Commentary: RBE in proton therapy - where is the experimental in vivo data?

The fractionation effect on proton RBE in a late normal tissue damage model in vivo

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

A constant relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of 1.1 is used in clinical proton therapy (PT) to convert prescribed photon doses into isoeffective proton doses. However, the RBE is not constant; it is a dynamic parameter highly influenced by factors such as linear energy transfer, tissue type, biological endpoint, and dose/fraction. Preclinical in vivo proton RBE studies using fractionated doses and late damage endpoints are almost nonexistent. The aim is to test the hypotheses that the RBE varies between single and fractionated doses and that the late damage development differs between proton and photon irradiation using a 6 MV linac as a reference modality in a murine leg model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The right hindlimb of unanesthetized mice was irradiated with single or four fractions of protons or 6 MV photons. Over one year after treatment, the mice were analyzed every fourteenth day using a joint contracture assay to investigate severe radiation-induced late damage.

RESULTS

The results indicated a higher RBE for severe late damage endpoint of 1.25 ± 0.06 (1.13-1.36) for fractionated doses than single doses, exhibiting an RBE of 1.16 ± 0.08 (1.00-1.31). The onset of late damage is earlier for protons than photons for doses higher than 47 Gy and fractionated doses above 50 Gy (12.5 Gy per fraction).

CONCLUSION

The findings demonstrate that fractionated doses enhance the RBE for a late damage endpoint and lead to an earlier onset of severe late effects than its photon counterpart in vivo.

The proton RBE and the distal edge effect for acute and late normal tissue damage in vivo

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

In proton therapy, a relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of 1.1 is used toreach an isoeffective biological response between photon and proton doses. However, the RBE varies with biological endpoints and linear energy transfer (LET), two key parameters in radiotherapy. Few in vivo studies have investigated the increasing RBE with increasing LET. This study aims to test the hypothesis that the RBE varies between endpoints and has a distal edge effect in vivo.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Unanesthetized micewere restrainedin jigs where their right hind legs were irradiated with a single dose of protons at the center (LET, all = 5.3 keV/μm) and distal edge (LET, all = 7.6 keV/μm) of a spread-out Bragg peak (SOBP). 6 MV photons were used as reference. The acute damage and skin toxicity were scored daily until day 30, and the late damage was evaluated using a joint contracture assay for one year after treatment.

RESULTS

An acute damage RBE of 1.06 ± 0.02(1.02-1.10) and late damage RBE of 1.16 ± 0.08(1.00-1.32) were found, displaying an enhanced RBE for late damage in the center SOBP. The distal edge RBE for acute and late damage was 1.15 ± 0.02(1.10-1.19) and 1.26 ± 0.09(1.07-1.43), showing a similar center-to-distal edge RBE enhancement of 8 % and 9 % for acute and late damage.

CONCLUSION

The findings demonstrate an increased RBE for late damage than acute damage and the distal edge effect is evident with increased RBE at the distal end of the proton SOBP in vivo.

Variations in linear energy transfer distributions within a European proton therapy planning comparison of paediatric posterior fossa tumours

Background and Purpose

Radiotherapy for paediatric posterior fossa tumours may cause complications in the brainstem and upper spinal cord due to high doses. With proton therapy (PT) this risk may increase due to higher relative biological effectiveness (RBE) from elevated linear energy transfer (LET). This study assesses variations in LET in the brainstem and spinal cord in proton treatment plans from European centres.

Materials and Methods

Ten European PT centres using spot-scanning PT planned two paediatric posterior fossa cases: One overlapping partly with the brainstem and upper spinal cord, prescribed 54 Gy(RBE), and the second wrapping around these organs, prescribed 59.4 Gy(RBE). Dose-averaged LET distributions were assessed in volumes of the brainstem and spinal cord irradiated to over 50 Gy(RBE = 1.1). The maximum hinge angle effect on near-maximum RBE-weighted doses using the Unkelbach RBE model was also investigated.

Results

In the first case, the mean LET in brainstem volumes receiving more than 50 Gy(RBE = 1.1) ranged from 2.8 keV/µm to 3.6 keV/µm across centres (median: 3.3 keV/µm). In the second case, treatment plans showed a narrower range of mean LET in the brainstem, from 2.5 keV/µm to 2.8 keV/µm (median: 2.7 keV/µm). There was no statistically significant impact of the maximum hinge angle.

Conclusions

LET distributions vary across centres due to different techniques but are also influenced significantly by factors like shape and position of the target volume.

An experimental setup for proton irradiation of a murine leg model for radiobiological studies

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to introduce an experimental radiobiological setup used for in vivo irradiation of a mouse leg target in multiple positions along a proton beam path to investigate normal tissue- and tumor models with varying linear energy transfer (LET). We describe the dosimetric characterizations and an acute- and late-effect assay for normal tissue damage.

METHODS

The experimental setup consists of a water phantom that allows the right hind leg of three to five mice to be irradiated at the same time. Absolute dosimetry using a thimble (Semiflex) and a plane parallel (Advanced Markus) ionization chamber and Monte Carlo simulations using Geant4 and SHIELD-HIT12A were applied for dosimetric validation of positioning along the spread-out Bragg peak (SOBP) and at the distal edge and dose fall-off. The mice were irradiated in the center of the SOBP delivered by a pencil beam scanning system. The SOBP was 2.8 cm wide, centered at 6.9 cm depth, with planned physical single doses from 22 to 46 Gy. The biological endpoint was acute skin damage and radiation-induced late damage (RILD) assessed in the mouse leg.

RESULTS

The dose-response curves illustrate the percentage of mice exhibiting acute skin damage, and at a later point, RILD as a function of physical doses (Gy). Each dose-response curve represents a specific severity score of each assay, demonstrating a higher ED50 (50% responders) as the score increases. Moreover, the results reveal the reversible nature of acute skin damage as a function of time and the irreversible nature of RILD as time progresses.

CONCLUSIONS

We want to encourage researchers to report all experimental details of their radiobiological setups, including experimental protocols and model descriptions, to facilitate transparency and reproducibility. Based on this study, more experiments are being performed to explore all possibilities this radiobiological experimental setup permits.

Proposing a Clinical Model for RBE Based on Proton Track-End Counts

PURPOSE

In proton therapy, the clinical application of linear energy transfer (LET) optimization remains contentious, in part because of challenges associated with the definition and calculation of LET and its exact relationship with relative biological effectiveness (RBE) because of large variation in experimental in vitro data. This has raised interest in other metrics with favorable properties for biological optimization, such as the number of proton track ends in a voxel. In this work, we propose a novel model for clinical calculations of RBE, based on proton track end counts.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

We developed an effective dose concept to translate between the total proton track-end count per unit mass in a voxel and a proton RBE value. Dose, track end, and dose-averaged LET (LETd) distributions were simulated using Monte Carlo models for a series of water phantoms, in vitro radiobiological studies, and patient treatment plans. We evaluated the correlation between track ends and regions of elevated biological effectiveness in comparison to LETd-based models of RBE.

RESULTS

Track ends were found to correlate with biological effects in in vitro experiments with an accuracy comparable to LETd. In patient simulations, our track end model identified the same biological hotspots as predicted by LETd-based radiobiological models of proton RBE.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that, for clinical optimization and evaluation, an RBE model based on proton track end counts may match LETd-based models in terms of information provided while also offering superior statistical properties.

Combined proton radiography and irradiation for high-precision preclinical studies in small animals

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Proton therapy has become a popular treatment modality in the field of radiooncology due to higher spatial dose conformity compared to conventional radiotherapy, which holds the potential to spare normal tissue. Nevertheless, unresolved research questions, such as the much debated relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of protons, call for preclinical research, especially regarding in vivo studies. To mimic clinical workflows, high-precision small animal irradiation setups with image-guidance are needed.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A preclinical experimental setup for small animal brain irradiation using proton radiographies was established to perform planning, repositioning, and irradiation of mice. The image quality of proton radiographies was optimized regarding the resolution, contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR), and minimal dose deposition in the animal. Subsequently, proof-of-concept histological analysis was conducted by staining for DNA double-strand breaks that were then correlated to the delivered dose.

RESULTS

The developed setup and workflow allow precise brain irradiation with a lateral target positioning accuracy of<0.26mm for in vivo experiments at minimal imaging dose of<23mGy per mouse. The custom-made software for image registration enables the fast and precise animal positioning at the beam with low observer-variability. DNA damage staining validated the successful positioning and irradiation of the mouse hippocampus.

CONCLUSION

Proton radiography enables fast and effective high-precision lateral alignment of proton beam and target volume in mouse irradiation experiments with limited dose exposure. In the future, this will enable irradiation of larger animal cohorts as well as fractionated proton irradiation.

Models for Translational Proton Radiobiology-From Bench to Bedside and Back

The number of proton therapy centers worldwide are increasing steadily, with more than two million cancer patients treated so far. Despite this development, pending questions on proton radiobiology still call for basic and translational preclinical research. Open issues are the on-going discussion on an energy-dependent varying proton RBE (relative biological effectiveness), a better characterization of normal tissue side effects and combination treatments with drugs originally developed for photon therapy. At the same time, novel possibilities arise, such as radioimmunotherapy, and new proton therapy schemata, such as FLASH irradiation and proton mini-beams. The study of those aspects demands for radiobiological models at different stages along the translational chain, allowing the investigation of mechanisms from the molecular level to whole organisms. Focusing on the challenges and specifics of proton research, this review summarizes the different available models, ranging from in vitro systems to animal studies of increasing complexity as well as complementing in silico approaches.

Variation in relative biological effectiveness for cognitive structures in proton therapy of pediatric brain tumors

BACKGROUND

Clinically, a constant value of 1.1 is used for the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of protons, whereas in vitro the RBE has been shown to vary depending on physical dose, tissue type, and linear energy transfer (LET). As the LET increases at the distal end of the proton beam, concerns exist for an elevated RBE in normal tissues. The aim of this study was therefore to investigate the heterogeneity of RBE to brain structures associated with cognition (BSCs) in pediatric suprasellar tumors.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Intensity-modulated proton therapy (IMPT) plans for 10 pediatric craniopharyngioma patients were re-calculated using 11 phenomenological and two plan-based variable RBE models. Based on LET, tissue dependence and number of data points used to fit the models, the three RBE models considered the most relevant for the studied endpoint were selected. Thirty BSCs were investigated in terms of RBE and dose/volume parameters.

RESULTS

For a representative patient, the median (range) dose-weighted mean RBE (RBE_d) across all BSCs from the plan-based models was among the lowest (1.09 (1.02-1.52) vs. the phenomenological models at 1.21 (0.78-2.24)). Omitting tissue dependency resulted in RBE_d at 1.21 (1.04-2.24). Across all patients, the narrower RBE model selection gave median RBE_d values from 1.22 to 1.30.

CONCLUSION

For all BSCs, there was a systematic model-dependent variation in RBE_d, mirroring the uncertainty in biological effects of protons. According to a refined selection of in vitro models, the RBE variation across BSCs was in effect underestimated when using a fixed RBE of 1.1.