A secondary structure in the 5' untranslated region of adhE mRNA required for RNase G-dependent regulation

Escherichia coli RNase G is involved in the degradation of several mRNAs, including adhE and eno, which encode alcohol dehydrogenase and enolase respectively. Previous research indicates that the 5' untranslated region (5'-UTR) of adhE mRNA gives RNase G-dependency to lacZ mRNA when tagged at the 5'-end, but it has not been elucidated yet how RNase G recognizes adhE mRNA. Primer extension analysis revealed that RNase G cleaved a phosphodiester bond between -19A and -18C in the 5'-UTR (the A of the start codon was defined as +1). Site-directed mutagenesis indicated that RNase G did not recognize the nucleotides at -19 and -18. Random deletion analysis indicated that the sequence from -145 to -125 was required for RNase G-dependent degradation. Secondary structure prediction and further site-directed deletion suggested that the stem-loop structure, with a bubble in the stem, is required for RNaseG-dependent degradation of adhE mRNA.

Role of mRNA stability during bacterial adaptation

Bacterial adaptation involves extensive cellular reorganization. In particular, growth rate adjustments are associated with substantial modifications of gene expression and mRNA abundance. In this work we aimed to assess the role of mRNA degradation during such variations. A genome-wide transcriptomic-based method was used to determine mRNA half-lives. The model bacterium Lactococcus lactis was used and different growth rates were studied in continuous cultures under isoleucine-limitation and in batch cultures during the adaptation to the isoleucine starvation. During continuous isoleucine-limited growth, the mRNAs of different genes had different half-lives. The stability of most of the transcripts was not constant, and increased as the growth rate decreased. This half-life diversity was analyzed to investigate determinants of mRNA stability. The concentration, length, codon adaptation index and secondary structures of mRNAs were found to contribute to the determination of mRNA stability in these conditions. However, the growth rate was, by far, the most influential determinant. The respective influences of mRNA degradation and transcription on the regulation of intra-cellular transcript concentration were estimated. The role of degradation on mRNA homeostasis was clearly evidenced: for more than 90% of the mRNAs studied during continuous isoleucine-limited growth of L. lactis, degradation was antagonistic to transcription. Although both transcription and degradation had, opposite effects, the mRNA changes in response to growth rate were driven by transcription. Interestingly, degradation control increased during the dynamic adaptation of bacteria as the growth rate reduced due to progressive isoleucine starvation in batch cultures. This work shows that mRNA decay differs between gene transcripts and according to the growth rate. It demonstrates that mRNA degradation is an important regulatory process involved in bacterial adaptation. However, its impact on the regulation of mRNA levels is smaller than that of transcription in the conditions studied.

Evidence classification of high-throughput protocols and confidence integration in RegulonDB

RegulonDB provides curated information on the transcriptional regulatory network of Escherichia coli and contains both experimental data and computationally predicted objects. To account for the heterogeneity of these data, we introduced in version 6.0, a two-tier rating system for the strength of evidence, classifying evidence as either ‘weak’ or ‘strong’ (Gama-Castro,S., Jimenez-Jacinto,V., Peralta-Gil,M. et al. RegulonDB (Version 6.0): gene regulation model of Escherichia Coli K-12 beyond transcription, active (experimental) annotated promoters and textpresso navigation. Nucleic Acids Res., 2008;36:D120–D124.). We now add to our classification scheme the classification of high-throughput evidence, including chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) and RNA-seq technologies. To integrate these data into RegulonDB, we present two strategies for the evaluation of confidence, statistical validation and independent cross-validation. Statistical validation involves verification of ChIP data for transcription factor-binding sites, using tools for motif discovery and quality assessment of the discovered matrices. Independent cross-validation combines independent evidence with the intention to mutually exclude false positives. Both statistical validation and cross-validation allow to upgrade subsets of data that are supported by weak evidence to a higher confidence level. Likewise, cross-validation of strong confidence data extends our two-tier rating system to a three-tier system by introducing a third confidence score ‘confirmed’.

Database URL:http://regulondb.ccg.unam.mx/

Messenger RNA Turnover Processes in Escherichia coli, Bacillus subtilis, and Emerging Studies in Staphylococcus aureus

The regulation of mRNA turnover is a recently appreciated phenomenon by which bacteria modulate gene expression. This review outlines the mechanisms by which three major classes of bacterial trans-acting factors, ribonucleases (RNases), RNA binding proteins, and small noncoding RNAs (sRNA), regulate the transcript stability and protein production of target genes. Because the mechanisms of RNA decay and maturation are best characterized in Escherichia coli, the majority of this review will focus on how these factors modulate mRNA stability in this organism. However, we also address the effects of RNases, RNA binding proteins, sRNAs on mRNA turnover, and gene expression in Bacillus subtilis, which has served as a model for studying RNA processing in gram-positive organisms. We conclude by discussing emerging studies on the role modulating mRNA stability has on gene expression in the important human pathogen Staphylococcus aureus.

Increased production of pyruvic acid by Escherichia coli RNase G mutants in combination with cra mutations

The Escherichia coli RNase G is known as an endoribonuclease responsible for the 5'-end maturation of 16S rRNA and degradation of several specific mRNAs such as adhE and eno mRNAs. In this study, we found that an RNase G mutant derived from the MC1061 strain did not grow on a glucose minimal medium. Genetic analysis revealed that simultaneous defects of cra and ilvIH, encoding a transcriptional regulator of glycolysis/gluconeogenesis and one of isozymes of acetohydroxy acid synthase, respectively, were required for this phenomenon to occur. The results of additional experiments presented here indicate that the RNase G mutation, in combination with cra mutation, caused the increased production of pyruvic acid from glucose, which was then preferentially converted to valine due to the ilvIH mutation, resulting in depletion of isoleucine. In fact, the rng cra double mutant produced increased amount of pyruvate in the medium. These results suggest that the RNase G mutation could be applied in the breeding of producer strains of pyruvate and its derivatives such as valine.

Effect of gene location, mRNA secondary structures, and RNase sites on expression of two genes in an engineered operon

The effects of endoribonuclease sites, secondary structures in mRNA, and gene placement on protein production and mRNA stability and steady-state levels were tested in a dual-gene operon containing the genes encoding beta-galactosidase (lacZ) from Escherichia coli and green fluorescent protein (gfp) from Aequorea victoria. Two previously identified RNase E sites were placed separately between the coding regions to direct cleavage in this area and produce two secondary transcripts, each containing a single-gene coding region. Novel secondary structures were engineered into the 3' and 5' ends of each of the coding regions to protect the transcript from inactivation by endoribonucleases (5' hairpins) and degradation by exoribonucleases (3' hairpins). In addition, the effects of relative gene placement were examined by switching the locations of the two coding regions. Depending on the particular secondary structures and RNase E sites placed between the genes the relative steady-state transcript and protein levels encoded by the two reporter genes could be changed up to 2.5-fold and 4-fold, respectively. By changing gene location and incorporating secondary structures and RNase E sites the relative steady-state transcript and protein levels encoded by the two reporter genes could be changed up to 100-fold and 750-fold, respectively.

The catalytic domain of RNase E shows inherent 3' to 5' directionality in cleavage site selection

RNase E, a multifunctional endoribonuclease of Escherichia coli, attacks substrates at highly specific sites. By using synthetic oligoribonucleotides containing repeats of identical target sequences protected from cleavage by 2'-O-methylated nucleotide substitutions at specific positions, we investigated how RNase E identifies its cleavage sites. We found that the RNase E catalytic domain (i.e., N-Rne) binds selectively to 5'-monophosphate RNA termini but has an inherent mode of cleavage in the 3' to 5' direction. Target sequences made uncleavable by the introduction of 2'-O-methyl-modified nucleotides bind to RNase E and impede cleavages at normally susceptible sites located 5' to, but not 3' to, the protected target. Our results indicate that RNase E can identify cleavage sites by a 3' to 5' "scanning" mechanism and imply that anchoring of the enzyme to the 5'-monophosphorylated end of these substrates orients the enzyme for directional cleavages that occur in a processive or quasiprocessive mode. In contrast, we find that RNase G, which has extensive structural homology with and size similarity to N-Rne, and can functionally complement RNase E gene deletions when overexpressed, has a nondirectional and distributive mode of action.

Role of the sequence of the rne-dependent site in 3' processing of M1 RNA, the catalytic component of Escherichia coli RNase P

The 3' processing of M1 RNA, the catalytic component of Escherichia coli RNase P, occurs by two pathways involving multiple steps. The precursor of M1 RNA has an rne-dependent site downstream of the processing site, whose sequence variation affects the processing efficiency. In this study, we showed that the sequence itself of the rne-dependent site possessed the ability to determine the processing pathways and that it also affected the cleavage specificity with the generation of the processing products at one nucleotide upstream or downstream of the normal cleavage sites.

Preferential cleavage of degradative intermediates of rpsT mRNA by the Escherichia coli RNA degradosome

RNase E, the principal RNase capable of initiating mRNA decay, preferentially attacks 5'-monophosphorylated over 5'-triphosphorylated substrates. Site-specific cleavage in vitro of the rpsT mRNA by RNase H directed by chimeric 2'-O-methyl oligonucleotides was employed to create truncated RNAs which are identical to authentic degradative intermediates. The rates of cleavage of two such intermediates by RNase E in the RNA degradosome are significantly faster (2.5- to 8-fold) than that of intact RNA. This verifies the preference of RNase E for degradative intermediates and can explain the frequent "all-or-none" behavior of mRNAs during the decay process.

Stabilization of circular rpsT mRNA demonstrates the 5'-end dependence of RNase E action in vivo

RNase E is the major intracellular endonuclease in Escherichia coli. Its ability to cleave susceptible substrates in vitro depends on both the cleavage site itself and the availability of an unstructured 5' terminus. To test whether RNase E activity is 5'-end-dependent in vivo in the presence of all the components of the RNA degradative machinery, a known substrate, the rpsT mRNA, has been embedded in a permuted group I intron to permit its efficient, precise circularization in E. coli. Circular rpsT mRNAs are 4-6-fold more stable in vivo than their linear counterparts. Even partial inactivation of RNase E activity further enhances this stability 6-fold. However, the stabilization of circular rpsT mRNAs depends strongly on their efficient translation. These results show unambiguously the importance of an accessible 5'-end in controlling mRNA stability in vivo and support a two-step ("looping") model for RNase E action in which the first step is end recognition and the second is actual cleavage.

Enhanced cleavage of RNA mediated by an interaction between substrates and the arginine-rich domain of E. coli ribonuclease E

Endonucleolytic cutting by the essential Escherichia coli ribonuclease RNaseE has a central role in both the processing and decay of RNA. Previously, it has been shown that an oligoribonucleotide corresponding in sequence to the single-stranded region at the 5' end of RNAI, the antisense regulator of ColE1-type plasmid replication, is efficiently cut by RNaseE. Combined with the knowledge that alteration of the structure of stem-loops within complex RNaseE substrates can either increase or decrease the rate of cleavage, this result has led to the notion that stem-loops do not serve as essential recognition motifs for RNaseE, but can affect the rate of cleavage indirectly by, for example, determining the single-strandedness of the site or its accessibility. We report here, however, that not all oligoribonucleotides corresponding to RNaseE-cleaved segments of complex substrates are sufficient to direct efficient RNaseE cleavage. We provide evidence using 9 S RNA, a precursor of 5 S rRNA, that binding of structured regions by the arginine-rich RNA- binding domain (ARRBD) of RNaseE can be required for efficient cleavage. Binding by the ARRBD appears to counteract the inhibitory effects of sub-optimal cleavage site sequence and overall substrate conformation. Furthermore, combined with the results from recent analyses of E. coli mutants in which the ARRBD of RNase E is deleted, our findings suggest that substrate binding by RNaseE is essential for the normal rapid decay of E. coli mRNA. The simplest interpretation of our results is that the ARRBD recruits RNaseE to structured RNAs, thereby increasing the localised concentration of the N-terminal catalytic domain, which in turn leads to an increase in the rate of cleavage.

Action of RNase II and polynucleotide phosphorylase against RNAs containing stem-loops of defined structure

The 3'-->5' exoribonucleases, RNase II and polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase), play an essential role in degrading fragments of mRNA generated by prior cleavages by endonucleases. We have assessed the ability of small RNA substrates containing defined stem-loop structures and variable 3' extensions to impede the exonucleolytic activity of these enzymes. We find that stem-loops containing five G-C base pairs do not block either enzyme; in contrast, more stable stem-loops of 7, 9, or 11 bp block the processive action of both enzymes. Under conditions where enzyme activity is limiting, both enzymes stall and dissociate from their substrates six to nine residues, on average, from the base of a stable stem-loop structure. Our data provide a clear mechanistic explanation for the previous observation that RNase II and PNPase behave as functionally redundant.

The CafA protein required for the 5'-maturation of 16 S rRNA is a 5'-end-dependent ribonuclease that has context-dependent broad sequence specificity

The CafA protein, which was initially described as having a role in either Escherichia coli cell division or chromosomal segregation, has recently been shown to be required for the maturation of the 5'-end of 16 S rRNA. The sequence of CafA is similar to that of the N-terminal ribonucleolytic half of RNase E, an essential E. coli enzyme that has a central role in the processing of rRNA and the decay of mRNA and RNAI, the antisense regulator of ColE1-type plasmids. We show here that a highly purified preparation of CafA is sufficient in vitro for RNA cutting. We detected CafA cleavage of RNAI and a structured region from the 5'-untranslated region of ompA mRNA within segments cleavable by RNaseE, but not CafA cleavage of 9 S RNA at its "a" RNase E site. The latter is consistent with the finding that the generation of 5 S rRNA from its 9 S precursor can be blocked by inactivation of RNase E in cells that are wild type for CafA. Interestingly, however, a decanucleotide corresponding in sequence to the a site of 9 S RNA was cut efficiently indicating that cleavage by CafA is regulated by the context of sites within structured RNAs. Consistent with this notion is our finding that although 23 S rRNA is stable in vivo, a segment from this RNA is cut efficient by CafA at multiple sites in vitro. We also show that, like RNase E cleavage, the efficiency of cleavage by CafA is dependent on the presence of a monophosphate group on the 5'-end of the RNA. This finding raises the possibility that the context dependence of cleavage by CafA may be due at least in part to the separation of a cleavable sequence from the 5'-end of an RNA. Comparison of the sites surrounding points of CafA cleavage suggests that this enzyme has broad sequence specificity. Together with the knowledge that CafA can cut RNAI and ompA mRNA in vitro within segments whose cleavage in vivo initiates the decay of these RNAs, this finding suggests that CafA may contribute at some point during the decay of many RNAs in E. coli.

Different processing of an mRNA species in Bacillus subtilis and Escherichia coli

Expression of the Bacillus subtilis glpD gene, which encodes glycerol-3-phosphate (G3P) dehydrogenase, is controlled by termination or antitermination of transcription. The untranslated leader sequence of glpD contains an inverted repeat that gives rise to a transcription terminator. In the presence of G3P, the antiterminator protein GlpP binds to glpD leader mRNA and promotes readthrough of the terminator. Certain mutations in the inverted repeat of the glpD leader result in GlpP-independent, temperature-sensitive (TS) expression of glpD. The TS phenotype is due to temperature-dependent degradation of the glpD mRNA. In the presence of GlpP, the glpD mRNA is stabilized. glpD leader-lacZ fusions were integrated into the chromosomes of B. subtilis and Escherichia coli. Determination of steady-state levels of fusion mRNA in B. subtilis showed that the stability of the fusion mRNA is determined by the glpD leader part. Comparison of steady-state levels and half-lives of glpD leader-lacZ fusion mRNA in B. subtilis and E. coli revealed significant differences. A glpD leader-lacZ fusion transcript that was unstable in B. subtilis was considerably more stable in E. coli. GlpP, which stabilizes the transcript in B. subtilis, did not affect its stability in E. coli. Primer extension analysis showed that the glpD leader-lacZ fusion transcript is processed differently in B. subtilis and in E. coli. The dominating cleavage site in E. coli was barely detectable in B. subtilis. This site was shown to be a target of E. coli RNase III.

mRNA degradation in bacteria

Messenger RNAs in prokaryotes exhibit short half-lives when compared with eukaryotic mRNAs. Considerable progress has been made during recent years in our understanding of mRNA degradation in bacteria. Two major aspects determine the life span of a messenger in the bacterial cell. On the side of the substrate, the structural features of mRNA have a profound influence on the stability of the molecule. On the other hand, there is the degradative machinery. Progress in the biochemical characterization of proteins involved in mRNA degradation has made clear that RNA degradation is a highly organized cellular process in which several protein components, and not only nucleases, are involved. In Escherichia coli, these proteins are organized in a high molecular mass complex, the degradosome. The key enzyme for initial events in mRNA degradation and for the assembly of the degradosome is endoribonuclease E. We discuss the identified components of the degradosome and its mode of action. Since research in mRNA degradation suffers from dominance of E. coli-related observations we also look to other organisms to ask whether they could possibly follow the E. coli standard model.

Ribonuclease E is a 5'-end-dependent endonuclease

The selective degradation of messenger RNAs enables cells to regulate the levels of particular mRNAs in response to changes in the environment. Ribonuclease (RNase) E, a single-strand-specific endonuclease that is found in a multi-enzyme complex known as the 'degradosome', initiates the degradation of many mRNAs in Escherichia coli. Its relative lack of sequence specificity and the presence of many potential cleavage sites in mRNA substrates cannot explain why mRNA decay frequently proceeds in a net 5'-to-3' direction. I have prepared covalently closed circular derivatives of natural substrates, the rpsT mRNA encoding ribosomal protein S20 and the 9S precursor to 5S ribosomal RNA, and find that these derivatives are considerably more resistant to cleavage in vitro by RNase E than are linear molecules. Moreover, antisense oligo-deoxynucleotides complementary to the 5' end of linear substrates significantly reduce the latter's susceptibility to attack by RNase E. Finally, natural substrates with terminal 5'-triphosphate groups are poorly cleaved by RNase E in vitro, whereas 5' monophosphorylated substrates are strongly preferred. These results show that RNase E has inherent vectorial properties, with its activity depending on the 5' end of its substrates; this can account for the direction of mRNA decay in E. coli, the phenomenon of 'all or none' mRNA decay, and the stabilization provided by 5' stem-loop structures.

In the absence of translation, RNase E can bypass 5' mRNA stabilizers in Escherichia coli

In Bacilli, ribosomes or 30 S ribosomal subunits that are stalled or bound on mRNAs can stabilize downstream regions, hence the view that the degradation machinery scans mRNAs from their 5' end. In E. coli, several mRNAs can also be stabilized by secondary structures involving their 5' end. To test whether a bound 30 S subunit can act as a 5' stabilizer in E. coli, we compare here the stabilities of two untranslated variants of the lacZ mRNA, the decay of which is controlled by RNase E. In the first variant, a 35 nt region including the Ribosome Binding Site (RBS) is deleted, whereas in the second it is replaced by an 11 nt-long Shine-Dalgarno (SD) sequence lacking an associated start codon. In the latter variant, an 80 nt fragment encompassing the SD and extending up to the mRNA 5' end was stable in vivo (t1/2>one hour), reflecting 30 S binding. Yet, the full-length message was not more stable than when the SD was absent, although two small decay intermediates retaining the 5' end appear somewhat stabilized. A third variant was constructed in which the RBS is replaced by an insert which can fold back onto the lac leader, creating a putative hairpin involving the mRNA 5' end. The fragment corresponding to this hairpin was stable but, again, the full-length message was not stabilized. Thus, the untranslated lacZ mRNA cannot be protected against RNase E by 5' stabilizers, suggesting that mRNA scanning is not an obligate feature of RNase E-controlled degradation. Altogether, these results suggest important differences in mRNA degradation between E. coli and B. subtilis. In addition, we show that mRNA regions involved in stable hairpins or Shine-Dalgarno pairings can be metabolically stable in E. coli.

Ribonuclease E organizes the protein interactions in the Escherichia coli RNA degradosome

The Escherichia coli RNA degradosome is the prototype of a recently discovered family of multiprotein machines involved in the processing and degradation of RNA. The interactions between the various protein components of the RNA degradosome were investigated by Far Western blotting, the yeast two-hybrid assay, and coimmunopurification experiments. Our results demonstrate that the carboxy-terminal half (CTH) of ribonuclease E (RNase E) contains the binding sites for the three other major degradosomal components, the DEAD-box RNA helicase RhlB, enolase, and polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase). The CTH of RNase E acts as the scaffold of the complex upon which the other degradosomal components are assembled. Regions for oligomerization were detected in the amino-terminal and central regions of RNase E. Furthermore, polypeptides derived from the highly charged region of RNase E, containing the RhlB binding site, stimulate RhlB activity at least 15-fold, saturating at one polypeptide per RhlB molecule. A model for the regulation of the RhlB RNA helicase activity is presented. The description of RNase E now emerging is that of a remarkably complex multidomain protein containing an amino-terminal catalytic domain, a central RNA-binding domain, and carboxy-terminal binding sites for the other major components of the RNA degradosome.

Reconstitution of the degradation of the mRNA for ribosomal protein S20 with purified enzymes

Previous work has implicated poly(A) polymerase I (PAP I), encoded by the pcnB gene, in the decay of a number of RNAs from Escherichia coli. We show here that PAP I does not promote the initiation of decay of the rpsT mRNA encoding ribosomal protein S20 in vivo; however, it does facilitate the degradation of highly folded degradative intermediates by polynucleotide phosphorylase. As expected, purified degradosomes, a multi-protein complex containing, among others, RNase E, PNPase, and RhlB, generate an authentic 147-residue RNase E cleavage product from the rpsT mRNA in vitro. However, degradosomes are unable to degrade the 147-residue fragment in the presence of ATP even when it is oligoadenylated. Rather, both continuous cycles of polyadenylation and PNPase activity are necessary and sufficient for the complete decay of the 147-residue fragment in a process which can be antagonized by the action of RNase II. Moreover, both ATP and a non-hydrolyzable analog, ATPgammaS, support the PAP I and PNPase-dependent degradation of the 147-residue intermediate implying that ATPase activity, such as that which may reside in RhlB, a putative RNA helicase, is not necessarily required. Alternatively, the rpsT mRNA can be degraded in vitro by a second 3'-decay pathway which is dependent on PAP I, PNPase and ATP alone. Our results demonstrate that a hierarchy of RNA secondary structures controls access to exonucleolytic attack on 3' termini. Moreover, decay of a model mRNA can be reconstituted in vitro by a small number of purified components in a process which is more dynamic and ATP-dependent than previously imagined.