Arrangement of myosin heads on Limulus thick filaments

The myosin interacting-heads motif is present in the relaxed thick filament of the striated muscle of scorpion

Electron microscopy (EM) studies of 2D crystals of smooth muscle myosin molecules have shown that in the inactive state the two heads of a myosin molecule interact asymmetrically forming a myosin interacting-heads motif. This suggested that inactivation of the two heads occurs by blocking of the actin-binding site of one (free head) and the ATP hydrolysis site of the other (blocked head). This motif has been found by EM of isolated negatively stained myosin molecules of unregulated (vertebrate skeletal and cardiac muscle) and regulated (invertebrate striated and vertebrate smooth muscle) myosins, and nonmuscle myosin. The same motif has also been found in 3D-reconstructions of frozen-hydrated (tarantula, Limulus, scallop) and negatively stained (scallop, vertebrate cardiac) isolated thick filaments. We are carrying out studies of isolated thick filaments from other species to assess how general this myosin interacting-heads motif is. Here, using EM, we have visualized isolated, negatively stained thick filaments from scorpion striated muscle. We modified the iterative helical real space reconstruction (IHRSR) method to include filament tilt, and band-pass filtered the aligned segments before averaging, achieving a 3.3 nm resolution 3D-reconstruction. This reconstruction revealed the presence of the myosin interacting-heads motif (adding to evidence that is widely spread), together with 12 subfilaments in the filament backbone. This demonstrates that conventional negative staining and imaging can be used to detect the presence of the myosin interacting-heads motif in helically ordered thick filaments from different species and muscle types, thus avoiding the use of less accessible cryo-EM and low electron-dose procedures.

Head-head interaction characterizes the relaxed state of Limulus muscle myosin filaments

Regulation of muscle contraction via the myosin filaments occurs in vertebrate smooth and many invertebrate striated muscles. Studies of unphosphorylated vertebrate smooth muscle myosin suggest that activity is switched off through an intramolecular interaction between the actin-binding region of one head and the converter and essential light chains of the other, inhibiting ATPase activity and actin interaction. The same interaction (and additional interaction with the tail) is seen in three-dimensional reconstructions of relaxed, native myosin filaments from tarantula striated muscle, suggesting that such interactions are likely to underlie the off-state of myosin across a wide spectrum of the animal kingdom. We have tested this hypothesis by carrying out cryo-electron microscopy and three-dimensional image reconstruction of myosin filaments from horseshoe crab (Limulus) muscle. The same head-head and head-tail interactions seen in tarantula are also seen in Limulus, supporting the hypothesis. Other data suggest that this motif may underlie the relaxed state of myosin II in all species (including myosin II in nonmuscle cells), with the possible exception of insect flight muscle. The molecular organization of the myosin tails in the backbone of muscle thick filaments is unknown and may differ between species. X-ray diffraction data support a general model for crustaceans in which tails associate together to form 4-nm-diameter subfilaments, with these subfilaments assembling together to form the backbone. This model is supported by direct observation of 4-nm-diameter elongated strands in the tarantula reconstruction, suggesting that it might be a general structure across the arthropods. We observe a similar backbone organization in the Limulus reconstruction, supporting the general existence of such subfilaments.

Invertebrate muscles: thin and thick filament structure; molecular basis of contraction and its regulation, catch and asynchronous muscle

This is the second in a series of canonical reviews on invertebrate muscle. We cover here thin and thick filament structure, the molecular basis of force generation and its regulation, and two special properties of some invertebrate muscle, catch and asynchronous muscle. Invertebrate thin filaments resemble vertebrate thin filaments, although helix structure and tropomyosin arrangement show small differences. Invertebrate thick filaments, alternatively, are very different from vertebrate striated thick filaments and show great variation within invertebrates. Part of this diversity stems from variation in paramyosin content, which is greatly increased in very large diameter invertebrate thick filaments. Other of it arises from relatively small changes in filament backbone structure, which results in filaments with grossly similar myosin head placements (rotating crowns of heads every 14.5 nm) but large changes in detail (distances between heads in azimuthal registration varying from three to thousands of crowns). The lever arm basis of force generation is common to both vertebrates and invertebrates, and in some invertebrates this process is understood on the near atomic level. Invertebrate actomyosin is both thin (tropomyosin:troponin) and thick (primarily via direct Ca(++) binding to myosin) filament regulated, and most invertebrate muscles are dually regulated. These mechanisms are well understood on the molecular level, but the behavioral utility of dual regulation is less so. The phosphorylation state of the thick filament associated giant protein, twitchin, has been recently shown to be the molecular basis of catch. The molecular basis of the stretch activation underlying asynchronous muscle activity, however, remains unresolved.

Calcium regulates scallop muscle by changing myosin flexibility

Muscle myosins are molecular motors that convert the chemical free energy available from ATP hydrolysis into mechanical displacement of actin filaments, bringing about muscle contraction. Myosin cross-bridges exert force on actin filaments during a cycle of attached and detached states that are coupled to each round of ATP hydrolysis. Contraction and ATPase activity of the striated adductor muscle of scallop is controlled by calcium ion binding to myosin. This mechanism of the so-called "thick filament regulation" is quite different to vertebrate striated muscle which is switched on and off via "thin filament regulation" whereby calcium ions bind to regulatory proteins associated with the actin filaments. We have used an optically based single molecule technique to measure the angular disposition adopted by the two myosin heads whilst bound to actin in the presence and absence of calcium ions. This has allowed us to directly observe the movement of individual myosin heads in aqueous solution at room temperature in real time. We address the issue of how scallop striated muscle myosin might be regulated by calcium and have interpreted our results in terms of the structures of smooth muscle myosin that also exhibit thick filament regulation.

3D Structure of fish muscle myosin filaments

Myosin filaments isolated from goldfish (Carassius auratus) muscle under relaxing conditions and viewed in negative stain by electron microscopy have been subjected to 3D helical reconstruction to provide details of the myosin head arrangement in relaxed muscle. Previous X-ray diffraction studies of fish muscle (plaice) myosin filaments have suggested that the heads project a long way from the filament surface rather than lying down flat and that heads in a single myosin molecule tend to interact with each other rather than with heads from adjacent molecules. Evidence has also been presented that the head tilt is away from the M-band. Here we seek to confirm these conclusions using a totally independent method. By using 3D helical reconstruction of isolated myosin filaments the known perturbation of the head array in vertebrate muscles was inevitably averaged out. The 3D reconstruction was therefore compared with the X-ray model after it too had been helically averaged. The resulting images showed the same characteristic features: heads projecting out from the filament backbone to high radius and the motor domains at higher radius and further away from the M-band than the light-chain-binding neck domains (lever arms) of the heads.

A new model for the surface arrangement of myosin molecules in tarantula thick filaments

Three-dimensional reconstructions of the negatively stained thick filaments of tarantula muscle with a resolution of 50 A have previously suggested that the helical tracks of myosin heads are zigzagged, short diagonal ridges being connected by nearly axial links. However, surface views of lower contour levels reveal an additional J-shaped feature approximately the size and shape of a myosin head. We have modelled the surface array of myosin heads on the filaments using as a building block a model of a two-headed regulated myosin molecule in which the regulatory light chains of the two heads together form a compact head-tail junction. Four parameters defining the radius, orientation and rotation of each myosin molecule were varied. In addition, the heads were allowed independently to bend in a plane perpendicular to the coiled-coil tail at three sites, and to tilt with respect to the tail and to twist at one of these sites. After low-pass filtering, models were aligned with the reconstruction, scored by cross-correlation and refined by simulated annealing. Comparison of the geometry of the reconstruction and the distance between domains in the myosin molecule narrowed the choice of models to two main classes. A good match to the reconstruction was obtained with a model in which each ridge is formed from the motor domain of a head pointing to the bare zone together with the head-tail junction of a neighbouring molecule. The heads pointing to the Z-disc intermittently occupy the J-position. Each motor domain interacts with the essential and regulatory light chains of the neighbouring heads. A near-radial spoke in the reconstruction connecting the backbone to one end of the ridge can be identified as the start of the coiled-coil tail.

The M.ADP.Pi state is required for helical order in the thick filaments of skeletal muscle

The thick filaments of mammalian and avian skeletal muscle fibers are disordered at low temperature, but become increasingly ordered into an helical structure as the temperature is raised. Wray and colleagues (Schlichting, I., and J. Wray. 1986. J. Muscle Res. Cell Motil. 7:79; Wray, J., R. S. Goody, and K. Holmes. 1986. Adv. Exp. Med. Biol. 226:49-59) interpreted the transition as reflecting a coupling between nucleotide state and global conformation with M.ATP (disordered) being favored at 0 degrees C and M.ADP.P(i) (ordered) at 20 degrees C. However, hitherto this has been limited to a qualitative correlation and the biochemical state of the myosin heads required to obtain the helical array has not been unequivocally identified. In the present study we have critically tested whether the helical arrangement of the myosin heads requires the M.ADP.P(i) state. X-ray diffraction patterns were recorded from skinned rabbit psoas muscle fiber bundles stretched to non-overlap to avoid complications due to interaction with actin. The effect of temperature on the intensities of the myosin-based layer lines and on the phosphate burst of myosin hydrolyzing ATP in solution were examined under closely matched conditions. The results showed that the fraction of myosin mass in the helix closely followed that of the fraction of myosin in the M.ADP.P(i) state. Similar results were found by using a series of nucleoside triphosphates, including CTP and GTP. In addition, fibers treated by N-phenylmaleimide (Barnett, V. A., A. Ehrlich, and M. Schoenberg. 1992. Biophys. J. 61:358-367) so that the myosin was exclusively in the M.ATP state revealed no helical order. Diffraction patterns from muscle fibers in nucleotide-free and in ADP-containing solutions did not show helical structure. All these confirmed that in the presence of nucleotides, the M.NDP.P(i) state is required for helical order. We also found that the spacing of the third meridional reflection of the thick filament is linked to the helical order. The spacing in the ordered M.NDP.P(i) state is 143.4 A, but in the disordered state, it is 144. 2 A. This may be explained by the different interference functions for the myosin heads and the thick filament backbone.

Towards an atomic model of the thick filaments of muscle

The thick filaments of muscle and non-muscle cells are polymers of myosin molecules whose energy-transducing heads lie on the filament surface, where they interact with actin to generate force. A key structural question is how the myosin heads are arranged in the relaxed state, and how this arrangement changes on activation of contraction. We have fitted the atomic structure of the myosin head to the three-dimensional structure of myosin filaments of tarantula muscle determined by electron microscopy to produce a near-atomic model of the head arrangement. A good fit is obtained only when the two heads from a myosin molecule run along the helical tracks antiparallel to each other. Oppositely oriented heads from axially adjacent molecules in a helix interact with each other, with their nucleotide-binding pockets opposed. This arrangement, supported also by crosslinking evidence, suggests a simple mechanism for the stabilization of myosin head helices in relaxed muscle via the formation of intermolecular "dimers" of heads from axially adjacent myosin molecules.

Differences in myosin head arrangement on relaxed thick filaments from Lethocerus and rabbit muscles

Relaxed thick filaments from insect asynchronous flight muscle appear different from those of other striated muscles, both in sections and as separated, negatively-stained structures. Unlike relaxed filaments of scallops, chelicerate arthropods, or vertebrate striated muscle, all of which display a predominantly helical arrangement of surface myosin heads, insect asynchronous flight muscle filaments appear striped, with cross-striations or shelves at spacings of 14.5 nm. Using a bifunctional agent to cross-link the active sites of nearest-neighbour myosin heads we previously demonstrated that the helical arrays on the surfaces of scallop, arthropod, fish and frog filaments are produced by the association of two oppositely-oriented myosin heads, each of which originates from an axially sequential molecule within the same helical strand. The effect of similarly cross-linking nearest-neighbour heads with the bifunctional agent 3,3'-dithiobis[3'(2')-O-(6-propionylamino)hexanoyl]adenosine 5'-triphosphate in the presence of vanadate on the solubility of thick filaments separated from Lethocerus indirect flight muscle (an insect asynchronous flight muscle) and rabbit psoas muscle was examined. After incubation on high salt, treated rabbit filaments retained their length and surface myosin, while untreated filaments and those with severed cross-links dissolved, indicating that the myosin head arrangement on rabbit filaments is similar to those previously studied. Treated indirect flight muscles filaments, however, separated into distinct segments of variable lengths, usually multiples of 150 nm, while untreated filaments and those with severed cross-links dissolved completely. This implies that intermolecular associations on indirect flight muscles filaments most likely occur between circumferentially-adjacent heads within each crown, but originating from different helical strands. We interpret this difference in the relaxed orientations of splayed myosin heads on the two types of filament as reflecting a difference in functional requirements at the onset of, or during, contractile activity.

Insect crossbridges, relaxed by spin-labeled nucleotide, show well-ordered 90 degrees state by X-ray diffraction and electron microscopy, but spectra of electron paramagnetic resonance probes report disorder

The structure of glycerinated Lethocerus insect flight muscle fibers, relaxed by spin-labeled ATP and vanadate (Vi), was examined using X-ray diffraction, electron microscopy and electron paramagnetic resonance (e.p.r.) spectra. We obtained excellent relaxation of MgATP quality as determined by mechanical criteria, using vanadate trapping of 2' spin-labeled 3' deoxyATP at 3 degree C. In rigor fibers, when the diphosphate analog is bound in the absence of Vi, the probes on myosin heads are well-ordered, in agreement with electron microscopic and X-ray patterns showing that myosin heads are ordered when attached strongly to actin. In relaxed muscle, however, e.p.r. spectra report orientational disorder of bound (Vi-trapped) spin-labeled nucleotide, while electron microscopic and X-ray patterns both show well-ordered bridges at a uniform 90 degrees angle to the filament axis. The spin-labeled nucleotide orientation is highly disordered, but not completely isotropic; the slight anisotropy observed in probe spectra is consistent with a shift of approximately 10% of probes from angles close to 0 degrees to angles close to 90 degrees. Measurements of probe mobility suggest that the interaction between probe and protein remains as tight in relaxed fibers as in rigor, and thus that the disorder in relaxed fibers arises from disorders of (or within) the protein and not from disorder of the probe relative to the protein. Fixation of the relaxed fibers with glutaraldehyde did not alter any aspect of the spectrum of the Vi-trapped analog, including the slight order observed, showing that the extensive inter- and intra-molecular cross-linking of the first step of sample preparation for electron microscopy had not altered relaxed crossbridge orientations. Two models that may reconcile the apparently disparate results obtained on relaxed fibers are presented: (1) a rigid myosin head could possess considerable disorder in the regular array about the thick filament; or (2) the nucleotide site could be on a disordered, probably distal, domain of myosin, while a more proximal region is well ordered on the thick filament backbone. Our findings suggest that when e.p.r. probes signal disorder of a local site or domain, this is complementary, not contradictory, to signals of general order. The e.p.r. spectra show that a portion of the myosin molecule can be disordered at the same time as the X-ray diffraction and electron microscopy show the bulk of myosin head mass to be uniformly oriented and regularly arrayed.

Location of paramyosin in relation to the subfilaments within the thick filaments of scallop striated muscle

Myosin co-assembles with paramyosin in the thick filaments of invertebrate muscles. The molar ratio of the two proteins varies greatly but where sufficient paramyosin is present it forms the filament core with myosin arranged on its surface. In the fastest acting striated muscles, paramyosin is present in small amounts, and neither its location nor the nature of its interactions with myosin has previously been established. Antibodies to paramyosin have now been used in an attempt to locate the protein in thick filaments that have been isolated from the striated adductor muscle of the scallop and then frayed apart into their constituent subfilaments. Using a gold-conjugated secondary antibody, the location of paramyosin in relation to the subfilaments has been determined by electron microscopy of negatively stained samples. The labelling indicates that paramyosin extends throughout the length of the scallop filaments and appears to be associated with each subfilament, raising the possibility that in these filaments paramyosin may not be confined to a central core domain.

Helical reconstruction of frozen-hydrated scallop myosin filaments

Native myosin filaments from scallop striated muscle that have been rapidly frozen in relaxing solutions appear to be well preserved in vitreous ice. Electron micrographs of samples at -177 degrees C were recorded with an electron dose of 10 e/A2 at 1.5 microns defocus. After filament images were straightened by spline-fitting, several transforms showed well-defined layer-lines arising from the helical structure of the filament. A set of 17 near-meridional layer-lines has been collected and corrected for background and for phase and amplitude contrast functions. Preliminary helical reconstructions from this still incomplete data set reveal aspects of structure that were not apparent from earlier analysis of negatively stained filaments from scallop muscle. Individual pear-shaped myosin heads now appear to be well resolved from each other and from the filament backbone. The two heads of each myosin molecule appear to be splayed apart axially. The reconstructions also reveal that the filament backbone has a polygonal shape in cross-section, and that it appears to contain seven peripherally located subfilaments.

X-ray diffraction study of the structural changes accompanying phosphorylation of tarantula muscle

Electron microscopy of negatively stained isolated thick filaments of tarantula muscle has revealed that phosphorylation of myosin regulatory light chains is accompanied by a loss of the helical order of myosin heads. From equatorial X-ray diffraction patterns of tarantula muscles in the phosphorylated state we have detected a mass movement in the myosin filaments that supports this finding.

The effect of calcium activation of skinned fiber bundles on the structure of Limulus thick filaments

Here we present evidence that strongly suggests that the well-documented phenomenon of A-band shortening in Limulus telson muscle is activation dependent and reflects fragmentation of thick filaments at their ends. Calcium activation of detergent-skinned fiber bundles of Limulus telson muscle results in large decreases in A-band (from 5.1 to 3.3 microns) and thick filament (from 4.1 to 3.3 microns) lengths and the release of filament end fragments. In activated fibers, maintained stretched beyond overlap of thick and thin filaments, these end fragments are translocated to varying depths within the I-bands. Here they are closely associated with fine filamentous structures that also span the gap between A- and I-bands and attach to the distal one-third of the thick filaments. End-fragments are rarely, if ever, present in similarly stretched and skinned, but unstimulated fibers, although fine "gap filaments" persist. Negatively stained thick filaments, separated from skinned, calcium-activated, fiber bundles, allowed to shorten freely, are significantly shorter than those obtained from unstimulated fibers, but are identical to the latter with respect to both the surface helical array of myosin heads and diameters. Many end-fragments are present on grids containing thick filaments from activated fibers; few, if any, on those from unstimulated fibers. SDS-PAGE shows no evidence of proteolysis due to activation and demonstrates the presence of polypeptides with very high molecular weights in the preparations. We suggest that thick filament shortening is a direct result of activation in Limulus telson muscle and that it occurs largely by breakage within a defined distal region of each polar half of the filament. It is possible that at least some of the fine "gap filaments" are composed of a titin-like protein. They may move the activation-produced, fragmented ends of thick filaments to which they attach, into the I-bands by elastic recoil, in highly stretched fibers.

Structural changes induced in Ca2+-regulated myosin filaments by Ca2+ and ATP

We have used electron microscopy and proteolytic susceptibility to study the structural basis of myosin-linked regulation in synthetic filaments of scallop striated muscle myosin. Using papain as a probe of the structure of the head-rod junction, we find that this region of myosin is approximately five times more susceptible to proteolytic attack under activating (ATP/high Ca2+) or rigor (no ATP) conditions than under relaxing conditions (ATP/low Ca2+). A similar result was obtained with native myosin filaments in a crude homogenate of scallop muscle. Proteolytic susceptibility under conditions in which ADP or adenosine 5'-(beta, gamma-imidotriphosphate) (AMPPNP) replaced ATP was similar to that in the absence of nucleotide. Synthetic myosin filaments negatively stained under relaxing conditions showed a compact structure, in which the myosin cross-bridges were close to the filament backbone and well ordered, with a clear 14.5-nm axial repeat. Under activating or rigor conditions, the cross-bridges became clumped and disordered and frequently projected further from the filament backbone, as has been found with native filaments; when ADP or AMPPNP replaced ATP, the cross-bridges were also disordered. We conclude (a) that Ca2+ and ATP affect the affinity of the myosin cross-bridges for the filament backbone or for each other; (b) that the changes observed in the myosin filaments reflect a property of the myosin molecules alone, and are unlikely to be an artifact of negative staining; and (c) that the ordered structure occurs only in the relaxed state, requiring both the presence of hydrolyzed ATP on the myosin heads and the absence of Ca2+.