What to stretch? - Isolated proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation stretching of either quadriceps or triceps surae followed by post-stretching activities alters tissue stiffness and jump performance

Vertical Jumping Performance: Recording the Effects of Proprioceptive Neuromuscular Facilitation Stretching at Different Plantar Flexor Lengths

INTRODUCTION

Flexibility seems to be an essential part of both the training and rehabilitation processes. Several stretching techniques have been used to improve the range of motion (ROM) of the joints with the proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation (PNF) method being the most effective one. Although plantar flexors are ideal to compare the acute effects of synergistic muscle groups on performance, it is not clear whether the PNF stretch at different muscle lengths could result in different alterations.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Sixteen male students randomly performed 2 levels of stretching (PNF with bended knees, or PNFshort, and with extended knee, or PNFlong) and 3 types of jumps, separated by 48 hours (7 sessions in total). Jumping parameters were recorded by a force plate, and the final jumping height (H) and ground reaction forces (Fz) were analyzed. Furthermore, the ROM of the ankle joint was recorded before, right after, and 15 minutes after the stretches.  Results: The ankle joint's ROM joint was increased after both interventions. No significant changes were found in the jumping height of all jumps. The Fz, during the squat jump (SJ) and countermovement jump (CMJ), were increased after PNFshort. Similarly, a significant increase was found in Fz in drop jumps (DJ) right after the PNFshort.

CONCLUSION

Our findings demonstrated that PNF stretches of different lengths could potentially alter the stretch-shortening cycle's performance, possibly leading to a non-optimal muscle-tendon interaction.

The Relationship Between Lower Limb Passive Muscle and Tendon Compression Stiffness and Oxygen Cost During Running

Studies have reported that a stiff triceps surae muscle and tendon-aponeurosis and also a more compliant quadriceps muscle and tendon-aponeurosis, are related to lower oxygen cost during running. However, to date, no study has investigated in a single experiment how oxygen cost during running is related to the stiffness of the free tendons (Achilles tendon, patellar tendon) and all the superficial muscles of two major muscle groups for running (i.e., quadriceps, triceps surae). Thus, 17 male trained runners/triathletes participated in this study and visited the laboratory on three occasions. On the first day, the participants were familiarized with the tests. On the second day, the passive compression stiffness of the triceps surae muscle (i.e., gastrocnemii), Achilles tendon, quadriceps muscle (i.e., vastii, rectus femoris), and patellar tendon was non-invasively measured using a digital palpation device (MyotonPRO). In addition, an incremental test was applied to test the VO2max of the participants. Thereafter, in the third visit, after at least 48-h of rest, participants performed a 15-min run on the treadmill with a speed reflecting a velocity of 70% VO2max, to assess oxygen costs during running. The Spearman correlation showed a significant negative correlation between passive Achilles tendon compression stiffness and running oxygen consumption, with a large effect size (rρ = -0.52; CI (95%) -0.81 to -0.33; P = 0.03). Moreover, no further significant relationship between oxygen cost during running and the passive compression stiffness of the quadriceps muscle and patellar tendon, as well as the triceps surae muscle, was detected. The significant correlation indicates that a stiffer passive Achilles tendon can lead to a lower oxygen cost during running. Future studies will have to test the causality of this relationship with training methods such as strength training that are able to increase the Achilles tendon stiffness.

Quadriceps or triceps surae proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation stretching with post-stretching dynamic activities does not induce acute changes in running economy

Previous studies reported that both a more compliant quadriceps tendon and a stiffer Achilles tendon are associated with better running economy. While tendon stiffness can be decreased by a single bout of proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation (PNF), post-stretching dynamic activities (PSA) can counteract the potential stretch-induced force loss. Thus, the purpose of this study was to investigate if a single, moderate duration, (4 × 15 s), bout of PNF stretching of either the quadriceps or triceps surae muscles followed each by PSA, causes either an improvement or impairment in running economy. Eighteen trained male runners/triathletes visited the laboratory five times. The first two visits were to familiarize the participants and to test for maximal oxygen consumption (VO₂max) respectively. The further three appointments were randomly assigned to either 1.) quadriceps PNF stretching + PSA or 2.) triceps surae PNF stretching + PSA or 3.) no stretching + PSA. Following the interventions, participants performed a 15-min run on the treadmill with a speed reflecting a velocity of 70% VO₂max to assess oxygen consumption (i.e., running economy) and running biomechanics. Our results showed neither a difference in oxygen consumption (p = 0.15) nor a change in any variable of the running biomechanics (p > 0.33) during the steady-state (i.e., last 5 min) of the 15-min run. Athletes can perform moderate duration PNF stretching of the quadriceps or triceps surae + PSA prior to a running event, without affecting running economy. Future studies should emphasize long-term training effects on tendon stiffness adaptations and running economy.