Instrumental assessment and treatment of hypernasality, following maxillofacial surgery, using SNORS: a single case study

Instrumental assessment of velopharyngeal function and resonance: a review

The purpose of this literature review is to describe and discuss instrumental assessment techniques of the velopharyngeal function in order to diagnose velopharyngeal disorders and resonance characteristics. Both direct and indirect assessment techniques are addressed, in which successively nasopharyngoscopy, videofluoroscopy, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), cephalometric radiographic analysis, computed tomography (CT), ultrasound, acoustic and aerodynamic measurements are considered. Despite the multiple instrumental assessments available to detect and define velopharyngeal dysfunction, the ideal technique is not yet accessible. Therefore, a combination of different quantitative parameters can possibly form a solution for a more reliable determination of resonance disorders. These multi-dimensional approaches will be described and discussed. The combination of quantitative measurement techniques and perceptual evaluation of nasality will probably remain necessary to provide sufficient information to make appropriate decisions concerning the diagnosis and treatment of resonance disorders.

LEARNING OUTCOMES

The reader will be able to describe and discuss currently available instrumental techniques to assess the velopharyngeal mechanism and its functioning in order to diagnose velopharyngeal disorders. Additionally, he will be able to explain the possible advantages of the combination of several types of complementary measurement techniques.

Veränderung der Nasalanz nach Le Fort-I Osteotomie

BACKGROUND

Nasalance represents a measure of the relative amount of oral and nasal acoustic energy produced by a speaker. Literature shows changes in nasalance after surgery of the oropharynx. The aim of this prospective study was to evaluate the outcome of speech and nasalance scores after Le-Fort-I-Osteotomy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A total of 20 individuals with normal speech development were examined preoperatively and 6 weeks postoperatively with the Nasometer 6200 (Kay-Elemetrics, USA) after bimaxillary surgery. The tone materials used comprised the standardized text passage: "Ein Kindergeburtstag", the vowels: /a/, /e/, /i/, /o/, /u/ and a syllable repetition subtest.

RESULTS

All patients showed changes in nasalance scores 6 weeks postoperatively. There were no significant changes reading the standard text. The syllable repetition test showed significant changes for repetition of "ma ma ma" and "na na na" (p=0,003, respectively p=0,033). Intonation of the vowel /a/1 also revealed significant changes regarding the pre- and postoperative values (p=0,006). However, the obtained values had no significant impact on the nasality characteristics of speech.

CONCLUSION

This study confirms that maxillary osteotomies can result in significant changes of nasalance scores. However these changes do not have any impact on normal speech and voice.

An instrument for the multiparameter assessment of speech

This paper describes the development of SNORS+, a clinical, user-friendly instrument for measurement of the articulators during speech. The design criteria for the instrument were based upon a wide-ranging review of current practice and available techniques. SNORS+ allows objective assessment of the function and co-ordination of key articulators. Appropriate targeting of therapy is therefore possible. Visual feedback is provided, for therapy, and an objective measurement of outcome is easily obtained. Preliminary results are presented. These suggest that the instrument will prove extremely useful in the assessment and management of many speech disorders.

Speech outcome in children with cleft palate: aerophonoscope assessment of nasal emission

The quality of speech is an important outcome measure of the success of primary surgery for clefts of the palate. A competent velopharyngeal mechanism is essential for normal speech, and disorders of resonance and nasal airflow are significant manifestations of velopharyngeal dysfunction in cleft palate subjects. The aim of this study was to determine the level of nasal emission during speech in patients with functionally repaired clefts of the palate and compare this with age and sex-matched controls. Forty-four children between the ages of 3 and 9 years were assessed for nasal emission using an Aerophonoscope. All these patients had primary functional surgery carried out at this unit by the same surgeon, and fell into three groups; complete bilateral, complete unilateral and soft palate clefts. Nasal breathing, blowing and groups of vowels and voiceless pressure consonants were assessed. There was no nasal emission in close to, or over, 90% of the patients for these parameters. The results indicate that a highly significant percentage of children with functionally repaired clefts of the palate have normal velopharyngeal function and speech, without inappropriate nasal emission. The Aerophonoscope provides an accurate, reliable and user-friendly diagnostic aid, and indeed therapeutic adjunct, to speech management in cleft palate patients.