Pharmacology of the skate electroretinogram indicates independent ON and OFF bipolar cell pathways

ON-OFF Interactions in the Retina: Role of Glycine and GABA

In the vertebrate retina, visual signals are segregated into parallel ON and OFF pathways, which provide information for light increments and decrements. The segregation is first evident at the level of the ON and OFF bipolar cells and it apparently remains as signals propagate to higher brain visual centers. A fundamental question in visual neuroscience is how these two parallel pathways function: are they independent from each other or do they interact somehow? In the latter case, what kinds of mechanisms are involved and what are the consequences from this cross-talk? This review summarizes current knowledge about the types of interactions between the ON and OFF channels in nonmammalian and mammalian retina. Data concerning the ON-OFF interactions in distal retina revealed by recording of single bipolar cell activity and electroretinographic ON (b-wave) and OFF (d-wave) responses are presented. Special emphasis is put on the ON-OFF interactions in proximal retina and their dependence on the state of light adaptation in mammalian retina. The involvement of the GABAergic and glycinergic systems in the ON-OFF crosstalk is also discussed.

Ionotropic GABA Receptors and Distal Retinal ON and OFF Responses

In the vertebrate retina, visual signals are segregated into parallel ON and OFF pathways, which provide information for light increments and decrements. The segregation is first evident at the level of the ON and OFF bipolar cells in distal retina. The activity of large populations of ON and OFF bipolar cells is reflected in the b- and d-waves of the diffuse electroretinogram (ERG). The role of gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), acting through ionotropic GABA receptors in shaping the ON and OFF responses in distal retina, is a matter of debate. This review summarized current knowledge about the types of the GABAergic neurons and ionotropic GABA receptors in the retina as well as the effects of GABA and specific GABAA and GABAC receptor antagonists on the activity of the ON and OFF bipolar cells in both nonmammalian and mammalian retina. Special emphasis is put on the effects on b- and d-waves of the ERG as a useful tool for assessment of the overall function of distal retinal ON and OFF channels. The role of GABAergic system in establishing the ON-OFF asymmetry concerning the time course and absolute and relative sensitivity of the ERG responses under different conditions of light adaptation in amphibian retina is also discussed.

Effects of picrotoxin on light adapted frog electroretinogram are not due entirely to its action in proximal retina

In order to evaluate the site of action of picrotoxin (antagonist of ionotropic GABA receptors) on the electroretinographic (ERG) b- and d-waves, in this study we compared its effects on the intensity-response function of the ERG waves in intact light adapted frog eyecup preparations with its effects in eyecups, where the activity of proximal neurons was blocked by 1 mMN-methyl-d-aspartate (MNDA). Picrotoxin markedly enhanced the b- and d-wave amplitude and slowed the time course of the responses at all stimulus intensities in the intact eyecups. Perfusion with NMDA alone caused significant enhancement of the b-wave amplitude and diminution of the d-wave amplitude without altering their time course in the entire intensity range. When picrotoxin was applied in combination with NMDA, an enhancement of the b-wave amplitude and slowing of its time course were observed at all stimulus intensities. The increase of the b-wave amplitude was significantly higher than that seen in NMDA group. Combined application of picrotoxin and NMDA caused an enhancement of the d-wave amplitude at the lower stimulus intensities and its diminution at the higher ones, while the d-wave time course was delayed over the entire intensity range. The results obtained indicate that a part of picrotoxin effects on the amplitude and time course of the photopic ERG b- and d-waves are due to its action in the distal frog retina.

Light-evoked responses of the retinal pigment epithelium: changes accompanying photoreceptor loss in the mouse

Mutations in genes expressed in the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) underlie a number of human inherited retinal disorders that manifest with photoreceptor degeneration. Because light-evoked responses of the RPE are generated secondary to rod photoreceptor activity, RPE response reductions observed in human patients or animal models may simply reflect decreased photoreceptor input. The purpose of this study was to define how the electrophysiological characteristics of the RPE change when the complement of rod photoreceptors is decreased. To measure RPE function, we used an electroretinogram (dc-ERG)-based technique. We studied a slowly progressive mouse model of photoreceptor degeneration (Prph(Rd2/+)), which was crossed onto a Nyx(nob) background to eliminate the b-wave and most other postreceptoral ERG components. On this background, Prph(Rd2/+) mice display characteristic reductions in a-wave amplitude, which parallel those in slow PIII amplitude and the loss of rod photoreceptors. At 2 and 4 mo of age, the amplitude of each dc-ERG component (c-wave, fast oscillation, light peak, and off response) was larger in Prph(Rd2/+) mice than predicted by rod photoreceptor activity (Rm(P3)) or anatomical analysis. At 4 mo of age, the RPE in Prph(Rd2/+) mice showed several structural abnormalities including vacuoles and swollen, hypertrophic cells. These data demonstrate that insights into RPE function can be gained despite a loss of photoreceptors and structural changes in RPE cells and, moreover, that RPE function can be evaluated in a broader range of mouse models of human retinal disease.

The evolution of early vertebrate photoreceptors

Meeting the challenge of sampling an ancient aquatic landscape by the early vertebrates was crucial to their survival and would establish a retinal bauplan to be used by all subsequent vertebrate descendents. Image-forming eyes were under tremendous selection pressure and the ability to identify suitable prey and detect potential predators was thought to be one of the major drivers of speciation in the Early Cambrian. Based on the fossil record, we know that hagfishes, lampreys, holocephalans, elasmobranchs and lungfishes occupy critical stages in vertebrate evolution, having remained relatively unchanged over hundreds of millions of years. Now using extant representatives of these 'living fossils', we are able to piece together the evolution of vertebrate photoreception. While photoreception in hagfishes appears to be based on light detection and controlling circadian rhythms, rather than image formation, the photoreceptors of lampreys fall into five distinct classes and represent a critical stage in the dichotomy of rods and cones. At least four types of retinal cones sample the visual environment in lampreys mediating photopic (and potentially colour) vision, a sampling strategy retained by lungfishes, some modern teleosts, reptiles and birds. Trichromacy is retained in cartilaginous fishes (at least in batoids and holocephalans), where it is predicted that true scotopic (dim light) vision evolved in the common ancestor of all living gnathostomes. The capacity to discriminate colour and balance the tradeoff between resolution and sensitivity in the early vertebrates was an important driver of eye evolution, where many of the ocular features evolved were retained as vertebrates progressed on to land.

Glutamatergic mechanisms in the outer retina of larval zebrafish: analysis of electroretinogram b- and d-waves using a novel preparation

A new preparation is described for recording the electroretinogram (ERG) from larval zebrafish (5-8 days postfertilization) which has allowed the investigation of the pharmacology of cone photoreceptor inputs onto bipolar cells. By using a pharmacological cocktail to isolate the photoreceptors and bipolar cells from inhibitory influences, it was found that an excitatory amino acid transporter (EAAT) presumably linked to a Cl() channel mediates most of the synaptic transmission from the cone photoreceptors to the ON bipolar cells, although metabotropic glutamate receptors (presumably mGluR6) also make a small contribution. On the other hand, alpha-amino-3-hydroxy- 5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionate (AMPA)/kainate receptors mediate synaptic transmission from cone photoreceptors to OFF bipolar cells. The glutamatergic input mechanisms underlying bipolar cell responses in the larval zebrafish are adultlike and similar to those in other teleost species.

OFF ganglion cells cannot drive the optokinetic reflex in zebrafish

Whereas the zebrafish retina has long been an important model system for developmental and genetic studies, little is known about the responses of the inner retinal neurons. Here we report single-unit ganglion cell recordings from 5- to 6-day-old zebrafish larvae. In wild-type larvae we identify at least five subtypes of ganglion cell responses to full-field illumination, with ON-OFF and ON-type cells predominating. In the nrc mutant retina, in which the photoreceptor terminals develop abnormally, we observe normal OFF responses but abnormal ON-OFF responses and no ON responses. Previously characterized as blind, these mutants lack an optokinetic reflex (OKR), but in another behavioral assay nrc mutant fish have near-normal responses to the offset of light and slow and sluggish responses to the onset of light. Pharmacological block of the ON pathway mimics most of the nrc visual defects. We conclude that the abnormal photoreceptor terminals in nrc mutants predominantly perturb the ON pathway and that the ON pathway is necessary to drive the OKR in larval zebrafish.

Retinal Bipolar Cell Input Mechanisms in Giant Danio. II. Patch-Clamp Analysis of on Bipolar Cells

Glutamate receptors on giant danio retinal on bipolar cells were studied with whole cell patch clamping using a slice preparation. Cone-driven on bipolars (Cbs) and mixed-input on bipolars (Mbs) were identified morphologically. Most Cbs responded to the excitatory amino acid transporter (EAAT) substrate d-aspartate but not to the group III metabotropic glutamate receptor (mGluR) agonist l-(+)-2-amino-4-phosphonobutyric acid (l-AP4) or the AMPA/kainate receptor agonist kainate, suggesting EAATs are the primary glutamate receptors on Cbs. The EAAT inhibitor dl- threo-β-benzyloxyasparate (TBOA) blocked all light-evoked responses of Cbs, suggesting these responses are mediated exclusively by EAATs. Conversely, all Mbs responded to d-aspartate and l-AP4 but not to kainate, indicating they have both EAATs and group III mGluRs (presumably mGluR6). The light responses of Mbs involve both receptors because they could be blocked by TBOA plus (RS)-α-cyclopropyl-4-phosphonophenylglycine (CPPG, a group III mGluR antagonist) but not by either alone. Under dark-adapted conditions, the responses of Mbs to green (rod-selective) stimuli were reduced by CPPG but enhanced by TBOA. In contrast, both antagonists reduced the responses to red (cone-selective) stimuli, although TBOA was more effective. Furthermore, under photopic conditions, TBOA failed to eliminate light-evoked responses of Mbs. Thus on Mbs, rod inputs are mediated predominantly by mGluR6, whereas cone inputs are mediated mainly by EAATs but also by mGluR6 to some extent. Finally, we explored the interactions between EAATs and mGluR6 in Mbs. Responses to d-aspartate were reduced by l-AP4 and vice versa. Therefore mGluR6 and EAATs suppress each other, and this might underlie mutual suppression between rod and cone signals in Mbs.

Retinal bipolar cell input mechanisms in giant danio. I. Electroretinographic analysis

Electroretinograms (ERGs) were recorded from the giant danio (Danio aequipinnatus) to study glutamatergic input mechanisms onto bipolar cells. Glutamate analogs were applied to determine which receptor types mediate synaptic transmission from rods and cones to on and off bipolar cells. Picrotoxin, strychnine, and tetrodotoxin were used to isolate the effects of the glutamate analogs to the photoreceptor-bipolar cell synapse. Under photopic conditions, the group III metabotropic glutamate receptor (mGluR) antagonist (RS)-alpha-cyclopropyl-4-phosphonophenylglycine (CPPG) only slightly reduced the b-wave, whereas the excitatory amino acid transporter (EAAT) blocker dl-threo-beta-benzyl-oxyaspartate (TBOA) removed most of it. Complete elimination of the b-wave required both antagonists. The alpha-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionate (AMPA)/kainate receptor antagonist 2,3-dioxo-6-nitro-1,2,3,4-tetrahydrobenzo[f]quinoxaline-7-sulfonamide (NBQX) blocked the d-wave. Under scotopic conditions, rod and cone inputs onto on bipolar cells were studied by comparing the sensitivities of the b-wave to photopically matched green and red stimuli. The b-wave was >1 log unit more sensitive to the green than to the red stimulus under control conditions. In CPPG or l-AP4 (l-(+)-2-amino-4-phosphonobutyric acid, a group III mGluR agonist), the sensitivity of the b-wave to the green stimulus was dramatically reduced and the b-waves elicited by the 2 stimuli became nearly matched. The d-wave elicited by dim green stimuli, which presumably could be detected only by the rods, was eliminated by NBQX.

IN CONCLUSION

1) cone signals onto on bipolar cells involve mainly EAATs but also mGluRs (presumably mGluR6) to a lesser extent; 2) rods signal onto on bipolars by mainly mGluR6; 3) off bipolar cells receive signals from both photoreceptor types by AMPA/kainate receptors.

Endogenous zinc as a retinal neuromodulator: evidence from the skate (Raja erinacea)

The effects of zinc on skate (Raja erinacea) bipolar cell responses to glutamatergic agonists were examined using whole-cell voltage-clamp recording. Isolated ON bipolar cell currents mediated by the metabotropic agonist trans-(+/-)-1-amino-1,3-cyclopentanedicarboxylic acid (30 microM), L-2-amino-4-phosphonobutyrate (3-10 microM) and glutamate (0.3-10 microM) were blocked when zinc (1 microM) was added to the test solution. Similarly, isolated OFF bipolar cell responses to the ionotropic agonist kainate (300 microM) were blocked by zinc (1 microM). The effects of zinc were further studied using electroretinogram (ERG) recording. Skate eyecup preparations were superfused with picrotoxin (200 microM) to block GABAergic input. When histidine (100 microM), a zinc chelator, was added to the superfusate, ERG ON responses increased. This suggests that endogenous zinc plays a neuromodulatory role in the retina and is consistent with zinc's suppressive effect on isolated bipolar cells.

Different effects of low Ca2+ on signal transmission from rods and cones to bipolar cells in carp retina

Modulation of signal transmission from rods, red-sensitive (R-) and green-sensitive (G-) cones to bipolar cells by lowering extracellular Ca(2+) was studied in the isolated superfused carp retina using intracellular recording techniques. Low Ca(2+) (nominally Ca(2+)-free) potentiated light responses of rod dominant ON bipolar cells (rod-ON-BCs). On the other hand, responses of cone dominant ON bipolar cells (cone-ON-BCs) driven by G-cones were dramatically decreased whereas those driven by R-cones were hardly changed in low Ca(2+). Similar effects were observed in scotopic and photopic electroretinographic (ERG) b waves, which reflect the activities of ON-BCs driven by rods and cones, respectively. IBMX (100 microM), an inhibitor of PDE, whose effects mimic those of low Ca(2+) on phototransduction, increased responses of both rod-ON-BCs and cone-ON-BCs, suggesting that the distinct effects of low Ca(2+) described above are attributable to differential modulation of signal transfer from different types of photoreceptors to BCs. Moreover, scotopic ERG P III responses, reflecting the rod activity, were potentiated both in low Ca(2+) and in the presence of IBMX (100 microM). Low Ca(2+) causes multiple changes in the outer retina, including increase of glutamate release from the photoreceptor terminal, increase of current and voltage responses of photoreceptors to light, alteration of the synaptic gain from photoreceptors to BCs and modulation of mGluR6 pathway in the rod-ON-BCs. Interplay of these changes may account for differential modulation of R-cone and G-cone driven BC responses, as well as the different effects on rod- and cone-ON-BCs.

GABA(C) receptors modulate the rod-driven ERG b-wave of the skate retina

Studies characterizing the types of GABA receptors present on cells isolated from the skate retina have allowed us to develop a working model of possible GABA interactions at the level of the outer plexiform layer (OPL). Earlier studies have shown an electrogenic GABA transport mechanism in horizontal cells presents a source of GABA in the OPL which could modulate feedback onto photoreceptors. GABA(A) receptors on Müller cells, or GABA(A) and/or GABA(C) receptors on bipolar cells. This model has been used for the interpretation of results of experiments in this study designed to test the role these interactions may exert on the electroretinogram (ERG). Simultaneous intracellular recording of the horizontal cell response (the S-potential) was used to monitor effects on photoreceptor transmitter release which would be altered if GABAergic photoreceptor feedback mechanisms were involved. Picorotoxin (50 microM), a chloride channel blocker which suppresses the responses of both GABA(A)Rs and GABA(C)Rs, reduced the ON (b-wave) component of the ERG substantially. Simultaneous intracellular horizontal cell recordings, however, showed no effect on their light-evoked response, suggesting that photoreceptor feedback is not involved in the picrotoxin effect on the ERG. On the other hand, even 100 microM bicuculline, a GABA(A)R antagonist produced no change in either the ERG or the horizontal cell response. This observation leads to the conclusion that the GABAARs on Miller cells and bipolar cells are not involved. Thus, there remains a distinct possibility that the ERG changes produced by picrotoxin are due to its ability to block the GABA(C)Rs on retinal bipolar cells.

Modification of the Xenopus electroretinogram by actions of glycine in the proximal retina

The electroretinogram (ERG) was recorded from the Xenopus retina, to examine the effects of glycine and strychnine on these responses and to determine the origins of these changes. Glycine at concentrations between 0.1 and 10 mM reduced the b- and d-waves of the ERG in a dose-dependent manner, while strychnine increased their amplitude. 2-Amino-4-phosphonobutyric acid (APB) reduced the b-wave and blocked the effect of glycine, but not strychnine, on the d-wave. When the d-wave had first been blocked by kynurenic acid (KYN) or reduced by (+/-)cis-2,3-piperidine dicarboxylic acid (PDA) the b-wave was enhanced by glycine, but not by strychnine. N-methyl-DL-aspartate (NMDLA), which alters responses in the proximal retina only, blocked the effects of glycine and strychnine on the ERG. This suggests that the glycinergic effects on the ERG are at least partly mediated by processes in the proximal retina. The results further support the suggestion that inhibitory neurotransmitters in the proximal retina may modulate both the b- and d-waves of the Xenopus ERG.

Current source density analysis of ON/OFF channels in the frog optic tectum

In the vertebrate retina, it is well known that an ON/OFF dichotomy is present. In other words, ON-center and OFF-center cells participate in segregated pathways morphologically and physiologically. However, there is no doubt that integration of both channels is necessary to generate the complicated response properties of visual neurons in higher optic centers. So far, functional organization of the ON and OFF channels in the optic centers has not been demonstrated at the level of neuronal populations. In this review article, we summarize our experimental approaches to demonstrate functional organization of the ON and OFF channels using current source density (CSD) analysis in the frog optic tectum. First, we show that one-dimensional CSD analysis, assuming constant conductivity, is applicable in the tectal laminated structure. The CSD depth profile of a response to electrical stimulation of the optic tract is composed of three current sinks (A, B, and D) in the retinorecipient layers and two current sinks (C and E) below those layers. This result is in agreement with previous morphological and physiological findings, and shows that CSD analysis is very useful to demonstrate the flow of visual information processing. Second, CSD analysis of tectal responses evoked by diffuse light ON and OFF stimuli reveals obviously different distributions of synaptic activity in the laminar structure. Two or three current sinks (I, II and III) are generated in response to ON stimulation only in the retinorecipient layers, while up to six current sinks (IV, V, VI, VII, VIII and IX) to OFF stimulation throughout the tectal layers. Based on well known properties of retinal ganglion cells of the frog, possible neuronal mechanisms underlying each current sinks and their functional roles in visually guided behavior are considered.

Two classes of bipolar cell in the retina of the skate Raja erinacea

We have used immunoreactions against serotonin and protein kinase C to visualize two distinct classes of bipolar cell in the all-rod retina of the skate, Raja erinacea. To enhance the immunoreaction in serotonin-accumulating bipolar cells, prior to fixation, some retinas were incubated in Ringer's solution containing serotonin and pargyline. We found the somata of serotonin-accumulating bipolar cells to be located slightly distal to the midline of the inner nuclear layer. With increasing eccentricity from the visual streak, the size of the perikarya increases, concomitant with a decline in density of their distribution. Dendrites emanate from stout primary stalks and branch out before reaching the outer plexiform layer. Axons are bistratified within the inner plexiform layer with ramifications at the border of strata 1 and 2 and in stratum 4. The overall morphology of serotonin-accumulating bipolar cells is similar to that of serotonin-accumulating OFF bipolar cells of other non-mammalian vertebrates. Protein kinase C immunoreactive cells display the typical appearance of rod bipolar cells. Somata of protein kinase C immunoreactive bipolar cells are spindle-shaped and located distal to the serotonin-accumulating bipolar cells. Dendrites of these bipolars do not ramify before reaching the outer plexiform layer. Thin axons of protein kinase C immunoreactive bipolar cells end in large, club-shaped terminals in stratum 5 of the inner plexiform layer, bearing a striking similarity to axon terminals of mammalian ON rod bipolar cells. Our findings suggest that the all-rod retina of the skate contains at least two distinct vertical pathways including an OFF bipolar cell pathway in addition to a classical rod ON bipolar pathway.