Contraceptive vaccine development

Contraception for population control in exotic carnivores

There is an increasing demand for management of feral and wild carnivores; since many of them have become "pest species" by adapting successfully to changing environments, having substantial impacts on their prey species, and serving as reservoirs for infectious diseases. Also in captivity, a low adult mortality and an increase in longevity, especially in large carnivores, cause an urgent need for population management. This paper presents an overview on contraceptive strategies to control reproduction in carnivores. Factors that have to be considered before applying a certain method for fertility suppression are discussed. For birth control, several methods of hormonal chemosterilization, immunocontraception and pregnancy termination have been developed in domestic and captive exotic carnivores, but none of them are yet suitable for free-ranging animals. GnRH agonists, which suppress pituitary function very efficiently, are recommended in captive and domestic animals for reversible contraception. Immunological contraception, causing prolonged infertility after single application, is a promising approach for feral animals. However, a specific gamete or hormone-derived "self" antigen must be identified for each particular species.

The application of in vitro sperm competition test to evaluate the impact of ZP-derived peptides on fertilization capacity of cat sperm

The present study aimed to establish a sensitive in vitro assay to assess the binding capacity of cat spermatozoa. Cat oocytes and epididymal sperm cells were isolated from gonads and cultured for in vitro fertilization. Before fertilization, the sperm cells were incubated either in 10 microM green dye Fluo-3-AM or 10 microM orange dye CellTracker Orange CMTMR (Molecular Probes), respectively. After removing the dyes by washing, sperm cells stained with each dye were added to medium drops containing oocytes in various proportions and cultured for 16 h at 37 degrees C, 5% CO(2). The oocytes were examined using fluorescence microscopy. Sperm bound to oocytes, and stained with different colors, were counted. When fresh epididymal sperm were mixed in at a specific proportion, the number of sperm bound to the zona pellucida (ZP) of oocytes reflected the proportion of differently colored sperm in the medium. This indicated that neither dye influenced the binding capacity of cat sperm. Mixing fresh and cryopreserved sperm, however, resulted in a higher number of fresh sperm bound to the oocyte surface in comparison to frozen-thawed sperm. Also, the pre-incubation of cat sperm cells with ZP derived peptide reduced the sperm binding capacity by 40%. In conclusion, the presented sperm competition assay allows assessment of fertilizing capacity of cat spermatozoa in vitro when a mixture of two different populations is used. The applied supravital fluorescence dyes do not affect motility and binding capacity of sperm cells and were clearly distinguishable under fluorescence microscopy. We demonstrate that the assay can be used to study the impact of sperm treatment, such as cryopreservation or pre-incubation in bioactive peptides, on fertilizing capacity.

Immunisation of the male tammar wallaby (Macropus eugenii) with spermatozoa elicits epididymal antigen-specific antibody secretion and compromised fertilisation rate

Immunocontraception has been proposed as an effective and humane means of controlling overabundant kangaroo populations in Australia. We have examined the feasibility of using a sperm-based vaccine for this purpose using a model macropod species, the tammar wallaby (Macropus eugenii). This study has demonstrated immunocontraception in a marsupial species following immunisation of males with homologous spermatozoa. Serum anti-sperm IgG titres were associated with a significant reduction in fertilisation rates following mating with superovulated female wallabies. Antigen-specific IgG penetrated the reproductive tract at the rete testis and bound spermatozoa in vivo. IgG was detected bound to the acrosome and midpiece regions of both epididymal and ejaculated spermatozoa. The absence of adverse testicular pathology and sperm movement effects suggests that contraception may have been achieved by antibody-mediated blocking of sperm surface antigens essential for fertilisation. This study demonstrates that a contraceptive vaccine targeting sperm antigens has potential for fertility control in male macropods.

Contraceptive vaccines

The control of human fertility would be revolutionised by the development of a safe, effective, long-acting contraceptive vaccine. The pursuit of this objective has involved the selection of appropriate targets within the reproductive process that are amenable to interference with antibodies. To date, three major targets have been researched. The zona pellucida (ZP) plays key roles in folliculogenesis, fertilisation and early development, and is comprised of powerful cell-specific antigens. The induction of infertility requires high ZP antibody titres that are difficult to maintain without inducing ovarian pathology characterised by a premature loss of primordial follicles. As a premature menopause would be a high price to pay for long-term contraception, this approach to a vaccine cannot progress until the cause of the ovarian pathology has been resolved. Sperm surface antigens represent another promising approach to contraceptive vaccine development. While there is some clinical data to support the likely efficacy of this strategy, none of the gamete-specific molecules characterised to date have fulfilled this promise. Anti-human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) vaccines terminate pregnancy by preventing the maternal recognition of pregnancy. This vaccine has reached the stage of clinical trials, and preliminary indications are that the approach is safe and potentially effective. However, reliability may be an issue, given the observed inter-individual variability in antibody generation. The future of contraceptive vaccine development will clearly involve a continuation of the intense search for suitable targets and the development of improved immunisation procedures that exploit the latest innovations in vaccine technology.

The potential use of sperm antigens as targets for immunocontraception; past, present and future

Immunocontraception, and in particular the targeting of antibodies to gamete-specific antigens implicated in sperm egg binding and fertilisation, offers an attractive approach to the growing global problem of overpopulation. Such an idea is not new; indeed several immunocontraception trials, using animal model systems, have been reported in recent years and a number are reviewed here. However, the results of these studies have been largely disappointing. We believe that two fundamental flaws attribute to the poor success of most of these preliminary immunocontraceptive trials. Firstly, loss of fertility has invariably been used as the assay. This presupposes that immuno-neutralisation of a single, gamete-specific antigen will be sufficient to cause a significant reduction in fertility; however, recent data suggests that such a premise may not be well-founded for a number of reasons. Secondly, and arguably the most important flaw, is the almost universal, but largely inappropriate, use of systemic immunisation as the sole route of antigen delivery. Whilst systemic immunisation regimes may lead to high serum IgG levels, these levels do not correlate with specific antibody levels in the reproductive tract or with contraceptive efficacy. Hence, an alternative antigen delivery approach is required which will induce an effective local immune response in the reproductive tract. Here we discuss the ways in which this might be achieved.

Fertility Control: An Option for Non-Lethal Control of Wild Carnivores?

Three types of fertility control, surgical sterilization, hormonal chemosterilization, and immunosterilization, are reviewed with regard to their potential for controlling problematic populations of carnivores. The fertility control agent and delivery protocol of choice may vary considerably according to: (i) the reason for control; (ii) the degree, urgency and duration of population reduction required; (iii) concerns about ethics and public opinion; and (iv) the status, population dynamics, social structure, mating system, size, behaviour and reproductive endocrinology of the target animals. Although they are often perceived and advocated as more preferable methods of population control than lethal approaches, it is important that wildlife managers as well as members of the public realize that the ethical acceptability of the various fertility control techniques may differ considerably - and that numerous questions regarding their effectiveness, humaneness and ecological safety remain unanswered.

A combinatorial phage display library for the generation of specific Fab fragments recognizing human spermatozoa and inhibiting fertilizing capacity in vitro

To select a source of lymphocytes for the generation of an anti-sperm-biased combinatorial phage display library, venous blood was obtained from 34 vasovasostomy (vasectomy reversal) patients approximately 3 mo after surgery. Using a variety of immunoassays, serum was analyzed for antibodies against human spermatozoa, and a patient was selected on the basis of high titer of antibodies that recognized the equatorial region of the sperm head and inhibited sperm fertilizing capacity in vitro. Total RNA isolated from the stored lymphocytes of this individual was reversed transcribed, and gamma1 (Fd) region and kappa chains were amplified by polymerase chain reaction for the successful construction of an antibody phage display library. The library was panned against human spermatozoa to isolate sperm-specific phage that recognized the equatorial region of the sperm head. Three preparations of Fab were tested via the hamster egg penetration test. Each preparation significantly (p < 0. 005) inhibited sperm-egg binding and fusion, with one preparation (designated Fab-G) causing complete inhibition. Sequence analysis of the kappa light gene encoding Fab-G revealed a 93% homology with the light chain of human anti-human immunodeficiency virus gp120 p35 variable region. This technology may have a practical application in characterization of the immune response to spermatozoa and for the design of sperm-based contraceptive vaccines.

Manipulation of the fertility of marsupials for conservation of endangered species and control of over-abundant populations

Marsupials present a dichotomy in population management; the numbers of many Australian marsupial species have declined due to loss of habitat, competition from introduced herbivores and predation by introduced carnivores, but other species have become locally overabundant in Australia or are introduced pests in New Zealand. The manipulation of reproduction offers the means to increase or decrease productivity; however, considerable fundamental research is required before reproductive technologies can be applied to marsupials. Marsupials differ from eutherian mammals in several aspects of their reproduction including sex differentiation, gamete function and endocrinology, as well as in the relative lengths of gestation and lactation. Although these differences present unique problems in the application of reproductive technologies to marsupials, they also present unique opportunities for marsupial-specific fertility control. This paper summarises the assisted breeding technologies currently being applied to marsupials including superovulation, artificial insemination, in vitro fertilization and gene banking; unique marsupial targets for contraceptive intervention including gamete production, sperm capacitation, gamete surface antigens and embryonic development; and some options for the delivery of contraceptive vaccines to marsupial populations.

Fertility-disrupting potential of synthetic peptides derived from the beta-subunit of follicle-stimulating hormone

PROBLEM

Hormone immunoneutralization is hampered by immunologic cross-reactivity caused by close-sequence homology between related molecules. One solution is to use smaller fragments to induce antibodies of greater specificity.

METHOD OF STUDY

A number of peptides selected from beta-follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) were conjugated to tetanus toxoid and were used to immunize female rats. The antisera were examined for FSH cross-reactivity by immunoassays and in an in vitro bioassay.

RESULTS

In the immunoassays, the antisera did not react with FSH but did react with their respective peptides. In the bioassay, sera from VYKDPARPC- and CDSLYTYP-immunized animals inhibited FSH-receptor interaction by 73% and 68%, respectively. These animals also showed reduced estradiol levels. Sequences were synthesized around VYKDPARPC and were tested on a FSH-receptor-bearing Chinese hamster ovary cell line. LVYKDPARPC, VYKDPARPC, YKDPARPIC, CLVYKDPARP, and LVYKDPARP inhibited FSH-receptor interaction by greater than 50%. In female mice, TRDLVYKDPARPKI and LVYKDPARP disrupted estrous cycling in all animals; LVYKDPARPC and CLVYKDPARP disrupted cycling in three of five animals, whereas VYKDPARPC disrupted cycling in one of four animals.

CONCLUSIONS

Peptides from two areas of beta-FSH (VYKDPARP and DSLYTYP) were shown to raise FSH-neutralizing antibodies, which were able to suppress estradiol levels. An additional leucine residue to VYKDPARP greatly enhanced the peptide's ability to inhibit FSH-receptor binding and caused fertility disruption in vivo.

Binding of rat and ovine epididymis-specific prealbumins (PES) to rat spermatozoa without effect of heterologous immunization on rat fertility

The epididymis, under control of testosterone, secretes proteins which bind to the membrane of the spermatozoa during their passage through the lumen. One such class is termed PES (prealbumin epididymal specific). Injection of heterologous oPES (ovine PES) into male rats caused antibody production but failed to induce sterility, unlike results previously obtained when rat PES was injected into male rats. This suggests that only very restricted species-specific epitopes of PES might be useful for causing immunocontraception. Despite this, the sperm binding properties of PES purified from the rat (rat PES) and from the ram (oPES) were shown to be similar. When either rat PES or oPES, conjugated with a fluorescent probe (dimethylamino-fluorescein), was incubated with washed rat spermatozoa originating from the caput, corpus or cauda epididymis, results of flow cytometric analysis showed: (1) the number of spermatozoa bound to isologous or heterologous fluorescent PES, and (2) the binding-affinity of spermatozoa for PES was greater for sperm collected from more distal sites in the epididymis.

Microvascular permeability to the F(ab')2 fragment of IgG in the male rat reproductive tract at puberty

Development of contraceptive vaccines has recently raised much interest following the cloning of the sperm and oocyte components involved in the sperm-oocyte interaction. The main difficulty of immunocontraception in the male is the poor access of antibodies to the luminal compartment. As recent literature suggests that many substances are transported to the testis by receptor-mediated or fluid-phase transcytosis, the dependence of the transport of IgG on the Fc receptor was studied in the present investigation by comparing the penetration of whole IgG and the F(ab')2 fragment of IgG to the testis and epididymis. The maximum volume of distribution (Veq) for the F(ab')2 fragment was significantly higher than that for whole IgG in the testis of 30-60-day old rats, in the caput and cauda of 30- and 45-day old rats and the corpus of 45-day old rats. The speeds at which equilibrium between tissue extracellular fluid and serum was reached (K) for the F(ab')2 fragment and whole IgG were significantly different in the testicular capsule of the 60-day old, in the caput and corpus of the 45- and 60-day old and in the cauda of the 45-day old rats. The microvascular permeabilities (PE) to the F(ab')2 fragment were more than 2-fold higher than those to whole IgG in the testis of the 20-, 45- and 60-day old, in the testicular capsule of the 20- and 45-day old, in the caput of 20-, 30- and 60-day old and in the corpus of 20-day old rats. The PE to whole IgG was more than 2-fold higher than that to the F(ab')2 fragment in the cauda of the 45-day-old rats. The PE to the F(ab')2 fragment increased steadily from 20 to 60 days of age in the testis and caput, but in the corpus there was a more abrupt increase between 30 and 45 days of age. In the cauda, PE remained in the same range of magnitude throughout pubertal development. These results suggest that the F(ab')2 fragment reaches the lumen of the reproductive tract more easily than whole IgG from 30 days of age onwards in the testis, whereas in the caput, corpus and cauda epididymidis the rate at which F(ab')2 fragment reaches the lumen increases only temporarily at the time of appearance of spermatozoa in the lumen. Transport of IgG to the male reproductive tract is thus unlikely to be mediated by Fc receptors.

On the horizon: new options for contraception

Future contraceptives include refinements of existing contraceptives and totally new methods. New formulations of oral contraceptives, subdermal hormonal implants, injectable hormones, vaginal spermicides, and intrauterine devices (IUDs) are being tested around the world. New methods that are not yet available include the use of vaginal preparations containing sperm-immobilizing agents, gonadotrophin releasing hormone agonists and antagonists, vaccines against ova and sperm, and endogenous hormones. Male contraceptive methods use hormones to suppress testosterone and vaccines to immobilize sperm. The availability of all future contraceptives is dependent on ample funds for research, development, and testing, and such funds are in jeopardy.

Sperm-binding proteins

Gamete recognition and binding are mediated by specific proteins on the surface of the sperm and egg. Identification and characterization of some of these proteins from several model systems, particularly mouse and sea urchin, have focused interest on the general properties and functions of gamete recognition proteins. Sperm-binding proteins located in egg extracellular coats as well as sperm-binding proteins that are localized to the egg plasma membrane are presented in the context of their structure and function in gamete binding. Unifying and disparate characteristics are discussed in light of the diverse biology of fertilization among species. Outstanding questions, alternative mechanisms and models, and strategies for future work are presented.