An overview of solvent extraction processes developed in Europe for advanced nuclear fuel recycling, part 1 — heterogeneous recycling

Speciation and Organic Phase Structure in Nitric Acid Extraction with Trioctylamine

Understanding chemical speciation and intermolecular interactions in multicomponent liquids is essential to understanding their phase and chemical equilibria, which underpin chemical separation processes, including solvent extraction. Here we report on the extraction of nitric acid from its aqueous solutions into organic solutions of trioctylamine (TOA) in toluene, investigated with spectroscopic, X-ray scattering, and computational tools to understand molecular speciation in the organic phase and its relationship with the nanoscale structure of the organic phase. Trends in acid and water extraction clearly show two and three regimes, respectively, indicating different stoichiometric relationships, but speciation of HNO3, water, and amine in these regimes is not apparent. 1H NMR of the organic phase shows that there are at least two distinct acidic protons in the organic phase while ATR-FTIR results show that the organic phase with excess acid extraction is a mixture of trioctylammonium-nitrate ion pairs (TOAH·NO3), and undissociated HNO3 molecules. Comparison with DFT-computed IR spectra show that the chain-like configurations of TOAH·NO3·HNO3·H2O are favored over TOAH·NO3·H2O·HNO3, i.e., direct interaction between the nitrate and HNO3 molecules is more favored compared to a water-mediated interaction. SAXS of the organic phases were modeled as sums of Ornstein-Zernike (O-Z) scattering and a prepeak feature in the higher Q region that corresponds to extractant packing. The extraction of undissociated HNO3 by the ion pairs leads to an increased X-ray scattering contrast in the organic phase without any significant change in the correlation length. These results show that the organic phase nanostructure is more sensitive to the concentration of TOAH·NO3 and is relatively unaffected by excess acid extraction. These findings will enable a molecular understanding of the mechanisms behind metal extraction from acidic media with basic extractants.

Ligand structure and diluent nature in defining improved Am3+ and Cm3+ separation using diglycolamides: a combined solvent extraction and DFT study

Separation of Am3+ and Cm3+ is one of the most challenging yet unavoidable steps in the back end of the nuclear cycle. Various ligands evaluated for Am/Cm separation have their own merits and demerits, and not a single ligand has been uniquely proposed for this purpose. In the present work, we evaluated N,N,N',N'-tetra-n-octyldiglycolamide (TODGA) vis-à-vis N,N,N',N'-tetra-2-ethylhexyldiglycolamide (T2EHDGA) in combination with a hydrophilic 2,6-bis(1,2,4-triazinyl)pyridine (SO3PhBTP) derivative in the aqueous phase for the separation of Am3+ and Cm3+ from nitric acid medium. The results showed that marginal selectivity for Am3+ over Cm3+ was observed with T2EHDGA in the presence of SO3PhBTP, which was attributed to the difference in the entropy change for their extraction from both the temperature-dependent liquid-liquid extraction and computational studies.

Selective Separation of Americium(III), Curium(III), and Lanthanide(III) by Aqueous and Organic Competitive Extraction

Adding hydrophilic ligands into aqueous solutions for the selective binding of actinides(III) is acknowledged as an advanced strategy in Ln(III)/An(III) separation. In view of the recycling and radioactive waste disposal of the minor actinide, there remains an urgent need to design and develop the appropriate ligand for selective separation of An(III) from Ln(III). Herein, four novel hydrophilic ligands with hard-soft hybrid donors, derived from the pyridine and phenanthroline skeletons, were designed and synthesized as masking agents for selective complexation of An(III) in the aqueous phase. The known N,N,N',N'-tetraoctyl diglycolamide (TODGA) was used as lipophilic extractant in the organic phase for extraction of Ln(III), and a new strategy for the competitive extraction of An(III) and Ln(III) was developed based on TODGA and the above hydrophilic ligands. The optimal hydrophilic ligand of N,N'-bis(2-hydroxyethyl)-2,9-dicarboxamide-1,10-phenanthroline (2OH-DAPhen) displayed exceptional selectivity toward Am(III) over Ln(III), with the concentrations of HNO3 ranging from 0.05 to 3.0 M. The maximum separation factors were up to 1365 for Eu/Am, 417.66 for Eu/Cm, and 42.38 for La/Am. The coordination mode and bonding property of 2OH-DAPhen with Ln(III) were investigated by 1H NMR titration, UV-vis spectrophotometric titration, luminescence titration, FT-IR, ESI-HRMS analysis, and DFT calculations. The results revealed that the predominant species formed in the aqueous phase was a 1:1 ligand/metal complex. DFT calculations also confirmed that the affinity of 2OH-DAPhen for Am(III) was better than that for Eu(III). The present work using a competitive extraction strategy developed a feasible alternative method for the selective separation of trivalent actinides from lanthanides.

New asymmetric tetradentate phenanthroline chelators with pyrazole and amide groups for complexation and solvent extraction of Ln(III)/Am(III)

To tune the complexation and solvent extraction performance of the ligands with a 1,10-phenanthroline core for trivalent actinides (An3+) and lanthanides (Ln3+), we synthesized two new asymmetric tetradentate ligands with pyrazole and amide groups, i.e., L1 (N,N-diethyl-9-(5-ethyl-1H-pyrazol-3-yl)-1,10-phenanthroline-2-carboxamide) and its analogue L2 with longer alkyl chains (N,N-dihexyl). The complexation of the ligands with Ln3+ was confirmed by 1H NMR titration and X-ray crystallography, and stability constants were measured in methanol by spectrophotometric titration. The asymmetric ligands exhibited an improved performance in terms of selective solvent extraction of Am3+ over Eu3+ in strongly acidic solutions compared to their symmetric analogues. The improved selectivity of the asymmetric ligands was interpreted theoretically by density functional theory simulations. This study implies that combining different functional groups to construct asymmetric ligands may be an efficient way to tune ligand performance with regard to An3+ separation from Ln3+.

A Simple yet Efficient Hydrophilic Phenanthroline-Based Ligand for Selective Am(III) Separation under High Acidity

Highly selective hydrophilic ligands were believed to be an efficient way to overcome the massive amount of hazardous organic solvent used in the liquid-liquid extraction process and stood as a new frontier in the Lns(III)/Ans(III) partition. Current reported hydrophilic ligands suffer from harsh preparation conditions, inferior extraction performances, limited available chemical structures, and inability to carry out extraction under high acidity. In this article, we report a simple yet efficient carboxylic group modified phenanthroline-diimide ligand which displayed unexpected Lns(III)/Ans(III) and Ans(III)/Ans(III) separation capabilities in 1.5 M HNO3. Unique dimeric architectures for Eu(III) complexes were observed, which could be the origin of the outperforming selectivity and acid resistance. We believe this crystal engineering approach could inspire a renaissance in searching for new functional groups and coordination modes for efficient, high-acid-tolerance Lns(III)/Ans(III) separation ligands.

Study of irradiation decomposition products of PUREX solvents on zirconium metal retention behavior

The metal retention behaviors of several simulated radiolysis products on zirconium metal were investigated, and it was found that acid phosphate radiolysis product HDEHP has the greatest effect. The effects of extraction nitric acid concentration, simulated radiolysis product concentration, metal concentration, and temperature on the zirconium metal retention behavior were also investigated. The results showed that zirconium metal forms complexes with HDEHP resulting in retention in the organic phase. Nitric acid concentration and metal concentration change the morphology of the metal thus affecting the extraction and metal retention behavior. The temperature has almost no effect on metal retention.

Pyridine-di-phosphonates as chelators for trivalent f-elements: kinetics, thermodynamic and interfacial study of Am(III)/Eu(III) solvent extraction

The fractionation of high-level radioactive waste from nuclear power plants simplifies the handling of its components, and facilitates the reduction of radiotoxic effects on the environment. The search and study of new ligands for solvent extraction, as one of the methods in fractionation, remains a complex and important research task. In this work, four pyridine diphosphonate ligands were synthesized. These ligands are part of the class of the N,O-donor extractants, which are selective towards Am(III). The separation factor SF(Am/Eu) for the best extractant reached values up to 10. The influence of the substituents on the efficiency of extraction and complexation of trivalent f-elements, the kinetics of extraction, and the behavior of the ligand at the interface were described. The effect of nitric acid concentration on the extraction was shown. The stoichiometry of the complexes was determined by slope analysis in solvent extraction experiment and verified by spectrophotometric titration in acetonitrile. Liquid tension experiments with a pendant drop method revealed the interfacial properties of the ligands in "F-3 solvent/H₂O" and "F-3 solvent/HNO₃" systems. The relationship between the surface activity and the ligand structure was shown. Studies of the extraction kinetics were performed in a modified Lewis cell. The effect of the ligand structure on the extraction rate was shown. The DFT calculation with the B3LYP density functional was used to explain the extraction properties of the ligands, including selectivity. The calculation of the pre-organization energy of the ligands explained the kinetics and extraction patterns for the studied series.

Spectroscopic investigation of the different complexation and extraction properties of diastereomeric diglycolamide ligands

(2R,2′S)-2,2′-oxybis-(N,N-didecylpropanamide) (cis-mTDDGA) and (2R,2′R)-2,2′-oxybis-(N,N-didecylpropanamide) (trans-mTDDGA) were studied using time-resolved laser fluorescence spectroscopy (TRLFS), vibronic side-band spectroscopy (VSBS) and density functional theory calculations (DFT) to find reasons for their different extraction properties. Stability constants of the respective Cm(III) and Eu(III) complexes show cis-mTDDGA to be the superior ligand which is in agreement with results from extraction experiments. cis-mTDDGA extracts Cm(III) and Eu(III) as 1:3 complexes. In case of trans-mTDDGA, 1:2 complexes of the form [M(trans-mTDDGA)2(η1-NO3)(H2O)2]2+ (M = Cm, Eu) are extracted additionally to the 1:3 complexes. VSBS and DFT confirm the presence of inner-sphere nitrate in the 1:2 complex.

Uranium: The Nuclear Fuel Cycle and Beyond

This review summarizes the recent developments regarding the use of uranium as nuclear fuel, including recycling and health aspects, elucidated from a chemical point of view, i.e., emphasizing the rich uranium coordination chemistry, which has also raised interest in using uranium compounds in synthesis and catalysis. A number of novel uranium coordination features are addressed, such the emerging number of U(II) complexes and uranium nitride complexes as a promising class of materials for more efficient and safer nuclear fuels. The current discussion about uranium triple bonds is addressed by quantum chemical investigations using local vibrational mode force constants as quantitative bond strength descriptors based on vibrational spectroscopy. The local mode analysis of selected uranium nitrides, N≡U≡N, U≡N, N≡U=NH and N≡U=O, could confirm and quantify, for the first time, that these molecules exhibit a UN triple bond as hypothesized in the literature. We hope that this review will inspire the community interested in uranium chemistry and will serve as an incubator for fruitful collaborations between theory and experimentation in exploring the wealth of uranium chemistry.

Selective actinide(III) separation using 2,6-bis[1-(propan-1-ol)-1,2,3-triazol-4-yl]pyridine (PyTri-Diol) in the innovative-SANEX process: laboratory scale counter current centrifugal contactor demonstration

An innovative-SANEX process for the selective separation of the trivalent actinides americium and curium from a simulated PUREX raffinate solution was successfully demonstrated on the laboratory scale using a 16-stage 1 cm annular centrifugal contactor setup. The solvent was composed of 0.2 mol L−1 N,N,N′,N′-tetra-n-octyl-diglycolamide (TODGA) and 5% v/v 1-octanol in a kerosene diluent. Zr(IV) and Pd(II) co-extraction was prevented using trans-1,2-diaminocyclohexane-N,N,N′,N′-tetraacetic acid (CDTA) as a masking agent in the feed. The actinide(III) selective back-extraction was achieved using 2,6-bis[1-(propan-1-ol)-1,2,3-triazol-4-yl]pyridine (PyTri-Diol) in 0.45 mol L−1 HNO3 as a CHON alternative to the sulfur-containing stripping agent used in a previous version of the innovative-SANEX process. The new process described in this paper showed excellent performance for the recovery of An(III). An An(III) product with a quasi-quantitative recovery of americium and curium (≥99.9%) and very good separation from fission and activation products was obtained (decontamination factors ≥4000). Only a slight contamination with Zr and Ru was observed. This test demonstrates the successful use of molecules containing only carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen atoms (so-called CHON molecules) for the selective separation of An(III) from a simulated PUREX raffinate solution. By avoiding sulfur- or phosphorous-containing molecules, the generation of secondary radioactive waste during process operation can be reduced drastically.

Probing the Difference in the Complexation of Trivalent Actinides and Lanthanides with a Tridentate N,O-Hybrid Ligand: Spectroscopy, Thermodynamics, and Coordination Modes

Comparatively revealing the complexation behavior of trivalent actinides and lanthanides with functional ligands in aqueous solution is of great importance to enrich our knowledge on the fundamental coordination chemistry of trivalent f-block elements and to control the fate of minor actinides in nuclear fuel cycles. In this work, the complexation of Am(III) and Nd(III), representatives for trivalent actinides and lanthanides, respectively, with a N,O-hybrid ligand 6-(dimethylcarbamoyl)picolinic acid (DMAPA, denoted as HL) was investigated by absorption spectroscopy, calorimetry, X-ray crystallography, and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Successive formation of 1:1, 1:2, and 1:3 (metal/ligand) complexes of Am(III) and Nd(III) with DMAPA was identified, and the corresponding thermodynamic parameters were determined. The binding strength of Am(III) with DMAPA is slightly stronger than that of Nd(III), and the complexation of Nd(III) with DMAPA is mainly entropy-driven. The crystal structure of the 1:2 Nd(III)/DMAPA complex and the DFT calculation shed additional light on the coordination and structural characteristics of the complexes. In contrast to the Nd-N bond in the Nd(III)/DMAPA complex, the Am-N bond in the Am(III)/DMAPA complex exhibits more covalency, which contributes to the slightly stronger complexation of Am(III) with DMAPA.

Ultra-Efficient Americium/Lanthanide Separation through Oxidation State Control

Lanthanide/actinide separation is a worldwide challenge for atomic energy and nuclear waste treatment. Separation of americium (Am), a critical actinide element in the nuclear fuel cycle, from lanthanides (Ln) is highly desirable for minimizing the long-term radiotoxicity of nuclear waste, yet it is extremely challenging given the chemical similarity between trivalent Am(III) and Ln(III). Selective oxidation of Am(III) to a higher oxidation state (OS) could facilitate this separation, but so far, it is far from satisfactory for practical application as a result of the unstable nature of Am in a high OS. Herein, we find a novel strategy to generate stable pentavalent Am (Am(V)) through coordination of Am(III) with a diglycolamide ligand and oxidation with Bi(V) species in the presence of an organic solvent. This strategy leads to efficient stabilization of Am(V) and an extraordinarily high separation factor (>10⁴) of Am from Ln through one single contact in solvent extraction, thereby opening a new avenue to study the high-OS chemistry of Am and fulfill the crucial task of Ln/Am separation in the nuclear fuel cycle. The synergistic coordination and oxidation process is found to occur in the organic solvent, and the mechanism has been well elucidated by quantum-theoretical modeling.

2-Methylpyrrolidine derived 1,10-phenanthroline-2,9-diamides: promising extractants for Am(iii)/Ln(iii) separation

In this work we report on new examples of phenanthrolindiamides containing asymmetric centers in amide substituents.

Engineering lanmodulin's selectivity for actinides over lanthanides by controlling solvent coordination and second-sphere interactions

Developing chelators that combine high affinity and selectivity for lanthanides and/or actinides is paramount for numerous industries, including rare earths mining, nuclear waste management, and cancer medicine. In particular, achieving selectivity between actinides and lanthanides is notoriously difficult. The protein lanmodulin (LanM) is one of Nature's most selective chelators for trivalent actinides and lanthanides. However, mechanistic understanding of LanM's affinity and selectivity for f-elements remains limited. In order to decipher, and possibly improve, the features of LanM's metal-binding sites that contribute to this actinide/lanthanide selectivity, we characterized five LanM variants, substituting the aspartate residue at the 9^th position of each metal-binding site with asparagine, histidine, alanine, methionine, and selenomethionine. Spectroscopic measurements with lanthanides (Nd³⁺ and Eu³⁺) and actinides (²⁴³Am³⁺ and ²⁴⁸Cm³⁺) reveal that, contrary to the behavior of small chelator complexes, metal-coordinated water molecules enhance LanM's affinity for f-elements and pH-stability of its complexes. Furthermore, the results show that the native aspartate does not coordinate the metal directly but rather hydrogen bonds to coordinated solvent. By tuning this first-sphere/second-sphere interaction, the asparagine variant nearly doubles LanM's selectivity for actinides versus lanthanides. This study not only clarifies the essential role of coordinated solvent for LanM's physiological function and separation applications, but it also demonstrates that LanM's preference for actinides over lanthanides can be further improved. More broadly, it demonstrates how biomolecular scaffolds possess an expanded repertoire of tunable interactions compared to most small-molecule ligands – providing an avenue for high-performance LanM-based actinide/lanthanide separation methods and bio-engineered chelators optimized for specific medical isotopes.

Nature’s most potent protein for f-elements, lanmodulin, relies on subtle first-sphere/second-sphere interactions to bind metal ions. Dissecting lanmodulin’s binding mechanism yielded variants with enhanced actinide/lanthanide selectivity.

Curium(iii) radiation-induced reaction kinetics in aqueous media

Insight into the effects of radiolytic processes on the actinides is critical for advancing our understanding of their solution chemistry because the behaviour of these elements cannot be easily separated from the influence of their inherent radiation field. However, minimal information exists on the radiation-induced redox behaviour of curium (Cm), a key trivalent transuranic element present in used nuclear fuel and frequently used as an alpha radiation source. Here we present a kinetic study on the aqueous redox reactions of Cm(iii) with radicals generated through the radiolysis of aqueous media. In particular, we probe reaction kinetics in nitric acid solutions that are used as the aqueous phase component of used nuclear fuel reprocessing solvent systems. Second-order rate coefficients (k) were measured for the reaction of Cm(iii) with the hydrated electron (e_aq^-, k = (1.25 ± 0.03) × 10¹⁰ M^-1 s^-1), hydrogen atom (H˙, k = (5.16 ± 0.37) × 10⁸ M^-1 s^-1), hydroxyl radical (˙OH, k = (1.69 ± 0.24) × 10⁹ M^-1 s^-1), and nitrate radical (NO₃˙, k = (4.83 ± 0.09) × 10⁷ M^-1 s^-1). Furthermore, the first-ever Cm(ii) absorption spectrum (300-700 nm) is also reported. These kinetic data dispel the status quo notion of Cm(iii) possessing little to no redox chemistry in aqueous solution, and suggest that the resulting Cm(ii) and Cm(iv) transients could exist in irradiated aqueous solutions and be available to undergo subsequent redox chemistry with other solutes.

PyRad: A software shell for simulating radiolysis with Qball package

The assessment of the radiolytic stability of media is an important task in the fields of nuclear power engineering and radiochemistry. Such studies must be carried out in special laboratory conditions with the use of sources of ionizing radiation, which may increase personal doses of the staff. In addition, difficulties arise in studying the products of irradiated media. While it is impossible to abandon experiments to obtain reliable results in this area, computational methods of quantum chemistry can reduce the number of experiments and help understand the mechanisms of the reactions that occur during radiolysis. Here we would like to present a software shell of the Qb@ll program performing time-dependent density functional theory simulations of the radiolysis process.

Radiation-induced effects on the extraction properties of hexa-n-octylnitrilo-triacetamide (HONTA) complexes of americium and europium

The candidate An(iii)/Ln(iii) separation ligand hexa-n-octylnitrilo-triacetamide (HONTA) was irradiated under envisioned SELECT (Solvent Extraction from Liquid waste using Extractants of CHON-type for Transmutation) process conditions (n-dodecane/0.1 M HNO3) using a solvent test loop in conjunction with cobalt-60 gamma irradiation. The extent of HONTA radiolysis and complementary degradation product formation was quantified by HPLC-ESI-MS/MS. Further, the impact of HONTA radiolysis on process performance was evaluated by measuring the change in 243Am and 154Eu distribution ratios as a function of absorbed gamma dose. HONTA was found to decay exponentially with increasing dose, affording a dose coefficient of d = (4.48 ± 0.19) × 10-3 kGy-1. Multiple degradation products were detected by HPLC-ESI-MS/MS with dioctylamine being the dominant quantifiable species. Both 243Am and 154Eu distribution ratios exhibited an induction period of ∼70 kGy for extraction (0.1 M HNO3) and back-extraction (4.0 M HNO3) conditions, after which both values decreased with absorbed dose. The decrease in distribution ratios was attributed to a combination of the destruction of HONTA and ingrowth of dioctylamine, which is capable of interfering in metal ion complexation. The loss of HONTA with absorbed gamma dose was predominantly attributed to its reaction with the n-dodecane radical cation (R˙+). These R˙+ reaction kinetics were measured for HONTA and its 241Am and 154Eu complexes using picosecond pulsed electron radiolysis techniques. All three second-order rate coefficients (k) were essentially diffusion limited in n-dodecane indicating a significant reaction pathway: k(HONTA + R˙+) = (7.6 ± 0.8) × 109 M-1 s-1, k(Am(HONTA)2 + R˙+) = (7.1 ± 0.7) × 1010 M-1 s-1, and k(Eu(HONTA)2 + R˙+) = (9.5 ± 0.5) × 1010 M-1 s-1. HONTA-metal ion complexation afforded an order-of-magnitude increase in rate coefficient. Nanosecond time-resolved measurements showed that both direct and indirect HONTA radiolysis yielded the short-lived (<100 ns) HONTA radical cation and a second long-lived (μs) species identified as the HONTA triplet excited state. The latter was confirmed by a series of oxygen quenching picosecond pulsed electron measurements, affording a quenching rate coefficient of k(3[HONTA]* + O2) = 2.2 × 108 M-1 s-1. Overall, both the HONTA radical cation and triplet excited state are important precursors to the suite of measured HONTA degradation products.