Two pathways for the induction of apoptosis in human lymphocytes

Downregulation of lncRNA BANCR participates in the development of retinopathy among diabetic patients

The long non-coding (lnc)RNA B-Raf proto-oncogene, serine/threonine kinase-activated non-protein coding RNA (BANCR) is a well-characterized oncogene, while its potential functions in other diseases remain elusive. In the present study, the possible association of BANCR with diabetic retinopathy was investigated. A total of 244 patients with diabetes were followed up every 6 months for 8 years to record the occurrence of retinopathy. A total of 38 patients developed diabetic retinopathy. During the follow-up, the plasma levels of lncRNA BANCR decreased in those patients with diabetic retinopathy but not in those with other complications or without any complications. The plasma levels of lncRNA BANCR at 12 months prior to the diagnosis of diabetic retinopathy are able to sufficiently distinguish diabetic retinopathy patients from healthy controls and diabetic patients without any obvious complications. In vitro, high-glucose treatment failed to affect the expression of lncRNA BANCR in the human retinal pigment epithelial cell line ARPE-19. However, lncRNA BANCR overexpression inhibited the apoptosis of ARPE-19 cells under high-glucose conditions. Therefore, it is indicated that lncRNA BANCR participates in the development of retinopathy in diabetic patients through its regulatory role in cell apoptosis, and may serve as a novel prognostic indicator and therapeutic target.

Frequency of background and radiation-induced apoptosis in leukocytes of individuals with alpha-thalassemia variants, assessed by the neutral comet assay

To study effects of ionizing radiation on apoptosis induction in leukocytes of alpha-thalassemia (alpha-thal) variants compared to normal controls, venous blood samples were obtained from 10 healthy volunteers and 30 alpha-thal patients. Different types alpha-thal were diagnosed by multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Blood samples were irradiated with three Gy gamma rays, used for comet assay, immediately or 48 h after irradiation. Results show that the frequency of background as well as apoptosis in silent alpha-thal carriers, alpha-thal carriers and controls was similar but there was a significant difference between Hb H patients and other groups in the study. The increased apoptosis in Hb H patients might suggest that accumulation of beta-globin and oxidative stresses are effective in causing apoptosis, and cells from these patients are more vulnerable to damage from radiation-induced toxic substances. Therefore, from alpha-thal patients, those with Hb H disease might be considered as radiosensitive in terms of apoptosis formation.

Low and high LET radiation‐induced apoptosis in M059J and M059K cells

PURPOSE

To investigate and compare the ability of DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK)-deficient and -proficient cells to undergo apoptosis after exposure to low and high linear energy transfer (LET) radiation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A human glioma cell line M059J lacking the catalytic subunit of DNA-PK (DNA-PKcs) and its DNA-PKcs-proficient counterpart, M059K, were exposed to 1 and 4 Gy of accelerated nitrogen ions (14N, 140 eV nm(-1), 8-12 Gy min(-1)) or 60Co gamma-rays (0.2 eV nm(-1), 0.7 Gy min(-1)). The induction of apoptosis was studied up to 144 h post-irradiation using two different methods: morphological characterization of apoptotic cells after fluorescent staining and cell size distribution analysis to detect apoptotic bodies. In parallel, protein expression of DNA-PKcs and poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) as well as DNA-PK and caspase-3 activity were investigated.

RESULTS

Low and high LET radiations (4 Gy) induced a time-dependent apoptotic response in both cell lines. Low LET radiation induced a significantly elevated apoptotic response in M059J as compared with M059K cells at 144 h post-irradiation. Following high LET radiation exposure, there was no difference between the cell lines at this time. PARP cleavage was detected in M059J cells following both low and high LET irradiation, while only high LET radiation induced PARP cleavage in M059K cells. These cleavages occurred in the absence of caspase-3 activation.

CONCLUSIONS

M059J and M059K cells both display radiation-induced apoptosis, which occur independently of caspase-3 activation. The apoptotic course differs between the two cell lines and is dependent on the quality of radiation.

Relative biological effectiveness of 280 keV neutrons for apoptosis in human lymphocytes

The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of neutrons varies from unity to greater than ten depending upon neutron energy and the biological endpoint measured. In our study, we examined apoptosis in human lymphocytes to assess the RBE of low energy 280 keV neutrons compared to Cs gamma radiation and found the RBE to be approximately one. Similar results have been observed for high energy neutrons using the same endpoint. As apoptosis is a major process that influences the consequences of radiation exposure, our results indicate that biological effect and the corresponding weighting factors for 280 keV neutrons may be lower in some cell types and tissues.

Ret, Abl1 (cAbl) and Trp53 gene fragmentations in comet-FISH assay act as in vivo biomarkers of radiation exposure in C57BL/6 and CBA/J mice

The International Commission on Radiation Protection (ICRP) has lowered the dose limits for workers and for the general public exposed to ionizing radiation. Consequently, a reliable dosimetric method for monitoring possible radiation-induced damage is of great importance in radioprotection. The counting of dicentric chromosomal aberrations and of micronuclei in peripheral blood lymphocytes is unreliable when it is applied to in vivo biopsies and for low-dose exposures. Single-cell gel electrophoresis (SCGE or comet assay), although sensitive and rapid, shows high variability when applied in vivo, probably due to prompt repair of the DNA breaks and confounding environmental factors. In this paper, we describe specific in situ hybridization of Ret, Abl1 (cAbl), and Trp53 gene fragmentations on SCGE slides (comet-FISH assay) in peripheral blood cells from C57BL/6 and CBA/J mice as an indicator of radiation-induced DNA damage. The results obtained from four mice for each experimental point (0, 1, 2 and 4 Gy of X rays) discriminated in a statistically significant way the effects of all doses when fragmentations were analyzed for the Ret, Ab1 and Trp53 genes. SCGE alone, when applied to the same specimens, produced no significant results because of interindividual and experimental variability.

Induction of apoptosis and necrosis in lymphocytes by the cis-Pt(II) complex of 3-aminoflavone in comparison with cis-DDP

cis-Diamminedichloroplatinum(II) (cis-DDP) is one of the most widely administrated antitumor drugs. However, the use of cis-DDP is severely limited because of its toxic side effects. Therefore, efforts are concentrated on the development of improved platinum compounds with a broader activity spectrum and effectiveness in chemotherapy, but lower toxicity. Beneficial properties of flavonoids, e.g. their antitumor activity, encouraged scientists to synthesize cis-bis(3-aminoflavone)dichloroplatinum(II). Abilities of these compounds to induce apoptosis and necrosis were compared by use of trypan blue, fluorochrome staining (Hoechst 33258/propidium iodide double staining) and TUNEL assays. The cytotoxicity was evaluated by MTT. The results obtained show that the cis-Pt(II) complex of 3-aminoflavone is less toxic than cis-DDP. However, the former compound has a faster rate of apoptosis induction in lymphocytes than the latter. The cis-Pt(II) complex of 3-aminoflavone induces apoptosis in normal lymphocytes to a lesser degree and could be a potential antitumor drug.

Detection of radiation-induced apoptosis using the comet assay

The electrophoresis pattern of apoptotic cells detected by the comet assay has a characteristic small head and spread tail. This image has been referred to as an apoptotic comet, but it has not been previously proven to be apoptotic cells by any direct method. In order to identify this image obtained by the comet assay as corresponding to an apoptotic cell, the frequency of appearance of apoptosis was examined using CHO-K1 and L5178Y cells which were exposed to gamma irradiation. As a method for detecting apoptosis, the terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase mediated dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL) assay was used. When the frequency of appearance of apoptotic cells following gamma irradiation was observed over a period of time, there was a significant increase in appearance of apoptosis when using the TUNEL assay. However, there was only a slight increase when using the comet assay. In order to verify the low frequency of appearance of apoptosis when using the comet assay, we attempted to use the TUNEL assay to stain the apoptotic comets detected in the comet assay. The apoptotic comets were TUNEL positive and the normal comets were TUNEL negative. This indicates that the apoptotic comets were formed from DNA fragments with 3'-hydroxy ends that are generated as cells undergo apoptosis. Therefore, it was understood that the characteristic pattern of apoptotic comets detected by the comet assay corresponds to cells undergoing apoptosis.

Preventive effects of a water-soluble derivative of chroman moiety of vitamin E on lipid hydroperoxide-induced cell injuries and DNA cleavages through repressions of oxidative stress in the cytoplasm of human keratinocytes

ChrCrx (6-hydroxy-2, 5, 7, 8-tetramethyl-chroman-2-carboxylic acid) is a water-soluble analog in which 4', 8', 12'-trimethyltridecyl chain is deleted from an alpha-tocopherol molecule known as a hydrophobic antioxidant. Cell viability of human skin epidermal keratinocytes HaCaT was lowered by treatment with tert-butylhydroperoxide (t-BuOOH) of 50 microM for 48 h, designated as a subacute cytotoxicity, which was prevented by previous administration with ChrCrx in a dose-dependent manner as estimated by mitochondrial function-based WST-1 assay and cell morphological microscopy. In contrast an acute cytotoxicity due to treatment with t-BuOOH as dense as 200 microM for a period as short as 2 h could be also prevented with ChrCrx that was administered before and after, but was eliminated during, treatment with t-BuOOH. In contrast alpha-tocopherol was not cytoprotective against t-BuOOH. DNA strand cleavages were induced with t-BuOOH in the keratinocytes, and could be prevented by ChrCrx more effectively than alpha-tocopherol as assayed by TUNEL stain. The intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS) was accumulated in a manner dependent on periods of t-BuOOH treatment in the cytoplasm more abundantly rather than the nucleus of keratinocytes, and was markedly diminished by ChrCrx as shown by fluorography using the redox indicator dye. Thus t-BuOOH-induced cell injuries and DNA cleavages of the keratinocytes can be prevented at least in part through efficient diminishment of ROS generated in the cytoplasm, to which the preferred distribution of ChrCrx may be advantageous over to the nucleus or membrane owing to its molecular hydrophilicity relative to alpha-tocopherol.

Apoptose radio-induite: une nouvelle approche par microspectroscopie infrarouge

Purpose: to characterize radiation-induced apoptosis in human cells using Fourier transform infrared microspectroscopy (FT-IRM) as a new analytical tool. Material and methods: Normal human circulating lymphocytes were given a γ ray dose of 6 Gy, or treated with t-butyl hydroperoxide (t-BuOH). HaCaT keratinocytes were given a dose of 20 Gy. Cells were deposited on ZnS windows for infrared spectral acquisition 2 days and 2 h after irradiation and 2 h after t-BuOH treatment. Apoptosis was simultaneously assessed by flow cytometry analysis of cells displaying annexin-V-positive staining. Results. The flow cytometry study showed that about 90% of sham and irradiated cells were annexin-V negative 2 h after irradiation. Two days after irradiation, 68% of lymphocytes and 76% of HaCaT cells were apoptotic, as well as 43% of lymphocytes treated with t-BuOH. In infrared spectra of these apoptotic cells, qualitative and quantitative changes were observed. In the 960–1245 and 1690–1720 cm–1 ranges, mainly attributed to nucleic acids, changes corresponding to conformational changes in DNA were associated with a decrease in the amount of detectable DNA. Conformational changes were also observed in secondary protein structure, in particular an increase in the amount of β structures. These DNA and protein changes were associated with an increase in the detectable amount of lipids in apoptotic HaCaT cells only. Two hours after irradiation, depending on the dose and (or) the cell type, qualitative and quantitative changes were observed in the IR spectra in the amide I and amide II bands, mainly attributed to proteins. These changes were associated with a significant decrease in the 1700–1750 cm–1 range, mainly attributed to the –C=O ester groups of DNA and phospholipids, in the irradiated HaCaT cells only. Conclusion: Our results are in agreement with biochemical published data on radiation-induced apoptosis, and show that DNA is the first cellular target of radiation-induced apoptosis, which, however, also requires conformational changes and synthesis of cell proteins. They also demonstrate that FT-IRM may be useful for assessing the early radiation damage at the molecular level in human cells.Key words: apoptosis, Fourier transform infrared microspectroscopy, γ irradiation, human lymphocytes, HaCaT keratinocytes.

Induction of apoptosis through the activation of SAPK/JNK followed by the expression of death receptor Fas in X-irradiated cells

A post-irradiation treatment of the human leukemia cell line MOLT-4 with the antioxidant Trolox attenuated caspase-3 dependent apoptosis. The increase in the p53 expression and SAPK/JNK activation after X irradiation was also inhibited by a Trolox treatment, but the expression of BCL-2 and BAX, which would occur downstream from p53, was not changed. Studies on the effects of the intracellular calcium chelator BAPTA-AM on the induction of apoptosis and the activation of SAPK/JNK and caspase-3 proved that the chelation of calcium merely delayed the onset of radiation-induced apoptosis and the activation of SAPK/JNK and caspase-3. When the effects of the protein synthesis inhibitor cycloheximde on the apoptotic signaling pathways, including the activation of caspase family proteins and SAPK/JNK, were investigated, the expression of death receptor Fas through SAPK/JNK activation was found to be required for radiation-induced apoptosis. Finally, the relationship between the amounts of DNA dsb and induction of apoptosis was examined by irradiating BrdU-incorporated cells. An increase in DNA dsb caused by BrdU was found, but the induction of apoptosis was not enhanced. From these data, we could get no positive evidence for DNA as a target of X-rays and p53 as an indispensable factor to induced apoptosis in X-irradiated MOLT-4 cells.

Infrared microspectroscopic characteristics of radiation-induced apoptosis in human lymphocytes

Infrared microspectroscopic characterization of radiation-induced apoptosis was used as a new analytical tool to study the kinetics of apoptosis in human peripheral blood lymphocytes at the molecular level. This vibrational technique, which has already been used to investigate biomolecules in normal and tumor cells, allows the simultaneous detection of the biochemical changes in the various subcellular compartments. Normal circulating lymphocytes from five healthy human donors were given a single dose of 6 Gy ((60)Co) and deposited on ZnS windows for infrared spectral acquisition 1, 2 and 4 days after irradiation. Apoptosis was assessed simultaneously by flow cytometry analysis of lymphocytes displaying annexin V-positive staining, and by detection of the DNA laddering that is characteristic of apoptosis. The flow cytometry study showed that about 80% of sham-irradiated lymphocytes were annexin V(neg)/PI(neg) at 1, 2 and 4 days. One day after irradiation, 46% of irradiated lymphocytes were annexin V(neg)/PI(neg), 48% were annexin V(pos)/PI(neg), 5% were annexin V(pos)/PI(pos), and 1% were annexin V(neg)/PI(pos). These mean percentages were respectively 31, 59, 9 and 1 at day 2 and 23, 36, 30, and 11 at day 4. Irradiated lymphocytes presented a DNA laddering pattern characteristic of apoptosis from day 1 after irradiation. In the infrared spectra of irradiated lymphocytes, qualitative and quantitative changes were observed from days 1 and 2, respectively. In the range of 960-1245 cm(-1) mainly attributed to nucleic acids, changes corresponding to conformational changes in DNA were associated with a decrease in the amount of detectable DNA. Conformational changes were also observed in secondary protein structures, in particular an increase in the amount of beta structures. These DNA and protein changes were associated with an increase in the detectable amount of lipids at day 4 after irradiation. These results showed that DNA is probably the first cellular target of radiation-induced apoptosis, which, however, also requires conformational changes and synthesis of cell proteins. Our results are in agreement with biochemical and morphological data on radiation-induced apoptosis of normal human circulating lymphocytes, and they demonstrate that infrared microspectroscopy may be useful for assessing the process of apoptosis at the molecular level.

Anti-apoptotic defense of bcl-2 gene against hydroperoxide-induced cytotoxicity together with suppressed lipid peroxidation, enhanced ascorbate uptake, and upregulated Bcl-2 protein

Although it is well known that Bcl-2 can prevent apoptosis, the Bcl-2's anti-apoptotic mechanism is not fully understood. Here, we investigate the mechanism of oxidant-induced cell death and to investigate the role of Bcl-2 in the tert-butyl hydroperoxide (t-BuOOH)-induced oxidant injury in Rat-1 fibroblasts and their bcl-2 transfected counterparts, b5 cells. Treatment with t-BuOOH causes mitochondrial disfunction and induced morphological features consistent with apoptosis more markedly in Rat-1 cells than in b5 cells. The hydroperoxide t-BuOOH at concentrations less than 100 nM for as long as 48 h or with higher concentrations (up to 100 microM) for only 3 h induces death in Rat-1 cells, whereas their bcl-2 transfectants were significantly resistant to cytotoxicity by both time and all concentration other than 100 microM. The similar results were obtained also for DNA strand cleavages as detected by TUNEL stain. The bcl-2 transfectants significantly suppressed t-BuOOH-induced increases in both lipid peroxidation and caspase-3 activation 3 and 1 h after t-BuOOH exposure, respectively, but failed to suppress either caspase-1 activation or an enhanced production of the intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS). Intracellular uptake of [1-(14)C] ascorbic acid (Asc) into the bcl-2 transfectants was superior to that into the non-transfectants always under examined conditions regardless of serum addition to culture medium and cell density. Upregulation of Bcl-2 proteins was rapidly induced after t-BuOOH exposure in the transfectants, but not in non-transfectants, and restored till 24 h to the normal Bcl-2 level. Thus suppressions of both lipid peroxidation and the subsequent cell death events such as caspase-3 activation and DNA cleavage were concerned with the inhibitory effects of Bcl-2 on the t-BuOOH-induced cytotoxicity. And some of these events may correlate with Bcl-2 expression-induced partial enhanced anti-oxidant cellular ability including enrichment of intracellular Asc and oxidative stress-induced upregulation of Bcl-2 protein. On the other hand, ROS production and caspase-1 activation were not related to cytoprotection by Bcl-2.

IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha production in gamma-irradiated blood units by mononuclear cells and GVHD prevention

Gamma-radiation of blood products is considered the mainstay of transfusion-associated graft-versus-host disease prevention. Previous studies have detected lymphocyte inhibition rate in blood components just one time after irradiation but there is evidence of cellular variability with production of cytokines at different storage time which could be related with irradiation activity and cellular damage repair. IFN-gamma, a Th1 cytokine, and TNF-alpha, a pro-inflammatory one, had a central role in the stimulation of cellular and inflammatory reactions. In this study whole blood was collected from five volunteer healthy donors and each donor bag was divided into two satellite bags: one of them was exposed to 137Cs-irradiation with a 2500 cGy dose. Samples for cytokine production, detected by ELISA methods, and proliferative response, evaluated by incorporation of H3 thymidine, were taken at the following storage time: 0, 24, 48, 72 and 96 h. The time-response curve of irradiated mononuclear cells from blood bags (BBMC) in mitogenic activation showed a time-related inhibition of cell proliferation with an enhanced response only after 24 h of storage and about 84% inhibition at 96 h. A similar pattern is follow by IFN-gamma production after OKT3 stimulation. TNF-alpha levels both in lipopolysaccharide stimulated or unstimulated cells were always high. This data suggest that BBMC cells maintain the ability to produce cytokines after gamma-radiation. On the ground of this study seems to be necessary to evaluate hypothetical risk associated with the administration of cytokine via irradiated blood components.

DNA-bound lipids of normal and tumor cells: retrospective and outlooks for functional genomics

By very soft phenol method, the high-molecular-mass natural DNA complexes (10(8)-10(9) Da), which contain 1-3% specific lipids, were isolated from different eukaryotic and prokaryotic cells. Two pools of DNA-bound lipids were isolated: loosely bound (extracted with 35% ethanol) and tightly bound lipids (extracted after additional treatment DNAse I). The composition of these two lipid pools of different sources (rat thymus, liver, regenerating liver, loach sperm, pigeon erythrocytes, Zajdel ascites hepatoma, Ehrlich ascites carcinoma, sarcoma 37, Escherichia coli B, T2 phage) was studied. The DNA-bound lipid pools consist of neutral lipids (NL) and phospholipids (PL), moreover NL is always in a few fold more than PL. The composition of these lipid pools of eukaryotes distinguishes between themselves, mainly, by free cholesterol (minor fraction), cardiolipin (major fraction), and by phosphatidylcholine. Only the tightly bound lipid pool was present in T2 phage DNA. The dramatic redistribution effect between all fractions of NL pools (free and ester cholesterol, free fatty acids, diglycerides) was observed in DNA synthesis phase of cell cycle on the background of the unchanged composition of PL pools. Comparative analysis of DNA-bound lipid pools of normal and cancer cells was carried out. The DNA-bound lipid pools of transformed cells significantly differ from the same normal cells both by PL composition (cardiolipin) and by the presence of additional fractions (mono- and triglycerides) as well. The possible functions of DNA-bound lipid pools, especially of cardiolipin and cholesterol at the attachment of DNA loops to the nuclear matrix, DNA replicon organization, replication, and transcription are discussed.

Detection of apoptotic frequency in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO-K1) cells after gamma-irradiation using both neutral Comet assay andterminal desoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT) assay

OBJECTIVES

Two assay methods, namely the neutral Comet assay andterminal desoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT) assay, were carried out for comparison to investigate the capability of using the neutral Comet assay as an alternative for detection of apoptosis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Chinese hamster ovary-K1 (CHO-K1) cells were exposed to gamma-rays with different doses and then the frequencies of apoptotic cells were determined at given points of time using the neutral Comet assay andTdT assay.

RESULTS

Apoptotic frequency of CHO-K1 cells after gamma-irradiation is dependent on both time after irradiation and radiation dose using either the neutral Comet assay orTdT assay. There are differences between the data obtained using the neutral Comet assay andTdT assay (p<0.01, Student's t-test).

CONCLUSIONS

The neutral Comet assay appears to be an appropriate tool for detection of radiationinduced apoptosis at the early stage of the process. Compared to the other methods such as theTdT assay, the neutral Comet assay is a rapid, simple and economical method for detection of apoptosis.

Clearance of radiation-induced apoptotic lymphocytes: ex vivo studies and an in vitro co-culture model

Lymphocytes are very sensitive to radiation. Our aim was to test the possibility of detecting apoptosis in lymphocytes as a potential short-term biomarker of ionizing radiation exposure. Our in vitro data confirmed the dose-time-effect relationships involved in radiation-induced apoptosis. The detection of in vivo induction of apoptosis in circulating lymphocytes after exposure of animals to radiation appears to depend critically on the technique used to measure apoptosis. Among the different techniques we investigated, mitochondrial modification was the most appropriate; they allowed establishment of dose-time-effect relationships when animals were observed for 72 h. A model of in vitro phagocytosis of apoptotic lymphocytes by macrophages was developed to mimic clearance of apoptotic cells occurring in vivo. Together, our data show that mitochondrial labeling may make it possible to detect ex vivo radiation-induced apoptosis of lymphocytes before macrophage ingestion occurs. We propose the measurement of apoptosis in lymphocytes as a potential short-term biomarker of ionizing radiation exposure.

Different programs of activation-induced cell death are triggered in mature activated CTL by immunogenic and partially agonistic peptide ligands

Activation-induced cell death (AICD) of mature T cells plays an important role in the control of immune homeostasis and peripheral tolerance. TNFRs and Fas have been implicated in the induction of AICD. However, these molecules were shown to be dispensable, at least in some experimental systems, for downsizing of Ag-induced T cell expansions and development of tolerance in vivo. The conditions of T cell activation leading to T cell deletion in a death receptor-independent manner are not well characterized. Here we show that human CTLs die through a death receptor-independent apoptotic program upon triggering with a partially agonistic peptide ligand. This apoptotic process exhibits some features of T cell death due to lymphokine deprivation and is blocked by exogenous IL-2. Our data demonstrate that engagement of TCR by MHC-peptide complexes can trigger diverse apoptotic programs of AICD and that the choice between these programs is determined by the agonistic potency of MHC-peptide ligand.

Dose-rate effects for apoptosis and micronucleus formation in gamma-irradiated human lymphocytes

We have compared dose-rate effects for gamma-radiation-induced apoptosis and micronucleus formation in human lymphocytes. Long-term assessment of individual radiation-induced apoptosis showed little intraindividual variation but significant interindividual variation. The effectiveness of radiation exposure to cause apoptosis or micronucleus formation was reduced by low-dose-rate exposures, but the reduction was apparent at different dose rates for these two end points. Micronucleus formation showed a dose-rate effect when the dose rate was lowered to 0.29 cGy/min, but there was no accompanying cell cycle delay. A further increase in the dose-rate effect was seen at 0.15 cGy/min, but was now accompanied by cell cycle delay. There was no dose-rate effect for the induction of apoptosis until the dose rate was reduced to 0.15 cGy/min, indicating that the mechanisms or signals for processing radiation-induced lesions for these two end points must be different at least in part. There appear to be two mechanisms that contribute to the dose-rate effect for micronucleus formation. One of these does not affect binucleate cell frequency and occurs at dose rates higher than that required to produce a dose-rate effect for apoptosis, and one affects binucleate cell frequency, induced only at the very low dose rate which coincidentally produces a dose-rate effect for apoptosis. Since the dose rate at which cells showed reduced apoptosis as well as a further reduction in micronucleus formation was very low, we conclude that the processing of the radiation-induced lesions that induce apoptosis, and some micronuclei, is very slow in quiescent and PHA-stimulated lymphocytes, respectively.