apply MS-CODE and RE-CODE to 1-site and 2-site CG models of methanol for the case of pressure, as well as to 1-site methanol and acetonitrile models for potential energy.

Determining Optimal Coarse-Grained Representation for Biomolecules Using Internal Cluster Validation Indexes

The development of ultracoarse-grained models for large biomolecules needs to derive the optimal number of coarse-grained (CG) sites to represent the targets. In this work, we propose to use the statistical internal cluster validation indexes to determine the optimal number of CG sites that are optimized based on the essential dynamics coarse-graining method. The calculated curves of Calinski-Harabasz and Silhouette Coefficient indexes exhibit the extrema corresponding to the similar CG numbers. The calculated ratios of the optimal CG numbers to the residue numbers of fine-grained models are in the range from 4 to 2. The comparison of the stability of index results indicates that Calinski-Harabasz index is the better choice to determine the optimal CG representation in coarse-graining. © 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Dual approach for effective potentials that accurately model structure and energetics

Because they eliminate unnecessary degrees of freedom, coarse-grained (CG) models enable studies of phenomena that are intractable with more detailed models. For the same reason, the effective potentials that govern CG degrees of freedom incorporate entropic contributions from the eliminated degrees of freedom. Consequently, these effective potentials demonstrate limited transferability and provide a poor estimate of atomic energetics. Here, we propose a simple dual-potential approach that combines "structure-based" and "energy-based" variational principles to determine effective potentials that model free energies and potential energies, respectively, as a function of the CG configuration. We demonstrate this approach for 1-site CG models of water and methanol. We accurately sample configuration space by performing simulations with the structure-based potential. We accurately estimate average atomic energies by postprocessing the sampled configurations with the energy-based potential. Finally, the difference between the two potentials predicts a qualitatively accurate estimate for the temperature dependence of the structure-based potential.

Relative entropy indicates an ideal concentration for structure-based coarse graining of binary mixtures

Many methodological approaches have been proposed to improve systematic or bottom-up coarse-graining techniques to enhance the representability and transferability of the derived interaction potentials. Transferability describes the ability of a coarse-grained (CG) model to be predictive, i.e., to describe a system at state points different from those chosen for parametrization. Whereas the representability characterizes the accuracy of a CG model to reproduce target properties of the underlying reference or fine-grained model at a given state point. In this article, we shift the focus away from methodological aspects and rather raise the question whether we can overcome the disadvantages of a given method in terms of representability and transferability by systematically selecting the state point at which the CG model gets parametrized. We answer this question by applying the inverse Monte Carlo (IMC) approach-a structure-based coarse-graining method-to derive effective interactions for binary mixtures of simple Lennard-Jones (LJ) particles, which are different in size. For such simple systems we indeed can identify a concentration where the derived potentials show the best performance in terms of structural representability and transferability. This specific concentration is identified by computing the relative entropy which quantifies the information loss between different IMC models and the reference LJ model at varying mixture compositions. Further, we show that an IMC model for mixtures of n-hexane and n-perfluorohexane shows the same trend in transferability as the IMC models for the LJ system. All derived models are more transferable in the direction of increasing concentration of the larger-sized compound.

Transferability of Local Density-Assisted Implicit Solvation Models for Homogeneous Fluid Mixtures

The application of bottom-up coarse grained (CG) models to study the equilibrium mixing behavior of liquids is rather challenging, since these models can be significantly influenced by the density or the concentration of the state chosen during parametrization. This dependency leads to low transferability in density/concentration space and has been one of the major limitations in bottom-up coarse graining. Recent approaches proposed to tackle this shortcoming range from the addition of thermodynamic constraints, to an extended ensemble parametrization, to the addition of supplementary terms to the system's Hamiltonian. To study fluid phase equilibria with bottom-up CG models, the application of local density (LD) potentials appears to be a promising approach, as shown in previous work by Sanyal and Shell [T. Sanyal, M. S. Shell, J. Phys. Chem. B, 2018, 122, 5678]. Here, we want to further explore this method and test its ability to model a system which contains structural inhomogeneities only on the molecular scale, namely, solutions of methanol and water. We find that a water-water LD potential improves the transferability of an implicit-methanol CG model toward high water concentration. Conversely, a methanol-methanol LD potential does not significantly improve the transferability of an implicit-water CG model toward high methanol concentration. These differences appear due to the presence of cooperative interactions in water at high concentrations that the LD potentials can capture. In addition, we compare two different approaches to derive our CG models, namely, relative entropy optimization and the Inverse Monte Carlo method, and formally demonstrate under which analytical and numerical assumptions these two methods yield equivalent results.

Development of Coarse-Grained Models for Polymers by Trajectory Matching

Coarse-grained (CG) models allow for simulating the necessary time and length scales relevant to polymers. However, developing realistic force fields at the CG level is still a challenge because there is no guarantee that the CG model reproduces all the properties of the atomistic model. A recent promising method was proposed for small molecules using statistical trajectory matching. Here, we extend this method to the case of polymeric systems. As the quality of the final model crucially depends on the model design, we study and discuss the effect of the modeling choices on the structure and dynamics of bulk polymers before a quantitative comparison is made between CG methods on different properties and polymers.