The biological hazards of plutonium

The plutonium problem: the Royal Society sits on the fence

A recent Royal Society report, Management of Separated Plutonium, considers the production and disposal of plutonium from the spent fuel from civil and nuclear power reactors. It accepts the need for dealing with plutonium stocks because of the toxicity of the element and as it can be used to fabricate nuclear weapons, and expresses concern that it might be illicitly acquired by terrorists. It recommends an independent Government commission on the management of plutonium, and considers the various options for this. However, it does not analyse the arguments against plutonium as a reactor fuel, and underestimates the risks of diversion to nuclear weapons and nuclear terrorism. This paper reviews the options, and concludes that separated plutonium should be added to high-level waste, vitrified, and eventually buried in a deep geological repository.

The radiological hazards of plutonium

About 1,500 tonnes of plutonium, 1,200 tonnes civilian, are now in world stockpiles, of which 200 tonnes have been separated from spent fuel in reprocessing plants. This will rise to 300 tonnes by the year 2000. Such reactor-grade plutonium contains a higher proportion of isotopes other than Pu-239, which progressively increases with longer burn-up. These isotopes have an increased risk of causing cancer, particularly if inhaled. Possible cancer rates from scattering of such plutonium in a city centre (e.g. by terrorist activity) are considered, and the implications of these calculations for the wisdom of continued reprocessing of spent nuclear reactor fuel are discussed.