COLLAGEN STRUCTURES CONSIDERED AS STATES OF AGGREGATION OF A KINETIC UNIT. THE TROPOCOLLAGEN PARTICLE

Collagen fibril formation in vitro: From origin to opportunities

Sometimes, to move forward, it is necessary to look back. Collagen type I is one of the most commonly used biomaterials in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine. There are a variety of collagen scaffolds and biomedical products based on collagen have been made, and the development of new ones is still ongoing. Materials, where collagen is in the fibrillar form, have some advantages: they have superior mechanical properties, higher degradation time and, what is most important, mimic the structure of the native extracellular matrix. There are some standard protocols for the formation of collagen fibrils in vitro, but if we look more carefully at those methods, we can see some controversies. For example, why is the formation of collagen gel commonly carried out at 37 ​°C, when it was well investigated that the temperature higher than 35 ​°C results in a formation of not well-ordered fibrils? Biomimetic collagen materials can be obtained both using culture medium or neutralizing solution, but it requires a deep understanding of all of the crucial points. One of this point is collagen extraction method, since not every method retains the ability of collagen to reconstitute native banded fibrils. Collagen polymorphism is also often overlooked in spite of the appearance of different polymorphic forms during fibril formation is possible, especially when collagen blends are utilized. In this review, we will not only pay attention to these issues, but we will overview the most prominent works related to the formation of collagen fibrils in vitro starting from the first approaches and moving to the up-to-date recipes.

Application of Alginate Hydrogels for Next-Generation Articular Cartilage Regeneration

The articular cartilage has insufficient intrinsic healing abilities, and articular cartilage injuries often progress to osteoarthritis. Alginate-based scaffolds are attractive biomaterials for cartilage repair and regeneration, allowing for the delivery of cells and therapeutic drugs and gene sequences. In light of the heterogeneity of findings reporting the benefits of using alginate for cartilage regeneration, a better understanding of alginate-based systems is needed in order to improve the approaches aiming to enhance cartilage regeneration with this compound. This review provides an in-depth evaluation of the literature, focusing on the manipulation of alginate as a tool to support the processes involved in cartilage healing in order to demonstrate how such a material, used as a direct compound or combined with cell and gene therapy and with scaffold-guided gene transfer procedures, may assist cartilage regeneration in an optimal manner for future applications in patients.

Segment-Long-Spacing (SLS) and the Polymorphic Structures of Fibrillar Collagen

The diverse and complex functions of collagen during the development of an organism are closely related to the polymorphism of its supramolecular structures in the extracellular matrix. SLS (segment-long-spacing) is one of the best understood alternative structures of collagen. SLS played an instrumental role in the original studies of collagen more than half a century ago that laid the foundation of nearly everything we know about collagen today. Despite being used mostly under in vitro conditions, the natural occurrence of SLS in tissues has also been reported. Here we will provide a brief overview of the major findings of the SLS and other structures of collagen based on a wealth of work published starting from the 1940s. We will discuss the factors that determine the stability and the structural specificity of the different molecular assemblies of collagen in light of the new studies using designed fibril forming collagen peptides. At the end of the chapter, we will summarize some recent discoveries of the alternative structures of collagen in tissues, especially those involved in pathogenic states. A revisit of SLS will likely inspire new understandings concerning the range of critical roles of fibrillar collagen in terms of its organizational diversity in the extracellular matrix.

Development of Fluorescently Labeled, Functional Type I Collagen Molecules

While de novo collagen fibril formation is well-studied, there are few investigations into the growth and remodeling of extant fibrils, where molecular collagen incorporation into and erosion from the fibril surface must delicately balance during fibril growth and remodeling. Observing molecule/fibril interactions is difficult, requiring the tracking of molecular dynamics while, at the same time, minimizing the effect of the observation on fibril structure and assembly. To address the observation-interference problem, exogenous collagen molecules are tagged with small fluorophores and the fibrillogenesis kinetics of labeled collagen molecules as well as the structure and network morphology of assembled fibrils are examined. While excessive labeling significantly disturbs fibrillogenesis kinetics and network morphology of assembled fibrils, adding less than ≈1.2 labels per collagen molecule preserves these characteristics. Applications of the functional, labeled collagen probe are demonstrated in both cellular and acellular systems. The functional, labeled collagen associates strongly with native fibrils and when added to an in vitro model of corneal stromal development at low concentration, the labeled collagen is incorporated into a fine extracellular matrix (ECM) network associated with the cells within 24 h.

Method for measurement of collagen monomer orientation in fluorescence microscopy

SIGNIFICANCE

Collagen is the most abundant protein in vertebrates and is found in tissues that regularly experience tension, compression, and shear forces. However, the underlying mechanism of collagen fibril formation and remodeling is poorly understood.

AIM

We explore how a collagen monomer is visualized using fluorescence microscopy and how its spatial orientation is determined. Defining the orientation of collagen monomers is not a trivial problem, as the monomer has a weak contrast and is relatively small. It is possible to attach fluorescence tags for contrast, but the size is still a problem for detecting orientation using fluorescence microscopy.

APPROACH

We present two methods for detecting a monomer and classifying its orientation. A modified Gabor filter set and an automatic classifier trained by convolutional neural network based on a synthetic dataset were used.

RESULTS

By evaluating the performance of these two approaches with synthetic and experimental data, our results show that it is possible to determine the location and orientation with an error of ∼37  deg of a single monomer with fluorescence microscopy.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings can contribute to our understanding of collagen monomers interaction with collagen fibrils surface during fibril formation and remodeling.

Measuring collagen fibril diameter with differential interference contrast microscopy

Collagen fibrils, linear arrangements of collagen monomers, 20-500 nm in diameter, comprising hundreds of molecules in their cross-section, are the fundamental structural unit in a variety of load-bearing tissues such as tendons, ligaments, skin, cornea, and bone. These fibrils often assemble into more complex structures, providing mechanical stability, strength, or toughness to the host tissue. Unfortunately, there is little information available on individual fibril dynamics, mechanics, growth, aggregation and remodeling because they are difficult to image using visible light as a probe. The principle quantity of interest is the fibril diameter, which is difficult to extract accurately, dynamically, in situ and non-destructively. An optical method, differential interference contrast (DIC) microscopy has been used to visualize dynamic structures that are as small as microtubules (25 nm diameter) and has been shown to be sensitive to the size of objects smaller than the wavelength of light. In this investigation, we take advantage of DIC microscopy's ability to report dimensions of nanometer scale objects to generate a curve that relates collagen diameter to DIC edge intensity shift (DIC-EIS). We further calibrate the curve using electron microscopy and demonstrate a linear correlation between fibril diameter and the DIC-EIS. Using a non-oil immersion, 40x objective (NA 0.6), collagen fibril diameters between ~100 nm to ~ 300 nm could be obtained with ±11 and ±4 nm accuracy for dehydrated and hydrated fibrils, respectively. This simple, nondestructive, label free method should advance our ability to directly examine fibril dynamics under experimental conditions that are physiologically relevant.

Self-assembly of collagen-based biomaterials: preparation, characterizations and biomedical applications

By combining regulatory parameters with characterization methods, researchers can selectively fabricate collagenous biomaterials with various functional responses for biomedical applications.

Fell Muir Lecture: Collagen fibril formation in vitro and in vivo

It is a great honour to be awarded the Fell Muir Prize for 2016 by the British Society of Matrix Biology. As recipient of the prize, I am taking the opportunity to write a minireview on collagen fibrillogenesis, which has been the focus of my research for 33 years. This is the process by which triple helical collagen molecules assemble into centimetre-long fibrils in the extracellular matrix of animals. The fibrils appeared a billion years ago at the dawn of multicellular animal life as the primary scaffold for tissue morphogenesis. The fibrils occur in exquisite three-dimensional architectures that match the physical demands of tissues, for example orthogonal lattices in cornea, basket weaves in skin and blood vessels, and parallel bundles in tendon, ligament and nerves. The question of how collagen fibrils are formed was posed at the end of the nineteenth century. Since then, we have learned about the structure of DNA and the peptide bond, understood how plants capture the sun's energy, cloned animals, discovered antibiotics and found ways of editing our genome in the pursuit of new cures for diseases. However, how cells generate tissues from collagen fibrils remains one of the big unsolved mysteries in biology. In this review, I will give a personal account of the topic and highlight some of the approaches that my research group are taking to find new insights.

Visualizing In Vitro Type I Collagen Fibrillogenesis by Transmission Electron Microscopy

Techniques and protocols for the in vitro formation of collagen type I fibrils and the extensive biochemical variation of the fibrillogenesis conditions are presented. In all cases, the incubation and fibrillogenesis product can be readily monitored by transmission electron microscopic study of negatively stained specimens. Representative TEM data is presented and discussed within the context of the products of the fibrillogenesis protocols, from which the extensive biochemical and structural possibilities of this integrated approach can be appreciated.

The collagen type I segment long spacing (SLS) and fibrillar forms: Formation by ATP and sulphonated diazo dyes

The collagen type I segment long spacing (SLS) crystallite is a well-ordered rod-like molecular aggregate, ∼300nm in length, which is produced in vitro under mildly acidic conditions (pH 2.5-3.5) in the presence of 1mM ATP. The formation of the SLS crystallite amplifies the inherent linear structural features of individual collagen heterotrimers, due to the punctate linear distribution and summation of the bulkier amino acid side chains along the length of individual collagen heterotrimers. This can be correlated structurally with the 67nm D-banded collagen fibril that is found in vivo, and formed in vitro. Although first described many years ago, the range of conditions required for ATP-induced SLS crystallite formation from acid-soluble collagen have not been explored extensively. Consequently, we have addressed biochemical parameters such as the ATP concentration, pH, speed of formation and stability so as to provide a more complete structural understanding of the SLS crystallite. Treatment of collagen type I with 1mM ATP at neutral and higher pH (6.0-9.0) also induced the formation of D-banded fibrils. Contrary to previous studies, we have shown that the polysulphonated diazo dyes Direct red (Sirius red) and Evans blue, but not Congo red and Methyl blue, can also induce the formation of SLS-like aggregates of collagen, but under markedly different ionic conditions to those employed in the presence of ATP. Specifically, pre-formed D-banded collagen fibrils, prepared in a higher than the usual physiological NaCl concentration (e.g. 500mM NaCl, 20mM Tris-HCl pH7.4 or x3 PBS), readily form SLS aggregates when treated with 0.1mM Direct red and Evans blue, but this did not occur at lower NaCl concentrations. These new data are discussed in relation to the anion (Cl(-)) and polyanion (phosphate and sulphonate) binding by the collagen heterotrimer and their likely role in collagen fibrillogenesis and SLS formation.

Estimating the 3D pore size distribution of biopolymer networks from directionally biased data

The pore size of biopolymer networks governs their mechanical properties and strongly impacts the behavior of embedded cells. Confocal reflection microscopy and second harmonic generation microscopy are widely used to image biopolymer networks; however, both techniques fail to resolve vertically oriented fibers. Here, we describe how such directionally biased data can be used to estimate the network pore size. We first determine the distribution of distances from random points in the fluid phase to the nearest fiber. This distribution follows a Rayleigh distribution, regardless of isotropy and data bias, and is fully described by a single parameter--the characteristic pore size of the network. The bias of the pore size estimate due to the missing fibers can be corrected by multiplication with the square root of the visible network fraction. We experimentally verify the validity of this approach by comparing our estimates with data obtained using confocal fluorescence microscopy, which represents the full structure of the network. As an important application, we investigate the pore size dependence of collagen and fibrin networks on protein concentration. We find that the pore size decreases with the square root of the concentration, consistent with a total fiber length that scales linearly with concentration.

Utility of an optically-based, micromechanical system for printing collagen fibers

Collagen's success as the principal structural element in load-bearing, connective tissue has motivated the development of numerous engineering approaches designed to recapitulate native fibril morphology and strength. It has been shown recently that collagen fibers can be drawn from monomeric solution through a fiber forming buffer (FFB), followed by numerous additional treatments in a complex serial process. However, internal fibril alignment, packing and resultant mechanical behavior of the fibers have not been optimized and remain inferior to native tissue. Further, no system has been developed which permits simultaneous application of molecular crowding, measurement of applied load, and direct observation of polymerization dynamics during fiber printing. The ability to perform well-controlled investigations early in the process of fiber formation, which vary single input parameters (i.e. collagen concentration, crowding agent concentration, draw rate, flow rate, temperature, pH, etc.) should substantially improve fiber morphology and strength. We have thus designed, built, and tested a versatile, in situ, optically-based, micromechanical assay and fiber printing system which permits the correlation of parameter changes with mechanical properties of fibers immediately after deposition into an FFB. We demonstrate the sensitivity of the assay by detecting changes in the fiber mechanics in response to draw rate, collagen type, small changes in the molecular crowding agent concentration and to variations in pH. In addition we found the ability to observe fiber polymerization dynamics leads to intriguing new insights into collagen assembly behavior.

Nanostructure and mechanics of mummified type I collagen from the 5300-year-old Tyrolean Iceman

Skin protects the body from pathogens and degradation. Mummified skin in particular is extremely resistant to decomposition. External influences or the action of micro-organisms, however, can degrade the connective tissue and lay the subjacent tissue open. To determine the degree of tissue preservation in mummified human skin and, in particular, the reason for its durability, we investigated the structural integrity of its main protein, type I collagen. We extracted samples from the Neolithic glacier mummy known as ‘the Iceman’. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) revealed collagen fibrils that had characteristic banding patterns of 69 ± 5 nm periodicity. Both the microstructure and the ultrastructure of dermal collagen bundles and fibrils were largely unaltered and extremely well preserved by the natural conservation process. Raman spectra of the ancient collagen indicated that there were no significant modifications in the molecular structure. However, AFM nanoindentation measurements showed slight changes in the mechanical behaviour of the fibrils. Young's modulus of single mummified fibrils was 4.1 ± 1.1 GPa, whereas the elasticity of recent collagen averages 3.2 ± 1.0 GPa. The excellent preservation of the collagen indicates that dehydration owing to freeze-drying of the collagen is the main process in mummification and that the influence of the degradation processes can be addressed, even after 5300 years.

Dynamic shear-influenced collagen self-assembly

The ability to influence the direction of polymerization of a self-assembling biomolecular system has the potential to generate materials with extremely high anisotropy. In biological systems where highly-oriented cellular populations give rise to aligned and often load-bearing tissue such organized molecular scaffolds could aid in the contact guidance of cells for engineered tissue constructs (e.g. cornea and tendon). In this investigation we examine the detailed dynamics of pepsin-extracted type I bovine collagen assembly on a glass surface under the influence of flow between two plates. Differential Interference Contrast (DIC) imaging (60x-1.4NA) with focal plane stabilization was used to resolve and track the growth of collagen aggregates on borosilicate glass for 4 different shear rates (500, 80, 20, and 9s(-1)). The detailed morphology of the collagen fibrils/aggregates was examined using Quick Freeze Deep Etch (QFDE) electron microscopy. Nucleation of fibrils on the glass was observed to occur rapidly (approximately 2 min) followed by continued growth of the fibrils. The growth rates were dependent on flow in a complex manner with the highest rate of axial growth (0.1 micro/s) occurring at a shear rate of 9s(-1). The lowest growth rate occurred at the highest shear. Fibrils were observed to both branch and join during the experiments. The best alignment of fibrils was observed at intermediate shear rates of 20 and 80s(-1). However, the investigation revealed that fibril directional growth was not stable. At high shear rates, fibrils would often turn downstream forming what we term "hooks" which are likely the combined result of monomer interaction with the initial collagen layer or "mat" and the high shear rate. Further, QFDE examination of fibril morphology demonstrated that the assembled fibrillar structure did not possess native D-periodicity. Instead, fibrils comprised a collection of generally aligned, monomers which were self-assembled to form a fibril-like aggregate. In conclusion, though constant shear-rate clearly influences collagen fibrillar alignment, the formation of highly-organized collagenous arrays of native-like D-banded fibrils remains a challenge. Modulation of shear in combination with surface energy patterning to produce a highly-aligned initial mat may provide significant improvement of both the fibril morphology and alignment.

Post-self-assembly experimentation on extruded collagen fibres for tissue engineering applications

Extruded collagen fibres have been shown to constitute a biomimetic three-dimensional scaffold with numerous tissue engineering applications. The multi-step fabrication process of this material provides opportunities for further advancements to improve the properties of the final product. Herein we investigated the influence of the post-self-assembly washing baths on the structural, mechanical and thermal properties of these fibres. The surface morphology and the inter-fibre packing were similar for every treatment. The overnight incubation in isopropanol yielded fibres with the highest temperature and energy of denaturation (p<0.013). Typical s- and j-shape stress-strain curves were obtained for all treatments in the dry and wet state respectively. Rehydration of the fibres resulted in increased fibre diameter (p<0.006) and reduced stress (p<0.001), force (p<0.001) and modulus (p<0.002) values for every treatment. In the dry state, the alcohol-treated fibres were characterized by the highest stress (p<0.002) values; whilst in the wet state the Tris-HCl-treated fibres were the weakest (p<0.006). For every treatment, in both dry and wet state, a strong and inverse relationship between the fibre diameter and the stress at break was observed. Overall, the fibres produced were characterized by properties similar to those of native tissues.

Prelude to corneal tissue engineering - gaining control of collagen organization

By most standard engineering practice principles, it is premature to credibly discuss the "engineering" of a human cornea. A professional design engineer would assert that we still do not know what a cornea is (and correctly so), therefore we cannot possibly build one. The proof resides in the fact that there are no clinically viable corneas based on classical tissue engineering methods available. This is possibly because tissue engineering in the classical sense (seeding a degradable scaffolding with a population synthetically active cells) does not produce conditions which support the generation of organized tissue. Alternative approaches to the problem are in their infancy and include the methods which attempt to recapitulate development or to produce corneal stromal analogs de novo which require minimal remodeling. Nonetheless, tissue engineering efforts, which have been focused on producing the fundamental functional component of a cornea (organized alternating arrays of collagen or "lamellae"), may have already provided valuable new insights and tools relevant to development, growth, remodeling and pathologies associated with connective tissue in general. This is because engineers ask a fundamentally different question (How can that be done?) than do biological scientists (How is that done?). The difference in inquiry has prompted us to closely examine (and to mimic) development as well as investigate collagen physicochemical behavior so that we may exert control over organization both in cell culture (in vitro) and on the benchtop (de novo). Our initial results indicate that reproducing corneal stroma-like local and long-range organization of collagen may be simpler than we anticipated while controlling spacing and fibril morphology remains difficult, but perhaps not impossible in the (reasonably) near term.

Prelude to corneal tissue engineering - gaining control of collagen organization

By most standard engineering practice principles, it is premature to credibly discuss the "engineering" of a human cornea. A professional design engineer would assert that we still do not know what a cornea is (and correctly so), therefore we cannot possibly build one. The proof resides in the fact that there are no clinically viable corneas based on classical tissue engineering methods available. This is possibly because tissue engineering in the classical sense (seeding a degradable scaffolding with a population synthetically active cells) does not produce conditions which support the generation of organized tissue. Alternative approaches to the problem are in their infancy and include the methods which attempt to recapitulate development or to produce corneal stromal analogs de novo which require minimal remodeling. Nonetheless, tissue engineering efforts, which have been focused on producing the fundamental functional component of a cornea (organized alternating arrays of collagen or "lamellae"), may have already provided valuable new insights and tools relevant to development, growth, remodeling and pathologies associated with connective tissue in general. This is because engineers ask a fundamentally different question (How can that be done?) than do biological scientists (How is that done?). The difference in inquiry has prompted us to closely examine (and to mimic) development as well as investigate collagen physicochemical behavior so that we may exert control over organization both in cell culture (in vitro) and on the benchtop (de novo). Our initial results indicate that reproducing corneal stroma-like local and long-range organization of collagen may be simpler than we anticipated while controlling spacing and fibril morphology remains difficult, but perhaps not impossible in the (reasonably) near term.

From collagen chemistry towards cell therapy - a personal journey

The Fell-Muir Award requires the recipient to deliver a lecture and a review manuscript which provides a personal overview of significant scientific developments in the field of matrix biology over the period of the recipient's career. In this context, this review considers the collagen family of structural proteins and the advances in biochemical, molecular biological and genetic techniques which led to the elucidation of the structure, synthesis and function of this important group of extracellular matrix constituents. Particular attention is focussed on early research on the identification and assembly of the soluble precursors of collagen types I and II, and the identification of the precursor of basement membrane collagen type IV. In subsequent studies investigating the maintenance of the chick chondrocyte phenotype in culture, the influence of the extracellular milieu was found to influence markedly both cell morphology and collagen gene expression. These studies led to the discovery of collagen type X whose expression is restricted to hypertrophic chondrocytes at sites of endochondral ossification. Such research provided a prelude to investigations of mammalian endochondral ossification which is known to be aberrant in a variety of human chondrodysplasias and is reactivated in bone fracture repair and in osteoarthritis. The cloning of bovine and then human collagen type X genes facilitated studies in relevant human diseases and contributed to the discovery of mutations in the COL10A1 gene in families with metaphyseal chondrodysplasia type Schmid. Clustering of mutations in the C-terminal domain of the type X collagen molecule has now been widely documented and investigations of the pathogenic mechanisms in animal models are beginning to suggest the prospect of novel treatment strategies.

Fibrous long spacing type collagen fibrils have a hierarchical internal structure

Nanodissection of single fibrous long spacing (FLS) type collagen fibrils by atomic force microscopy (AFM) reveals hierarchical internal structure: Fibrillar subcomponents with diameters of approximately 10 to 20 nm were observed to be running parallel to the long axis of the fibril in which they are found. The fibrillar subcomponent displayed protrusions with characteristic approximately 270 nm periodicity, such that protrusions on neighboring subfibrils were aligned in register. Hence, the banding pattern of mature FLS-type collagen fibrils arises from the in-register alignment of these fibrillar subcomponents. This hierarchical organization observed in FLS-type collagen fibrils is different from that previously reported for native-type collagen fibrils, displaying no supercoiling at the level of organization observed.

Creating nanoscopic collagen matrices using atomic force microscopy

The atomic force microscope (AFM) is introduced as a biomolecular manipulation machine capable of assembling biological molecules into well-defined molecular structures. Native collagen molecules were mechanically directed into well-defined, two-dimensional templates exhibiting patterns with feature sizes ranging from a few nanometers to several hundreds of micrometers. The resulting nanostructured collagen matrices were only approximately 3-nm thick, exhibited an extreme mechanical stability, and maintained their properties over the time range of several months. Our results directly demonstrate the plasticity of biological assemblies and provide insight into the physical mechanisms by which biological structures may be organized by cells in vivo. These nanoscopic templates may serve as platforms on non-biological surfaces to direct molecular and cellular processes.

Hierarchical assembly and the onset of banding in fibrous long spacing collagen revealed by atomic force microscopy

The mechanism of formation of fibrillar collagen with a banding periodicity much greater than the 67 nm of native collagen, i.e. the so-called fibrous long spacing (FLS) collagen, has been speculated upon, but has not been previously studied experimentally from a detailed structural perspective. In vitro, such fibrils, with banding periodicity of approximately 270 nm, may be produced by dialysis of an acidic solution of type I collagen and alpha(1)-acid glycoprotein against deionized water. FLS collagen assembly was investigated by visualization of assembly intermediates that were formed during the course of dialysis using atomic force microscopy. Below pH 4, thin, curly nonbanded fibrils were formed. When the dialysis solution reached approximately pH 4, thin, filamentous structures that showed protrusions spaced at approximately 270 nm were seen. As the pH increased, these protofibrils appeared to associate loosely into larger fibrils with clear approximately 270 nm banding which increased in diameter and compactness, such that by approximately pH 4.6, mature FLS collagen fibrils begin to be observed with increasing frequency. These results suggest that there are aspects of a stepwise process in the formation of FLS collagen, and that the banding pattern arises quite early and very specifically in this process. It is proposed that typical 4D-period staggered microfibril subunits assemble laterally with minimal stagger between adjacent fibrils. alpha(1)-Acid glycoprotein presumably promotes this otherwise abnormal lateral assembly over native-type self-assembly. Cocoon-like fibrils, which are hundreds of nanometers in diameter and 10-20 microm in length, were found to coexist with mature FLS fibrils.

Investigating the ultrastructure of fibrous long spacing collagen by parallel atomic force and transmission electron microscopy

The ultrastructure of fibrous long spacing (FLS) collagen fibrils has been investigated by performing both atomic force microscopy (AFM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) on exactly the same area of FLS collagen fibril samples. These FLS collagen fibrils were formed in vitro from type I collagen and alpha1-acid glycoprotein (AAG) solutions. On the basis of the correlated AFM and TEM images obtained before and after negative staining, the periodic dark bands observed in TEM images along the longitudinal axis of the FLS collagen fibril correspond directly to periodic protrusions seen by AFM. This observation is in agreement with the original surmise made by Gross, Highberger, and Schmitt (Gross J, Highberger JH, Schmitt FO, Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1954;40:679-688) that the major repeating dark bands of FLS collagen fibrils observed under TEM are thick relative to the interband region. Although these results do not refute the idea of negative stain penetration into gap regions proposed by Hodge and Petruska (Petruska JA, Hodge AJ. Aspects of protein structure. Ramachandran GN, editor. New York: Academic Press; 1963. p. 289-300), there is no need to invoke the presence of gap regions to explain the periodic dark bands observed in TEM images of FLS collagen fibrils.

Some highlights in the emergence of modern concepts of osteoarthritis

The present-day concept that osteoarthritis may be amenable to biological modification rather than a hopeless expression of old age or injury has historical roots in the period of 1935 through the early 1970s. One root was the structural and chemical delineation of the connective tissues: discovery of the proteoglycans and multiple molecular species of collagen. Another was the recognition of the ability of mature articular chondrocytes to replicate themselves rather than being terminally differentiated. A third was the elucidation of the engineering physiology of the joint: the role of matrix hydrophilia to the material properties of articular cartilage and biolubrication. Each root has direct relevance to ongoing therapeutic approaches to degenerative joint disease. The early epidemiological studies of Kellgren and Lawrence evolved into new techniques for testing their validity in clinical practice. Along the way there was a rich 2-way interaction between scientists and clinicians in arriving at these ideas.

A study of fibrous long spacing collagen ultrastructure and assembly by atomic force microscopy

Fibrous long spacing collagen (FLS) fibrils are collagen fibrils that display a banding with periodicity greater than the 67nm periodicity of native collagen. FLS fibrils can be formed in vitro by addition of alpha(1)-acid glycoprotein to an acidified solution of monomeric collagen, followed by dialysis of the resulting mixture. We have investigated the ultrastructure of FLS fibrils formed in vitro using the atomic force microscope (AFM). The majority of the fibrils imaged showed typical diameters of approximately 150nm and had a distinct banding pattern with a approximately 250nm periodicity. However, we have also observed an additional type of FLS fibril, which is characterized by a secondary banding pattern surrounding the primary bands. These results are compared with those obtained in past investigations of FLS ultrastructure carried out using the transmission electron microscope (TEM). The importance of the fibril's surface topography in TEM staining patterns is discussed. Images of FLS fibrils in various stages of assembly have also been collected, and the implications of these images in determining the mechanism of assembly and the formation of the characteristic banding pattern of the fibrils is discussed.

Abnormal collagen assembly, though normal phenotype, in alginate bead cultures of chick embryo chondrocytes

The collagens produced by chick embryo chondrocytes cultured in alginate beads were investigated both biochemically and ultrastructurally. The cartilage phenotype is maintained for at least 14 days, as indicated by the production of the cartilage-specific collagens II, IX, and XI and the absence of collagen I. There were differences in the distributions of collagens among the three different compartments analyzed (cells and their associated matrix, further-removed matrix (released by alginate solubilization), and culture medium), with large amounts of collagen IX (mainly in proteoglycan form) in the culture medium. Inhibition of lysyl oxidase activity by beta-aminopropionitrile led to an overall decrease in collagen production. In contrast to the biochemical observations, collagen ultrastructure in the extracellular matrix of alginate cultures was not in the form of the expected 64-nm banded fibrils, but rather in the form of segment-long-spacing-like crystallites. This abnormal structure is likely to be a result of alginate disrupting normal assembly. We conclude that, in this system, the native fibrillar structure of the collagenous matrix is not essential for the maintenance of the differentiated phenotype of chondrocytes.

Morphological and chemical studies of collagen formation. II. Metabolic activity of collagen associated with subcellular fractions of guinea pig granulomata

Electron micrographs of thin sections of nuclear, microsomal, and mitochondrial fractions obtained from a carrageenin-induced granuloma showed considerable contamination of the heavier by the lighter fractions. Striated collagen fibrils could be identified in the nuclei + debris fraction. Only a few striated fibrils occurred in the mitochondrial fraction; very fine filaments (diameter 50 A) could be seen in this fraction, but could not be distinguished with certainty from fibrillar material derived from broken nuclei. 35 per cent of the mitochondrial and 80 per cent of the microsomal collagen was extractable by 0.2 M NaCl and could be purified by the standard methods of solution and reprecipitation. The amino acid composition of these collagen fractions determined by ion exchange chromatography was within the range normally found for collagen and gelatin from other mammalian species, allowing for 10 to 20 per cent of some non-collagenous contaminant of the microsomal collagen. Hydroxyproline and proline were isolated by chromatography on paper from hydrolysates of the nuclear, mitochondrial, and microsomal collagen fractions, after incubation of tissue slices with L-¹⁴C-proline. The specific activities of the hydroxyproline from these collagens were in the approximate ratio 1:2:6, while that of bound hydroxyproline derived from the supernatant was only 1, indicating primary synthesis of collagen in the microsomes. Attempts to demonstrate incorporation of L-¹⁴C-proline into collagen or into free hydroxyproline in cell free systems were unsuccessful, nor was it possible to demonstrate non-specific incorporation of L-¹⁴C-valine into TCA-insoluble material by various combinations of subcellular fractions.

Studies on the mode of action of lathyrogenic compounds

The lathyrogenic effect of INAH in the chick embryo may be measured by the increase in the extractibility of collagen from the bones with 1 M NaCl. Incubation of these bones in vitro with carbonyl compounds diminishes the amount of extractible collagen; with D-L-glyceraldehyde the reversal of the INAH effect is complete. This reversal effect is dependent on the time and temperature of incubation and on the quantity of D-L-glyceraldehyde, but is independent of the pH of the incubating medium, the optical form of the glyceraldehyde, or the metabolism of the cells; this suggests that it depends on a simple chemical combination. D-L-glyceraldehyde also reverses completely the extractibility of collagen from the bones of embryos rendered lathyrogenic with BAPN, semicarbazide, and hydrazine hydrate. The hypothesis has been advanced "that lathyrogenic agents act by blocking carbonyl groups on the collagen molecule, thus preventing cross-linking essential to normal maturation; normal maturation may be restored by the addition of carbonyl groups which act by competing either for the lathyrogen or for functional sites on the collagen molecule." In support of this hypothesis, it has been shown that purified lathyritic guinea pig collagen takes up lesser amounts of 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine—a compound which combines with carbonyl groups—than does normal collagen; it has been shown that lathyritic collagen still possesses the ability to form segment-long-spacing (SLS) collagen, but that these fibres are much thinner than normal; this is due perhaps to blockade of groups essential for lateral cross-linking of the tropocollagen unit. It has also been shown that normal, purified guinea pig collagen which has been pretreated with INAH, takes up lesser amounts of 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine and forms much thinner SLS fibres than the untreated controls.

Fibrous long spacing collagen ultrastructure elucidated by atomic force microscopy

Fibrous long spacing collagen (FLS) fibrils are collagen fibrils in which the periodicity is clearly greater than the 67-nm periodicity of native collagen. FLS fibrils were formed in vitro by the addition of alpha1-acid glycoprotein to an acidified solution of monomeric collagen and were imaged with atomic force microscopy. The fibrils formed were typically approximately 150 nm in diameter and had a distinct banding pattern with a 250-nm periodicity. At higher resolution, the mature FLS fibrils showed ultrastructure, both on the bands and in the interband region, which appears as protofibrils aligned along the main fibril axis. The alignment of protofibrils produced grooves along the main fibril, which were 2 nm deep and 20 nm in width. Examination of the tips of FLS fibrils suggests that they grow via the merging of protofibrils to the tip, followed by the entanglement and, ultimately, the tight packing of protofibrils. A comparison is made with native collagen in terms of structure and mechanism of assembly.