In vivo 23Na and 31P NMR measurement of a tonoplast Na+/H+ exchange process and its characteristics in two barley cultivars

Root vacuolar Na+ sequestration but not exclusion from uptake correlates with barley salt tolerance

Soil salinity is a major constraint for the global agricultural production. For many decades, Na⁺ exclusion from uptake has been the key trait targeted in breeding programs; yet, no major breakthrough in creating salt-tolerant germplasm was achieved. In this work, we have combined the microelectrode ion flux estimation (MIFE) technique for non-invasive ion flux measurements with confocal fluorescence dye imaging technique to screen 45 accessions of barley to reveal the relative contribution of Na⁺ exclusion from the cytosol to the apoplast and its vacuolar sequestration in the root apex, for the overall salinity stress tolerance. We show that Na⁺ /H⁺ antiporter-mediated Na⁺ extrusion from the root plays a minor role in the overall salt tolerance in barley. At the same time, a strong and positive correlation was found between root vacuolar Na⁺ sequestration ability and the overall salt tolerance. The inability of salt-sensitive genotypes to sequester Na⁺ in root vacuoles was in contrast to significantly higher expression levels of both HvNHX1 tonoplast Na⁺ /H⁺ antiporters and HvVP1 H⁺ -pumps compared with tolerant genotypes. These data are interpreted as a failure of sensitive varieties to prevent Na⁺ back-leak into the cytosol and existence of a futile Na⁺ cycle at the tonoplast. Taken together, our results demonstrated that root vacuolar Na⁺ sequestration but not exclusion from uptake played the main role in barley salinity tolerance, and suggested that the focus of the breeding programs should be shifted from targeting genes mediating Na⁺ exclusion from uptake by roots to more efficient root vacuolar Na⁺ sequestration.

Increased tolerance to salt stress in the phosphate-accumulating Arabidopsis mutants siz1 and pho2

High salinity is an environmental factor that inhibits plant growth and development, leading to large losses in crop yields. We report here that mutations in SIZ1 or PHO2, which cause more accumulation of phosphate compared with the wild type, enhance tolerance to salt stress. The siz1 and pho2 mutations reduce the uptake and accumulation of Na(+). These mutations are also able to suppress the Na(+) hypersensitivity of the sos3-1 mutant, and genetic analyses suggest that SIZ1 and SOS3 or PHO2 and SOS3 have an additive effect on the response to salt stress. Furthermore, the siz1 mutation cannot suppress the Li(+) hypersensitivity of the sos3-1 mutant. These results indicate that the phosphate-accumulating mutants siz1 and pho2 reduce the uptake and accumulation of Na(+), leading to enhanced salt tolerance, and that, genetically, SIZ1 and PHO2 are likely independent of SOS3-dependent salt signaling.

Insights into the salt tolerance mechanism in barley (Hordeum vulgare) from comparisons of cultivars that differ in salt sensitivity

Although barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) is a salt-tolerant crop, the underlying physiological and molecular mechanisms of salt tolerance remain to be elucidated. Therefore, we investigated the response of salt-tolerant (K305) and salt-sensitive (I743) cultivars to salt stress at both physiological and molecular levels. Salt treatment increased xylem sap osmolarity, which was attributed primarily to a rise in Na(+) and Cl(-) concentration; enhanced accumulation of the ions in shoots; and reduced plant growth more severely in I743 than K305. The concentration of K(+) in roots and shoots decreased during 8 h of salt treatment in both cultivars but with no marked difference between cultivars. Hence, the severe growth reduction in I743 is attributed to the elevated levels of (mainly) Na(+) in shoots. Analysis of gene expression using quantitative RT-PCR showed that transcripts of K(+)-transporters (HvHAK1 and HvAKT1), vacuolar H(+)-ATPase and inorganic pyrophosphatase (HvHVA/68 and HvHVP1) were more abundant in shoots of K305 than in shoots of I743. Expression of HvHAK1 and Na(+)/H(+) antiporters (HvNHX1, HvNHX3 and HvNHX4) was higher in roots of K305 than in I743 with prolonged exposure to salt. Taken together, these results suggest that the better performance of K305 compared to I743 during salt stress may be related to its greater ability to sequester Na(+) into sub-cellular compartments and/or maintain K(+) homeostasis.

Response of nitrogen fixation in relation to nodule carbohydrate metabolism in Medicago ciliaris lines subjected to salt stress

The effect of salt stress on nitrogen fixation, in relation to sucrose transport towards nodules and other sink organs and the potential of sucrose breakdown by nodules, was investigated in two lines of Medicago ciliaris. Under salt stress conditions, the two lines showed a decrease of total biomass production, but TNC 1.8 was less affected by salt than TNC 11.9. The chlorophyll content was not changed in TNC 1.8, in contrast to TNC 11.9. Shoot, root, and nodule biomass were also affected in the two lines, but TNC 1.8 exhibited the higher potentialities of biomass production of these organs. Nitrogen fixation also decreased in the two lines, and was more sensitive to salt than growth parameters. TNC 1.8 consistently exhibited the higher values of nitrogen fixation. Unlike nodules, leaves of both lines were well supplied in nutrients with some exceptions. Specifically, the calcium content decreased in the sensitive line leaves, and the nodule magnesium content was not changed in either line. The tolerant line accumulated more sodium in its leaves. The two lines did not show any differences in the nodule sodium content. Sucrose allocation towards nodules was affected by salt in the two lines, but this constraint did not seem to affect the repartition of sucrose between sink organs. Salt stress induced perturbations in nodule sucrolytic activities in the two lines. It inhibited sucrose synthase, but the inhibition was more marked in TNC 11.9; alkaline/neutral activity was not altered in TNC 1.8, whereas it decreased more than half in TNC 11.9. Thus, the relative tolerance of TNC 1.8 to salt stress could be attributed to a better use of these photoassimilates by nodules and a better supply of bacteroids in malate. The hypothesis of a competition for sucrose between nodules and other sink organs under salt stress could not be verified.

Na+ transport in plants

The ability of plants to grow in high NaCl concentrations is associated with the ability of the plants to transport, compartmentalize, extrude, and mobilize Na(+) ions. While the influx and efflux at the roots establish the steady state rate of entry of Na(+) into the plant, the compartmentation of Na(+) into the cell vacuoles and the radial transport of Na(+) to the stele and its loading into the xylem establish the homeostatic control of Na(+) in the cytosol of the root cells. Removal of Na(+) from the transpirational stream, its distribution within the plant and its progressive accumulation in the leaf vacuoles, will determine the ability to deal with the toxic effects of Na(+). The aim of this review is to highlight and discuss the recent progress in understanding of Na(+) transport in plants.

A novel fluorescent pH probe for expression in plants

BACKGROUND

The pH is an important parameter controlling many metabolic and signalling pathways in living cells. Recombinant fluorescent pH indicators (pHluorins) have come into vogue for monitoring cellular pH. They are derived from the most popular Aequorea victoria GFP (Av-GFP). Here, we present a novel fluorescent pH reporter protein from the orange seapen Ptilosarcus gurneyi (Pt-GFP) and compare its properties with pHluorins for expression and use in plants.

RESULTS

pHluorins have a higher pH-sensitivity. However, Pt-GFP has a broader pH-responsiveness, an excellent dynamic ratio range and a better acid stability. We demonstrate how Pt-GFP expressing Arabidopsis thaliana report cytosolic pH-clamp and changes of cytosolic pH in the response to anoxia and salt-stress.

CONCLUSION

Pt-GFP appears to be the better choice when used for in vivo-recording of cellular pH in plants.

23Na NMR microimaging: a tool for non-invasive monitoring of sodium distribution in living plants

Detailed knowledge of the sodium (Na) distribution within the tissues of highly salt-tolerant Australian native species could help in understanding the physiological adaptations of salt-tolerance or salt-sensitive plants. ²³Na nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) microimaging is presented as a tool to achieve this goal. Maps of the Na distribution in stem tissue were obtained with an in-plane resolution of approximately125 µm and a slice thickness of 4 mm. Simultaneously recorded high resolution ¹H NMR images showing water distribution in the same slice with 31 µm in-plane resolution and 1 mm slice thickness, were used as an anatomical reference together with optical micrographs that were taken immediately after the NMR experiments were completed. To quantify the Na concentration, reference capillaries with known NaCl concentrations were located in the NMR probe together with the plant sample. Average concentration values calculated from signal intensities in the tissue and the capillaries were compared with concentration values obtained from atomic emission photometry and optical microscopy performed on digested stem sections harvested immediately after NMR experiments. Results showed that ²³Na NMR microimaging has great potential for physiological studies of salt stress at the macroscopic level, and may become a unique tool for diagnosing salt tolerance and sensitivity.

Effects of Sodium Chloride on plant cells; a 31P and 23Na NMR system to study salt tolerance

In plant cells, the Na(+)/H(+) antiport at the tonoplast provides a biochemical pathway to transport cytoplasmic Na(+) into the vacuole. Recently it was shown that overexpression of a vacuolar Na(+)/H(+) promotes sustained plant growth at high NaCl levels (Apse et al. Science 285, 1256, 1999). The sequestration of Na(+) ions into the vacuole can be followed using 31P and 23Na NMR spectroscopy. Suspension cell cultures are very suitable for this purpose and allow rapid and accurate assessment of the activity of the Na(+)/H(+) antiport and therefore potentially of salt tolerance. Perfusion experiments with maize cells that are not particularly salt (NaCl) tolerant showed that during salt stress the cytoplasmic pH remains unchanged while the vacuolar pH significantly increased. During Na(+) sequestration into the vacuole, the cytoplasmic pH equilibrates faster than that of the vacuole. Both vacuolar pH and the cellular Na(+) uptake rate were dependent on extracellular Na(+) for concentrations up to approximately 300 mM. For Na(+) concentrations >/=300 mM, both vacuolar pH and cellular Na(+) uptake became independent of the extracellular concentration. This indicates either a saturation of Na(+) uptake at the cell surface or a saturation of the Na(+)/H(+) transporter at the tonoplast. Na(+) uptake into the cell is accompanied by a rapid increase in vacuolar PO(4)(3-), broadening of the 31P resonances and a reduction in glucose monophosphate and UDPG.

Transport processes of solutes across the vacuolar membrane of higher plants

The central vacuole is the largest compartment of a mature plant cell and may occupy more than 80% of the total cell volume. However, recent results indicate that beside the large central vacuole, several small vacuoles may exist in a plant cell. These vacuoles often belong to different classes and can be distinguished either by their contents in soluble proteins or by different types of a major vacuolar membrane protein, the aquaporins. Two vacuolar proton pumps, an ATPase and a PPase energize vacuolar uptake of most solutes. The electrochemical gradient generated by these pumps can be utilized to accumulate cations by a proton antiport mechanism or anions due to the membrane potential difference. Uptake can be catalyzed by channels or by transporters. Growing evidence shows that for most ions more than one transporter/channel exist at the vacuolar membrane. Furthermore, plant secondary products may be accumulated by proton antiport mechanisms. The transport of some solutes such as sucrose is energized in some plants but occurs by facilitated diffusion in others. A new class of transporters has been discovered recently: the ABC type transporters are directly energized by MgATP and do not depend on the electrochemical force. Their substrates are organic anions formed by conjugation, e.g. to glutathione. In this review we discuss the different transport processes occurring at the vacuolar membrane and focus on some new results obtained in this field.

23Na and (1)H NMR microimaging of intact plants

(23)Na NMR microimaging is described to map, for the first time, the sodium distribution in living plants. As an example, the response of 6-day-old seedlings of Ricinus communis to exposure to sodium chloride concentrations from 5 to 300 mM was observed in vivo using (23)Na as well as (1)H NMR microimaging. Experiments were performed at 11.75 T with a double resonant (23)Na-(1)H probehead. The probehead was homebuilt and equipped with a climate chamber. T(1) and T(2) of (23)Na were measured in the cross section of the hypocotyl. Within 85 min (23)Na images with an in-plane resolution of 156 x 156 micrometer were acquired. With this spatial information, the different types of tissue in the hypocotyl can be discerned. The measurement time appears to be short compared to the time scale of sodium uptake and accumulation in the plant so that the kinetics of salt stress can be followed. In conclusion, (23)Na NMR microimaging promises great potential for physiological studies of the consequences of salt stress on the macroscopic level and thus may become a unique tool for characterizing plants with respect to salt tolerance and salt sensitivity.

Sodium transport in plant cells

Salinity limits plant growth and impairs agricultural productivity. There is a wide spectrum of plant responses to salinity that are defined by a range of adaptations at the cellular and the whole-plant levels, however, the mechanisms of sodium transport appear to be fundamentally similar. At the cellular level, sodium ions gain entry via several plasma membrane channels. As cytoplasmic sodium is toxic above threshold levels, it is extruded by plasma membrane Na(+)/H(+) antiports that are energized by the proton gradient generated by the plasma membrane ATPase. Cytoplasmic Na(+) may also be compartmentalized by vacuolar Na(+)/H(+) antiports. These transporters are energized by the proton gradient generated by the vacuolar H(+)-ATPase and H(+)-PPiase. Here, the mechanisms of sodium entry, extrusion, and compartmentation are reviewed, with a discussion of recent progress on the cloning and characterization, directly in planta and in yeast, of some of the proteins involved in sodium transport.

Sodium-driven potassium uptake by the plant potassium transporter HKT1 and mutations conferring salt tolerance

Sodium (Na+) at high millimolar concentrations in soils is toxic to most higher plants and severely reduces agricultural production worldwide. However, the molecular mechanisms for plant Na+ uptake remain unknown. Here, the wheat root high-affinity potassium (K+) uptake transporter HKT1 was shown to function as a high-affinity K(+)-Na+ cotransporter. High-affinity K+ uptake was activated by micromolar Na+ concentrations; moreover, high-affinity Na+ uptake was activated by K+ (half-activation constant, 2.8 microM K+). However, at physiologically detrimental concentrations of Na+, K+ accumulation mediated by HKT1 was blocked and low-affinity Na+ uptake occurred (Michaelis constant, approximately 16 mM Na+), which correlated to Na+ toxicity in plants. Point mutations in the sixth putative transmembrane domain of HKT1 that increase Na+ tolerance were isolated with the use of yeast as a screening system. Na+ uptake and Na+ inhibition of K+ accumulation indicate a possible role for HKT1 in physiological Na+ toxicity in plants.

Na+/H+ antiporters, molecular devices that couple the Na+ and H+ circulation in cells

Na+/H+ antiporters are universal devices involved in the Na+ and H+ circulation of both eukaryotes and prokaryotes, thus playing an essential role in the pH and Na+ homeostasis of cells. This review focuses on the major impact of the application of molecular biology tools in the study of the antiporters. These tools permit the verification of the role of the antiporters and provide insights into their unique biology. A novel signal transduction to Na+ involving nhaR, a positive regulator, controls the expression of nhaA in E. coli. A "pH sensor" regulates the activity of Na+/H+ antiporters, both in eukaryotes and prokaryotes. A most intricate signal transduction to pH involving phosphorylation steps controls the activity of nhel in higher mammals. The identification of Histidine 226 in the "pH sensor" of NhaA is a step forward towards the understanding of the pH regulation of these proteins.

An in Vivo Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Investigation of Ion Transport in Maize (Zea mays) and Spartina anglica Roots during Exposure to High Salt Concentrations

The response of maize (Zea mays L.) and Spartina anglica root tips to exposure to sodium chloride concentrations in the range 0 to 500 mM was investigated using 23Na and 31P nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR). Changes in the chemical shift of the pH-dependent 31P-NMR signals from the cytoplasmic and vacuolar orthophosphate pools were correlated with the uptake of sodium, and after allowing for a number of complicating factors we concluded that these chemical shift changes indicated the occurrence of a small cytoplasmic alkalinization (0.1-0.2 pH units) and a larger vacuolar alkalinization (0.6 pH units) in maize root tips exposed to salt concentrations greater than 200 mM. The data were interpreted in terms of the ion transport processes that may be important during salt stress, and we concluded that the vacuolar alkalinization provided evidence for the operation of a tonoplast Na+/H+-antiport with an activity that exceeded the activity of the tonoplast H+ pumps. The intracellular pH values stabilized during prolonged treatment with high salt concentrations, and this observation was linked to the recent demonstration (Y. Nakamura, K. Kasamo, N. Shimosato, M. Sakata, E. Ohta [1992] Plant Cell Physiol 33: 139-149) of the salt-induced activation of the tonoplast H+- ATPase. Sodium vanadate, an inhibitor of the plasmalemma H+- ATPase, stimulated the net uptake of sodium by maize root tips, and this was interpreted in terms of a reduction in active sodium efflux from the tissue. S. anglica root tips accumulated sodium more slowly than did maize, with no change in cytoplasmic pH and a relatively small change (0.3 pH units) in vacuolar pH, and it appears that salt tolerance in Spartina is based in part on its ability to prevent the net influx of sodium chloride.

Potassium transport into plant vacuoles energized directly by a proton-pumping inorganic pyrophosphatase

Potassium is accumulated in plant vacuoles against an inside-positive membrane potential. The mechanism facilitating energized K+ transport has remained obscure. However, electrogenic activity of the inorganic pyrophosphatase (H(+)-PPase) at the vacuolar membrane is dependent on cytoplasmic K+, raising the possibility that the enzyme translocates K+ into the vacuole. Membrane currents generated by the H(+)-PPase were measured (using a patch clamp technique) in intact vacuoles isolated from Beta vulgaris storage tissue. A significant orthophosphate-dependent outward current mediated by the enzyme in reverse mode is evoked only when potassium is present at the vacuolar face of the tonoplast, suggesting that potassium is a translocated ion. Furthermore, current-voltage analysis of the effects of extravacuolar potassium and pH on the reversal potential of the H(+)-PPase-generated current points to direct translocation of K+ and H+ by the enzyme. Thus the H(+)-PPase represents a distinct class of eukaryote translocase and could facilitate vacuolar K+ accumulation in vivo.

Identification of a 170-kDa protein associated with the vacuolar Na+/H+ antiport of Beta vulgaris

The effect of the addition of amiloride to the growth medium was tested on the Na+/H+ antiport activity of tonoplast vesicles isolated from sugar beet (beta vulgaris L.) cell suspensions. Cells grown in the presence of NaCl and amiloride displayed an increased antiport activity. Analysis of the kinetic data showed that while the affinity of the antiport for Na+ ions did not change, the maximal velocity of the Na+/H+ exchange increased markedly. These results suggest the addition of more antiport molecules to the tonoplast and/or an increase in the turnover rate of the Na+/H+ exchange. The increase in activity of the antiport by the presence of amiloride was correlated with the enhanced synthesis of a tonoplast 170-kDa polypeptide. The increased synthesis of this polypeptide was detected not only upon exposure of the cells to amiloride but also when the cells were exposed to high NaCl concentrations. Polyclonal antibodies against the 170-kDa polypeptide almost completely inhibited the antiport activity. These results suggest the association of the 170-kDa polypeptide with the vacuolar Na+/H+ antiport.

The k/na selectivity of a cation channel in the plasma membrane of root cells does not differ in salt-tolerant and salt-sensitive wheat species

The characteristics of cation outward rectifier channels were studied in protoplasts from wheat root (Triticum aestivum L. and Triticum turgidum L.) cells using the patch clamp technique. The cation outward rectifier channels were voltage-dependent with a single channel conductance of 32 +/- 1 picosiemens in 100 millimolar KCl. Whole-cell currents were dominated by the activity of the cation outward rectifiers. The time- and voltage-dependence of these currents was accounted for by the summed behavior of individual channels recorded from outside-out detached patches. The K(+)/Na(+) permeability ratio of these channels was measured in a salt-sensitive and salt-tolerant genotype of wheat that differ in rates of Na(+) accumulation, using a voltage ramp protocol on protoplasts in the whole-cell configuration. Permeability ratios were calculated from shifts in reversal potentials following ion substitutions. There were no significant differences in the K(+)/Na(+) permeability ratios of these channels in root cells from either of the two genotypes tested. The permeability ratio for K(+)/Cl(-) was greater than 50:1. The K(+)/Na(+) permeability ratio averaged 30:1, which is two to four times more selective than the same type of channel in guard cells and suspension culture cells. Lowering the Ca(2+) concentration in the bath solution to 0.1 millimolar in the presence of 100 millimolar Na(+) had no significant effect on the K(+)/Na(+) permeability ratios of the channel. It seems unlikely that the mechanism of salt tolerance in wheat is based on differences in the K(+)/Na(+) selectivity of these channels.