Tryptophan scanning mutagenesis of the gammaM4 transmembrane domain of the acetylcholine receptor from Torpedo californica

Distinct functional roles for the M4 α-helix from each homologous subunit in the hetero-pentameric ligand-gated ion channel nAChR

The outermost lipid-exposed α-helix (M4) in each of the homologous α, β, δ, and γ/ε subunits of the muscle nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) has previously been proposed to act as a lipid sensor. However, the mechanism by which this sensor would function is not clear. To explore how the M4 α-helix from each subunit in human adult muscle nAChR influences function, and thus explore its putative role in lipid sensing, we functionally characterized alanine mutations at every residue in αM4, βM4, δM4, and εM4, along with both alanine and deletion mutations in the post-M4 region of each subunit. Although no critical interactions involving residues on M4 or in post-M4 were identified, we found that numerous mutations at the M4–M1/M3 interface altered the agonist-induced response. In addition, homologous mutations in M4 in different subunits were found to have different effects on channel function. The functional effects of multiple mutations either along M4 in one subunit or at homologous positions of M4 in different subunits were also found to be additive. Finally, when characterized in both Xenopus oocytes and human embryonic kidney 293T cells, select αM4 mutations displayed cell-specific phenotypes, possibly because of the different membrane lipid environments. Collectively, our data suggest different functional roles for the M4 α-helix in each heteromeric nAChR subunit and predict that lipid sensing involving M4 occurs primarily through the cumulative interactions at the M4–M1/M3 interface, as opposed to the alteration of specific interactions that are critical to channel function.

Assessment of the functionality and stability of detergent purified nAChR from Torpedo using lipidic matrixes and macroscopic electrophysiology

In our previous study we examined the functionality and stability of nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR)-detergent complexes (nAChR-DCs) from affinity-purified Torpedo californica (Tc) using fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) in Lipidic Cubic Phase (LCP) and planar lipid bilayer (PLB) recordings for phospholipid and cholesterol like detergents. In the present study we enhanced the functional characterization of nAChR-DCs by recording macroscopic ion channel currents in Xenopus oocytes using the two electrode voltage clamp (TEVC). The use of TEVC allows for the recording of macroscopic currents elicited by agonist activation of nAChR-DCs that assemble in the oocyte plasma membrane. Furthermore, we examined the stability of nAChR-DCs, which is obligatory for the nAChR crystallization, using a 30 day FRAP assay in LCP for each detergent. The present results indicate a marked difference in the fractional fluorescence recovery (ΔFFR) within the same detergent family during the 30 day period assayed. Within the cholesterol analog family, sodium cholate and CHAPSO displayed a minimum ΔFFR and a mobile fraction (MF) over 80%. In contrast, CHAPS and BigCHAP showed a marked decay in both the mobile fraction and diffusion coefficient. nAChR-DCs containing phospholipid analog detergents with an alkylphosphocholine (FC) and lysofoscholine (LFC) of 16 carbon chains (FC-16, LFC-16) were more effective in maintaining a mobile fraction of over 80% compared to their counterparts with shorter acyl chain (C12, C14). The significant differences in macroscopic current amplitudes, activation and desensitization rates among the different nAChR-DCs evaluated in the present study allow to dissect which detergent preserves both, agonist activation and ion channel function. Functionality assays using TEVC demonstrated that LFC16, LFC14, and cholate were the most effective detergents in preserving macroscopic ion channel function, however, the nAChR-cholate complex display a significant delay in the ACh-induce channel activation. In summary, these results suggest that the physical properties of the lipid analog detergents (headgroup and acyl chain length) are the most effective in maintaining both the stability and functionality of the nAChR in the detergent solubilized complex.

The M4 Transmembrane α-Helix Contributes Differently to Both the Maturation and Function of Two Prokaryotic Pentameric Ligand-gated Ion Channels

The role of the outermost transmembrane α-helix in both the maturation and function of the prokaryotic pentameric ligand-gated ion channels, GLIC and ELIC, was examined by Ala scanning mutagenesis, deletion mutations, and mutant cycle analyses. Ala mutations at the M4-M1/M3 interface lead to loss-of-function phenotypes in GLIC, with the largest negative effects occurring near the M4 C terminus. In particular, two aromatic residues at the M4 C terminus form a network of π-π and/or cation-π interactions with residues on M3 and the β6-β7 loop that is essential for both maturation and function. M4-M1/M3 interactions appear to be optimized in GLIC with even subtle structural changes at this interface leading to detrimental effects. In contrast, mutations along the M4-M1/M3 interface of ELIC typically lead to gain-of-function phenotypes, suggesting that these interactions in ELIC are not optimized for channel function. In addition, no cluster of interacting residues involving the M4 C terminus, M3, and the β6-β7 loop was found, suggesting that the M4 C terminus plays little role in ELIC maturation or function. This study shows that M4 makes distinct contributions to the maturation and gating of these two closely related homologs, suggesting that GLIC and ELIC exhibit divergent features of channel function.

Phylogenetic conservation of protein-lipid motifs in pentameric ligand-gated ion channels

Using the crosstalk between the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) and its lipid microenvironment as a paradigm, this short overview analyzes the occurrence of structural motifs which appear not only to be conserved within the nAChR family and contemporary eukaryotic members of the pentameric ligand-gated ion channel (pLGIC) superfamily, but also extend to prokaryotic homologues found in bacteria. The evolutionarily conserved design is manifested in: 1) the concentric three-ring architecture of the transmembrane region, 2) the occurrence in this region of distinct lipid consensus motifs in prokaryotic and eukaryotic pLGIC and 3) the key participation of the outer TM4 ring in conveying the influence of the lipid membrane environment to the middle TM1-TM3 ring and this, in turn, to the inner TM2 channel-lining ring, which determines the ion selectivity of the channel. The preservation of these constant structural-functional features throughout such a long phylogenetic span likely points to the successful gain-of-function conferred by their early acquisition. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Lipid-protein interactions.

Tryptophan scanning mutagenesis reveals distortions in the helical structure of the δM4 transmembrane domain of the Torpedo californica nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

The lipid-protein interface is an important domain of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) that has recently garnered increased relevance. Several studies have made significant advances toward determining the structure and dynamics of the lipid-exposed domains of the nAChR. However, there is still a need to gain insight into the mechanism by which lipid-protein interactions regulate the function and conformational transitions of the nAChR. In this study, we extended the tryptophan scanning mutagenesis (TrpScanM) approach to dissect secondary structure and monitor the conformational changes experienced by the δM4 transmembrane domain (TMD) of the Torpedo californica nAChR, and to identify which positions on this domain are potentially linked to the regulation of ion channel kinetics. The difference in oscillation patterns between the closed- and open-channel states suggests a substantial conformational change along this domain as a consequence of channel activation. Furthermore, TrpScanM revealed distortions along the helical structure of this TMD that are not present on current models of the nAChR. Our results show that a Thr-Pro motif at positions 462-463 markedly bends the helical structure of the TMD, consistent with the recent crystallographic structure of the GluCl Cys-loop receptor which reveals a highly bent TMD4 in each subunit. This Thr-Pro motif acts as a molecular hinge that delineates two gating blocks in the δM4 TMD. These results suggest a model in which a hinge-bending motion that tilts the helical structure is combined with a spring-like motion during transition between the closed- and open-channel states of the δM4 TMD.

Fourier transform coupled tryptophan scanning mutagenesis identifies a bending point on the lipid-exposed δM3 transmembrane domain of the Torpedo californica nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) is a member of a family of ligand-gated ion channels that mediate diverse physiological functions, including fast synaptic transmission along the peripheral and central nervous systems. Several studies have made significant advances toward determining the structure and dynamics of the lipid-exposed domains of the nAChR. However, a high-resolution atomic structure of the nAChR still remains elusive. In this study, we extended the Fourier transform coupled tryptophan scanning mutagenesis (FT-TrpScanM) approach to gain insight into the secondary structure of the δM3 transmembrane domain of the Torpedo californica nAChR, to monitor conformational changes experienced by this domain during channel gating, and to identify which lipid-exposed positions are linked to the regulation of ion channel kinetics. The perturbations produced by periodic tryptophan substitutions along the δM3 transmembrane domain were characterized by two-electrode voltage clamp and (125)I-labeled α-bungarotoxin binding assays. The periodicity profiles and Fourier transform spectra of this domain revealed similar helical structures for the closed- and open-channel states. However, changes in the oscillation patterns observed between positions Val-299 and Val-304 during transition between the closed- and open-channel states can be explained by the structural effects caused by the presence of a bending point introduced by a Thr-Gly motif at positions 300-301. The changes in periodicity and localization of residues between the closed-and open-channel states could indicate a structural transition between helix types in this segment of the domain. Overall, the data further demonstrate a functional link between the lipid-exposed transmembrane domain and the nAChR gating machinery.

Tryptophan scanning of the acetylcholine receptor's betaM4 transmembrane domain: decoding allosteric linkage at the lipid-protein interface with ion-channel gating

The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) is a ligand-gated ion channel protein that mediates fast excitatory synaptic transmission in the peripheral and central nervous systems. Changes in the structure and function of the AChR can lead to serious impairment of physiological processes. In this study, we combined site-directed mutagenesis, radioligand binding assays, electrophysiological recordings and Fourier analyses to characterize the functional role and structural aspects of the betaM4 transmembrane domain of the Torpedo AChR. We performed tryptophan replacements, from residues L438 through F455, along the betaM4 transmembrane domain. Expression levels of mutants F439W-G450W and F452W-I454W produced peak currents similar to or lower than those in wild-type (WT). Tryptophan substitutions at positions L438 and T451 led to a deficiency in either subunit expression or receptor assembly. Mutations L440W, V442W, C447W and S453W produced a gain-of-function response. Mutation F455W produced a loss of ion channel function. The periodicity profile of the normalized expression level (closed state) and EC(50) (open state) revealed a minor conformational change of 0.4 residues/turn of the betaM4 domain. These findings suggest that a minor movement of the betaM4 domain occurs during channel activation.

Functional contribution of alpha3L8' to the neuronal nicotinic alpha3 receptor

The role of position L8', located in transmembrane domain 1 of the neuronal nicotinic alpha3 subunit, was characterized by using two-electrode voltage clamp in Xenopus oocytes. Four amino acids (Ala, Ser, Phe, and Tyr) were inserted at this conserved position, and the mutant subunit was coexpressed with either wild-type beta2 or beta4 subunits. These substitutions led to significant alterations in the pharmacodynamic parameters of cholinergic agents, resulting in loss of function. Ala and Ser substitutions resulted in losses in agonist (ACh, nicotine, and DMPP) potency and intrinsic activity at both alpha3beta2 and alpha3beta4 receptors. Similarly, significant changes in antagonist potency were produced by the Ala and Ser substitutions. Phe and Tyr mutations did not alter the receptor's EC(50) for ACh or nicotine but reduced the EC(50) for DMPP at both receptors. The Phe mutation also reduced the intrinsic activity of all agonists tested at both receptors. The Tyr mutation, though, led to a decrease in intrinsic activity for all agonists at the alpha3beta2 receptor, yet resulted in no changes for DMPP, a decrease for nicotine, and an increase for ACh at the alpha3beta4 receptor. The most dramatic changes in the receptor's functional properties were produced by substitutions that introduced the largest changes in amino acid volume. Additional replacements (Gly, Thr, and Val) suggested an inverse correlation between amino acid volume at position alpha3L8' and EC(50) for alpha3beta4 nAChRs; however, alpha3beta2 nAChRs displayed a nonlinear correlation. These data demonstrate that structural alterations at position alpha3L8' could propagate to the agonist-binding site.

Aromaticity at the water-hydrocarbon core interface of the membrane: consequences on the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

Almost all lipid-exposed transmembrane domains of integral proteins contain aromatic residues flanking the hydrophobic segment of the domains. These residues generally reside close to the carbonyl region of the membrane, and several structural and functional roles have been associated to these residues. Although the roles and physicochemical reasons for aromatic preference have been extensively studied using model systems, few studies have been done in a native membrane system. To gain insight about the mechanistic implication for this aromatic preference, we selected position alpha F426 of the muscle-type nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR). alpha F426 is a lipid-exposed residue at the extracellular segment of the alpha M4 transmembrane domain and is highly conserved among different nAChR subunits and species. We used site-directed mutagenesis, alpha-Bungarotoxin-binding assay, and two-electrodes voltage clamp in Xenopus laevis oocytes to characterize mutations at position alpha F426, which impart different physicochemical properties like volume, polarity, hydrogen bonds, aromaticity and net electrical charge. All mutations except the aromatic residues resulted in a significant reduction of the nAChR cell-surface levels and the macroscopic currents to acetylcholine. These results suggest that position alpha F426 contributes to structural stability and open-close transitions of the nAChR. Finally, the present study also provides information about how intermolecular interactions at position alpha 426 modulate open-close transitions of the nAChR.

Fourier transform coupled to tryptophan-scanning mutagenesis: lessons from its application to the prediction of secondary structure in the acetylcholine receptor lipid-exposed transmembrane domains

Although Fourier transform (FT) and tryptophan-scanning mutagenesis (TrpScanM) have been extremely useful for predicting secondary structures of membrane proteins, they are deemed to be low-resolution techniques. Herein, we describe the combined use of FT and TrpScanM (FT-TrpScanM) as a more reliable approach for the prediction of secondary structure. Five TrpScanM studies of the acetylcholine receptor lipid-exposed transmembrane domains (LETMDs) were revisited and analyzed by FT-TrpScanM. FT analysis of the raw data from the aforementioned TrpScanM studies supports and validates the conclusions derived from their tryptophan-periodicity profiles. Furthermore, by FT-TrpScanM, we were able to determine the minimum number of consecutive tryptophan substitutions necessary for more robust prediction of alpha-helical secondary structures and evaluate the quality of structure predictions by alpha-helical character curves. Finally, this study encourages future utilization of FT-TrpScanM to more reliably predict secondary structures of the membrane protein LETMDs.

Tryptophan-scanning mutagenesis in the alphaM3 transmembrane domain of the muscle-type acetylcholine receptor. A spring model revealed

Membrane proteins constitute a large fraction of all proteins, yet very little is known about their structure and conformational transitions. A fundamental question that remains obscure is how protein domains that are in direct contact with the membrane lipids move during the conformational change of the membrane protein. Important structural and functional information of several lipid-exposed transmembrane domains of the acetylcholine receptor (AChR) and other ion channel membrane proteins have been provided by the tryptophan-scanning mutagenesis. Here, we use the tryptophan-scanning mutagenesis to monitor the conformational change of the alphaM3 domain of the muscle-type AChR. The perturbation produced by the systematic tryptophan substitution along the alphaM3 domain were characterized through two-electrode voltage clamp and 125I-labeled alpha-bungarotoxin binding. The periodicity profiles of the changes in AChR expression (closed state) and ACh EC50 (open-channel state) disclose two different helical structures; a thinner-elongated helix for the closed state and a thicker-shrunken helix for the open-channel state. The existence of two different helical structures suggest that the conformational transition of the alphaM3 domain between both states resembles a spring motion and reveals that the lipid-AChR interface plays a key role in the propagation of the conformational wave evoked by agonist binding. In addition, the present study also provides evidence about functional and structural differences between the alphaM3 domains of the Torpedo and muscle-type receptors AChR.

Contribution of valine 7' of TMD2 to gating of neuronal alpha3 receptor subtypes

The second transmembrane domain (TMD2) of the Cys-loop family of ligand-gated ion channels forms the channel pore. The functional role of the amino acid residues contributing to the channel pore in neuronal nicotinic alpha3 receptors is not well understood. We characterized the contribution of TMD2 position V7' to channel gating in neuronal nicotinic alpha3 receptors. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to substitute position alpha3 (V7') with four different amino acids (A, F, S, or Y) and coexpressed each mutant subunit with wild-type (WT) beta2 or beta4 subunits in Xenopus oocytes. Whole-cell voltage clamp experiments show that substitution for an alanine, serine, or phenylalanine decreased by 2.3-6.2-fold the ACh-EC(50) for alpha3beta2 and alpha3beta4 receptor subtypes. Interestingly, mutation V7'Y did not produce a significant change in ACh-EC(50) when coexpressed with the beta2 subunit but showed a significant approximately two-fold increase with beta4. Similar responses were obtained with nicotine as the agonist. The antagonist sensitivity of the mutant channels was assessed by using dihydro-beta-erythroidine (DHbetaE) and methyllycaconitine (MLA). The apparent potency of DHbetaE as an antagonist increased by approximately 3.7- and 11-fold for the alpha3beta2 V7'S and V7'F mutants, respectively, whereas no evident changes in antagonist potency were observed for the V7'A and V7'Y mutants. The V7'S and V7'F mutations increase MLA antagonist potency for the alpha3beta4 receptor by approximately 6.2- and approximately 9.3-fold, respectively. The V7'A mutation selectively increases the MLA antagonist potency for the alpha3beta4 receptor by approximately 18.7-fold. These results indicate that position V7' contributes to channel gating kinetics and pharmacology of the neuronal nicotinic alpha3 receptors.